Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Ser
TH1
~21d
lo.
998
National Research
m n c i l Canada
Conseil national
de recherches Canada
c. 2
--
ANALYZED
Reprinted f r o m
Proceedings, 10th International Conference on
Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering
Stockholm, 15 - 19 June 1981
p. 513 - 518
:.
t':x
g-.
NRC
'
I1
P r i c e $1.00
OTTAWA
MRCC 19688
SOMMAIRE
Des e s s a i s de f a c t u r a t i o n hydraulique o n t 6 t d e f f e c t u d s dans
d e w couches d ' a r g i l e molle s e n s i b l e de n a t u r e geologique
d i f f C r e n t e pour Btudier les f r a c t u r e s q u i s e f o m e n t autour des
pi8zome'tres i n s i t u .
Au cours du programme d ' e s s a i , on s ' e s t
s e r v i de pi8zomStres de d i v e r s e s longueurs e t d'une t e i n t u r e au
b l e u de d t h y l s n e pour marquer l e s f i s s u r e s .
Aprss a v o i r
r e c o u v e r t 1' a r g i l e d' un g c h a n t i l l o n d e l a r g e d i a m s t r e , les
f i s s u r e s ont Bte r e c h e r c h k s , p u i s r e p r o d u i t e s s u r une c a r t e .
Des f i s s u r e s v e r t i c a l e s bien n e t t e s s e s o n t d h e l o p p e e s a u t o u r
d e 1 1 e x t r Q n i t 8 d e s p i C z o d t r e s les p l u s longs, mais pas a u t o u r
d e s p i 8 z o d t r e s de 0 arm.
Cependant, dans t o u s l e s e s s a i s , d e s
f i s s u r e s i n c l i n e e s d e 20 a 35 d e g r e s p a r r a p p o r t B
1'horizon t a l e s e s o n t developees au-dessus d e chaque e x t r h i t 8
des pi6zodtres.
Ces f i s s u r e s ont l a forme d'un cane i n v e r s e
L1btude
d o n t l e soumet se s i t u e a l a t S t e du p i 8 z o d t r e .
t r a i t e de l a forme des f r a c t u r e s e t de l ' i n f l u e n c e de l a
l o n g u e u r d e s p i 6 z o m 8 t r e s , du temps p e n d a n t l e q u e l l e s
pi8zouGtres r e s t e n t en p l a c e , e t d e s m o d i f i c a t i o n s causdes par
l a
presence
des
pi6zomiStres
dans
l e
sol.
OFFPRINT
TIRE-A-PART
A.A. BALKEMA/ROlTERDAM/1981
G. LEFEBVRE
A PHlLlBERT
M. BOZOZUK
J-J. PARE
SYNOPSIS
Hydraulic fracture tests were carried out in two geologically different soft sensitive
clays in order to study the fracture pattern which had formed in situ around inserted piezometers.
Piezometers of different lengths were used in the test program, and a methylene blue dye was used to
mark the fissures. The fractured clay was recovered with a large diameter block sampler and the
fissures identified and mapped. Well defined vertical fractures developed around the long piezometer tips but not around the ones of zero length. In all tests, however, fractures inclined from
20 to 35 degrees from the horizontal developed above each piezometer tip, tracing the surface of an
inverse cone with its apex at the top of the piezometer.
The paper discusses the fracture patterns and the effects of piezometer length, time of embedment,
and the effect of soil disturbance, caused by installing the piezometers, on hydraulic fracture test
results.
INTRODUCTION
Hydraulic fracture applied to rock formations is
a well known technique that has been used by the
petroleum industry for several decades (Le
Tirant and Baron, 1979). Its use in cohesive
soils to determine lateral stresses in situ is
relatively recent (Bjerrum et al, 1972; Bjerrum
and Andersen, 1972). The analytical aspects of
this technique is based upon the assumptions
that the soil is a semi-infinite, homogeneous,
isotropic, elasto-plastic mass. Based on these
assumptions, Bjerrum et al.(1972) proposed an
analytical model to explain what happens in a
soil around a piezometer when it is subject to
hydraulic fracture.
In the last few years, some questions have been
raised concerning the hydraulic fracture test
in soft clays with respect to the zone of remoulded soil around the piezometer tip, the
direction and extent of the fractures, the degree of homogeneity and natural fissuring
(Bozozuk, 1974; Massarsch et al. 1975; Parkin,
1977; Tavenas et al. 1975). The interpretation
of the test results was always based on the
assumption that hydraulic fracture occurred in
a unique and well defined mode. It was never
demonstrated that the hydraulic fractures that
occurred around a small piezometer tip pushed
into a small clay specimen in a laboratory
(Bjerrum and Andersen, 1972) were accurate representations of the hydraulic fractures that
developed around a full size piezometer in the
field, and that the method used to interpret
the laboratory test results could be applied
directly to the field tests. In the present
study hydraulic fracture tests were performed
in the field and the fractured clays around the
piezometer tips were extracted and examined in
order to verify the mode of fracturing in situ.
Studies were also made to determine how the
TABLE I
Summary of Engineering Properties
of Soil at the Two Sites
Olga
90%
70%
40%
20 kPa
10
2,9
P;/P;
Clay Size Particules (<2u) 90%
Natural Water Content
Liquid Limit
Plasticity Index
Cu (Field Vane)
Sensitivity (Field Vane)
Gloucester
75%
52%
25%
20 kPa
70-100
1,4
14%
TEST PROCEDURES
Installation of ~iezometers
Geonor piezometers made of porous bronze and
33 nun in diameter were used. Three lengths
were installed: 300 mm (standard), 100 mm and
0 nun. The piezometer tips of 0 length were
made from a porous bronze plate. Before installation all piezometer tips and connecting
tubing were filled and saturated with deaired
water, care being taken to ensure that the
tubing uaS tightly plugged at the top to hold
the water and to resist the excess pore water
pressures generated during installation. After
saturation the piezometer tips were fitted to
"E" size steel drill rods (O.D. about 36 mm)
and jacked continuously into the ground until
the desired depth was attained. Five piezometers were installed to depths of 3,7 to 3,8 m
TABLE I1
Characteristics and Results of Hydraulic Fracture Tests
PIEZOMETER NO.
LENGTH
mm
Gloucester test site
P-43 original
300
P-43 E
300
P-43 W
300
P-43 (0)
0
P-43 (10)
100
Olga test site
P-19
300
DATE OF INSTALLATION
DEPTH
m
DATE OF TEST
O'
FRACTURE PATTERN
Vertical Cone
(0,73)
(0,68)
(0,81)
(0,901
(0,81)
yes
yes
yes
no
yes
21-31
350
350inv.
16O-18~
lSO-30
(1,82)
(1,39)
(2,03)
(1,461
yes
yes
yes
yes
Figure 3 was prepared from the observed distribution of fractures to show the fracture mode
PIUOMETER
HORIZONTAL SECTIONS
ABOVE PIEZOMETER T I P
HORIZOHTAL
SECTIOHS
ACROSS F i E M U m E R TlP
PIEZOMETER
I
Fig. 1
Fig. 2
BOUNDARY OF
THE SAMPLE
12
16
PIEZOMETER
LOCATION
!
20
24
* SWEDISH
FALL
CONE 1 0 0 / 3 0
Fig. 4
Soil disturbance or remoulding caused by installing the piezometer has often been used to
explain questionable test results. It was
possible in the present study to verify the
extent of remoulding and to evaluate its influence on the mode of fracture in the hydraulic
fracture test. Tests with a Swedish cone
penetrometer were carried out on each of the
slices cut from the large block samples. The
penetration indices showed that the disturbed
zone extended horizontally for a distance of 2
to 3 piezometer diameters (Fig. 4). Some of
this disturbance occurred at the time of installation, but most of it probably took place
after the tests were completed when the piezometers were rotated and pulled out. This zone
was generally less im~ortantfor the less plastic (I = 25%), extremely sensitive (St = 70P
100) clays at Gloucester than for the clays at
Olga where the plasticity was higher (I = 40%)
P
and the sensitivity less (St = 10).
The development of radial fractures around the
piezometer tips did not seem to be affected by
the presence of the disturbed zone of soil.
The fractures developed and passed through the
disturbed zone and extended into the undisturbed neighbouring clay as indicated on Fig.2,
Sections BB and CD.
GLOUCESTER 1979
LENGTH OF PIEZOMETER T I P ( cm
Fig. 5
was mostly influenced by the horizontal pressure in the soil. The 100 m long tip produced shorter vertical and subvertical fractures. The fact that KO increased to 0,81
shows that the test is also sensitive to the
inclined fractures which formed at the head of
the piezometer, and that it is responding more
to the vertical pressure. There were no vertical fractures around the piezometer of 0
length, and it gave a KO = 0,91. The fractures were inclined forming an inverted cone.
Consequently the pressures measured in this
test were strongly influenced by the vertical
overburden pressure, and to a minor extent by
the horizontal pressure.
The inverted fracture cone was observed to
develop above all piezometer tips in all
tests, and consequently all determinations of
K0 were affected. It could be argued that the
best results were obtained using the 300-mlong piezometer tips, but the correct K is
0
still not known.
!
I
CONCLUSIONS
Seven hydraulic fracture tests performed in two
soft clay deposits of different geologic origin
have shown that the fracture mode is not unique.
Two distinct sets of fractures developed. Vertical fractures radiated out from the piezometer tips as expected and, in addition, cracks
inclined from 20 to 35 degrees from the horizontal formed an inverted cone-shaped fracture
surface with its apex at the top of the piezometer. As the hydraulic fracture test would be
sensitive to the fluid pressures in both sets
of fractures it would lead to an overestimate
of KO. The hypothesis that a unique fracture
mode, i.e., that only vertical fractures developed in normally consolidated clay, was not
verified.
The presence of the remoulded or disturbed soil
around the piezometer tips did not affect the
development of fractures during the hydraulic
fracture tests.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors gratefully acknowledge the conscientious efforts of A. Laberge and T.J.
Hoogeveen, Technical Officers, Division of
Building Research, for carrying out the hydraulic fracture tests. The research has been carried out jointly by the University of
Sherbrooke and the Division of Building Research, National Research Council of Canada and
has been supported by the Soci6te dlEnergie de
la Baie James, the MinistSre de 1'Education du
Quebec and the Natural Sciences and Engineering
Research Council Canada.
REFERENCES
DISCUSSION
The fractures formed in the clay soils from the,
hydraulic fracture tests were easily marked and
identified using the methylene blue dye. Fractures that formed during the tests are not only
related to the horizontal pressures, but also
to the vertical pressure.
The fracture cone observed at the head of piezometer P-43W (Table 2) sloped downwards and
limited the length of the vertical fractures
which developed around the piezometer tip.
Consequently the vertical stress had a greater
influence during the test, and this increased
the measured KO to 0,81 from 0,68 obtained with
P-43E (Table 11).
Soil mechanics and foundation engineering - Proceedings o f the 10th international conference, Stockholm,
15-19 June 1981
1981,28 cm, c.3500pp., 4 vols., Hfl.850 1 $380/170
Over 500 papers (40 in French, rest Enghsh) from contributors throughout the world. Prediction and performance; tunnelling in soils; groundwater and seepage
problems; laboratory testing; soil/structure interaction;
environmental control (incl. waste material); soil
exploration and sampling; pile foundations; saving cities
and old buildings; soil dynamics; slope stability; soil
improvement. All papers were selected and reviewed by
the nationaI societies of the International Society for
Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering.
CONTENTS
1. Prediction and performance (Accuracy of predictions and its
determination; Application
of probability and decision theory
-design; Factors governing the performance of buildings and
other structures). Pile foundation problems in white chalk;
Settlements under intermittent loading; Settlement calculation
by a new strength theory; Construction of a pile wall in a rockfill dam; Rheological definition of loess subsidence; Insulation
for foundations and buried services; Land reclamation using
fine-grained dredged material; Settlement analysis of tanks on
soft clay; Pitfalls of back-analyses; Observations of creep during
heave; Consolidation of sensitive clays; etc.
2. Tunnelling in soils (Case records of tunnel constructions;
Effects of different excavation/construction techniques; New
calculation methods; Mapping and control systeins). Strain
field around a tunnel in stiff soil; Principles of tunnel design
for seismic regions; Analytical study of NATM; etc.
3. Groundwater and seepage problems (Prediction and measurement of groundwater conditions and flow; Internal erosion and
piping, hydraulic fracturing, etc.; Control of ground water;
Effects of changes in groundwater level). Theory of non-linear
seepage; Experience in plastic filter application; Jet grout
method and cut-off walls stability; Soil drainage and stability
of slopes; Initial gradient in a dense glacial till; Structural
improvement of alluvial soils; Seepage interaction etc.
4. Laboratory testing (Relevance of laboratory soil testing
methods; Standardization of laboratory tests for practical
application; New laboratory testing methods; Model tests).
Investigation of soils creep; Mechanical properties of soft rock
and rock mass; Laboratory and pressuremeter tests on a stiff
clay; Laboratory testing of vertical drains; The consolidation
properties of a soft rock; Dynamic compaction of rockfill
samples; Model for determining of soil parameters; ctc.
5. Soil structure interaction (Case histories and observation of
real behaviour; Design and construction procedures which take
account of soil/structure interaction; Acceptable deformation
in relation to the performance and function of structures). An
elastoplastic analysis of anchored walls; Computing foundation
slabs with building rigidity; Soil interaction in buried structures;
A method of settlement calculation; On the validity of Winkler's principle; Design and monitoring of an embankment on
alluvium; Anchor slab structure retains earth fill; etc.
6. Environmental control (Waste material in earth structures
and protection against groundwater pollution; Erosion protection; Change of geotechnical properties due to pollution; Subsidence due to lowering of the groundwater level and to the
withdrawal of oil and mining). Fly ash as fill material; Mechanical behaviour of coal fly ashes; Mechanisms for detoxifying
soil; Pollution in peats; Environment protection in Italy; etc.
7. Soil exploration and sampling (In-situ testing and deformation measurements; Quality (scatter) of soil data in relation to
specific foundation problems; New techniques for soil sampling
and penetration tests). Portable geotechnical field equipment;
The static-dynamic penetrometer; Geological interpretation of
SIR data; Energy dissipation on the SPT rods; Field investigations of clay soils; A sampler with a new type of shutter; Tests
in alluvial sand with the PQS probe; etc.