Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 78

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project

Relay Co-ordination Studies

CTJV

OCT 2007

Mott MacDonald
1 Atlantic Quay
Broomielaw
Glasgow
G2 8JB
UK
Tel: 44 (0)141 222 4500
Fax: 44 (0)141 221 8083

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

List of Contents

Page

Chapters and Appendices


1 Introduction

1-1

2 Model Description and Modelling Methodology

2-1

2.1

Introduction

2-1

2.2

ETAP Software Package

2-1

2.3

System model Data


2.3.1 System Earthing
2.3.2 System Operation

2-2
2-2
2-2

3 Relay Setting Results and Discussion

3-1

3.1

Introduction

3-1

3.2

Relay Setting and Co-ordination Studies


3.2.1 Fault current matrix for relay settings
3.2.2 Guidelines for relay settings for 51, 50, 51N and 51G protection function
3.2.3 Guidelines for relay setting for 27 protection function
3.2.4 Guidelines for relay setting for 59 protection function
3.2.5 Guideline for relay setting for 49 protection function
3.2.6 Guidelines for relay setting for 46 protection function
3.2.7 Guidelines for relay setting for 66 protection function
3.2.8 Guidelines for relay setting for 37 protection function
3.2.9 Relay setting for 87 protection function / Interface with Kahramaa
3.2.10 Setting of 25 function for ATS at 33 kV and 6.6 kV levels
3.2.11 Over current protection for the LV systems

3-1
3-1
3-4
3-6
3-8
3-9
3-11
3-12
3-12
3-13
3-25
3-26

Appendix - A: Relay setting schedules

A1

A-1: LV relays setting schedule

A2

A-2: HV feeders relay setting schedule

A20

A-3: Interface with Kahramaa - Schedule for 87L and 87T protection

A25

A-3: 33/6.6 kV and 6.6/0.415 kV transformer relay setting schedule

A29

A-4: MV motor relay setting schedule

A33

Appendix - B: TCC for relay co-ordination

B1

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/i of i


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Table 1-1: Main protection functions set and relay used for the protection
Table 3-1: Fault levels at 132 kV main switchboard of the Kahramaa substation
Table 3-2: Current matrix for various ratings of transformer
Table 3-3: Fault current matrix for over current relay setting
Table 3-4: Permissible time delay for over current relay co-ordination
Table 3-5: Guideline for relay setting for under voltage protection
Table 3-6: Guideline for relay setting for over-voltage protection
Table 3-7: Setting group for REM 543 relay for thermal over load protection
Table 3-8: Time constant heating; Data assumed if not available
Table 3-9: Setting of 87L protection for 33 kV feeders from SB-27101 A/B
Table 3-10: Setting group for REF 542+ relay for 87T protection
Table 3-11: Setting of 87M protection for MV BOG compressors
Table 3-12: Direct on line starters with MCCB and INSUM-2, load up to 45kW
Table 3-13: Direct on line starters with MCCB and INSUM-2, load more than 45kW

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

1-1
3-1
3-2
3-3
3-4
3-6
3-8
3-9
3-10
3-14
3-21
3-24
3-27
3-28

Figure 3-1: Sample circuit diagram for relay setting guideline


3-4
Figure 3-2: Setting of 87L protection for 33 kV out going feeders from SB-27101 A/B on the relay
characteristic
3-15
Figure 3-3: Representation of 87L protection for 132 kV cable
3-16
Figure 3-4: Representation of 87T protection for TR-27101 A/B
3-19
Figure 3-5: Characteristic for the differential protection of REF 542 +
3-21
Figure 3-6: Three-phase stabilized differential protection for motors
3-23

ii

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/ii of i


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Summary and Conclusion


This report describes the results of the relay co-ordination studies performed for the QGX-CLP
development Project.
In this report, relay setting and co-ordination for QGX-CLP electrical distribution system (SS-2702
and SS-2701) are carried out for all voltage levels from 132 kV to 0.415 kV. Setting of protections
functions such as 87L, 87T, 87M, 81U, 27, 59, 49, 46, 47, 66, 50, 51, 50N, 51N, 51G etc. (as defined
in the relaying scheme documents) are covered. Down stream over-current relays are co-ordinated
with the up stream relays. At 0.415 kV level, MCCBs are co-ordinated with the up-stream over-current
relays. At all voltage levels the proper co-ordination of the relays and setting of various protection
functions are ensured for both minimum and maximum fault currents.
Time current characteristics (TCC) of the over-current relays at different voltage levels are presented
in the report. TCCs shows that the protection setting adopted are in line with the selective, sensitive
and fast operation of relays.
Siemens relays are mainly used in the HV system at 132 kV level while ABB relays are mainly used
in 33kV and below voltage levels.
Relay setting schedules are presented in Appendix - A and TCCs of the over-current protection are
presented in Appendix - B.

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Introduction

This report describes the relay co-ordination studies performed by Mott MacDonald on behalf of
Chiyoda Technip Joint Venture (CTJV) for the QGX-CLP (Qatar Gas II Common Lean LNG
Project) development project.
The electrical distribution system of the CLP network comprises of the substation SS-2701, SS-2702
and SS-2703. The substation SS-2701 is having option of power supply either from QGX system or
from the SS-2702. The substation SS-2702 (Lean LNG storage tank substation-2) is connected to the
Kahramaa substation through two 132 kV underground cables and the substation SS-2703 is supplied
from SS-2701. For the CLP system study the substation SS-2701 is considered to be supplied from the
substation SS-2702.
In this report, integrated relay setting of various protection functions and co-ordination of various
relays are presented. Main protection functions for which the relay settings are carried out are shown
in Table 1-1.

S.No.

ANSI Number

Protection Name

Relay Type used

87-T & 87-N

Transformer differential

7UT612, REF542+

87-L

Line differential

7SD53, SOLKOR-N, REL 561

87-M

Motor differential

REM 543

49

Motor Thermal

REM 543

27

Under voltage

REF 542+, REM 534

59

Over voltage

REF 542+, REM 543

46

Unbalance current

REM 543

47

Phase sequence voltage

REM 543

66

Max. motor starts

REM 543

37

Under power

REM 543

51, 51N, 51G

Over current / EF

REF 542+, REM 543

10

50, 50N

Instantaneous O/C and E/F

REF 542+, REM 543

11

81U

Under frequency

REF 542+

Table 1-1: Main protection functions set and relay used for the protection

1-1

221661/02/B - 05/10/2007 /1-1 of 1


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Model Description and Modelling Methodology

2.1

Introduction

This section describes the electrical distribution system for the QGX-CLP development project, the
modelling methodology adopted and the data used in performing the electrical system studies.
Included within this section is a description of the following:

Software package

EATP model development

The ETAP representation of the QGX-CLP electrical network is presented in electrical system studies
report1 already submitted.
2.2

ETAP Software Package

Fault level and relay co-ordination studies are carried out using version 5.0.3 of ETAP PowerStation,
developed by Operation Technology, Incorporated. This package uses standard models of the main
components in the power system in combination with numerical techniques to solve the various
electrical and mechanical equations describing the system. The system model and parameters are
entered into the model using the ETAP network schematic capture facility.
The main components represented in the ETAP model are as follows:
Synchronous machines: A standard two-axis equivalent circuit model is used to represent
synchronous machines. This model includes sub-transient, transient and synchronous reactances and
their associated time constants and allows full dynamic modelling of transient events. Stator and rotor
saturation are accounted for, as are the alternator and prime mover inertia.
Asynchronous (induction) machines: These elements are modelled based on their per-phase
equivalent circuit parameters. The equivalent circuit data is manipulated to create a two axis transient
model that also includes the motor and driven load inertia and the load torque-slip curve. The
dynamic simulation therefore takes account of the motor and load dynamics. The model also accounts
for the momentary and decaying current contribution that asynchronous machines will make into a
system short circuit.
Transformers: These are modelled as equivalent pi impedance network. The zero sequence
impedance, and winding connections are included in the model. This is used to assemble the correct
zero sequence network representation when calculating earth fault currents.
Cables: Cables (and transmission lines) are modelled by a circuit of fixed positive sequence
impedance and shunt susceptance. A pi impedance network is used to represent the circuit with half of
the total circuit capacitance connected as a shunt element at each end of the circuit.

Electrical system studies for QGX-CLP development protect; Load flow, short circuit and motor starting studies Rev A;
Mar 2007, report submitted by Mott MacDonald Ltd.

2-1

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/2-1 of 1


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Controllers: The prime mover turbines and voltage regulator/exciter system associated with
synchronous machines are included as transfer function block diagrams and associated gains and time
constants.
Relays:
Over current relay specific to manufacturer and model are available with all setting
ranges and typical ANSI and IEC curves for inverse, very inverse and other characteristics. By
selecting one particular setting of current and time delay the same can be projected on TCC (on loglog scale) to view the possible operation time for various currents.
2.3

System model Data

The ETAP single line representation of the QGX electrical system is based on CTJV General Single
Line Diagram for the Electrical System2. The system model3 used for system study is used for the
relay co-ordination.
2.3.1

System Earthing

The QGX electrical system earth fault levels are generally limited by neutral earthing resistors that are
organised as follows:

132 kV

- Solidly earthed

33 kV

- limited to 400 A by each transformer NER

11 kV

- limited to 400 A by unit transformer NER (unit fed compressor motors)

6.6 kV

- limited to 400 A by each transformer NER;

0.415 kV

- limited to 10 A by each transformer NER.

2.3.2

System Operation

Various transformer configurations were considered in the studies for calculation of the minimum and
the maximum fault current calculation. The following definitions are used throughout the report when
referring to transformer connections:

Dual transformers each switchboard section is fed in isolation by its associated transformers.
This is the normal operating configuration for the system.

Single transformers two or more switchboard sections are fed via a single transformer. This is to
consider a case where there is a single transformer outage and its load is taken up by another unit.
For a switchboard fed by three or more transformers, it is not expected that one unit would be
rated to supply the whole load.

CTJV, QATARGAS II DEVELOPMENT PROJECT General Single Line Diagram, Dwg. N: QGX/20/91/EL/DR/SD/001
Rev C2
3
Electrical system study for QGX-CLP development project Mar-2007 (Study report for load flow, short circuit, motor
starting) submitted by Mott MacDonald Ltd.

2-2

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/2-2 of 2


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Relay Setting Results and Discussion

3.1

Introduction

Methodology used for relay setting and co-ordination of relays are presented in the various sub-section
below. Based on that relay setting schedules and TCC of the over current relays are prepared.
3.2

Relay Setting and Co-ordination Studies

The relay setting and co-ordination studies are carried out for various relays and protection functions
presented in the Table 1-1. Before carrying out the relay setting, a fault current matrix for various
voltage levels is prepared.
The current matrix gives important information for the minimum and maximum fault currents seen by
each relay at various locations in the system, based on which proper discriminated, sensitive and coordinated protection can be achieved.
In order to achieve the uniform relay setting for the feeders having similar rating of transformers and
loads guidelines are prepared for setting of the various protection functions.
3.2.1

Fault current matrix for relay settings

Current matrix is calculated for faults at voltage levels. The following tables present the current
matrices.
The minimum and maximum three-phase fault levels at 132 kV main switchboard of the Kahramaa
substation4 are presented below:
S.No.

Fault level

Three-phase fault current (kA)


at 132 kV main switchboard of
the Kahramaa substation

X/R ratio

The minimum

10.2

12.05

The maximum

15.47

6.48

Table 3-1: Fault levels at 132 kV main switchboard of the Kahramaa substation

Email from Vincent Sauvergrain to Manoj Gupta, dated 31/08/2007, subject: QGX-CLP-MMD electrical studies-Company
and KM comments

3-1

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/3-1 of 1


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

S.No
1
2
3
4
5
6

Transformer
Tag
Name
TR-27101 A/B
TR-27601
TR-27204 A/B
TR-27201 A/B
TR-27301 A/B
DTR-27302 A/B

Primary
Voltage

Secondary
Voltage

KV
132
33
33
33
6.9
6.9

kV
33
11
6.9
6.9
0.44
0.44

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Transformer
Rating
Min
Max
MVA
MVA
80
100
25
25
20
25
12
15
1.6
1.6
1
1

Full load current (FLC)


Inrush
(kA)
Current Type
I-Min
I-Max
I-Min
I-Max
(Multiple
Primary Primary Secondary Secondary of FLC)
0.35
0.437
1.4
1.75
7
Step down
0.437
0.437
1.312
1.312
7*
HV Distribution
0.350
0.437
1.674
2.092
4.75
MV Distribution
0.210
0.262
1.004
1.255
5.19
MV Distribution
0.134
0.134
2.100
2.100
7.31
LT Distribution
0.084
0.084
1.312
1.312
11.66
LT Distribution

Table 3-2: Current matrix for various ratings of transformer


* Assumed data (Higher side value is considered for protection margins)
Fault current matrix for fault currents at various voltage levels and associated fault current flow at higher voltage levels is presented in Table 3-2 below

3-2

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Three-phase fault current when supplied


from Kahramaa S/S
Minimum (kA)
Maximum (kA)
21.17
22.34
21.17
22.34
1.38
1.45

Fault location

Fault current
observation

0.415 kV
SB-27302A

SB-27302A
Bus section
6.6 kV incomer

0.415 kV
SB-27301A

SB-27301A
Bus section
6.6 kV incomer

28.12
28.12
1.83

30.22
30.22
1.98

6.6 kV
SB-27201 A

SB-27201A
6.6 kV incomer
Bus section
33 kV TR-27201
33 kV incomer
132 kV CLP

10.08
10.08
10.08
2.06
2.06
0.52

16
11
11
2.34
1.51
0.4

6.6 kV

SB-27205A
6.6 kV incomer
Bus section
33 kV TR-27204
33 kV incomer
132 kV CLP

11.81
11.81
11.81
2.41
2.41
0.62

17
11.73
11.73
2.89
1.68
0.45

33 kV TR-27603
Bus section
33 kV incomer
132 kV CLP

9.02
9.02
9.02
2.31

13.92
13.92
9.46
2.52

132 kV CLP

9.5

13.92

132 kV CLP
(LG fault current)

10.05

15.17

SB-27205A

33 kV
TR-27603

132 kV
TR-27101A

Table 3-3: Fault current matrix for over current relay setting
For the minimum three-phase fault current calculation, the minimum fault level at Kahramaa S/S and
no motor contribution are considered. For the maximum fault current calculation, the maximum fault
level at Kahramaa S/S and motor contributions are considered. All faults currents are as per
IEC 60909 symmetrical breaking currents. Earth fault current is restricted to the value as indicated in
the Section 2.3.1 due to the resistance grounded system.

3-3

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

3.2.2

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Guidelines for relay settings for 51, 50, 51N and 51G protection function

The following guidelines are adopted for the relay settings

Time discrimination between the relays

The Circuit protection Time Interval (CTI)5 for the over current relay settings is presented
below
S.No.

Components

CTI with field test (s)


Static / Electronics relays

Circuit breaker opening time 5 cycles

Relay over travel

Relay tolerance and error

0.1
0
0.12

Total CTI

0.22

Table 3-4: Permissible time delay for over current relay co-ordination
Hence it is practical to have CTI for the electronics relays as low as 0.22 s. CTI provides the
necessary time delay between the operations of the two relays and ensure co-ordinated
operation.

Guideline for setting of the over current relays

A sample circuit is shown below with a transformer and load. Relay locations are presented
by A, B and C. Fault is presented on the primary side and secondary side of the transformer
by Fp and Fs respectively.
C
Fp

B
.

A
Fs
Figure 3-1: Sample circuit diagram for relay setting guideline

IEEE Std. 242-2001: Chapter 15 Over current protection

3-4

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

For the over current protection following guidelines are adopted

The characteristic of the relays at A, B and C for over current protection is normal
inverse. Exception can be made for the relay at A, if associated with a motor protection,
then it may be definite time or extremely inverse.

Relay at B and C must not operate for the maximum full load current of the transformer.
The pickup is set between 115-150% of the full load current depending on the coordination with the down-stream and up-stream relays.

Relay at C must not operate for inrush current of the transformer, to ensure this the
pickup setting of the instantaneous element must be more than the inrush current as
indicated in the Table 3-1

For the fault Fs, the instantaneous elements of the relay at A should give protection,
backup by the over-current element of the B and C. The instantaneous element of the
relay at B will not be co-ordinated as the same is used for blocking of ATS (Automatic
transfer system)6 in event of fault at the secondary side of the transformer. Pickup values
for the instantaneous element at B are considered as follows
o

At 33 kV level set pickup = 2 kA

At 6.6 kV level set pickup = 4 kA

At 0.415 kV level set pickup = 10 kA

The instantaneous element of C should provide protection for the fault Fp

In no case the minimum CTI should be violated for the maximum fault current seen by
the relays

Because earth fault current is limited by the NGR, definite time characteristics are
adopted to co-ordinate all 51N and 51G protection functions.

Characterise of the fuse are as per the ABB fuse manual7. The fuse characteristics as
given on page 13 of the manual are modelled in ETAP.

The TCCs for the over current protection is presented in the Appendix B.

6
7

Secondary selective systems, document number QGX/20/19/EL/TS/NA/026


PowerIT Motor Circuit Fuses, CMF/CEF ABB catalogue 1YMB631051-en

3-5

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

3.2.3

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Guidelines for relay setting for 27 protection function

For the under voltage protection the following settings are considered

S.No.
1
2

Under voltage element


U< = 0.1 - 1.2 Un
t< = 40 - 30,000 ms

For Motor
0.7
500 ms

For Transformer
0.7
70 ms

Table 3-5: Guideline for relay setting for under voltage protection

Under voltage relay at transformer secondary is used for ATS operation as shown in
figure below. During the operation of 50, 50N or 27 immediate transfers of the loads
to the other main bus (S1-R) should not occur otherwise that bus (S1-R) will also see
the fault. For this reason operation time of the 27 and ATS should be time delayed to
allow the operation of 51, 51N at each outgoing feeder to disconnect the faulty
feeders from the bus (S1-L), if the fault is at the outgoing feeders. Hence the
additional time delay is used for this purpose. Time delay of 2s is provided by the
27X of the ATS.

The action can be summarised as follows:

For faults at transformer secondary side the ATS operation is blocked by the
instantaneous over-current relays 50 and 50N as well as 27

For the low voltage at the secondary of the transformer by opening the primary
CB motor under voltage operates first followed by under voltage relay on the
transformer secondary with the time delay of 70 ms that activates the transfer
logic of ATS. The ATS operates after a delay of 2s by opening the primary CB of
the affected transformer, then opening secondary CB of the transformer and
closing the bus coupler. In this way the bus S1-L is transferred to the bus S1-R.

3-6

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

P1-L

P1-R
C

"#
$

27X at 33kV: Time delay = 2 s


27X at 6.6kV: Time delay = 3 s
27X at 415V: Time delay = 3.5 s

!
"#
%
'(

S1-L

Time delay of the 27X is taken care by


the control logic. The following time
delays are suggested for the 27X
operation at different voltage levels

S1-R

A
Fs
"#&
&
Figure 3-1A: ATS operation Interaction with over-current and under voltage relays

3-7

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

3.2.4

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Guidelines for relay setting for 59 protection function

For the over voltage protection the following settings are considered

S.No.
1
2

Over voltage element


U> = 0.1 - 3.0 Un
t = 40 - 30,000 ms

For Motor
1.15
5000

Table 3-6: Guideline for relay setting for over-voltage protection

Motor starting results reveals that the maximum post transient over voltages after the motor
start are as high as 1.1 pu for less than 100 ms. Considering the result of the motor starting the
low set U> of the 59 function is set to 1.15 pu with a time delay of 5s.

3-8

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

3.2.5

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Guideline for relay setting for 49 protection function

For the thermal over load protection (49) of the MV motors, REM 543 (ABB) is used. For the
LV motors the setting of the thermal protection is presented in Appendix A1.
3.2.5.1 49 protection function for ABB REM 543 relay

S.No.

Setting Parameter

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21

Ist = 0.1-10.00 In
Tst = 0.1 - 120.0 s
NC-st = 1-3
Device Type = 0-6
Trip Temp. = 80-120 %
Alarm Temp. = 40-100%
Reset Temp. = 40-100%
Am Temp.= -50-100 Deg C
TC-cooling = 1.0-10.0
TC-Heating = 1-999 min
ST-CS = 0.0-999.0 min
LT-CSS = 0.0-999.0 min
p = 0.0 - 1.0
S-TR =50-350 Deg C
Tmax S = 0.0-350 Deg C
ST-CR = 0.0-999.0 min
LT-CR = 0.0-999.0 min
p = 0.0 - 1.0
R-TR =50-350 Deg C
Tmax R = 0.0-350 Deg C
Trip Delay = 0-86400 s

Sample
Data
3.5
12
3
3
120
90
60
50
3
45
14.00
69
0.5
90
155
4
69
0.25
100
200
3600

Remarks
Starting current
Starting time
Number of starts allowed from cold
Surface cooling
Trip temperature
Alarm temperature
Reset temperature
Ambient Temp.
* TC-Heating
Time constant
Short TC - Stator
Long TC - Stator
Wt. factor
Stator Temp. rise at FL
Stator Max. Temp
Short TC - Rotor
Long TC - Rotor
Wt. factor
Rotor Temp. rise at FL
Rotor Max. Temp
60 min

Table 3-7: Setting group for REM 543 relay for thermal over load protection
Explanations of the above setting parameters are presented below

Ist is set as per the individual motor starting current

Tst is set as per the individual motor starting time

NC-st is set as per the individual motor data

Device type8 is set for motor rating > 500 kW and surface cooling

Relay technical data sheet: ABB ProtectIT Machine Terminals REM 543 and REM 545, document number:
1MRS751173-MBG

3-9

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Trip Temp. is set to 120% with Trip Delay of 60 min (3600s). It means that from
motor temperature in the range of 100-120%, warning alarm will be generated until
time delay of 60 min, for temperature more than 120%, tripping will occur
instantaneously.

Alarm Temp. is set at 90%

Reset Temp. is set at 60% of the thermal capacity

Am. Temp. is set at 50 Deg. C

TC-cooling is set at 3 times the heating time constant. For motors less than 1300 kW
it is taken as 6.0

TC heating is set according to individual motor data. Following values are used
when the data is not available

S.No.

Motor rating

Time constant Heating (Min)

Less than 1300 kW

30

1300 kW to 2000 kW

35

2100 kW to 3000 kW

40

More than 3000 kW

45

Table 3-8: Time constant heating; Data assumed if not available

Settings from ST-CS to TMAX R are taken as default setting for wide range of motor
ratings, except for S-TR and R-TR. The value of S-TR and R-TR for motors above
2000 kW is 90 and 100 respectively and for motors between 1000 kW to 2000 kW is
70 and 80 respectively.

3-10

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

3.2.6

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Guidelines for relay setting for 46 protection function

For current unbalance protection (for ABB REM 543) the following settings are considered

Operation mode = Inverse time (2)

Pick up Is = 0.05

K is calculated for individual motor in such a manner that the tripping time of the
relay is below the thermal damage curve. For motors above 2500 kW the thermal
damage limit is taken as 15s and below that it is 10s.

Thermal damage curve is plotted using I2 * t = 15 (10).


And the motor tripping time is plotted for (I2 Is2) * t = K
For successful tripping the tripping curve must lie below the thermal damage curve.

Operation time = Not applicable as the operation mode is not definite time

Start delay = 1 s

Minimum operation time = 7 s

Maximum operation time = 3600 s

Cooling time = 1800 s

For ABB make REM 5439 relay inverse time characteristic is used for this function.

Negative Phase Sequence Protection ABB document no. 1MRS752310-MUM, Issued 10/1998, Version
E/24.11.2003
3-11

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

3.2.7

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Guidelines for relay setting for 66 protection function

For protection function 66 (for ABB make, REM 543) the following settings are considered

Operation mode = 2 (Both I2t and stall protection)

Starting current = From the motor data sheet

Start time = 1.1 * motor start time (10% margin)

Time limit = Number of hot starts * start time

Countdown rate = 3 * start time

Stall time = From the motor data sheet

The protection function is also used to derided the 51LR protection function using the
NOC3High (I>>)10 of the over- current protection. Output of the 66 protection function (using
MotStart) is applied as input to NOC3High to double the setting of the NOC3High during the
motor start-up duration. Once the motor reaches to its normal speed the NOC3High is
returned to the actual setting (which set at 0.75 * Motor starting current). In this way 51LR is
achieved during the motor start-up and the motor normal running condition. During the motor
start-up the 51LR function is provided by the MotStart (66 protection function) and during the
motor normal running condition the 51LR function is provided using the NOC3High of the
over-current protection.
3.2.8

Guidelines for relay setting for 37 protection function

For protection function 37 (for ABB make, REM 543) the following settings are considered
Minimal load = 5%, Minimal current = 5%
Op. time = 300 s (5 min)

10

Email from Toshiaki Saito to Manoj Gupta; dated 28/09/2006; subject: QGX : 51LR protection of REM543
(SL19020); attachment: Motstart_ver_0.10.pdf
3-12

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

3.2.9

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Relay setting for 87 protection function / Interface with Kahramaa

The differential protection as indicated in Table 1-1 is used for cables, transformers and
motors protections. The differential protection is a unit protection and setting of this function
required detailed analysis. The following sections present the calculation of the differential
protection for various equipments using different relays.

3.2.9.1 Setting of 87L protection for 33 kV outgoing feeders


Relay type: Solkor-N
Setting is based on the minimum fault current basis, in this case the earth fault current, hence
the differential current setting is equal to earth fault current. For the bias current setting
minimum through fault is considered to be equal to two times the full load plus the earth fault.
Based on these criteria the setting points are presented in Table 3-8 and on the relay
characteristic by black dots in Figure 3-2.
In the Figure 3-2, operating point of the relays are shown to test the stability of the relay
under EF condition with relatively higher value of the restraint current (2 * FLC + EF) / 2. If
for the operating point falls inside the relay selected characteristic then the relay will operates
for other higher value of the phase current as well. Hence in the figures below operating
points of the relays are shown by black dots to present a case in which differential current is
equal to the EF current and the bias current is (2*FLC + EF)/2. The operating point will assist
to select the correct value of relay setting such as B2 and Is

3-13

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

33 kV feeder To

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

TR-27204 A/B

TR-27601 to TR-27605

TR-27201 A/B

MaxLoad Current/ Cable


Rating (A)

438

438

263

CT Ratio (to 1A)

600

600

400

Primary EF Current (A)

400

400

400

Relay Bias Current (x In)


Relay Differential Current
(xIn)

1.06

1.06

1.16

0.67

0.67

1.00

Minimum Differential
Allowed wrt to Ic (x In)

0.1

0.1

0.1

Diff Setting Chosen

0.2

0.2

0.2

Bias Break point Chosen

Table 3-9: Setting of 87L protection for 33 kV feeders from SB-27101 A/B
Same setting is used for both sending end and receiving end of the 33 kV feeder cables
Ic: Relay bias current

3-14

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Solkor N - Bias Characteristic


Is = 20% ,S1=20% , S2=150% , B2= 0.5, 1, 1.5, 2

Operate or Differential Current (x


IN )

2.500

2.000

1.500

1.000

B2 = 2.5

0.500

0.000
0.00000

0.50000

1.00000

1.50000

2.00000

2.50000

3.00000

Restraint or bias Current (x I N )


Figure 3-2: Setting of 87L protection for 33 kV out going feeders from SB-27101 A/B on the relay characteristic
3-15

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

3.2.9.2 Interface with 132 kV Kahramaa substation - Setting of 87L protection


Relay Type: 7SD53 (Siemens) and REL 561 (ABB)
132 kV Kahramaa S/S

800/1

REL 561

800/1

7SD53

3*1C 1000 Sqmm


2850 m
XLPE
800/1

7SD53

800/1

REL 561

132 kV CLP- SS2702


Figure 3-3: Representation of 87L protection for 132 kV cable
Cable charging current = 20 A (Approximately)
Guidelines adopted for 87L relay settings are

Pickup for differential current (I-Diff>) should be more than 2.5 time the charging
current

5% CT error should be added for calculation of the differential current

Charging current compensation is not required as the charging current is only 20A

Harmonic current stabilisation feature should be set to On

No additional time delay is required either for I-Diff> or for I-Diff>>

For dual slope characteristic relay, set the first slope to 50%, second slope to 100%,
and intersection of slope 1 and slope 2 to 350% of I-bias.

Same setting of the differential protection should be adopted for both the ends of
cable if CT ratios at both the ends are same.

3-16

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Calculations of relay setting parameters for 7SD53 are presented below

Setting of I-Diff>
I-Diff> = (2.5 * Charging current + 5% CT ratio error) / CT ratio
= (2.5 * 20 + 0.05 * 800) / 800
= 0.1125
Adopted setting for I-Diff> = 0.12

Setting of I-Diff> Switch On


Setting of the I-Diff> is increased to the minimum 3 times during cable energization
I-Diff> Switch On = 3 * I-Diff>
= 3 * 0.12 = 0.36
Adopted setting for I-Diff> Switch On = 0.36

Time delay for I-Diff> = 0.0s

Time delay for I-Diff>> = 0.0s

Charging current compensation = OFF

I-Diff>> = Min ( 3* Full load current, Line-line fault current) / CT ratio


= Min ( 3 * 300 A, 7.45 kA) / 800
= 1.125
Adopted setting for I-Diff>> = 1.25

I-Diff>> Switch On = 4 * I-Diff>>


= 4 * 1.25
=5

Inrush Restraint = On

2nd Harmonic restraint = 30%

Cross block = No

Maximum Inrush Peak = 9.0 (Based on 11 * Transformer full load RMS current)

3-17

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Calculations of relay setting parameters for REL 561 are presented below

Operation = On

CT factor = 1 (Because CT ratio of both sides of the cable are same)

IminSat (Minimum current for CT saturation detection)


Adopted setting = 300%

Iminop (Pick for differential current)


I-Diff> for 7SD52 is 12%, in REL 561 the minimum setting available is 20%
Adopted setting = 20%

IDiffLVl1 (Slope 1 of the relay characteristics)


IDiffLVl1 = 50%

IDiffLVl2 (Slope 2 of the relay characteristics)


IDiffLVl2 = 100%

ILV1/2Cross (Intersection of the slope 1 and slope 2)


ILV1/2Cross = 350%

Evaluate = 3 of 4 (Refer relay manual for this setting)

Asymdelay (Asymmetrical time delay in data communication between the two ends)
Asymdelay = 0.0 (Refer relay manual for this setting)

Diff Sync (For synchronising the operation of relays at two ends)


Set Diff Sync = Master (For the relay at Kahramaa Substation)
Set Diff Sync = Slave (For the relay at CLP SS-2702 substation)

CCom (Charging current compensation)


Set CCom to Off

Complete relay setting schedule for the 87L protection is listed in Appendix A3, for the
132 kV feeders C30 and C40.

3-18

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

3.2.9.3 Interface with 132 kV Kahramaa substation - Setting of 87T protection


for TR-27101A/B
Relay Type: 7UT612
This relay provides the differential protection for the 80 MVA, 132/33kV transformer
connecting the Kahramaa substation to SS-2702 substation.
132 kV
600/1

TR-27101 A/B
80 MVA
Z = 12.5%

87 T
87N

7UT612

400/1

2000/1
33 kV
Figure 3-4: Representation of 87T protection for TR-27101 A/B
Calculations of the relay setting parameters are presented below

Setting of differential current (Id>)

The relay should have minimum restrain for magnetising current (assumed to be 2% of full
load current) , CT errors (considered to be 5%) at full loads and should consider the effects of
transformer tap operations
Using the formula shown below minimum restraint current = 0.07
Minimum restraint current (Is) = (5% of Isecondary / CT ratio) + (5% of Iprimary / CT ratio)
Isecondary = X * FLC (FLC: Full load current)
Iprimary = X * FLC
X = 1.15 (15% allowable overload is considered)
Adding the differential current at full load due to CT ratio mismatch, the minimum
differential current = 0.07 + 0.11 = 0.18
Considering the safety margin, CT saturation and transformer tap operation set Id> to 0.25 In
3-19

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Add on Stabilization
Setting of the Add on Stabilization is based on the inrush current magnitude.
Inrush current for TR-27101A/B = 7 * Full load current
= 7 * 350 = 2450 A
The inrush current seen at CT secondary = 2450 / 600 = 4.08
Adopted setting for Add on Stabilization = 75% of 4.08In = 3.0 In

Set Action time = 250 cycles

High set differential current (Id>>)

Setting of Id>> is calculated based on the formula given in the manual of 7UT612 on page 37
Id>> = (Transformer Full load current / CT primary) / Z (pu)
= (350/ 600) / 0.125 = 4.7 In
Adopted setting for Id>> = 4.7

Pickup on switch on = 1 (No shifting of the characteristic during switching)

TD for Id> = 0.0, TD for Id>> = 0.0

I2N / IfN = 30% (2nd harmonic restraint ratio)

InfN / IfN = 30% (5th harmonic restraint ratio)


Cross block = 0
Time for cross bloc = Deactivated

Calculation of setting parameters for 87N protection (Setting group of Restricted Earth
Fault (64) are use for 7UT612)
Secondary side Neutral CT ratio = 400/1
Line CT ratio = 2000/1

Set I-REF> to 100 A


I-REF> = 100 / 400 = 0.25

Set time delay = 0

Slope = 0

Because earth fault current is limited to 400A hence chances of CT saturation and error due to
through fault current is remote. Complete relay setting schedule for the 87T protection for the
transformer TR-27101 A/B is presented in the Appendix A3.

3-20

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

3.2.9.4 Setting of 87T protection for 33/6.6 kV and 132/33 kV transformers


Relay type: REF 542+
Basic setting groups for the transform differential protection for the ABB make REF 542 plus
relay are presented below for the 87T protection of TR-27101A/B
S.No.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13

Setting Parameter
VG = 0 - 11
Earthing P: Yes / No
Earthing S: Yes / No
Ip = 10 - 100000 A
Is = 10 - 100000 A
Ith = 0.1 - 0.5 Ir
URL = 0.5 - 5.0 In
SBRT = 0.2 - 2.0
SBRL = 1.00 - 2.00 Ir
Slope = 0.4 - 1.0
Trip Id> = 5.00-40.00
I2 Block= 0.1 - 0.3
I5 Block = 0.1 - 0.3

Sample Data
0
Yes
Yes
350
1400
0.2
0.5
0.25
1
1
5
0.3
0.3

Remarks
Transformer vector group
Rated primary side current
Rated secondary current
Threshold current
Unbiased region limit
Slightly biased threshold
Slightly biased region limit
Third region slope
Upper Id threshold for trip
2nd harmonic threshold
5th harmonic threshold

Table 3-10: Setting group for REF 542+ relay for 87T protection

Id =

Id>

I1 I2

R3

R1: Unbiased region

Trip only without


2nd and 5th
harmonics

R2: Slightly biased region


R3: Heavily biased region
Slope

SBRT
It

R2

R1

URL

SBRL

Ib = (I1 + I2) / 2

Figure 3-5: Characteristic for the differential protection of REF 542 +


Area above the thick black line is the trip area and below is the no trip region
3-21

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Explanation of the individual setting parameter is presented below

VG: Vector group is set to 11 as all MV transformer as Dyn11

Ip and Is are set according to the individual transformer rating

Ith: Threshold current for the unbiased region (R1) is set to 20%, considering the
maximum CT error of +5% and -5% at both ends of the transformer for through fault
condition
For 33/6.9 kV transformers Ith is set to 10%

URL: Unbiased region limit is set to 0.5In corresponding to 50% of the full load

SBRT: Slightly biased region threshold (R2) is set to 25%


For 33/6.9 kV transformers Ith is set to 20%

SBRL: Slightly biased region limit is set to 1.0, corresponding to full load
Slope is set to 1 so that wider area is covered under tripping zone and at the same
time higher than the minimum setting to provide the sufficient bias during through
fault condition and CT situation conditions.
For 33/6.9 kV transformers Ith is set to 0.5

Trip Id> is set at 5.0, which is higher than the inrush current

I2 Block and I5 Block for the harmonic current is taken as to be at the default set
value

3-22

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

3.2.9.5 Setting of 87M protection for motor


Relay Type: REM 543
Differential protection of the motors using REM 543 is based on stabilized three-phase differential
protection11. Basic relay characteristic is shown below

Figure 3-6: Three-phase stabilized differential protection for motors


The setting groups are as follows

Basic setting (Id>): Pickup for the differential element (5 50 %)

Turing point 1: Value of Ib/In from where the first slope starts (0.0 1.0 In)

Starting ratio: Slope of the line after the Turning point 1 (10 - 50%)

Turning point 2: Value of Ib/In from where second slope starts (1.0 3.0 In)

Inst. Setting (Id>>): Instantaneous differential element pickup (5.0 30.0 In)

11

Diff6G-Stabilized Three-Phase Differential Protection for Generators ABB document number 1MRS752302-MUM,
version C/18.1.2002

3-23

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Settings adopted for BOG compressor motor relay are set as under

S.
No.

Motor Rating (kW)


Calculation parameters

9500

CT ratio

700/1

Basic setting (Id>) [5 50%]

10

Turing point 1 [0.0 1.0 In]

0.5

Starting ratio [10 50%]

50

Turning point 2 [1.0 3.0 In]

1.5

Inst. Setting (Id>>) [5.0 30 In]

5.0

Table 3-11: Setting of 87M protection for MV BOG compressors

3-24

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

3.2.10 Setting of 25 function for ATS at 33 kV and 6.6 kV levels


Relay type: REF 542+
The relay operates when the Delta Voltage and Delta Angle are within the set limits for a specified
Time Delay, based on this
Delta Voltage = 0.05 pu
Delta Angle = 10 Degree
Time Delay = 15s
Explanations of the above setting are given below
Settings are as per the operating criteria described in the relay manual12
Delta V is set as per the allowable LF voltage limits for HV and MV (5%) switchboards
Delta Angle is set to 10 (More than this value may be the indicator of the overloads / faults on the
switchboards). This is also supported by the load flow result under normal condition, where the buses
angle were found to be near to 5 degree while in the single transformer operation exceeding 10 degree
at 6.6 kV switchboards, in all these cases of LF Delta Angle is within 10 degree.
Time delay is set to 15s to give enough time before Delta V and Delta Angle remain within the set
values.

12

Relay REF 542+ manual Protection functions: configuration and settings ABB document number
1VTA10002 Rev03, en
3-25
221661/02/B - OCT 2007
P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

3.2.11 Over current protection for the LV systems


LV motors and static loads protections are provided by the ABB make INSUM-2 relay. INSUM13 has
an inbuilt CT which can be used for loads up to 63A, for loads more than 63 A an external CT is used
to scale down the current as per the requirement of the application. ABB make MCCB with static
release type PR221 and PR111 are used for the loads more than 45kW. Tables 3-11 and 3-12, presents
the different type of MCCB used for different rating of LT loads and related setting of the releases.
Settings of the INSUM-2 for each type of load as shown in the Tables 3-11 and 3-12 are presented in
Appendix A. TCCs of MCCBs are already reported in company approved QGX relay setting studies
report14.
For the five LNG circulating pumps (415V - 104.4 kW) supplied by the LDB Siemens panels, the
protection relay in use is GE multilin MM2, setting of which is provided by CTJV15 and presented in
Appendix A-1.

13

MCU parameter description Ver. 3.0, ABB document on the INSUM relay
Electrical system study for QGX, Company approved report Relay co-ordination studies Rev G, July 07, report
submitted by Mott MacDonald Ltd. To CTJV
15
Email from Vincent to Manoj Gupta; dated 28/09/2007; subject: RE: QGXE2A4042 / CLP - LDB Relays in Satellite SS2701A, SS-2702A/B/C Settings; Attachment: MM2 Setpoint File Information.pdf
14

3-26

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

S.

No.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19

Cub

Size
6E
6E
6E
6E
6E
6E
6E
6E
6E
6E
6E
6E
6E
6E
6E
6E
6E
12E
12E

Motor

kW
0.18
0.25
0.37
0.55
0.75
1.1
1.5
2.2
3
4
5.5
7.5
11
15
18.5
22
30
37
45

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

MCCB

I (A)
0.72
0.83
1.1
1.5
2
2.8
3.5
5
6.6
8.6
11.5
15.2
22
28.5
36
42
56
68
83

Type
T2H160 MF 1
T2H160 MF 1
T2H160 MF 1.6
T2H160 MF 1.6
T2H160 MF 2
T2H160 MF 3.2
T2H160 MF 4
T2H160 MF 5
T2H160 MF 8.5
T2H160 MF 11
T2H160 MF12.5
T2H160 MA 20
T2H160 MA 32
T2H160 MA 52
T2H160 MA 52
T2H160 MA 52
T2H160 MA 80
T2H160 MA 80
T2H160 MA 100

Magnetic
Tripping
current (A)
13
13
21
21
26
42
52
65
110
145
163
200
288
364
468
520
800
960
1200

I1

MCCB Setting
t1
I2
t2

I3

13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
10
9
7
9
10
10
12
12

Contactor

INSUM

Interpose

QGX Type
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A16
A26
A26
A30
A50
A50
A50
A50
A50
A63
A75
A95
A110

TYPE
MCU2 0.1-3.2 A
MCU2 0.1-3.2 A
MCU2 0.1-3.2 A
MCU2 0.1-3.2 A
MCU2 0.1-3.2 A
MCU2 63 A
MCU2 63 A
MCU2 63 A
MCU2 63 A
MCU2 63 A
MCU2 63 A
MCU2 63 A
MCU2 63 A
MCU2 63 A
MCU2 63 A
MCU2 63 A
MCU2 63 A
MCU2 0.1-3.2 A
MCU2 0.1-3.2 A

CT
KORC 1A 105/1 S
KORC 1A 105/1 S

Table 3-12: Direct on line starters with MCCB and INSUM-2, load up to 45kW

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

3-27

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Cub
Size

Motor
kW I (A)

I1

MCCB Setting
t1
I2
t2

I3

Contactor
QGX
Type

INSUM
TYPE

Interpose
CT

T4H250 PR221-I In 160

Tripping
current
(A)
1360

20

12E

55

98

8.5

A145

MCU2 0.1-3.2 A

KORC 1A 105/1 S

21

12E

75

135

T4H250 PR221-I In 250

1875

7.5

A185

MCU2 0.1-3.2 A

KORC 1A 185/1 S

22

16E

90

158

T4H250 PR221-I In 250

2000

A210

MCU2 0.1-3.2 A

KORC 1A 185/1 S

23

16E

110

193

T4H320 PR221-I In 320

2080

6.5

A260

MCU2 0.1-3.2 A

KORC 1A 310/1 S

24

Cub600

132

232

E2N1250In400 PR121/LI

2400

0.8

12

N/A

MCU2 0.1-3.2 A

SUCCESS 400/1 A

25

Cub600

FDR

630

T5H630In630 PR221-LSI

2835

4.5

26

Cub600

FDR

800

S6H800In800 PR212-LSI

6400

S.
No.

Type

MCCB

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Table 3-13: Direct on line starters with MCCB and INSUM-2, load more than 45kW

221661/02/B - OCT 2007


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

3-28

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Appendix - A: Relay setting schedules

The relay setting schedule is organised as follows


A1: LT relays setting schedule
A2: 33 kV feeders relay setting schedule
A3: 33/6.6 kV and 6.6/0.415 kV transformer relay setting schedule
A4: MV motor relay setting schedule

A1

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/1 of 1


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

A-1: LV relays setting schedule


Setting Guideline for Auto-Restart Function
With referring to the Annexure-III (Motor Auto Restart Study) of the QGX relay setting report13, autoRestart setting is provided for the LV motors required to be re-started as per the following guideline;
Device Duty: Function 27
Setting Parameter:

Reset Voltage Level (RVL)


Range: 50 - 100%
Setting: 90%

Max Auto Re-closing Time (MAT)


Range: 0.0 - 5.0sec
Setting: 0.0sec16

Max. Power down Time (PDT)


Range: 0 - 1200sec
Setting: 5sec (Refer Note-1 below)

Staggered Start Time (SST)


Range: 0 -1200sec
Setting: Refer Note-2 below

Note-1: Referring to the Annexure-IV (Transformer Energization Study) of the QGX relay setting
report13.
Note-2: Setting value to be as per "Switch-In Time" for each priority group specified in Annexure-III
(Motor Auto Restart Study) of the QGX relay setting report13.

16

Email from Toshiaki Saito to Manoj Gupta dated 22/06/2007; Subject: Re: QGX : Wrap-up Comment on Relay
Coordination Study (INSUM Setting)

A2

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/2 of 2


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies
S.N Cub.
o. Size

Rated Rated I Protection


kW
A
Type

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

INSUM
Device
CT ratio
Setting range
TYPE
Duty
Schedule for LV (0.415 kV) feeders
ST

Setting

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 0.10 - 3.20 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
49

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
1

6E

0.18

0.72

TYPE -C

MCU2

Remark

0.72
6
5

Nominal current
Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
10
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec

0.1 - 3.2A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

27

A3

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

Alarm Only
Measure
1
Alarm level
0.3

Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
0
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
Of the QGX Rev G report

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/3 of 3


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV
ST

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 0.10 - 3.20 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
49

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
2

6E

0.25

0.83

TYPE-C

MCU2

27

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

ST
MRD

49

0.37

1.1

TYPE-C

MCU2

Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
As per Motor Data
10
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
Alarm level
80
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

As per Motor Data

In = 0.10 - 3.20 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
6E

Nominal current

0.1 - 3.2A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

0.83
6
5

1.1
6
5

Nominal current
Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
10
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec

0.1 - 3.2A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

27

A4

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
Of the QGX Rev G report

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/4 of 4


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV
ST

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 0.10 - 3.20 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
49

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
4

6E

0.55

1.5

TYPE-C

MCU2

27

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

ST
MRD

49

0.75

TYPE-C

MCU2

Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
As per Motor Data
10
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
Alarm level
80
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

As per Motor Data

In = 0.10 - 3.20 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
6E

Nominal current

0.1 - 3.2A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

1.5
6
5

2
6
5

Nominal current
Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
10
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec

0.1 - 3.2A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

27

A5

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
Of the QGX Rev G report

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/5 of 5


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV
ST

MRD

49

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

As per Motor Data

In = 2.0 - 63.0 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
6

6E

1.1

2.8

TYPE-C

MCU2

2.8
6
5

27

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

ST

Enable
Standard
10
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
Alarm level
80
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
Auto reclosing time
0
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 2.0 - 63.0 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
49

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
6E

1.5

3.5

TYPE-C

MCU2

Startup ratio

2.0-63.0 A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

Nominal current

3.5
6
5

Nominal current
Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
10
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec

2.0-63.0 A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

27

A6

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
Of the QGX Rev G report

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/6 of 6


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV
ST

MRD

49

6E

2.2

TYPE-C

MCU2

2.0-63.0 A

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

As per Motor Data

In = 2.0 - 63.0 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
Trip Delay
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

27

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

ST

5
6
5

Trip Only
400%
5sec
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
Alarm level
80
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
Auto reclosing time
0
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

As per Motor Data

In = 2.0 - 63.0 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
9

6E

6.6

TYPE-C

MCU2

Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
10
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level

MRD

49

Nominal current

6.6
6
5

Nominal current
Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
10
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec

2.0-63.0 A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

27

A7

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
Of the QGX Rev G report

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/7 of 7


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV
ST

MRD

49

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

As per Motor Data

In = 2.0 - 63.0 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
10

6E

8.6

TYPE-C

MCU2

8.6
6
5

27

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

ST

Enable
Standard
10
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
Alarm level
80
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
Auto reclosing time
0
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 2.0 - 63.0 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
49

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
6E

5.5

11.5

TYPE-C

MCU2

Startup ratio

2.0-63.0 A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

11

Nominal current

11.5
6
5

Nominal current
Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
15
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec

2.0-63.0 A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

27

A8

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
Of the QGX Rev G report

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/8 of 8


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV
ST

MRD

49

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

As per Motor Data

In = 2.0 - 63.0 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
12

6E

7.5

15.2

TYPE-C

MCU2

15.2
6
5

27

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

ST

Enable
Standard
15
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
Alarm level
80
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
Auto reclosing time
0
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 2.0 - 63.0 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
49

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
6E

11

22

TYPE -C

MCU2

Startup ratio

2.0-63.0 A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

13

Nominal current

22.0
6
5

Nominal current
Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
15
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec

0.1 - 3.2A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

27

A9

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
Of the QGX Rev G report

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/9 of 9


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV
ST

MRD

49

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

As per Motor Data

In = 2.0 - 63.0 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
14

6E

15

28.5

TYPE-C

MCU2

28.5
6
5

27

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

ST

Enable
Standard
15
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
Alarm level
80
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
Auto reclosing time
0
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 2.0 - 63.0 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
49

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
6E

18.5

36

TYPE-C

MCU2

Startup ratio

2.0-63.0 A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

15

Nominal current

36.0
6
5

Nominal current
Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
15
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec

2.0-63.0 A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

27

A10

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
Of the QGX Rev G report

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/10 of 10


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV
ST

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 2.0 - 63.0 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
49

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
16

6E

22

42

TYPE-C

MCU2

27

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

ST
MRD

49

30

56

TYPE-C

MCU2

Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
As per Motor Data
15
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
Alarm level
80
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

As per Motor Data

In = 2.0 - 63.0 A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
6E

Nominal current

2.0-63.0 A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

17

42.0
6
5

56.0
6
5

Nominal current
Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
15
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec

2.0-63.0 A
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A

27

A11

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level

Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
Of the QGX Rev G report

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/11 of 11


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies
0.1 - 3.2 A

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

ST

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

Ext CT1 Ip = 10 - 6300A


Ext CT Is = 0.01 - 3.20 A

105
1

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 10.5 - 105A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
49

18

12E

37

73.5

TYPE-B

MCU2

KORC 1A

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A
27

0.1 - 3.2 A

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

ST

73.5
5.6
6

Enable
Standard
15
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level
Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III

105
1

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 10.5 - 105A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s

19

12E

45

84

TYPE-B

MCU2

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
KORC 1A
Trip Delay
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A
27

A12

Startup ratio

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

Ext CT1 Ip = 10 - 6300A


Ext CT Is = 0.01 - 3.20 A

49

Nominal current

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

84.0
5.9
5

Nominal current
Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
15
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level
Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III

Of the QGX Rev G report

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/12 of 12


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies
0.1 - 3.2 A

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

ST

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

Ext CT1 Ip = 10 - 6300A


Ext CT Is = 0.01 - 3.20 A

105
1

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 10.5 - 105A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
49

20

12E

55

105

TYPE-B

MCU2

KORC 1A

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A
27

0.1 - 3.2 A

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

ST

105.0
5.3
6

Enable
Standard
29
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level
Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III

185
1

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 18.5 - 185A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s

21

12E

75

129.5

TYPE-B

MCU2

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
KORC 1A
Trip Delay
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A
27

A13

Startup ratio

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

Ext CT1 Ip = 10 - 6300A


Ext CT Is = 0.01 - 3.20 A

49

Nominal current

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

129.5
6.2
5

Nominal current
Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
13
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level
Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III

Of the QGX Rev G report

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/13 of 13


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies
0.1 - 3.2 A

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

ST

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

Ext CT1 Ip = 10 - 6300A


Ext CT Is = 0.01 - 3.20 A

185
1

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 18.5 - 185A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
49

22

16E

90

166.5

TYPE-B

MCU2

KORC 1A

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A
27

0.1 - 3.2 A

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

ST

166.5
5.7
6

Enable
Standard
15
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level
Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III

310
1

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 31 - 310A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s

23

16E

110

186

TYPE-B

MCU2

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
KORC 1A
Trip Delay
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A
27

A14

Startup ratio

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

Ext CT1 Ip = 10 - 6300A


Ext CT Is = 0.01 - 3.20 A

49

Nominal current

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

186.0
5.7
6

Nominal current
Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
12
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level
Enable
415
80
Alarm level
70
Trip level
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
0
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III

Of the QGX Rev G report

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/14 of 14


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV
ST

0.1 - 3.2 A

NR-DOL/RCU Starter Type

Ext CT1 Ip = 10 - 6300A


Ext CT Is = 0.01 - 3.20 A

400
1

MRD

As per Motor Data

In = 40 - 400A
Ist = 1.0 - 10 In
Tst = 1 - 600s
49

24 Cub600

132

240

TYPE-A

MCU2

Success

Function TOL
TOL Type
t6 = 5 - 40s
CDTF = 1 - 100
AL = 50 - 100%

51 LR Stall Protection
Trip Level
Trip Delay
51 G Function EF
Method
RCT Ip = 1,5,50 A
AL = 0.1(0.1)<Ip A
27

For the five LNG circulating pumps


Siemens panels are presented below:

(415V

Function 27
Un = 230 - 690 V
AL = 50 - 100%
U< = 50 -100%
t< = 0.2 - 5 s
RVL = 50 - 100 %
MAT = 0.0 - 5.0 s
PDT = 0 - 1200 s
SST = 0 - 1200s

104.4

kW)

240.0
5.8
6

Nominal current
Startup ratio

Enable
Standard
18
As per Motor Data
4
cool down time fact.
90
Alarm level
Trip Only
400%
5sec
Alarm Only
Measure
1
0.3
Alarm level
Enable
415
80
70
0
Trip delay for DOL/RCU
90
Reset Voltage Level
0
Auto reclosing time
5
Note-1
As per annexure-III
Of the QGX Rev G report

supplied

by

the

LDB

27-MP 7111and 27-MP 7112 at the switchboard LDB 27302


27-MP 7113 at the switchboard LDB 27305
27-MP 7114 and 27-MP 7115 at the switchboard LDB 27306
The protection relay in use is GE multilin MM2, setting of which is provided by CTJV17 and presented
below:

17

Email from Vincent to Manoj Gupta; dated 28/09/2007; subject: RE: QGXE2A4042 / CLP - LDB Relays in Satellite SS2701A, SS-2702A/B/C Settings; Attachment: MM2 Setpoint File Information.pdf

A15

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/15 of 15


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

A16

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/16 of 16


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

A17

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/17 of 17


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

A18

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/18 of 18


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

A19

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/19 of 19


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

A-2: HV feeders relay setting schedule

S.No.

Switch
Board
ID

Voltage
(kV)

Panel
Number

Feeder
Name

Device Type /
Manufacturer

CT
ratio

Device
Duty

Setting range

Setting

Remark

Schedule for 33 kV feeders

2000/1
1

SB27101A

33

A1
B1

Incoming
A/B TR27101 A/B

51

I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5

50

I>> = 0.05-40

50N

REF 542 +
51N

51G
400/1

A20

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/20 of 1


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

t>> = 0.02 to 300s


I0>> = 0.05 - 40
k = 0.05 - 1.5

0.95
Curve = NI
0.12

Output to ATS

0.02
0.05
0.05 (NI)

Output to ATS

I0>> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5
t0>>DT = 0.04 to 300s

0.05
Curve = DT

I0> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5
t0>DT = 0.04 to 300s

I0>0.25
Curve = DT

0.42

t0>DT = 0.72

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

S.No.

Switch
Board
ID

Voltage
(kV)

Panel
Number

Feeder
Name

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Device Type
/
Manufacturer

CT
ratio

Device
Duty
51

SB27101A

SB27101A

33

33

A2
B2

A4
B4

TR-27204
A/B

TR-27604
TR-27605

REF 542 +

REF 542 +

Setting range
I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5

50

I>>> = 0.05-40
t>>> = 0.015 to 300s

27

U< pickup (relay logic)


Time delay

51N

I0> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
t0>DT = 0.04 to 300s

51

I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5

Setting

Remark
0.75

Curve = NI
0.15
9.85
0.015

600/1

600/1

A21

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/21 of 2


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

50

I>>> = 0.05-40
t>>> = 0.015 to 300s

27

U< pickup (relay logic)


Time delay

51N

I0> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
t0>DT = 0.04 to 300s

50%
4s

CB Open
(Not to trip)

I0>0.15
Curve = DT
t0>DT = 0.12
1.25
Curve = EI
0.2
10.35
0.015
50%
4s
I0>0.15
Curve = DT
t0>DT = 0.12

CB Open
(Not to trip)

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

S.No.

Switch
Board
ID

Voltage
(kV)

Panel
Number

Feeder
Name

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Device Type /
Manufacturer

CT
ratio

Device
Duty
51

SB27101A

33

A5
B5

TR-27603
TR-27606

REF 542 +

600/1

SB27101A

33

A6
B7

SB-27104
SB-27105

REF 542 +

600/1

Remark

I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5

Curve = EI

1.25
0.2

I>>> = 0.05-40
t>>> = 0.015 to 300s

27

U< pickup (relay logic)


Time delay

51N

I0> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT

I0>0.15
Curve = DT

t0>DT = 0.04 to 300s

t0>DT = 0.12

I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5

Curve = EI

50

I>>> = 0.05-40
t>>> = 0.015 to 300s

27

U< pickup (relay logic)


Time delay

51N

I0> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
t0>DT = 0.04 to 300s

A22

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/22 of 3


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Setting

50

51

Setting range

10.35
0.015
50%
4s

1.65
0.05
6.85
0.015
50%
4s
I0>0.15
Curve = DT
t0>DT = 0.12

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

S.No.

Switch
Board
ID

SB27101A

SB27102
SB27103

Voltage
(kV)

33

33

Panel
Number

A7
B6

RMU
outgoing
feeder
to SB27201

Feeder
Name

SB-27102
SB-27103

RMU
outgoing
feeder

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Device Type /
Manufacturer

REF 542 +

7SJ600

CT
ratio

Device
Duty

400/1

400/1

Setting range

Setting

51

I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5

0.75
Curve = NI
0.29

50

I>>> = 0.05-40
t>>> = 0.015 to 300s

6.85
0.15

27

U< pickup (relay logic)


Time delay

50%
4s

51N

I0> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
t0>DT = 0.04 to 300s

I0>0.25
Curve = DT
t0>DT = 0.12

51

I> = 0.1-4
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 3.2

Curve = NI

0.7
0.2

50

I>>> = 0.1-25
t>>> = 0.0 to 60s

6.9
0.01

27

U< pickup (relay logic)


Time delay

50%
4s

51N

I0> = 0.05-25
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
t0>DT = 0.0 to 60s

A23

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/23 of 4


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Remark

I0>0.25
Curve = DT
t0>DT = 0.12

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

S.No.

Switch
Board
ID

Voltage
(kV)

Panel
Number

Feeder
Name

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Device Type /
Manufacturer

CT
ratio

Device
Duty
51

SB27104
SB27105

33

RMU
outgoing
feeder BOG
Compressor

RMU
outgoing
feeder

7SJ600

600/1

A24

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/24 of 5


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Setting range
I> = 0.1-4
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 3.2

Setting

Remark
1.6

Curve = EI
0.05

50

I>>> = 0.1-25
t>>> = 0.0 to 60s

6.9
0.01

27

U< pickup (relay logic)


Time delay

50%
4s

51N

I0> = 0.05-25
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT

I0>0.15
Curve = DT

t0>DT = 0.0 to 60s

t0>DT = 0.12

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

A-3: Interface with Kahramaa - Schedule for 87L and 87T protection
S.No.

Switch
Board
ID

Voltage
(kV)

Panel
Number

From

1A

SS-2702

33

All
outgoing
33 kV
feeders

SS-2702

Device Type /
Manufacturer

CT
ratio

Device
Duty

33

All
outgoing
33 kV
feeders

Setting range

Schedule for line differential protection


Id> = 0.1 - 2.5 In
up
BS1 = 20 - 150 %
A7
stream
BS2 = 30 - 150 %
400/1
Ibreak = 0.5 - 20.0 In
td> 0.0 - 10 s
Solkor-N
87L
Down
CT Ratio Cor = 0.50 - 1.0
B6
stream
CT Ratio Cor = 0.50 - 1.0
400/1
Internal Trip = ON, OFF
External Trip = ON, OFF
Delay Ex. Trip = 0.0 - 10s
A2-A6

From

1B

Feeder
Name

up
stream
600/1
Solkor-N
B2-B5, B7

87L

Down
stream
600/1

A25

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/25 of 1


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Id> = 0.1 - 2.5 In


BS1 = 20 - 150 %
BS2 = 30 - 150 %
Ibreak = 0.5 - 20.0 In
td> 0.0 - 10 s
CT Ratio Cor = 0.50 - 1.0
CT Ratio Cor = 0.50 - 1.0
Internal Trip = ON, OFF
External Trip = ON, OFF
Delay Ex. Trip = 0.0 - 10s

Setting

0.1
20
150
1
0.05
1
1
OFF
ON
0
0.1
20
150
1
0.05
1
1
OFF
ON
0

Remark

Differential current
1st Bias slope
2nd Bias slope
Bias break point
Differential delay
At up-stream relay
At down stream relay

External trip delay


Differential current
1st Bias slope
2nd Bias slope
Bias break point
Differential delay
At up-stream relay
At down stream relay

External trip delay

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

S.No.

Switch
Board
ID

Interface
with KM
132 kV
SSRLS2

Voltage
(kV)

132

Panel
Number

132 kV
KM S/S
Outgoing
feeders
to QGXCLP

Feeder
Name

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Device Type /
Manufacturer

7SD53

132

87L

800/1

C30
132 kV
KM S/S
Outgoing
feeders
to QGXCLP

Device
Duty

800/1

C30

C40

Interface
with KM
132 kV
SSRLS2

CT
ratio

800/1
REL 561

C40

87L

800/1

Setting range
I-Diff> = 0.1 - 20.00 A
I-Diff>Switch On
TD I-Diff>= 0.0 - 60.0 s
T310 Iphas = 0.0 to 0.5 s
Ic-Com = ON, OFF
IcSTAB/IcN = 2.0 - 4.0
I-Diff>> = 0.8 - 100.0 A
I-Diff>>Switch On
Inrush restraint = ON, OFF
I2/In = 10 - 45%
Cross block = NO, YES
Imax-inrush = 1.1 - 25.0 A
Cross B 2HM
CTFactor = 0.4-1.0
IminSat = 100-1000% In
IminOp = 20-150% In
IdiffLvl1= 20-150% Ib
IdiffLvl2= 30-150% Ib
ILvl1/2Cross = 100-1000% Ib
Evaluate = 2 of 4, 3 of 4
AsymDelay = 0.0 - 5.0 ms
DiffSync = Mater, Slave
CCComp = ON, OFF

A26

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/26 of 2


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Setting
0.12
0.36
0
0
OFF
1.25
5
ON
15
NO
9
0
1
300
20
50
100
350
3 of 4
0
Master
Slave
OFF

Remark
I-Diff> pickup value
I-Diff> under switch on
Time delay for I-Diff
Charging current comp.
Ic stabilization
I-Diff>> pickup value

2nd Harmonic % of In
Max. inrush peak value

CT matching factor
Imin for saturation detection
Idiff pickup
Slope 1
Slope 2
Slope 2 intersection
Tripping condition
Asymmetrical delay
At Kahramma substation
At QGX-CLP SS-2702
Charging current comp.

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

S.N
o.

SB
ID

SB27101

Voltage
(kV)

33

Panel
Number

A1
B1

Feeder
Name

TR-27101
A/B

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Device /
Manufactur
er

7UT612

CT
ratio

Up
stream
800/1

Device
Duty

87T

Down
stream
2000/1

Setting range
Diff. Prot.
INC. CHAR.START
INRUSH 2. HARM.
REST.n.HAR.
I-Diff>Mon
I>Curr. GUARD
DIFFw.IE1-MEAS
DIFFw.IE2-MEAS
I-DIFF> 0.05 - 2.00 (0.01)
T I-DIFF> = 0.0 - 60.00s
I-DIFF>> = 0.5-35.0 (0.1)
T-IDIFF>> = 0.0 - 60.00s
SLOPE 1= 0.1 - 0.5
BASE Point1 = 0.0 - 2.00
SLOPE 2 = 0.25 - 0.95
BASE Point2 = 0.0 - 10.0
I-REST. STARTUP = 0.0 - 2.0
START-FACTOR = 1.0 - 2.0
T START MAX = 0 - 180s
I-ADD ON STAB = 2.0 - 15.0
T ADD ON STAB = 2- 250
2. HARMONIC = 10- 80%
CROSSB.2.HARM = 2-1000
n. HARMONIC = 10 - 80%
CROSSB.n.HARM = 2-1000
IDIFFmax.n.HM = 0.5 - 20
I-DIFF>MON
T I-DIFF>MON = 1 - 10s

A27

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/27 of 3


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Setting
ON
OFF
ON
5. Harm
ON
0
NO
NO
0.25
0
4.7
0
0.25
0.5
0.5
1
0.1
1
0
3
250
15
20
30
0
1.5
0.25
2

Remark

Increase of trip char.


Inrush 2nd Harm. Restraint
nth Harmonic Restraint
Diff. current monitoring
I> for current guard

Id> pickup
Time delay for Id>
Id>> pickup
Time delay for Id>>
Differential relay characteristic
I-RESTRAINT for start detc.
Factor for increasing Char.
Starting time
Pickup for ADD on Stability
Cycles for ADD on stability
2nd Harmonic Content in Id>
Cycles for cross block 2nd harm.
nth Harmonic in Id>
Cylces for cross block nth harm.
Limit Id> max for nth harm. Rest.
Diff current for monitoring
Monitoring time delay

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

S.No.

Switch
Board
ID
SB27101

Voltage
(kV)

Panel
Number
A1

33

Feeder
Name

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Device Type /
Manufacturer

TR-27101
A/B

7UT612

33
B1

2000/1

TR-27101
A/B

REF 542 +

87N

87T

VG = 0 - 11
Earthing P: Yes / No
Earthing S: Yes / No
Ip = 10 - 100000 A
Is = 10 - 100000 A
Ith = 0.1 - 0.5 Ir
URL = 0.5 - 5.0
SBRT = 0.2 - 2.0
SBRL = 1.00 - 2.00 Ir
Slope = 0.4 - 1.0
Trip Id> = 5.00-40.00
I2 Block= 0.1 - 0.3
I5 Block = 0.1 - 0.3

Down
stream
2000/1

A28

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/28 of 4


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Setting range
REF Prot = ON, OFF,
BLOCK
I-REF> = 0.05 - 2.0 In
TD-IREF = 0.0 - 60.0 s
Slope = 0.00 - 0.95

Up
stream
800/1

A1
SB27101

Device
Duty

400/1

B1

CT
ratio

Setting

Remark

ON
0.25
0
0.5

I REF> pickup value


Time delay
Slope of characteristic
0

Transformer vector gp.

Yes
Yes
437
1750
0.2
0.5
0.25
1
1
5
0.3
0.3

Threshold current
Unbiased region limit
Slightly biased threshold
Slightly biased region limit
Third region slope
Upper Id threshold for trip
2nd harmonic threshold
5th harmonic threshold

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

A-3: 33/6.6 kV and 6.6/0.415 kV transformer relay setting schedule


S.
Switch
No
Board ID
.

Voltage
Feeder Name
(kV)

Device Type /
Device
CT ratio
Setting range
Manufacturer
Duty

Schedule for 6.6 kV switch board SB-27204


51 I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5
t>DT = 0.02 to 300s
50
2500

50N
51N

51G
400/1
REF 542 +

1 SB-27204

6.6

I0> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5
t0>DT = 0.04 to 300s
U< = 0.1 - 1.2 Un
t< = 40 - 30,000 ms

87

VG = 0 - 11
Earthing P: Yes / No
Earthing S: Yes / No
Ip = 10 - 100000 A
Is = 10 - 100000 A
Ith = 0.1 - 0.5 Ir
URL = 0.5 - 5.0
SBRT = 0.2 - 2.0
SBRL = 1.00 - 2.00 Ir
Slope = 0.4 - 1.0
Trip Id> = 5.00-40.00
I2 Block= 0.1 - 0.3
I5 Block = 0.1 - 0.3

87L

Solkor-N
(33 kV side)

I0>> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5
t0>>DT = 0.04 to 300s

600/1

A29

Remark

0.85
NI
0.07

I>> = 0.05-40
t>> = 0.02 to 300s
I0>> = 0.05 - 40
k = 0.05 - 1.5

27
PT
6.6/0.11

Incoming A/B
TR-27204 A/B
20000 kVA

Setting

1.6
0.015
0.05
0.05 (NI)
0.05
DT
0.72
0.25
DT
1.02
0.7
70

No
Yes

Id> = 0.1 - 2.5 In


BS1 = 20 - 150 %
BS2 = 30 - 150 %
Ibreak = 0.5 - 20.0 In
td> 0.0 - 10 s
CT Ratio Cor = 0.50 - 1.0
Internal Trip = ON, OFF
OFF
External Trip = ON, OFF ON
Delay Ex. Trip = 0.0 - 10s

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/29 of 1


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

11 Transformer vector gp.

437
2092
0.1 Threshold current
0.5 Unbiased region limit
0.2 Slightly biased threshold
1 Slightly biased region limit
0.5 Third region slope
9 Upper Id threshold for trip
0.3 2nd harmonic threshold
0.3 5th harmonic threshold
0.2 Differential current
20 1st Bias slope
150 2nd Bias slope
1 Bias break point
0.05 Differential delay
1 CT raio correction
0 External trip delay

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

S.
Switch
No
Board ID
.

Voltage
Feeder Name
(kV)

Device Type /
Device
CT ratio
Setting range
Manufacturer
Duty
2500

2 SB-27204

6.6

Bus Coupler

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

REF 542 +

PT
6.6/ 3
/

51

25

0.110/ 3

3 SB-27204

6.6

REF 542 +

150/1

Fuse ABB-CEF
51N

51

4 SB-27204

6.6

TR-27303A/B
1600 kVA

REF 542 +

200/1

6.6

SB-27205A/B

REF 542 +

500/1

0.07
0.05 Delta voltage
10 Delta phase
15 Time delay

0.65
NI
0.2
200A

I0> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
t0>DT = 0.04 to 300s

DT

0.35

I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5

NI
0.19

I>>> = 0.05-40
t>>> = 0.015 to 300s

51N

I0> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
t0>DT = 0.04 to 300s

DT

I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5

NI

50

I>>> = 0.05-40
t>>> = 0.015 to 300s

51N

I0> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
t0>DT = 0.04 to 300s

A30

0.12

0.85

50

51

5 SB-27204

0.85

V = 0.02 - 0.4 Un
Phase = 5 - 50 Deg.

I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5

Remark

NI

TD = 0.2 - 1000s
51

DTR27305A/B
1000 kVA

I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5

Setting

20
0.015
0.25
0.12
2.35
0.05
11.75
0.015
0.25
DT

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/30 of 2


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

0.42

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

S.
Switch
No
Board ID
.

Voltage
Feeder Name
(kV)

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Device Type /
Device
CT ratio
Setting range
Manufacturer
Duty

Schedule for 11 kV switch board SB-27603


51 I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5
t>DT = 0.02 to 300s
50
REM 543

700/1

51N

51G
REF542+

REM 543
SB-27603
1 To
SB27606

11

Incoming
TR-27603
to
TR-27606
25000 kVA

400/1

I0>> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5
t0>>DT = 0.04 to 300s
I0> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5
t0>DT = 0.04 to 300s

27

U< = 0.1 - 1.2 Un


t< = 40 - 30,000 ms

87

VG = 0 - 11
Earthing P: Yes / No
Earthing S: Yes / No
Ip = 10 - 100000 A
Is = 10 - 100000 A
Ith = 0.1 - 0.5 Ir
URL = 0.5 - 5.0
SBRT = 0.2 - 2.0
SBRL = 1.00 - 2.00 Ir
Slope = 0.4 - 1.0
Trip Id> = 5.00-40.00
I2 Block= 0.1 - 0.3
I5 Block = 0.1 - 0.3

PT
6.6/0.11

REF542+

87L

Solkor-N
(33 kV side)

I>> = 0.05-40
t>> = 0.02 to 300s
I>>> = 0.05-40
Op. mode I>>>

600/1

Setting

EI

DT

0.15
0.12
0.25

DT
0.72
0.7 From 11 kV, 9500 kW
70 Motor relay

No
Yes

11 Transformer vector gp.


437
1312
0.1 Threshold current
0.5 Unbiased region limit
0.2 Slightly biased threshold
1 Slightly biased region limit
0.5 Third region slope
9 Upper Id threshold for trip
0.3 2nd harmonic threshold
0.3 5th harmonic threshold
0.2 Differential current
20 1st Bias slope
150 2nd Bias slope
1 Bias break point
0.05 Differential delay

CT Ratio Cor = 0.50 - 1.0

1 CT raio correction
OFF
ON

Delay Ex. Trip = 0.0 - 10s

A31

1.55 From 11 kV, 9500 kW


Motor relay
0.78

Used for
51LR
4.75
2

Id> = 0.1 - 2.5 In


BS1 = 20 - 150 %
BS2 = 30 - 150 %
Ibreak = 0.5 - 20.0 In
td> 0.0 - 10 s
Internal Trip = ON, OFF
External Trip = ON, OFF

Remark

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/31 of 3


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

0 External trip delay

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

S.
Switch
No
Board ID
.

Voltage
Feeder Name
(kV)

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Device Type /
Device
CT ratio
Setting range
Manufacturer
Duty

TR-27303A/B
SB-27303
0.415 TR-27301A/B
SB-27301
1600 kVA

2500/1

I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5

50

I>> = 0.05-40
t>> = 0.02 to 300s

27

U< = 0.1 - 1.2 Un


t< = 40 - 30,000 ms

1.05
NI
0.09
4 For ATS
0.02 operation

REF 542 +

10/1

51G

51

LDBDTR27302,
27302, 27305,
2
27305,
0.415
27306,
27306,
27307 A/B
1000 kVA
27307 A/B

Remark

Schedule for 0.415 kV switch boards


51

Setting

I0> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
t0>DT = 0.04 to 300s

DT

I> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
k = 0.05 - 1.5

NI

50

I>> = 0.05-40
t>> = 0.02 to 300s

27

U< = 0.1 - 1.2 Un


t< = 40 - 30,000 ms

1600/1

0.7
70
0.25
0.52

0.95
0.09
6.2 For ATS
0.02 operation

REF 542 +

10/1

51G

A32

I0> = 0.05-40
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
t0>DT = 0.04 to 300s

0.7
70

DT

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/32 of 4


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

0.25
0.52

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

A-4: MV motor relay setting schedule


Following functional blocks are used for the motor protection using REM 543

Relay
REM
543

Protection
Duty
51(I>)
50 (I>>>)
51N(I0>)

Non directinal over current low set


Non directinal over current inst.
Non directinal earth fault low set

Functional
block
name
NOC3Low
NOC3Inst
NEF1Low

27(U<)
27 (U<<)

Undervoltage low set


Undervoltage high set

UV3LOW
UV3High

59 (U>)

Overvoltage low set

OV3Low

49

Thermal overload

TOL3Dev

46

Negative phase sequence

NPS3Low

66

Start-up supervision

MotStart

37 (I<)

Under current

NUC3St1

51LR

Lock rotor protection

NOC3High

47

Three-phase phase sequence

PSV3ST1

87M

Motor differential

Diff6G

Function name

A33

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/33 of 5


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies
S.
Switch
No
Board ID
.

SB-27201
SB-27204

Voltage
Feeder Name
(kV)

Device
Type

CT
ratio

PT
ratio

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Device
Setting range
Duty

Setting

Schedule for 6.6 kV switch board SB-27201


27 U< = 0.1 - 1.2 Un
t< = 0.1 - 300 s
Operation Mode = 0,1,2

6.6

27-PM7102
LNG Loading
REM 543
pump
589 kW

100/1

59

U> = 0.10 - 1.60 Un


t> = 0.05 - 300 s
Operation Mode = 0,1,2,3

1.15
5
1

49

Ist = 0.1-10.00 In
Tst = 0.1 - 120.0 s
NC-st = 1-3
Device Type = 0-6
Trip Temp. = 80-120 %
Alarm Temp. = 40-100%
Reset Temp. = 40-100%
Am Temp.= -50-100 Deg C
TC-cooling = 1.0-10.0
TC-Heating = 1-999 min
ST-CS = 0.0-999.0 min
LT-CS = 0.0-999.0 min
p = 0.0 - 1.0
S-TR =50-350 Deg C
Tmax S = 0.0-350 Deg C
ST-CR = 0.0-999.0 min
LT-CR = 0.0-999.0 min
p = 0.0 - 1.0
R-TR =50-350 Deg C
Tmax R = 0.0-350 Deg C

3.6
1
3
3
120
90
60
50
6
30
14
69
0.5
70
155
4
69
0.25
80
200

46

Operation Mode = 0-2


I2> = 0.01 - 0.5 In
K = 5.0 - 100.0
Start Delay = 0.1 - 60 s
Tmin = 0.1 - 120 s
Tmax =500 - 10000 s
T cooling = 5 - 10000 s

66

Operation Mode = 0 - 2
Ist = 1.0 - 10.0 In
Tst = 0.3 - 250 s
Time limit = 1.0 - 500.0s
Countdwn Rate = 2.0-250 s/h
Stall time = 2.0 - 120.0s

1
3.6
1.1
2
3

37

Op. mode
Op. criteria
I< = 0.1 - 0.99 In
t< = 0.1 - 600.0 s
I< Block
t< blocking

2
0
0.1
300

6.6/0.1
1

51

I> = 0.10 - 5.0


Op. mode I>
k = 0.05 - 1.0

Fuse ABB - CEF


7.2 kV
51N I0> = 1 - 100%
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
t0>DT = 0.05 to 300s
51LR I>> = 0.05-40
t>> = 0.05 to 300s

A34

0.7
0.5
1

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/34 of 6


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

2
0.05
5
1
7
3600
1800

Disable
0
1.35
EI
0.74
160 A
65
DT
0.12
2.7
0.5

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies
S.
Switch
No
Board ID
.

SB-27603
SB-27606

Voltage
Feeder Name
(kV)

Device
Type

CT
ratio

PT
ratio

Mott MacDonald
CTJV
Device
Setting range
Duty

Setting

Schedule for 6.6 kV switch board SB-27603


27 U< = 0.1 - 1.2 Un
t< = 0.1 - 300 s
Operation Mode = 0,1,2

11

27-KM7101
Motor 9500
kW

REM 543

0.7
0.5
1

59

U> = 0.10 - 1.60 Un


t> = 0.05 - 300 s
Operation Mode = 0,1,2,3

1.15
5
1

49

Ist = 0.1-10.00 In
Tst = 0.1 - 120.0 s
NC-st = 1-3
Device Type = 0-6
Trip Temp. = 80-120 %
Alarm Temp. = 40-100%
Reset Temp. = 40-100%
Am Temp.= -50-100 Deg C
TC-cooling = 1.0-10.0
TC-Heating = 1-999 min
ST-CS = 0.0-999.0 min
LT-CS = 0.0-999.0 min
p = 0.0 - 1.0
S-TR =50-350 Deg C
Tmax S = 0.0-350 Deg C
ST-CR = 0.0-999.0 min
LT-CR = 0.0-999.0 min
p = 0.0 - 1.0
R-TR =50-350 Deg C
Tmax R = 0.0-350 Deg C

3.7
10
3
3
120
90
60
50
6
20
14
69
0.5
90
155
4
69
0.25
100
200

46

Operation Mode = 0-2


I2> = 0.01 - 0.5 In
K = 5.0 - 100.0
Start Delay = 0.1 - 60 s
Tmin = 0.1 - 120 s
Tmax =500 - 10000 s
T cooling = 5 - 10000 s

2
0.05
8
1
7
3600
1800

66

Operation Mode = 0 - 2
Ist = 1.0 - 10.0 In
Tst = 0.3 - 250 s
Time limit = 1.0 - 500.0s
Countdwn Rate = 2.0-250 s/h
Stall time = 2.0 - 120.0s

47

Operation Mode = 0 - 7
U2> = 0.01 - 1.00
t2> = 0.04 - 60.00 s

5
0.05
1

87

Id> = 5 - 50%
TP1 = 0.0 - 1.0 In
Starting ratio = 10 - 50%
TP2 = 1.0 - 3.0 In
Id>> = 5 - 30 In

10.0
0.5
50
1.5
5

51

I> = 0.10 - 5.0


Op. mode I>
k = 0.05 - 1.0

700/1 11/0.11

1
3.7
11
40
30

2 (EI)

51LR I>> = 0.05-40


t>> = 0.05 to 300s
Op. mode I>>
50 I>>> = 0.05-40
Op. mode I>>>
51N I0> = 1 - 100%
Curve = NI, EI, VI, DT
t0>DT = 0.05 to 300s

A35

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/35 of 7


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

1.55
0.78
2.8
0.5
1
4.75
2

1 (DT)

15
0.12

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Relay Co-ordination Studies

Mott MacDonald
CTJV

Appendix - B: TCC for relay co-ordination


The TCC of the over current (O/C) and motor protections are arranges as follows

S.No.

Relay location

CT
ratio

Reference
location voltage

Switch Board
number

DTR-27305

150/1

6.6 kV

SB-27204

TR-27303

200/1

6.6 kV

SB-27204

MR-27PM7104A

100/1

6.6 kV

SB-27205

MR-27KM7101C

700/1

11 kV

SB-27603

TR-27204

600/1

33 kV

SB-27101

TR-27201

400/1

33 kV

SB-27101

B1

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/1 of 1


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Mott MacDonald
Relay Co-ordination Studies

CTJV

S.No.

Relay location

CT ratio

Reference location
voltage

Switch Board number

DTR-27305

150/1

6.6 kV

SB-27204

B2

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/2 of 1


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Mott MacDonald
Relay Co-ordination Studies

CTJV

S.No.

Relay location

CT ratio

Reference location
voltage

Switch Board number

TR-27303

200/1

6.6 kV

SB-27204

B3

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/3 of 2


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Mott MacDonald
Relay Co-ordination Studies

CTJV

S.No.

Relay location

CT ratio

Reference location
voltage

Switch Board number

MR-27PM7104A

100/1

6.6 kV

SB-27205

B4

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/4 of 3


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Mott MacDonald
Relay Co-ordination Studies

CTJV

S.No.

Relay location

CT ratio

Reference location
voltage

Switch Board number

MR-27KM7101C

700/1

11 kV

SB-27603

Settings of relay at the outgoing RMU feeders from switchboard SB-27104/5, is set equal to the relay
settings of the 33kV feeder TR-27601 from the switchboard SB-29103 of the QGX system. The time
margin with the upstream relay will not be available when the SB-27601 and SB-27602 are supplied
either from the QGX system or CLP system; due to the tight relay co-ordination at the 33kV and upstream relays.

B5

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/5 of 4


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Mott MacDonald
Relay Co-ordination Studies

CTJV

S.No.

Relay location

CT ratio

Reference location
voltage

Switch Board number

TR-27204

600/1

33 kV

SB-27101

B6

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/6 of 5


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Electrical System Studies for QGX-CLP Development Project


Mott MacDonald
Relay Co-ordination Studies

CTJV

S.No.

Relay location

CT ratio

Reference location
voltage

Switch Board number

TR-27201

400/1

33 kV

SB-27101

Settings of relay at the outgoing RMU feeders from switchboard SB-27102/3, is set equal to the relay
settings of the 33kV feeder TR-27201 from the switchboard SB-29103 of the QGX system. As shown
the above TCC, time margin is provided between the relay RMU-27103 and relay at the incomer feeder
TR-27201 from the switchboard SB-27101 (of the CLP system). The same time margin will not be
available with the upstream relays, when the SB-27201 is supplied from the QGX system due to the tight
relay co-ordination at the 33kV and up-stream relays of the QGX system.

B7

221661/02/B - OCT 2007/7 of 6


P:\Glasgow\PSB\EEG\3Jobs\221661 QGX\CLP Studies\Report\221661A - QGX-CLP - Relay Coordination-Rev1.doc/CLP

Вам также может понравиться