Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
2008 by the Kellogg School of Management, Northwestern University. This case was prepared by Professor Robert C. Wolcott and
Research Associate Michael J. Lippitz. Cases are developed solely as the basis for class discussion. Cases are not intended to serve as
endorsements, sources of primary data, or illustrations of effective or ineffective management. To order copies or request permission
to reproduce materials, call 800-545-7685 (or 617-783-7600 outside the United States or Canada) or e-mail
custserv@hbsp.harvard.edu. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, used in a spreadsheet, or
transmitted in any form or by any meanselectronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwisewithout the permission of
the Kellogg School of Management.
This document is authorized for use only in GMBA/DXB/Global Immersion 3_New Markets, Reduced Costs and Better Techn... by Prof. Detlev Zwick, S P Jain School of Global Management ?
Dubai from April 2016 to October 2016.
KEL340
2
KELLOGG SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT
This document is authorized for use only in GMBA/DXB/Global Immersion 3_New Markets, Reduced Costs and Better Techn... by Prof. Detlev Zwick, S P Jain School of Global Management ?
Dubai from April 2016 to October 2016.
KEL340
Digital clocks soon became standard equipment in automobiles and numerous other products.
By 1979 Computime had delivered more than one million devices to customers in North America
and Europe. In 1980 it built a manufacturing facility in neighboring Guangzhou, China, making
the company an early mover into the newly created special economic zones (SEZs) set up by the
Chinese government in the Deng Xiaoping era. Dengs government, roughly from 1978 through
the early 1990s (Deng never held the official head of state position but was recognized during
most of this period as Chinas undisputed leader), instituted widespread economic reforms to
transform China from a traditional communist state to a socialist market economy, creating what
Deng referred to as socialism with Chinese characteristics. The SEZs allowed foreign direct
investment and other economic liberalizations for specific areas. The National Peoples Congress
passed Regulations for the Special Economic Zone of Guangdong Province in August 1980.
Computime completed its Guangzhou facility soon after.
However, Mr. Auyang recognized that the companys products would become commoditized
due to intensified competition from other companies making similar products. He decided to
create something that does more than show time. Computimes engineering team expanded the
functionality of its product lines to include programmability, i.e., the ability to switch devices on
and off at prescribed times. In the early 1980s, Mr. Auyang challenged his company to learn how
to make temperature control devices to replace the largely mechanical thermostats of the time.
(The Honeywell electronic programmable thermostat had already been invented, but it served a
small niche market.) Computime became the first Chinese company to introduce appliance timers
and electronic thermostats.
By focusing on manufacturing quality and efficiency, as well as tracking the latest product
trends from the United States and Europe, Computime expanded overseas. The company opened
its first office in the United States in 1982. It moved its manufacturing operations and six hundred
staff to Shenzhen, China, in 1984, further betting on the then-nascent transformation of the
Chinese economy. Beginning in 1987, Mr. Auyang vertically integrated development,
manufacturing, and sales to enhance quality control, efficiency, and responsiveness. As staff size
grew to include more than 1,000 people in 1989, the company opened corporate headquarters in
Kwun Tong, Hong Kong, to better access global markets and world-class management expertise.
Computime became an early convert to the International Standards Organization (ISO)
certification standards for manufacturing practices. It became ISO 9002 certified in 1995, ahead
of many manufacturers of comparable size in the United States and Europe.2 The company also
worked hard to instill the values of teamwork and responsibility for the community promulgated
by its founder.
2
ISO 9002 is maintained by ISO, the International Organization for Standardization, and is administered by accreditation and
certification bodies. Some of the requirements include procedures for key business processes, monitoring and recordkeeping
processes, checking output for defects, and facilitating continual improvement. See Wikipedia, ISO 9000, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/
ISO_9000.
KEL340
certification in 2002, and U.S. Food and Drug Administration approval for the manufacture of
medical devices for the U.S. market in 2003.
The five-year plan also paved the way for new management systems. The company grew over
many years by pursuing leading trends in time-based programmable electronics products and
building high-quality, efficient manufacturing capabilities. While this strategy worked, it relied
largely on the insight and direction of the company founder. Like entrepreneurs worldwide, Mr.
Auyang knew that he would eventually need to transfer leadership to the next generation. He also
recognized that his growing company required an expanded professional management team.
Mr. Auyangs son Bernie Auyang represented the future of this family-owned business.
Having started on the production line and in the warehouse, Auyang had risen through the ranks
of finance, sales, and marketing to become president in 1998 and CEO in 2002. Although Mr.
Auyang remained chairman, he provided his son with increasing autonomy, particularly in hiring
and setting the overall strategic direction of the company. Computime also added an
exceptionally effective chief operations officer (COO), Choi Po Yee (Alice), and invested her
with substantial authority for day-to-day operations.
One of Auyangs first hires, in 1998, was Wei Long (W. L.) Ha as chief of engineering. Ha
brought experience in new product development for telecommunications products companies, as
well as advanced degrees in electronic systems design and industrial management. He developed
and implemented a formal new product introduction (NPI) process based on state-of-the-art stagegate processes and built up Computimes Chinese engineering force. (Computime could hire
about three mainland Chinese engineers for the same cost as a single Hong Kong engineer.)
In 2000 Computime split into business units in order to better focus on distinct customer
groups. The business unit structure evolved as market opportunities changed. In 2002 business
units included building and home controls, appliance controls, and commercial and industrial
controls. (Appliance controls was originally part of building and home controls but split off when
the market became large enough to justify an independent division.) Ha became president of
building and home controls, the largest business unit. Exhibit 3 depicts the 2007 Computime
organizational chart and Exhibit 4 lists major product lines by business unit and major OEM
customers.
Despite respectable growth from these initiatives, Auyang realized that increased competition
in contract manufacturing was coming. Many new Chinese companies were becoming proficient
at turning a specification into a product with good quality control. If Computime wanted to
continue to grow and prosper, it would need to continue to find new opportunities.
4
KELLOGG SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT
This document is authorized for use only in GMBA/DXB/Global Immersion 3_New Markets, Reduced Costs and Better Techn... by Prof. Detlev Zwick, S P Jain School of Global Management ?
Dubai from April 2016 to October 2016.
KEL340
through R&D. Rather than being strictly an EMS or ODM company, Computime would become
an Asian control technology leader. (See Exhibit 5 for global locations.)
Branded Products
One of the first growth initiatives in the second five-year plan was to move into branded
products, in addition to serving as a contract manufacturer. In 2002 Computime formed a
partnership with Sensotec of the UK, a leader in safety electronics, to create Salus Controls Plc.,
with a focus on thermostats, timers, and values. In 2004 Computime acquired a controlling
interest in Salus and in 2006 acquired the remaining stock. Since 2004 Salus had doubled its
product sales in the UK. Dean Jepson, managing director of Salus, saw the partnership with
Computime as helping Salus become a leading international brand. Commenting on the 2006
equity investment, Jepson said:
Its taken us just two years, in a crowded . . . market, for Salus to become widely
renowned for its unparalleled product offering, technical support, and after-sales service.
With additional substantial investment from Computime in product development and
ambitious marketing strategies, we look forward to penetrating existing and new
markets.3
In addition to expanding geographically across Europe, Salus was developing solar energy
products to take advantage of that fast-growing segment.
Going Public
In order to raise money to finance the companys growthi.e., its R&D strategy, strategic
acquisitions, and geographical expansionComputime became a publicly traded company on the
Hong Kong exchange in October 2006. In its prospectus, it identified high-margin opportunities
in high-technology controls used in equipment such as power turbines and medical testing
devices. Computime indicated that it would seek to acquire other controls manufacturing
technologies and proprietary and innovative engineering processes. As for geographic
expansion, in 2007 Salus products launched in Germany and France, with plans to eventually be
sold throughout Europe. Computime also began seeking partnerships with its OEMs to expand its
presence in China and elsewhere.
The IPO was about more than raising capital. Contrary to many family companies
perspectives, Auyang, his father, and the rest of the board believed that building a public
company traded on a sophisticated exchange would instill discipline and rigor in management and
raise awareness within global capital markets. Computime welcomed the enhanced scrutiny, even
as it faced increased pressure to report and perform. Consistent with its move into more
technologically sophisticated solutions, the move to the public markets also allowed the company
to institute a stock option plan to attract and retain experienced professionals.
3
Salus Announces Major Developments, Buildingtalk, June 20, 2007, http://www.buildingtalk.com/news/saz/saz102.html (accessed
April 5, 2008).
KEL340
Environmentally friendly
Energy efficient
Easy to use
Wireless (Zigbee4)
Zigbee was a wireless networking protocol for which Computime made compatible products.
6
KELLOGG SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT
This document is authorized for use only in GMBA/DXB/Global Immersion 3_New Markets, Reduced Costs and Better Techn... by Prof. Detlev Zwick, S P Jain School of Global Management ?
Dubai from April 2016 to October 2016.
KEL340
Human-machine interface
Sensors
Software control
In 2004 Auyang asked W. L. Ha to become the first head of R&D. Ha was reluctant, as he
had already achieved 20 percent growth in the building and home controls unit. He would be
giving up business unit leadership in exchange for a handful of people and a portfolio of R&D
projects. He suggested Auyang hire someone from the outside with experience as an R&D lead.
However, Auyang wanted to retain continuity and ensure a close working relationship between
R&D and engineering. He reasoned that engineering would need to adopt R&D projects when
they matured and apply them in their markets, so the linkage had to be strong. More importantly,
management at Computime relied strongly on trust. It would be important to have an experienced
and respected insider lead the new effort.
Ha agreed, though he retained his leadership of the building and home controls unit until
October 2005. Ha began building an R&D capability by bringing in a small number of top
internal people who possessed both technical skill and open-minded personalities. He found that
most of these people, by dint of their forward-thinking tendencies, did not necessarily fit well into
the engineering culture of the business units or were not being well managed by their supervisors.
He eventually located ten people inside the company who wanted to be part of the R&D
enterprise. (Coincidentally, during this period, the heads of the two other Computime business
units were changed, reducing resistance to internal reassignments.)
After Ha selected these ten internal people, he began hiring from the outside until he had built
the organization to thirty-five people. He hired certain people primarily for their technical skills
related to the five initial project areas identified during the strategic planning for the R&D
function. He hired others for their vision for innovation.
In June 2006 Computime opened a stand-alone R&D center in Nanshan, China, in the
Shenzhen High Technology Park. This enabled most of Computimes R&D personnel to work
next door to researchers from other corporate R&D centers, rather than near factory engineers. In
addition, a handful of engineers remained in Hong Kong and a few in the United States.
KEL340
R&D also needed to synchronize with the business units, a common problem for corporate
innovation programs. The mission for R&D was to develop technology platforms for
incorporation into products three to five years in the future. The business units were much nearer
term and more market focused. Kairy Lei, an up-and-coming young R&D manager, articulated
the problem well: How do you know when its time to involve the business unit? When should
marketing become involved, and how?
Early on, the R&D center sometimes extended its work into commercialization, though this
occasionally caused friction with business unit engineers accustomed to owning projects. There
also seemed to be concern about who would take the credit or blame for a projects results. To
manage these issues, Ha began personally working with the business units to help transition R&D
projects. Computime also developed more defined methods for keeping both R&D and
engineering staff appropriately involved and engaged during commercialization, for example,
with informal recognition rewards.
Lei said that R&D engineers would be motivated by seeing the results of their work in the
marketplace. Stories of which projects succeeded and why were to be actively shared, though by
2007 there were still no formal communication channels between R&D and business unit
engineers. There were, however, informal exchanges in which business unit engineers made
extended visits to the R&D center. An internal meeting on thermostat technology built
understanding between R&D and business unit engineers, as well as helped them synchronize
their efforts.
It was also a challenge to train R&D engineers hired in mainland China. While mainland
Chinese engineers tended to have a stronger theoretical basis in their training than their Hong
Kong counterparts, they were less accustomed to working in an environment of regular change,
where mistakes were tolerated and one needed to constantly try new approaches and seek new
ideas outside the company. Even Internet access restrictions in China could present real problems
interacting with external venues such as interoperability standards organizations. Chinese
engineers also tended to be less accustomed to sharing problems, offering ideas, and working in
teams. They had typically not been well trained in careful documentation of goals and processes.
Cheng, whose background included design engineering and product development, trained
engineers in the R&D center to devise and propose design improvements. He also focused on
finding those with an aptitude for English, allowing them to become more directly involved in
customer engagements. Hong Kong managers were also integrated into client-facing projects to
ensure R&D engineers did not inadvertently reveal intellectual property.
Andrew Li, the head of building and home controls, believed that by 2007 the process was
working well. The Zigbee wireless platform developed by the R&D center had found applications
in home automation to connect controls home-wide. His engineers piloted technologies from the
R&D center and found ways to improve the performance and reliability of their applications.
They were able to showcase the new capabilities to potential customers, customizing the message
to focus on price for retail markets and reliability for industrial markets.
Business units also began providing feedback to the R&D center. One of Lis customers,
seeking ways to improve energy efficiency in fan motors, approached Computime for help. R&D
devised an innovative way of controlling air flow and speed. Computime later considered
applying the technology to other variable motor control applications.
8
KELLOGG SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT
This document is authorized for use only in GMBA/DXB/Global Immersion 3_New Markets, Reduced Costs and Better Techn... by Prof. Detlev Zwick, S P Jain School of Global Management ?
Dubai from April 2016 to October 2016.
KEL340
KEL340
2006
Rank
2007 Annual
Revenue
2006 Annual
Revenue
Change
(%)
Foxconn
54,706
39,253
39
Flextronics
33,346
28,876
15
Jabil
12,432
11,087
12
Sanmina-SCI
10,138
10,872
Celestica
8,069
8,811
Elcoteq
5,740
5,139
11
Benchmark
2,915
2,907
Venture
2,617
1,971
33
10
USI
2,046
1,676
22
10
NA
Plexus
1,624
1,513
133,633
112,105
19
Company Name
Total Top 10
2006
Rank
Quanta
23,259
14,170
64
Asustek
23,033
17,348
33
Compal
13,634
9,410
45
Wistron
8,658
6,603
31
TPV
8,419
7,238
16
Inventec
7,191
7,167
Lite-On
5,760
5,048
14
NA
Innolux
4,806
3,207
50
10
Mitac Intl
2,558
2,540
10
Inventec App
2,378
3,389
30
Total Top 10
99,696
76,120
31
Company Name
2007 Annual
Revenue
2006 Annual
Revenue
Change
(%)
10
KELLOGG SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT
This document is authorized for use only in GMBA/DXB/Global Immersion 3_New Markets, Reduced Costs and Better Techn... by Prof. Detlev Zwick, S P Jain School of Global Management ?
Dubai from April 2016 to October 2016.
KEL340
350
2006
IPO in HK;
R&D Center opens
in Nanshan, China
300
2005
Bantian packaging
site; New US HQ;
Chamerlain JV
250
2004
200
1989
New headquarters in
Kwun Tong, HK
150
1999
2002
Moved to Shenzhen,
China with 600 staff
100
Founded by Ho
Auyang in HK to
design & manufacture 1980
electronic clocks &
New factory in GZ
timing devices.
ISO14001 certified;
launched 2nd 5-yr Plan
1998
2001
1982
1974
2003
350,000sf manufacturing
space in Meilin, China
1984
1979
Shipped 1M digital
clocks
50
ISO13485 certified;
open Buji Tech Park,
Launched Salus brand
HK Quality Award
2000
QS9000 certification;
open Japan and
Germans offices
1995
ISO9002 certification
0
74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 '00 01 02 03 04 05 06
Executive Office
CEO
COO
CFO
Corporate
Operations
Finance
SBUs
Technologies
VP
Quality
VP
Operations
Buji
Corp Finance
&
Treasury
VP
Building &
Home Controls
VP
Commercial &
Industrial Controls
VP
SBM
GM
Operations
Meilin
Legal
&
Compliance
VP
Appliance
Controls
President
Branded
Business
Director
HR
VP
Operations
Bantian
Internal
Audit
Department
VP
Research &
Development
KEL340
OURMARKETS
Control and automation devices in the follo wing end market applications:
Appliance controls
Commercial and
industrial controls
Climate controls
Security contr ols
Intelligent home
White goods
Brown goods
Spa and pool
controls
12
KELLOGG SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT
This document is authorized for use only in GMBA/DXB/Global Immersion 3_New Markets, Reduced Costs and Better Techn... by Prof. Detlev Zwick, S P Jain School of Global Management ?
Dubai from April 2016 to October 2016.
KEL340
BUSINESSMODEL
TMB
Technology
Research and
Development
Technology
Product design
and Engineering
Optimized
ODM
Manufacturing
Brand
Management
KEL340
CORPORATE POLICIES
SOCIAL We strive to strengthen
ties with the communities we
operate in, with emphasis on
creating opportunities for young
people.
EMPLOYEE We practise the po licies
of equal opportunity employment and
make employee well-being,
satisfa ction and take ho me value our
major concerns.
ENVIRONMENTAL We are guided
by principles o f acting responsibly in
all areas of our operations. We are
committed to conservation,
preservation and recycling.
14
KELLOGG SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT
This document is authorized for use only in GMBA/DXB/Global Immersion 3_New Markets, Reduced Costs and Better Techn... by Prof. Detlev Zwick, S P Jain School of Global Management ?
Dubai from April 2016 to October 2016.