Make sure to do jurisdictional analysis [Does the additional claim arise’ ‘out of the same case or No Sw basic requirement of, 91367/a). To determine CNOF: +1. Whether such claims would commonly be heard together 2. whether the claims are against the same A| Federal Question eit feo aa Federal Question or Diversity {§1367() limitation does not facts (Game evidence, witnesses, theories of Jurisdiction? Apply Federal question(s lial, andlor whereduhen the claims arose) Tong as (a) apples! Diversity ONLY YES SMI 2 Claim brought by an? ‘tere bough by Adon under §¢ Yes oR 3 Heiter is "Yes, en Yes | eth claim broughtby an 3 lo loosnt a there is NO Supp. dx. i the cake ornate, Sear eee Ne '§1387(b) dossn' apply against Ajeinad under rule 14, 19,20, 0242 ‘and Supp Je. is ‘under §1367 ‘ule 19 or 247 § 1367(o) gives judges discretion fo decline the exercise of Supplomental be