Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Section
15
Syndromes
Endocrine Disorders
Abstract
was no difference in
sleep
complaints
between the cancer
and patients
Patients with cancer complain of fatigue before patients
with
medical
treatment, during chemotherapy or radiation therapy, and
conditions other than
1
after the completion of therapy. These patients also
cancer.5 Almost half
complain of sleep disruption.2 Both fatigue and poorof the group had a
sleep probably contribute to decreased quality of life. 3poor sleep efficiency
There is a growing body of literature on the relationship
between fatigue and the quality or quantity of sleep. This
chapter will review the evidence on cancer-related sleep
disruption and fatigue and their treatment, as well as the
possible contribution of poor sleep and desynchronized
circadian rhythms to cancer-related fatigue.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Sleep Disruption
The prevalence of sleep complaints in cancer patients has
been studied primarily in cross-sectional studies using
con-venience samples with heterogeneous definitions and
mea-sures of sleep disturbances. In a large questionnaire
study of over 900 patients with different types of cancer,
fatigue (44%), leg restlessness (41%), insomnia (31%),
and exces-sive sleepiness (28%) were the most prevalent
complaints.4 Another survey showed that 61% of the
cancer patients had significant sleep deficits, but there
1416
Chapter
123
patients.
These
studies found prevalence
rates
of
(defined
as
theinsomnia symptoms
percentage of timeof 48% in breast
spent asleep) belowcancer survivors and
85%. Those patients32% in prostate
receiving radiationcancer survivors. 8,9
insomnia
or
chemotherapyWith
tended to have moresyndrome defined as
sleep disturbancessleep-onset latency or
than
those
notwake after sleep
greater than 30
receiving treatment.onset
minutes, at least 3
In addition, sleepnights per week,
problems predictedassociated with a
deficits in quality ofsleep
efficiency
life.
lower than 85% and
Prevalence ratessignificant daytime
or
of
insomniaimpairments
symptoms
havemarked distress, the
were
ranged from 30% toprevalences
and
18%,
50%.6,7 Only two19%
8,9
In
studies
haverespectively.
attempted
to95% of the cases, the
distinguish betweeninsomnia syndrome
having subclinicalwas chronic (i.e.,
and clinical levels ofduration 6 months).
insomnia in cancer Not
much
is
patients with mixed cancer sites has found that the overall prevalence
rates of the insomnia syndrome and of insomnia symptoms (including
those with an insomnia syndrome) at baseline (T1i.e., before or right
after the surgery) were 27.2% and 56.4%, and they decreased to 21.3%
and 39.5% 2 months later (T2), respectively.11 The prevalence rates of
insomnia symptoms were highest in patients with breast cancer and
gyneco-logic cancer and lowest in patients treated for prostate cancer. The
PATHOGENESIS
Pathogenesis of Sleep Disruption
Patients with cancer may complain of insomnia, hyper-somnia, or both,
but the pathogenesis of this sleep disrup-tion can be quite varied.
Chemotherapy, radiation therapy, and hormone therapy may all contribute
to the problem, but studies looking at their different effects on sleep patterns are lacking. In addition, commonly administered analgesics such as
opioids, and antiemetic medications such as corticosteroids, are also
known to disrupt sleep.31 The estrogen deficiency induced by
chemotherapy and hormone therapy, the abrupt cessation of hormone
replace-ment therapy at cancer diagnosis, or an ovary removal may each
trigger or exacerbate preexisting hot flashes. A study using objective
measurements of both sleep and hot flashes in breast cancer survivors
showed that nocturnal hot flashes were associated with more wake time
mate total sleep time or overestimate wake time during the night.
In the same study, although there was no difference in the amount of
sleep-disordered breathing, the cancer patients had a higher prevalence of
periodic limb move-ments in sleep (PLMS) than insomnia patients or
healthy volunteers.17 However, more recently, in two small-scale studies
(17 and 33 patients), an elevated prevalence of obstructive sleep apnea
(OSA), ranging from 12% to 91.7%, was found in patients with head and
neck cancer.18 Prospective studies are warranted to investigate to what
extent OSA is caused by the cancer itself or by the cancer treatment.
Sleep-disordered breathing also appears to be frequent in patients with
brain tumors, with tumor removal resulting in a significant decrease in the
apneahypopnea index.19 An ongoing research study indicates that the
prev-alence of OSA in women with breast cancer who have completed
chemotherapy was 48%, and the prevalence of PLMS was 36%.20 These
high prevalence rates of PLMS and OSA may help explain some of the
sleep disturbance found in this population.
Actigraphy, a noninvasive, continuous, ambulatory measure of
circadian restactivity rhythms, has also been used to characterize the
sleep and rhythms of patients with cancer.21-24 Studies comparing cancer
patients to healthy controls have consistently shown less contrast between
daytime and nighttime activity in cancer patients, a pattern indicative of
circadian disruption.21,25 In a study of 85 women with breast cancer, 72hour actigraphy before the start of chemotherapy demonstrated a mean
total sleep time of 6 hours, with only 76% of the night spent asleep. On
average, the women napped for about 1 hour a day.23
Fatigue
Fatigue is one of the most frequent and disturbing com-plaints of patients
with cancer3,26: more than 75% of patients who undergo chemotherapy or
radiation therapy report feeling weak and tired. Cancer-related fatigue has
been defined as a persistent, subjective sense of tiredness related to
cancer and cancer treatment that interferes with usual functioning. 27 It is
believed to be distinct from general fatigue, as it is unrelated to exertion
level and is not relieved by rest or sleep. It has been reported that 76% of
patients receiving chemotherapy report fatigue at least a few days each
month,28 interfering with daily life, reduc-ing quality of life, 3,29 and being
one of the key reasons for discontinuing treatment.
An increasing number of studies in the past few years have followed
cancer patients over time. Overall, these studies suggest that fatigue is
highly prevalent before as well as during and after treatment. 26,29 In one
study, 66% of the women reported at least some fatigue before treat-ment
and 84% reported fatigue during treatment.23 Addi-tionally, the
percentage of women reporting extreme fatigue doubled from
approximately 5% before treatment, to approximately 10% during
treatment. Several studies have suggested that fatigue can continue for
months, and even years, after the completion of therapy. A recent systematic review of the literature identified 10 longitudinal studies on
cancer-related fatigue and concluded that can-cer-related fatigue may
persist for up to 5 years after com-pletion of adjuvant treatments.30
and more stage changes to lighter sleep.32
The amount of insomnia in cancer patients can be as high as the
amount found in depressed patients, so clini-cians should not overlook the
possibility that poor sleep in cancer patients may indicate some
psychological distress. However, there is evidence that, although
insomnia and psychological distress are interrelated, there are still a significant proportion of patients who have only insomnia. In one sample of
newly diagnosed breast cancer patients, insomnia was the most frequent
symptom, reported by 88% of the patients, and was correlated with high
levels of distress and anxiety.33 However, contrary to the belief that
disturbed sleep before treatment is attributable to the increased stress and
anxiety resulting from a recent diag-nosis of a life-threatening illness,
insomnia and fatigue were rated high even in those patients who rated
them-selves low on anxiety. Similarly, another study revealed that 46% of
prostate cancer survivors with an insomnia syndrome did not have
clinical levels of anxiety or depres-sive symptoms.9
Pain has often been thought to be the cause of sleep disruption, not
only in patients with cancer but also in patients with a multitude of other
medical conditions.2 It is not yet known whether the pain contributes to
poor sleep or whether the pain medications contribute to poor sleep, or
both. One hypothesis is that pain may be the initial cause of the frequent
awakenings, but psychological distress prevents the patient from falling
back to sleep.34 A second hypothesis is that while sleep leads to recovery
and repair of tissue and may offer a temporary cessation of the
psychological awareness of pain, poor sleep leads to difficulty managing
pain.35 In this way, a cycle of pain and poor sleep may become selfperpetuating. In a study examining the relationship between pain and
sleep disrup-tion, patients with breast cancer, lung cancer, insomnia (with
no cancer) and normal controls were questioned. Although those with
breast cancer reported pain before bedtime, neither their poor sleep nor
that of the patients with lung cancer was associated with reports of pain. 17
Another study conducted in patients with advanced cancer showed
significant correlations between pain and poor sleep quality.36 Moreover,
those patients with poor quality of life had the most disturbed sleep and
the highest levels of pain.
Physiological factors
e.g., pain
anemia
Psychological factors
e.g., depression
anxiety
Fatigue
Social/cultural factors
e.g., education
socioeconomic status
Chronobiological factors
e.g., sleep
circadian rhythms
Pathogenesis of Fatigue
Fatigue is believed to be caused by multiple factors, includ-ing physical
(e.g., cachexia, weight loss, and biochemical, hematologic, and endocrine
abnormalities) and psycho-logical (e.g., depression) and social factors
(Fig. 123-1). Anemia and other biochemical abnormalities are found in
cancer patients and cause fatigue, although hemoglobin levels are only
moderately related to fatigue and quality of life. One study examining the
incremental effect of increas-ing hemoglobin on quality of life found that
improving the anemia improved quality of life only to a point, beyond
which there was no further improvement.37 Alternative possible
physiologic mechanisms include inflammation (e.g., increased
proinflammatory cytokines), serotonin dys-regulation, hypothalamicpituitary-adrenal axis dysfunc-tion (e.g., altered cortisol response), and
altered muscle metabolism.38 Among these potential mechanisms, inflammation is probably the one currently receiving the most attention and is
believed to be a common pathway through which cancer and its treatment
would lead to a variety of behavioral consequences, including improved
fatigue and decreased sleep disturbances.38
Several studies have found significant relationships between reports of
fatigue and depression,26 but it is unclear to what extent these are
etiologically related. Indeed, depression is far less common than fatigue
in cancer patients, which suggests that fatigue often occurs independently.
Moreover, it has been shown that cancer-related fatigue is different from
fatigue experienced by patients with depression.
In addition, there is evidence that sleep disturbance is a significant
predictor of fatigue.39 Studies on symptom clus-ters have revealed that
sleep and fatigue are often part of a cluster of three or more symptoms. 40
Moreover, most cross-sectional and prospective studies found a strong
correlation between self-reported sleep complaints and fatigue.
Evidence on the relationship between circadian rhythms and subjective
ratings of fatigue have been mixed, with most studies finding a significant
relationship.24,41 Daytime inactivity and nighttime restlessness were
associated with higher subjective ratings of cancer-related fatigue in one
restlessness at treatment times compared with cycle midpoints when
higher activity during the day prevailed and there were fewer nighttime
awakenings.41,42 Others24 found that self-reported fatigue was
significantly associated with an actigraphy measure of sleepwake pattern
stability (i.e., similarity versus dissimilarity of rest and activity patterns
across time, a surrogate measure of circadian rhythm), but not with total
sleep time. Moreover, changes in fatigue from the second to the fourth
on-study chemotherapy cycles were significantly associated with changes
in the consistency of the sleepwake pattern. On the other hand, a study
of breast cancer patients before chemotherapy23 found no significant
TREATMENT
The complaints of sleep disturbances and fatigue in patients with cancer
are often overlooked in clinical practice and, when a treatment is initiated,
it is often a pharmacologic one (e.g., sedative-hypnotics for insomnia,
psychostimu-lants for fatigue). While pharmacologic therapy may be
appropriate at times, there is accumulating evidence sup-porting the
efficacy of alternative treatments including psychological treatments,
activity-based interventions, and bright-light therapy.
Sleep
PHARMACOTHERAPY
Hypnotic medications, particularly benzodiazepines, are by far the most
commonly prescribed treatment for sleep disturbances in cancer patients. 7
In 2005, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) State of the Science
Confer-ence on Insomnia concluded that the newer, shorter acting
nonbenzodiazepines were safer and more effective than the older, longeracting benzodiazepines for the treatment of insomnia. 43 More recently,
newer agents, such as a mela-tonin receptor agonist, have also been
approved by the
BEHAVIORAL THERAPY
The NIH State-of-the-Science Conference on Insomnia also concluded
that cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) is the most effective treatment
for primary insomnia.43 There is now also accumulating evidence
supporting its efficacy for insomnia in cancer survivors. 44,45 Overall,
these studies have been quite consistent in demonstrating that CBT
(combining stimulus control, sleep restriction, cognitive restructuring,
and sleep hygiene) results in increased sleep efficiency and reduced total
wake time, decreased psycho-logical distress, and improved general
quality of life. One study also showed changes in immune functioning 46
associ-ated with CBT for insomnia, but the clinical relevance of these
changes in terms of cancer prognosis or other health outcomes is
unknown. Although replication is needed, it appears that the effects of
CBT in improving sleep would be mediated by both nonspecific (i.e.,
treatment expectan-cies) and specific (i.e., reduced maladaptive sleep
habits and dysfunctional beliefs) factors.47
Some evidence from uncontrolled studies suggests that mindfulnessbased stress reduction interventions in cancer patients result in improved
daily sleep quality.48 However, as none of these studies selected patients
on the basis of a minimal insomnia severity, it is unclear whether this
inter-vention is potent enough to treat syndromal or chronic insomnia.
Fatigue
Numerous medications have been investigated for the treatment of
cancer-related fatigue, including hematopoi-etics (e.g., epoetin alfa,
darbepoetin alfa), psychostimulants (methylphenidate), antidepressants
(e.g., bupropion, par-oxetine), corticosteroids (e.g., methylprednisolone,
pred-nisone), L-carnitine, and modafinil. A recent literature review
concluded that hematopoietics are effective in reducing fatigue in patients
with anemia.49 Promising results have been obtained in open-label
prospective studies investigating the efficacy of other medication classes,
in particular psychostimulants and modafinil. However, data from
placebo-controlled trials, which would allow counterbalancing beneficial
and adverse effects, are warranted, as many of these drugs have
significant side effects.49
Several nonpharmacologic interventions for fatigue have been assessed
in cancer patients. A recent review of the literature identified a total of 41
publications, 24 assess-ing the efficacy of various psychological
interventions (e.g., cognitive-behavioral therapy) and 17 reporting on the
effi-cacy of activity-based interventions. 50 Overall, the effect size
obtained was of a small magnitude across all types of intervention and
outcome measures (e.g., fatigue, vigor). When types of intervention were
compared, a greater effect size was found for psychological interventions
than for activity-based interventions. It is noteworthy, however, that none
of these studies used heightened levels of fatigue as an inclusion criterion,
thus limiting the power to detect
patients is not confirmed, there may be a negative feedback loop such that
less light exposure desynchronizes patients circadian rhythms, which
then causes or deteriorates to fatigue, and fatigue further leads to less
light exposure.51
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS: IS IT
SLEEPINESS, FATIGUE, OR SOMETHING
ELSE?
The clinician needs to determine the cause of a patients symptoms,
recognizing that the words used by the patient to describe the symptoms
may be vague. Is the symptom related to sleepiness (the patient may
describe unintended episodes of falling asleep in the daytime or have an
elevated Epworth Sleepiness Scale score), or to fatigue (complaints of
muscular weakness, or lack of energy but not weakness)? Patients may
Fatigue and sleep disturbances are among the most common and
most distressing complaints of patients with cancer. When left
untreated, these symptoms can significantly impair patients
quality of life. Clini-cians should screen more routinely for these
distur-bances
and
administer
evidence-based
treatment
strategies to help patients coping with them.
Acknowledgements
Supported by: NCI CA112035, NIA AG08415, Moores UCSD Cancer
Center, the Research Service of the Veter-ans Affairs San Diego
Healthcare System, the Canadian Institutes of Health Research, the
Canadian Breast Cancer Research Alliance, and the Fonds de la
recherche en sant du Qubec.
This chapter is dedicated to the memory of Dr. J. Christian Gillin,
dear friend and colleague, who died of cancer. He was fatigued but he
never let it get to him. He was an inspiration and a role model to us
all.
REFERENCES
2. Fleming L, Gillespie S, Espie CA. The development and impact of insomnia on cancer
survivors: a qualitative analysis. Psychooncology In Press 2010.
6. Fiorentino L, Ancoli-Israel S. Insomnia and its treatment in women with breast cancer.
Sleep Med Rev 2006;10:419-429.
3. Enderlin
4. Davidson JR, MacLean AW, Brundage MD, et al. Sleep disturbance in cancer patients.
Soc Sci Med 2002;54:1309-1321.
5. Fortner BV, Stepanski EJ, Wang SC, et al. Sleep and quality of life in breast cancer
patients. J Pain Symptom Manage 2002;24:471-480.
7. Savard
8. Savard
9. Savard
10.
11.
12.
28.
13.
29.
14.
Curt GA, Breitbart W, Cella D, et al. Impact of cancer-related fatigue on the lives
of patients: new findings from the Fatigue Coalition. Oncologist 2000;5:353-360.
Visser MRM, Smets EMA. Fatigue, depression and quality of life in cancer
patients: how are they related? Support Care Cancer 1998;6:101-108.
30.
15.
31.
16.
32.
17.
33.
18.
34.
19.
20.
21.
35.
Lewin DS, Dahl RE. Importance of sleep in the management of pediatric pain. J
Dev Behav Pediatr 1999;20:244-252.
36.
37.
22.
38.
23.
39.
24.
40.
25.
26.
Ryan JL, Carroll JK, Ryan EP, et al. Mechanisms of cancer-related fatigue.
Oncologist 2007;12(Suppl 1):22-34.
27.
Mock V, Atkinson A, Barsevick A, et al. NCCN practice guidelines for cancerrelated fatigue. Oncology (Williston Park) 2000;14: 151-161.
41.
42.
Berger AM. Patterns of fatigue and activity and rest during adju-vant breast
cancer chemotherapy. Oncol Nurs Forum 1998;25: 51-62.
43.
44.
45.
46.
47.
48.
49.
Carroll JK, Kohli S, Mustian KM, et al. Pharmacologic treatment of cancerrelated fatigue. Oncologist 2007;12:43-51.
50.
Jacobsen PB, Donovan KA, Vadaparampil ST, et al. Systematic review and metaanalysis of psychological and activity-based interventions for cancer-related fatigue.
Health Psychol 2007;26:660-667.
51.
Liu L, Marler M, Parker BA, et al. The relationship between fatigue and light
exposure during chemotherapy. Support Care Cancer 2005;13:1010-1017.