Avi Adelman’s Video #8074 At 00:10- Officer's Cannon and Craig are viewed at the scene assisting three DFR personnel with the patient, Adelman appears to be approximately 10 to 15 ft away from the scene. Branch is viewed securing the scene. At 00:12 Branch stepped forward and Adelman moved backward around Branch, Avi Adelman’s Video #8075 At 00:10- Officer's Cannon and Craig are viewed at the scene assisting three DFR personnel with the patient. Adelman appears to be approximately 15 to 20 ft away from the scene. Branch is viewed securing the scene. Avi Adelman’s Video #8159 At 00:10- Officer's Cannon and Craig are viewed at the scene assisting three DFR personnel with the patient. Adelman appears to be approximately 10 to 15 ft away from the scene. Branch is viewed securing the scene. At 00:14- Officer Branch is viewed on her cell phone, moving towards Adelman and can be heard saying “Sir leave” “Sir, Sir you need to leave” At 00:16- Adelman- No Branch- Sir you need to leave Adeiman- Call your supervisor Braneb- I’m talking to my supervisor Adelman- Good, no, Call your supervisor Braneb- Let me see your ID Adelman-No At 00:25- A man in a wheelchair appears from the right side and between the medical scene and where Branch and Adelman are arguing, Avi Adelman’s Video #8160 Branch- Stop Adelman- Ok I’m stopped Adelman- Call your supervisor here and get him on site Branch- okAdelman- And he will tell you I have a right to take pictures in public Branch- Not if someone is getting medical treatment... Adelman- I can take pictures yes... HIPPA does not apply Branch- Look I just got through talking with my Sgt. and you can’t do that Adeiman- Your.... Sgt......I can take pictures of people in public Branch- I want you to leave.....You can take pictures from the street but you cannot take pictures here... Adelman- Ok your badge number is 331 Branch- Yes, and I told you to leave Adelman- And your name is? Branch- I'm identified by my badge number Branch- That’s all you need to know Adelman- Ok that’s all I need Adetman- I will leave but 1... Branch- Give me your ID before you leave Adelman- No why? Adelman- Ok why? You want my ID, ok under what right? What is my detaining? Braneb- Give it to me Adelman- Ok what am I being detained for... Branch- Give it to me Adelman- Are you detaining me? Branch- Yes I’m detaining you Adelman- Are you arresting me? Branch- Cause I asked you to leave and you're refusing to give me your identification. . Adelman- I do not have to give it to you unless you are arresting me 2Branch- Stop....Stop Adelman- I'm not doing anything.....I'm scratching my head Adelman- What is the arrest for Branch- I'm detaining you Adelman- For what? Branch- Because I told you to leave Adelman- I don’t have to leave.....It’s public property....I can stay and take pictures Branch- Yes you do this is DART property (handcuffs clicking) Adelman- Ok I'll give you my ID I will give you my ID Branch- Have a scat, no, I asked you for it before and you wouldn't give it to me. Adelman- You're going to arrest me for what? Not... I can take pictures of people in public there is nothing illegal about that. Branch- And I asked you to leave DART property. Adelman- I can stay on the DART property there is no requirement that says I have to leave when I'm taking pictures, you cannot take chase with me and not everybody else, it’s called the right to photograph in public. Braneh- No... Adelman. Yes it is..... My ID is in my right hand pocket under the camera, my wallet | mean, here I'm leaning over ....that’s it sir yes, it’s the third card on the right hand side as you flip it open. Fleming- Stand up for me sir.. Adelman- I can’t .....thank you sir... sit when you get inside it's behind one of those cards...sorry just trying to help there you go look for the stripes... it’s in that first rack there somewhere ..that first wallet it’s in there .... That might be it ...there itis Adelman- I’ve... scratched Branch- Have a seat.... have a seat Adelman- I’ve my, I scratched my back Branch- Have a seatAdelman- Ok I'm getting down I’m getting down. Branch- Have a seat... Have a seat .. Now when | get back-up here you want to comply Adelman- No... no I was ready to comply before he got here Braneh- No... | asked you several times when 1 was on the phone with my Sgt. Adelman- you do realize the right to photograph in public does not Braneb- But you cannot photograph him while he is under medical attention.. Adelman- No.. yes I can...no .. there is no law Braneh- | asked you to leave didn’t I? I asked you several times to leave... Adelman- Write the ticket please.. Branch- I am Adelman- Can someone do a time check for me? Fleming- Time check? Adelman- First off my hat is about to block my vision....can you push it off or take it off...1 can’t.....it’s rolling down. Second off.... Need to see what time it is that’s what I meant by a time check. Fleming- Time check is 7:53 Adelman- Thank you... can you ... can you take my hat off at least. Branch- You want a whole lot of things Adelman- Because it's falling down and I can’t see...Ok that’s great, thank you ...... What will the ticket be for may I ask? jeming- Who do you work for? Adelman- I do not work for anybody I’m a free lance public photographer. Fleming- What were you doing here? Adelman- I am out here taking pictures... there no reason I have to explain past that...I’'ve been out here about an hour and a half. I freelance....[f someone buys my pictures then I sell them but I don’t I mean it’s a hard way to explain it but I do it for a living. Fleming- Ok‘Adelman- The only picture I've sold is of a fire where they pulled out marijuana plants that’s where a house blew up it looked bad in black and white,Officer Branch Audio Recording #2000091 I/A-16-05 Adelmanifl Branch- Ok alright, hold on Sarge hold on....Sir leave Adelman- No.. Branch- you gotta leave Adelman- Call your supervisor Branch- I’m talking to my supervisor. Adelman- Good Branch- let me see your ID Adelman- No.. Branch- let me see your Texas ID Adelman- No...no. Branch- This is what I’m going through......well leave our property..you're not catching... Adelman- No I don’t have to leave...I’m not leaving... this is public property Branch- No it’s not this is DART property Adelman- No I’m not leaving this is not their property... can be here... am not leaving Braneh- No you cannot...ok Sarge you hear me right.......Alright you cannot take picture of him while they getting . Adelman- I can take pictures ...I can take pictures Branch- Not while they are getting medical attention ...no you cannot Adelman- HIPPA does not apply here... Branch- Leave... No Adelman- No....you will have to arrest me... Braneh- Leave... ok is that what you want? Have a seat. Adelman- No... you know HIPPA does...the firemen know HIPPA does apply here Branch- Ni you cannot take pictures of him ...