Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Review
Monthly Focus: Anti-infectives
1. Introduction
2. Aetiology
3. Diagnosis and clinical
appearance of pityriasis
versicolor
4. Histopathology
5. Goal of therapy
6. Treatment of pityriasis
versicolor
7. Conclusion
8. Expert opinion
1. Introduction
Ashley Publications
www.ashley-pub.com
PV is the only dermatological disorder conclusively caused by Malassezia spp. Historically, it has been suggested that the rounded form of Malassezia spp., the mycelial form, previously referred to as Pityrosporum orbiculare, was the aetiological agent
[7]. The Malassezia organism may change from the saphrophytic form to the aetiological mycelial form in response to predisposing factors such as high temperature
and humidity, profuse sweating, hereditary factors, steroid medication and malignant lymphomas [3,8,9]. Altered cell-mediated immunity has been implicated as one
of the predisposing factors. Such a response has been demonstrated by lymphocyte
transformation tests in healthy individuals [10]. Lymphocyte transformation in
patients with PV, however, has been reported with diverse results [11-15]. Although
antibodies to Malassezia yeasts have been shown in normal controls as well as
165
Treatment regimen
Study MC (%)
design
[58]
23 versus
23
DB, R
21 days:
23 (100) versus 23 (100) versus
23 (100) versus 22 (96)
22 (96)
22 (96)
[40]
Op, R
1 week :
17 (85) versus
19 (95)
[113]
DB, R
[114]
DB, R
[63]
16 versus
16
Op
[115]
6 versus 4
SB
6 (100) versus
4 (100)
[53]
17 versus
14
DB, R
4 weeks:
14 (80) versus
11 (79)
[48]
SB, R
[64]
DB, R
19 (95) versus
17 (89)
[73]
SB, R
4 weeks:
20 (100) versus
20 (100) versus 19 (95)
19 (95)
[111]
DB, R
20 versus
20
60 versus
53
CC (%)
Complete
cure (%)
Follow-up
MC at 4 weeks:
19 (95) versus
15/19 (22)
8 (40) versus
2 (10)
4 (20) versus
8 (40)
6 (100) versus
4 (100)
6 (100) versus
4 (100)
6 weeks: all
remained cured
60 (92) versus
58 (89)
19 (95) versus
17 (89)
46 (77) versus
24 (45)
2 weeks: 44/50
(88) versus 32/44
(73) remained
cured
CC: Clinical cure; DB: Double-blind; MC: Mycological cure; N: Sample number; Op: Open; R: Randomised; SB: Single-blind.
5. Goal
of therapy
The main challenge with the treatment of PV is the recurrence of the disease. The goal of therapy should therefore be
to customise a safe and efficacious treatment, so that improvement occurs with low recurrence rates. An appropriate prophylactic treatment to prevent recurrence of PV is also an
important consideration. Furthermore, in todays healthcare
climate, the cost of treatment is a significant factor. The cost
of PV treatment modalities vary widely. The newer oral antifungals are effective following short-term regimens, thus
of pityriasis versicolor
6.1 Topical
treatments
There are numerous topical treatments of PV, and the consequent decrease in the number of Malassezia yeasts often parallels the clinical improvement (Table 1). Many topical
treatments have proved to be effective in the control of PV.
167
Table 2. Efficacy of nonspecific topical antifungal agents in the treatment of pityriasis versicolor.
Ref.
Treatment regimen
Study
design
[41]
20
Op
[55]
20 versus
20
[52]
20
[102]
[46]
MC (%)
CC (%)
Complete
cure (%)
Follow-up
20 (100)
2 weeks: 18/18
(100) remained
cured
20 (100)
versus 0
2 weeks: 20 (100)
versus 0
20 (100)
DB, R
39 (81)
27 (71)
7 (15)
30 (100)
versus 29
(100)
30 (100)
versus 29
(100)
24 months: 14
(47) versus 25 (86)
remained cured
CC: Clinical cure; DB: Double-blind; MC: Mycological cure; N: Sample number; Op: Open; R: Randomised.
Treatment regimen
Study
design
MC (%)
CC (%)
[60]
14 versus
15
DB, R
11 (79) versus
5 (33)
10 (71) versus
9 (60)
[103]
32 versus
29
DB
[104]
Op,
113 (93)
98 (81)
98 (81)
[62]
30
30
Op, R
18 (60)
19 (63)
22 (73)
21 (70)
18 (60)
19 (63)
25 (83)
27 (90)
25 (83)
28
4 weeks:
15 (54)
16 (57)
B) once-daily on days 1, 2, 3
C) once-daily on days 1, 3, 5
36
35
36 (100)
34 (97)
35 (97)
34 (97)
[105]
[106]
30
Complete Follow-up
cure (%)
2 weeks: 11 (79)
versus 4 (27) cured
2 weeks: all patients
remained MC and all
but one CC (Group 2)
3 months: 23/29 (79)
cured
22/29 (73) cured
27/29 (90) cured
Op, R
Op, R
4 months:
23 (77)
25 (83)
CC: Clinical cure; DB: Double-blind; MC: Mycological cure; N: Sample number; Op: Open; R: Randomised.
168
Selenium sulfide is available as a 2.5% lotion, cream or shampoo. It has long been known to be effective in the treatment of
PV [46,47], but a high rate of relapse is generally expected [46].
Selenium sulfide is as effective as some of the more recent specific antifungal agents used in the topical treatment of PV [40,48];
however, the course of treatment is often longer [40].
Treatment regimen
Study MC (%)
design
CC (%)
Complete
cure (%)
[42]
Terbinafine 1% solution
versus placebo twice-daily
for 1 week
76 versus
34
DB, R
8 weeks:
62 (81) versus
14 (41)
55 (72) versus
9 (26)
[107]
Terbinafine 1% solution
96 versus
versus vehicle twice-daily for 46
7 days
DB, R
1 week: 57
(59) versus 26
(56)
45 (47) versus
14 (30)
[108]
A) Terbinafine 1% solution
versus vehicle twice-daily for
1 week
B) Terbinafine 1% solution
versus vehicle once-daily for
1 week
[74]
2 weeks:
108 (56) versus
34 (35)
MC at 8 weeks: 123
(64) versus 32 (33)
MC at 8 weeks: 25 (50)
versus 14 (28)
50 versus
50
DB, R
Follow-up
CC: Clinical cure; DB: Double-blind; MC: Mycological cure; N: Sample number; R: Randomised.
6.1.2.1 Azoles
169
Table 5. Efficacy of other topical antifungal agents in the treatment of pityriasis versicolor.
Ref.
Treatment regimen
[69]
Study
design
MC (%)
DB, R
[109]
Econazole 1% foaming
solution, once-daily for
3 versus 6 days
Op
4 weeks:
39 (91) versus
46 (96)
[68]
DB, R
3 weeks:
53 (79) versus
37 (63)
[70]
Tioconazole 1% cream
twice-daily for 3 weeks
65
Op
[64]
Clotrimazole 1% solution
once-daily for 1 week
22
Op
3 weeks:
22 (100)
22 (100)
[66]
A) Clotrimazole 1% solution
versus vehicle once-daily for
2 weeks
B) Clotrimazole 1% cream
versus vehicle once-daily for
2 weeks
116
versus
107
10 versus
8
DB, R
96 (83) versus
68 (64)
96 (83) versus
68 (64)
8 (80) versus
3 (38)
8 (80) versus
3 (38)
[110]
Clotrimazole 1% solution
versus vehicle twice-daily for
2 weeks
35 versus
33
DB
[71]
Fluconazole 2% shampoo
versus vehicle applied for
5 consecutive days
16 versus
16
DB, R
6 days: 12
(75%) versus 0
[57]
Ketoconazole 2% cream
51 versus
versus placebo once-daily for 50
11 22 days (mean 14 days)
DB, R
43 (84) versus
11 (22)
34 (67) versus
11 (22)
[56]
A) Ketoconazole 2%
103
shampoo once on day 1 plus
placebo once-daily for next
2 days
B) Ketoconazole 2%
106
shampoo once-daily for
3 days
C) Placebo once-daily for
103
3 days
DB, R
31 days:
79 (78)
31 days:
71 (69)
89 (84)
77 (73)
11 (11)
5 (5)
[111]
73 versus
72
[76]
Ciclopiroxolamine 0.1%
solution for 4 8 weeks
[112]
Isoconazole 1% cream
twice-daily for 3 8 weeks
43 versus
48
CC (%)
4 weeks:
41 (95) versus
46 (96)
Complete
cure (%)
Follow-up
4 weeks:
39 (91) versus
46 (96)
53 (81.5)
1 year: 3/9 (33)
relapsed
2 weeks: 30 (86)
versus 17 (52)
2 weeks: 13 (81%)
versus 0 cured
43 (84) versus
5 (10)
Ketoconazole group
cure rates: 1 year:
42/51 (82)
2 years: 16/51 (33)
DB, R
36 (49) versus
17 (24)
90
Op
4 weeks:
67 (74);
8 weeks:
77 (86)
24
Op
23 (96)
6 weeks:
3 (12) relapsed
CC: Clinical cure; DB: Double-blind; MC: Mycological cure; N: Sample number; Op: Open; R: Randomised.
This hydroxy-pyridone interferes with the uptake and accumulation of products required for cell membrane synthesis.
The effectiveness of ciclopirox olamine has been supported in
a number of studies (Table 5) [75,76].
170
6.2 Oral
treatments
Most recently, oral treatments have been developed. The advantages of oral medications include increased patient compliance,
due to the fact that these treatments are more convenient than
Table 6. Studies comparing systemic antifungal agents in the treatment of pityriasis versicolor.
CC (%)
Follow-up
[89]
50 versus DB, R
50
2 weeks: 30 (60)
versus 28 (56);
8 weeks: 45 (90)
versus 44 (88)
[86]
45
24 (53)
30 (67)
45
33 (73)
33 (73)
45
45
37 (82)
29 (64)
36 (80)
27 (60)
0 relapsed
2/29 (6.9) relapsed
[87]
30
30
30
1 month: 21
(70)
29 (97)
24 (80)
18 (60)
23 (77)
22 (73)
[88]
20 versus Op, R
20
[131]
27 versus Op
25
Op, R
Op, R
CC: Clinical cure; DB: Double-blind; MC: Mycological cure; N: Sample number; Op: Open; R: Randomised.
Treatment regimen
Study MC (%)
design
[77]
10 versus DB, R
10
[79]
CC (%)
Complete
cure (%)
Follow-up
9 (100) versus
2 (20)
Op
57 (70)
134 (82)
273 (97)
34 versus DB, R
32
90
Op
84 (93), 6
cleared after
extra 14 day
treatment
82
Op
78 (95)
6 (7) relapsed
DB, R
10 (83)
9 (75)
8 (67)
[78]
[93]
34 (100)
33 (97) versus
versus 3 (9) 0
60
Op
3 months: 55
(92)
3 months:
57 (95)
Op
3 weeks: 26
(81)
5 weeks: 32
(100)
26 (81)
32 (100)
25 (42) versus
31 (51)
1 month: no significant
difference between two groups
6 (30)
20
Op
171
CC: Clinical cure; DB: Double-blind; MC: Mycological cure; N: Sample number; Op: Open; R: Randomised.
Treatment regimen
Study MC (%)
design
[122]
15 versus Op, R
15
0 versus 2
13 (87) versus
12 (80)
[96]
13 versus Op, R
15
10 (77) versus
13 (87)
3 months: 1 patient in
second group remained
cured
[83]
20
Op
20 (100)
20 (100)
20 (100)
40 weeks: 19 (95)
completely cured
[123]
17
12
12
12
20
Op
8 (47)
7 (58)
7 (58)
12 (100)
14 (70)
[124]
15 versus Op
15
100% in both
groups
100% in both
groups
100% in
both groups
2 weeks:
hyperpigmentation
disappeared. No relapse
[125]
22 versus Op, R
20
21 (95) versus
15 (75)
22 (100) versus
18 (90)
[126]
24 versus Op
23
[127]
50 mg/day versus
100 mg/day for maximum
of 4 weeks
14 versus Op, R
13
5 (36) versus 8
(62)
11 (79) versus
13 (100)
[128]
17 versus DB
16
11/15 (73)
versus 0
[97]
18 versus DB, R
17
[129]
8 versus
5
[85]
24 versus Op, R
26
DB
CC (%)
Complete
cure (%)
Follow-up
7 (88) versus 0
20 (83) versus
23 (88)
18 (75) versus
21 (81)
CC: Clinical cure; DB: Double-blind; MC: Mycological cure; N: Sample number; Op: Open; R: Randomised.
topical therapies. Not only are they less time-consuming for the
patient, but the length of the treatment is often much shorter
compared to topical medications (Table 6).
Terbinafine, administered orally, has been shown to be ineffective in treating PV as fungicidal levels are not attained in
the stratum corneum [42].
Ketoconazole 200 mg/day for 5, 10 and 28 days is effective
in the treatment of PV (Table 7) [57,77,78]. Another option is
the use of a single dose of 400 or 200 mg administered on
three occasions 12 h apart [79]. As ketoconazole is excreted in
eccrine sweat, it is recommended that the patient work up a
sweat following ingestion of ketoconazole. This aids in the
172
Treatment regimen
Study design
MC (%)
CC (%)
Follow-up
[130]
23
Op
3 weeks: 14 (61)
17 (74)
[90]
Op, R
161 (78)
177 (93)
179 (87)
CC: Clinical cure; MC: Mycological cure; N: Sample number; Op: Open; R: Randomised.
Table 10. Studies comparing oral and topical antifungal agents in the treatment of pityriasis versicolor.
Ref
Treatment regimen
Study design
MC (%)
CC (%)
[132]
20 versus 20
Op, R
3 weeks: 13 (65)
versus 20 (100)
17 (85) versus 16
(80)
CC: Clinical cure; MC: Mycological cure; N: Sample number; Op: Open; R: Randomised.
dose of itraconazole 400 mg/day was as effective as itraconazole 200 mg/day for 7 days in the treatment of PV. These
data, however, need to be confirmed by further investigation.
Fluconazole (Table 9) taken orally is effective in PV management. The drug is effective at various doses: single dose
fluconazole 400 mg/week [86-88]; 300 mg/week for 2 [87,89] or
4 [90] weeks; 300 mg every 2 weeks for 4 weeks [90]; or
150 mg/week for 4 weeks [86].
6.3 Prophylactic
7. Conclusion
PV is a chronic and recurrent disorder, and repetitive treatment courses are often necessary. Exogenous and endogenous predisposing factors are probably of major importance
for the disease and its recurrence. A wide range of antifungal
agents are effective in the treatment of PV. In a broad sense,
all these medications are at least transiently effective if used
appropriately. Some of the agents are far more effective in
producing prolonged cures. Spontaneous cure of PV is not
common, and the disease will persist for many years if left
untreated.
8. Expert
opinion
173
6.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
174
7.
8.
9.
10.
Bibliography
Papers of special note have been highlighted as
either of interest () or of considerable interest
() to readers.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
FAERGEMANN J: Antibodies to
Pityrosporum orbiculare in patients with
tinea versicolor and controls of various ages.
J. Invest. Dermatol. (1983) 80(2):133-135.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
TARAZOOIE B, KORDBACHEH P,
ZAINI F et al.: Study of the distribution of
Malassezia species in patients with pityriasis
versicolor and healthy individuals in
Tehran, Iran. BMC Dermatol. (2004)
4(1):5.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
KARAOUI R, BOU-RESLI M,
AL ZAID NS, MOUSA A: Tinea
versicolor: ultrastructural studies on
hypopigmented and hyperpigmented skin.
Dermatologica (1981) 162(2):69-85.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
MAYSER P, STAPELKAMP H,
KRAMER HJ et al.: Pityrialactone- a new
fluorochrome from the tryptophan
metabolism of Malassezia furfur. Antonie
van Leeuwenhoek (2003) 84(3):185-191.
36.
37.
38.
NAZZARO-PORRO M, PASSI S:
Identification of tyrosinase inhibitors in
cultures of Pityrosporum. J. Invest.
Dermatol. (1978) 71(3):205-208.
39.
40.
41.
42.
NAZZARO-PORRO M, PASSI S,
PICARDO M, MERCANTINI R,
BREATHNACH AS: Lipoxygenase activity
of Pityrosporum in vitro and in vivo.
J. Invest. Dermatol. (1986) 87(1):108-112.
Provides evidence to suggest that the
presence of a significant amount of
lipoperoxides in skin lipids may play a
role in the pathogenesis of skin alterations
in PV.
CHU AC: Comparative clinical trial of
bifonazole solution versus selenium
sulphide shampoo in the treatment of
pityriasis versicolor. Dermatologica (1984)
169(Suppl.):181-186.
FAERGEMANN J, FREDRIKSSON T:
An open trial of the effect of a zinc
pyrithione shampoo in tinea versicolor.
Cutis (1980) 25(6):667, 669.
VERMEER BJ, STAATS CC: The efficacy
of a topical application of terbinafine 1%
solution in subjects with pityriasis
versicolor: a placebo-controlled study.
Dermatology (1997) 194(Suppl.):122-124.
43.
44.
45.
46.
47.
48.
KATSAMBAS A, RIGOPOULOS D,
ANTONIOU C, ZACHARI A,
FRAGOULI E, STRATIGOS J: Econazole
1% shampoo versus selenium in the
treatment of tinea versicolor: a single-blind
randomized clinical study. Int. J. Dermatol.
(1996) 35(9):667-668.
49.
50.
51.
FAERGEMANN J, FREDRIKSSON T:
Antimycotic activity of propane-1,2-diol
(propylene glycol). Sabouraudia (1980)
18(3):163-166.
52.
FAERGEMANN J, FREDRIKSSON T:
Propylene glycol in the treatment of tinea
versicolor. Acta Derm. Venereol. (1980)
60(1):92-93.
53.
54.
55.
FREDRIKSSON T, FAERGEMANN J:
Double-blind comparison of a zinc
pyrithione shampoo and its shampoo base
in the treatment of tinea versicolor.
Cutis (1983) 31(4):436-437.
56.
57.
175
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
67.
68.
176
69.
70.
71.
72.
73.
74.
FAERGEMANN J, HERSLE K,
NORDIN P: Pityriasis versicolor: clinical
experience with Lamisil cream and Lamisil
DermGel. Dermatology (1997)
194(Suppl.):119-121.
75.
PALACIO-HERNANZ A,
GUARRO-ARTIGAS J,
FIGUERAS-SALVAT MJ,
ESTEBAN-MORENO J,
LOPEZ-GOMEZ S: Changes in fungal
ultrastructure after short-course
ciclopiroxolamine therapy in pityriasis
versicolor. Clin. Exp. Dermatol. (1990)
15(2):95-100.
76.
77.
78.
79.
80.
81.
82.
83.
84.
CAUWENBERGH G, DE DONCKER P,
STOOPS K, DE DIER AM,
GOYVAERTS H, SCHUERMANS V:
Itraconazole in the treatment of human
mycoses: review of three years of clinical
experience. Rev. Infect. Dis. (1987)
9(Suppl. 1):S146-S152.
85.
86.
87.
88.
89.
FARSHCHIAN M, YAGHOOBI R,
SAMADI K: Fluconazole versus
ketoconazole in the treatment of tinea
90.
91.
92.
93.
94.
95.
96.
97.
98.
99.
DELGADILLO J, GICH I,
IZQUIERDO I, FORN J: Flutrimazole 1%
dermal cream in the treatment of
dermatomycoses: a multicentre, doubleblind, randomized, comparative clinical trial
with bifonazole 1% cream. Efficacy of
flutrimazole 1% dermal cream in
dermatomycoses. Catalan Flutrimazole
Study Group. Dermatology (1995)
190(4):295-300.
GONZALEZ-VALLE O, BORGERS M,
VAN CUTSEM J, CAUWENBERGH G:
Itraconazole therapy in pityriasis versicolor.
Br. J. Dermatol. (1986) 115(2):217-225.
177
178
MENENDEZ RF,
RODRIGUEZ-NORIEGA BA:
Randomized comparative clinical trial of
itraconazole and selenium sulfide shampoo
for the treatment of pityriasis versicolor. Rev.
Infect. Dis. (1987) 9(Suppl. 1):S121-S127.
Affiliation