Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Ferrer vs. Ferrer
*
G.R.No.166496.November29,2006.
571
VOL.508,NOVEMBER29,2006
571
PETITIONforreviewoncertiorariofthedecisionand
resolutionoftheCourtofAppeals.
ThefactsarestatedintheopinionoftheCourt.
Romualdo M. Jubayforpetitioner.
Tambio Law Officeforprivaterespondents.
572
572
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Ferrer vs. Ferrer
CHICONAZARIO,J.:
Before this Court
is an Appeal by Certiorari which assails
1
theDecision oftheCourtofAppealsdated16August2004
inCAG.R.
SP No. 78525, reversing and setting aside the
2
Order dated16December2002oftheRegionalTrialCourt
(RTC), Mandaluyong City, Branch 212 in Civil Case No.
MC021780.TheCourtofAppealsorderedthedismissalof
3
the Complaint filed by petitioner Josefa Bautista Ferrer
against respondents Sps. Manuel M. Ferrer and Virginia
Ferrer,andSps.IsmaelM.FerrerandFloraFerrerinthe
aforesaidCivilCaseNo.MC021780.
InherComplaintforpaymentofconjugalimprovements,
sum of money, and accounting with prayer for injunction
and damages, petitioner alleged that she is the widow of
Alfredo Ferrer (Alfredo), a halfbrother of respondents
ManuelM.Ferrer(Manuel)andIsmaelM.Ferrer(Ismael).
BeforehermarriagetoAlfredo,thelatteracquiredapieceof
lot, covered
by Transfer Certificate of Title (TCT) No.
4
67927. He applied for a loan with the Social Security
System (SSS) to build improvements thereon, including a
573
VOL.508,NOVEMBER29,2006
573
_______________
5 Entitled, Sps.
Ismael R. Ferrer and Flora C. Ferrer and Sps. Manuel M. Ferrer and
Virginia Ferrer.
6PennedbyJoseH.Hernandez;Records,pp.1722.
7Id.,atp.3.
574
574
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Ferrer vs. Ferrer
575
VOL.508,NOVEMBER29,2006
575
thefollowingprocedureshallapply:
(1) An inventory shall be prepared, listing separately all the
properties of the conjugal partnership and the exclusive
propertiesofeachspouse.
(2) Amounts advanced by the conjugal partnership in payment of
personaldebtsandobligationsofeitherspouseshallbecredited
totheconjugalpartnershipasanassetthereof.
(3) Each spouse shall be reimbursed for the use of his or her
exclusivefundsintheacquisitionofpropertyorforthevalueof
his or her exclusive property, the ownership of which has been
vestedbylawintheconjugalpartnership.
(4) The debts and obligations of the conjugal partnership shall be
paid out of the conjugal assets. In case of insufficiency of said
assets, the spouses shall be solidarily liable for the unpaid
balance with their separate properties, in accordance with the
provisionsofparagraph(2)ofArticle121.
(5) Whatever remains of the exclusive properties of the spouses
shallthereafterbedeliveredtoeachofthem.
576
576
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Ferrer vs. Ferrer
motiontodismissonthegroundoffailuretostateacauseofaction.
Albeittherespondenthereinhasthelegalrighttobereimbursedof
the cost of the improvements of the subject property, it is not the
petitioners but the estate of her deceased husband which has the
obligation to pay the same. The complaint herein is therefore
dismissible for failure to state a cause of action against the
petitioners. Needless to say, the respondent is not without any
furtherrecourseasshemayfileherclaimagainsttheestateofher
deceasedhusband.
_______________
(6) Unless the owner had been indemnified from whatever source,
the loss or deterioration of movables used for the benefit of the
family,belongingtoeitherspouse,evenduetofortuitousevent,
shallbepaidtosaidspousefromtheconjugalfunds,ifany.
(7) The net remainder of the conjugal partnership properties shall
constitute the profits, which shall be divided equally between
husband and wife, unless a different proportion or division was
agreed upon in the marriage settlements or unless there has
been a voluntary waiver or forfeiture of such share as provided
inthisCode.
(8) The presumptive legitimes of the common children shall be
delivereduponthepartitioninaccordancewithArticle51.
(9) In the partition of the properties, the conjugal dwelling and the
lotonwhichitissituatedshall,unlessotherwiseagreeduponby
the parties, be adjudicated to the spouse with whom the
majority of the common children choose to remain. Children
below the age of seven years are deemed to have chosen the
mother,unlessthecourthasdecidedotherwise.Incasethereis
no such majority, the court shall decide, taking into
considerationthebestinterestsofsaidchildren.
577
VOL.508,NOVEMBER29,2006
577
578
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Ferrer vs. Ferrer
statuteoflimitations;
(g) Thatthepleadingassertingtheclaimstatesnocauseofaction;
(h) Thattheclaimordemandsetforthintheplaintiffspleadinghas
beenpaid,waived,abandoned,orotherwiseextinguished;
(i) That the claim on which the action is founded is unenforceable
undertheprovisionsofthestatuteoffrauds;and
(j) That a condition precedent for filing the claim has not been
compliedwith.
17
No.143788,9September2005,469SCRA505,511.
579
VOL.508,NOVEMBER29,2006
579
Christian,G.R.No.161135,8April2005,455SCRA175,183.
19 Goodyear
No.154554,9November2005,474SCRA427,435.
20Concepcion
436Phil.233,238;387SCRA427,432(2002).
21 Victoria
December2005,478SCRA365,372.
580
580
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Ferrer vs. Ferrer
VOL.508,NOVEMBER29,2006
581
582
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Ferrer vs. Ferrer