CONSTI 2

Atty Dacanay
Case List
(Saturday 10-1)
Week 1:
Introduction:
1. Marbury v. Madison,
5 U.S. 137
2. Ernesto Francisco Jr. v House of Representatives
Carpio Morales
G.R. No. 160261 November 10, 2003;
3. Manila Prince Hotel v Government Service Insurance System
Bellosillo
G.R. No. 122156. February 3, 1997
4. Pablo Sanidad v The Commission on Elections
Martin
G.R. No. L-44640 October 12, 1976
5. Raul L. Lambino v The Commission on Elections
Carpio
GR No. 174153 October 25, 2006
Police Power
6. Leovillo C. Agustin v Hon Romeo F. Edu
Fernando
GR No: L-49112 February 2,1 979
7. Lao H. Ichong v Jaime Hernandez
Labrador
GR No. L-7995 May 31, 1957
8. City Government of Quezon City v Hon. Judge Vicente G. Ericta
Gutierrez Jr.
GR No. L-34915 June 24, 1983
9. Metropolitan Manila Development Authority v Bel-Air Village Association Inc
Puno
GR No: 135962. March 27, 2000
10. Celestino Tatel v Municipality of Virac
Concepcion
GR No L-29159 November 24, 1972
Eminent Domain
11. Republic of the Philippines v PLDT
Reyes J.B.L
GR No: L-18841 January 27, 1969
12. National Power Corporation v Sps. Misericordia Gutierrez
Bidin
GR No: L-60077. January 18. 1991
13. Export Processing Zone Authority (EPZA) v Hon. Cefrerino Dulay
Gutierrez Jr.
Gr No- L59603
14. Victoria Amigable v Nicolas Cuenca
Makalintal
Gr No: L-26400 Feb 29, 1972
15. Christina De Knecht v Hon. Court of Appeals
Puno
GR No: 108015. May 20, 1998
Tax
16. Pascual v Public Works
GR No: L-10405. December 29, 1960
Concepcion

17. John H. Osmena v Oscar Orbos

GR No: 99886. March 31, 1993
Narvasa C.J
18. Rev Fr. Casimiro Lladoc v Commission of Internal Revenue
GR No: L-19201. June 16, 1965
Paredes
Due Process
19. Lao Ichong v Jaime Hernandez
GR No: L-7995. May 31, 1957
Labrador
20. Restituto Ynot v Intermediate Appellate Court
GR No: 74457. May 20, 1987
Cruz
21. Ang Tibay v The Court of Industrial Relations
GR No: L-46496. February 27, 1940
Laurel
22. Ateneo De Manila v Hon. Ignacio Capulong
GR NO: 99327. May 27, 1993
Romero
23. ABAKADA Guro Party List v Hon Exec. Eduardo Ermita
GR NO: 168056 September 1, 2005
Austria-Martinez
24. White Light Corporation v City of Manila
GR NO: 122846 January 20 2009
Tinga
Equal Protection
25. Patricio Dumlao v Commission on Elections
GR No: L-52245 January 22, 1980
Melencio Herrera
26. Tele and Broadcast Attorneys of the Philippines v COMELEC
GR No: 132922. April 21, 1998
Mendoza
27. Panfilo Lacson v Executive Secretary
GR NO: 128096 January 20, 1999
Martinez
28. ISAE v Leonardo Quisumbing
GR NO: 128845. June 1, 2000
Kapunan
29. Eleazar Quinto v Commission on Elections
GR NO 189698 February 22,2010
Puno
OUTLINE WEEK 2
I.

Searches and Seizures

Art III Sec 2 , Sec 3

A. Requirements for Search Warrants

1. Bache & Co v Ruiz 37 SCRA 823

2. Prudente v Dayrit, 180 SCRA 69
3. Salazar v Achacoso 183 SCRA 149
4. Stonehill v Diokno 20 SCRA 383 exclusionary rule
What may be seized Rule 126, Sec 3, Rules of Court

B. When Search may be made Without Warrant (warrantless search)

Rule 113, Sec 5, Rules of Court

Search and Seizure by private persons

5. People v Marti, 193 SCRA 57
a. Custom Searches
b. Moving Vehicle

c.

6. Papa v Mago 22 SCRA 857

7. People v Lo Ho Wing 193 SCRA 122
Incident of Valid Arrest

8.
Nolasco v Cruz Pano 139 SCRA 152, 147 SCRA 599
d. Things seized are within plain view
9.
Roan v Gonzales 145 SCRA 687
10. People v Asio 177 SCRA 250
11. Pita v Court of Appeals 178 SCRA 362
e. Stop and Frisk
12. Posadas v CA 188 SCRA 288
13. People v Musa 217 SCRA 597
C. Strict enforcement of the need for arrest warrants
14. People v Burgos 144 SCRA 1
15. Prof. Randolf David v Pres GMA 489 SCRA 160
N.B Immunity from Arrest of Members of Congress Art VI, Sec 11
D. When arrest may be made without a warrant

Rule 113 Sec 5, Rules of Court

a. Continuing Crimes of Subversion
16. Umil v Ramos 187 SCRA 311 , 202 SCRA 251
b. Illegal Possession of Guns or Drugs

17. People v Linsangan 195 SCRA 784

E. Issuance of Warrants of Arrest v Search warrants

Compare Rule 112 Sec 6 with Rule 126, Sec 4

18. Soliven v Makasiar, 167 SCRA 393

19. Samulde v Salvani 165 SCRA 734
F. Constitutionality of Checkpoints and Areal Target Zonings

II.

20. Valmonte v De Villa 173 SCRA 256

21. Guazon v De Villa 181 SCRA 623
Rights of Persons under Custodial Investigation

Art III Sec 12

RA No 7438

A. Miranda Warnings
22.
23.
24.
25.

Miranda v Arizona 384 US 436

People v Duero 104 SCRA 379
People v Andag 96 SCRA 861
People v Ramos 122 SCRA 312

B. Exceptions
a. Confessions executed before Jan 17 1973
26. People v Ribadajo 142 SCRA 637
b. Res Gestae Statements
c.

27. People v Dy 158 SCRA 111

Administrative Investigations
28. People v Ayson 175 SCRA 216

d. Custodial Phase of Investigation Police Lineups

29. People v Compil 244 SCRA 135
30. De La Torre v CA 294 SCRA
31. Gamboa v Cruz 162 SCRA 642
32. US v Wade 388 US 218
e. Waiver of Right to Remain Silent and to Counsel in Writing and in the Presence of Counsel
33. People v Galit 135 SCRA 465
34. People v Jara 144 SCRA 516
35. People v Lucero 244 SCRA 425
C. Exclusionary Rule

Art 3 Sec 12 (3)

36.

New York v Quarels 104 S. CT 2626 (1984)