Project : Digital Zone 2, Chennai.

Owner : Marg Construction, Chennai.

DIGITAL ZONE 2 TECHNICAL COMPARISON

Air cooled Chilled Water Package-

S.No

DESCRIPTION
Chiller Type

Consultant
Specificatio
n
AIR COOLED
SCREW

280 TR

(Normal Operation)

BLUE STAR

ETA

TRAC

VOLTAS

AIR COOLED
SCREW

AIR COOLED
SCREW

AIR COOLED
SCREW

AIR COOLED
SCREW

30 G X E 328

RTAC 300

WDAT -3.2.420
STTP

AFHX320-5SR

Model No.

-Vendor to
specify-

Overall chilling machine

-Vendor to
specify-

1.1

Dimensions (L x B x H) mm x
mm x mm

-Vendor to
specify-

8740 x 2254 x
2297

10057 x 2250 x
2570

1.2

Actual Capacity (TR) at

105F ambient, 44 deg F
CHW leaving with 1.9 GPM
flow / TR

280

278 TR

277.4 TR

1.3

Make

-Vendor to
specify-

Carrier

TRANE

DB

1.4

Model

SCREW

SEMI - HERMETIC
SCREW

Screw

AFHX320-5SR

1.5
1.6

Quantity (Nos.)
Overall Weight shipping Kgs

2
-Vendor to
specify-

2
7779

2
9235

11520

2
25300LBS

1.7

Type of vibration isolation

RUBBER MAT

Serrated Rubber
Mats

Neoprene Isolators

Spring

By others

1.8

No. of compressors per

chiller

-Vendor to
specify-

1.9

No. of refrigerants circuits

per chiller

-Vendor to
specify-

1.1

Overall IKW/TR at As per ARI

-Vendor to
specify-

434.5 L X 98.5 H X
88 W
277

296.7

100% load

-Vendor to
specify-

1.256

1.41

1.42

1.37

75% load

-Vendor to
specify-

1.021

1.05

0.93

1.177

50% load

-Vendor to
specify-

0.835

0.91

0.69

1.155

25% load

-Vendor to
specify-

0.762

0.7

0.56

1.084

NPLV for the Above >1

-Vendor to
specify-

0.896

0.93

0.754

1.156

Overall IKW/TR at constant

condensing temp. air
entering at 105 deg F water
in/out 6/13 deg. C

-Vendor to
specify-

100% load

-Vendor to
specify-

1.47

1.41

1.42

1.37

75% load

-Vendor to
specify-

1.43

1.4

1.32

1.272

50% load

-Vendor to
specify-

1.35

1.42

1.24

1.362

25% load

-Vendor to
specify-

1.35

1.31

1.36

1.612

NPLV for the Above >1.35

-Vendor to
specify-

1.384

1.39

1.288

1.347

COP at ARI & Consultant

Ambient

-Vendor to
specify-

2.8 / Const.2.37

1.11

Total connected load per

chiller (KW)

-Vendor to
specify-

411

392.2

315

406.5

1.12

Maximum inrush current

-Vendor to
specify-

Last Modified : 20 July 2005

Ver : R0

718

Architect : Edifice Architects Pvt Ltd, Chennai - 17

HVAC Consultant : Air Treatment Engg. Pvt Ltd, Chennai - 20

Project : Digital Zone 2, Chennai.

Owner : Marg Construction, Chennai.

BLUE STAR

ETA

TRAC

VOLTAS

1.8

1.2

0.9

96 inch

-Vendor to
specify-

1.8

2.4

1.8

96 inch

No

By others

Consultant
Specificatio
-Vendor to
1.13 Minimum clearance required
from adjacent structures m
specify-

S.No

DESCRIPTION

1.14 Minimum clearance required

between Two machines m
1.15

Whether any plat form of

Pedestal required for
installation? If so, furnish
details

-Vendor to
specify-

YES

Yes

1.16

Noise level at a distance of

1m from the machine at
intervals of 1m along the
perimeter

-Vendor to
specify-

78 dB(A)

69 dB A

90 dBa

1.17

Noise level as mentioned

above when All the machines
are working db

-Vendor to
specify-

80 dB(A)

By others

1.18

Finish details i.e., hot dip

galvanised, Corrosion
resistent etc.

-Vendor to
specify-

1.19

Whether factory fabricated

(YES / NO)

YES

Compressor

-Vendor to
specify-

2.1

Actual Capacity (TR) at

operating conditions

2.2

Hot Dip Galvanised

Powder coating

YES

Yes

250

278 TR

277.4 TR

2 x 138.5

296.7

Saturated Suction Temp. (C)

-Vendor to
specify-

proprietary

2.3

Saturated Discharge Temp.

(C)

-Vendor to
specify-

2.4
2.5

Refrigerant
Make

134A / 407C
-Vendor to
specify-

R - 134 A
CARLYLE

R-134 A
TRANE

R-134 A
Bitzer

R-134 A
DB

2.6

Model & Origin

-Vendor to
specify-

BRAZIL

RTAC 300, FRANCE

Germany

HISC 1816

2.7

Type

SEMIHERMETIC

Semi Hermatic

Semi Hermatic

Semi Hermatic

Semi Hermatic

2.8

Quantity per chiller

-Vendor to
specify-

2.9
2.1

Unloading Steps
Capacity Control Type

Stepless
Continous

Stepless

Stepless
Automatic slide
valve mechanism

2.11

Control Panel Details

-Vendor to
specify-

Microprosser

Microprosser

Microprocessor

Microcomputer

2.12

Motor KW

-Vendor to
specify-

93.25
Kw/compressor

2 x 157.5

194 KW each

2.13

Electrical Characteristics

-Vendor to
specify-

400 V / 3 Phase /
50 Hz

400 V / 3 Phase /
50 Hz

400 V / 3 Phase /
50 Hz +/- 6 %

400 V / 3 Phase /
50 Hz

2.14

Motor Make

-Vendor to
specify-

Ao Smith

Standard

European

DB

2.15

Frame Size

-Vendor to
specify-

2.16
2.17

Insulation Class
Protection Class

F
-Vendor to
specify-

F
B

2.18

Type

-Vendor to
specify-

2.19

Full current amps.

-Vendor to
specify-

842 Amps

2.2

Starting current amps

-Vendor to
specify-

922 Amps

-Vendor to
specify-

2.21 Maximum instantaneous unit

current

Last Modified : 20 July 2005

Ver : R0

STEP LESS Stepped (10 Steps)

CONTINUOUS
Pilot Operated

Yes

proprietary

Custom built
F

F
IP 55

F
Semi Hermatic
with thermistors

Semi Hermatic

Semi Hermatic

670 Amps

670

349-chiller

831 Amps

1054

718-chiller
718

Architect : Edifice Architects Pvt Ltd, Chennai - 17

HVAC Consultant : Air Treatment Engg. Pvt Ltd, Chennai - 20

Project : Digital Zone 2, Chennai.

Owner : Marg Construction, Chennai.

Consultant
Specificatio
-Vendor to
specify-

BLUE STAR

ETA

TRAC

VOLTAS

277TR , 394 KW

Effy = 0.9

S.No

DESCRIPTION

2.22

Capacity and corresponding

Bkw

Air Cooled Condenser

-Vendor to
specify-

3.1

Manufacturers name

-Vendor to
specify-

CARRIER

TRANE

3.2

Model

-Vendor to
specify-

30GXE 328

RTAC 300

3.3

Heat rejection capacity at

operating

Chennai
Condition

1328 KW

3.4

Entering Air DB Temp. -C

Chennai
Condition

40.55

3.5

Leaving Air WB Temp. C

Chennai
Condition

3.6

Air quantity (CMH)

-Vendor to
specify-

3.7

Tubes

-Vendor to
specify-

Type

COPPER TUBE

COPPER TUBE

OD

-Vendor to
specify-

Material
Thickness

COPPER TUBE
-Vendor to
specify-

Yes

3.8

Condensing Temperature

-Vendor to
specify-

proprietary

3.9

Air Flow Velocity (m/sec)

-Vendor to
specify-

532 fpm

3.1

Instruments / Controls

-Vendor to
specify-

Microprosser
Control ( PRO
DIACON)

Microprocessor
based

microp

3.11

Drain Connection Size

-Vendor to
specify-

3/8 "

Propritory data

tba

3.12

Fan arrangement

-Vendor to
specify-

Vertical Throw

Direct Driven

vertical

Power consumption (KW)

-Vendor to
specify-

38 KW

14 x 3

3 kw each

3.13

Fan Dia (mm)

-Vendor to
specify-

800

860

3.14

Fan Speed (RPM)

-Vendor to
specify-

15.8 R/S

915

3.15

No. of fans

-Vendor to
specify-

16

18

14

18

3.16

No. of rows

-Vendor to
specify-

multiple

3.17

Heat rejection capacity at

operation conditions

-Vendor to
specify-

1328 KW

3.18

Whether any sub-cooling

circuit provided? If so, furnish
details

-Vendor to
specify-

Yes , Integrated
Sub Cooler

3.19

Test pressure Kg/cm2

-Vendor to
specify-

1000 Kpa

3.2

Fans dynamically & statically

balanced

YES

Yes

Yes

Chiller

-Vendor to
specify-

4.1

Make

-Vendor to
specify-

CARRIER

TRANE

4.2

Model

-Vendor to
specify-

30 GXE328

RTAC 300

WDAT -3.2.420
STTP

U1R

4.3
4.4

Entering Water Temp. (C)

Leaving Water Temp. (C)

130C
60C

6
13

6
13

13
6

13
6

Last Modified : 20 July 2005

Ver : R0

93.25

DB
CLIVET, Air cooled

Air cooled
397 ton

105 F

105 F

40.5
50.6

85520 L/s

164894 cfm

315030

243540

Internally Finned

plain

Propritory data

3/8 "

Copper
Propritory data

Copper
tba

Internally Finned
Seam less Copper
Tube

Copper

Direct Drive
Vertical discharge

30"

950

397 ton
Yes

Yes

no

450 PSI
Yes

Yes

DB

Architect : Edifice Architects Pvt Ltd, Chennai - 17

HVAC Consultant : Air Treatment Engg. Pvt Ltd, Chennai - 20

Project : Digital Zone 2, Chennai.

Owner : Marg Construction, Chennai.

Consultant
Specificatio
n
4.5
Water Flow Rate
1.9Gpm/TR
4.6 Capacity at design conditions -Vendor to
specify-

S.No

DESCRIPTION

BLUE STAR

ETA

TRAC

VOLTAS

33.3 L/S
278 TR

119
277

565.1 USGPM
296.7 ton

multiple

Shell & Tube, Dry

expansion type

Finned tube

R-134 A

3/4 "

Copper

Copper

4.7

No of passes

-Vendor to
specify-

4.8

Tubes

-Vendor to
specify-

COPPER TUBE

Internally Finned

Type

-Vendor to
specify-

Flooded Type

Copper Tubes

OD

-Vendor to
specify-

Material

-Vendor to
specify-

MS

Thickness

-Vendor to
specify-

No. Of tubes

-Vendor to
specify-

4.9

No. Of refrigerant circuit

-Vendor to
specify-

4.1

Water Flow Velocity (m/sec)

-Vendor to
specify-

Pressure drop (Mtr.WC)

-Vendor to
specify-

23 KPa

4.11

Shell dia and length

-Vendor to
specify-

4.12

Insulation details

Polyethylene
Foam

Insulatted with 19
mm closed cell ,
PVC form with Max
K factor 0.28

4.13

Drain Connection Size

-Vendor to
specify-

4.14

Fouling Factor (Hr ft of F /

BTU)

4.15

Copper

.025 "

21 KPa

multiple

proprietary

Less than 2.5 m/s

4.2 FPS

3.6

7.2
26" & 125"

Closed cell
insulation

Elatomeric rubber

3/8"

Propritory data

tba

0.0005

0.0005

0.0005

0.0005

Chiller connections

-Vendor to
specify-

Victaulic

Inlet dia

-Vendor to
specify-

8"

8"

8"

10 "

Outlet dia

-Vendor to
specify-

8"

8"

8"

10 "

Material of shell & thickness

Water side surface area
(sq.m)

Steel
-Vendor to
specify-

Steel
-

Carbon Steel

4.18 Ref. Side surface area sq.m

-Vendor to
specify-

4.16
4.17

Note:

19.mm Armflex

SA53B & 0.37 "

477.8 SFT
556.2 SFT

BSR Enterprises have not submitted the technical data

Last Modified : 20 July 2005

Ver : R0

Architect : Edifice Architects Pvt Ltd, Chennai - 17

HVAC Consultant : Air Treatment Engg. Pvt Ltd, Chennai - 20