CITYOFOAKLANDCITIZENS'POLICEREVIEWBOARDSUSTAINEDCASES20062016

ComplaintNo.
150248

150147

Complainant
KyleRobinson

MarcusBraud

150235

BrandonJones

150125

DeandreCurrington&KristyZhang

150221

BrandonJones

140067

WarrenAviles

140257

EstherGoolsbyetal

HearingDate
AllegationCategory
2/25/2016 Harassment
Harassment
FailuretoActFailuretoactivatePDRD
FailuretoActFailuretoactivatePDRD
FailuretoActOther
FailuretoActOther
VerbalMisconductRudeness
FailuretoActOther
1/28/2016 Racial/IdentityProfilingRace
Improper/UnlawfulArrest
Improper/UnlawfulSearchPerson
Improper/UnlawfulSearchPerson
FailuretoActFailuretoproperlysupervise
FailuretoActFailuretoproperlysupervise
2/11/2016 VerbalMisconductRudeness
FailuretoActFailuretoinvestigate
FailuretoActFailuretoactivatePDRD
1/14/2016 ExcessiveForceGrab/push/shove/trip
ExcessiveForceGrab/push/shove/trip
VerbalMisconductRudeness
ExcessiveForceHandcuffsunnecessary
ExcessiveForceHandcuffstootight
Harassment
1/28/2016 FailuretoActFailuretoidentifyself
FailuretoActFailuretoidentifyself
FailuretoActFailuretoidentifyself
1/8/2015 Improper/UnlawfulArrest
Improper/UnlawfulArrest
FailuretoActFailuretoinvestigate
VerbalMisconductRudeness
FailuretoActOther
FailuretoActFailuretoprovidemedicalassistance
Bias/Discrimination
3/12/2015 FailuretoActFailuretoproperlysupervise
FailuretoActFailuretoproperlysupervise
Improper/UnlawfulSearchPerson
FailuretoActOther
FailuretoActFailuretoproperlysupervise
Improper/UnlawfulArrest
FailuretoActFailuretoproperlysupervise
FailuretoActFailuretowriteareport

BoardFinding
Unfounded
Unfounded
Sustained
Exonerated
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Exonerated
Unfounded
Exonerated
NotSustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
NotSustained
Exonerated
Sustained
Unfounded
Exonerated
Sustained
Exonerated
Exonerated
Unfounded
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Exonerated
Sustained
Sustained
NotSustained
Sustained
Sustained
Unfounded
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained

BoardDisciplinary
Recommendation

Suspension
Counseling/Training
WrittenReprimand
Counseling/Training

Counseling/Training
Counseling/Training
Counseling/Training

Counseling/Training

Counseling

Suspension
Suspension
Suspension
WrittenReprimand
Suspension
Counseling
Suspension
Suspension
WrittenReprimand
Counseling/Training
Counseling/Training
WrittenReprimand
WrittenReprimand
WrittenReprimand
Counseling/Training

140662

140761

140871

150218

141024

TrevelAdanandusSr.etal

AnthonyR.Peters

AliviaBlount

DesleyBrooks

KendallAnderson

6/25/2015

7/9/2015

9/3/2015

9/24/2015

11/12/2015

FailuretoActFailuretowriteareport
FailuretoActFailuretowriteareport
FailuretoActFailuretoactivatePDRD
FailuretoActFailuretoactivatePDRD
FailuretoActFailuretoproperlysupervise
FailuretoActOther
ExcessiveForceOther
ExcessiveForceHandcuffstootight
ExcessiveForcePointingoffirearm
ExcessiveForcePointingoffirearm
ExcessiveForcePointingoffirearm
Improper/UnlawfulDetention/Stop
Improper/UnlawfulDetention/Stop
VerbalMisconductRudeness
VerbalMisconductProfanity
Improper/UnlawfulSearchOther
Improper/UnlawfulSearchOther
Improper/UnlawfulSearchOther
Improper/UnlawfulSearchOther
Bias/Discrimination
Bias/Discrimination
ExcessiveForceHandcuffstootight
ExcessiveForceHandcuffstootight
ImproperArrest
FailuretoActOther
PropertyDamaged/missing/seized
Other
Racial/IdentityProfilingRace
FailuretoActFailuretoinvestigate
VerbalMisconductRudeness
VerbalMisconductRudeness
ImproperCitation
Other
Other
VerbalMisconductRudeness
UntruthfulnessVerbalstatements
UntruthfulnessVerbalstatements
VerbalMisconductRudeness
VerbalMisconductRudeness
Other
FailuretoActOther
Other
FailuretoActOther
FailuretoActOther

Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Unfounded
Exonerated
Exonerated
Exonerated
Exonerated
Exonerated
Exonerated
Sustained
Unfounded
Sustained
Sustained
NotSustained
NotSustained
Unfounded
Unfounded
Exonerated
Exonerated
Exonerated
Unfounded
Sustained
NoJurisdiction
NotSustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
NotSustained
Unfounded
Exonerated
Exonerated
NotSustained
NotSustained
Sustained
Sustained
Unfounded
Unfounded
Sustained
Unfounded
NotSustained

Counseling/Training
WrittenReprimand
Suspension
Counseling
Suspension
WrittenReprimand

Counseling
WrittenReprimand
Suspension

Counseling

Suspension
Counseling
Counseling

Suspension
Suspension

Suspension

130500

FrenswaRaynor

3/13/2014

130442

HarrietKuroiwa

3/13/2014

130761

MoniqueMiles

3/27/2014

131084

JacobCrawford

6/12/2014

120348

T.Moloney

1/24/2013

101568

DerrickJones

6/13/2013

120767

RickeyClay

6/13/2013

120977

GuyDilling

6/13/2013

122414

S.Mayfield

9/26/2013

122578

EllaIvy

12/12/2013

FailuretoActOther
VerbalMisconductRudeness
Other
FailuretoActFailuretoinvestigate
FailuretoActOther
ExcessiveForceShooting
FailuretoActivatePDRD
RudeStatement
RudeStatement
RudeStatement
FailuretoProperlySupervise
FailuretoWriteAReport
FailuretoActivatePDRD
Retaliation
ImproperCitation
RudeStatements
FailuretoWriteaReport
FailuretoInvestigate
FailuretoWriteaReport
FailuretoInvestigate
ExcessiveForceShooting
ExcessiveForceShooting
FailuretoActTactics
FailuretoActTactics
TruthfulnessReporting
TruthfulnessReporting
TruthfulnessReporting
ExcessiveForcePush
ArrestImproper
Other
FailuretoActOther
FailuretoInvestigate
FailuretoActOther
FailuretoWriteAReport
FailuretoActivatedPDRD
FailuretoInvestigate
RudeStatement
PropertynotSecured
FailuretotakeaComplaint
FailuretoProperlySupervise
FailuretotakeaComplaint
ExcessiveForcePulling
ImproperArrest
ExcessiveForce

Sustained
Sustained
Exonerated
Unfounded
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
NotSustained
NotSustained
Sustained
Sustained
NotSustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Unfounded
Unfounded
NotSustained
NotSustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
NotSustained
Exonerated
NoFinding
Unfounded
NotSustained
Exonerated
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained
Exonerated
NotSustained
Sustained
NotSustained
NotSustained
Sustained
Not Sustained

Counseling
Training

Training
(OPDdisciplinebegun)
(OPDdisciplinebegun)
Counseling/Training
Counseling/Training

Counseling/Reprimand

WrittenReprimand
WrittenReprimand
Training

Suspension
Suspension
PossibleTermination
PossibleTermination
PossibleTermination

WrittenReprimand
WrittenReprimand
Counseling
Counseling

Training

HandcuffstooTight
FailuretoActivatePDRD
FailuretoActivatePDRD
FailuretoProperlyReport
ImproperDetention

101192

FreddieAldana

3/10/2011 Bias/Discrimination

Failuretoact(other)
Failuretoproperlyobtainasearchwarrant
Failuretoinvestigate
100212

090449

LorenzaAvila

MoniqueThomas

MargaritaZepedaHernandez

NotSustained
NotSustained
Sustained
NotSustained

1NotSustained

2Exonerated

Failuretoact(other)
Other

1Sustained
1Exonerated

2/11/2010 ImproperDetention

4/8/2010 FailuretoActProvideTranslator

ForceKick
ForcePush
ForceHandcuffstootight
GeneralConductDemeanor
ForcePulled
ForceImproperlyHandcuffed

WrittenReprimand
TheBoardrecommendedone
subjectofficerreceive
counselingforfailingto
properlyobtainasearch
warrant.

2NotSustained
2Sustained
2Notsustained

6/9/2011 Failuretoact(other)

ImproperSearchPerson
ImproperSearchPerson
VerbalConductRudeStatements
ExcessiveForcePointingofFirearm

091284

NotSustained

1Sustained

TheBoardsustained
allegationsagainstasubject
officerforfailuretomakean
arrest.

TheBoardrecommendedthat
thesubjectofficerreceivesa
writtenreprimandfortheone
sustainedallegationforthe
improperdetention.

1Exonerated
1NotSustained
1NotSustained
4NotSustained

1Sustained

1NotSustained
1NotSustained
1NotSustained
1NotSustained
1Exonerated
1Exonerated

TheBoardrecommendedthat
thesubjectofficerreceivesa
writtenreprimandfortheone
sustainedallegationfora
failuretoprovidealanguage
interpreter.

090639

SharonWoodardGrant

4/15/2010 ImproperSearchPerson

ExcessiveForcePointingofFirearm
UnlawfulFelonyCarStop
ForceImproperlyHandcuffed
ImproperSearchVehicle
ImproperSearchPerson
ImproperSearchVehicle
ExcessiveForcePointingofFirearm
UnlawfulStop

EuniceBarry

5/3/2010 FailuretoActImproperCollisionReport

FailuretoActConductproperinvestigation
FailuretoActIssueCitation

KathleenWindsor

8/11/2010 FailuretoActCallDispatch

FailuretoActViolatedFootPursuitPolicy
FailuretoActImproperFootPursuit
PerformanceofDuty
ExcessiveForceFirearm

1Sustained

TheBoardrecommendedthat
thesubjectofficerreceives
trainingforthefoursustained
allegationsrelatingto
conductinganimproper
felonycarstop.

1Sustained
1Sustained
1Sustatined
1NotSustained
1NotSustained
1NotSustained
1Exonerated
1Exonerated

1Sustained

TheCPRBstaffrecommended
totheCityAdministratorthat
disciplinebeimposedonthe
subjectofficerforthe
sustainedallegationfor
writinganimpropercollision
report.

1NotSustained
1Exonerated

1Sustained

1Sustained
1Sustained
1Sustained
1Exonerated

TheCPRBstaffrecommended
totheCityAdministratorthat
thesubjectofficerwiththe
foursustainedallegations
receiveawrittenreprimand
relatedtothefootpursuit

JeromeWilliams

10/1/2010 FailuretoActReportSubjectOfficer

CompromisedCriminalCase
FailuretoActImproperReport
FailuretoActTamperedwithEvidence
FailuretoActImproperSolicitation
ImproperVehicleStop
FailuretoActMirandaRights

080675

RonaldCurry

4/23/2009

FailuretoActConductaproperinvestigation

VerbalMisconductProfanity
PropertyFailuretosecureduringanarrest

LaquetaHarper

5/21/2009

Bias/DiscriminationRacialProfiling

ImproperDetention
ImproperSearchPerson
ImproperSearchVehicle
Bias/DiscriminationConducttowardothers
ExcessiveForceGrab
ExcessiveForceWhilehandcuffing
ImproperDetention
VerbalMisconductRudeness
VerbalMisconductRudeness

1Sustained

TheCPRBstaffrecommended
totheCityAdministratorthat
thesubjectofficerwiththe
threesustainedallegations
relatedtoevidencetampering
beterminatedandsubject
officerwiththesustained
allegationonreportwritingto
receivetrainingand
counseling.

1Sustained
1Sustained
1Sustained
1NotSustained
1Exonerated
1Unfounded

2Sustained

TheBoardrecommended
bothsubjectofficersreceive
writtenreprimandsforthe
sustainedallegationsfor
failingtoconductaproper
investigation.

1NotSustained
1NotSustained

1Sustained

1Sustained
1Unfounded
1Unfounded
3Unfounded
1Unfounded
1Exonerated
3Unfounded
1Unfounded
1NotSustained

TheBoardrecommendeda
fifteendaysuspensionforthe
subjectofficerasdisciplinefor
thesustainedallegationsof
racialprofilingandan
improperdetention.

GuoHuang/ZhangLiu

5/6/2009 FailuretoActConductaproperinvestigation

FailuretoActProperlyobtainasearchwarrant
FailuretoActProperlysupervisesearch
FailuretoActWriteaproperreport
UntruthfulnessReporting
ExcessiveForcePointingfirearmsandgrabbing

OlusegunOmowale

9/22/2009 ImproperDetention

FailuretoActReleasecomplainant
ExcessiveForceHandcuffstootight
UntruthfulnessVerbal
VerbalMisconductRudeStatement

JamesButler

12/4/2009 UntruthfulnessReport

UntruthfulnessReport
ImproperSearch
ImproperSearch
ImproperVehicleStop
ExcessiveForcePulled
ImproperSearchVehicle

RobertGraham

4/16/2008 FailuretoWriteaReport

TruthfulnessReporting
ForceKick
ForceGrab/Push/Shove/Trip

1Sustained

TheCPRBstaffrecommended
totheCityAdministratorthat
disciplinebeimposedonthe
subjectofficersinvolvedin
thesevensustained

1Sustained
3Sustained
1Sustained
1Sustained
1Unfounded

1Sustained

TheCPRBstaffrecommended
totheCityAdministratorthat
thetwosubjectofficersfor
theonesustainedallegation
ofanimproperdetention
receivewrittenreprimands.

1NotSustained
1NotSustained
1NotSustained
1NotSustained

1Sustained

TheCPRBstaffrecommended
totheCityAdministratorthat
theonesubjectofficerforthe
onesustainedallegationof
untruthfulnessinreporting
receivesamultipleday
suspension.

3NotSustained
1Exonerated
1NotSustained
2Exonerated
1Unfounded
2Exonerated

2Sustained

2Sustained
1NotSustained
1NotSustained

TheCPRBstaffrecommends
disciplinebeimposedonthe
officersinvolvedinthefour
sustainedallegations.

ForceKneed
ForceStrikew/HandorUnknownObject
FailuretoProvideMedicalAssistance
FailuretoInvestigate
TruthfulnessVerbalStatements
070486

LulaMaeGamble

5/22/2008

SearchPerson
SearchPerson
SearchPerson
CustodyImproperTreatment
CustodyImproperTreatment
PlantingEvidence
ForceChoke
FailuretoActToProvideMedicalAssistance

070720

OlufolaSababu

9/11/2008

FailuretoInvestigate

FailuretoInvestigate
Detention/StopImproper
Detention/StopImproper
Detention/StopImproper
Detention/StopImproper
ForceHandcuffstoTight
ForceTwistedArm

060412

LeticiaRodriguez

5/10/2007 FailuretoActDuringCarChase

FailuretoActDuringCarChase
FailuretoActToInvestigate
PropertyDamaged/Missing/Seized
PropertyDamaged/Missing/Seized
VerbalConductProfanity/RudeStatements

2NotSustained
3NotSustained
2NotSustained
5NotSustained
1NotSustained
1Sustained

TheBoardrecommends
terminationforthetwo
subjectofficerswiththree
sustainedallegations.

2Unfounded
4NotSustained
2Sustained
1Unfounded
1Unfounded
1Unfounded
3Unfounded

1Sustained

TheBoardrecommendsa
writtenreprimandanda
threedaysuspensionforthe
officerwiththetwosustained
allegations.

2NotSustained
1Sustained
3Unfounded
1Exonerated
1NotSustained
3NotSustained
1NotSustained

8Sustained

3Unfounded
1NotSustained
1NotSustained
1Exonerated
1Sustained

TheBoardrecommendsthe
subjectofficersreceiveaone
daysuspensionforthe
allegationssustained.

070007

CarolAnnGregg

6/14/2007 FailuretoActToInvestigate

FailuretoActToInvestigate
FailuretoActToWriteaReport
FailuretoActToWriteaReport
070410

BeverlyRoberts

9/13/2007 FailuretoActToInvestigate
VerbalConductProfanity/RudeStatements

060914

BryonFreelon,RhodaFreelon

10/18/2007 Bias/Discrimination

Bias/Discrimination
Bias/Discrimination
Detention/StopImproper
FailuretoActToInvestigate
FailuretoActToWriteaReport
ForceGrab/Push/Shove/Trip
ForceHandcuffsUnwarranted
ForceHandcuffsUnwarranted
ForceKick
ForcePointingofFirearm
SearchPerson
SearchVehicle
SearchVehicle
VerbalConductProfanity/RudeStatements
VerbalConductProfanity/RudeStatements

070233

BehijaBalic,JeromeDonnelly

12/13/2007 UnprofessionalConductVerbalStatements

6Sustained

TheBoardrecommendstwo
subjectofficersreceiveatwo
daysuspensionandone
subjectofficerreceiveathree
daysuspensionforthe
allegationssustained.

1Unfounded
1NotSustained
1Sustained
3Sustained

TheBoardrecommendsthe
subjectofficerreceives
counselingforallallegations
sustained.

1Sustained

4NotSustained

TheBoardrecommendsthe
subjectofficerreceivesa
writtenreprimandforthe
allegationsustained.

1Exonerated
1Unfounded
7Exonerated
1Exonerated
5Exonerated
2Exonerated
1Exonerated
1NotSustained
1Exonerated
3Exonerated
1Exonerated
1Sustained
3Exonerated
1Exonerated
2NotSustained

1Sustained

TheBoardrecommendsthe
subjectofficerreceivesaone
daysuspensionforthe
allegationsustained.

05626

MichaelMorgan

2/23/2006 ForceChoke

ForceStrikew/HandorUnknownObject
ArrestImproper
ForceStrikew/Hand
VerbalConductProfanity/RudeStatements

05178

JacquelineNelson

3/23/2006 FailuretoActToWriteAReport

FailuretoActToInvestigate
FailuretoActToInvestigate
FailuretoActToWriteAReport
FailuretoActToInvestigate
PropertyDamaged/Missing/Seized
FailuretoActToInvestigate

MaeWalker

4/6/2006 FailuretoActToWriteAReport

ForcePush
Entry/SearchResidenceorBldg.

DominicNguyen

6/29/2006 FailuretoActToWriteAReport

VerbalConductProfanity/RudeStatements
FailuretoActToInvestigate
FailuretoActToWriteAReport
FailuretoActToWriteAReport
FailuretoActExplanationforCitizensArrest

2Sustained

TheBoardrecommendsthe
subjectofficerseachreceive
15and20daysuspensionsfor
illegaldetention,falsearrest
andexcessiveuseofforceon
Mr.Morgan.

Sustained
Sustained
NotSustained
Unfounded

3Sustained

TheBoardrecommendsthe
subjectofficersreceive
trainingonreportwriting,
investigationsand
landlord/tenantlaws.

2Sustained
NotSustained
NotSustained
2NotSustained
Unfounded
Exonerated

2Sustained

TheBoardrecommendsthe
subjectofficerreceivesa
writtenreprimandforfailing
todocumentproperty
damageandaninjurytoMs.
Walkerinhisreport.

NotSustained
Exonerated

Sustained

NotSustained
3NotSustained
NoMotionMade
2Exonerated
3Exonerated

TheBoardrecommendsthe
subjectofficerreceivesa
writtenreprimandfornot
writingacrimereportforthe
incidentinvolvingMr.
Nguyen'srestrainingorder.

FailuretoActToEnforceRestrainingOrder

3Exonerated