Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
4958
Printed in the USA. All rights reserved.
ROS DERRETT
School of Tourism and Hospitality Management, Southern Cross University, Lismore, NSW
The cultural aspects of a way of life of a place and a sense of community help us to better understand the
processes of change being experienced in regional Australia. This article explores how community-based
festivals grow over time to reflect the values, interests, and aspirations of residents. It presents observations
of the nature of four community cultural festivals in destinations in the northern rivers region of NSW. The
investigation explores how a sense of community and place are linked to such events. It seeks to establish
how festivals develop and manage the tensions generated by different community voices. How community
festivals reflect the communitys sense of itself and its place validates the substantial shared interest by
residents and visitors in such events.
Regional community cultural festivals
Sense of community
Sense of place
Events tourism
Address correspondence to Ros Derrett, Lecturer, School of Tourism and Hospitality Management, Southern Cross University, Lismore, NSW,
Australia. Tel: 02 6620 3150; Fax: 02 6622208; E-mail: rderrett@scu.edu.au
49
50
DERRETT
A Sense of Place
According to Teodori and Luloff (1998), community involvement, including support for a festival, is an
important factor in predicting the strength of a persons
attachment to a community or place. Place is a particular part of space occupied by people and things. Studies have shown that recognizing peoples attachment
to a place influences their sense of stewardship with a
place (Greene, 1996). Individuals affective relationship with the landscape or material environment may
vary in intensity, discretion, and manner of expression
(Tuan, 1974). Profiling the characteristics of individuals who are strongly attached to their (sense) community would be helpful to event managers responsible
for developing relationships with the local community
(Wickam & Kerstetter, 2001).
The emotional attachment to the natural landscape
and the built environment, climatic changes, and shared
memories of communal heritage allow individuals to
come together for formal or spontaneous interactions
like festivals and community cultural events. Place is
said to have spirit or personality. It seems that a sense
of place can vary from person to person and time to
time. There can be a distinction between the characteristics of place for residents and of those of visitors. Can
visitors ever develop an appreciation and commitment
to the same extent as locals? Does the contact with place
and space allow visitors to go beyond just appreciation
and understanding to conservation of sites or experiences based on access to particular location and natural forms?
Tourism, for example, is typified in some respects as
the experience and consumption of place (Meethan,
1995). For places to achieve distinctiveness and status
as places to go, or to be seen in, they have to be created. Organizers of events can offer tangible and intangible experiences to connect people to places. That is
why some popular events are sited in spectacular locations.
This suggests that a sense of place brings into play
not only the commonly understood five senses of touch,
taste, hearing, smell, and sight but also the two dimensions mentioned in the Bible, namely, animation and
feeling. This suggests that the sixth sense as the gift of
mind and the seventh as the interpreter of ones faculties could be readily accommodated in both the domains of individuals perception of place and community. Festivals offer people permission to indulge in both
51
present. People turn to their culture as a means of selfdefinition and mobilize to assert their local cultural
values (Adams & Goldbard, 2001) and share them with
visitors. This is demonstrated in the four case study
destinations.
A Sense of Community
A sense of community is an almost invisible yet critical part of a healthy community. Though hard to define, it includes a communitys image, spirit, character,
pride, relationships, and networking (Bush, 2000). A
sense of community comes from a shared vision, where
a clear sense of purpose values individuals ideas and
contribution and involves working together on community issues, celebrations, and problem solving. Developing a sense of community is challenging, longterm work, building levels of connectedness, belonging,
and support (Dugas & Schweitzer, 1997). Festivals and
cultural events are observed as providing a forum for a
shared purpose to be manifest (Dunstan, 1994).
The complex relationships that festivals provide for
individual members of a community as each exchanges
information and energy offers the stability and protection that community can provide and that isolation cannot. Festivals can provide the heart to a community
(Wheatley & Kellner-Rogers, 1998, p. 14) as their
celebratory nature provides residents with conditions
of freedom and connectedness rather than a fixation on
the forms and structures of the community. The organizations and civic institutions managing the festivals
and events temporarily offer a spatial boundary in terms
of place, which harnesses the communitys vision of
itself and provide participative opportunities to nurture
and sustain what is important to their constituency.
Festivals and events provide an opportunity for community cultural development (Getz, 1997). Festivals and
events can provide direction for communities. They
provide a now and offer opportunities to speculate
on a future. Programming can draw out views of attendees through symposia, workshops, skills development workshops, dreaming places, graffiti walls, and
postcards.
Festivals can reflect the dynamic value systems of
individuals united by the same customs, images, collective memory, habits, and experiences. Festivals can
be replicated and each generation can pass on something of its experience to the next. This is of particular
interest to families that use events to assemble reunions.
52
DERRETT
ism by forming its content. Only if Australians are involved in tourism will it survive (Wood, 1993).
While there is little research on how a community is
empowered to form the content of tourism, Wood suggests that tourism influences identity by generating
images such as that of the quintessential Australian. This
anthropological approach to cultural tourism is highlighted by Lips (cited in Wood, 1992) who suggests
that, cultural tourism is the art of participating in another culture, of relating to people and places that have
a strong sense of their own identity. It is an approach to
tourism that gives tourists credit for intelligence, and
promises them some depth of experience and real-life
layering that can be explored on many levels (p. 4).
The four community cultural festivals that share their
culture that becomes the content of the tourism
experience for visitors demonstrate how regional and
local distinctiveness influence festivals. To better explain the phenomenon it is useful to map the major elements, processes, and relationships found in such
events. These are represented in Figure 1. Festivals
emerge from the congruence of three major elements;
the destination (place) in which they are held, the people
who reside in that location (and within the region), and
the visitors who are attracted to the festival. All of these
are underpinned by the physical landscape in which
Cultural Tourism
Distinctiveness
Community, the custodians of the content of Australian tourism, must be enabled to participate in tour-
Figure 1. Representation of how elements, processes, and relationships of regional and local distinctiveness influence festivals.
Regional
PLACE
Sense of
Community
and Place
RESIDENTS
FESTIVALS
Destination
Marketing
Cultural
Tourism
VISITORS
53
54
DERRETT
Table 1
Community Well-Being
Community Well-Being
Community Well-Being
Dimensions
Social and cultural
Economic
Environmental and built
Outcomes
Conviviality, equity, vitality
Adequate prosperity
Livability, sustainability, and viability
Table 2
Components of Well-Being Building Blocks
Building Blocks
Components/Features
Democratic governance
Visions, goals, leadership, policies
Active citizenship
Equal political, civil, and civic rights
Social justice
Human rights, social supports, empowerment
Social capital
Interpersonal and organizational trust,
reciprocity, and collective action
Source: Wills (2001, p. 34).
other aspects of community life. Festivals can be a longterm investment in the aggregate value and principles
that underpin that elusive sense of community. The
Well-Being Framework has been applied to the four
festivals and their communities and provides a useful
tool for observations of communities anywhere.
Sense and Sensitivity: Four Case Study Communities
The northern rivers region has a distinctive heritage
that reflects the waves of migration to the coast and
hinterland. The individuals and groups who have sought
to stay since the indigenous settlement have contributed to the regional culture. Their stories reflect the give
and take of each generation of people who came as
timber-getters, farmers, professionals, merchants, surfers, hippies, alternates, and retirees. Each layer contributes to the tapestry of celebrations that have been
generated by individuals and communities ever since
and that are attractive to residents. New settlers contribute ideas and experience to the development of festivals that reflect the cultural mix.
Each communitys festival provides occasions where
a specific mood, tone, or spirit, responding to a sense
of place, time of year, or season, is demonstrated. As
people seek to fill their increased leisure time in the
region with new experiences, they demand value for
money expended to access the event, heightened enjoyment from exposure to these new and novel activities, security, and recognition as individuals (Dimmock,
Tiyce, & Derrett, 1999). With the self at the center of
modern consumer society, community-based festivals
appear to tie together issues of choice, identity, status,
alienation, and culture. Visitors to community cultural
festivals wish to avoid unsafe situations, discomfort,
doubts, and being made to feel a nuisance. Event organizers of the case study events identified a responsibility to deliver not only a program of activityreflecting who the locals are by showcasing local skills and
pursuits and what they aspire to through a celebration
that provides the aesthetics of wonderbut to capture
a regional spirit for the visitors as well! They have done
this with local produce, cuisine, arts practice, youth
involvement, and business activity.
The four community events involve the local population in a shared experience for their mutual benefit.
These annual moments provide both the social function and symbolic meaning of the festival. These functions reflect the communitys social identity, its historical continuity, and its physical survival that is
ultimately what festivals celebrate. While each of the
four communities offer separate and distinctive programs reflecting these functions, there is evidence of a
significant overarching regional flavor to them. Each
festival has also, over time, identified key ways in which
to distinguish themselves from other regional events.
In marketing terms, each has sought a point of difference, particularly in terms of the program of the event.
In each of the four festivals under discussion, the power
exerted by individuals and subgroups begins to work
independently of the dominant culture. The trust,
reciprosity, proactivity, commons, participation in networks, and social norms, suggested by Cox (1995) as
fundamental to the notion of social capital, are represented in each event. A particular subcultural group in
Nimbin, for example, convenes Mardi Grass, fully mindful of competing interests represented within the community. The collaboration between local government and
community-based festival committees is a marked feature of the Casino, Byron Bay, and Grafton events.
The Jacaranda Festival, Grafton
The Jacaranda Festival (www.graftoncity.nsw.gov.au)
was the first floral (themed) festival organized in Australia and was based upon the traditional English spon-
55
was known as a community safety committee. A community-based Council committee sought to redress the
image generated by chaos and mayhem resulting
during New Years Eve street activity in 199394. The
negative national media coverage spurred volunteers
to seek solutions of a local nature through strategic
partnerships, rebranding the town, and generating street
entertainment. Extensive work has been undertaken to
reorient the target market to revert to resident families
primarily, provide participation opportunities for locals
and youthful holiday-makers through workshops to
prepare floats for a parade, harm minimization strategies in relation to consumption of alcohol and drugs,
and innovative waste management to deal with up to
40,000 people.
Extensive community consultation sought to develop
an event that reflected the lifestyle of residents. Held
during the summer season, it reflects the outdoor beach
culture while at the same time capitalizing on the iconic
status of Byron Bay as a tourism destination. The business houses in the CBD were vital to ongoing negotiations for effective management and monitoring of subsequent events. The 2000 New Year event was deemed
a millennium success in terms of local empowerment,
delivery of accessible entertainment, and satisfying
expressed concerns about potential tourism influxes.
This model has been continued through the employment of an event director and a program reflective of
community suggestions (Lawrence & Wynn-Moylan,
2002).
Beef Week, Casino
Casino Beef Week (www.casinobeefweek.com.au)
commenced in 1981 on the recommendation of an outside consultant engaged by the local Council to determine the viability of an event linked to local interest
that would ultimately attract visitors. While not initiated from within the community, it was immediately
embraced by the Casino Agricultural Show Society and
a community committee has managed it from its inception.
It is actually a 12-day week of activity geared to
its established market of beef producers across the eastern states of Australia. It comprises such elements as
the annual dinner dance and crowning of the Beef Week
Queen with each of the up to 10 candidates representing a specific breed; broadly based community entertainment with a cattle theme; and the highlight is seen
56
DERRETT
as a parade of cattle, horse-drawn vehicles, and commercial floats. A roundabout in the main street is converted into a judging ring for 120+ live steers to compete. In recent years programming has embraced aspects
of the timber industry, local arts and crafts, and shop
displays.
This profile-raising exercise involves numerous individuals, volunteers, and community representative
groups in its management with a dedicated Festival
coordinator funded from donations and fundraising for
the event. Tour packages are developed by accommodation houses and bus companies. The Council employed a Tourism Officer and a committee-financed
Festival Coordinator work to integrate Beef Week into
local and regional promotions. Visitors are drawn mostly
from the regional and domestic market, though increasing media exposure has relayed details of the event
overseas.
Breakfast with the Butchers and service club barbecues are no longer enough for the increasingly sophisticated festival attendee, and so a new element in the
festival is Beef on Barker (Street). Local enterprises
value add to the beef sector with olives, nuts, vegetables,
wine, and dairy and are now showcased in a sit-down,
coupon-based food fest.
Summary
The actual place and space used by each of the festivals in each destination plays an influential role in program choices, reflects the heritage of settlement, and
provides boundaries between residential areas, commercial outlets, and public space. Grafton stages activities on both sides of the Clarence River. The four
destinations each utilize their CBD for day and night
activities. The beach and adjacent parkland is important to Byron Bays New Years Eve revelers, while
Nimbin Mardi Grass uses the main thoroughfare for a
parade and the parkland for a rally. Grafton and Casino
hold events indoors and outdoors. Parades are a distinctive program feature of all events, allowing people
to move through the natural and built environments.
Graftons Jacaranda Festival has been entertaining
locals and visitors since the mid-1930s, while Casino
Beef Week commenced in 1981. Nimbin Mardi Grass
celebrated its 10th anniversary in 2002 and Byron Bays
New Years Eve celebration has been managed in a formal way since 1994. The flowering of the Jacaranda
trees in late October or early November influences the
57
58
DERRETT
Lawrence, M., & Wynn-Moylan, P. (2002). Byron shire residents attitudes to New Years Eve celebrations. Lismore:
Southern Cross University, Centre for Regional Tourism
Research.
Richins, H., & Pearce, P. (2000). Influences on tourism development decision making: Coastal local government areas in
Eastern Australia. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 8(3), 207
231.
Meethan, K. (1995). Place, image and power: Brighton as a resort. In T. Selwyn (Ed.), The tourist image: Myths and myth
making in tourism. New York: John Wiley.
Theodori, G., & Luloff, A. (1998). Land use and community
attachment. 7th International Symposium on Society and Resource Management, University of Missouri.
Trotter, R. (1999, March). Is there a role for community cultural
development in tourism? Artwork Magazine, 42, 3843.
Tuan, Y. (1974). Topophilia: A study of environmental perceptions, attitudes and values. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: PrenticeHall.
Ulrich, D. (1998). Six practices for creating communities of
value, not proximity. In F. Hesselbein, M. Goldsmith, R.
Beckhard, & R. F. Schubert (Eds.), The community of the
future (pp. 155166). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers.
Wheatley, M. J., & Kellner-Rogers, M. (1998). The paradox and
promise of community. In F. Hesselbein, M. Goldsmith, R.
Beckhard, & R. F. Schubert (Eds.), The community of the
future (pp. 918). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers.
Wickham, T. D., & Kerstetter, D. L. (2001). The relationship
between place attachment and crowding in an event setting.
Event Management, 6, 167174.
Wills, J. (2001). Just, vibrant and sustainable communities, a
framework for progressing and measuring community
wellbeing. Local Government Community Services of Australia, Townsville.
Wood, C. (1992). Frameworks for travellers. Australians Travelling Abroad, Melbourne.
Wood, C. (1993). Package tourism and new tourism compared.
In Proceedings from National Conference, Community Culture and Tourism (p. 11). Melbourne, July.