Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Associate Professor.
Acoustic Characteristics of an
Expansion Chamber With Constant
Mass Flow and Steady
Temperature Gradient (Theory and
Numerical Simulation)
The governing equation of acoustic wave propagation in a circular expansion chamber with mean flow and temperature gradient is solved. The circular chamber is
divided into N segments and the flow speed and temperature are assumed to be
constant in each segment. The solution is obtained in recursive form by applying
the matching condition on the boundary of adjacent elements. The solution is verified
by comparing it with the experimental results. The results demonstrate that the
present theory can well predict the transmission loss of an expansion chamber which
has offset, a twisting angle, mean flow, and temperature gradient.
Introduction
An understanding of acoustic wave propagation through an
expansion chamber is essential in order to design the silencer
system of automobiles, blowers, and other machines. The main
difficulty of this subject is that the governing wave equation
is not linear because of the nonuniform mass flow of gas as
well as the temperature gradient along the chamber.
Munjal and Prasad [1] applied the perturbation method to
solve the wave equation which represents the acoustic characteristics of a uniform pipe with mean flow as well as linear
temperature gradient. The solution shows an unrealistic offset
of the transmission loss curve. Peat [2] derived the transfer
matrix considering variable mean gas density and the velocity
gradient along uniform pipe, but this result also has the offset
which cannot be explained in a physical sense. El-Sharkawy
and Nayfeh [3] successfully analyzed the acoustic characteristics of an expansion chamber by theory and experiment, but
the effects of mean flow and temperature variations along the
chamber on the propagation of acoustic wave were not considered. Due to the complexity of the wave equation, which
represents sound wave through an expansion chamber with
mass flow and temperature gradient, Munjal [4] tried to solve
the equation by numerical technique. The drawback is that
many meshes are required to account for higher order modes.
Apart from this approach, Ih and Lee [5] succeeded in getting
theoretical results which included higher order modes of a
circular expansion chamber whose inlet and outlet ports have
offset and a twisting angle. The temperature effect was not
/_dP\
PC2
dtypc2 dt)
(VP)>V =0
(1)
The second and fourth terms express the change of energy due
to the change of velocity and temperature in space. The third
term is the time rate of change of energy within the system.
The general solution of this equation has not been found yet.
One of the reasons is that the acoustic velocity and density of
gas are not constant, varying with respect to a spatial coordinate. For example, temperature (7), density (p), acoustic
velocity (c), and mean flow velocity (W0) of a simple expansion
chamber which has a linear temperature gradient (Fig. 1) can
be expressed as follows:
_ T2~T_2
T(z)
=T,
p(z)
=pm/
c(z)
=20.05
Tx + T2'
= Ti + Tl
(H
1-T,
(2)
Fig. 1 Geometry of simple expansion chamber and temperature gradient shape
yJT{z)
-(H
W(z) = Wm
V2*-
1 D oP
=0
V 2 P - -5
<?D<f
(3)
where
1 Dfa= 0
(4)
<?D0t2
a*
dt
K=-V*
For a cylindrical chamber (Fig. 1), the solution of equation
(4) can be written as
where
${r,6,z,t)=4>(r,d,z)e>'*'
(5)
where
Mrftx)
= E E (RL^nmZ
Rnmeik'^z)Jn(kmmr)cosnd
(6)
Nomenclature
au
/ = Bessel function of
order n
wave number in
r-direction
wave number in
K-znm
z-direction
i = length of expansion chamber
transmission loss
LTL
Mach number
M
pressure
P
coefficient of veKm
locity potential of
element i
reflection coeffi^inm
cient between
Km and Rrm of
element /
T = temperature
Journal of Vibration and Acoustics
Tm = temperature at
midpoint of expansion chamber
Tr = temperature gradient
at inr T2 = temperature
let/outlet pipe
Ti[, Ti2, T2\, T22 = four-pole parameter
U\, U2 = volume flow rate
at inlet/outlet
pipe
V particle velocity
Vu V2 - particle velocity
at inlet/outlet
pipe
W = coefficient according to boundary conditions of
elements
W = mean flow velocity
Wm = mean flow velocity at midpoint of
expansion chamber
D0t2
partial derivative
with respect to
time
material derivative with respect
to time
dz
oz z=i
VJ2(r,8),
z=l
dr
30
= 0,
dr
dz z=o
-0
{la)
=0
(lb)
V
\mj
n = 0,1,2, . . .
m = 0,1,2, . . .; n - 0 and m = 0 should not be assigned to zero simultaneously
_(1 n= 0
7
"~(2 n*0
Hence, the velocity potentials for the first and the last elements
are
>
(eik+izMz + sl00e>k'iz0Oz)
^-\Jl(\nm)\n
z
(e>* I*** + Slnme>k w>>(Km
)J,
~a)cosndl
V~JV\
(8)
*& (e/ky^:
+ Sy00e/ky^oz)
^iz00 + "inofc
100-lz00
+EE
n m
(9)
Wynm ...W2,
(-)'
dz
(16)
I->a
(ai
HzOO + Sinak]
100ftl00
dz
(15)
where
-C
where
-\ COS/20
(\m)
kfnm = k[M =F V l - ( l - M 2 ) ( f c r a m / f c ) 2 / ( l - M 2 ) ]
Acosnddrdd
4>i=JVi
^(Xnm)=0
j \rf(r,6)Jn(\m
(ID
l-la
- d6
P=jup4> + pW-^(12)
dz
Using the second equation of equation (la), the relation
between R%m and R^m can be found. Then the matching conditions which are expressed by equations (10) and (11), lead
to the following recursive equations.
where
( n )
= 0,1,2, . . .
m = 0,l,2, . . .; = 0 and m = 0 should not be assigned to zero simultaneously
5 =
ifI P '
rdrdd=UiZi
(18)
.-^Il^y**-^A
n m
(19)
(14)
To apply the first equation of equation (7a) to equation (13),
we must expand fx(r, 6) in terms of the Fourier-Bessel series
[7], That is
Pyrdrd6=U2Z^
l
' Tfl? j ] '
U2( = ira2V2) is the volume flow rate of the outlet port. Pit Py,
Z2 and Z 4 are shown in Appendix B.
Finally, the mean pressures of the inlet and outlet ports of
the expansion chamber can be obtained from equations (18)
and (19).
Transactions of the ASME
CdBJ
SB
=L3ZJ=
2.6kHz
,w
nf \ f
vvW
a.a
frequency
(a)
4.a
\f
If
it
li/\l//J
...
ZGktiz
s.i
CkHz J
=H.
"1
l_
IM^
A* l\
3.2
frequency
(c)
D = 1 5 0 m m , L = 3 0 0 m m , Center to Center
( - : Experimental result. : Plane wave thenrv 1
S.4
CkHzJ
D = 1 5 0 m m , L = 4 5 0 m m , Center t o Center
( - : Experimental result, : Plane wave theory )
[dB]
60
=CEE s
JVxWI
JvL
:OTYYYliiklU
J
13
3.2
[Mb]
4.B
BA
frequency
(d) D~150mm, L450mm, Center to Center
(Present theory; 1 element, n~2, m 7)
Pl=Pn+Pa=UlZi
+ U2Z2
(20)
P2 =
P21+P22=UlZ3+U2Z4
Rewriting equation (20) in matrix form leads to
Tu
[T21
where Tn
n-
(21)
Z, r L = 201og
z3
where
Z\Z4
*]
- ^ - 0
z,
2Jll2 = 0
'Ul]
z3
z4
z3
=-
-M2))
Tu =jpc/(Tra1)e-JklM/U-M\m(lcl/(
1 - M2))
T2i =jira2/(pc)e-JklM/^-M\m(kl/(l
T22 =
JklMni M
e-
I Tn + Ti2/Zm
+ T2lZ02 + T221
(23)
Z0i=PiCi/(ircr\)
Z02 =
pyc/(iraj)
+ Z2
T,,=
T22
Tl2
T22
- M2))
2
- \os(kl/(\-M ))
Experimental result
.. : Present theoryfl element, n=5, m=7)
Experimental result
: Present theory(l element, n=2, m=7)
1.6
3.2
4.a
frequency
6.4
: Experimental result
: Present theory(l element, n=5, m=7)
CkHil
R)
"L
_r
mm
3
frequency
-t.S
[kH
frequency
Dti9s]
Fig. 8 Effect of temperature gradient on TL of simple expansion chamber without mean flow (M = 0; D = 150 mm, L = 300 mm; 6 elements,
n = 5, m = 7)
Conclusions
The solution of the acoustic wave equation which governs
the acoustic wave propagation in a circular expansion chamber
in the presence of mean flow and temperature gradient was
derived in recursive form. The solution was verified by numerical simulation. The numerical results of transmission loss
were compared with the experimental results. We found that
the suggested numerical solution well predicted the transmission loss of an expansion chamber. The number of elements
and number of modes in radial and circumferential directions,
which are required for convergence, are sufficiently small
enough to extend this scheme to more general cases; i.e., an
elliptic expansion chamber, pulsating gas flow, etc.
References
This is the reason why Figs. 2(c) and 2(d), and Fig. 6 are almost
identical.
The effect of mean flow is demonstrated better in Fig. 7
than Fig. 6. In the low frequency range, the frequency shift
due to the presence of mean flow can be observed easily. In
the high frequency range where higher order modes control
the transmission loss, the mean flow modifies the curve of
transmission loss in a more complicated way than it does in
the low frequency range [equation (22)].
The effect of temperature gradient on transmission loss is
shown in Fig. 8. As the temperature gradient increases, so do
the amplitude of transmission loss and the cutoff frequency.
Acoustic impedance is inversely proportional to \pT. Therefore, the acoustic impedance of the outlet port is higher than
that of the inlet port. This introduces a higher transmission
loss in magnitude.
It is very difficult and expensive to obtain a high mach
number and meaningful temperature gradient in the experiment. Also, the measurement of transmission loss of an expansion chamber in the presence of a high Mach number and
temperature gradient has many difficulties [9]. Noise due to
the turbulence of the flow must be properly handled, and
special sensors which can be operated in hot gas must be designed or obtained. The numerical solution does not have these
limitations.
The number of elements which were required for convergence was 6 to 9 in most cases. The number of modes for
convergence was always less than 10. In most cases, it was 8,
as can be found in all of the figures.
Journal of Vibration and Acoustics
1 Munjal, M. L., and Prasad, M. G., 1986, "On Plane Wave Propagation
in a Uniform Pipe in the Presence of a Mean Flow and a Temperature Gradient,''
Journal oflheAcoust.
Soc. Am., Vol. 80, No. 5, pp. 1501-1506, Nov.
2 Peat, K. S., 1988, "The Transfer Matrix of a Uniform Duct with a Linear
Temperature Gradient," Journal of Sound and Vibration, Vol. 123, No. 1, pp.
43-53.
3 El-sharkawy, A. I., and Nayfes, Ali H., 1978, "Effect of an Expansion
Chamber on the Propagation of Sound in Circular Duct,'' Journal oftheAcoust.
Soc. Am., Vol. 63, No. 3, pp. 667-674, Mar.
4 Munjal, M . L . , 1987, " A Simple Numerical Method for Three Dimensional
Analysis of Simple Expansion Chamber Mufflers of Rectangular as well as
Circular Cross Section with a Stationary Medium," Journal of Sound and
Vibration, Vol. 116, No. 1, pp. 71-88.
5 Ih, Jeong-Guon, and Lee, Byung-Ho, 1985, "Analysis of Higher Order
Mode Effects in the Circular Expansion Chamber with Mean Flow," Journal
oftheAcoust.
Soc. Am., Vol. 77, No. 4, pp. 1377-1388, April.
6 Davies, P. O. A. L., 1988, "Practical Flow Duct Acoustics," Journal of
Sound and Vibration, Vol. 124, No. 1, pp. 91-115.
7 Hildebrand, F. B., 1976, Advanced Calculus for Application, Prentice Inc.,
Chap. 5.
8 Watson, 1966, A Treatise on the Theory of Bessel Functions, Cambridge
Univ. Press, Chap. 6.
9 Kim, Y.-H., Lim, B. D., Kim, S. H., and Kwak, Y. K., 1989, "Experimental
Study on Acoustic Wave Propagation in Circular Expansion Chamber with Mean
Flows," ASME Paper 89-WA/NCA-7, also presented at the Winter Annual
Meeting, San Francisco, California. December 10-15, 1989.
APPENDIX
(q-\)nm'
Xq\ \Xq22
XqnXq2\
.eik\q~\)zmn^
Xq2lQ(q-
w =
Tr
qnm
+ - + /(?-1))
\)nm ~ Xq\2k(qA
\XaY>
X\
^q\\ qTL
\)znm
Xi
X,
q\2A2ql\
: e/(*;
Qinm=pq^^Wqk^nm)
(/ z)
- )./n(xm0cosn0
=e/*5w('i+- + '(- 1 ) ) G, + m + S, n m
Xqn
(a2/a)2
*,=y'*2
e*?W'i+-+'<-i)>g- n f f l
kyzOO + SyaAyzOO
2y(.a2/a)J_(
^2. ^
+/(<?-i))+s,nm^m
Xnm -^\7,
UE
' ^yznm "* ^ynm^yznm)
"-{g-l^nm17
^022
Zi=-
(i/) 2
Pi
Tl
(ei'K-l'-!l + S . / j " -
[co(l+S 100 )
I '
47A(x
) / , X ra
cosn9
"\ " a)
-1)00
^7^X^
TTtfJ C
(Knm + S\nmkunm)\A~
! l
where n = 0,1,2, . . .
m = 0,1,2, . . . ; n = 0 and m = 0 should not be assigned
to zero simultaneously
+ ^i(*i+zoo + Sioo*iloo)]
\ * ~~ -v 2
'
W z O O + SlOO^ljOO
"
(X m - ^ j
^r)
^ j O O + ^OO^VzOO
fyKn,)H nm
+ aJ
i
4T-/- (X
^synm^-yznm)
?im
i
z,=
E D
^ m /
cosfl0[(^tz(')+5,^*1^(0) _ ^ ( * 1 + w i ^ * W ' )
+ Wy(ky+^kyzco'+Syaok-aoeik~ym')]+
+ SinmfcfOTme'*T^('))]
4 7 ^ - (x ) J-n (x f ) 7, ( x 5 ) 7, (x ra | ) ^.y/im
( k\Znm
+ Slitmk\zm
) \ ^ ~
Km/
r r 2nm
) ^n( \ m ) X,
cosnd0[o>(e'kyz>"l+Syme>kyz">1) + Jy(k+!,me>kyzil
z
+ SynmkyZmeikyznmi)}
4 = % L + ^/f^-K
where n = 0,1,2, . . .
/ = 0,1,2, . . . ; = 0 and w = 0 should not be assigned
to zero simultaneously
A P P E N D I X
'Vznm
- 90i
y"K2
(a2/a)2Wm.
('-)'
where = 0,1,2, . . .
m = 0,l,2, . . .; = 0 and m = 0 should not be assigned
to zero simultaneously
X 9 n^?22 XtfuX^i
yzWS ~r 'JyOoKyzM
^ynm'^yznm.
LJ
y Zm)]
[Cl)(l +Sy
Wy(kyZm+ Sy
mky
^ynm)m ) rryK^ywrn'
ynm'
yznm!
dz
. .W,( J
>./-.(.;) 4 * )
-EE-
P , =76)00!+p*P,
Py=jWp(j>y + pWy
('- w)^
'(?)>
+
(,_/,_.
tgl" (q+iyznm1-1
'1
, , ,,,
'(9-1))
1"m
X
,)K
g 2 2 Q ( g + l)m ~ X g l 2 k ( + g + j)znm
X
l 1X?22 ~ X 9 l 2 X 9 2 1
Kqnm
Xqn=-^kig+Dznm(l-n
^qnm^-qnm
^ \ Iznm
7
Iznm
lnm
lg)Q-q
\)nm
iznm)l
H-lznm
Xql\~
-lq)
~lq)
"
2. Dote of Filing
1B. PUBLICATION N O .
TRANSACTIONS
JOURNAL
OF V I B R A T I O N
OF T H E ASME
AND ACOUSTICS
3. Frequency of Issue
3 A . N o . of Issues Published
Annually
QUARTERLY
FOUR
4 , Complete Mailing Address of K n o w n Office of Publication (Street, City, County, Slate and ZIP+4 Code) (Not primers)
9/11/90
3B. Annuel Subscription Price
$110.00
NY 10017
5. Complete Mailing Address of t h e Headquarters of General Business Offices of the Publisher (Not printer)
Full N a m e
The American S o c i e t y o f
M e c h a n i c a l Enqineers
345 E a s t 4 7 t h S t r e e t
Hew Y o r k . NY 1 0 0 1 7
8. K n o w n Bondholders, Mortgagees, a n d Other Security Holders O w n i n g or Holding 1 Percent or More of Total A m o u n t of Bonds, Mortgages or Other
Securities (If there are none, so state)
Fult N a m e
NONE
NONE
9. For Completion by Nonprofit Organizations Authorized To Mail at Special Rates (DMM Section 423.12 only)
The purpose, f u n c t i o n , and nonprofit status of this organization and the exempt status for Federal income tax purposes (Check one)
111
1 | Has Not Changed During
L K J Preceding 1 2 Months
^ '
.21
ij Has Changed During
1 1 Preceding 1 2 Months
ofCandD)
G. TOTAL (Sum ofE, Fl and 2should equal net press run shown In A)
VI.
2,420
2,371
1,638
1,812
1,638
1,812
428
231
2,066
2,083
354
328
2,420
2,371
Publisher