Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
doi: 10.1093/jtm/tav005
Original article
Original article
Abstract
Background. Risk of tuberculosis (TB) is generally considered to be low for long-term travellers, though risk varies
with travel destination, duration and purpose. Peace Corps Volunteers (PCVs) serve for 27 months as communitylevel development workers in various countries around the world and may be exposed to TB in the course of their
service. This study examines recent trends in TB in PCVs and compares rates with a previous analysis published by
Jung and Banks.
Methods. Tuberculosis case data submitted to the Peace Corps Epidemiologic Surveillance System by Peace Corps
Medical Officers and gathered from Federal Employees Compensation Act claims for latent TB infection (LTBI) and
active TB between 2006 and 2013 were aggregated and analysed for trends and significance.
Results. Overall, there were 689 cases of LTBI and 13 cases of active TB, for a rate of 0.95 cases of LTBI [95% confidence interval (CI) 0.881.02] and 0.02 cases of active TB (95% CI 0.010.03) per 1000 Volunteer-months. Both are significantly lower than rates presented in the initial study (P < 0.001). Per-country incidence rates for LTBI ranged from
0.00 to 4.52 cases per 1000 Volunteer-months. Per-country active TB rates ranged from 0.00 to 0.78 cases per 1000
Volunteer-months. Among the 13 cases of active TB, there was one successfully treated case of extensively drug-resistant TB.
Conclusions. Overall rates of both active and latent TB in PCVs were significantly lower compared with the previous
study period. PCVs continue to have statistically significantly higher rates of active TB compared with the general
US population but lower rates compared with other long-term travellers.
Key words: Tuberculosis, epidemiology, Peace Corps Volunteers
Introduction
Despite the progress that has been made in achieving the
Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) target of halting and
reversing tuberculosis (TB), the World Health Organization estimates that 1.5 million people died of TB and 9 million contracted the illness in 2013.1 In 2008, Jung and Banks2 published
an examination of TB risk in Peace Corps Volunteers (PCVs) between 1996 and 2005, concluding that PCVs have a higher risk
of contracting TB than the general US population but a lower
risk as compared with other non-US long-term travellers previously studied. The emergence and spread of multi-drug-resistant
(MDR) and extensively drug-resistant (XDR) TB has further
contributed to public concern.3,4 Worldwide, 5% of reported
Methods
Data analysed for this study were from the Peace Corps Office of
Health Services Epidemiologic Surveillance System (ESS). This system counts major health concerns experienced by currently serving
Volunteers. Data are submitted monthly by Medical Officers located in each Peace Corps country. ESS data provide only aggregate
data on the diagnosis and the country of service. It does not provide
demographic information such as age, sex, site placement, or sector
of work, nor does it provide details about the case.
ESS data only capture testing that is conducted during service.
For cases of tuberculin testing performed subsequent to a
Volunteers Close of Service (COS) date, data were drawn from the
Federal Employees Compensation Act (FECA) claims database.
FECA claims for LTBI and active TB were counted for the year in
which the Volunteer closed service and analysed with the ESS data.
For the purposes of this study, LTBI and active TB are defined in accordance with Peace Corps Medical Technical
Guidelines: a positive tuberculin skin test result 5 mm is considered positive (a conversion indicative of TB exposure) in
those individuals who are recent contacts of a TB case, have
known or suspected immunosuppressive disease, or have fibrotic changes on chest radiograph consistent with previous TB
infection. A result 10 mm is considered positive in those individuals who have recently returned from high-prevalence countries, residents and employees of high-risk congregate settings,
or persons with clinical conditions that make them high risk,
such as diabetes. A positive skin test 15 mm is considered
positive in individuals with no known risk factors. These guidelines are aligned with classification of tuberculin skin test (TST)
reactions from the US Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention. Peace Corps Medical Officers (PCMOs) are trained
to account for a Volunteers pre-service history of LTBI when
reading the skin test. Alternatively, some countries test for TB
with the IGRA. There are currently two IGRAs approved by the
FDA: the QuantiFERON-TB test, which was introduced in
V
2001, and the T-SPOT .TB test, which was introduced in
2008,1416 both of which are used by Peace Corps posts opting
to test for TB using IGRA. Although the previous Peace Corps
study used the term PPD Conversions to refer to positive tuberculin skin tests in previously negative individuals, this study refers to reactive exposure as LTBI. Determination of active TB
requires a chest radiograph and assessment of symptomology
and exposure; otherwise, the case is classified as LTBI.
As individuals may serve for different lengths of time, Volunteermonths were utilized as the denominator unit of measurement to
calculate the rates of conversion and active disease in each country.
This unit of measurement reflects the number of months that
Volunteers spent in their country of service and is the customary
person-time variable used in studies of long-term travellers.
Peace Corps groups its countries of service into three regions:
Africa; Europe, Mediterranean, and Asia; and Inter-America and
Pacific. For the purposes of this study, posts were divided further
into the following categories: Europe and Central Asia, East Asia
and South Asia, Africa, Central America, Caribbean, South
America and Pacific Islands. Volunteers serving in Dominica, Saint
Lucia, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, and Grenada and
Carriacou are collectively grouped as the Eastern Caribbean post.
Significance was assessed using a two-tailed mid-P exact statistical test. P-values < 0.05 were considered significant.
Analysis was conducted using OpenEpi 3.0.1 (Atlanta, GA) and
Stata/IC 12.0 (College Station, TX).
R
Results
Data were queried from 1 January 2006 to 31 December 2013.
During the study period, 728 516 Volunteer-months were
served, compared with the 801 781 Volunteer-months served
during the initial study. Peace Corps Response Volunteers and
Global Health Service Partnership Volunteers accounted for
8238 (1%) of the total Volunteer-months. Of the Volunteer
population during the study period, female Volunteers accounted for 60% of the population. Seventeen percent selfidentified as minorities, and the mean age at the start of service
was 33 years (median 30 years, range 2190 years). There were
689 LTBIs and 13 cases of active TB, for a rate of 0.95 conversions [95% confidence interval (CI) 0.881.02] and 0.02 cases
of active TB (95% CI 0.010.03) per 1000 Volunteer-months.
Of these, 596 LTBIs and 10 cases of active TB were diagnosed
in-service or at close of service, and 93 LTBIs and 3 cases of active TB were diagnosed after service. In countries where Peace
Corps was active during the study period, per-country LTBI incidence rates ranged from 0.00 to 4.52 cases per 1000
Volunteer-months; per-country active TB rates ranged from
0.00 to 0.78 cases per 1000 Volunteer-months. Figure 1 depicts
the rates of LTBI and active TB per 1000 Peace Corps
Volunteer-months from 2006 to 2013.
Reported rates of LTBI range from 1.4 to 4.26 cases per 1000
person-months.10,11
PCVs are similar to long-term travellers in that they spend
an extended period of time overseas and may have similar risk
profiles to other travellers. PCVs work around the world at the
request of host countries to pursue the organizations mission of
promoting world peace and friendship through sustainable
grassroots development.12 They serve approximately 27 months
in-country, with tours consisting of 10 weeks of training followed by 24 months of service. The average age of Volunteers is
28, though there is no upper age limit.13 Currently, 7% of
Volunteers are older than age 50.13 Volunteers work in the areas
of agriculture, community economic development, education,
environment, health, youth in development, or as part of the
Peace Corps Response program.13 Volunteers live embedded in
their communities, often staying with host families during their
service. A small fraction (<1.5%) serve shorter tours as Peace
Corps Response Volunteers (312 months) or Global Health
Service Partnership Volunteers (12 months) and serve under the
same conditions as traditional 27-month Volunteers.
Due to the nature of Peace Corps service and the countries in
which PCVs serve, many Volunteers are considered to be at risk
for exposure to TB during their service. All Peace Corps applicants are required to complete a tuberculin skin test prior to beginning their service to establish a baseline reaction
measurement as part of their pre-service health screening. All
Volunteers are screened with a tuberculin skin test again at the
completion of their service, and during service if clinically indicated. During service, Peace Corps provides safe housing and
quality medical care for Volunteers, which may reduce risk.
Figure 1. Rates of LTBI and active TB per 1000 Peace Corps Volunteermonths 200613
Figure 2. Rate of LTBI and active TB per 1000 Peace Corps Volunteermonths by region 200613
Table 1. Rate of LTBI and active TB per 1000 Peace Corps Volunteer-months by region, 200613
Total Volunteermonths,
200613
Total LTBIs,
200613
Total active
TB cases,
200613
Africa
306 172
273
Caribbean
35 424
33
Central America
99 473
122
45 891
13
146 374
200
Pacific Islands
25 991
19
South America
69 191
29
728 516
689
0.89a
(0.791.00)
0.93
(0.641.31)
1.23
(1.021.46)
0.28a
(0.150.48)
1.37
(1.181.57)
0.73
(0.441.14)
0.42a
(0.280.60)
0.95a
0.02a
(0.010.04)
0.03
(0.000.16)
0.01a
(0.000.06)
0.04
(0.010.16)
0.03
(0.010.07)
0.00
(0.000.14)b
0.00
(0.000.05)b
0.02a
Total
a
1
1
2
4
0
0
13
Significant (P < 0.05) decrease from the rate observed in the previous study.
One-sided, 97.5% CI.
Region
each country and their length of service, the rate of LTBI among
PCVs at these six posts combined was more than four times
greater than the rate of LTBI in all other Peace Corps countries;
this difference was significant (P < 0.001).
The posts with the highest rates of active TB (Table 3) were
Liberia (0.78 cases per 1000 Volunteer-months; 2 cases), Sierra
Leone (0.32; 1), Mexico (0.19; 1), Philippines (0.14; 2) and
Azerbaijan (0.10; 1). Fifty-four percent of all cases of active TB
among PCVs occurred in these five countries. The rate of active
TB among PCVs at these five posts combined was more than 23
times greater than the rate of active TB at all other Peace Corps
posts; this difference was significant (P < 0.001).
Discussion
Rates of both LTBI and active TB among PCVs were significantly less than the rates reported in the previous study period.
The rate of LTBI was 26% less in this study period (0.95 cases
per 1000 Volunteer-months) compared with the previous study
period (1.28 cases per 1000 Volunteer-months); the difference
was significant (P < 0.001).2 The rate of active TB was 67% less
in this study period (0.02 cases per 1000 Volunteer-months)
than the previous study period (0.06 cases per 1000 Volunteermonths) (P < 0.001).2
Years as a Peace
Corps country
Total Volunteer-months,
200613
Total LTBIs,
200613
Guatemala
200613
16 802
76
Mexico
200613
5272
20
Fiji
200613
5354
15
Moldova
200613
11 694
27
Sierra Leoneb
200913
3137
Ukraine
200613
32 775
73
4.52a
(3.575.66)
3.79
(2.325.85)
2.80
(1.574.62)
2.31
(1.523.36)
2.23
(0.904.59)
2.23a
(1.752.80)
Significant (P < 0.05) increase from the rate observed in Jung and Banks.2
It was not open as a Peace Corps country during the study by Jung and Banks.2
The rates of LTBI in the regions of East Asia and South Asia,
Africa and South America were lower than the regional rates reported in the earlier study (P < 0.05). The rates of active TB in
the regions of Africa and Central America were lower than the
regional rates in the previous study (P < 0.05). No region reported significantly higher rates of LTBI or active TB.
Peace Corps Volunteers continue to have significantly higher
rates of active TB compared with the general US population
(21.41 cases per 100 000 Volunteer-years in PCVs between
2006 and 2013 compared with 3.56 cases per 100 000 personyears among 25- to 64-year olds in the USA in 2013).18 This
rate is significantly less than the rate of 68.9 per 100 000
Volunteer-years between 1996 and 2005.2 Excluding the prior
study of Jung and Banks on PCVs, there are no other published
studies reporting active rates in US-based long-term travellers,
providing no other comparison data.
In the earlier study, the posts with the highest rates of PPD
conversion (LTBI) were Hungary (5.51 conversions per 1000
Volunteer-months; total of 6 conversions), Guinea-Bissau (5.31;
6), Ethiopia (3.38; 5), Cote dIvoire (3.16; 29) and Mali (3.11;
59). In this study, we found that the posts with highest LTBI rates
were Guatemala (4.52 LTBI per 1000 Volunteer-months; total of
76 conversions), Mexico (3.79; 20), Fiji (2.80; 15), Moldova
(2.31; 27), Sierra Leone (2.23; 7) and Ukraine (2.23; 73). Of the
Peace Corps countries observed in both studies, the countries
with the highest LTBI rates in the first study had generally lower
rates in the second study period: Cameroon (3.10 vs 0.76),
Albania (2.80 vs 0.66), China (2.79 vs 0.59), etc.
The posts with the highest rates of active TB in the previous
study were all located in the Africa region: Central African
Republic (2.13 cases of active TB per 1000 Volunteer-months; 1
case), Guinea-Bissau (0.89; 1), Ethiopia (0.68; 1), Cameroon
(0.38; 6) and Botswana (0.36; 1). The posts with the highest
rates of active TB in this study showed greater geographic diversity: Liberia (0.78 cases per 1000 Volunteer-months; 2 cases),
Sierra Leone (0.32; 1), Mexico (0.19; 1), Philippines (0.14; 2)
and Azerbaijan (0.10; 1).
The ratio of LTBI to active TB differed from post to post.
For example, the Philippines exhibited one case of LTBI for
Years as a Peace
Corps country
Total Volunteer-months,
200613
Total active
TB cases, 200613
Liberia
200813
2549
Sierra Leonea
200913
3137
Mexico
200613
5272
Philippinesb
200613
14 506
Azerbaijan
200613
9539
0.78
(0.102.83)
0.32
(0.011.77)
0.19
(0.001.06)
0.14
(0.020.50)
0.10
(0.000.58)
It was not open as a Peace Corps country during the study by Jung and Banks.2
Funding
This project was funded within the normal operating budget of the Peace
Corps Office of Health Services.
Conflict of interest: None declared.
References
1. World Health Organization. Global Tuberculosis Report 2014.
WHO Report 2014. Geneva: World Health Organization (WHO/
HTM/TB/2014.08).
2. Jung P, Banks R. Tuberculosis risk in US Peace Corps Volunteers,
1996-2005. J Travel Med 2008; 15:8794.
3. World Health Organization. Antimicrobial Resistance. WHO Report
2014. Geneva: World Health Organization (Fact Sheet No. 194). http://
www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs194/en/ (1 December 2014, date
last accessed).
4. Millard J, Ugarte-Gil C, Moore DAJ. Multidrug resistant tuberculosis. BMJ 2015; 350:h882.
5. World Health Organization. Multidrug-Resistant Tuberculosis
(MDR-TB) 2014 Update. WHO Report 2014. http://www.who.int/
tb/challenges/mdr/mdr_tb_factsheet.pdf?ua1 (1 December 2014,
date last accessed).
6. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Latent Tuberculosis
Infection: A Guide for Primary Health Care Providers. CDC Report
2014. Atlanta: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. http://
www.cdc.gov/tb/publications/ltbi/diagnosis.htm (16 March 2015,
date last accessed).
7. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The Difference between
Latent TB Infection and TB Disease. CDC Report 2012. Atlanta:
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (Fact Sheet
CS227840_F).
http://www.cdc.gov/tb/publications/factsheets/gen
eral/ltbiandactivetb.htm (1 December 2014, date last accessed).