Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Domestic
Review Violence
Vol. 16: 311322
in New South
(2007)Wales, Australia
Published online in Wiley InterScience
(www.interscience.wiley.com) DOI: 10.1002/car.991
Domestic Violence:
A Priority in Child
Protection in New
South Wales,
Australia?
311
Jude Irwin*
Fran Waugh
Faculty of Education and Social
Work, University of Sydney,
Australia
Over the last several years there has been increasing awareness of
the connection between domestic violence and child abuse, yet only
minimal attention has been paid to the implications of this for child
protection practice. This article begins to address this gap. Drawing on
research undertaken in New South Wales (NSW), Australia, it examines
child protection practice in relation to children and young people who
have been exposed to domestic violence. The research involved
analysis of the responses of the statutory child protection authority
in NSW (the Department of Community Services or DoCS) to abuse
allegations involving domestic violence. The data are drawn from
observation and analysis of the initial responses to referrals to DoCS
and the tracking of a sample of these referrals over an 18 month
period. From the data obtained, it is evident that domestic violence
referrals are treated less seriously than other referrals, with more
being confirmed as abuse but fewer resulting in follow up or
intervention. The implications of this for child protection practice are
teased out. Copyright 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Increasing
awareness of
the connection
between domestic
violence and child
abuse
Domestic violence
referrals are treated
less seriously than
other referrals
Correspondence to: Associate Professor Jude Irwin, Faculty of Education and Social
Work, Building A35, University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia. E-mail: J.Irwin@edfac.
usyd.edu.au
Contract/grant sponsor: Australian Research Council; Barnardos, Australia; NSW Department
of Community Services.
Copyright 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
312
How do
practitioners make
sense of this in
their practice?
313
The Research
The aims of the overall research project were to:
1. examine practitioners knowledge and understandings of domestic
violence;
2. review the child protection strategies utilised by practitioners; and
Copyright 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
314
An intended
outcome of the
research was the
development of a
template of good
practice
When a referral
was first received
there were three
possible decisions
315
a notification on the CIS. At the time of the research this was the
official recording of the child abuse allegation and involved follow up. (The nomenclature for notification changed to report in
new child protection legislation in 2000.)
confirmed, registered;
confirmed, referred, closed;
confirmed, closed;
not confirmed, referred, closed; or
not confirmed, closed and not located.
Five possible
outcomes of an
investigative
assessment were
Researchers at
each of the five
participating
offices shadowed
an intake worker
and used a
structured
questionnaire
316
A total of 431
referrals were
observed in the
five participating
offices
A higher
percentage of
domestic violence
referrals were
recoded as
information only
domestic violence in child protection practice with the consequences of no follow up, ongoing involvement with the family or
referral to another service.
A similar picture emerged in relation to notifications. Even though
a similar percentage of the initial domestic violence and other
referrals were recorded as notifications, there was a significant
difference between the percentage of domestic violence referrals
and all other tracked referrals which were followed up with investigative assessments. Investigative assessments were pursued in
36% (40) of the domestic violence notifications and 52% (55) of the
other notifications. Again it is evident that referrals on the primary
grounds of domestic violence were less likely to be followed up with
an investigative assessment than referrals on other grounds.
There was also great disparity between confirmation of the
domestic violence and other abuse referrals, namely, 75% of
the initial domestic violence referrals were confirmed and 56%
of the other initial referrals were confirmed. Although a higher
percentage of domestic violence referrals were confirmed, only 16%
(three) of the confirmed domestic violence referrals were recorded
as registered cases, whereas 63% (19) of the other confirmed
referrals were recorded as registered cases. So, although more likely
to be confirmed, referrals based on domestic violence were less
likely to be registered and result in an ongoing response from statutory child protection workers.
317
Re-referrals
Over the 18 month tracking period, 88 of the original referrals were
re-reported to statutory child protection authorities on one or more
occasion. Of these 69% resulted in a notification, with similar
rates for both the domestic violence and other categories of abuse.
As with the initial referrals, a higher percentage of domestic
violence re-referrals resulted in an intake only decision and were
filtered out of the child protection system. The domestic violence
re-referrals were again less likely to result in investigative assessments and registration. Investigative assessments were undertaken
in 55% of domestic violence referrals and 68% of other referrals.
Only 19% of domestic violence re-referrals were registered compared with 48% of the other re-referrals.
From these data, a clear pattern emerged that domestic violence
was treated differently from other abuse referrals. Despite being the
highest reason for original referrals, the data show that domestic
violence is either not considered as a child protection issue or is
responded to less seriously than other forms of abuse and neglect.
At all stages of statutory child protection intervention, domestic
violence referrals were filtered out at a far greater rate than
other referrals. At intake, a greater number of domestic violence
Copyright 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Domestic violence
referrals were
filtered out at a far
greater rate than
other referrals
318
Domestic violence
re-referrals being
much less likely to
be registered
Although the child at risk category emotional abuse due to exposure to domestic violence had been included as a reason for child
abuse referrals in June 1994, less than half of the 20 practitioners
interviewed had undertaken training about assessing risk related
to domestic violence. The domestic violence knowledge of the
statutory child protection practitioners in this study varied considerably and fell into four broad groups. The first group of practitioners perceived that domestic violence was not a child protection
issue unless the child was physically hurt or saw the abuse of their
mother. These practitioners tended to have narrow understandings
of domestic violence as either physical abuse, or the threat of such
abuse. They had limited knowledge of the dynamics of domestic
violence, especially as it related to children. While the second group
of practitioners had a greater knowledge and understanding of
domestic violence, especially as it related to children and young
people, like the first group they considered domestic violence only
of concern when children or young people saw physical violence
between their parents/carers. They had only minimal understanding of the broader implications of living in a household where
there is domestic violence. These two groups struggled to identify
domestic violence unless it was very obvious. The third group
demonstrated a more comprehensive knowledge of domestic
violence and the effects of living in a household where domestic
violence is present. These practitioners had confidence in assessing the impact of domestic violence. They frequently saw women
as having the responsibility to protect their children. The fourth
group also had a comprehensive knowledge of domestic violence
especially as it related to children and young people. For these practitioners, the womans and childrens safety was inter-dependent.
The largest numbers of practitioners fell into the second (eight)
and third groups (six) with three each in the first and fourth groups.
Understanding of domestic violence and their view about whether
it constituted a child protection issue were highly influential in how
these practitioners responded to referrals of child abuse based
primarily on domestic violence.
Child Abuse Review Vol. 16: 311322 (2007)
DOI: 10.1002/car
319
Be no concomitant
perceptual or
service delivery
response
Services and
support which
may enable them
to begin to make
changes in their
lives
320
Living with
domestic violence
was not
conceptualised as a
real child protection
issue
The gendered
nature of domestic
violence, power
and control issues
Copyright 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
colleagues (2002) in which children and their mother were interviewed about their experiences of living with domestic violence.
The research showed that listening to children and supporting
mothers to connect with their children are key functions of
agencies, creating opportunities to understand and enhance safety.
Irrespective of the controversy around the mandatory reporting
of domestic violence to the NSW statutory child protection agency,
referrals to DoCS create this same possibility. In this study however, the opportunity for ongoing intervention was rarely realised.
Children, young people and their mothers who were exposed to
domestic violence and referred to the statutory child protection
authority were unlikely to receive protective intervention, support
or referral to other agencies. Was this because of an overwhelming
increase in the numbers of notifications combined with statutory
practitioners limited understandings about the complexities surrounding domestic violence, resulting in less priority given to
investigating such notifications? Was it because of the complexity
of the situations with domestic violence often co-occurring with
other with other forms of abuse such as parental drug and alcohol
misuse and /or mental health concerns? For whatever reason, the
opportunity for intervention was lost. The women and their
children received inadequate or no risk assessments, limited referral and support, sporadic or no follow up or referral to agencies
largely because, for whatever reason, living with domestic violence
was not conceptualised as a real child protection issue. Despite
the NSW government being committed to a co-ordinated and
comprehensive response to promote the protection of children
and young people and their families, this was only rarely evident
in the referrals based on domestic violence. All too frequently the
chances to provide women and their children with support were lost.
We are arguing for a response that is sympathetic to women
and their children who live with domestic violence, linking them
with supportive and empowering services rather than one that
ignores the impact of violence, is punitive and blaming of women
for not protecting their children. Protecting children from harm is
not the responsibility for only one agency, it requires collaboration
from both public and community based agencies working effectively together to reduce the risks to children (see for example and
Stanley and Humphreys, 2006). In a review of six research studies
on domestic violence, Radford and Hester (2006) conclude that
if there is to be positive practice with children and mothers who
live with domestic violence, then a multi-agency approach is
crucial and has to underpin any work by welfare or other agencies
engaged in work with families experiencing domestic violence
(Radford and Hester, 2006, p. 149). Child protection services need
to understand the gendered nature of domestic violence, power
and control issues and ensure a supportive, positive rather than a
Child Abuse Review Vol. 16: 311322 (2007)
DOI: 10.1002/car
321
Conclusion
Many women, children and young people who live with domestic
violence do have contact with health and human service agencies
so there are genuine opportunities to intervene and provide services and support. Unless child protection practitioners and policy
makers move beyond the rhetoric to take domestic violence seriously and develop relevant training and risk assessment processes
that account for the specific needs of children and young people who
live with domestic violence, effective services to children, young
people and their mothers will remain limited. We need to ensure
that practitioners work collaboratively to pick up the cues and
respond to domestic violence to end the kind of experience
described by an eight year participant in the research who said:
No one helped my mum.
No one helped my
mum
Acknowledgements
This research project was sponsored by a grant from the Australian
Research Council, Barnardos Australia and the NSW DoCS. The
research was undertaken with approval from the NSW DoCS.
However, the conclusions drawn from the study constitute the
views of the authors and do not necessarily represent the view
of the NSW Government, The Minister for Community Services,
or the Department. The authors acknowledge the contribution of
the late Dr Marie Wilkinson to this project.
References
Breckenridge J, Ralfs C. 2006. Point of contact front-line workers responding
to children living with domestic violence. In Domestic Violence and Child
Protection: New Directions for Practice, Humphreys C, Stanley N (eds).
Jessica Kingsley Publications: London; 110 123.
Calder M, Harold G, Howarth E. 2004. Children Living with Domestic Violence.
Towards a Framework for Assessment and Intervention. Russell House Publishing: Lyme Regis, Dorset.
Edleson J. 2001. Studying the Co-Occurrence of Child Maltreatment and
Domestic Violence in Families. In Graham-Bermann S, Edleson J (eds).
Domestic Violence in the Lives of Children. American Psychological Association: Washington, D.C. 91110.
Houghton C. 2006. Listen Louder: Working with Children and Young People.
In Humphreys C, Stanley N (eds). Domestic Violence and Child Protection:
New Directions for Practice. Jessica Kingsley: London. 8294.
Copyright 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
322