MODEL CHECKS

NAME
20160612_POST_PERIPHERAL_WIND0_K

20160612_TORQUECORRELATED_PERIPHERAL_WIND0_K

LOADS
LOADS NOT OK.
POST MOMENT MAX LOAD CASE M
LOAD COMBO 1 MISSING
1.2 DEAD + 1.6 WIND MISSING
LOADS OK.
LOAD COMBO 1 MISSING
1.2 DEAD + 1.6 WIND MISSING

20160612_POSTS_PERIPHERAL_WIND20_K

LOAD COMBO 1 MISSING

1.2 DEAD + 1.6 WIND MISSING
LOADS ARE MORE THAN WHAT
CALCULATION3 PREDICTS
FOR 90KMPH

20160612_POSTS_INTERNAL_WIND45_K

THE SQRT(2) FACTOR SEEMS TO

HAVE BEEN MISSED.

20160612_POSTS_PERIPHERAL_WIND45_K

LOADS OK.

SECTIONS
MIDDLE PIPE 127x115. NEXT 127x119. NEXT 127x121. NEXT 127X122
T MAX LOAD CASE MISSSING
1 MISSING
.6 WIND MISSING
MIDDLE PIPE 127x115. NEXT 127x119. NEXT 127x121. NEXT 127X122
OK
1 MISSING
.6 WIND MISSING

1 MISSING
.6 WIND MISSING
ORE THAN WHAT
N3 PREDICTS

FACTOR SEEMS TO

OK

IDDLE PIPE 127x115. NEXT 127x119. NEXT 127x121. NEXT 127X122

IDDLE PIPE 127x115. NEXT 127x119. NEXT 127x121. NEXT 127X122

DESIGN PARAMS
ONLY LYS PUT.
POSTS USE 2.4
LZs TO BE put FOR ,
COMPLETENESS
POSTS USE 2.4

AFTER ADDING LY
FAILURE IN 1 TORQUE
TUBE SEGMENT.

ESIGN PARAMS
NLY LYS PUT.
OSTS USE 2.4
Zs TO BE put FOR ,
OMPLETENESS
OSTS USE 2.4

OUTPUT
POSTS 0.03
TT 0.623

DAF APPLIED
YES
1.25

POSTS 0.01/0.98
YES
TT 0.95
1.13
AS MOMENT MAX LOAD CASE WAS MISSING
TT WAS PASSING IN POSTS MODEL WHILE
IT SHOULD FAIL

FTER ADDING LY
POSTS 0.55
AILURE IN 1 TORQUE TT 1.06 AWAY FROM CENTRAL
UBE SEGMENT.
SEGMENT

YES
1.471875

MODEL CHECKS
NAME
POSTS INTERIOR WIND0

POSTS INTERIOR WIND20

LOADS
FOUND OK.
DAFS USED WERE OK.
MOMENT MAX LOADS WERE
ADDED
LOADS
USED DAFS SEEM MORE THAN
WHAT IS REQUIRED.
DAF GCN
1.3
DAF MCHR
1.2
USED DAFS
1.4
1.5

MOMENTMAX LOADS WERE ADDED

POSTS INTERIOR WIND45

used DAFS seem more than what

is required
DAF REQ
GCN
1.2
MHYROW
1.2
LOADS OK

20160616_TorqueCorrelated_Interior_Wind0_K

LOADS OK.
DAFS OK

20160616_TorqueCorrelated_Interior_Wind20_K

DAF MORE THAN REQD

DAF REQ
GCN
1.3
MHYROW
1.2
LOADS OK
LOAD COMBO
1.6 INC BY 15% TO 1.84

20160616_TorqueCorrelated_Interior_Wind45_K

DAFs OK
Loads OK

20160616_TorqueCorrelated_Peripheral_Wind0_K

DAFS SEEM OK.

GCN DAF MIGHT BE MORE

THAN REQD
LOADS OK

20160616_TorqueCorrelated_Peripheral_Wind20_K

DAFS SEEM OK.

20160616_TorqueCorrelated_Peripheral_Wind45_K

DAFS SEEM OK.

POSTS PERIPHERAL WIND0

DAFS OK
LOADS OK

POSTS PERIPHERAL WIND20

DAFS OK
LOADS OK

POSTS PERIPHERAL WIND45

DAFS OK
LOADS INCORRECT. 20 SIN USED
CHANGED.

X LOADS WERE

SECTIONS
UNSYMMETRICALLY ASSIGNED SECTIONS.
FOLLOWING CHANGES MADE
POSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5
BETA 90
SECTIONS

EEM MORE THAN

FOLLOWING CHANGES MADE
POSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5
BETA 90

LOADS WERE ADDED

em more than what

DAF USD
1.25
1.5

POSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

BETA 90

POSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

BETA 90

HAN REQD
DAF USD
1.3
1.5
POSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5
BETA 90

% TO 1.84

HT BE MORE

POSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

BETA 90

POSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

BETA 90

RECT. 20 SIN USED

MEMBERS USED
CENTRAL PI
SECOND
THIRD
FOURTH
TORQUE STRUT 145X82X4
POSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5
BETA 90

POSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

BETA 90

POSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

BETA 90

POSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

BETA 90

POSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

BETA 90

NSYMMETRICALLY ASSIGNED SECTIONS.

OLLOWING CHANGES MADE
OSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

OLLOWING CHANGES MADE

OSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

OSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

OSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

OSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

DESIGN PARAMS
FOR POSTS Kz
changed to 1.5 for
cantilever effect
ONE PARAM LIST
DESIGN PARAMS
FOR POSTS Kz
changed to 1.5 for
cantilever effect
ONE PARAM LIST

DESIGN PARAMS
FOR POSTS Kz
changed to 1.5 for
cantilever effect
ONE PARAM LIST

DESIGN PARAMS
FOR POSTS Kz
changed to 1.5 for
cantilever effect
ONE PARAM LIST

DESIGN PARAMS
FOR POSTS Kz
changed to 1.5 for
cantilever effect
ONE PARAM LIST

OSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

OSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

DESIGN PARAMS
FOR POSTS Kz
changed to 1.5 for

EMBERS USED
6MM
4MM
2.5MM
2.5MM
ORQUE STRUT 145X82X4

cantilever effect
ONE PARAM LIST

OSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

DESIGN PARAMS
FOR POSTS Kz
changed to 1.5 for
cantilever effect
ONE PARAM LIST

OSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

DESIGN PARAMS
FOR POSTS Kz
changed to 1.5 for
cantilever effect
ONE PARAM LIST

OSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

DESIGN PARAMS
FOR POSTS Kz
changed to 1.5 for
cantilever effect
ONE PARAM LIST

OSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

DESIGN PARAMS
FOR POSTS Kz
changed to 1.5 for
cantilever effect
ONE PARAM LIST

OSTS CHANGED TO W6X8.5

DESIGN PARAMS
FOR POSTS Kz
changed to 1.5 for
cantilever effect
ONE PARAM LIST

ESIGN PARAMS
OR POSTS Kz
hanged to 1.5 for
antilever effect
NE PARAM LIST

ESIGN PARAMS
OR POSTS Kz
hanged to 1.5 for
antilever effect
NE PARAM LIST

OUTPUT
ONLY MIDDLE 2 SPANS
TT AND CENTRAL POSTS FAIL
RATIOS CLOSE TO 1
WUD BE EXPECTED TO PASS IN
MOMENT CORRELATED MODELS
OUTPUT
ALL PASSING
ONLY CENTRAL TT FAILS.
TORQUE STRUTS FAIL
WUD BE EXPECTED TO PASS IN
MOMENT CORRELATED MODELS

ESIGN PARAMS
OR POSTS Kz
hanged to 1.5 for
antilever effect
NE PARAM LIST

ALL RELEVANT SECTIONS PASSING

EVEN INTERNAL ONES

ESIGN PARAMS
OR POSTS Kz
hanged to 1.5 for
antilever effect
NE PARAM LIST

TORQUE TUBE PASSES

AT CENTRE. TORQUE STRUT
IS FAILING AT 1.02

ESIGN PARAMS
OR POSTS Kz
hanged to 1.5 for
antilever effect
NE PARAM LIST

ALL MEMBERS PASS

ESIGN PARAMS
OR POSTS Kz
hanged to 1.5 for

all members pass

all members pass

TORQUE STRUT
CENTRAL AND SECOND ARE

DAF APPLIED
YES

DAF APPLIED

antilever effect
NE PARAM LIST

ABOVE 0.9 UTILIZATION.

ESIGN PARAMS
OR POSTS Kz
hanged to 1.5 for
antilever effect
NE PARAM LIST

all members pass

TORQUE STRUT
CENTRAL AND SECOND ARE
ABOVE 0.7 UTILIZATION.

ESIGN PARAMS
OR POSTS Kz
hanged to 1.5 for
antilever effect
NE PARAM LIST

all members pass

ESIGN PARAMS
OR POSTS Kz
hanged to 1.5 for
antilever effect
NE PARAM LIST

ALL MEMBERS PASS

ESIGN PARAMS
OR POSTS Kz
hanged to 1.5 for
antilever effect
NE PARAM LIST

ALL MEMBERS PASS

TT AT 0.867

ESIGN PARAMS
OR POSTS Kz
hanged to 1.5 for
antilever effect
NE PARAM LIST

ALL MEMBERS PASS

TORQUE TUBE
SPAN 2 IS AT 1.01