Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 4

IntheCentralInformationCommission

at
NewDelhi
FileNo:CIC/WB/A/2010/000500AD
DateofHearing :December28,2010
DateofDecision :December28,2010
Parties:
Applicant
ShriYogendraArya
F.No.467
Pocket01,SectorB4
PoliceColony
Narela
Delhi110040
TheApplicantwaspresentforthehearing
Respondent
AllIndiaCouncilforTechnicalEducation
7thFloor,ChanderLokBuilding
Janpath
NewDelhi
Representedby:Dr.DerleD.V,CPIO&DirectorandShriD.R.Bhagat,PIO&UDC

InformationCommissioner

:Mrs.AnnapurnaDixit

___________________________________________________________________
DecisionNotice

The Commission directs the PIO to inform the Appellant in writing that AMIE course is not
approvedbyAICTEandthatheisthereforenoteligibleforthepostofAssistantProfessor.

IntheCentralInformationCommission
at
NewDelhi
FileNo:CIC/WB/A/2010/000500AD
ORDER
Background
1.

TheApplicantfiledanRTIApplicationdt.4.2.10withthePIO,AICTEseekinginformationagainst4
pointsregardinghiseligibilitytothepostof AssistantProfessorinTechnicalInstitutions(Degree)
accordingtoRegulations2010whichshallcomeintoforcew.e.fthedateoftheirpublicationinofficial
gazetteincludingwhetherAMIECourseisequivalenttoBE/B.TechandM.TechwithFirstDivision,In
thisconnectiontheApplicantalsowantedtoknowwhetherhewaseligleforthepsotofAssistant
Professor. Onnotreceivinganyreply,hefiledanappealdt.8.4.10withtheAppellateAuthority
reiteratinghisrequestfortheinformation. Dr.R.S.Rathore,CPIOrepliedon1.4.10statingthatthe
informationbeingsoughtisnotasperdefinitionofinformationgiveninSection2(f)oftheRTIAct,
2005.Beingaggrievedwiththereply,theApplicantfiledasecondappealdt.20.5.10beforeCIC.

Decision
2.

Duringthehearing,theAppellantwantedtoknowwhetherhisAMIEqualificationisrecognizedby
AICTE.TheRespondentstatedthatinformationcouldnotbeprovidedalsobecausetheAppellant
hadnotprovidedhiseducationalqualifications. Whenthe Appellantprovidedfurtherinformation
regardinghiseducationalqualificationsincludingthefact thathehadcompletedhis AMIEfrom
InstituteofEngineers,KolkattaandhadstudiedatGovt.College,DeenbandhuInstituteofScience
andTechnology,Sonepat,Haryana,theRespondentsclarifiedthattheAMIEcourseisnotapproved
byAICTE.

3.

TheCommissionafterhearingthesubmissionsbybothsidesdirectsthePIOtoinformtheAppellant
inwritingthatAMIEisnotapprovedbyAICTEby5.2.11andtheAppellanttosubmitacompliance
reporttotheCommissionby10.2.11.

4.

Theappealisdisposedofwiththeabovedirections.
(AnnapurnaDixit)
InformationCommissioner

Authenticatedtruecopy

(G.Subramanian)
DeputyRegistrar

Cc:

1.

ShriYogendraArya
F.No.467
Pocket01,SectorB4
PoliceColony
Narela
Delhi110040

2.

ThePublicInformationOfficer
AllIndiaCouncilforTechnicalEducation
7thFloor,ChanderLokBuilding
Janpath
NewDelhi

3.

TheAppellateAuthority
AllIndiaCouncilforTechnicalEducation
7thFloor,ChanderLokBuilding
Janpath
NewDelhi

4.

OfficerIncharge,NIC

Вам также может понравиться