Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
6.2
OVERALL COST
(RM)
PACKAGE 1
(RM)
PACKAGE 2
(RM)
PACKAGE 3
(RM)
BRIDGE
(RM)
Traffic Study
2,539,200.00
610,677.00
480,924.00
376,817.00
1,070,782.00
Topographical and
Detail Survey
11,109,000.00
2,671,714.00
2,104,044.00
1,648,577.00
4,684,665.00
Soil Investigation
7,935,000.00
1,908,368.00
1,502,889.00
1,177,554.00
3,346,189.00
EIA Report
5,078,400.00
1,221,355.00
961,848.00
753,636.00
2,141,561.00
Safety Audit
2,856,600.00
687,012.00
541,040.00
423,920.00
1,204,628.00
Laboratory
2,221,800.00
534,342.00
420,808.00
329,717.00
936,933.00
TOTAL
31,740,000.00
7,633,468.00
6,011,553.00
4,710,221.00
13,384,758.00
132
25
16
Traffic Study
Soil Investigation
EIA Report
9
30
7
8
Chart 6.1
133
Safety Audit
Laboratory
134
DESCRIPTION
OVERALL COST
(RM)
PACKAGE 1
(RM)
PACKAGE 2
(RM)
PACKAGE 3
(RM)
BRIDGE
(RM)
16,769,300.00
4,033,016.00
3,176,105.00
2,488,564.00
7,071,615.00
Project
Management
Consultant
26,830,880.00
6,452,826.00
5,081,768.00
3,981,702.00
11,314,584.00
Construction
Supervision
13,415,440.00
3,226,413.00
2,540,885.00
1,990,852.00
5,657,290.00
Performance Bond
6,707,720.00
1,613,206.00
1,270,442.00
995,427.00
2,828,645.00
3,353,860.00
806,603.00
635,223.00
497,712.00
1,414,322.00
67,077,200.00
16,132,064.00
12,704,423.00
9,954,257.00
28,286,456.00
Design Consultancy
Levy To CIDB
TOTAL
Table 6.2: Cost Breakdown of project management cost in Senai Desaru Expressway
135
Design Consultancy
Construction
Supervision
10%
25%
40%
Chart 6.2
136
Levy to CIDB
137
Table 6.3: Cost Breakdown of Main Civil Work cost in Senai Desaru Expressway
DESCRIPTION
OVERALL COST
(RM)
PACKAGE 1
(RM)
PACKAGE 2
(RM)
PACKAGE 3
(RM)
BRIDGE
(RM)
68,558,400.00
16,488,295.00
12,984,960.00
10,174,066.00
28,911,079.00
21,424,500.00
5,152,592.00
4,057,800.00
3,179,397.00
9,034,711.00
205,675,200.00
49,464,885.00
38,954,882.00
30,522,202.00
86,733,231.00
Rock Excavation
25,709,400.00
9,274,666.00
7,304,041.00
9,130,693.00
Drainage Works
42,849,000.00
10,305,184.00
8,115,600.00
6,358,793.00
18,069,423.00
Pavement Works
137,116,800.00
32,976,590.00
25,969,921.00
20,348,135.00
57,822,154.00
DESCRIPTION
OVERALL COST
(RM)
PACKAGE 1
(RM)
PACKAGE 2
(RM)
PACKAGE 3
(RM)
BRIDGE
(RM)
General and
Preliminaries
Site Clearance
138
Road Furniture
29,994,300.00
7,213,629.00
5,680,920.00
4,451,155.00
12,648,596.00
Utilities
34,279,200.00
8,244,147.00
6,492,480.00
5,087,035.00
14,455,538.00
RC Bridge
94,267,800.00
94,267,800.00
Cabling Works
51,418,800.00
12,366,221.00
9,738,720.00
7,630,552.00
21,683,307.00
Landscaping Works
42,849,000.00
14,427,258.00
16,231,201.00
12,190,541.00
Interchanges
102,837,600.00
41,220,738.00
32,462,402.00
29,154,460.00
856,980,000.00
207,134,205.00
167,992,927.00
138,227,029.00
343,625,839.00
Relocation of Public
TOTAL
139
25
20
Total Main Civil Cost RM 856,980,000
15
10
The Bar Charts show the percentage from the total costs of main civil works for Senai
Desaru Expressway, which is the total RM 856,980,000.00. The bar charts clearly show
the highest rating is in item earthwork and soil stabilization which is 24% for RM
205,675,200.00 from the total main civil cost. The cost of earthwork and soil
stabilization was expensive because it is use for remove large volumes of
unsatisfactory soils and replaces them with suitable material, particularly if it is to be
imported. Furthermore, it is more expensive when much emphasis has been placed
upon finding methods of modifying the properties of soils available at the site. Besides
140
141
6.4:
OVERALL COST
(RM)
PACKAGE 1
(RM)
PACKAGE 2
(RM)
PACKAGE 3
(RM)
Table
Cost
21,614,940.00
9,455,346.00
7,213,867.00
4,945,727.00
16,811,620.00
7,354,158.00
5,610,785.00
3,846,677.00
Officers
9,606,640.00
9,606,640.00
TOTAL
48,033,200.00
16,809,504.00
22,431,292.00
8,792,404.00
Toll Plaza
Supervision
Buildings
Administration
Breakdown of Toll Plaza and Operation Offices cost in Senai Desaru Expressway
142
143
20%
35%
144
145
OVERALL COST
(RM)
PACKAGE 1
(RM)
PACKAGE 2
(RM)
PACKAGE 3
(RM)
BRIDGE
(RM)
5,281,536.00
1,872,964.00
1,728,118.00
1,680,454.00
25,747,488.00
6,192,270.00
4,876,574.00
3,820,929.00
10,857,715.00
System
1,980,576.00
476,328.00
375,121.00
293,919.00
835,208.00
TOTAL
33,009,600.00
8,541,562.00
6,979,813.00
5,795,302.00
11,692,923.00
Toll Equipment
Traffic Surveillance
Emergency Phone
Table 6.5: Cost Breakdown of Toll Equipment, Traffic Surveillance and Control System cost in Senai Desaru
Expressway
146
6%
16%
Toll Equipment
Traffic Surveilliance
Emergency Phone System
78%
147
148
149
DESCRIPTION
OVERALL
COST (RM)
PACKAGE 1
(RM)
PACKAGE 2
(RM)
West
10,580,000.0
0
East
10,580,000.0
0
TOTAL
PACKAGE 3
(RM)
21,160,000.00
Table 6.6: Cost Breakdown of Rest and Services area cost in Senai
Desaru Expressway
From the above table, we can see the total for the of the rest and services
area is RM 21,160,000.00. For this Senai Desaru Expressway was provide 2 R&R to
the consumers at the west and east on package 2 ( Ulu Tiram to Pasir Gudang). The
cost of construction for each R&R is RM 10,580,000. The total cost of construction
R&R which is 2% from the total of the development cost.
The costing was about the cost for the construction and also about the cost for
the services also the facilities was provided on the R&R. This R&R was new design
and have many different also more modern of R&R from others R&R was provided in
others highway.
150
A food court within a reasonable walking distance from the car park
Clear unobstructed access from the food court to the toilets and surau
A simple two-way car parking system for smooth traffic flow and drivers
convenience
Police Station is located at the centre of a group of three buildings for better
supervision and visibility
ATMs are placed immediately outside the police beat for similar safety reasons
Wakafs, playground and fruit stalls are provided at strategic locations to further
enhance travellers' convenience
151
OVERALL COST
(RM)
PACKAGE 1
(RM)
PACKAGE 2
(RM)
PACKAGE 3
(RM)
BRIDGE
(RM)
Pre - Construction
Cost
31,740,000.00
7,633,468.00
6,011,553.00
4,710,221.00
13,384,758.00
Project
Management Cost
67,077,200.00
16,132,064.00
12,704,423.00
9,954,257.00
28,286,456.00
856,980,000.00
207,134,205.00
167,992,927.00
138,227,029.00
343,625,839.00
48,033,200.00
16,809,504.00
22,431,292.00
8,792,404.00
Toll Equipment,
Traffic Surveillance
and Control System
33,009,600.00
8,541,562.00
6,979,813.00
5,795,302.00
11,692,923.00
21,160,000.00
21,160,000.00
TOTAL
1,058,000,000.00
237,280,008.00
167,479,213.00
256,250,803.00
Table 6.7: Cost Breakdown of total development cost in Senai Desaru Expressway
152
396,989,976.00
153
Development Cost ( RM )
900,000,000.00
800,000,000.00
700,000,000.00
600,000,000.00
500,000,000.00
400,000,000.00
300,000,000.00
200,000,000.00
100,000,000.00
-
Series 1
Based on that Bar Chart 6.6, it is can be con conclude the highest proportion show of
the Senai - Desaru Expressway for development cost is clearly cost of main civil works.
Which is the cost of main civil works is RM 856,980,000.00 or 81% from the total
development cost. The main civil works consists pavement works, site clearance
drainage works, interchange, bridge and others. As we can see, bride construction
definitely show the highest cost of development cost other than that all package in this
highway construction which is RM 396,989,976.00. The bridge construction will be one
of the longest single plane cable stayed bridges in the world. Furthermore bridge
construction used 740m long span composite steel and concrete box girder is used for
the main span and side spans of the cable-stayed portion of the structure.
154
The
155
PACKAGE
WHOLE
LENGTH
(KM)
WIDTH (M)
TOTAL AREA
Package 1
22
20
440
Package 2
27
20
540
Package 3
26
10.5
27.3
Bridge
1.7
22
37.4
TOTAL
77
48
1,045
156
Package 1
(RM)
Package 2
(RM)
Package 3
(RM)
Bridge
(RM)
Total
Construction Cost
256,250,803
237,280,008.
167,479,213
396,989,976
Total Length of
Highway (KM)
22
27
26
1.7
COST PER KM OF
THE HIGHWAY
11,647,763
8,788,148
6,441,508
233,523.515
From the above table, we can see and conclude the cost or per km of each
package include a cable stay bridge. For the highest cost of per km is on bridge
construction which is RM 233,523.515/km and follows up by package 1 and package 2
RM 11,647,763/km and RM 8,788,148/km. For the lowest cost is on package 3 RM
233,523.515/km.
157
6.10 ANALYSIS ON COST OF SENAI DESARU EXPRESSWAY AGAINST LEKAS HIGHWAY AND
LEBUHRAYA PANTAI TIMUR PHASE 2 PACKAGE 12
For more finding about the cost of highway construction, this chapter also carries out the comparisons of cost with LEKAS Highway
and Lebuhraya Panatai Timur Phase 2 Package 12.
Table 6.9 shows the comparisons of cost/km with LEKAS Highway and Lebuhraya Pantai Timur Phase 2 Package 12.
LEKAS HIGHWAY
LEBURHRAYA
PANTAI
TIMUR PHASE
12
Package
Total
Construction Cost
(RM)
Total Length Of
Highway in KM
Cost per km of
the highway (RM )
165,254,
789
174,106,17
2
169,656,52
5
18.2
14.5
11.575
9,709,9
34
12,007,32
2
14,657,15
1
158
12
256,250,80
3
237,280,00
8
167,479,21
3
22
27
26
12,222,500
11,647,76
3
8,788,148
6,441,508
97,780,000
Construction Cost ( RM )
Series 1
Package 3(SDE )
167,479,213
Package 2 (SDE )
237,280,008
Package 1 (SDE )
256,250,803
97,780,000
Package 3( LEKAS )
169,656,525
Package 2 ( LEKAS )
174,106,172
Package 1 ( LEKAS )
165,254,789
159
160
6.12 CONCLUSION
From the discussed and analyzed about the all elements involved for this
construction and about the length of km Senai - Desaru Expressway also the
comparative study about the comparisons with other type of highway construction, as
the conclusion Senai Desaru Expressway more expensive and required the really big
budget from government
161
CHAPTER 7
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
7.1
CONCLUSION
Highway construction plays a vital role in the development of a country. The
economic success of country depends not only on the availability and proper utilization
of its natural resources but also rely heavily on its efficient form of transportation
system, of which systematic, well-planned and good road networks provide the principal
venue for the rapid conveyance of the commodities produced. The growth in road
transport in recent years has focused attention on the importance of well-planned
highway system to the economy of any nation.
For this study overall finding about the information expressway system in
included constructability concept of expressway Malaysia especially Senai Desaru
Expressway (SDE).From the study of Senai Desaru expressway, we can know and
learned about why the needed of this construction, how it is construct, overall cost
involved in this project and others.
162
7.2
EXPRESSWAY (SDE)
Overall the analysis the construction of Senai Desaru Expressway was be
described on the chapter 4. For the summary of the construction of the Senai Desaru
expressway, generally the method of construction of highway is commonly based on
principle and the standard specification of highway construction issued by the Jabatan
kerja Raya (JKR) and Lembaga Lebuhraya Malaysia (LLM) To avoid waste and to
ensure the project complete within the construction period, all the construction method
must be determined and prepared early by the contractor. For the construction flexible
pavement especially on the layer must be smooth and followed the Specification and
followed Specification. Other than that, the bridge construction also important and the
construction consist of foundation of main pylons, pile cap or abutment, column or piers,
crosshead, beam launching, diaphragm and deck, parapet and railing as well as the
miscellaneous.
163
Pylon
related problems.
For
example,
the inconvenience of
164
Figure 7.1
Figure 7.2
Figure 7.3
Figure 7.4
165
166
7.4 RECOMMENDATION
Based from the case study and overall the topic include in this case study, some
recommendation about this project is made as below:
cost of highway.
We also must take note and make important to the decrease of the failure in
highway construction. Because of that, the engineer should still undergo some
improvement like using high quality of the materials and also choose the right
delay.
Recommendation for this highway is further study should made to find the most
effective and economical ways to construct this highway and also study the detail
about the strategic location of the project. Besides that, more research should be
carried out for all highways project to gather more and more cost yard stick so that
cost yardstick will be more reliable.
167