Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
A. Curtis Burton
Christopher LaMonica
Mariko Hemmingsen
Board Members:
John Akokpari
Lere Amusan
Priya Chacko
Mourtada Deme
Ibaba Samuel Ibaba
Christopher LaMonica
Victoria Mason
Masse Ndiaye
Stanley Naribo Ngoa
J. Shola Omotola
Karen Smith
Kathryn Sturman
Franoise Ugochukwu
Douglas Yates
F R I C A N A
Boston University
African Studies Center
232 Bay State Road
Boston, MA 02210
U.S.A.
Print: ISSN 2155-7829
On-line: ISSN 2155-7837
www.africanajournal.org
Vol. 5, No. 1
Vol. 5, No. 1
ii
CONTENTS
v
vi
22
49
74
108
Vol. 5, No. 1
iii
140
164
189
Armed Militancy in the Niger Delta: Quintessential PlayOff of Sub-Regional Economic Disparities
Franklins A. Sanubi, PhD
216
238
272
Vol. 5, No. 1
iv
Vol. 5, No. 1
Vol. 5, No. 1
vi
the view that those human senses are inherently dangerous and
therefore should not be a part of social science inquiry. We firmly
believe that human sensitivity toward and empathy for our fellow
man is tragically undervalued in the social sciences. Following in the
logic of philosopher George Santayana, the late Edward Said, and
Canadian critic John Ralston Saul, we believe that the lessons of the
Enlightenment have been hijacked by a world of thinkers and
practitioners who are, in their pursuit of rational scientific inquiry,
neglecting that other important lesson of the Enlightenment:
reasonable-ness, i.e. that each of us by virtue of being human has
inalienable rights and, as such, must be included as a critical factor in
all discussions of policy. Modes of rational scientific inquiry, now and
in history, have all too often neglected that basic fact: each of us
matters.
It is perfectly understandable that many feel empowered by scientific
methods and productive outcomes to include those of the oil
industries; indeed the entire world is being transformed as a result!
But we cannot forget our common human-ness along the way; we
cannot set aside enormous populations on this Earth and simply write
them off as a cost of our rationalist scientific enterprise. Let us put
this even more bluntly: Hitler and Stalin were similarly justified in
their scientific pursuits of Nazism and Communism, respectively. We
all know all of us that breaking a few eggs to make an omelet, as
Stalin infamously put it, is wrong. Yet this is fundamentally the
logic of far too many who are now engaged in African affairs. And
so we remind our readers that that approach, so evident in a place like
the Niger Delta Region, is wrong, inappropriate, and in the words of
so many who inspired the Spirit of the Enlightenment: unreasonable.
The test of reasonable-ness makes us think of things that are often
listed as costs in an otherwise more practical or pragmatic mode:
human lives, the quality of life, the environment, arts, cultures,
Vol. 5, No. 1
vii
Vol. 5, No. 1
viii
Vol. 5, No. 1
ix
Vol. 5, No. 1
Vol. 5, No. 1
xi
Vol. 5, No. 1
xii
Vol. 5, No. 1
xiii
Vol. 5, No. 1
xiv
Introduction
The Niger Delta is one of the ten most important wetland and
coastal marine ecosystems in the world. It is home to some 31 million
people. (Report of the Niger Delta Technical Committee, November
2008:102). The Niger Delta is also the location of massive oil and gas
deposits, which have been exploited since 1956. Oil has generated an
estimated $600 billion since the commercial exploitation of oil in
Nigeria. Despite this, the majority of the people in the oil bearing
enclave of the Niger Delta are conspicuously poor. The United
Nations Development Programme (UNDP) describes the region as
suffering
from
administrative
neglect,
crumbling
social
infrastructure, and services, high unemployment, social deprivation,
abject poverty, filth and squalor and endemic conflict (UNDP, 2006).
What the UNDP failed to add is that the region is also embroiled in
cultural crisis engendered by the activities of the oil majors.
The Niger Delta remains one of the critical fault lines of Nigerian
politics. Not only is it the region that holds Nigerias predominantly
oil reserves and therefore, the national wealth, it has assumed a new
geopolitical importance in the context of global oil politics. Like many
oil producing countries, the region has not been spared the agony of
recurring violent conflicts associated with the management of oil
resources (Oyefusi, 2007).
Since the mid 1990s, there has been on-going violence and uprising in
the Niger Delta region with a renewed call for self-determination and
/or local control of oil resources. These conflicts, often attended by
kidnapping of foreign oil workers for ransom, vandalization and
sometimes blow-up of oil installations, have taken on a frightening
dimension over the years. According to a report by Hamilton and
others (2004), violence in the Niger Delta alone is estimated to have
killed about 1000 persons a year between 1999 and 2004. This chapter
focuses on one dimension of the crisis in the Niger Delta: the cultural
crisis. Attempt is made to dissect and explicate the nature of the
cultural crisis in the region. Conventional analysis of the crisis in the
ND seems to down play the ancillary impact of the oil industry with a
focus on the flora and the fauna. This, as it were must have blurred
the intricacy of the issues in contention. Thus, a holistic assessment of
the crisis must also take cognizance of the culture of the people that is
constantly violated and has subsequently engendered a strange subculture detrimental to every life in the region. Our analysis charts the
common ground of oil induced behavioral modification that seems to
be impairing a hitherto tranquil and harmonious society. In this light,
a concise discourse of the oil industry in the region is undertaken to
lay a background to the cultural crisis in the area. This is done against
the backdrop of an analysis of the precise causes of the social
disequilibrium and the resultant break down of culture in the region.
Petro-Business in the Niger Delta
The Niger Delta region has been defined in terms of geology,
geography and ethnography (Onokerhoraye, 2000). There is hardly
any controversy over the geological, geographical and ethnographical
description of the Niger Delta Region (NDR). With the ascendancy of
crude oil, the NDR is synonymous, in the perception of many
Nigerians, with oil provinces of the delta. The NDDC Act, 2000, and
the OMPADEC Act of 1992 would seem to have accentuated this
Vol. 5, No. 1
Vol. 5, No. 1
Vol. 5, No. 1
Vol. 5, No. 1
Vol. 5, No. 1
Vol. 5, No. 1
for both income and food. The activities of the oil companies have
engendered land hunger and subsequently distorted the cultural
practices of the people that are tied to their land.
In the traditional Niger Delta setting, such as the Ogoni area, when
a woman gets married, her husband is required to give her a piece
of land to farm. The woman is expected to feed her family and
grow for food for sale in order to buy other staples from the parcel
of land. This tradition allowed the woman to enjoy a measure of
economic independence. However, the constant land-take for oil
activities, and the resultant pollution from the industry, has left
women in the region with little or no means to feed or support
their families in this otherwise symbiotic arrangement. Women
have to go further away from home to find unpolluted land and
water for their domestic chores (Diana).
As is the case in most Nigerian communities, women play
prominent role in the management of health of the household
because as agents of fertility, they have specific knowledge of local
medicines. Their knowledge of herbs, tree barks and other local
cures were acquired during their fattening room period. This
starts after the birth of the first child and lasts for one year. During
this period, she is not allowed out of the family compound.
Besides being a time to rest, it is also a time of informal schooling
when she learns how to look after her child and home. She is
attended to by women from her family and older women in the
community. As pressure grows on young women, forced to deal
with shrinking agricultural resources, very little time is left for
them to acquire the specialized health knowledge traditionally
gained through a fattening room period. For those who still
practice this tradition, it rarely exceeds two months after which
they must return to farming (Diana).
Vol. 5, No. 1
Vol. 5, No. 1
lack of any alternatives has led many young girls into prostitution
and are made to engage in bestiality by some expatriates
(Adalikwu, 2007:164; Semenitari, 1998; Brisibi, 2001). More
importantly perhaps is the fact that because men have migrated
away in search of greener pastures, their wives become susceptible
to the seduction of the oil men. When eventually they return to
hear gory tales of the escapade of their wives, the men in return
disown their wives and consequently swell the already large pool
of free women willing to engage in commercial sex. In fact, break
down of marriages is a serious aspect of the cultural crisis in the
Niger Delta. There is also an emerging army of fatherless children
in the region. This is not unconnected with the high wave of
prostitution enunciated above. As the young and impressionistic
girls fall victims to the itinerant oil workers, they are made to bear
the burden of caring for the children who unfortunately are rejected
by the oil men. Indeed, it may not be out of place to stress that the
children today are the arrow heads of the militants in the region.
The argument may be made that the young girls are equally guilty
since it takes two to tangle. But when one discovers the level of
social awareness in the region, one would easily exonerate them.
These are materially impoverished folks living far away from urban
communities and hence ignorant of more dignifying means of
livelihood after their farmland had been degraded by oil
multinationals (Aghalino 1999). The teenage girls are attracted to
the steady flow of cash from their transient lovers and
subsequently ignore going to school as it is seen as time wasting. It
is therefore explicable why the young girls are highly susceptible to
the oil men who can lure them with little sums of money but
which unfortunately appear enormous in the eyes of the girls
(Teilanye, 1997:25).
Vol. 5, No. 1
10
Vol. 5, No. 1
11
migrations in the Niger Delta are also informed by the wish to move
elsewhere because of unbearable pollution of water ways and land
as well as the inflationary trend institute by oil field workers.
Others are searching for opportunities to re-establish trading
activities as a result of the lost of their farmland to oil pollution. It
seems that Nigeria's oil boom has turned the "Petroleum producing
areas to centrifugal centers of oil doom where people leave rather
than live in". (Adeniyi, et al.1983). It is easily conjectured that the
rapid migratory wave to cities and oil enclave had denuded the
population of the Niger Delta, dislocated the active stratum of society
and had consequently disoriented social networks that previously
sustained a virile cultural life style in the region (Darah, 1995).
Decline in artistic and socio-cultural and religious performances
illustrate the above development. Hitherto, the vibrancy in artistic life
was a prominent feature of the Niger social outlook. An urban-rural
was already showing in the Niger Delta by the time oil became a
dominant feature of the economy. The oil boom years sharpened it
.Rural-urban migrations intensified with a consequent decline in rural
population. The sharp decrease in rural population caused a decline in
the number and frequency of annual or seasonal performances and
observance of important cultural ceremonies, especially festivals. The
cultural space lost to traditional festivals is now filled largely by
elaborate obituary ceremonies. In point of fact, burials of the aged
were always elaborate in the region as the forum was used to reenact
culture and tradition. What is new is the conduct of funeral in form of
carnivals even for young people. This has engendered cultural crisis as
these burials entails extravagant spending, especially the spraying of
currency notes on the children of the deceased.
An adjunct to the above is that a majority of households in the region
is now headed by women as a result of the migration of their
Vol. 5, No. 1
12
Vol. 5, No. 1
13
Vol. 5, No. 1
14
Vol. 5, No. 1
15
Vol. 5, No. 1
16
Conclusion
This paper has attempted to examine the cultural crisis
induced by oil exploration and production in the Niger Delta. The
point was adumbrated that it is conventional for scholars to view the
crises in the Niger Delta from the binoculars of environmental
deterioration occasioned by oil pollution and gas flaring without
taking cognizance of the cultural crisis as these are intertwined. The
environment of the people of the region cannot be divorced from their
every activity which is embedded in their culture.
Thus, the cultural crisis in the region is explicated by the break down
of pristine ways of doing things and this is reflected in the violation of
land rights, degradation of cultural artifacts such as shrine, groves
and even burial sites. The cultural crisis in the region is acute as it
affects women and their access to land, water and pharmaceutical
product derived from land. More importantly perhaps is the wave of
migration, resurgence of crime as attested to by youth militancy and
disdain for constituted authority. There is structural and social
dislocation of society as epitomized by high wave of prostitution,
acceptance of spirit of rugged individualism and strained inter-group
relations. Our point of departure is that although the federal
government is making concerted effort to tame the Niger Delta crisis,
this must be done from a holistic perspective by taking into
consideration the cultural dimension of the crisis. This, in fact, entails
social re-engineering and cultural re-orientation to integrate the
people back to their society.
Vol. 5, No. 1
17
References
Academic Associates Peace Work, (2006). Oil Prospecting and Communal
Crisis. Case Studies of Private Corporations Activities in the Niger
Delta, Nigeria
Adalikwu, J. 2007.Globalisation and the Uneven Application of International
Regulatory Standard: the Case of Oil Exploration in Nigeria. PhD
Thesis, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon.
Adeniyi E. O. et al (1983) Environmental and Socio-economic Impacts of oil
Spillage in the Petroleum Producing areas of Nigeria in proceedings
of the 1983 international Seminar on the Petroleum Industry and
the Nigerian Environment (Lagos: NNPC).
Aghalino S. O. (1994) Isoko Under Colonial Rule 1896-1949 M.A. Thesis
University of llorin.
Aghalino, S.O. and B.M. Eyinla, 2009. Oil Exploitation and Marine Pollution:
Evidence for the Niger Delta, Nigeria, Journal of Human Ecology,
Vol. 28, No. 3, pp.177-182.
Aghalino, S.O. (2000) British Colonial Politics and the Oil Palm Industry
in the Niger Delta Region, 1900-1960, African Study Monographs
21(1).
Aghalino, S.O. (2005). Issues and Trend in the Payment of Compensation in
the Oil Industry in Nigeria, 1969-1997, Ibom Journal of History and
International Studies, Vol., 12, No. 1, pp186-208
Aghalino, S.O. 2009. Oil Exploitation and the Accentuation of Intergroup
Relations in the Niger Delta, Nigeria. Journal of Human Ecology.
Vol.28, No.3, pp.153-159.
Aghalino, S.O. 2009. The Olusegun Obasanjo Administration and the Niger
Delta 1999-2007. Studies of Tribes and Tribals Vol. 7, Number 1,
pp.57-60.
Aghalino, S.O. 2010.Resource Control and the Problem of the Niger Delta
Region of Nigeria. In Adam Karap Chekpkwony & Peter M.J. Hess
(ed.) Human Views on God. Variety Not Monotony. Essays in
Honour of Ade P. Dopamu, Kenya: Moi University Press, Eldovet
pp.263-271.
Vol. 5, No. 1
18
Vol. 5, No. 1
19
Fayeye, J.O. 2009. The Place of Culture in Plural Societies; In Lasisi, R.O. and
Fayeye, J.O. (ed.,) Leading Issues in General Studies. Ilorin: General
Studies Division
Fayeye, J.O. 2009. The Place of Culture in Plural Societies, In: Lasisi, R.O.
and J.O. Fayeye, (eds.) Leading Issues in General Studies. Ilorin:
General Studies Division
Federal Republic of Nigeria (2000) Report of the special Committee on the
Review of the Petroleum Supply and Distribution.
Federal Republic of Nigeria (2008). Report of the Technical Committee on the
Niger Delta. Volume 1.
Federal
Republic
of
Nigeria,
Cultural
Policy.
Available at
http://www.wwcd.org/policy/clink/nigerai.html
Fekumo, J.A (1990) Civil Liability for Damages Caused by Oil Pollution in
Omotola, J.A. (ed.) Lagos: University of Lagos Press
Fregene, P.A.A. 1997. Oil Exploration and Production Activities: The Socioeconomic and Environmental Problems in Warri Division-Itsekiri
Homeland. Paper presented at the seminar on oil and environment
organized by Fredrich Ebert Foundation at Port Harcourt, 14 and 15
March.
Frynas, J.G (1998). Political instability and Business: Focus on Shell in
Nigeria, Third World Quarterly, Vol.19, No. 3, pp457-478
Hamilton, J., Stockman, L. Brown, M., Marshall, G., Muttit, G. and Rau, N.
2004. The case for an Oil-free Future, www.nonewoil.org
Jayaraman, R. and Lanjouw, P. (1999) The Evolution of Poverty and
Inequality in Indian Villages, The World Bank Research Observer Vol.
14(1).
Legborsi, S.P. 2007.The Adverse Impacts of Oil Pollution on the Environment
and Wellbeing of a Local Indigenous Community: The Experience of
the
Ogoni
people
of
Nigeria.
Available
at
http://www.un.org/esg/socdev/unpfil/.../workshop_IPPE_Pyagbara.
doc.Accessed 29/6/10.
Moffat, D and Linden, O. (1995) Perception and Really: Assessing Priorities
for sustainable Development in the Niger River. Delta, Ambio Vol. 24
(7-8).
Oil Times, June 2001
Vol. 5, No. 1
20
Vol. 5, No. 1
21
Abstract
Globally, environmental justice principles are in tandem with
democratic ideals and practices. This is because environmental justice
seeks to analyze and overcome the power structures that have the
potency of thwarting and militating against the principles of fairness
and equity which democracy both represents and enforces. In the
Third World, poor and shallow democratic institutions and culture
have engendered environmental injustice typified by imbalance
between access to environmental costs (pollution, unemployment,
social and economic dislocation and crime) and environmental
benefits (food security, clean air and water, health care, educational
opportunity, transportation facilities and gainful employment). In the
Nigerias Niger Delta region, environmental injustice that has almost
assumed a crisis dimension is a product and a manifestation of the
unsettled democracy and the stunted and stifled democratic
institutions, especially as environmental policy decisions are a
reflection of the political process. This paper therefore examines how
Nigerias pseudo democracy has both occasioned and reinforced the
prolonged and protracted environmental injustice that is yet plaguing
the Niger Delta. The paper that relied on relevant secondary sources
Kelly Bryan Ovie Ejumudo, Ph.D. is with the Department of Political
Science,
Delta
State
University,
Abraka,
Nigeria.
E-Mail:
drkellypaulovieejumudo@yahoo.com.
2
Introduction
Environmental justice is an increasingly important element of
policy making and it is fundamentally about equity and fairness
toward the disadvantaged individuals, groups, communities,
societies, institutions, regions and nations. Environmental justice
offers the opportunity for merging two difficult agenda at both the
national and international levels, by seeking to resolve the conflict
between environmental and social goals and focusing on tackling
environmental problems as part of the social exclusion agenda. There
has been considerable progress on integrating the economic and social
goals with far-reaching programme on social exclusion and
neighborhood renewal, but there has been much less on integrating
the environmental with the social; this is where environmental justice
focus is both desirable and inevitable. Environmental justice
principles and practices, therefore, require a focus on the needs of
future generations, for environmental justice will not be pragmatic if
this were achieved at the expense of people in future generations. This
is essentially as a result of the fact that social and economic concerns
and goals that fail to recognize and accommodate the critical
environmental element and consideration will reduce the ability of the
environment to provide non-substitutable resources and services
(labeled critical natural capital by environmental economists).
In the face of the recognized and acceptable efficacy of environmental
justice principles and practices across communities, societies and
nations, particularly in the third world, there is still massive
environmental degradation such that the rural, urban and generally
Vol. 5, No. 1
23
neglected areas have experienced large scale erosion and waterquality deterioration, deforestation, declining soil productivity and
socio-economic dislocation. Worse still, majority of the people
especially the youths have little or no access to the benefits derivable
from production activities that should expectedly mitigate the
negative effects and costs of the environmental degradation to which
they have been perpetually subjected. As a consequence, they cannot
lead a life that they value and cherish and their potentials are hardly
actualizable and realizable. In the Niger Delta region of Nigeria, the
costs of environmental pollution and degradation that is borne by the
marginalized, oppressed and pauperized people as well as the
benefits that should flow to them in the form of employment, skill
acquisition programmes, educational scholarship schemes, provision
of basic social amenities and other pro-poor life-enhancing
programmes are heavily disproportional so much so, that the
principles of fairness and equity that underlie or underpin
environmental justice are impaired with one likely hazardous
consequence, environmental crisis.
Critical to the environmental injustice problem in the Niger Delta is
the shallow, flawed, failed and pseudo democracy that is in practice in
Nigeria. The justification for the above position is that true,
consolidated and functional democracy presupposes an institutional
and governance climate that encourages and upholds fundamental
human rights, guarantees equity and fairness and promotes
responsible, accountable and representative governance that are the
heart of environmental justice. The creation and entrenchment of ideal
democratic institutions and values, the expediency of environmental
justice and the true recognition, acceptance and practicability of
cultural re-orientation are therefore a desideratum.
Vol. 5, No. 1
24
Vol. 5, No. 1
25
Vol. 5, No. 1
26
Vol. 5, No. 1
27
Vol. 5, No. 1
28
and natural resources and 100 of them specifically recognize the right
to a clean and healthy environment and the states obligation to
prevent environmental harm (Cunningham et al 2007:542).
Paying attention to environmental justice makes sense for two
reasons: ethical and pragmatic. The ethical dimension concerns
whether distribution of risks, benefits and costs is in accordance with
the norms of social justice. The desire for just policies is therefore a
conventional complement to the desire for efficient policies. The
pragmatic dimension, on the other hand, emphasizes the relationship
between the distributional burdens. Policies and programmes that are
perceived as unfair will therefore stand little prospect of passage even
if they enhance the prospects for efficiency and sustainability
(Tietenberg 2005:501). The political conflicts in which many natural
resource issues get embroiled are, as a consequence, often related to
the fact that the groups who enjoy the benefits are not the same as
those who bear the costs (Field 2005:145). These are matters of equity
or fairness which is why they can become so controversial. Another
important aspect of distributional fairness in resource programmes is
how they impact people with different income levels. This is a major
issue in the environmental justice.
Vol. 5, No. 1
29
Vol. 5, No. 1
30
Vol. 5, No. 1
31
Vol. 5, No. 1
32
that is aimed at reconciling freedom with the need for law and its
enforcement and it is a political method by which every citizen has
the opportunity of participating through discussion in an attempt to
reach voluntary agreement as to what shall be done for the good of
the community as a whole.
Mill (cited in Mahajan 2008: 794) also viewed democracy as that form
of government in which the whole people or a numerous portion of
them exercise the governing power through deputies periodically
elected by themselves, while Seeley opined that democracy is a
government in which everybody has a share. According to Hall (cited
in Mahajan 2008: 794), democracy is that form of political organization
in which public opinion has control and Mayo (cited in Mahajan 2008:
794) noted that democracy is one in which public policies are made on
a majority basis by representatives subject to effective popular control
at periodic elections which are conducted on the principle of political
equality and under conditions of political freedom. Kpanneh (cited in
Mbah 2003: 151) equally argued that democracy is a complex process
of institution building, development of a liberal political culture and
traditions, an uninhibited growth of free speech, an unfettered
development of the press and respect for not only the rule, but the
due process of the law.
It can be safely stated therefore that democracy cannot exist in the
absence of fundamental human rights, whether individually or
collectively, which is in consonance with Nnolis (2003: 143) notion
that democracy is a system of government usually involving freedom
of the individual in many respects of political life, equality among
citizens, justice in the relationship between the people and the
government and the participation of the people in choosing those in
government. In fact, democracy is one which makes government
responsive and accountable and a form of government where the
Vol. 5, No. 1
33
Vol. 5, No. 1
34
Vol. 5, No. 1
35
Vol. 5, No. 1
36
Vol. 5, No. 1
37
Vol. 5, No. 1
38
Vol. 5, No. 1
39
Vol. 5, No. 1
40
Vol. 5, No. 1
41
Vol. 5, No. 1
42
Vol. 5, No. 1
43
Vol. 5, No. 1
44
Concluding Remarks
Functional democracy and environmental justice are
inextricably linked together, because while democracy creates the
conditions that are precedent to and the climate that is genial for the
bedding, fruition and sustenance of environmental justice,
environmental justice is not only an element and an integral part of
democracy, it also facilitates its deepening and consolidation process.
Given the failure of the Nigerian specie of democracy to produce the
conditions that will guarantee the true ideals and practice of
environmental justice, the expediency of functional democracy is
arguably inevitable. This is particularly because equity is relevant and
critical to environmental law policy making, whether in the area of
distribution of benefits or the burdens created by environmental
pollution. The fundamental issue is thus how a just society should
distribute the various benefits (resources, opportunities and
freedoms) it produces and the burdens (costs, risks and hazards). And
since justice has to do with the very basic structure of society, it
defines how the various rights, goods, social advantages and liberties
are distributed and how equality and inequality are regulated.
Environmental justice which includes within its purview the
distributional implications of the environmental protection laws
designed to redress the hazards that have their own distinct set of
benefits and burdens is therefore a key dimension and an essential
element of the broad spectrum of social justice that permeates the
structure of the Nigerian society. This implies that the necessary
condition for environmental justice principles and practices in Nigeria
generally and the Niger Delta in particular, is functional democracy.
Although democracy, in the face of its critical role in engineering and
sustaining environmental justice, is not a sufficient condition,
especially as there are intervening variables that are essential in
actualizing the democracy/environmental nexus, the level of
Vol. 5, No. 1
45
References
Bullard, R.D. (2000): Confronting Environmental Racism: Voices from the
Grassroots. London: Free Press.
Burns, C.D. (1935): Democracy. London: Free Press.
Cunningham, W. P., Cunningham, M.A. and Saigo, B.W. (2007): Environmental
science: A Global Concern. Toronto: McGraw-Hill.
Dahl, R. (1971): Polyarchy: Participation and Opposition. New Haven: Yale
University Press.
De Jourenel, B. (1949): On Power and Democracy. New York: Viking Press.
Diamond, L. (1999): Developing Democracy: Toward Consolidation. Baltimore:
The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Vol. 5, No. 1
46
Vol. 5, No. 1
47
Vol. 5, No. 1
48
ABSTRACT
The issue of Small Arms and Light Weapons Proliferation has been
given widespread international focus in the post cold war era. This is
so because these weapons have become the primary tools of ethnic
and internal conflicts in recent times. It has equally been observed that
developing countries in the Third world, particularly in Africa are the
most vulnerable. The African situation has to be understood from the
context of the post independence political, economic and sociocultural setting. This period witnessed the existence of a highly
factionalized and fictionalized society, weak structures, sectoral
dislocation exacerbated by foreign domination and vulnerability to
the vagaries of cold war rivalry between the super powers of which
Nigeria where the Niger Delta Region is situated is not an exception.
The backlash of this development was widespread national, ethnic
and communal conflicts giving rising to the excessive militarization of
the continent. Hence, Small Arms and Light Weapons (SALW)
George I.J Obuoforibo, PhD was born in 1954 in Ogu/Bolo Local Government
Area. He is Senior Lecturer of International Relations, Political and Administrative
Studies in the Department of Social Sciences at the University of Port Harcourt in
Rivers State, Nigeria. His e-mail is obuoforibo@yahoo.co.uk
3
Vol. 5, No. 1
50
INTRODUCTION
The issue of small Arms and Light Weapons (SALW)
proliferation has been given wide spread international focus in the
post cold war era. This is because these weapons have become the
primary tools of ethnic and internal conflicts in recent times. They
have been the sources of violence, wars, conflicts and crimes. It has
equally been observed that developing countries in the third world,
particularly in Africa are the most vulnerable. The question is why are
such conflicts persisting or why do they reoccur even after the end of
such conflicts? Does it mean that the disarmament, demobilization
and reintegration process has not been able to sufficiently address the
problems that may have necessitated the occurrence of such conflicts?
Answers to questions of these nature would go a long way in making
us to understand the persistent instability in the Niger delta, made
possible by small Arms and Light Weapons (SALW) proliferation that
has reached a crisis level, hence the topic of this paper small Arms
and Light Weapons (SALW) proliferation and instability in the Niger
Delta, an analysis of the disarmament demobilization and
reintegration process.
The Niger Delta an oil rich region in Nigeria is characterized by the
existence of wide spread poverty, squalor and environmental
degradation due to long period of neglect and marginalization by
successive regimes both civil and military. Several efforts have been
made through representations of traditional rulers, opinion leaders
and public spirited individuals on behalf of the people. These moves
have been met by successive regimes with disdain and draconian
brute force. The small Arms and Light Weapons crisis we are
witnessing currently in the Niger Delta is necessitated by such brute
force, as the people had no alternative than resorting to violence.
Though some disarmament, demobilization and disintegration
programme was carried out by President Olusegun Obasanjo, they
Vol. 5, No. 1
51
could not provide lasting solution to the crisis due to lack of genuine
interest on the part of government. The question is how genuine is the
current disarmament, demobilization and reintegration programme of
YarAduas government in ensuring a lasting solution to the Niger
Delta crisis by making sure that those factors that necessitated the
crisis are taken care of once and for all?
It is true that a lot has been written on the issue of small arms and
light weapons proliferation and instability in the Niger Delta. But
such writings have been focused largely on the aspects of
disarmament, demobilization and reintegration process. The real
issues that really necessitated the wide spread usage of such weapons
have not been sufficiently addressed. For instance, Bekoe Dorina in
his strategies for peace in the Niger Delta was of the view that
previous attempts at disarmament, demobilization and integration
(DDR) programmes did not succeed due to the absence of a
coordinating body and employment opportunities. He went further to
say that there is the need for comprehensive approach that will
address the incentives of groups to hold arms, implement best
practices from successful programmes, invite international observers
to monitor disarmament processes and ensure coordination between
disarmament, demobilization and reintegration efforts and also
creating meaningful employment opportunities (Bekoe Dorina 2009,
p.7). In as much as one appreciates Dorinas views, it is our contention
in this paper that such views does not help to sufficiently address
the problem of small Arms and Light weapons crisis in the Niger
delta. This is predicated on the fact that, what is necessary at this
point in time is the success of the post Amnesty peace building
process. The concern of this paper therefore, is the extent to which the
post amnesty peace building process can ensure the existence of a
lasting peace considering the pernicious long term effects of the
existence of small arms and light-weapons in a post conflict situation.
Vol. 5, No. 1
52
Vol. 5, No. 1
53
legitimate military, police and civilian users. Small arms and light
weapons are used both by government forces (military and police)
and non state actors (guerrillas, ethnic militias war lords, brigands
and so on engaged in low intensity conflicts (Klare 2009, p.3. In an era
of Oligarchic rule, who says power says Oligarchy. As posited by
elitist theory, the elites a small category of well organized few knows
the importance of power which when acquired is more often made
arbitrary use of that is inimical and detrimental to the interests of the
majority of the people.
It is a known fact that the principles of national sovereignty set no
boundaries to the violence in which domestic conflict can be
conducted. When polarization occurs along communal cleavages, the
conflict situation describes entire collectivities as enemies. Such
confrontation is intense in its mobilization effect and swiftly escalates
fears to a level where the very physical survival of a collectivity may
appear to be at stake. Taking into consideration the extent to which
Americans Melting Pot theory was challenged, it is understandable
why certain factors such as urbanization, industrialization and
secularization can hardly work in multinational society, even if the
total authority and coercive means available to the state were
launched to a coherent strategy of assimilation (Young 1993. p.7).
Again the American experience makes one to realize that the viability
of the assimilation paradigm came under growing attack in the 1960s,
as evidence began to accumulate that ethnicity was far more
persistent that the melting pot theory would permit. For the fact that
change and process are central we need to pay particular heed to the
social vectors which alter identity patterns and to the political arenas
which define their saliency (Young, 1993. p.11).
In Africa and indeed Nigeria, the identity of circumstances, the
fluidity of groups and pace of change offer a view of the entire range
Vol. 5, No. 1
54
The situation in the Niger Delta can be seen from the above assertion.
However, the point of difference is that Jasper Isaac Adaka Boros
attempt at secession in his 12 days revolution in 1967 was due to the
long period of marginalization and neglect of the people of this area.
It is also true that militant groups resorted to oil bunkering activities
to finance their operations. Again the point of difference with
Kegleys assertion is that they were doing it in collaboration and
involvement of high level government officials.
According to the United Nations, some 359 million people (of 578
million who belongs to groups that face some form of cultural
exclusion) are disadvantaged or discriminated against relative to
others in following their beliefs and frustration, anger often erupts in
Vol. 5, No. 1
55
Vol. 5, No. 1
56
Vol. 5, No. 1
57
the motions that would help him put together the arithmetical
problem of getting members to be the president. He was not doing it
because he had sat down and believed in it. He was doing it as part of
his political strategy to get into power.
It is true that the Willinks Commission was set up to address and
take care of fears expressed by the minorities. But the Commissions
report only gave palliatives that did not address the problems of the
Niger Delta. Rather it recommended the setting up of the Niger Delta
Basin Development Authority (NDDBA) which was just a mere
symbolic representation of the governments intension to douse the
tension that arose as a result of the agitations of the people. This was
so mainly because of the collaborative complicity of both the colonial
authorities and the leaders of the majority parties in Nigeria as at that
time. Therefore the root cause of the instability in the Niger Delta
could be traced to the time of colonial era when the structural
imbalances that are bedeviling the nation and indeed the Niger Delta
started.
One would have thought that the political leaders may have learnt
their lessons in the post independence era, by way of introducing
measures through policies to take care of these problems once and for
all, but the reverse was the case. Rather the leadership was unable to
transform inherited structures to meet popular aspirations for security
and peaceful transfer of power. Instead these institutions were grafted
onto and grow apart from traditional structures, thus creating fatal
fault lines in the architecture of the new state (Abdel p.4). To the
extent that the minorities in the Niger Delta do not see themselves as
stakeholders in the nation building project, the state in Nigeria has
lacked popular legitimacy and remained a shell state. The
preoccupation with assuring personal power and regime security
blocked any moves towards democratic institution building. The state
Vol. 5, No. 1
58
Vol. 5, No. 1
59
of the petroleum Act in 1969 can be described as giving with one hand
and taking back with another. As if that action of Gowon was not
enough, Obasanjos military government introduced the land use
decree in 1978, thereby dispossessing the people of their God given
land and its natural resources. What came out of this development
was collaboration between successive military governments and the
oil multinational corporations in the systematic exploitation of the
resources. The irony of the situation is the brazen manner in which
the resources were exploited, without the slightest regard or resort to
standard environmental practices. The result of this was the
degradation of the environment which affected the ecosystem and the
depletion of the flora and fauna which is the peoples source of
livelihood. Chief Dappa Biriyes views on this issue are important he
said
The countrys gratitude to our loyalty was to exercise all offshore
royalties from coastal states in the time of Gowon through the
petroleum Act of 1969. That is a paradox of qualitative excellence
and undermined by its very beneficiaries.
With this development what the people needed and requested for was
the protection of their environment and the provision of basic
amenities for their sustenance. This was met with brute force by
successive military regimes. One of such brutal actions of government
was the killing of Ken Sarowiwa and eight other Ogoni activists by
Abachas military government. When peoples popular and legitimate
aspiration for self actualization and preservation are met with brute
force, the result is resistance at all costs regardless of what might be
the likely consequences. It is in this context that one need to
appreciate and understand the issue of small arms and light Weapons
proliferation in the Niger Delta.
Vol. 5, No. 1
60
However, the most recent violence in the Niger Delta grew out of the
political campaign in 2003. As they competed for office, politicians in
Rivers State, a focal point of violence in 2003 manipulated the Niger
Delta Vigilantes led by Ateke Tom, and the Niger Delta Peoples
Volunteer Force led by Alhaji Asari Dokubo. (Bekoe, 2009, p.5).
Exacerbating rivalries, political candidates used these groups to
advance their aspirations often rewarding gang members to commit
acts of political violence and intimidation against their opponents. The
conclusion of the 2003 elections did not end the violence. The Niger
Delta Vigilantes and the Niger Delta Volunteer Force continued to
fight each other through out 2004. The hostilities peaked when over
300 commanders of the Ijaw ethnic group announced that if the
government did not change conditions in the Niger Delta, they would
take action against both the government and the oil installations
(Bekoe, 2009, p.5). This was the turning point when arms originally
meant and used for political violence ended up being used as
instruments of militancy for Niger Delta struggle. This development
may well be an after thought or a face saving devise on the part of the
so called militants when their services were no longer required by the
politicians at the end of the elections. It need to be pointed out
however, that this after thought or face saving devise would not have
been possible if the prevailing circumstances in the Niger Delta where
any thing to the contrary. In other words, if the government and the
oil multinationals operating in the area had done what is expected,
the loopholes that necessitated this turning point would not have
arisen. Going by the pedigree of these youths who had no education
or skill except gunmanship, taking advantage of the existing situation
was necessary for their sustenance. According to The Hard Truth a
militant who called himself marine Scorpion said,
Our commanders and by extension our field officers were used in
the 2003 elections. Shortly after we were abandoned. A man armed
Vol. 5, No. 1
61
without a regular paying job, has to find way to make ends meet
with the gun he was given in the first instance.(The Hard Truth,
2007, p.2).
Vol. 5, No. 1
62
Vol. 5, No. 1
63
Vol. 5, No. 1
64
Vol. 5, No. 1
65
Vol. 5, No. 1
66
Vol. 5, No. 1
67
Vol. 5, No. 1
68
sector reform in their dealings with societies in conflict, and for good
reason. The enduring image of the military in the conscience of the
ordinary people is one of brutality and impunity (Abdel Fatau, 2002,
p. 248). The preconditions for sustainable security and peace in region
remain the production and equitable distribution of public goods. In
other words, government has to do everything possible to ensure that
the factors that necessitated or brought about the crisis are taken care
of and not the usage of brute military force. Tony Uranta, local
facilitator of the commission of Nobel laureates to the Niger Delta and
member of the Technical Committee on the Niger Delta said
One of the ways government can improve the quality of lives of the
Niger Delta people is to withdraw the JTF back to the barracks as a
standby force to be deployed only in an emergency. He added that
this should go hand in hand with visible efforts on the part of the
Federal Government to develop the Niger Delta Region. Whatever
steps are taken, the parties involved should take into consideration
the ordinary people in the region (The Hard Truth, March 5-11, 2009
page 3).
Vol. 5, No. 1
69
CONCLUSION
In the foregoing discussion we have been made to understand
the fact that small arms and light Weapons proliferation in Niger
Delta has been made possible due to long period of neglect and
marginalization of the people of this oil rich region by successive
governments in Nigeria. Representations to government made by
traditional rulers and opinion leaders of the area to address these
problems are often met by brute force on the part of a government.
The frustration and anger of the people resulted into the first armed
revolution and the attempt at secession in the 12 days revolution
carried out by Jasper Isaac Adaka Boro in 1967. In spite of this
development, successive governments in the country not only
resorted to the neglect and marginalization, but also carried out state
legislations that brought about enactments that completely
dispossessed the people of their God given natural resources. The
result was a joint exploitation of the peoples resources by the
government and the multinational oil cooperations. The irony of the
situation was the brazen manner in which these resources were
exploited without the slightest regard to standard environmental
practices required in the exploitation of such resources. The
devastation of the environment affected the ecosystem and the
depletion of the flora and fauna being the peoples main source of
livelihood.
Again the peoples demand for the protection of their environment
and the provision of certain basic amenities was met with brute force
as shown in the killing of Ken Sarowiwa and eight other Ogoni
activists. The struggle to emancipate the people of the Niger Delta
from what is currently being seen as internal colonization was
hijacked by the youths who were armed by politicians in 2003 general
elections. Be that as it may, if government had genuine interest to
resolve the crisis once and for all we would not have found ourselves
Vol. 5, No. 1
70
in the present level of small arms and light weapons crisis. The
genuine interest and concern on the part of late President Musa
YarAdua, has brought in relative peace in the area, though an uneasy
one. If the relative peace currently being experienced in the region is
to be sustained the following steps are necessary. The operators of the
SALW pipelines into the sub-region cash trapped rogue exporting
states mainly from Eastern Europe and central Europe, clandestine
western suppliers, brokers and private military entrepreneurs as well
as the recyclers and transhippers within the sub-region itself must be
exposed and sanctioned. There is a need to combine weapons
elimination from society with effective measures to diffuse societal
tensions. The long-term and sustainable path to addressing the small
arms crisis lies in addressing those factors which drive the demand
for small arms such as socio-economic and political exclusion. This
would require rebuilding the nation so that all segments of society
have a sense of ownership and belonging (Abdel Fatau, 2002:247). The
problem of bureaucratic ineptitude has to be reduced to the barest
minimum. The joint task force has to be removed and kept in their
barracks only to be called in during emergency periods, government
should involve all stakeholders i.e. traditional rulers, opinion leaders,
youths, the operating companies etc so that the out come of the
discussion is not just that of a government imposition but a buy in by
people of the area. This is predicated on the fact that nobody seeks to
destroy what he calls his own.
REFERENCES
Abdel-Fatau, Musali; The Political Economy of Small Arms and Conflicts;
International Alert, Security and Peace Building Programme, 346 Chapham
Road, London SW99 AP, UK; Africa, Page 2.
Vol. 5, No. 1
71
Vol. 5, No. 1
72
Vol. 5, No. 1
73
ABSTRACT
So much has been written about the challenges in the Oil producing
areas of Nigeria, however minimal effort has been made to historicize
and interrogate the system of contribution and rewards in Nigerias
fiscal federalism which is at the heart of the problem in the Niger
Delta area of Nigeria. The problematic here is that in the practice of
fiscal federalism in Nigeria, between 1960 and 1999 there was no
proper correlation or relationship between funds and functions. The
Nigerian constitution allocated functions while funds were allocated
statutorily by the parliament which was structurally dominated by
majority ethnic groups. What existed up till 2010 was an asymmetrical
situation in which those who controlled the politics of the federation
did not finance the federation and those who financed it had no
political control over the federation and its resources. This study
places in proper historical perspective the politicization of revenue
allocation, the economic injustice, poverty and systematic
disempowerment of the oil producing minority states within the
context of Federal government control. It argues that the progressive
denigration of the derivation principle by the gate keepers, the
institutionalization of unjust revenue sharing principles and actual
allocations which run contrary to the sacred principles and fine tenets
Ekanade Olumide, PhD, is with the Department of History and International
Relations at Redeemers University, Nigeria. E mail: orogidi@yahoo.com
4
of federalism are at the core of the crisis between the Nigerian State
and the oil producing minorities. The paper concludes with some
policy recommendations which suggest that a way out of this
quagmire is for the Nigerian state to embark on the fundamental
restructuring and reinvention of the Nigerian state in order to
guarantee equity, tranquility and social justice
It is a federalism that has deprived the rights of the minorities. It is a
federalism that appropriates and expropriates the wealth of the
minorities without let or hindrance. It is a federalism that now stands on
its head. It is a federalism that has grown so insensitive to the political
and socio economic rights of the minorities so much so that all the
political calculations therein are based on the need to sustain the tripodal
hegemony of the three dominant ethnic groups. It is a federalism that has
lost its soul Dr. Kimse Okoko (National Concord 29 May, 1992; 5).
INTRODUCTION
This paper takes a cursory look at the system of contributions
and rewards in Nigerias fiscal federalism with specific reference to
the minorities of the Niger Delta. The work also places in a proper
historical perspective, the economic injustice, poverty and
disempowerment of the minorities within the context of Federal
government control and the institution of unjust revenue sharing
principles and actual allocations which run contrary to the sacred
principles of federalism up to 1999.
Vol. 5, No. 1
75
Vol. 5, No. 1
76
Vol. 5, No. 1
77
the latter because of its authority over mineral policy and probable
involvement in funding of the oil industry. Besides, other regions
should partake of oil revenues in the interest of balanced
development of the regions. Thus, the approved sharing of formula
was 50%, 20% and 30% for the mineral region, Federal government
and distributable pool account (D.P.A) respectively. The principles for
sharing the 30% that went into the DPA included need (determined
by population) and national interest. At the end, the North, West and
Eastern regions each had 40%, 24% and 31% respectively (Ehwarieme
1999, 63 - 64). It followed therefore that till 1965 when oil accounted
for 8.4% of total Federal government revenue, 50% (Ehwarieme 1999,
59) of that oil revenue, rents and royalties both onshore and offshore
devolved, (on the basis of derivation) back to the region from where
the oil was extracted principally the Niger Delta area in the then
Mid-West Region. In addition, up till 1966, all export duties on
agricultural produce (from majority areas), the import duty on
tobacco and motor fuel were returned to regions on the basis of
derivation (Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1963, 65).
From 1966 onwards when the military seized the reins of government,
the successive military and civil regimes progressively denigrated the
derivation principle. They diluted its dominance and brought up a
number of new sharing principles as oil came to dominate
government revenue as the major revenue and foreign exchange
earner for the Federal government. We now turn to examine revenue
distribution in the federal state under the military with specific
reference to the minorities and the derivation principle.
Federalism according to O.B.C Nwolise implies that resources in
regions or states are controlled by the states and agreed quantum paid
into the central pool (Nwolise, 2005, 116 ). However, the distribution
of revenue in Nigeria from 1966 did not bear out this sacred tenet of
Vol. 5, No. 1
78
federalism. Two reasons are responsible for this deviation. They are
the fundamental shift in Nigerias economy from agricultural cash
crops (found in majority ethnic group areas) to crude oil
(expropriated from minority areas) and the intervention of the
military in the political space (The Guardian 14 May, 2002). When the
agricultural sector predominated, the component regional
governments retained the principal ratio of the revenue accruable to
them from export of agricultural produce and only surrendered a
fraction of it for the upkeep of the central government. The crude oil
era which came to dominate Nigerian economy from 1966 to date was
on the other hand marked by extreme concentration of fiscal resources
in the hands of the Federal government, while the federating units
were forced to depend on the central government for their financing.
With the military coup of January 1966 and the counter coup of July
1966, the military government through General Yakubu Gowon
restructured the federation into twelve states on May 27, 1967. The
excuse was that the exercise was to provide a platform for selfassertion by previously suppressed groups (minorities) (Gowon and
Effiong 2001, 13). This development increased the influence of the
minorities in the Eastern Region (inhabitants of the Niger Delta) and
they got a new state, Rivers State. This solution to their agitation for a
separate state since the 1950s, however assumed that the problem was
a political one. The belief by the minorities that creation of states
translated to exclusive control of their oil and land to the exclusion of
the majorities proved to be a fatally wrong assumption as subsequent
developments after the civil war further reinforced their
marginalization (The Niger Delta Question 2004, 8: 18 -19).
Military Decrees as centralization apparatus
After the creation of twelve states and given the notable
impact of oil on public funds, General Yakubu Gowon decided to
Vol. 5, No. 1
79
Vol. 5, No. 1
80
produces resources that sustain the entire Nigerian state and at the
same time bear the brunt of negative impact of exploratory activities
in their region. Furthermore in 1971, following the recommendations
of Dina Revenue Allocation Commission, the Federal military
government through Decree No. 9 of 1971 assumed proprietorship of
rents and royalties of all offshore oil revenues and reduced derivation
to states of origin to 30% (Omoruyi 2001,8). The provision of this
decree once and for all repealed a provision of the constitution of the
first republic that the continental shelf of a region should be deemed
to be part of that region in the allocation of of mining rents and
royalties to the region of derivation. The exclusion of this particular
constitutional provision from all of Nigerias post military
constitutions (1979, 1989, 1995 and 1999) has undermined the claims
of the oil producing states to offshore oil wealth (Suberu 2002, 151-152
). Decree No 38 of 1971, a fallout of decree No 5 of 1967 also extended
Nigerias territorial waters from 12 miles to 30 miles. This in effect
made royalties accruing to the Federal government increase at the
expense of the same oil producing communities (Nigerian Tribune, 20
June 1975:34; Osaghae 1988, 71)
Obviously, what informed and reinforced this development were the
unitary character of the military, the fact that oil wells were located in
a few southern minority areas with little or no political influence, and
also the fact that, throughout the late 1960s and 1970s in Nigeria, the
derivation formula was stigmatized by many prominent public
finance experts as the devil of revenue sharing (Suberu 2002, 14).
By 1975, Decree numbers 6 and 7 were introduced and had far more
reaching effect on transfer of resources from states to the Federal
government and in the redistribution of resources in a manner that
increasingly made non oil producing states to depend and survive on
the resources from oil rich states. In fact, the non oil producing states
Vol. 5, No. 1
81
benefited more than oil rich states. This included reduction of the
mining rents and royalties paid to the states of origin from 45% to 20%
while the share of the D.P.A increased to 80%. Half of the 80% in the
DPA was divided among states on equality basis and the other half on
basis of states population (Ebajemito and Abudu 1999, 224; Dudley
1982, 260; Daily Times, 10 March 1975, 1) .
By July 1975 a new regime of General Murtala Mohammed and
Brigadier Olusegun Obasanjo had taken over the reins of governance.
Immediately afterwards the regime further divided the 12 states into
19 states which necessitated the adoption of another revenue
allocation system to administer federal fund amongst the new units.
This was how the Aboyade technical committee was set up in 1977 to
look into the revenue distribution issue and make recommendations.
The Aboyade committee reduced the mining rent and royalties paid
to state of origin from 20% to 5% (Zuokumor 1985, 33) . In the place of
derivation he recommended an adoption of principles that ensured
equity and efficiency among states (Fajana 2001, 118). But Fajana Femi
had argued that despite these recommendations and application of
hitherto recommended principles, neither equity nor efficiency had
been achieved in horizontal revenue sharing (Fajana 2001,121). All the
same Aboyades report and recommendations were rejected by the
civilian regime that came into office on 1st October, 1979.
Vol. 5, No. 1
82
Vol. 5, No. 1
83
Vol. 5, No. 1
84
Vol. 5, No. 1
85
Vol. 5, No. 1
86
Zones
Amount received by
% Contribution
each zone (in billions)
North Central
N45.811
0.00
North East
N46.213
0.00
North West
N44.488
0.00
South East
N33.476
2.75
South West
N42.502
3.97
South South
N145.171
91.54
Source: The Punch (Lagos), Tuesday July 12, 2005 p.14
Vol. 5, No. 1
% Allocation
7.48
8.00
8.31
8.31
7.43
17.3
87
THE
INTERVENTION
AGENCIES
NIGER
DELTA
DEVELOPMENT BOARD
Before crude oil became the mainstay of the Nigerias
economy, the Sir Henry Willink Commission (appointed to look into
the fears of the minorities) in 1958 had recognized the Delta region of
the southern minority zone as poor, backward and neglected given
its ecological state and to place on the concurrent list, a new subject
which should be known as The development of special areas (Sir
Henry Willink Report 1958, 94 95). This explained the establishment
of the Niger Delta Development Board (NDDB) which came into
being by an Act of Parliament in 1961(Lawal 2004, 273; Nigerian
Tribune 28, September, 2004, 31). This board was expected to act as a
unique agency to develop the Delta area in terms of infrastructural
development. However there were no clear cut responsibilities
apportioned to the central and regional authorities, hence the board
did not make any impact. Another reason for the boards inefficiency
was that the problems of the minorities at that period were
overshadowed by the grim power struggle among the major ethnic
groups (The Niger Delta Question 2004:8, 39). Moreover, the NDDB
failed because the Federal government deviated from the prescribed
composition of members of the board, which according to Diepreye
Alamieseigha had no single representative from the Niger Delta area
Vol. 5, No. 1
88
Vol. 5, No. 1
89
Vol. 5, No. 1
90
oil producing areas were not people who understood the peculiar
problems, demands and needs of the oil producing communities
(Onokerhoraye 1995,321) hence their inability to perform.
OMPADEC under the military was transformed into a machinery of
the presidency to settle critics (Tell Magazine 18 March 1996, 26). This
argument coheres with M. Chris Allis submission that government
corruption crippled OMPADEC (Alli 2000, 255). In addition, contracts
from OMPADEC were used to bribe those people who could cause
breach of peace in the oil producing communities. Howbeit, people
who were non-professional contractors (given the manner in which
they executed the contracts) simply abandoned assigned projects after
collecting mobilization fee (Tell Magazine 18 March 1996, 26). In the
light of this, OMPADEC after seven years of existence (1993-1991)
admittedly left a legacy of abandoned projects all over the Niger Delta
area since there was little regard for accountability and transparency.
Vol. 5, No. 1
91
In view of the enormity of challenges that faced and are still facing the
oil producing communities, the 3% derivation fund was a drop in the
ocean of myriad of problems that faced the oil producing
communities. The derivation percentage of 3% was grossly
inadequate (The Guardian 14 May 1993, 25). A clause in OMPADECs
decree stipulated that projects from the fund including employment
should be shared within the oil producing communities according to
the percentage of their production quota. Ironically Olobiri where oil
was first struck (where production has now ceased) would not benefit
from the fund because there would be no percentage to base their
production on (The Guardian 14 May 1993, 25). Sad enough these
were communities where the high activity of oil exploration and
expropriation had impacted negatively on their environment, their
eco-system and their health. The following environmental table
completes the story of the plight of the oil producing communities
who are daily subjected to a life of misery owing to the dictates of a
warped Federal system which the Nigeria state operates.
TABLE 1.1. RANKING OF MAJOR ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEMS,
SOCIAL ISSUES AND PRIORITIES
Problem Type
Natural environment
Development related
Vol. 5, No. 1
Problem Subset
Coastal/river bank erosion
Flooding
Sedimentation/silt
Substance
Exotice (water hyacinth)
Land degradation/soil fertility loss
Agricultural decline/shortened fallow
Delta forest loss (mangroves)
Bio-diversity depletion
Fisheries decline
Oil spillage
Gas flaring
Priority Ranking
Moderately high
Moderate
Low
Low
High
High
High
High
High
High
Moderate
Moderate
92
Problem Type
Problem Subset
Priority Ranking
Sewage and waste water
High
Other chemicals
Moderate
Socio-economic
Poverty
High
problems
Unemployment
High
Community-oil company conflict
High
Intercommunity conflict
High
Intercommunity conflict
Moderate
Conflicts over land
High
Inadequate compensation
High
Displacement
Moderate
Decay in societal values
High
Poor transportation/high cost of fuel
High
Housing pressure/infrastructure
Decay/crime
High
Source: R.N. Egbon and P.C. Okoh, Fiscal Federalism and Revenue Allocation in Fiscal
Federalism and Nigerian Economic Development .Proceedings of N.E.S Conference
Ibadan, 1999.
Vol. 5, No. 1
93
(Okoh and Egbon 1993, 412). The World Bank had as far back as 1995
warned that, an urgent need exists to implement a mechanism to
protect the life and health of the Niger Delta regions inhabitants
(Financial Standard 4 July 2005, 12).
One reason for Federal governments relative indifference and
inability to enforce standards at the period has to do with the fact that
she is a major stakeholder in some of the major multinational oil
companies involved in oil spillage activities in the Niger Delta and
invariably the government is involved in oil spillage. With regard to
clearing up the mess of oil spillage, multinational oil companies posit
that having paid their rents, their royalties and taxes to the federal
government that also has controlling shares, they (oil companies) are
absolved of the task of providing amenities and infrastructures in the
oil producing areas (Eboe 1985, 122) in spite of the fact that Nigeria
(according to Time Magazine) had earned at least 300 billion dollars
from oil exports and 199.3 billion dollars between 1990 and 1993
(Owuga 1999,105). A clear picture appears with the Nigerian
Guardians documentation of the Ogoni challenge when it wrote:
At the end of 1992, cumulative oil production from
Ogoni was put at 634 million barrels valued at
5.2billion dollars. Of this, 15% was cost of production,
79% was paid to the federal government as taxes, i.e.
equity crude and 6% left for the private partners
including
Shell
Petroleum
Development
Corporation(The Guardian 1 June 2005,2).
All this transpired between 1958 and 1993 when Shell was forced to
withdraw from Ogoniland. The Ogoni field in 1993 had a production
potential of 28,000 barrels per day, about 3% of Shell Petroleum
Development Corporations total crude oil production (The Guardian
Vol. 5, No. 1
94
1 June 2005, 2). Yet Ogoni land suffered great neglect as attested to by
Ken Saro Wiwa who pointed out that You have taken away all these
oil from the Ogoni people. You build dams in Hausaland, in Fulani
country, you have provided for agriculture. What have you given
Ogoni people? <Without oil, they will not have the dams that are
making agriculture in the North possible (Eliagwu 2001, 185).
Despite all these cries of neglect the Federal governments primary
objective however had continued to be the profit motive, centering on
how to expand oil production and earn more revenue (Okoh and
Egbon 1993, 412).
A further demonstration of governments insensitivity to the effects of
its fiscal policy is all the more obvious with a critical look at the
average revenue of states and population figures between 1990 and
1996. Central Bank of Nigerias Annual report of 1996 and 1994 (CBN,
1996, 76-77: CBN 1994, 63) and Statistical bulletin 1996 (Statistical
Bulletin, 1996, 7,:118) make this very glaring. The tables reveal that
only Rivers State (a member of the Niger Delta) fell into the ranking of
the ten highest mean statutory revenue allocation received by states in
the Nigerian nation between 1990 and 1996. Even at that, Rivers state
occupied the eighth position (with N848.6 million). The first seven
states in descending order are as follows Kano (N3066.4m), Sokoto
(N976.8 million), FCT, Abuja (N907.7million), Lagos (N904.9million),
Bauchi (N891m), Oyo (N869m) and Bornu (N878m) . A look at the
population figures on same table shows that the states with the three
largest populations respectively are Lagos (5685.8m), Kano (5632.0m)
and Sokoto (4392.4m). This reflects the centrality of the population
factor as against derivation principle in the revenue allocation
formula (Okoh and Egbon 1993, 414).
Vol. 5, No. 1
95
Vol. 5, No. 1
96
Vol. 5, No. 1
97
Vol. 5, No. 1
98
bodies (The Guardian 23 April 1993, 4) and the Print media (The
Guardian 30 April 1993, 10) all asking for his release. The affair
continued as earlier mentioned until his extra judicial murder in 1996.
The whole campaign of the oil-producing communities was
predicated on their perceived neglect by the state and federal
governments on one hand and the oil companies on the other hand.
Fifteen years after the demise of Ken Saro Wiwa, the crisis in the
Niger Delta has not abated. Though the federal government has put in
place a host of palliative measures including the Niger Delta
Development commission (NDDC) to build infrastructure, and the
Yaradua amnesty programme for ex militants, the crises seem not to
have abated considerably. Rather, it has assumed alarming
proportions currently threatening the stability and viability of the
Nigerian state. In the post 1999 period, a militant group known as
Movement for the emancipation of the Niger Delta (MEND) has
become a thorn in the flesh of the successive civil regimes in post 1999
Nigeria engaging in acts of criminality. MEND has been linked to
attacks on petroleum operations in Nigeria as part of the conflict in
the Niger Delta, engaging in acts including sabotage, theft, property
destruction, guerrilla warfare, outright serial killings and kidnap of
expatriates (Wikipedia, 2011)
CONCLUSION
In conclusion, this paper has chronicled the fate of oil
producing communities in the Nigerian state pointing out the fact that
they have been marginalized by majority ethnic groups and the
military in terms of resource allocation. Through out this period
corporate politics intersected with successive dictatorships - military
and civil. Under these dictatorships the Nigerian government signed
laws that appropriated oil resources and placed them under the
Vol. 5, No. 1
99
Vol. 5, No. 1
100
NOTES
1.
2.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Adebayo, A.G. 1993. Embattled Federalism: History of Revenue Allocation in
Nigeria, 1946-1990 New York: Peter Lang.
Adedeji, Adebayo. 1969.Nigerian Federal Finance London: Hutchinson Press.
Alagoa, E. J. 1999. The Eastern Niger Delta and its Hinterland in the 19th
Century In Groundwork of Nigerian History, edited by Obaro, Ikime.
.249-261. Ibadan: Heinemann Books.
Vol. 5, No. 1
101
Alli, M.C. 2000. The Federal Republic of Nigerian Army: The siege of a Nation.
Lagos: Malthouse Press.
Constitution of the Federal republic of Nigeria , 1999 constitution. Lagos: Federal
Government Press.
Danjuma, T. Y. 1994. Revenue Sharing and the Political Economy of Nigerian
Federalism, in Federalism and Nation Building in Nigeria: Challenges of
the 21Century, edited by I. Eliagwu, P.C. Logams and H.S. Galadima,
94105. Abuja: National Council on Intergovernmental Relations.
Discussion with Ayoade, John. A. Professor, Department of Political Science,
University of Ibadan on 16 January, 2005.
Dudley, B. 1982. An Introduction to Nigerian Government and Politics London:
Macmillan Press.
Ebajemitso, O and I. Abudu. 1999. Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations in
Nigeria In Proceedings of the 1999 Annual Conference. 215-35. Ibadan
:Nigerian Economic Society.
Eboe, Hutchful. 1985 Oil companies and environmental pollution in
Nigeria, In The Political Economy of Nigeria , edited by Ake, C,114
128.Lagos: Longman.
Ehwarieme, W. 1999. The Military, Oil and Development In Proceedings of
the 1999 Annual Conference. 53-72. Ibadan :Nigerian Economic
Society.
Ekanade, O. 2010. Fiscal federalism and Nigerias Economic Development :
Comparative perspectives from Canadian Fiscal federalism, in
Journal of Global Initiatives, Kenessaw State University, U.S.A. Vol .5,
No3, 2010.
Vol. 5, No. 1
102
Eliagwu, I. 1979. The military and state building: Federal State relations in
Nigeria, 1967-1976, in Readings on Federalism, edited by A.B.
Akinyemi, P.D. Cole, and W. Ofonagoro, 151-81, Lagos: Nigerian
Institute of International Affairs.
.2001. Military rule and Federalism in Nigeria, In The foundations of
Nigerian Federalism, edited by I, Eliagwu, and R. A. Akindele,166
93. Jos :Institute for Governance and Social Research.
Emenuga, Chidozie. 1993. The search for an acceptable revenue allocation
formula, In Proceedings of the Nigerian Economic Society (N.E.S) 1993
Annual conference, 79105 Ibadan, Nigerian Economic Society.
Fajana, F. 2001. Three and a half decades of Fiscal Federalism in Nigeria, In
Foundation of Nigerian Federalism 1960 1995, edited by I. Eliagwu
and R.A Akindele. 87 124.Jos:Institute for Governance and Social
Research.
Festus O. E., Egwaikhide, F and O. Aregbeyen, 1999. Oil Production
Externalities in the Niger Delta, In Proceedings of the 1999 Annual
conference, 101115. Ibadan: Nigerian Economic Society.
Financial Standard, (Lagos), 4 July, 2005.
Gowon, Y and P.E. Obong. 2001. The Nigerian Civil War and its Aftermath:
Views from within. Ibadan, Programme on Ethnic and Federal
Studies, University of Ibadan, Occasional paper. Ibadan. 1:13
Ikime, Obaro. 1999. The Peoples and Kingdoms of the Delta province, In
Groundwork of Nigerian History, edited by Obaro, Ikime, 89108. Ibadan:
Heinemann Books.
Iniodu, P.U. 1999. Fiscal Dependence of Local Governments in Nigeria, In
Proceedings of the Nigerian Economic Society (N.E.S) 1993 Annual
conference, 28913. Ibadan, Nigerian Economic Society.
Vol. 5, No. 1
103
Vol. 5, No. 1
104
Vol. 5, No. 1
105
Hurst
Vol. 5, No. 1
106
Zuokumor, Kate. 1985 The oil industry and Ijaw politics. B.A. Dissertation,
Department of History University of Ibadan, Nigeria.
NEWSPAPERS AND MAGAZINES
Central Bank of Nigeria Annual Reports for 1996 and 1994.
Daily Times, Lagos.
Financial Standard, Lagos
National Concord, Lagos
Newswatch Magazine, Lagos
Nigerian Tribune, Ibadan
Punch, Lagos
Saturday Tribune, Ibadan
Statistical Bulletin, 1996
Sunday Times, Lagos
Tell Magazine, Lagos.
The Guardian, Lagos
The News Magazine, Lagos
Vol. 5, No. 1
107
5Akachi
Introduction
The concept of garden presupposes a place of gentle
progress and nurturing, freshness and peace, beauty and rest; a
largely sustainable green environment. The use of Garden City as
an alias in the description of Port Harcourt due to the residents flair
for nurturing flower gardens around their houses, a result of the
influence of the early European settlers in the area (Ogionwo 1979)
shows the citys stature in the past. This is in addition to the
numerous opportunities available in the city for just anyone to make it
in life there: very cosmopolitan environment and blessed with an
array of economic concerns. At one moment, everything looked
possible in this once adorable city; but suddenly, everything went
wrong. Ghettos and slums started sprouting everywhere; organised
crimes became the order of the day; fraud and stark violence took
centre stage and the city started losing its serenity, greenness and
greatness. In recent times, Port Harcourt city has been at the brink of
total collapse.
Port Harcourt is the deepwater port city-capital of Rivers state,
Nigeria. It lies along the, 66 kilometers upstream from the Gulf of
Guinea, about 40 feet above sea level and a very few degrees above
the equator. It is located at the edge of the Niger Deltas mangrove
foreshore and swamplands (Wolpe 1974, p. 15). The largest and most
significant urban center in the Niger Delta and an important
industrial and commercial center in Nigeria, Port Harcourt city
possesses two seaports (one of them Nigerias second largest), two
airports (one international with a local wing and one for the Nigerian
Air Force), two oil refineries, two universities, two sports stadia and a
Vol. 5, No. 1
109
Vol. 5, No. 1
110
Vol. 5, No. 1
111
Vol. 5, No. 1
112
The railway and seaport, and the economic activities and attractions
attached to these industries, however, provide only one part of the
explanation for Port Harcourts socioeconomic and political
significance in the country. Petroleum and natural gas round out the
equation (Wolpe 1974, p. 22). Oil was found in the Niger Delta area in
the mid 1950s. Soon after, Port Harcourt became the main operational
base for multi-national petrobusinesses which refined crude oil both for
local consumption and export. Indeed, Port Harcourts rapid growth
and development was mainly tied to the effects of oil exploitation
activities in the town. In other words, though there developed an
industrial labour force due to the initial foundation industries,
petrobusiness activities led to an influx of expatriate multi-national
corporations which activities aided tremendously in the radical
transformation of the city (Ezedinma and Chukuezi 1999, p. 137).
These heightened migrations, which were strongly stimulated,
especially since the 1970s, by the oil boom.
Population wise, the growth of Port Harcourt has been quite
remarkable, as the census figures show. Three years after its founding
(1915), its population was about 5,000. Others include: 1921 7,185;
1931 15,201; 1944 30,200; 1946 34,000 (est.); 1952/3 79,634; 1963
179,563; 1971 213,443; 1973 231,632; (Anyanwu 1979, Ogionwo
1979, Izeogu 1989, p. 59), and in 1991 440,399 (Obinna et al 2010).
Since the 2006 national census was fraught with serious controversy,
and thus, is very unreliable, to have an insight into the 2009
population estimate of the city, Obinna et al (2010, p. 173) projects
from the less controversial 1991 census figure. With an annual growth
rate of 5.8% (as establishes by the National Population Commission),
he affirms that the 2009 population figure of Port Harcourt in 2009 is
projected to be 900,176 persons. This is, indeed, a phenomenal growth
regime for Port Harcourt. For instance, the percentage change of
Vol. 5, No. 1
113
Vol. 5, No. 1
114
Vol. 5, No. 1
115
To live in Port Harcourt between the 1930s and 1980s (except for the
period of the war) was desirable, cherished and, indeed, a privilege,
as the city had the best of almost everything good: It was a Garden
where Nigerians of all groups came together and lived happily in
search of peace and fortune<It was the city of lovely hotels, a
multilingual, multicultural society where various influences coexisted in fine harmony<It was a thriving centre of commerce and
culture (Abati 2007, p. 3). Its progress was gentle, gradual but steady
until sometime in the early 1990s when the repercussions of dire
governance started taking tolls on the citys sociology and
development. Of course, the problems of governance in Port
Harcourt, nay the Niger Delta, are not divorceable from the general
mis-governance which the Nigerian state has been witnessing. The
only twists are that: the region is a very delicate one, produces oil
which accounts for up to 95% of Nigerias export earnings and over
80% of its revenue (pumping about 2.5 million barrels of crude per
day), devastated by environmental and ecological degradation due to
oil exploitation, totally neglected by governments and petrobusinesses
operating there and the least developed geo-political zone in Nigeria
(Odoemene 2010). These were, indeed, a recipe for socio-political
explosion.
Conflict in the Niger Delta arose in the early 1990s due to tensions
between the expatriate petrobusinesses and government on one side,
and a number of the Niger Deltas minority ethnic groups who felt
they were being criminally exploited, on the other. Ethnic and
political unrest has persisted, and has led to a crisis situation in Port
Harcourt, where the politics of oil is hottest. This is all about the
political economy of oil in the country, which has bred corruption and
violence over the years. The wealth deposited underneath Niger
Deltas soil holds unprecedented promise for an ecologically delicate
terrain as the delta. Under normal circumstances, the region should be
Vol. 5, No. 1
116
Vol. 5, No. 1
117
Due to this dire ecological situation and high cost of living in Port
Harcourt occasioned by the economics of oil exploration activities,
people started drifting to the outskirts of the city to live and make a
living. They started setting up shanty neighbourhoods/slums,
especially along the river banks. These are locally called Watersides
and there are forty-seven waterfront shanty suburbs in Port Harcourt
and the once adorable city was worse for it. Though the present Chief
Rotimi Amaechis administration has destroyed the waterfront
shanties, this has led to even more problems. For instance, there are
no compensation and/or resettlement plans for the hundreds of
thousands persons whose homes were demolished. They have, thus,
remained homeless and without sources of livelihood. Most of these
displaced persons now squat at different corners of the city trying to
eke out a living (Gusau 2010, p.15). Soon after the demolition of the
waterfronts and the displacement of persons, residents of Port
Harcourt witnessed a sharp increase in the incidences of crime in the
city (Obed 2010, p.5). This is understandably not surprising.
Gradually, the famed Garden City degenerated into a Garbage City,
and its marvelous flowers proved no better than wreaths. Describing
this in a catchy poetic manner, Abati (2007, p. 4) notes that Paradise
is lost. The Garden has been defiled. It is desolate. Beauty has given
way to ugliness. Another observer notes thus:
Dense, garbage-heaped slums stretch for miles.
Choking
black
smoke
from
an
open-air
slaughterhouse rolls over housetops. Streets are
cratered with potholes and ruts. Vicious gangs roam
school grounds. Peddlers and beggars rush up to
vehicles stalled in gas lines. This is Port Harcourt,
Nigerias oil hub<smack-dab in the middle of oil
reserves bigger than the United States and Mexicos
combined. Port Harcourt should gleam; instead, it
rots (Oneill 2007, p. 2).
Vol. 5, No. 1
118
Vol. 5, No. 1
119
Vol. 5, No. 1
120
Port Harcourt, <the time for talking has passed. When the situation
in the delta threatens to turn into another Middle East, then the world
will finally intervene (Ohiagbuchi 2007). In another explanation for
this situation, another Port Harcourt-based Niger Delta youth opines:
The activities of these oil companies in collaboration with the state
are threatening our environments and natural habitat. So the battle we
v
are wedging is the battle for our life. These show the resolute spirit
of the youth of the Niger Delta region in finding a solution to their
unacceptable situation.
In a bid to realize their aims, many of the youth in the area formed
themselves into gangs and began to wreck havoc in different Niger
Delta cities and towns. In all these, Port Harcourt has had the most
shares for obvious reasons. It is the oil headquarters of Nigeria and
consequently has the largest concentration of oil firms expatriate
workers. This makes them good targets for attacks that will send
signals to their employers, the government and the West of the Niger
Delta peoples frustrations. Pointedly, the violence that has rocked the
city of Port Harcourt in recent years has been aimed mainly at foreign
petrobusiness, their expatriate workers and the security operatives
protecting them. Hundreds of kidnappings/hostage-taking by
militants, pipeline bombings and attacks on flow stations have
occurred in the past three years alone. And the number and severity
of these attacks have been building.
Commenting on these gangs and the severity of their actions in Port
Harcourt city, Oruwari and Owei (2006, p. 6-7) opine:
The gangs have become a security threat to oil
workers as the involvement of the gangs in
bunkering, extortions, kidnapping of expatriate oil
workers and rivalry wars, along
with
the
Vol. 5, No. 1
121
Dozens have been killed and many more wounded. In many cases,
and unfortunately too, most of the dead have come from bystanders
caught in crossfire. Arguably, one could perceive the magnitude of
the gang problem in Port Harcourt if the one hundred and three (103)
groups listed as banned organizations in the Rivers State Anti-cult Bill
are taken into consideration. In any case, the banning of these groups
has not been effective, neither has it stemmed down the tide of
violence in the city. Oruwari and Owei (2006) report that the gangs
are still around and operate in broad daylight, even in the presence of
law enforcement agents. Further commenting on the grim situation in
the city, Watts (2007) notes thus:
Port Harcourt has become to all intents and purposes
ungovernable: it is disorderly and lawless, and this
lawlessness now extends from the waterside slums
to the middle class Government Residential Area
(GRA). In particular, organized robbery by wellorganized gangs of alienated and angry youth has
exploded since the 1990s<
Vol. 5, No. 1
122
Vol. 5, No. 1
123
Vol. 5, No. 1
124
were not only handsomely paid, but government kept a blind eye to
their illegal oil bunkering activities.
By the end of 2003, the influence of the group had become enormous.
After the 2003 elections, Odili fell out with Asari and his NDPVF
group. Asari was dropped and his lieutenant, Ateke Tom, became
Odilis new bride. He established the NDV, a break-away faction of
the NDPVF group, to keep Asari and his men in check (Odoemene
2011, 10). By August 2004, the NDPVF began clashing with NDV
causing an unprecedented violence in the Port Harcourt city. Before
the end of 2007, Ateke and his group had also fallen out with their
political master, Dr. Peter Odili, thus making the scenario
dangerously complex (Asuni 2009, Courson 2009, Ghazvinian nd).
Moreover, from about 2007 there emerged on the scene a multiplicity
of other militant groups, all fighting for their perceived rights, both
real and imagined. At various times some of these groups had clashes
among themselves which resulted in many deaths, including those of
innocent, law-abiding citizens. For instance, it was two major militant
groups the Bush Boys and the Greenlanders purportedly had their
leaders killed by Ateke and his men (Asuni 2009b, p. 12), occurrences
that further charged the Port Harcourt polity. The inability of Dr.
Odili and his associate, Abiye Sekibo, to contain the militia gangs
became a bane of Port Harcourt city the seat of power due to their
militancy and gangsterism. This was pertinently because
Many militant groups were never disarmed after the
elections were held, becoming in effect standing
armies for their political patrons. But while the
armed groups remained, their political allegiances
constantly shifted. Sekibo found himself unable to
reign in Atekes excesses, and the pair had a falling
out during the 2007 election campaign when the
Vol. 5, No. 1
125
Vol. 5, No. 1
126
and power, and Niger Deltas most significant urban social space, has
been the main war theatre. Indeed, it has become worse for it. Abati
(2007, p. 3) remarkably points out the implications of hobnobbing
with these evil groups that has become part of Port Harcourt city and
seem to have assumed permanence:
<they are causing so much problem because they need to get even
with the politicians who used them during the elections (2003, 2007),
only to get into office and ignore them. They promise to kidnap both
politicians and their relatives and make the area ungovernable<The
hoodlums who are now kings of the territory acquired power and
influence under the watch of political Godfathers who used them as
political thugs and armed them with sophisticated weapons. The
elections are over; the genie is out of the bottle; the boys with the
arms and ammunition have found a new occupation in terrorism.
And the matter is now beyond the Godfathers who dare not declare
their association with the boys too openly. We are paying the price
for bad leadership and bad politics.
Vol. 5, No. 1
127
Vol. 5, No. 1
128
pursued included not just the fight for resource control, but also the
sacking from the city of all persons who are not from the Niger
Delta. Thus, indigenes of Port Harcourt, over time, became very
unreceptive to migrants, non-indigenes or settlers in the city, who
they claim had dominated and oppressed them for so long. LeithRoss (1937, p. 247) observations, only 25 years after the founding of
the city, are instructive as they underline, in some way, the
predisposition of the citys residents to such dichotomous politics and
their adjustments accordingly:
Port Harcourt is not, as might be expected, a
melting pot where races and speeches, customs and
character will fuse and mingle and out of which a
new and stable people will emerge, but rather a
railway platform with people coming and going.
Each family part holding closely together,
contemptuous and suspicious of the other
The insecurity and threats that these patterns of urban ethnic relations
pose underlines one of the main bases for the existence, prominence
vii
and vibrancy of organized ethnic unions in the city. These are
fashioned to deal with the vagaries of urban life and existence
guarantying adequate welfare and security as it affects their
members (Mabogunje 1976, Osaghae 1994). The existence of such
unions is a consequence of the weakening of family roles, nuclear
and/or extended, due to the exigencies of migration. Mabogunje (1976,
p. 23), for instance, notes these unions as <perhaps the most
important social phenomenon in many African cities. This is deeply
rooted in the kind of functions they performed, especially in
providing security to the urban migrants, dubbed settlers, in Port
Harcourt city.
Vol. 5, No. 1
129
Vol. 5, No. 1
130
Concluding Remarks
In all, a critical examination of these problems would show
that they were a reflection of a dilemma: failed governance. This has
been almost totally motivated by corruption which is rooted in the oil
of the delta region and its money. This is at the roots of Port
Harcourts woes. Thus, it has been subverted by the very thing that
gave it promise oil. As (Oneill 2007, p. 1) notes:
Oil fouls everything in southern Nigeria. It spills
from the pipelines, poisoning soil and water. It stains
the hands of politicians and generals, who siphon off
its profits. It taints the ambitions of the young, who
will try anything to scoop up a share of the liquid
riches fire a gun, sabotage a pipeline, kidnap a
foreigner.
The cruelest twist is that half a century of oil extraction in the delta
has failed to make the lives of the people better. Instead, they are
poorer still, and hopeless. As Oneill (2007, p. 3) reports, a Chief from
x
Oloibiri had charged thus: If we had never seen oil, we would have
been better off.
Vol. 5, No. 1
131
What future, then, is there for Port Harcourt city, in the face of its
glaring opportunities for positive transformation, and also the
tendencies of complete disintegration? Indeed, the social pendulum in
Port Harcourt has the potentials of swinging to any one of these
options. Its eventual course would, however, be largely dependent on
the approach to its problems. The continued neglect, alienation and
the suppression of its vast peoples, indigenes and settlers alike, by
either the government or petrobusinesses, or both, could be a recipe for
disaster. Its implications would be grave, especially as Port Harcourts
significance both for the Niger Delta region and the Nigerian state is
prominent. On the other hand, an honest appraisal of the crisis of
governance in the city of Port Harcourt, and the sincerity of the State
at oiling the friction by quickly dealing with the diverse problems,
could turn the city away from its destructive drift. It is only then that
the potentials of the city to truly create new arrangements and human
organizations through which a viable chance for all citizens to pursue
their aspirations could be effectively realised.
While one agrees that Port Harcourt, the Garden city, may not be
horticultural green anymore (a situation it can also turn around if its
administrators have the will), the city is still metaphorically green in
the context of the billions of dollars it spins, not only from
petrobusinesses, but also from other numerous industrial, commercial
and seaport activities therein. This offers the city a wonderful
advantage for a total turn-around. One has to reiterate that for this to
be possible, there has to be a credible government and leadership in
the city, the Niger Delta and Nigeria as a whole. This must be the first
step towards restoring the city on the part of sustainable development
and progress. These hard facts must have to be borne in mind
constantly, and consciously too.
Vol. 5, No. 1
132
References
Abati, R. 2007. Port Harcourt: A Paradise Lost [online]. Available from:
http://www.nigeriavillagesquare.com/articles/reuben-abati/portharcourt-a-paradise-lost/pdf.html [Assessed on 29 June 2008].
Amnesty International. nd. Nigeria: Rape the Silent Weapon [online].
Available from:
http://www.amnestyusa.org/document.php?id=ENGAFR440202006
&lang=e [Assessed on 20 September 2009].
Anyanwu, C.N. 1979. The growth of Port Harcourt, 1912-1960. In Ogionwo,
W. (ed.) The city of Port Harcourt: A symposium on its growth and
development. Ibadan: Heinemann Educational Books.
Archibong, M. 2004. Port Harcourt: Garden city with few flowers. The Sun
Newspaper, Thursday, 11 March.
Asuni, J.B. 2009. Understanding the Armed Groups of the Niger Delta.
Working Paper, Council on Foreign Relations (CFR) (September).
Asuni, J.B. 2009. Blood Oil in the Niger Delta. USIP Special Report 229
(August). Washington D.C.: United States Institute of Peace (USIP).
Courson, E. (2009). Movement for the Emancipation of the Niger Delta
(MEND): Political Marginalization, Repression and Petro-insurgency
in the Niger Delta. Discussion Paper 47, Nordiska Afrikainstitutet,
Uppsala.
Dixon-Fyle, M. 1989. The Saro in the Political Life of Early Port Harcourt,
1913-49. The Journal of African History, 30 (1), 125138.
Dorothy, Q.T. and Regan E.R. 1994. Rape in War: Challenging the Tradition of
Impunity. SAIS Review, 14 (1) (Winter/Spring), 8199.
Vol. 5, No. 1
133
Vol. 5, No. 1
134
Vol. 5, No. 1
135
Vol. 5, No. 1
136
Polgreen, L. 2007. Nigerian gangs turn their guns on their own. International
Herald Tribune, (Thursday, November 8) [online]. Available from:
http://www.iht.com/bin/printfriendly.php?id=8252160 [Assessed 2
December 2007].
Rowell, A., Marriott, J. and Stockman, L. 2005. The Next Gulf: London,
Washington and oil conflict in Nigeria. London: Constable and
Robinson.
Watts, M. 2007. So Goes Port Harcourt< Political Violence and the Future of
the Niger Delta. CSIS Africa Policy Forum (27th September) [online].
Available from: http://forums.csis.org/africa/?p=61 [Assessed 15
November 2007].
Wolpe, H. 1974. Urban politics in Nigeria A study of Port Harcourt. Berkeley:
University of California Press.
Notes
i
C.S.C. 1/32, Nigeria Dispatch to C.O., 5 June, 1913. National Archives Enugu
(NAE).
ii
Nigeria 183, CO. 583/4/Vol. 3. Sir Frederick Lugard to the Rt. Hon. Lewis
Harcourt, Secretary of State for the Colonies, 18 August 1913, Public Records
Office, London.
iii
Vol. 5, No. 1
137
vi
The decree provides that every such sale was deemed to have been lawful
and valid, and was to have effect according to its tenor; the new purchasers
of the abandoned properties were free of all encumbrances, while the registrar
of lands was directed, upon presentation to him of the instrument of sale duly
signed by or on behalf of the Committee, to expunge from the register the
names of the hitherto registered owners and to substitute same with that of
the new purchasers. Failure by anyone to comply with these stipulations was
made a criminal offence punishable by imprisonment for one year without the
option of a fine (Nwabueze 1985).
ix
Rivers State was the name of the wartime new state with headquarters at
Port Harcourt, granted to the people of the area. This statehood was
primarily granted to weaken the Biafran side by giving semblance of
freedom to groups who had groaned under the Igbo influence.
x
Vol. 5, No. 1
138
Vol. 5, No. 1
139
Introduction
There can be no liberty for a community which lacks the means to detect lies. Walter Lippmann
Without information there is no accountability. Information is power and the more
people who possess it, the more power is distributed. The degree to which a media is
independent is the degree to which it can perform an effective public watchdog
function over the conduct of public affairs. - Pope Jeremy
Vol. 5, No. 1
141
Vol. 5, No. 1
142
Vol. 5, No. 1
143
Here lies the fact that Habermass contention in his seminal work,
Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere (1962) is steeped in the
Kantian formulation, which articulates the use of reason and criticism
in public debate. The characterisation of the media as a conduit for
critical rationality, objectivity, informed opinion and widened space,
as well as an apparatus for governmental checks and balances make it
the fourth estate of the realm as intimated by Edmund Burke.
The activities of the media in the public sphere are very essential in
the contemporary world of democracy, this is particularly so in the
Niger delta region of Nigeria, which has been described as
an enclave of youth militancy, and unmitigated violence on a large
scale< The region has been the epicentre of conflicts between oil
bearing/host communities and oil companies (mainly over land
rights or compensation for ecological damage); between oil
producing communities and the government (over increased access
to oil wealth); and between and among ethnic groups (over claims to
land ownership and sharing of amenities). (Ojakorotu 2006: 230).
With the above in mind, the place of the media regarding the
protracted crises and conflicts in the Niger delta is cardinal; it is even
more in this era of post amnesty deal. In the era of post amnesty deal,
the media could help in widening the frontiers of the public sphere for
good governance and development. The media can do this by
legitimising, criticising and questioning the legitimacy as well as the
operations of the parties (that is the federal government and the
communities) involved in the peace process or amnesty deal.
Vol. 5, No. 1
144
Particularly, in the Niger delta, the media has enormous role to play
in the wake of the demands of the amnesty deal. The place of the
media in this regard has been captured clearly in a piece by Chigozi
Ijeomah Eti titled Objectivity and Balance in Conflict Reporting:
Imperatives for the Niger Delta Press. As he argues,
The press has been found to play a significant role in managing
conflict situations in the society< and building confidence, hope and
a sense of community and communality especially during or after
conflict event, with particular reference to the Niger delta. (Eti 2009:
91)
The remit of this study will not permit an exhaustive analysis of the
Niger deltas resource curse thesis and political impasse, rather it
will be exploring the ways and manner the dyadic relationship of the
public sphere and the media can help in galvanising methods and
approaches for dealing with conflicts amongst the Nigerian states, the
multinationals and their host community as well as resolving
Vol. 5, No. 1
145
Theoretical Framework
The theoretical framework of this study is based on Jurgen
Habermass theory of the public sphere, a realm made up of private
people gathered together as a public and articulating the needs of
society with the state (Habermas 1991: 176). Jurgen Habermass
avant-garde work, The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere: an
Inquiry into a Category of Bourgeois Society (1962) has attracted extensive
attention in debates regarding the correlation between the public and
the private spheres and the public good. In the line of thought of the
cultural theorist, Habermas, the book questions the status of public
opinion in the exercise of representative democracy and good
governance. Although, originally used to gauge the heartbeat of
broadened public opinion as it affected the public sphere in Western
Europe, the concept, the public sphere, has been appropriated by
societies the world over to deal with their disparate situations
regarding expanding debates that bring about democratic changes.
For Hauser, the public sphere is a discursive space in which
individuals and groups congregate to discuss matters of mutual
interest and, where possible, to reach a common judgment
(1999:117). In the thinking of Nancy Fraser, it is basically a site for
the production and circulation of discourses that can in principle be
critical of the state (1990: 57). In addition, Asen in his Toward a
Normative Conception of Difference in Public Deliberation,
considers it as a realm of social life in which public opinion can be
formed (1999: 125). Habermass theorising here made a foray into
using the public sphere, a correlate of mass media to engage with
states excesses in the light of good governance and development. The
Vol. 5, No. 1
146
Vol. 5, No. 1
147
The press, it has been argued, was in the forefront of the struggle for
enthronement of democracy or better still, the return to civil rule
(because not a few Nigerians believe we do have a democracy yet).
Many in this group will point out that the press was also in the
vanguard of the independence struggle. To them while other
countries in Africa fought for their independence on the battlefield,
that of Nigeria was fought for, and won on the pages of newspapers
expending millions of words, instead of ammunitions, in the process.
(Kalejaiye 2009: 75)
Vol. 5, No. 1
148
Vol. 5, No. 1
149
and fairness. In order to bring good governance in the Niger delta, the
Nigerian media should be in the vanguard of promoting the enabling
environment that will translate the federal governments promises
regarding the amnesty deal, which was brokered by President Umaru
Musa YarAdua with the warring militants in the region. The ability
of the media to engender conflict resolution has been lauded:
This cannot be less true of conflict in the Niger delta. In fact, the
establishment of the regional press in the Niger delta may be part of
societys response to the nagging and protracted crises in the oil-rich
area. < There is an emerging press system in the Niger delta that is
domiciled in the area or elsewhere in the country, but is established
to articulate the agitations of the Niger delta people. (Eti 2009: 92)
Vol. 5, No. 1
150
Vol. 5, No. 1
151
The activities of the media and public sphere in the above light will
ultimately register a sense of transition from frontier mercantilism to
restrained, sensitive mode of operation in the multinationals in the
Niger delta, whose operations are the raison d'tre for the conflicts in
the region.
Furthermore, the presence of a virile, responsible media practice is
correlate of media social responsibility. Thus, a social responsible
media galvanises actions towards corporate social responsibility. This
practice is tantamount to journalistic activism in challenging and
changing oppressive structures (Shah 1996: 145). A gagged media
does not foster democracy, a harbinger of expanded public sphere,
which brings about inputs from the people regarding how they want
the society to move. As Chris Ogbondah observed, a free press is an
indispensable institution of a democratic society (1997: 291), meaning
that a society that allows free flow of information and ideas from the
people that usually stem from expanded public sphere is democratic
and developmental. It is in this direction that it has been noted that
In modern practice, the concept of social responsibility informs us
that the media should be responsible to the people in order to
advance the cause of good governance. This technically means that
the media should be a platform to advance the cause of humanity. It
calls for socially relevant information to be disseminated and shared,
thereby making available the stimulation of public dialogue on
issues of concern to a democratic, populist Society. (Nwagbara 2008:
246)
Vol. 5, No. 1
152
Another way the media and the public sphere could bring a wave of
change characterised by less tension and peace in the Niger delta is by
deflecting false information, slant and propaganda, a term which the
media legend, Walter Lippmann calls the picture in our heads
(1997: 95), an enemy of a conflict-free society. Propaganda is a hotbed
of conflict, crisis and the like. Hence, a misinformed people will
naturally get the wrong signal and thereby act in that light. The media
could help foster that the right information and news are being
filtered for public consumption in the region. The presence of a weak
media in the region rather being a platform for healthy change and
conflict resolution will be an avenue for sedation, a process the
cements the pictures in our head as Lippmann indicates, thereby
fuelling multilayered conflict and violence in the erstwhile
combustible Niger delta environment.
It has been noted that Africa (Nigeria or the Niger delta) is a theatre of
war. And part of the conflicts in Nigeria is as a result of the hype,
sensationalism, propaganda and skewed reportage that the media in
this part of the world carries out. In consonance with this,
Consistently, the news pages of virtually all Nigerian
newspapers are daily littered with necrophilous, if not
apocalyptic, fear-inducing, anxiety-promoting phrases which
draw attention to the transitional nature of the Nigerian state and
society. (Kehinde 2009: 126)
Vol. 5, No. 1
153
fruition. It has been asserted that the media has become a crucial
battlefield (Shpiro 2002: 76) in mans quest to triumph over conflict
and its aftermath.
Vol. 5, No. 1
154
Vol. 5, No. 1
155
Vol. 5, No. 1
156
Vol. 5, No. 1
157
As the media brings the issues that shape human existence to the front
burner, it will be contributing to sustainable human development and
lasting peace in the Niger delta (Eti 2009: 100).
In this vein, the media helps in galvanising sense of solidarity in times
of conflict; it helps reciprocally hostile and incongruent entities find a
common ground. In the post amnesty era, this duty is doubly
relevant, hence, the media in this instance should serve as a platform
for cohesion and trust in making sure the ideals of the amnesty is
achieved. This can be achieved by dissemination of truth and politicsfree information that will enhance good governance and development
in the region. It is to this end that the role of media will be
contributory to Nigerias national peace and security as well as
causative to ending sectional and ideologically oriented agenda in her
body politic. This pattern is what Sydney Head calls national pride
and sense of communal identity (1985: 301). This is what has been
described as the media being able to create < a sense of community,
a sense of espirit-de-corps, a sense of shared identity (especially in
suffering), a sense of shared purpose and shared identity (Eti 2009:
100) in the Niger delta.
As the Niger delta media and other media outfits in Nigeria engage in
journalism that will bring lasting peace, sustainability, democracy and
good governance in the Niger delta, they will be enhancing the core
philosophy underpinning the amnesty deal that was brokered by
President YarAdua. The Nigerian medias effort in this perspective is
encapsulated here:
Vol. 5, No. 1
158
Conclusion
It has been demonstrated in this paper that lasting peace,
security, democracy, sustainable development and good governance
are verged on robust combination of virile media and public sphere.
This is rather redoubled in the post amnesty period in the Nigeria
delta region of Nigeria, which before now was characterised by high
level of restiveness, militancy, marginalisation, agitation and inept
governance, all stemming from oil exploration by the multinationals
in cahoots with the political operators in the region and Nigeria by
extension. In a world brimming with ideology, events, incidents,
information, politics and cultural disparities, determination of issues,
opinions and editorials that will make it to the headlines is very
complex. A form of media practice steeped in reconciling the
contradictions in this region for the benefit of its inhabitants and
Nigerians in general as well as the expansion of its public sphere is
needed. An effective media framework plus widened public sphere
will spawn the needed energy to effect change in the region in the
wake of the amnesty deal.
Vol. 5, No. 1
159
Works Cited
Adesoji, Abimbola O. Globalisation of the Media and the Challenges of
Democratisation in Nigeria. Nebula: a Journal of Multidisciplinary
Scholarship, 3.2(2006): 38-50.
Andrews, Kenneth R. The Concept of Corporate Strategy. Illinois: Richard D.
Irwin, 1991.
Asen, Robert. Towards a Normative Conception of Difference in Public
Deliberation. Argumentation and Advocacy, 25(Winter 1999):115-129.
Besson, Samantha. Sovereignty in Conflict. Towards an International Legal
Community: The Sovereignty of the States and Sovereignty of International
Law. Tierney, S. and Warbrick C (eds.). Aldershot: Ashgate
Publishing, 2004.
Eti, Chigozi I. Objectivity and Balance in Conflict Reporting: Imperatives for
the Niger Delta Press. The Journal of African Studies, 3.3(2009):91-104.
Fred, A. I. Omu. Press and Politics in Nigeria, 1800-1937. London: Longman,
1978.
Hause, Gerald. Vernacular Dialogue and the Rhetoricality of Public
Opinion. Communication Monographs, 65.2(1998):83-107.
Fraser, Nancy. Rethinking the Public Sphere: A Contribution to the Critique
of Actually Existing Democracy. Social Text,25.26(1990):56-80.
Head, Sydney. World Broadcasting System. California: Wadsworth Publishing,
1985.
Jibo, Mvendaga. The Nigerian Media: An Assessment of Its Role in
Achieving Transparent and Accountable Government in the Fourth
Republic. Nordic Journal of African Studies, 12.2(2003):180-195.
Vol. 5, No. 1
160
Kalejaiye, Olugbenga. The Press, Military Coup, and the Nigerian Polity: A
Historical Perspective. Journal of Social Sciences, 19.1(2009):75-81.
Kehinde, Ayo. The Muse as Peace-Maker: The Moral Burden of Conflict
Management and Resolution in Nigerian Literature The African
Symposium: An Online Journal of African Educational Research Network.
9.2(2009): 126-42.
Kukah, Matthhew H. Democracy and Civil Society in Nigeria. Ibadan: Spectrum,
1999.
Lippmann, Walter. Public Opinion. New York: Free Press, 1997.
Lunat, Ziyaad. The Internet and the Public Sphere: Evidence from Civil
Society in Developing Countries. EJISC, 35.3(2008): 1-12.
Manoff, R. K. The Medias Role in Preventing and Moderating Conflict.
http://www.usip.org/pubs/usipeace. Retrieved March 14, 2010.
McQuail, Denis. McQuails Mass Communication Theory. London: Sage, 2000.
Nwabueze, Ben. Democratisation. Ibadan: Spectrum Books, 1993.
Nwagbara, Uzoechi. Political Power and Intellectual Activism in Tanure
Ojaides The Activist. Nebula: A Journal of Multidisciplinary
Scholarship, 5.4 (December 2008): 225-253.
Ogbondah, Chris W. Communication and Democratisation in Africa:
Constitutional Changes, Prospects, and Persistent Problems for the
Media. Gasette, 59.4-5(1997):271-294.
Ojakorotu, Victor. Youth Militancy and Development Efforts in African
Multiethnic Society. Asteriskos, 1.2 (2006): 229-242.
Vol. 5, No. 1
161
Vol. 5, No. 1
162
Vol. 5, No. 1
163
INTRODUCTION
The Niger Delta has been described as one of the worlds
largest and Africas third largest drainage area. This flood plain is
home to over seven million people, grouped into several nations or
ethnic groups the Ijaw, Urhobo, Itsekiri, Isoko, Efik, Etche, Ibibio,
Andoni, Ikwere, Ogoni, Edo, and Kwale-Igbo. The bulk of these
groups inhabit the heart of the delta which is spread over three states
in present day Nigeria namely, Bayelsa, Delta and Rivers states. These
states take up about 80% of the area.
The Niger Delta has been a topic for intense debate since the 90s due
to the local and international awareness created by Ken Saro Wiwa of
the regions cursed blessing. In the words of Ibaba (2005:3):
The Niger Delta Region of Nigeria is an odd paradox. Despite its
evident and abundant resources which include the nations oil
wealth, the area represents one of extreme poverty and
underdevelopment. The Niger Delta is not only underdeveloped, but
is also experiencing a crisis of developmental instability.
Infrastructural development is very low, poverty level is about 80%
and unemployment level ranks 70%. Access to basic social amenities
is very limited. For example, over 80% of the coastal or riverine
communities source water for drinking, cooking and other domestic
uses come from rivers, streams and lakes that are equally used for
disposing of human and other forms of waste. The upland
communities largely drink from shallow wells that are
contaminated. Indeed, the Niger Delta region falls below the
national average, in all measures or indicators of development
More often than not, most literature on the Niger Delta place the
blame of underdevelopment on the conspiracy between the MNCs
who milk this region of its resources and the federal government who
is the end beneficiary of this wanton exploitation. Most arguments
Vol. 5, No. 1
165
Vol. 5, No. 1
166
OBJECTIVE OF STUDY
Peoples of the core Niger Delta have for long complained
about marginalization and neglect in the distribution and utilization
of the countrys resources. The Izon, presumably believed to be
Nigerias largest minority group and the largest of the ethnic groups
in the Niger Delta claim to be the most affected. With the advent of
development in the region in the wake of violent agitations by the
people for a fair share of the nations proceeds from oil which is
sourced from their grossly underdeveloped towns and villages and
the effects of which impoverishes them even further, it becomes ironic
and worrying to note that in new and budding Niger Delta towns
such as Yenagoa, idleness among the indigenous workforce (youths)
seems to be at its highest. The same also applies to many oil
producing communities. The result of the refusal of the native youths
to apply themselves to labour, is that, the provision of services
becomes completely dominated by none indigenes.
In view of this scenario, this paper aims at first identifying the reasons
for this increase in human resource wastage amid increasing
development programmes. The essence of this is to identify gaps in
development strategies meant for the Niger Delta and consequently
point decision makers in the right direction of situating development
programmes within the context of the environment and its peoples.
Vol. 5, No. 1
167
Vol. 5, No. 1
168
education and all other demands that would improve the quality of
life communally and individually.
DEVELOPMENT
FROM
A
SOCIO-PSYCHOLOGICAL
PERSPECTIVE
Okereke (1999:1) defines development as the qualitative
improvement in the living standard of members of the society. and
administration as the role relationship that defines the intentions and
programmes of government, the means available internally and
externally to accomplish them; where, when and how they are to be
accomplished; and who is to benefit from them. He summarizes
therefore that development administration refers to all the activities
of government and its agencies aimed at the attainment of higher
levels of development. (ibid:2)
Ujo (in Okoli and Onah 2002:130) contends that development is both
a physical process and a state of mind. The transformation of
institution is one aspect. The other aspect is that the thinking of the
people must change. Development, no matter the circumstance,
refers to change, a change for the better. Ujos perception above
implies that development can only be achieved when the mental
accompanies the social, economic, environmental and infrastructural
aspects of development. If a community experiences an economic and
structural revolution, and the affected people are unable to adapt to
the changes brought therein, then a fit occurs in the developmental
process. In other words, these development gains would be lost if the
peoples psyche are unable to adapt to these changes to ensure
maximum utilization of these structures. This situation which is a
recurrent trend in the Niger Delta justifies the application of the
human resource management theory as the framework for this paper. For
every development stride made, there ought to be a commensurate
Vol. 5, No. 1
169
HUMAN
RESOURCE
DEVELOPMENT
AMONG
THE
ABORIGINES OF THE NIGER DELTA
It is a widely held that the Niger Delta is one of Nigerias
most educationally disadvantaged regions of which the Ijaws
(Nigerias fourth largest ethnic group) have arguably been the worst
hit. This state of affairs coupled with their crude agricultural methods
Vol. 5, No. 1
170
The utter neglect of the rural communities in the Niger Delta has led
to a massive rural-urban drift occasioned not only by lack of basic
amenities (healthy drinking water, electricity and medical care) and
unemployment, but also by the destruction of their environment and
livelihood from oil exploitation as well as the frequent inter and intra
communal clashes witnessed in the region (most of which are also oil
related). The outcome of the prevalence of these problems is the
population explosion of the regions few urban centres. As Worgu
(ibid) notes once again,
this has ultimately caused problems of environmental refugees.
Some of the landless farmers migrate to other more fertile lands in
other rural communities putting pressure on scarce fertile lands.
While some of the displaced farmers out-migrate to the urban areas
in search of other means of livelihood.
Vol. 5, No. 1
171
Vol. 5, No. 1
172
Vol. 5, No. 1
173
Vol. 5, No. 1
174
Vol. 5, No. 1
175
Vol. 5, No. 1
176
In line with this assertion, it is logical to affirm that the increasing gap
between the development strategies of the Niger Delta (no matter
how meagre) and the level of awareness and relevant skills
acquisition to enable the people adapt to the changes therein, has
further underdeveloped the inhabitants of the region. The increasing
social fit has left the aborigines of the Niger Delta grappling for
relevance and inclusion in a system most are not suited for. I find this
scenario aptly depicted in the political satire/comic movie, The Gods
Must Be Crazy. In this movie, a bottle (science and technology) finds
its way into a primitive yet peaceful society of San Bushmen. The
presence of the bottle (which signifies development) makes living
easy as it becomes a handy tool for grinding and crushing. But just as
it is useful, it becomes the centre of squabbles for the primitive and
once peaceful community as every one wants use of it at the same
time. A community that had grown so used to doing things together
Vol. 5, No. 1
177
could not adapt to the pattern of taking things in turn. In the end, they
had to get rid of the bottle to let peace return.
The traditional inhabitants of the Niger Delta fall into the occupations
of fishing, subsistence farming and canoe building. The viability and
sustainability of these occupations amid the slowly increasing road
network and extensive environmental pollution gets increasingly
questionable with each passing decade. With the pollution of rivers
and lands, surviving on fishing and farming is almost impossible.
This is understood in view of the terrain which a World Bank Report
in 1995 described as vast interface between land and water. (cf
Ighodalo 2005: 321). Hence Briggs et al (cf Obi, 1997: 14) state; we
have widespread water pollution and soil pollution, contamination
with oil spills become dangerous for farming, even where they
continue to produce any significant yields. So, in a changing Delta,
what becomes the lot of the fishermen who have no fish to catch,
farmers who have no land to farm on, or canoe carvers or boat men
whose services are required less as time passes? These people along
with those seeking the better life head for the urban centres and
eventually find themselves ill equipped and consequently misplaced
in todays modern society. (Agreed that many more communities still
commute by water, but when we consider that just about a decade
ago, communities such as Abonema, Buguma, Degema, Amassoma,
Ogoibiri, Agudama-Ekpetiama, Trofani, Ikhibiri, Bomadi and most
Isoko areas which could only be reached by water can now be reached
by land, it would not take a seer to project into the future on the
relevance of professions such as canoe building and boating)
Vol. 5, No. 1
178
Vol. 5, No. 1
179
Vol. 5, No. 1
180
Vol. 5, No. 1
181
Vol. 5, No. 1
182
CONCLUSION
There has been so much emphasis on curbing the
underdevelopment of the Niger Delta. Much of this emphasis borders
on the provision of roads, hospitals, educational institutions, portable
water, electricity, theatres and so forth. But little attention has been
paid to underdevelopment from a socio-psychological perspective.
This paper argues that for infrastructural development to be
meaningful, emphasis ought to be paid to education, both formal and
informal to help the aborigines of the Niger Delta adapt positively to
the changes that ensue from physical development. While it would
not be easy to alter the quick money culture which has been
encouraged by politicians and oil companies, it is the position of this
paper that relevant skills acquisition and adaptation ought to be
commitedly implemented both in rural and urban areas so that the
youths find relevance in society.
The government both at federal and local levels has shown itself to be
overtly unwilling to effectively address issues pertaining to the Niger
Delta region. However, while not excusing
or encouraging
government irresponsibility, it is my contention that since these oil
companies work in the remotest of communities, they stand a better
chance of providing fastest the basic amenities to make life for these
distant rural dwellers a little more comfortable and thereby reduce the
allure of migrating to the townships where the meager facilities have
already been over stretched and where these migrants end up being
disillusioned and, more often than not, become threats to society.
After the provision of basic facilities, next comes the effort at helping
them make optimal use of their habitat, be relevant to society and
keep abreast with the times through the acquisition of relevant skills
and crafts. This becomes a vital step in human resource development
in the Delta. It is a step which both the government and MNCs in the
Vol. 5, No. 1
183
Delta have the capital and wherewithal to achieve. The only problem
here is the will. But the earlier they settle to achieve this, the better,
lest communities and youth groups that are still accommodating of
government policies and MNCs operations become hostile and
aggressive like their already restive brothers. If the MNCs can begin
this process of human resource development, it is only hoped that
somewhere along the line, the various arms of government would
genuinely follow.
While the implementation of these conditions may not completely
address the complex issues of human development and restiveness in
Nigerias Niger Delta, the intention of this research is to point stake
holders in the right direction in the search for a solution to the
stagnating of human resource development in the Niger Delta region.
One of such stakeholders is the novel Ministry of the Niger Delta
whose responsibility is the development of the Niger Delta, but whose
creation met with so much skepticism since the Niger Delta
Development Commission which is already saddled with the same
responsibility, has arguably not succeeded despite being in existence
for about a decade. The Niger Delta Ministry, in view of arguments
presented here would go a long way in effectively tackling issues of
restiveness and development in the region if only they would divert
adequate attention and resources to human resource development
programmes which would make the Niger Delta aborigines more self
sufficient and deft to change.
Vol. 5, No. 1
184
REFERENCES
Ake, Claude (2001), Democracy and Development in Africa. Lagos: Spectrum
Books Ltd.
Alanamu, Ayinla S. ed (2003), Issues in Political Violence in Nigeria. Illorin:
Hanson Printing Communication Resource Ltd.
Ehwarieme, W. (2006). Politics Among Minorities. A Paper Presented at the
Faculty of Social Sciences Seminar Series, Niger Delta University, June.
Etekpe, Ambily. (2007). The Politics and Conflict Over Oil and Gas in the
Niger Delta Region: The Bayelsa State Experience. Port Harcourt:
TowerGate Resources.
Friedman, John (1967), A Conceptual Model for the Analysis of Planning
Behaviour.Administrative Science Quarterly, vol.122, 225-252.
Gant, George F. (1979), Development Administration: Concepts, Goals,
Methods. Wisconsin: The University of Wisconsin.
Herbert, Simon (1957) Models of My Life. www.msu.edu/course/aec .
Ibaba, S.I. (2005), Understanding the Niger Delta Crisis. Port Harcourt,
Nigeria: Amethyst and Colleagues Publishers.
Ibaba, S.I. (2006). Aliens in Their Land: Reflections on Community Conflicts
and Internal Displacements in Bayelsa State. Paper Presented at the
Faculty of Social Sciences Seminar Series, Niger Delta University, July.
Ikelegbe, Augustine (2008), Interrogating a Crisis of Corporate Governance
and the Interface with Conflict: The Case of Multinational Oil
Companies and the Conflicts in the Niger Delta, in International
Conference on the The Nigerian State, Oil Industry and the Niger Delta.
Vol. 5, No. 1
185
Vol. 5, No. 1
186
Vol. 5, No. 1
187
Watts, M and Okonta, I. (2003) Petro Politics and Nigeria Democracy Preface
to Dimieari Von Kemedi (2003) Community Conflicts in the Niger
Delta: Petro-weapon or Policy Failure? Berkeley Workshop on
Environmental Politics Working Papers 03-12 Institute of
International Studies University of California Berkeley.
Worgu,
Vol. 5, No. 1
188
Niger Delta:
Sub-Regional
Abstract
Sub-national economic disparities between the Northern and
Southern Nigeria have continuously estranged policy makers in government
from adopting purely technical strategies in dealing with the nations
chequered economy. This paper uses a structural functional theoretical
framework to analyze the place of armed militancy in the Niger Delta as a
response to growing inter-regional economic disparity and sub-national
marginalization and explains why present institutional arrangement may
falter in yielding the desired national results. It concludes with a suggestion
of relevant policy suggestions for ensuring peace in the Niger Delta region of
Nigeria.
Vol. 5, No. 1
190
Vol. 5, No. 1
191
Vol. 5, No. 1
192
Vol. 5, No. 1
193
Vol. 5, No. 1
194
The reality of the economic disparities between these regions has over
the years created a profound interplay of political machinations by
stakeholders having differing mindsets of which the armed militancy
is only an expression.
Vol. 5, No. 1
195
for 40% Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and 80% gross revenue for the
country (CBN, 2006). With such a rich economic potential, the Niger
Delta region paradoxically gets continuously enmeshed in perilous
development challenges including, widespread poverty with about
70% of the population living on or below poverty line (FGN, 2006); a
very low level of industrial development, high rate of unemployment
involving a staggering number of school leavers most of whom are
college (university) graduates; illiteracy; diseases, poor health and
20% child mortality rate which is amongst the worlds highest; poor
infrastructures; social restiveness and conflict among others.
The environmental devastation associated with the industry and the
accompanying lack of distribution of oil wealth has collectively
provided a source of numerous environmental movements and interethnic conflicts in the region. The countless incidents of industrial
emissions, gas flaring and other operational hazards such as oil
spillage, fire outbreak, and gas leakage have, for instance contributed
immensely to despoiling the environment culminating in the
destruction of economic waters used by the local people for fishing
and even sometimes drinking. This has drastically reduced aquatic
life and destroyed flora and fauna in the region thus consolidating the
region peoples poverty levels. The health implication of this
development is profound as a government agency (FGN, 2006) even
acknowledges:
Water-related diseases represent at least 80 percent of all
reported illnesses in the region. Malaria followed by other
water-related diarrheal diseases such as dysentery, typhoid
and cholera are the most common causes of morbidity at
the various health establishments in the region< In
addition, 30% of the region is located in brackish or
Vol. 5, No. 1
196
Even a study of the region by the World Bank (1995) warned that an
urgent need exists to protect the life and health of the regions
inhabitants and its ecological system from further deterioration
There is the feeling among major stakeholders in the area that the
underpinning philosophy in targeting these issues is that by
equipping local peoples with appropriate knowledge, skills and
abilities, their opportunities and intelligence are enhanced and choice
making will be improved (Niger Delta Foundation, 2007).
As the region contributing the highest share to the federal revenue
(depicted by Table I), stakeholders in the Niger Delta have argued
their case for resource control on the grounds of the continuing
underdevelopment of the area by what they believe is a connivance of
the federal government and oil multinational companies operating in
the area. While ethnic cleavages are intense in the Niger Delta, its
inhabitants are united by a sense of grievance about the exploitation
and neglect of their region. The federal government virtually ignored
the Niger Delta during the 1990s, leaving development in the hands of
the oil companies in an era when corporate social responsibility meant
little (Asuni, 2009). Environmental activism and militancy are a direct
response to the impunity, human rights violations, and perceived
neglect of the region by the Nigerian state on the one hand and
through sustained environmental hazards imposed on local Niger
Delta communities as a result of the oil production activities of
multinational oil companies on the other (Ojakorotu, 2008)
Typically, the revenue disposition of the oil and non-oil sectors of the
Nigerian economy (and hence the South and North sub-regions
respectively) can be analyzed.
Vol. 5, No. 1
197
Table I ( 5-Year disposition of Oil and Non-Oil Sectors' Contribution to Gross Domestic Product
2002-2006)
Years
Row
Labels
A
Total
revenue
(N
Billion)
Oil
Revenue
(N
Billion)
%
Contribu
-tion to
Total
Revenue
Non-Oil
Revenue
(N
Billion)
%
Contribu
-tion to
Total
Revenue
5-Yr
Total
5-Yr
Growth
%
Growth
5,965.1
19,740
4,233.3
244.55
4,762.4
5,287.6
16,710
4,056.7
329.57
85.6
85.8
88.6
84.65
17.5
24.61
500.8
565.7
785.1
677.5
3,030.1
176.5
35.23
19.4
14.4
14.2
11.4
15.35
(17.5)
-60.55
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
1,731.8
2,575.1
3,920.5
5,547.5
1,230.9
2,074.3
3,354.8
71.1
80.6
501
28.9
Source: Authors analysis based on data provided on Table B1.1, Public Finance
Statistics, Bullion, Central Bank of Nigeria, Abuja(2006) Vol. 17,Dec, Pp.91-92
Vol. 5, No. 1
199
B
C
D
E
F
G
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
5-Year
Total
5-Yr
Growth
%
Grwth
1,692.8
1,821
2,438.8
2,643.7
2,964.2
11,560.5
1,271.4
75.11
97.75
70.72
62.21
47.66
49.69
58.56
(48.06)
-49.16
859
917.1
1,147.9
1,237.2
1,385.1
5,546.3
526.1
61.25
50.7
50.4
47.1
46.8
46.7
48.
(4.02)
-7.92
398.8
419.8
582.2
627.5
703.
2,731.3
304.2
76.28
23.6
23.1
23.9
23.7
23.7
23.6
0.16
0.67
333.9
346.9
448.9
483.8
542.
2,155.5
208.1
62.32
19.7
19.
18.4
18.3
18.3
18.6
(1.44)
-7.3
(N B)
0.0
137.
259.9
295.3
333.4
1,025.6
333.4
As % of
Total
Distrib
0.0
7.5
10.7
11.2
11.2
8.9
11.25
Source: Authors analysis based on data provided on Table B1.1, Public Finance Statistics,
Bullion, Central Bank of Nigeria, Abuja (2006) Vol. 17,Dec Pp.91-92
243.36
Total
Distrib
(N B)
As % of
Total
Revenue
Federal
Govrnmnt
(N B)
As % of
Total
Distrib
State
Govrnmnts
(N B)
As % of
Total
Distrib.
Local
Govrnmnts
(N B)
As % of
Total
Distrib.
Derivation
13% - Oil
Producing
states
149.5
Percentage Share
60
Federal government
50
40
State Government
30
Local government
20
13% derivation to Oil
Producing states
10
0
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
Years
Source: Authors analysis based on data provided on Table B1.1, Public
Finance Statistics, Bullion, Central Bank of Nigeria, Abuja Pp.91-92.
Vol. 5, No. 1
201
Vol. 5, No. 1
202
Vol. 5, No. 1
203
Vol. 5, No. 1
204
Vol. 5, No. 1
205
Vol. 5, No. 1
206
Vol. 5, No. 1
207
the country. Even with the quadrupling of the international oil prices
in 1973 and the subsequent windfalls in oil export proceeds, there was
no deliberate attempt to use the oil wealth to address the issue of
poverty and the developmental needs of the region (Ojameruaye,
2004). The collective failure of both the NDDB and another
experimental agency - the River Basin Development Authority
(RBDA) established in 1970 - increased the local peoples
consciousness of the unserious posture of the federal government
towards the development of the region and in response, the military
government of Ibrahim Babangida created yet another development
agency called the Oil Mineral Producing Area Development
Commission (OMPADEC) in 1991 with operating headquarters in
Port Harcourt, in the heart of the Niger Delta. Like its predecessor, the
OMPADEC which operated between 1992 and 1995 did not impact
any positively on the people and the region. It abandoned many
projects and accrued huge debts most of which were dubious and
fraudulent. The OMPADEC lacked focus amidst irregularities of
funding, official profligacy, corruption, excessive political
interference, lack of transparency and accountability. The commission
was to receive a statutory 3% of the federation account but it hardly
got a single percent of its yearly mandate throughout its four year
lifetime. Within, the commission never had any regard for due process
in the determination and award of its contracts and never sought the
choice of the people in the determination of prospective development
projects. There was little, if any, of poverty reduction and the vast
majority of the poor people were sidelined in its activities and the
economic situation of the local people worsened. This increased the
degree of restiveness and discontent in the area reached alarming
proportion in 1998 when the latest spark of the Niger Delta crises was
presented in the Ijaw/Itsekiri ethnic conflicts (Imobighe et al, 2002,
Ojameruaye, 2004). Consequently, one of the first actions of former
President Olusegun Obasanjo taken on assumption of office in May
Vol. 5, No. 1
208
1999 was to send a bill to the national assembly for the establishment
of another interventionist agency called the Niger Delta Development
Commission (NDDC). The euphoria, as a roaring flame, which greeted
its establishment and inauguration in 2001 soon died down as a cold
impotent ash (Achebe, 1960) after barely two years of its operation
when the initial funding intensity gradually waned. The main task of
the NDDC at its establishment was to complete some of the abandoned
and uncompleted projects of its predecessor, OMPADEC and
necessarily embark on some new ones including, preparing a detailed
master plan for the development of the Niger Delta region. By 2003, it
appeared the NDDC had achieved some good start as its Chairman,
Albert K. Horsefall told a meeting in June 2003, of local stakeholders
in the region known as Traditional Rulers of Oil Mineral Producing
Communities of Nigeria (TROMPCON) of the modest achievement of
NDDC including its application of the 47Billion naira receipts from all
its sources to an estimated 700 contract awards of which 258 had been
completed as at the time of that meeting and the successful execution
of 40 roads projects, 90 water projects, 129 electrification projects, 47
shore protection/jetty projects, 50 health centers, 205 new block of sixschool classrooms each, among others (Ojameruaye,2004). These
figures though show some impressive record but hardly indicate the
impact the commission had had on the lives of the people especially
in poverty reduction perspective as the depth and severity of poverty
in the oil producing communities continues to manifest.
While not ignoring the fact that the NDDC (through its contract
awards and employment of local contractors and some natives into its
staff positions which has, in a positive way, negligibly impacted on
the economic and social lives of the people) has ignited some level of
consciousness and responsibility on the part of the federal government
towards the plight of the local people, the internal issues of corruption
and accountability, tepid funding and insider-politics in the
Vol. 5, No. 1
209
Vol. 5, No. 1
210
Vol. 5, No. 1
211
Vol. 5, No. 1
212
REFERENCES:
Abbide,
Vol. 5, No. 1
213
Vol. 5, No. 1
214
Ojakorotu, V. (2009) Militancy and oil violence in the Niger Delta Journal of
Energy Security, Institute for the Analysis of Global Security,
Washington: 98, August, 349.
Ojameruaye, E. (2004). Lessons from the Chadian model for the distribution of
oil wealth in Nigeria, Urhobo Historical Society. Retrieved from the
web on 12/04/2009 @ www.waado.org/Environmental/Remediation.
Omotola, J.S. (2007) From the OMPADEC to the NDDC: An Assessment of
state responses to environmental insecurity in the Niger Delta,
Nigeria
Africa Today, Indiana University Press, (54)1,Fall,pp.73-89.
Parsons, T., (1961) Theories of Society: foundations of modern sociological theory,
New York: Free Press.
Rothberg, R.L. (2004) The failure and collapse of nation states: Breakdown,
prevention and repair, In Robert L. Rothberg (Ed.) When states fail:
Causes and consequences, Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University
Press.
Ukiwo, U, (2006) Creation of local government areas and ethnic conflicts in
Nigeria: The case of Warri, Delta State, Paper presented at the CRISE
West Africa Workshop, Accra Ghana: March, 23-25.
Urien, J. O. (2009) Militancy in the Niger Delta: Its relationship to national
development, Unpublished MSc Political Science Dissertation, Delta
State University, Abraka, P.121.
World Bank (1995) as cited in FGN (2006) p.103
Vol. 5, No. 1
215
Abstract
The Niger Delta the geographical heart of oil production in
Nigeria has been a breeding ground for militants and impoverished
ethnic groups for some years now. This is because the discovery of
oil and its exploitation has ushered in a miserable, undisciplined,
decrepit, and corrupt form of petro-capitalism which produces
conflict accelerating factors. Devastated by the ecological costs of oil
spillage and the highest gas flaring rates in the world, the Niger Delta
has become a centre of violence. In an attempt to solve the Niger Delta
crisis, the Federal Government recently introduced the policy of
amnesty to militants as the solution to the Niger Delta Crisis. The
amnesty programme has been acclaimed by some persons to be a
success. Consequently this paper makes a careful study of the
amnesty Programme which is basically a disarmament,
demobilization and reintegration (DDR) Strategy for Sustainable
Peace. With the aid of secondary data and content analysis, the paper
argues that sustainable peace can only be ensured if the root causes of
violence in the Niger Delta are identified and ameliorated. In the
course of the study, it was discovered that ecological devastation and
Dr. Atare Otite and Nathaniel Umukoro are with the Department of Political
Science, Faculty of the Social Sciences at Delta State University in Abraka, Nigeria.
Dr.
Otites
e-mail
is
atareotite@yahoo.com;
Mr.
Umukoros
is
numukoro@yahoo.co.uk.
9
Introduction
The Niger Delta, an area of dense mangrove rainforest in the
southern tip of Nigeria, has been a centre of violent conflicts for some
years now. The Nigerian government like a doctor has over 50 years
tried to solve the problem in the region. During the colonial era the
Willinks Commission was set up following the agitation by the
minorities over what they saw as imbalance in the political and
economic structure of Nigeria. In 1962, the Niger Delta Development
Board (NDDB) was set up to serve in advisory capacity and provide
government with information that would lead to the alleviation of the
plight of the area in conjunction with the Development Act of 1961.
The NDDBs reports were never made public; they died with the First
Republic when the military took over power in 1966. Between 1960s
and late 1980s, nothing significant was done to solve the
environmental and developmental problems of the Niger Delta. In
1989, the military government of General Ibrahim Babangida, in an
attempt to assuage the people of the Niger Delta, set up the Oil
Minerals Producing Areas Development Commission (OMPADEC)
but failed to actualize its objectives due to wastefulness and
corruption. During the Obasanjos administration the Niger Delta
Development Commission (NDDC) was established in 2000 with the
sole mandate of developing the oil-rich Niger-Delta region of
southern Nigeria. Like OMPADEC a magnifying lens is required to
see its performance. This has made the Federal Government to create
a new ministry called Ministry of Niger Delta in 2008, to address the
Vol. 5, No. 1
217
Vol. 5, No. 1
218
Vol. 5, No. 1
219
Vol. 5, No. 1
220
Vol. 5, No. 1
221
kidnapped for ransom over the past three years. Skeptics say that,
even if commanders disarm, there is little hope to stop fighters from
finding new leaders and resuming attacks. Some residents fear they
will return to the creeks unless those who hand over their weapons
can quickly find work.
Vol. 5, No. 1
222
b.
Vol. 5, No. 1
223
Reinsertion: This addresses the most immediate needs of excombatants. Reinsertion assistance consists of short-term
relief interventions, which provide a safety net for
demobilized ex-combatants. Assistance may include housing,
Vol. 5, No. 1
224
Vol. 5, No. 1
225
Goals of DDR
The goals of DDR can be classified into two, namely:
1.
2.
Vol. 5, No. 1
226
The Amnesty Programme and the DDR Strategies for Peace in the
Niger Delta
The success of the amnesty programme and the DDR
strategies for peace in the Niger Delta depends on finding lasting
solutions to the root causes of violence in the area. A proper diagnosis
of the causes of conflict in the Niger Delta area of Nigeria requires a
tripartite dissection of conflict. These are: structural background
conditions of conflict, conflict accelerating factors and the triggers.
The structural background conditions of conflict at best only point to
the existence of conflict potential but cannot explain the actual
occurrence of a given conflict. They include; differences in ethnic
Vol. 5, No. 1
227
Vol. 5, No. 1
228
Vol. 5, No. 1
229
government and oil companies. Such claims have been in the form of
demands for compensations, increased revenue allocation to oil
producing states, provision of adequate social and economic
infrastructure, creating more job opportunities for the youths and the
demand for resource control (Onduku, 2001; Saro-wiwa, 1993).
The slow response of the political system to meet most of the
demands of the people can be related to the contradictions of the
countrys corrupt economy. The problems of rising poverty,
unemployment and environmental decay with no real solution in
sight have sown the seed of frustration in the minds of many. This
makes them susceptible to aggression and militant activities. The
quest for political redeemers or messiahs is also related to the
ubiquity of violence during periods of election.
In a nutshell, it is generally comprehended that the recurring crisis in
the Niger Delta region is the product of the deep-seated sense of
neglect and marginalization by the government and oil companies in
supporting critical human development and provision of basic social
amenities (Aboribo, and Umukoro, 2008). The situation in the Niger
Delta is indeed a paradox of poverty in the midst of plenty. In spite of
the oil wealth, the Niger Delta still remains one of the least developed
parts of Nigeria. Outside the major urban areas, the level of
infrastructural development and the provision of social amenities
such as electricity, health care and education are very poor. The state
of infrastructure in the Niger Delta made the World Bank to warn in
1995 that an urgent need exists to implement mechanism to protect
the life and health of the regions inhabitants and its ecological
systems from further deterioration (World Bank, 1995). Fourteen
years after this warning the Niger Delta still suffers from
infrastructural decay and underdevelopment (The News, 2009).
Vol. 5, No. 1
230
Even though the activities of oil companies affect the health of the
people in the rural areas, health facilities and personnel are
concentrated in the cities and the quality of health care delivery is
poor because of inadequate facilities and personnel. The people of the
Niger Delta still suffer from debilitating diseases such as malaria,
diarrhea and yellow fever (NDES, 1995). As a result of oil activities
and migration, infrastructure has come under pressure in the cities,
impacting heavily on the quality of life. Electricity supply has
degenerated to the lowest ebb. In an attempt to solve these problems
series of reports and recommendations have been made by different
committees, commissions and conferences. Huge financial resources
have also been wasted in handling the Niger Delta problem without
significant achievement basically because of corruption (Umukoro,
2008). In recent times, especially before the amnesty programme, too
much emphasis has been placed on coercive force with which to cow
the militants in search for peace. This has not yielded positive results.
Conclusion
There is an urgent need for decisive action to be taken to solve
the developmental problems in the Niger Delta area since it is the root
cause or justification of militant activities and violent conflicts in the
area. Eradication of corruption and social peace building are the keys
to ensuring sustainable development in the Niger Delta area of
Nigeria. The relative peace experienced in the Niger Delta area as a
result of the amnesty programme has major impacts on the Nigerian
economy and the potentials for the generation of adequate revenue
for development. The first major impact is that oil production has
increased. This means increase in government's revenue and
enhanced foreign exchange earnings. Benefits will also be realized in
the gas sector, particularly in the area of gas supply to power plants
for internal use. This will help to boost electricity supply which has
Vol. 5, No. 1
231
References
Aboribo, R.O. and Umukoro N. (2008) Conflict of Globalization and the
Globalization of Niger Delta Conflict in Nigerian Sociological Review,
Vol. 8
Ake, C. (1985) Political Economy of Nigeria, Lagos: Longman
Vol. 5, No. 1
232
Vol. 5, No. 1
233
Vol. 5, No. 1
234
Vol. 5, No. 1
235
Vol. 5, No. 1
236
Vol. 5, No. 1
237
Abstract
This paper interrogated the Nigerian Government amnesty
program, intended to resolve the Niger Delta conflict. The objective
was to address the frustration-aggression trap and highlight the
challenges it poses to peace-building. To achieve this, the paper was
divided into five sections, including the introduction. The first section
after the introduction examined theoretical issues of interest and
describes frustration-aggression trap as a condition where individuals
or groups cannot get out of frustration because their environment and
policies of government reinforces the blockage of goal attainment or
ignores it. The second located the context of oil related conflict in the
Niger Delta, while the third, which analyzed the challenges posed to
the amnesty program by the frustration-aggression trap, focused on
oil induced environmental degradation and corruption in governance
as elements of the trap, which has created conditions for violence, and
noted that if not addressed, it can trigger the recurrence of violence in
the region. The fourth section concluded the study and noted
environmental protection through the strengthening and enforcement
of environmental laws as one option to deal with the problem.
Further, it suggested bringing the fight against corruption into peaceIbaba Samuel Ibaba, PhD, is affiliated to the Department of Political Science,
Niger Delta University, Nigeria where he lectures Political Science and engages in
research focused on conflict analysis, peace building and development. He can be
contacted via E-mail: eminoaibaba@yahoo.com or through P.O. BOX 1529, Yenagoa,
Bayelsa State, Nigeria.
10
Introduction
Agitations in Nigerias Niger Delta dates back to the colonial
era when the fear of domination and neglect by the major ethnic
groups in the country, triggered demands for state creation, seen by
people of the Niger Delta as a guarantee for development and a shield
from ethnicity-based political domination. The colonial government
established the Willink Commission to inquire into these fears and
demands, but the Commission refused the request for state creation
which it considered inappropriate. However, having recognized the
lack of development as the key reason for the agitations, it
recommended the declaration of the region as a special area of
development, and the establishment of a board to plan its
development (Willink Commission Report, 1958:94-95).
The Nigerian government responded to this recommendation and
established the Niger Delta Development Board (NDDB) in 1961, but
the development plight of the region was not addressed as vindicated
by the 1966 Major Isaac Adaka Boro led rebellion which cited
development neglect, arising largely from ethnicity-based political
domination as the reason for the rebellion which sought to create a
Niger Delta Republic. The revolt which commenced on February 23,
1966 lasted till March 6th of the same year, when leaders of the
rebellion were taken into custody by federal troops (Tebekaemi, 1982).
At this point, the violence was not directly linked to oil, probably
because it was not yet the economic pivot of the country. But things
took a different turn when in the 1970s, oil-related conflicts erupted.
First as community agitations against Transnational Oil Companies
Vol. 5, No. 1
239
Vol. 5, No. 1
240
Vol. 5, No. 1
241
Vol. 5, No. 1
242
Vol. 5, No. 1
243
Vol. 5, No. 1
244
Vol. 5, No. 1
245
Reintegration (The
socio-economic
process of
becoming a civilian)
Processes
Collection and documentation of arms
and ammunitions from combatants
and development of arms
management program
Discharge of active combatants from
armed groups and the provision of
reinsertion (transitional assistance) in
the form of allowances to cover basic
needs, short-term education, training
and employment.
Status change process from combatant
to civilians
Vol. 5, No. 1
246
Vol. 5, No. 1
247
and schools at the site of former militant camps (NDTC, 2008: 67). The
amnesty program was therefore not imposed by the federal
government, neither is it a beneficent gift to Niger Delta militias, nor
is it an instrument of political patronage or primitive accumulation of
wealth as argued by Davidheiser and Nyiayaana ( 2010) and JoabPeterside ( 2010).
The amnesty program was proclaimed on June 25, 2009, and militias
were given a 60 day period (August 3 to October 4, 2009) to accept the
offer. Arms collection centers and withholding camps were created
across the region. At the end of the period, over 20,000 militias
disarmed and surrendered thousands of arms ammunitions, and
other weapons of war ranging from rocket launchers, KK 47 Rifles,
pump action guns, machine guns and gun boats (Okogun & Okeneye,
2009: 1-2; Joab-Peterside, 2010: 85-98).
The program has since moved on to the rehabilitation and
reintegration phase. First, the militias were sent for non-violence
training, to ensure behavior modification and equip them with
strategies for peaceful resolution of conflicts. Thereafter, they have
been sent for training in their chosen areas of economic
empowerment, including vocational skills acquisition and
entrepreneurship training. While some are trained within the country,
others were sent to South Africa and Ghana. The federal government
has also stepped up efforts in providing social infrastructure,
although the noticeable project in this area thus far, is the accelerated
construction of the East-West road2
The East-West Road is the major road that connects the Niger Delta states.
Importantly too, it is the major link between the Niger Delta and other parts
of Nigeria. This makes it an important road for communication and the
2
Vol. 5, No. 1
248
It is discernible from the above that the amnesty program has the
essential features of DDR. The report of the NDTC which was based
on wide consultation with stake holders, and the consultations and
negotiations between opinion and political leaders of the Niger Delta
and the militia groups which preceded the commencement of the
amnesty program can be termed in context as Pre-DDR negotiations.
Importantly also, militia leaders who accepted the amnesty held
meetings with the late president of the country, Alhaji Umaru Musa
Yaradua, to clear doubts, build trust, express demands, make
guarantees, and clarify intentions (Ikelegbe, 2010:11).The
disarmament and demobilization of militias, the sub-sequent closure
of their camps, and the on-going rehabilitation and reintegration
process are also indications of the DDR strategy for peace-building.
Thus far, the program has restored peace; the militias have left the
creeks, attacks on oil infrastructure and oil company personnel have
stopped, and oil production has been restored to normal level of
about 2.3 million barrels per day (AIT, 2010). The possible recurrence
of violence is however a major concern.
(c) Conflict and Peace-Building
Conflict necessitates peace-building, which seeks to secure peace
through conflict prevention, resolution and management (World
Bank, 2006; Ibeanu, 2006; Francis, 2006; Best, 2007). This is however
enhanced by knowledge of the motives for conflict and peculiarities of
particular conflict systems (Bassey, 2002). Conflict prevention requires
the identification and containment of possible conflict drivers before
they trigger conflicts. In contrast, conflict resolution intervenes to
change or facilitate the course of a conflict. This is also seen as part of
evacuation of petroleum products from the Niger Delta to other areas in
Nigeria.
Vol. 5, No. 1
249
Vol. 5, No. 1
250
Staring points
Decision making
authority
Outcome of
intervention
Focus of
intervention
Number of
outcome
Number of
parties required
for occurrence
of intervention
Parties influence
over identified
third party
Types of Intervention
Adjudication
Arbitration
Judge
Arbiter
Mediation
Disputants
Binding
Binding
Non binding
Law based
outcome
Law based
outcome
Win-lose
Win-lose
One
All
Management and
pragmatic
outcome
Win-Win
(Compromise)
All
No
Yes
Yes
Vol. 5, No. 1
251
Vol. 5, No. 1
252
Year
1958
1959
1960
1961
1962
1963
1964
1965
1966
1967
Vol.
of
Prod.
In
mbpd.
1.9
4.1
6.4
16.4
24.6
27.9
44.0
99.4
152.4
116.6
Year
1968
1969
1970
1971
1972
1973
1974
1975
1976
1977
Vol.
of
Prod.
In
mbpd.
51.9
196.3
395.8
558.7
655.3
719.4
823.3
660.1
758.1
766.1
Year
1978
1979
1980
1981
1982
1983
1984
1985
1986
1987
Vol.
of
Prod.
In
mbpd.
696.3
845.5
760.1
525.5
470.6
450.9
507.5
547.1
535.9
482.9
Year
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
Vol.
of
Prod.
In
mbpd.
529.0
626.7
660.6
689.9
711.3
695.4
696.2
715.4
681.9
855.0
Year
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
Vol. of
Prod.
In
mbpd.
806.4
774.7
828.3
859.6
725.9
844.1
900.0
923.5
814.0
880.0
Conflicts between the oil producing communities and the TOCs robed
off on inter-community and intra-community conflicts which became
worse with competition over benefits of the oil industry such as
employment, location of project, award of contracts, naming of oil
facilities such well sites, flow stations and manifolds. Further, the use
of security operatives (in particular the anti-riot police squad or
Mobile Police and the Army) by TOCs to protect their facilities and
the suppression of protests by communities pitched the communities
against the security operatives in the 1980s, setting the stage for
violent confrontation between the communities and security agencies.
Vol. 5, No. 1
253
Vol. 5, No. 1
254
Inter community
conflicts
Community against
state
Inter-ethnic
Intra-militia/cult/
confraternity groups
Inter-militia/cult/
confraternity groups
Vol. 5, No. 1
255
Vol. 5, No. 1
256
Vol. 5, No. 1
257
Vol. 5, No. 1
258
Vol. 5, No. 1
259
Vol. 5, No. 1
260
national level where the Central Bank Governor alleged in 2010 that
the National Assembly alone gulped 25% of federal government
overhead budget for 2010.
The implication of this pattern of expenditure is twofold. First, it
encourages corruption, as demonstrated by the many allegations of
corruption against past and present public office holders by the two
prominent anti graft agencies in the country; the Economic and
Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) and the Independent Corrupt
Practices Commission (ICPC). Attempts have been made to deal with
this problem, and perhaps the most celebrated was the 2005 arrest in
London, of former Bayelsa State Governor, Chief D.S.P
Alamieyeseigha for money laundering and related practices involving
hundreds of millions of United States Dollars. Chief Alamieyeseigha,
who was alleged to have escaped from London, was later convicted
by a Nigerian High Court in 2007. Other examples include the
conviction of former Edo State Governor, Chief Lucky Igbinedion for
misappropriation of State funds. Former Delta State Governor, Chief
James Ibori, is facing similar charges. The conviction of Chief Olabode
George, a chieftain of the ruling Peoples Democratic Party and its
former deputy national chairman for the South-West zone3 (PDP) is
also a case in point.
Although information on the actual sum of money stolen by public
office holders in the country is sketchy, one estimate put it about $380
Nigeria is divided into six geo-political zones comprising five to seven
states: South-West ( Lagos, Ogun, Ondo, Osun, Ekiti and Oyo States); SouthEast ( Anambra, Ebonyi, Enugu, Abia and Imo States); South-South ( Bayelsa,
Akwa-Ibom, Delta, Edo, Croos River and Rivers States); North West (
Jigawa, Kaduna, Kano, Katsina, Kebbi, Sokoto and Zamfara States.); NorthEast ( Adamawa, Bauchi, Borno, Gombe, Taraba and Yobe States); and NorthCentral ( Benue, Kogi, Kewara, Nasarawa, Niger, Plateau and the Federal
Capital Territory-Abuja)
3
Vol. 5, No. 1
261
billion between 1960 and 1999 (HRW, 2007:16). It has also been
estimated that $14 billion was stolen in 2003 alone (Ejibunu, 2007: 18),
while about $12 billion oil wind fall monies are alleged to have
disappeared between 1958 and 1993(HRW, 2007:16). This leads us to
the second point. Due to corruption, only a small fraction of budgeted
funds trickle down to the poor. This deprives the people adequate
funds for infrastructure development and provision of social
amenities and services. The socio-demographic data of the Niger
Delta indicates low life expectancy, high maternal and infant deaths,
and limited access to education, health and clean water, among
others.
It is imperative to note that state agencies such as the Oil Minerals
Producing Areas Development Commission ( OMPADEC), and the
Niger Delta Development Commission ( NDDC), established by the
Nigerian Government to intervene in the development of the region
have been also noted for corruption( Omotola, 2010), which
undermined their mandate to ameliorate the development plight
which underlies the violence. Similarly, corruption has been identified
as one of the reasons responsible for the failure of TOCs community
development programs to impact significantly on the living standards
of the people (Okoko, 1998; Ibaba, 2005).Here, the frustrations which
have resulted in agitations, protests and insurgency, is linked to the
poor state of infrastructure and quality of living in the region, despite
the huge oil revenue generated by the country 4, the billions of United
It has been reported that Nigeria has earned over $600 billion from oil
exports in the last 50 years (EFCC, 2010). Despite this, the country generates
just about 3000 megawatts of electricity for a population of over 150 million.
None of its over a 100 universities is ranked among the best 5000 universities
in the world, while only five of its universities are among the best 100
universities in Africa. Road infrastructure is very poor, the health sector is in a
4
Vol. 5, No. 1
262
sorry state, while the public school system at the primary and post-primary
levels are in comatose.
5 In Nigeria, national revenue is collected and paid into a common purse
called the Federation Account. On a monthly basis, revenue is shared from
this account on the basis of population, social development factor, equality of
states, land mass/ territory and derivation. Derivation takes 13% of allocation
and goes to the oil mineral producing states and local governments in the
Niger Delta as oil derivation fund. The remainder is shared as statutory
revenue among the federal government, the 36 states and Abuja, the federal
capital territory, and the 774 local government councils. Available data
indicates that the Niger Delta States have received huge revenues since 2000
due to the increase in the oil derivation fund from 3% to 13% in 2000. For
example in the first 11 months of 2008, the Niger Delta States received $4
billion out of a total of $11 billion allocated to the 36 states of the federation (
monthly figures collected from www.fmf.gov.ng, and then added up to give
annual total)
Vol. 5, No. 1
263
Vol. 5, No. 1
264
Oil spillages are industry based and also caused by sabotage. The
regulatory bodies in the country such as the Directorate of Petroleum
Resources (DPR) have a crucial role to play.
One major cause of lawlessness in Nigeria is the culture of impunity.
Thus enforcement of environment laws and placement of adequate
sanctions on TOCs is a sure way to elicit compliance and thus protect
the environment. Sabotage spills can be contained by responding to
the development challenges of the people, in addition to enforcing the
relevant laws dealing with sabotage as an economic crime. This will
address the causes of sabotage as engagement strategy of protesting
communities and groups, and as a form of business involving a
network of community youths and leaders, contractors to TOCs and
officials of TOCs and oil theft syndicates. Related to this is the need to
pursue the gas flare out policy of the government with uncommon
commitment. The development of gas utilization infrastructure will
create conditions to support the TOCs to end gas flaring. The
completion of the West Africa and Trans-Sahara gas projects6, gas
related power generation projects in the country can be considered in
this regard. This suggests that the resolution of the frustrationaggression trap, and by extension the Niger Delta conflict, requires an
integrated and holistic approach. The amnesty program is defective in
this regard, as it has isolated the ex-combatants for attention, while
neglecting other segments of the population. Further, the
rehabilitation program is disconnected from the national economy
The West African gas project is expected to convey about 450 cubic meters of
gas to Ghana, Togo and Benin Republic Annually on completion (Nigeria,
Country Briefs, 2009). Similarly, the Trans-Sahara gas projected is expected to
supply about 20 billion cubic meters of gas per annum to Europe by 2016
when completed ( Afrik-News, 2010)
6
Vol. 5, No. 1
265
Vol. 5, No. 1
266
Vol. 5, No. 1
267
Ejibunu, H.T (2007), Nigerias Niger Delta: Root Causes of Peacelessnes, EPU
(European University Center for Peace Studies, Austria), Research
Papers, Issue No. 7.
Faleti, S. A. (2006), Theories of Social Conflict, in Best, S.G ( eds), Introduction
to Peace and Conflict Studies in West Africa: A Reader, Spectrum Books
Limited, Ibadan, Nigeria, pp.35-60.
Francis, D. J. (2006), Peace and Conflict Studies: An African Overview of Basic
Concepts in Best, S.G. (eds), Introduction to Peace and Conflict Studies
in West Africa: A Reader, Spectrum.
Godongs, S. (2006), The Methods of Conflict Resolution and Transformation,
in Best, S.G ( eds), Introduction to Peace and Conflict Studies in West
Africa: A Reader, Spectrum Books Limited, Ibadan, Nigeria, pp. 93-115.
Gurr, Ted, ( 1968), Psychological Factors in Civil Violence, World Politics, Vol.
20, No. 2, pp.245-278.
HRW ( Human Rights Watch)( 2007), Chop Fine: The Human Rights Impact
of Local Government Corruption and Mismanagement in Rivers State,
Nigeria, Report, Volume 19, No. 2 ( A).
Humphreys, M. Weinstein, J.M. (2007) Journal of Conflict Resolution, Vol. 51
No 4, pp. 531-567.
Ibaba, S.I. (2005), Understanding the Niger Delta Crisis, Amethyst and
Colleagues Publishers, Port Harcourt, Nigeria.
Ibaba, S.I. (2009), Civil Society Organizations, Democracy and Peace Building
in the Niger Delta, International Journal of Nigerian Studies and
Development, Vol. 15, 32-49.
Ibaba, S.I. and Ikelebge, (2009) A. Militias and Pirates in the Niger Delta,
Paper Presented at Institute of Security Studies (ISS) South African,
Workshop on Militia and Rebel Movements Human Insecurity and
State Crisis in Africa, Pretoria, South Africa, April 20-21, 2009.
Ibeanu, O. (2006), Conceptualizing Peace, in Best, S.g. (ed) Introduction to
Peace and Conflict Studies in West Africa: A Reader, Spectrum Books
Limited, Ibadan, Nigeria, pp.3-14.
Ikelegbe, A, 2010, Resolving the Niger Delta Conflict: A Critical and
Comparative Analysis of The Amnesty and Post Amnesty Challenges,
paper presented at the International
Conference on Natural
Resource, Security and Development in the Niger Delta, Organized by
Vol. 5, No. 1
268
Vol. 5, No. 1
269
Vol. 5, No. 1
270
Vol. 5, No. 1
271
Abstract
For centuries the Western classics of the social sciences have
helped to justify the decisions of business entrepreneurs and
development practitioners in developing country contexts like
Nigeria. These classical lessons are not devoid of merit but tend to
promote a very one-sided pro-entrepreneur approach to development
that systematically marginalizes the concerns of exploited regions of
the world, like the Niger Delta Region (NDR). Instead of accepting
responsibility for the turmoil that external actors have caused within
the NDR, the institutional norm in both the international oil industry
and the international development industry is to squarely point
fingers at Nigerias internal shortcomings, as if all of these growing
problems are due to Nigerian failings and solely for Nigerians to
11
The Problem
Today there can be little doubt that the Niger Delta Region
(NDR) is under tremendous developmental strain; to include
environmental degradation, relocation of peoples, affronts to cultural
ways of life, and a sudden rise of violent conflict.
NDRs
immiseration truly began, as so many people from the region have
commented, with the lighting of the oil companys first gas flares in
1958; since then, the gas flares have been continuously burning. And
since that time external actors, colluding with Nigerian politicians,
have been vigorously pursuing crude oil exploration and extraction
with virtual impunity.
In recent years Nigerias Economic and Financial Crime Commission
(EFCC), formally established in 2003, has duly filed charges of bribery
and conspiracy against individuals (a list of Most Wanted is
regularly posted on their web-page) and international oil companies
Vol. 5, No. 1
273
Major oil companies include, e.g., Royal Dutch Shell, Halliburton and its
subsidiary Kellogg, Brown & Root. See: http://www.efccnigeria.org/
(Accessed February 2011).
2 BBC on-line, Dec. 7, 2010, Nigeria Files Charges Against Cheney,
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-11943192 (Accessed February 2011).
3 Cited in Wall Street Journal, Commentary and news about money
laundering, bribery, terrorism finance and sanctions, Nov. 4, 2010. Posted at:
http://royaldutchshellplc.com/2010/11/06/panalpina-settlements-announcedwith-236-5-million-in-penalties/ (Accessed February 2011).
Vol. 5, No. 1
274
The fundamental reason why these and other oil company crimes
were allowed to occur is that Nigerian institutions civil, state, and
other are not able to ward-off these joint venture (oil companies
colluding with Nigerian politicians) abuses of power. The same kind
of institutional weakness that leads to those and other forms of
corruption is, ironically, again found when the Nigerian state
attempts to enforce punishment. Knowing that local enforcement is
virtually impossible, the EFCC is left negotiating for and taking
anything it can get its hand on. From beginning to end, then, one sees
a pattern of abusing the privilege of power and of taking advantage of
Nigerias low institutional capacity.
Of course, similar forms of corruption and enforcement challenges
have been experienced elsewhere in the world. However, when one
considers the now global pattern of avoiding jail time through
payment of fines or other, with virtually no institutional change,
Nigeria certainly appears to be one of the worlds worst. Joshua E.
Keating of Foreign Affairs does not mince his words when he describes
circumstances there:
Nigerias oil sector is plagued by corruption and willful
ignorance... One watchdog group put the discrepancies in
the Nigeria Central Banks oil earnings figures at [only]
around $155 million for 2005. With Western oil majors
heavily invested in the Niger Delta, theres suspicion that
those companies are extracting more than theyre reporting.4
Vol. 5, No. 1
275
natural resource curse. The concept, first noted in the 1980s, is quite
simple: a small number of local elites, working with external
entrepreneurs, manage to tap into and disproportionately benefit
from the profits that result from natural resource extraction.
Accordingly, receipts from the sale of valuable resources like oil
that states like Nigeria have are squandered with no visible
improvement in economic development. In the Nigerian context,
since 1958, $billions of oil revenues have been misused or have
disappeared entirely. Moreover, the global demand for oil tends to
impact foreign exchange rates, thereby squeezing out the
competitiveness of other traditional exports such as agriculture and
manufactured goods.5 Before the 1950s, a great many agricultural and
other products were exported from Nigerias ports; today 85% of the
countrys foreign exchange earnings come from oil and gas. Nigeria
has therefore followed in the developing state pattern of having a
mono-crop economy that caters to the needs of external actors and
resists economic diversity.
In addition to the many adverse
consequences of having foreign oil interests dictate Nigerias
developmental future, then, is the added danger of having the entire
economy dependent on the sometimes volatile world price of oil.
An oft-cited and influential 1997 study on the natural resource
curse, by Jeffrey Sachs and Andrew Warner, considers data from
eight slow-growing oil-exporting states.6
What they find
Vol. 5, No. 1
276
Black Gold: Hope and Betrayal in the Niger Delta, National Geographic
Magazine, (February 2007), available on-line at:
http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/2007/02/nigerian-oil/oneill-text (Accessed
February 2011).
7 The doctrine of comparative advantage is normally identified as one of the
theoretical foundations of international political economy in textbooks on
the subject. See, e.g., Frederic Pearson and Simon Payaslian, International
Political Economy, (McGraw-Hill, 1999), Part I.
8 Sachs and Warner (1997).
Vol. 5, No. 1
277
Vol. 5, No. 1
278
10
See, e.g., Karen Armstrong, The Great Transformation: The World in the Times
of Buddha, Socrates, Confucius and Jeremiah, (London: Atlantic Books, 2006);
Joseph Campbells 4-vol. series The Masks of God; and Jon R. Stone, ed., The
Essential Max Mller: On Language, Mythology, and Religion (Palgrave
Macmillan, 2002).
11 A term that is similarly employed by Armstrong (2006), in her comparative
survey of religion.
Vol. 5, No. 1
279
12
Vol. 5, No. 1
280
15
Vol. 5, No. 1
281
When considering the dismal state of affairs in the NDR, it is hard not
to conclude that the epistemological and developmental politics
battles, of which Ake and Amin speak, may be lost. But there are
reasons for hope. Since these authors aforementioned publications
there has been a groundswell of support, found throughout the world,
for the view that does there exist a profound gap in global scholarship
that systematically marginalizes the post-colonial non-West and/or
subaltern conditions and views. 18 Of course there is still much work
to do: Western-based philosophies, so readily found throughout the
world, still dominate and, in many ways, are perceived as the
language of power. Unless and until that Foucauldian problem is
adequately addressed, the self-righteous attitudes of those involved in
all forms of developmental politics will continue to foment the
recurring patterns of Nigerian politics that consistently marginalize
the needs of the NDR. What, then, are those external actors thinking?
What are the concerns of Ake, expressed in his 1979 book, that still
have an impact to this day?
For starters, among external actors, there is an underlying conviction,
informed by the classics and confirmed by scientific certitude, that
leads to a preference for clarity over the more nuanced explanations
as to why things might be going wrong in places like the NDR.
Conviction and clarity were, of course, hallmarks of the colonial era
but, for many, they remained in a very ideological form, throughout
the Cold War. And although the Cold War is now over, these
ideological sentiments of absolute certainty linger. At a most basic
level there remains methodological resistance, for example, to the
18
See, e.g., Ranajit Guha, Subaltern Studies, Vols. 1-X, (Oxford University
Press, 2010); Robbie Shilliam, ed., International Relations and Non-Western
Thought: Imperialism, Colonialism and Investigations of Global Modernity,
(Routledge, 2011).
Vol. 5, No. 1
282
intertwining of the political and the economic which, for many external
actors, has a whiff of Marxist logic.
It was Marx, after all, who famously argued that differences of
material wealth or class translated into rifts in politics. And one
still finds the development practitioners kneejerk reaction is to reject
economic explanations of Africas political problems.
Economic
growth requires, as liberal economists like Sachs would have it, the
identification of a states comparative advantage, that is, there are
economic laws that resolve economic problems. Similarly, drawing
on the lessons of Western political theory, the mainstream
development practitioner assumes that all democratic theories have,
as part of their virtue, clarity, viz: political solutions to political
problems. The influential political realist Hans Morgenthau suggests,
for example, that intellectually *he+ maintains the autonomy of the
political sphere, as the economist, the lawyer, the moralist maintain
theirs.19
Now it must be acknowledged that not all development practitioners
necessarily agree with Morgenthaus autonomy of the political
sphere argument. But it cannot be denied that the Cartesian-like
compartmentalization of developmental problems is very prevalent in
both Western education and developmental politics. Within the social
sciences
one
sees
a
very
strong
tendency
toward
compartmentalization of the studies of, e.g., anthropology, history,
politics, economics, psychology, and so on. And, the corollary to that
is found in the organizational structure of virtually all modern
19
Hans J. Morgenthau, Politics Among Nations, 5th Ed. Rev., (Alfred A. Knopf,
1973), p. 12. Morgenthau continues: <the economist thinks in terms of
interest defined as wealth; the lawyer, of the conformity of action with certain
rules; the moralist, of the conformity of action with moral principles.
Vol. 5, No. 1
283
20
Vol. 5, No. 1
284
21
Adam Smith, The Weath of Nations (1776), (The Modern Library, 1937), p.
532. Emphasis mine.
22 Ake (1979) emphasizes this very point.
23 John Locke, Two Treatises on Government (1690).
Vol. 5, No. 1
285
24
Edward Said, Imperialism and Culture (1993), p. xx. Saids tone is of course
cynical but his comments do, nevertheless, describe important and ongoing
changes in the dynamics between the West and the Rest.
Vol. 5, No. 1
286
Vol. 5, No. 1
287
cultures and political solutions.25 But again all of these classic texts
are filled with surprises if one is to read them carefully. Notably, as a
growing number of post-colonial writers have emphasized, these
Enlightenment thinkers comments on race look odd to the modern
21st-century reader. 26 Moreover, though radical for their time, they
were far from being protagonists of some form of liberal hedonism;
their carefully crafted texts never argued for unrestricted individual
freedoms, as some libertarians and neoliberal ideologues might argue
today, but for various forms of liberal social contract. 27 Rousseaus
argument for shared liberty, for example, emphasized the notion of
citizen responsibility, that is, the citoyen (citizen) was not only
responsible for himself but encumbered with civil responsibilities to
the rest of society. The opening line of his Social Contract (1762) is
regularly cited in this regard: Man is born free yet everywhere is in
chains.28
In other words, even these famous proponents of
democratic liberalism understood that there were purposeful
constraints on unbounded freedoms; to argue otherwise, in their
25
Vol. 5, No. 1
288
Vol. 5, No. 1
289
31
Ibid, p. 76.
James Madison, Federalist No. 51, in The Federalist Papers (1789), (Mentor
Books, 1999), p. 292.
33 Ibid.
32
Vol. 5, No. 1
290
Vol. 5, No. 1
291
35
Vol. 5, No. 1
292
number of Western capitalists are clearly in full allegiance with nondemocratic power-seeking Africans.
It is the discourses of power then, as Antonio Gramsci might have
argued, that need to be challenged. And we find these in academia,
heralding the language of power, just as we find them in the oil
industry and in politics. In fact, while the Western classics remain
influential to many external actors mindsets, virtually any Western
textbook on African politics, specifically, will readily emphasize the
continents colonial legacy and, upon reflection, the emphasis on
external influences on African development is now part-and-parcel of
the entire subject. Claude Ake was right to say that social science has
been imperialistic; what still needs to be achieved is the forging of
critically-minded alliances or of a viable counter hegemony as
Gramsci would have it. In the post-cold war era these alliances will
not be ideologically based; in fact their purpose should be to counter
remaining ideological clarity in the world.
Admittedly, a Western-centric solution to this problem will be
challenging in many ways as it would be in direct contrast with the
aforementioned lessons of the founding democratic classics which, as
we said, emphasize the importance of internal (domestic) solutions to
the potential abuse of power. Within the West, as elsewhere, there
remains a Foucauldian problem that needs to be challenged; one of
the best ways of addressing the problem may be to forge global
alliances, which include Western participants, with critical and
informed subaltern voices. As stated, the founding of North
American and European democracies did not take place with
anywhere near as much external influence and pressure as African
states have endured. But this fact can be readily shared and openly
discussed in ways that demonstrate mutual understanding of the
problem and a mutual concern for solutions. Of course, this still
Vol. 5, No. 1
293
Vol. 5, No. 1
294
Throughout the Cold War, and to this day, African state development
has taken place in an atmosphere of raging debates as to which
approach is best. Based on Huntingtons ideal of celebrating the freeand-open debate of (Western democratic) ideas, we can understand
why this is the case: methodologically, this should eventually lead to
better ideas and policies. But to date those debates have been
dominated by the prevailing thoughts of external actors. And as that
scientific process or debate rages on, one can only wonder in the
interim: at what human cost?
In many ways, from the colonial era to present, external actors have
been very consistent in their policies towards Africa in at least three
ways. First, foreign state policies have always emphasized the pursuit
of national interest. Of course, this was the case during the colonial
and imperial eras but still remains the case to this day, as most
recently demonstrated by Frances intervention in both the Ivory
Coast and Libya, i.e. colonial ties remain strong. Second, external
actors economic policies have been consistently justified by the
pursuit of profit a tricky matter that often overlaps with the priorities
of the state. Third, development policies toward Africa have
consistently emphasized the internal change of African states. This
latter point is crucially significant as it remains the fall-back position
of so many external actors and can be demonstrated as follows:
38
Jeffrey Sachs, Growth in Africa: It Can Be Done, The Economist, (June 29,
1996), p. 19.
Vol. 5, No. 1
295
Table 1
Internal vs. External Focus on Reasons for Developmental Woes
FOCUS
Political
Orientation
Developmental
Agenda
INTERNAL
(pushed for by Western/
External Participants)
Left
Right
(Liberal)
(Conservative)
EXTERNAL
(emphasis of many Local/
Internal Participants)
Left
Right
(Marxist(Local
Leninist)
Beneficiaries)
Civil Society
Leadership
Colonialism
Power
Community
Governance
Capitalist
Exploitation
JointVentures
Education
Policy
Cold War
Non-Demo.
Government
Empowerment
Corruption
International
Finance
Multinational
Corporations
Vol. 5, No. 1
296
Vol. 5, No. 1
297
Vol. 5, No. 1
298
Vol. 5, No. 1
299
43
Dambisa Moyo, Dead Aid: Why Aid Is Not Working and How There Is A Better
Way for Africa, (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2009), p. 144.
44 Ibid, p. 114.
Vol. 5, No. 1
300
Ibid.
Vol. 5, No. 1
301
Vol. 5, No. 1
302
Vol. 5, No. 1
303
had the terrorist attack there. Bush in Japan on Six Nation Asia Tour,
CNN.com, October 17, 2003. See also Rices comments at Bush Departs for
Asian Tour, Cox News Service, October 14, 2003. (Originally accessed in
October 2003.)
48 The National Security Strategy of the United States of America, May
2010, p. 33.
Vol. 5, No. 1
304
Table 2
Official Development Assistance (ODA) of the U.S. as a % of GNP
vs. selected OECD states
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
Belgium
0.88
0.48
0.50
0.46
0.36
Denmark
0.09
0.38
0.74
0.94
1.06
France
1.38
0.65
0.63
0.60
0.32
Germany
0.31
0.32
0.44
0.42
0.27
Netherlands
0.31
0.63
0.97
0.92
0.84
Norway
0.11
0.33
0.87
1.17
0.80
Sweden
0.05
0.37
0.78
0.91
0.80
United Kingdom
0.56
0.37
0.35
0.27
0.32
United States
0.53
0.31
0.27
0.21
0.10
2009
0.55
0.88
0.47
0.35
0.82
1.06
1.12
0.52
0.21
Source: Theodore Cohn, Global Political Economy, 3rd Ed. (2005), p. 366;
http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/42/30/44285539.gif (Accessed February 2011).
Vol. 5, No. 1
305
In recent years then, the US has made dramatic changes to its aid
policy and ODA statistics. During the cold war aid might have been
politically justified by national interest and defeating Communism;
today aid is targeted toward areas of broader security concern.
Moreover, assistance to areas where the US has been engaged in war
Vol. 5, No. 1
306
49
This is likely due to the increased use of extra-military contractors that are
not counted as direct military expenditure.
50 As a brief visit to http://www.oecd.org will attest.
51 Hillary Clinton, Remarks on Development in the 21 st-Century made to
the Center for Global Development, Washington, D.C., January 6, 2010. Text
available at: http://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2010/01/134838.htm (Accessed
February 2011).
Vol. 5, No. 1
307
Conclusion
Responsibility for the ongoing plight of the entire Niger Delta
Region extends well beyond Nigerias borders. External actors have
dramatically impacted the patterns of Nigerian development and
politicking and they, as we all know, have largely marginalized the
Vol. 5, No. 1
308
interests of the NDR. Today too many Africanists are too quick to
explain away the regions problems solely in terms of tribal
identities but that ethnic focus speaks only to the superficial surface of
Nigerian political behavior while systematically ignoring some of the
underlying reasons why local politicians and others resort to
tribalism. Throughout history men all over the world have used
tribalism as a means for achieving the end of maintaining power.
There are solutions and the Western classics do not necessarily have a
monopoly on what those solutions are. Indeed, the best ways to
ward-off the abuses of power are democratic but let us not forget that
external actors have heretofore destroyed indigenous checks-andbalances and, of course, much else. Moreover, the democratic
challenges a developing West might have had pale in comparison to
what developing states like Nigeria now face; globally significant and
dramatic flows of capital, peoples, and resources now impact Nigeria
in countless ways that, tragically, the world is just beginning to
understand. Hopefully the worlds mutual interest in security and
development, as described here, will soon lead to a better
developmental reality for the people of the NDR and all of Nigeria.
Here it is argued that much can be achieved through global alliances
of critically informed scholars and practitioners who, in the end, can
have a substantive impact on the actions of those involved in all forms
of development activity.
And, when it comes to the resource curse phenomenon described
by Sachs and Warner, and later popularized by Thomas L. Friedman,
there is good news: Economists C.N. Brunnschweiler and E.H. Bulte
published a 2008 article in Science with opposite conclusions:
The last word in the resource curse debate is far from having
been spoken; but economic advisors should be aware that
natural resources do not necessarily spell doom for
Vol. 5, No. 1
309
Of course they are right. Unlike the Sachs and Warner study, their
data consider a broader spectrum of resource-rich countries; since
then, a good many experts have compared African crises, and the
Nigerian case specifically, with resource-rich countries that are faring
much better. Countries in the North Sea region, notably Norway,
have now managed to hold on to a very sizable $300 billion,
expected to grow to $900 billion in a decade portion of their oil and
gas revenues.53
Yet critics remain. John Ghazvinian, author of Untapped: The Scramble
for Africas Oil (2007), investigates the prospect of employing a
Norwegian model in African contexts and concludes that the
challenges in oil-rich nations like Nigeria are simply too vast. His
words are blunt and even offensive: People in the Niger Delta live
almost as if its the Stone Age. They live in stick huts on little islands
in the mangrove swamps< Nearby, you will have these multibillion
oil facilities, with executives being dropped in by helicopter. 54 Yet
Ghazvinian is describing a developmental reality that Moyo similarly
describes: impoverishment, social and environmental degradation,
alongside clear evidence of vast wealth. Cynical and depressing, for
certain, but literature of the kind is encouraging in the sense that it is
52
Vol. 5, No. 1
310
Writers like Ross feel obligated to research such statistics if only to ask
this simple question: Why has Nigerias remarkable oil wealth done
so little to raise incomes and alleviate poverty? 57 The answers are
becoming quite obvious but Ross is undoubtedly aware of the
ideological stance of those involved in development and, of course,
the self-righteous stance of so many in the oil industry. He is
therefore compelled to go through the bother of citing statistics. But
he does, eventually, get to the heart of the matter as he assuredly aims
to do. In a more recent publication, Ross concludes that the oil
industry:
Often wreaks havoc on a countrys economy and politics,
helps fund insurgents, and aggravates ethnic grievances.
55
Vol. 5, No. 1
311
Michael L. Ross, Why Oil Wealth Fuels Conflict, Foreign Affairs, May/June
2008.
59 Basil Davidson, Modern Africa: A Social and Political History, 3rd Ed.,
(Longman, 1994).
60 Douglas A. Yates, The French Oil Industry: And the Corps des Mines in Africa,
(Africa World Press, 2009).
61 See, e.g., Carlene J. Edie, Politics in Africa: A New Beginning? (Wadsworth,
2003), pp. 76-78.
Vol. 5, No. 1
312
Vol. 5, No. 1
313
1.
Vol. 5, No. 1
314
Vol. 5, No. 1
315
2.
Vol. 5, No. 1
316
63
Vol. 5, No. 1
317
4.
Vol. 5, No. 1
318