Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
1
2
ABSTRACT: New crosslinked ultra high molecular weight polyethylenes (UHMWPEs) have recently been developed, characterized and introduced in clinical applications. UHMWPE cross-linking treatments are very promising for reducing osteolysis induced by wear debris. The irradiation type, gamma or beta, the dosage and the thermal treatment performed during or following the irradiation process are all factors affecting polyethylene wear resistance. Thermal stabilization treatments performed after or during the irradiation process at a temperature above melting point (i.e. >130 C) have been proven to effectively remove
the free radicals generated during irradiation from UHMWPE, but their effect on the mechanical properties of UHMWPE are
not completely clear. In addition to wear rate reduction, maintaining good mechanical properties is fundamental aspect in designing the new generation of crosslinked UHMWPE for artificial load bearing materials, especially considering the application in total knee replacements.
In this study, we investigated the influence of different stabilization treatments, performed after gamma irradiation, on structural, wear and mechanical properties of UHMWPE. We performed four different stabilization treatments, with different temperatures and cooling rates, on 100 kGy gamma irradiated UHMWPE. Structural properties of UHMWPE were assessed by
differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). To assess the mechanical performance of the materials, uni-axial tensile tests were performed according to the ASTM D638 standard, bi-axial tension performance was evaluated by small punch tests (ASTM
F2183-02), toughness resistance was evaluated by the Izod method (ASTM F648), and cold flow resistance was analysed by a
dynamic compressive test. Evaluation of wear resistance was by a multidirectional pin-on-disk screening machine. Materials
considered were in aged and non-aged conditions. Results confirmed that cross-linking greatly enhances UHMWPE wear
resistance, but introduces some detrimental effects on the mechanical properties. In this study, we found that the negative effects on the mechanical properties of crosslinked UHMWPE can be modulated, to some extent, by choosing a thermal stabilization treatment at a correct temperature and cooling rate. (Journal of Applied Biomaterials & Biomechanics 2004; 2: 20-8)
KEY WORDS: UHMWPE, Cross-linking, Wear, Thermal treatment
Received 27/12/03; Revised 14/01/04; Accepted 16/01/04
INTRODUCTION
In the last few decades, ultra high molecular weight
polyethylene (UHMWPE) has been the chosen material for load bearing surfaces in total joint replacements. Excellent tribological properties and
good mechanical performance established its success and worldwide distribution. Nevertheless, it
has become evident that in the long term, the loosening and failure of joint prostheses is closely asso-
1722-6899/020-09$15.00/0
Chiesa et al
Tensile test
Before and after accelerated ageing the irradiated
UHMWPE and the non-irradiated control underwent
tensile mechanical testing according to ASTM D638.
The tensile properties of the samples were evaluated at
room temperature using an Instron universal tester
(model 4302) at a cross-head speed of 50 mm/min.
The specimens, machined from the bar, were subsequently cut with a sample die and preconditioned for
24 hr at 23 1 C with a 50 5% UR. Yield stress, ultimate tensile stress and strain were recorded. Five specimens were tested for each material.
Toughness resistance
Medical grade UHMWPE resin GUR 1020, originally produced by Ticona, and compression molded by
a commercial converter (Poly Hi Solidur, Germany) was used for all experiments.
UHMWPE bars were crosslinked using 100 kGy of
rays and were subsequently thermally stabilized above
melting temperature to eliminate free radicals.
Table I summarizes the materials included.
The materials were artificially aged according to
the ASTM F2003-00 method B for 14 days at 5 bar
of pure O2 at 70 C (oxygen bomb ageing).
TABLE I - MATERIALS
NT
25 kGy
130 W
130 1/10
155 W
155 1/10
Irradiation
dose (kGy)
Temperature
and duration of thermal
treatment (C)
Cooling rate
25
100
100
100
100
130 C - 72 hr
130 C - 72 hr
155 C - 72 hr
155 C - 72 hr
fast
slow (0.1 C/min)
fast
slow (0.1 C/min)
21
Influence of heat treatment on structural, mechanical and wear properties of crosslinked UHMWPE
cold flow = a .N b
where:
N is the number of cycles;
a and b are the characteristic parameters of cold
flow, evaluated by the iterative Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm.
In a double logarithmic chart, parameter a is the
intersection with the deformation axis at initial cycles, and indicates the initial deformation. Parameter b is the slope of the line indicating the cold flow
deformation rate.
Finally, the average strain standard deviation
(SD) at 250,000 cycles was calculated for each material.
Wear test
where:
l0 is the initial height in millimeters of the cylindrical specimen;
S is the displacement in micrometers recorded by
the extensometer at cycle i;
is the cold flow deformation at cycle i.
The average strain value was calculated for each cycle, and the value obtained was assumed as the ini
22
Wear testing was carried out using a six-station pinon-disk machine (Ortho-POD, AMTI Watertown,
MA, USA) applying a multidirectional sliding motion. Highly polished CoCrMo disks (Ra < 0.05)
were used as counter-specimens.
Calf bovine serum (Sigma B9433) diluted at 25%
volume concentration in de-ionized water was used
as a lubricating medium. A figure-of-eight shaped
Chiesa et al
Tm (C)
h (J/g)
Cryst %
NT
25 kGy
130 W
130 1/10
155 W
155 1/10
135.8
136.1
135.8
136.8
134.7
137.8
104.0
151.7
110.0
126.7
115.1
119.5
36.0
52.5
38.0
43.7
39.7
41.2
Yield strength
(MPa)
Strain at break
UTS
(MPa)
Impact strength
(kJ/m2)
NT
25 kGy
130 W
130 1/10
155 W
155 1/10
23.06 2.29
22.77 0.58
21.87 0.29
21.91 0.16
18.47 0.38
19.85 0.62
401.7 18.1
462.8 15.4
236.0 10.8
246.0 6.60
261.6 9.20
245.3 12.2
45.86 5.16
52.98 3.83
40.19 2.24
44.32 1.64
33.20 2.34
36.35 2.97
156.3 7.3
123.3 4.1
060.9 3.5
060.9 2.4
069.6 4.2
070.2 4.5
23
Influence of heat treatment on structural, mechanical and wear properties of crosslinked UHMWPE
TABLE IV - TENSILE PROPERTIES AND TOUGHNESS (IZOD) RESULTS AFTER ACCELERATED AGEING
Materials
Yield strength
Strain at break
(MPa)
NT
25 kGy
155 1/10
24
23.36 0.16
28.13 0.69
20.83 0.39
381.4 31.6
102.2 65.9
256.6 23.2
UTS
Impact strength
(MPa)
(kJ/m2)
28.47 1.24
08.83 4.48
31.81 4.47
128.4 7.2
023.3 7.4
053.3 1.9
Chiesa et al
NT
25 kGy
130 W
130 1/10
155 W
155 1/10
69.8 1.6
68.3 3.1
4.30 0.10
4.16 0.07
3.19 0.33
3.04 0.07
3.50 0.25
3.34 0.25
54.5 2.4
53.9 4.0
84.5 7.6
85.4 1.5
71.0 4.2
86.0 5.2
245 12
232 7
190 28
189 5
168 18
201 24
NT
25 kGy
130 W
130 1/10
155 W
155 1/10
73.4 2.7
72.7 2.5
78.5 0.9
76.8 1.3
4.17 0.13
4.10 0.20
2.74 0.06
2.89 0.19
3.11 0.52
3.08 0.27
56.8 2.4
52.4 2.0
73.5 3.1
70.8 5.4
081.7 14.2
083.6 11.2
247 11
240 70
186 40
184 11
183 48
184 27
Influence of heat treatment on structural, mechanical and wear properties of crosslinked UHMWPE
Fig. 6 - a) Representative scanning electron micrographs of
UHMWPE small
punch test specimens
of untreated or sterilized materials after
testing to failure (original magnification
15x); b) fracture surface (original magnification 200x).
a
b
NT
25 KGy
130 1/10
130W
155 1/10
155W
2542
2628
0.09609
1639
0.11236
1321
0.13049
2872
0.08649
2808
0.10068
Wear test
Table IX and Figure 9 summarize the effect of gamma irradiation and stabilization treatment on
UHMWPE wear behavior.
Before ageing, crosslinked and stabilized materials
exhibited an improved resistance to wear over the
NT and 25 kGy sterilized materials. The mean
weight loss measured for the crosslinked specimens
was nearly zero, regardless of the thermal treatment performed (temperature and cooling
rate).
After ageing, with the crosslinked materials, there
was no difference in the amount or wear rate. On
26
TABLE VIII - DYNAMIC COMPRESSIVE TESTS: AVERAGE STRAIN AND SD AT 250,000 CYCLES
Materials
NT
8650 510
25 Kgy
8370 480
130 W
6470 950
130 1/10
6460 1120
155 W
9670 460
155 1/10
8120 1090
Chiesa et al
Materials
Wear
(mg)
Wear after
aging (mg)
NT
3.5 0.4
0.4.3 2.3
25 kGy
5.4 0.5
.33.2 9.3
130 W
0.1 0.40.
0.8 0.9
130 1/10
0.3 0.60.
0.8 0.8
155 W
0.2 0.4
0.0.9 3.6
155 1/10
0.0 0.4
0.0.2 0.3
CONCLUSION
Cross-linking treatments greatly increased
UHMWPE wear resistance, especially when
aged. A reduction in tensile and toughness
properties was seen for all crosslinked materials
analyzed, although there were slightly better results for slow cool-rate heat treatments. There
was a slight improvement in toughness behavior
of materials heat-treated at 155 C. Tensile and
toughness tests, performed on selected materials before and after ageing, showed important
27
Influence of heat treatment on structural, mechanical and wear properties of crosslinked UHMWPE
REFERENCES
1. Willert H, Bertram H, Buchhorn GH. Osteolysis in
alloarthroplasty of the hip The role of ultra-high
molecular weight polyethylene wear particles. Clin
Orthop 1990; 258: 95-107.
2. Amstutz HC, Campbell P, Kossovsky N, Clarke IC.
Mechanism and clinical significance of wear debrisinduced osteolysis. Clin Orthop 1992; 276: 7-18.
3. Cooper RA, McAllister CM, Borden LS, Bauer TW.
Polyethylene debris-induced osteolysis and loosening in uncemented total hip arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty 1992; 7: 285-90.
4. Encyclopedia of polymer science and technology, vol
6. Wiley & Sons 1976.
5. Muratoglu OK, Bragdon CR, OConnor DO et al.
Unified wear model for highly crosslinked ultra-high
molecular weight polyethylenes (UHMWPE). Biomaterials 1999; 20: 1463-70.
6. Oonishi H, Ishimaru H, Kato A. Effect of cross-linkage by gamma radiation in heavy doses to low wear
polyethylene in total hip prostheses. J Mater Sci
Mater Med 1996; 7: 753-63.
7. Chiesa R, Tanzi MC, Alfonsi S, Paracchini L,
Moscatelli M, Cigada A. Enhanced wear performance of highly crosslinked UHMWPE for artificial
joints. J Biomed Mater Res 2000; 50: 381-7.
8. Bragdon CR, OConnor DO, Muratoglu OK, et al. A
new polyethylene with undetectable wear at 12 million cycles. 24th Annual Meeting of the Society for
Biomaterials, 22-26 April, San Diego, California,
USA (1998), 2.
9. Shen FW, McKellop H, Salovey R. Improving the resistance to wear and oxidation of acetabular cups of
UHMWPE by gamma radiation crosslinking and
remelting. 24th Annual Meeting of the Society for
Biomaterials, 22-26 April, San Diego, California,
USA (1998), 3.
10. Wang A, Polineni VK, Essner A, Sun DC, Stark C,
Dumbleton JH. Effect of radiation dosage on the
wear of stabilized UHMWPE evaluated by hip and
28
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.