NCQC 2013 Evaluation Criteria PRE - EVALUN Criteria MON OF QC CASE STUDY 1 | IDENTIFICATION OF PROBLEMS SELECTION OF PROBLEMS DEFINITION OF THE PROBLEM. ANALYSIS OF PROBLEM CAUSE - EFFECT ANALYSIS ROOT CAUSE ANALYSIS DATA ANALYSIS ON THE ROOT CAUSE 8 DEVELOPMENT OF SOLUTION 9 | FORESEEING PROBABLE RESISTANCE, 10/ TRIAL IMPLEMENTATION & CHECKING PERFORMANCE 11, REGULAR IMPLEMENTATION 12) FOLLOW UP/REVIEW & RECURRENCE PREVENTION PRE-EVALUATION TOTALEVALUATION OF REGISTER ED BY THE QUALITY CIRCLE 8. Criteria Max. No. Marks 1. | General Information (*Page No. 3, 8 to 11) 1 2. | Projects information (*Page No. 12 — 21) 1 3. | Attendance 1 4, | Meeting Minutes (Compare with Milestone chart of Case Study) 5 5. | Monitoring of Meeting Minutes (By HOD/Co-ordinator/Facilitator) 1 6. | Special features 1 Total 10 KNOWLEDGE TEST FOR QC TEAM 1. Knowledge test will be for the Quality Circle group as a whole with all members participating in answering it. Each circle will be given one question paper along with the criteria. The total marks for this will be 30 and the time duration allowed will be 30 minutes.EVALUATION CRITERIA FOR QC & ALLIED CASE STUDY PRESENTATION SL Max No. Criteria Marks 1 | Sequence, Clarity, Team Participation, Smooth change over from one speaker to another 10 2 |'Time Management 10 3 | Communication Skills, Confidence level 10 4 | Special features 10 5 | Answering satisfactorily & correctly the questions from judges | 20 TO L MARKS 60PRE-EVALUATION CRITERIA FOR ALLIED CONCEPT C SL. Max. No. Criteria Marks Explanation of the concept Defining the project taken Methodology used in the concept for project Result obtained Follow-up / ReviewMODEL PRESENTATION - EVALUATION CRITERIA SI. No. Particulars Max. Marks a Relevant to Presenting Project / Problem 10 b Creativity 10 c¢ — |Communication & Explanation 10 d —_ |Quality of Model 10 e |Special Effect 10 [TOTAL MARKS 50 CATEGORY OF AWARDS : A circle scoring between i) 50 & 60% Meritorious ii) 60 to 70% Distinguished iii) 70 to 80% Excellent iv) 80 & above Par Excellence.SI. No. Particulars KIT EVALUATION CRITERIA Max. Marks a Content b Dialogue Delivery c Dress & Make-Up a Co-ordination/ Communication e Time Management 100 TOTAL 300