0 оценок0% нашли этот документ полезным (0 голосов)
790 просмотров2 страницы
Google struggled to reconcile its core value of not being evil with China's regulatory requirement for censorship. It initially complied by censoring some search results but not all, hoping for compromise. However, China continued to demand more censorship. Facing a hard choice between access to the Chinese market or compromising its principles, Google ultimately chose to remove its search services from China in 2010. Microsoft took a different approach of fully complying with Chinese laws to successfully operate in the country. Cultural differences also contributed, as Western companies' individualistic approaches conflicted with China's collectivist culture that values relationships and national interests over open information.
Google struggled to reconcile its core value of not being evil with China's regulatory requirement for censorship. It initially complied by censoring some search results but not all, hoping for compromise. However, China continued to demand more censorship. Facing a hard choice between access to the Chinese market or compromising its principles, Google ultimately chose to remove its search services from China in 2010. Microsoft took a different approach of fully complying with Chinese laws to successfully operate in the country. Cultural differences also contributed, as Western companies' individualistic approaches conflicted with China's collectivist culture that values relationships and national interests over open information.
Google struggled to reconcile its core value of not being evil with China's regulatory requirement for censorship. It initially complied by censoring some search results but not all, hoping for compromise. However, China continued to demand more censorship. Facing a hard choice between access to the Chinese market or compromising its principles, Google ultimately chose to remove its search services from China in 2010. Microsoft took a different approach of fully complying with Chinese laws to successfully operate in the country. Cultural differences also contributed, as Western companies' individualistic approaches conflicted with China's collectivist culture that values relationships and national interests over open information.
Hamilton, S, Zhang, J 2011, Doing Business with China: Avoiding the
Pitfalls, 1st edition, Palgrave Macmillan, Great Britain
Google sees itself as a different kind of company, one that makes its own way and refuses convention almost on principle (page 13) Microsofts took a different approach that was successful in breaking the Chinese market Microsoft respects and follows laws and regulations in every country where we run business. We operate in China in a manner that both respects local authority and culture and makes clear that we have differences of opinion with official content-management policies. (page 13) Harmony is deeply rooted in the Chinese culture, and is essential to successful partnerships in China. Yet, few Western companies have realized its importance. Some appear to have achieved certain level of peaceful coexistence with their Chinese partners, but most have faced troubles, which first appeared only as the top of the iceberg. (page 13) Googles slogan Dont be Evil. They (Google) cant afford to not be in China. They are facing a hard choice. They really dont want to be seen as doing something that is evil, but no one goes into China on their own terms. Google failed to reconcile the regulatory requirement for censorship with its core value Dont be evil. Ever since googles formation it had been uncensored and available to internet users worldwide. (pg. 7) Levy, S 2011, Google and its Ordeal in China, Fortune, Volume 163, Issue 6 After the employee's departure, Google chose a three-person government relations team, all female, led by Julie Zhu, an energetic woman in her thirties. She was hired straight from a government ministry, instead of the commercial sector with its backscratching culture. Zhu was better able to communicate with Mountain View. But she had her hands full fending off Chinese government directives. A demand would come from a government ministry to take down 10 items; Google would typically take down seven and hope that the compromise resolved the matter. Sometimes after a few days or weeks Google would quietly restore links it had censored. Every five months Google's policy-review committee in China would meet to make sure it was filtering the minimum it could possibly get away with. It was, as Google China engineering director Jun Liu put it, "trench warfare," but he believed that Google's continuing problems were proof that it was indeed moving the democracy needle in China.
EU SME Centre 2013, Negotiating and dealing with Chinese Business
Partners, brochure, EU SME Centre, Beijing, [Westerners] tend to be more individualistic, whereas Chinese are move collectivist, Europeans are more information oriented or fact oriented, while Chinese focus on relationships thus resulting in censorship to promote and maintain nationalism. Westerners will have an impatient and aggressive means of negotiation and persuasion, whilst Chinese will have an enduring means of persuasion. Westerners are focused on myopic, short term deals, whilst Chinese are about forging a long term relationship. Being aware of, understanding and working with such [cultural] differences will allow you to make the most out of your partnerships, whereas trying to do it your own way and thus going against the culture will be a difficult undertaking. Keeping face is extremely important in china. Chinese people dont like to expose their problems to the outside world. They are guided by the principle of turning big problems into smaller problems.
Tian, X 2007, Managing International Business in China, 1st edition,
Cambridge University Press Chinese negotiators tend to start negotiation on a few general principles first, leaving specific detail to a later stage resulting in the unwarranted blocks in Youtube after video. This is opposite to America where all the details are laid out in the initial stages of the negotiation. Chinese negotiators tend to attack the other side for not complying with the general principles that have been agreed upon earlier.
Google attempted to comply with Chinese government censorship
whilst dissociating itself from them. It provided a message stating that a blocked website was made unavailable due to local laws, regulations and policies, suggesting to Chinese users that the information existed but the government had denied them access.