MIAMI DADE COLLEGE

COMMITTEE SCORING SPREADSHEET - INITIAL SCORING

SUPLEMENTAL INFORMATION PACKAGE (SIP) USP3 - 2015-20-10 - 2015-20-10 - PUBLIC/PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF A MIXED
USE PROJECT AT 520 BISCAYNE BOULEVARD,
MIAMI, FLORIDA 33132
---------------------------------Weighted Score------------------------------------

---------------------------------Rating (0-5)------------------------------------

CONCENSUS

CONCENSUS

Gregg Covin Development/

Oppenheim Architecture

R. Montoya

EH Levering

N. Otero

R. Martinez

Y. Ponce-Fullana

R. Montoya

EH Levering

N. Otero

TOTAL
R. Martinez

Y. Ponce-Fullana

i. Proposed Project Concept

(Plan for Accomplishing the Project Requirements, Goals and
Objectives)

3.5

105

105

4.5

135

135

120

120

4.5

45

45

ii. Company Background, Financial Strength and

Business Success
(Development Experience and Financial Ability to Develop the
Project, Experience of Offeror and Key Personnel, and
References)

iii. Business Terms

(Financial Considerations and proposed legal relationship with the
College for ownership of the proposed facility)

iv. Other Information; and local small business

utilization
(Additional Items)

Total

---------------------------------Rating (0-5)------------------------------------

---------------------------------Weighted Score------------------------------------

CONCENSUS

Nader+Museu I Limited Liability Limited

Partnership

R. Montoya

EH Levering

N. Otero

405

CONCENSUS
R. Martinez

Y. Ponce-Fullana

R. Montoya

EH Levering

N. Otero

TOTAL
R. Martinez

Y. Ponce-Fullana

i. Proposed Project Concept

(Plan for Accomplishing the Project Requirements, Goals and
Objectives)

120

120

4.5

135

135

4.5

135

135

50

50

ii. Company Background, Financial Strength and

Business Success
(Development Experience and Financial Ability to Develop the
Project, Experience of Offeror and Key Personnel, and
References)

iii. Business Terms

(Financial Considerations and proposed legal relationship with the
College for ownership of the proposed facility)

iv. Other Information; and local small business

utilization
(Additional Items)

5
Page 1 of 4

Total

---------------------------------Rating (0-5)------------------------------------

---------------------------------Weighted Score-----------------------------------CONCENSUS

CONCENSUS

Pi Art Tech and Trade Center at MDC,

LLC.(Axis Realty Trust)

R. Montoya

EH Levering

N. Otero

440

R. Martinez

Y. Ponce-Fullana

R. Montoya

EH Levering

N. Otero

TOTAL
R. Martinez

Y. Ponce-Fullana

i. Proposed Project Concept

(Plan for Accomplishing the Project Requirements, Goals and
Objectives)

90

90

3.5

105

105

90

90

4.5

45

45

ii. Company Background, Financial Strength and

Business Success
(Development Experience and Financial Ability to Develop the
Project, Experience of Offeror and Key Personnel, and
References)

iii. Business Terms

(Financial Considerations and proposed legal relationship with the
College for ownership of the proposed facility)

iv. Other Information; and local small business

utilization
(Additional Items)

Total

---------------------------------Rating (0-5)------------------------------------

---------------------------------Weighted Score-----------------------------------CONCENSUS

CONCENSUS

PRH Investments, LLC./The Related Group

R. Montoya

EH Levering

N. Otero

330

R. Martinez

Y. Ponce-Fullana

R. Montoya

EH Levering

N. Otero

TOTAL
R. Martinez

Y. Ponce-Fullana

i. Proposed Project Concept

(Plan for Accomplishing the Project Requirements, Goals and
Objectives)

4.5

135

135

150

150

4.5

135

135

50

50

ii. Company Background, Financial Strength and

Business Success
(Development Experience and Financial Ability to Develop the
Project, Experience of Offeror and Key Personnel, and
References)

iii. Business Terms

(Financial Considerations and proposed legal relationship with the
College for ownership of the proposed facility)

iv. Other Information; and local small business

utilization
(Additional Items)

Total

Page 2 of 4

470