Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
SunrnR AXLAND,
I o12
PLLC
Judge Building
Jesse C. Trentadue
January 23,2012
E-mail jesse32@sautah.com
www.sautah.com
PLAINTIFF'S
EXHIBIT
28
VIA E-MAIL
Ms. Kathryn L. Wyer, Esq.
Assistant U.S. Attorney
20 Massachusetts Avenue N.W
Washington, D.C. 20530
Re
Avoiding
Motion to Compel
As you recall, I made a specific request for the Regency Tower videotapes,
and commenced this lawsuit to obtain them. On or about July 16,2009, Mr. Hardy
sent me "video coverage for the Regency Tower (6 DVDs), responsive to your
FOIA request IOKBOMB VIEOTAPESI noted above."r You may also recall
my complaints to you about those tapes having been edited, which now appears to
have been the case. I say this because of the testimony of FBI agent Jon Hersley.
Recently, I happened upon the testimony that Mr. Hersley gave on April
27,1995, during the Preliminary Hering for Timothy McVeigh. In that
testimony, Mr. Hersley describes in detail a videotape from one of the Regency
Tower exterior surveillance cameras taken at approximately 9:00 AM on the
morning of April 19,1995, including images of the Ryder Truck and "yellow
Mercury" shown in that tape.
According to Mr. I-Iersely, this camera scanned the area in front of the
Regency Towers and that while, for some unexplained reason, he had not watched
the entire tape but was shown still photographs produced from the tape, these
photographs showed the Ryder Truck moving in an "easterly direction" towards
the Murrah Building at approximately 9:00 AM on April 19,7995.2
The problem that I am having is that none of the images described by Mr.
Hersely in his Preliminary Hearing testimony appear on the 6 DVDs which Mr.
Hardy sent to me. I would very much appreciate it, therefore, if you could inquire
of the FBI about the missing video footage and provide me with a copy as soon as
possible.
Thank you
AXLAND
esse C. Trentadue
Case 2:08-cv-00788-CW-DBP
2053
July 1, 2009
MR. JESSE C. TRENTADUE
SUITE 2OO
8 EAST BROADWAY
SALT LAKE CITY, UT 84111
Jesse C, Trentadue v, FBI
Civil Action Number: 2:08-cv-00788
FOIA Request No,; 1120866-000
Subject: OKBOMB^/IDEOTAPES
Dear Mr. Trentadue:
Enclosed please fnd video coverage for the Regency Tower (6 DVs), responsive to your FOIA
request noted above.
These videos represent our final release in this matter; and are being furnished to you without
redactions. The duplicatin fee per DVD is $f 5.00, After crediting you for your payment of $91.40, there is
an account balancs of $90.00; an account summary is enclosed, Upon receipt of this final release, please
submit your check or money order in the amount of $90.00, payable to the Federal Bureau of lnvestigation.
To ensure proper credit of your payment, please include FOIA request number 1120866 with your payment
and mail it'directly to 170 Marcel Drive, Winchester, VA 22602-4843, within 45 days of the date of this
letter.
Sincerely yours,
b*Lt
David M, Hardy
Section Chief,
Record/lnformation
Dissemination Section
Records Management Division
Enclosures
Kathryn L. Wyer (w/o encl,)
cc:
OKLAHOMA
UNITED STATES OF
AMERICA,
Plaintiff,)
TIMOTHY JAMES
McVEIGH,
Defendant.)
27, L995
PRELIMINARY HEARING
MAGISTRATE RONALD HOWLAND, PRBSIDING
APPEARANCES
Merrick Garland, Arlene Joplin, United States Attorneys Office,
210 West Park Avenue, Oklahoma City, OK73LO2
COUNSEL FOR THE PLAINTIFF
I
I
Jon Hersley.
THE COURT; Mr. Hersley, step forward, face the
Clerk, raise your right hand and be sworn.
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. GARLAND:
0.
A.
A,
A,
a.
A.
About 20 years.
A.
A,
--
a.
A.
Yes.
a.
A.
Yes, I have.
a.
Building,
A,
A.
A,
0.
A,
a.
A.
A,
A.
Yes.
a,
A.
How many?
Between 100 and 150 is what I have heard
CROSS-EXAMINATION
BY MR. COYLE:
O.
A,
Good afternoon.
a.
Would you tell me, please, sir, if prior to the time that
A.
No,
0,
in connection
A.
a.
A.
I don't believe
A.
Can you tell me, please, sir, the agents that you have
so.
A.
a.
Rick?
A.
Rick Flahn --
a,
Okay.
tE
t7
.l
A.
A.
A.
A.
Now, can you tell us, please, sir, what your role has been
in the investigation?
A.
Yes,
O.
A.
, ,
,);D
"
t--
tlD'-
,-
!7
a.
So your
ofthe evidence and then you assign other FBI agents out to do
other tasks or to make calls?
A.
There are other agents that are assigned to the same types
of duties that
O.
A.
Yes.
A.
A,
D.-'
. ,
O.
A.
r:tr.-'
, ,-
,l:t.t
-'
:-
. ,--
tr
f,
, D-t
t.-'
Q. Okay,
so --
A.
Yes.
Q.
parked over the crater, the eite what you say is the
site of the exploeion?
A. I don't
crater ie. There are other pictures of the Ryder Truck on that
street.
A.
, ,--
tt.a
. ,.t
t:t"'-
east?
Yes.
A.
No.
Q.
Q.
Murrah Building?
A. That is correct.
Q. Are the photographs that you
saw or is
it still photo or
film?
photos.
A.
Yes.
>t
x'--'
. ,-f
t'.-'
- t-t
tt:t.-'
,-t
L07-I0
Filed
A.
Q,
So
A. It wasn't
a closeup photo,
of what building
it came off
of?
No,
Q.
that it came from one -- one of the films came from the Regency
Tower Apartments.
Q.
No
A.
t):rr . ,
-t
"
,r
B-
A, That is correct.
Q. What was the
A. I could not tell myself exactly what the eize was from the
photograph that I saw, but I would estimate t from what I saw
to be approximately 20 feet.
Q, Okay, can you tell us, please, sir, what that time was?
of 9;00
not study the photographs in great detail, and I don't know the
exact time on the photographs, but
9:00 a.m.
Q.
A.
. t-I
lt'-',
- t-I
f,:tr.-,
'. .;
, r^-
Da''
taken there.
A.
Yes.
No.
Q. Are you
a,vvare of
A.
No.
Q.
tl-rart
you are aware of, Agent, that shows the accused Timothy McVeigh
/t
,ffigi
1-1-
of 17
t7
A.
No.
a,m.
A. That is correct,
Q.
A,
Yes.
Murrah Buildng?
A.
Not that I have seen. I have not viewed all of the film of
Q.
exists. Have
No.
A.
a-
D-r lt.-
D_.r
tltf
.-
r-r
nt
--
D-l
nF.-
t07-10
i
I
McVeigh; am I correct?
Yes, you are correct as there are many other things
that
A.
see those?
Q.
Now, I assume -- who are those agents that are tasked with
purely speculative.
THE COURT: Overruled.
BY MR. COYLE:
A.
'-r
t1''
j-
" D-l
-:
. ,--
I:D.-'
. >--
f,:1',
D-r
I
{
No, he is
not.
.i
it to my attention
seen
exclude the Ryder Truck, not only around the Ryder Truck? Have
I
A,
No,
Q.
,liF
--
ry
L5 of L7
l
j
l
j
I
speeding away
A.
Can you clearly tell in the photographs that you have seen
or have you been advised that you can clearly tell in the film
the time of the explosion?
A.
A.
A,
The
not view the entire film. The pictures that were shown to me
were before the explosion,
a.
lot -- now I'm talking about the parking lot across the street
from the Murrah Building --
A.
Right.
a.
A.
Yee.
a,
Correct?
A.
Yes.
0.
, >-t) rD1''
. D-f
,fD.-,
. ,-)
t:D.-'
: .--,
A6l25lt2 Page L6 of L7
A.
Yes,
a.
A.
A.
A.
a.
A.
O.
A.
A,
A.
t-t
,j'',
"
1-7
of
1-7
Q,
seen.
Yes.
Q. And you havc cliscussed that with the agents and thc
importance an significance of the suggestiveness of the fact
that his picture has been broadcast like that throughout our
lancl; have you not?
A. I have not been the one to cliscuss that, but I know that is
being cliscussed. I have spoken with a couple of the other
agents alrottt that, but another ageul. has beert assigned to
oversee that portion of the investigation.
Q. Who is that
A.
It. woulcl
agent?
A. 'lo
cliscutsseci
it with?
Srn
is Mike. I don't
tu''
b..ffi
TtuF,';"
--ffi
.+*rB' i",
.-W
,rLltr. 1'
-,-'
^ffi
;sh. r-