DISCLAIMER

The facts stated in the present case are fictitious and have been drafted solely for the
purposes of the competition. The facts, names, locations and dates bear no
resemblance to any person, event or happening whether dead or alive. Any
resemblance, if any found is purely co-incidental.
No additional evidence or additional witness testimonies (other than provided) can be
brought on record by any team for the purposes of the competition. Failure to adhere
to the same will result in disqualification.
The names used in the case are purely for the purposes of the competition. No real
incidences are to be attached with them.
This problem does not intend to hurt the feelings of any section of the society or to
offend any person.

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

Statement of Facts
Priya Sharma, a 20 year old girl was involved in a love affair and a physical
relationship with Rohan Das, a 23 year old boy. Priya has completed the first year of
Degree College and stays with her family of five members at her residence in Dadar,
Mumbai. Rohan is an uneducated and unemployed person who also resides in Dadar,
Mumbai. In the course of their relationship, Priya realised that she was pregnant and
planned to elope and marry Rohan, as her family was against their relationship.
On the night of 20th July, 2016, all members of the Sharma family, Priya, her parents and
her grandparents, namely the father, Mr. Raju Sharma, his wife Smt. Manju Sharma,
grandfather, Mr. Ram Sharma and his wife, Smt. Sita Sharma were present at their
residence. At about 2.30 a.m. (i.e. the intervening period between 20th July and 21st July)
on that fateful night, upon hearing constant screaming and cries of a woman from the
neighbouring house, Mr. Vasant Naik (PW 1), the neighbour of the Sharmas, and his
brother broke the door and entered their house. They found Priya lying unconscious in
the bedroom of her parents, who were lying in a pool of blood, with their respective
throats slit. Thereafter they discovered that both the grandparents were also lying dead
in the opposite bedroom with their respective throats slit.
Immediately, Mr.Naik raised an alarm gathering other neighbours and also informed
the police at Dadar Police Station. Accordingly a case was recorded on the basis of
information received from Mr.Naik, and a First Information Report (FIR) was registered
at about 3.05 a.m. under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) against unknown
persons for the murder of four members of the Sharma family. The police investigation
team, which constituted of P.I. Kiran Rane (PW-6), a PSI, two constables along with two
Panch witnesses conducted the inquest panchnama and thereafter dispatched the four
dead bodies for post-mortem at the Government Hospital. Dr. A.B. Barve (PW-5)
conducted the post-mortem of all the four deceased persons. Further, blood stained
pillows, bed sheets, mattresses, etc near the respective dead bodies, were duly sealed,
marked, taken into possession and sent to the Forensic Laboratory.
ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

On further investigation, the police found out that there were mobile phone
conversations made between Priya and Rohan Das from 1.50 a.m. to 2.00 a.m. on 21st
July.The police found a white dress, stained with blood in the cupboard. Also, a wrapper
of ten sleeping tablets, which Priya had allegedly purchased and mixed in the dinner of
the deceased persons, was found in the cupboard.
It was later found that Rohan had committed suicide by hanging himself to the
roof of his residence at about 8.30 p.m. on 21st July, 2016. Additionally the murder
weapon; a blood-stained knife and a mobile phone were recovered from Rohans
residence. The recovered materials were sent to the Forensic Laboratory which
confirmed that the blood on the murder weapon and their respective clothes matched
with the blood of the deceased persons.
S.S. Rathod (PW-4), a person working at Dave Medical Stores at Dadar,
confirmed that Ms. Priya Sharma had visited his shop on 19th July, 2016 at about 8.00
p.m. and had purchased a packet of ten sleeping tablets, after which she left the shop
immediately.
Priya Sharma (accused and DW-1) was arrested on 21st July, 2016 at 5.00 p.m.,
near Dadar Railway Station.
According to the police, Priya and Rohan had together executed the murder
plan, wherein Priya had allegedly administered sleeping pills to the deceased persons
through their dinner and thereby rendered them unconscious and thereafter had
allegedly slit their throats. The alleged motive behind the commission of these
gruesome murders was to eliminate Priyas family which was not in favour of the
relationship between Priya and Rohan and thereby secure the entire property of the
family and create financial security for the couple. Accordingly, on completion of the
investigation, a charge-sheet was drawn. Priya Sharma has been charged under Section
302 of the IPC for the brutal murder of her innocent family members. The statements of
all the witnesses have been recorded.

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

FIRST INFORMATION REPORT (FIR)

(under Section 154 Cr.P.C)

1. State: Maharashtra
FIR No. R1- 4432

District: Mumbai

Police Station: Dadar

Year: 2016

Date: 21/07/2016

2. Act- Indian Penal Code- Section 302

3. (a) Occurrence of offence
Day Thursday
Date 21/07/2016
Time- 02:30 hours
(b) Information received at police station Dadar
21/07/2016

Time: 02.45 hours

(c) General Diary Reference: R1-10-4432

Entry No. 27

Date: 21/07/2016

Time: 03.05 hours

4. Type of information: Oral

5. (a) Place of Occurrence: Dadar
Direction and distance from police station: 1km. to the south of the Police Station
Chouki/ Beat No.: 02
(b) Address of occurrence: 86, Sadanand Apartments, Talekar Road, Dadar, Mumbai400028
Ward: 185
(c) In case outside the limit of this police station then that police stations
Name: N/A
Taluka: N/A
District: N/A
State: N/A
6. Complainant/ Informant:
(a) Name: Vasant P. Naik
ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

(b) Fathers name: Prabhakar A. Naik

(c) Date of birth: 17/09/1964
(d) Nationality: Indian
Phone number/s- 09146678091
(e) Passport No. N/A
(f) Occupation: School Teacher
(g) Religion: Hindu
Caste: N/A
Sub-caste: N/A
(h) Address: 88, Sadanand Apartments, Talekar Road, Dadar, Mumbai- 400028
Ward: 185
Nearest Post Office: Dadar Post Office
Nearest Police station: Dadar
Nearest identifiable place: RV Church
District: Mumbai
State: Maharashtra
Voter ID card number: WSG002451
7. Details, Name and Address of Accused
Name: Priya Sharma
Age: 20 years
Address: 86, Sadanand Apartments, Talekar Road, Dadar, Mumbai- 400028
8. Reasons for delay in reporting by the Complainant/ Informant: N/A
9. Particulars of properties stolen/recovered
a. Total value of properties: N/A
b. Recovered properties: N/A
c. Unnatural/ Accidental death case no.: 02134
10. Action taken: Since the above information reveals commission of offenses U/S as
mentioned in item no. 2,
(1) Registered the case and took up the investigation
ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

(2) Refused to take up investigation: N/A

F.I.R read over to the Complainant/Informant, admitted to be correct and copy given to
the Complainant/Informant free of cost.

Sd/Signature and thumb impression

Station
of the Complainant/ Informant

Sd/Signature of Officer, Police

Name: Kiran Rane (P.B.N 1276)
Rank: Police Inspector
Posting: Dadar Police Station

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

Panchnama
1) Pancha No. 1: Smt. Kalyani Harihar Pawar, Age: 32, Occupation: LIC Agent
Address: 12, Manorama Nivas, Raut Road, Dadar, Mumbai- 400028
2) Pancha No. 2: Mr. Rahul Bhide, Age: 28, Occupation: Hotel Owner
Address: Hotel Samadhan, Raut Road, Dadar, Mumbai- 400028
Today, we the abovementioned panchas, on being called by P.I. Kiran Rane,
visited the Dadar Police Station and subsequently, alongwith P.I. Kiran Rane, a PSI, and
two constables, visited the place of occurrence of crime, at Sadanand Apartments,
Dadar, at about 03.30 a.m. in a Toyota Qualis car, under crime registration number 252
of 2016. The informant, Vasant P. Naik was personally present. We were requested to
be panchas for conducting the said panchnama.
The informant showed us the place where the incident took place. The door of
the house is located on the southern wall. There is a passage, right opposite the door,
which leads to the kitchen, the toilets and the two bedrooms. One bedroom is on the
left while the other is on the right side, after entering the passage. We entered the
bedroom on the left side where we found two persons lying dead, with their throats
cut. The blood stained bedsheets, mattresses and pillows were seized. In the other
bedroom, we found two persons, who appeared to be more than 70 years old, lying
dead, with their throats slit in a similar manner. The blood stained bedsheets,
mattresses and pillows from this bedroom too were seized. A white dress, stained with
blood, was found in a cupboard in the second bedroom. Also, an empty packet of
Ramelteon Rozeren tablets was found in the cupboard. The four bodies were sent to
the nearest Government Hospital for conducting post mortems.
We left the crime scene at 04.15 am.
The aforesaid panchnama is true and correct as per the site as seen by we
panchas. Panchnama commenced at 3.30 am and completed at 4.15 am.
ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

Before me,
Sd/
Pancha 1

Sd/
Pancha 2

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

STATEMENT OF MR. VASANT NAIK (INFORMANT AND PW-1)

Name: Vasant Prabhakar Naik, Age: 52, Sex: Male, Occupation: School Teacher,
Residence: 88, Sadanand Apartments, Talekar Road, Dadar, Mumbai-28.
I am a resident of Sadanand Apartments, Dadar from the last seven years and I
have known the Sharma family since then. I stay there along with my younger brother. I
am employed as a school teacher at Childrens Academy, Churchgate, Mumbai. On the
intervening night between 20th July to 21st July, 2016. I heard loud cries at about 2.30
a.m. from Flat no. 86, upon which me and my brother rushed over there. After knocking
many times and failing to get any answer from inside, we broke the door and got inside
the house. We then entered a bedroom, wherein we found Priya Sharma lying
unconscious beside the bed, wearing a green dress. We discovered that both her
parents were lying dead in a pool of blood on the bed, with their throats slit. We also
discovered that in the opposite bedroom, both the grandparents were also lying dead
in a similar condition as that of the parents.
I was shocked and raised an alarm, upon which I gathered many other
neighbours. Thereafter, I immediately decided to inform the police and I telephoned
the Dadar Police Station at about 2.45 a.m. The police arrived at around 03.30 a.m. The
bodies were sent for post-mortem, and the bed sheets, mattresses, pillows, white dress
etc. were seized. I would further like to state that it was known to me and other
members of our apartments about the internal conflict within the Sharma family
because of the stiff opposition to Priyas relationship by the family members.

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

STATEMENT OF S.S. RATHOD (PW-4)

Name- S.S. Rathod. Age- 40 years. Profession Employee at Dave Medical Store

I, S.S. Rathod, have been working at Dave Medical Store since 20 years. I have
completed my education till HSC and have been working at this medical store since
then.
The members of Sharma family used to visit our store very frequently and hence, I was
acquainted with all the family members.
I state that on 19th July 2016, at around 8 pm, Ms. Priya Sharma had visited Dave
medical store. She asked for a packet of sleeping tablets. As she often used to purchase
these sleeping tablets, I presumed that she must be conscious about the risk of
overdose of the same, additionally no suspicion aroused in my mind and I gave out the
required packets of sleeping tablets. After grabbing the two packets, she immediately
left the shop because of which I could not provide her with the bill for the payment. I
was the only person who was present in the store at that time.

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

FINAL INVESTIGATION REPORT

(UNDER SECTION 173 OF THE CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE)
COURT: IN THE COURT OF SESSIONS AT MUMBAI
1) District: Mumbai
Police Station: Dadar Police Station
Year: 2016
CR No: 252/2016
Date: 21/07/2016
2) Final report/ charge sheet number: 07864353
3) Date: 20/09/2016
4) Provision: Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section- 302
5) Nature of Final Report: Charge sheet filed
6) Name of the Investigating Officer: Kiran Manoj Rane
Designation: PI, P.B.N 1276
7) Name of Complainant/ Informant: Vasant Prabhakar Naik
Fathers/ Husbands name: Prabhakar Naik
8) Things obtained at the time of investigation/ confiscated and property relied upon/
details of the articles (if necessary, add a separate list with the same)
Sr.No Description of the
property

Estimated
value

Sr. No of
the police
station
record diary

1.

N/a

654

N/a

655

N/a

656

N/a

657

2.
3.
4.

Bed sheets(Blood
stained) (2)
Mattresses(Blood
stained) (2)
Pillows(Blood
stained) (4)
Empty packet of
Ramelteon Rozeren
tablets

Property
recovered
from whom
and from
where
Spot of
crime
Spot of
crime
Spot of
crime
Spot of
crime

Disposal

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

5.

N/a

658

6.

Blood stained white

dress
Blood stained knife

N/a

663

7.

Mobile phone

5000

664

Spot of
crime
House of
deceased
boyfriend of
accused
House of
deceased
boyfriend of
accused

9) Details of the Accused against whom charge sheet is filed:

1. Name and age: Priya Sharma, 20 years
2. Whether identified and how: By witness
3. Father/ Husbands name: Raju Sharma
4. Sex: Female
5. Nationality: Indian
6. Passport Number: N/A
7. Religion: Hindu
8. If belongs to SC/ST: No
9. Profession: N/A
10. Address: 86, Sadanand Apartments, Talekar Road, Dadar, Mumbai- 400028
If verified: Yes
11. Temporary offender No. 24563 of 2016
12. Regular offender No. : N/A
13. Date of arrest: 21/07/2016
14. Date of release on bail: N/A
15. Date of sending to Court: N/A
16. Provision of arrest: Indian Penal Code, 1860- Section 302
17. Suretys name and address: N/A
18. Related previous conviction: N/A
ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

19. Condition of Accused: J.C

10) Details of examined witnesses

Name of
Witness
Vasant P. Naik

Father/Husba
nds name
Prabhakar
Naik

AGE

OCCUPATION ADDRESS

52

School
Teacher

2 Kalyani Pawar

Harihar Pawar

32

LIC Agent

3 Rahul Bhide

Mukesh Bhide

28

Hotel Owner

4 S.S. Rathod

Sunil Rathod

40

Employee

5 Dr. A.B.Barve

Balvant Barve

40

Doctor

6 Kiran M. Rane

Manoj Rane

45

Police
Inspector

88,
Sadanand
Apartment
s, Talekar
Road,
Dadar,
Mumbai
400028
12,
Manorama
Nivas, Raut
Road,
Dadar,
Mumbai400028
Hotel
Samadhan,
Raut Road,
Dadar,
Mumbai400028
Bhatkar
Colony,
ABC Road,
Dadar,
Mumbai
400028
12, Pragati,
A Road,
Fort,
Mumbai-01
3/31, Dadar
Police
Quarters,
Dadar,
Mumbai

Nature of
Witness
Informant
(PW 1)

Pancha No. 1
(PW 3)

Pancha No. 2
(PW 2)

Witness
(PW 4)

Witness
(PW 5)

Investigating
Officer
(PW 6)

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

7 Priya Sharma

Raju Sharma

20

Student

86,
Sadanand
Apartment
s, Talekar
Road,
Dadar,
Mumbai28

Accused
(DW 1)

11) Findings of Lab Testing:

a) The blood stains on the mattresses in the first bedroom, matched the blood
groups of the corpses in that bedroom and the blood stains on the mattresses in
the second bedroom, matched the blood groups of the corpses in that
bedroom.
b) The blood stains on the bed sheets also matched the blood groups of the
deceased people.
c) The blood stains on the knife could not be identified

Sd/-

Sd/-

Endorsed by the Senior Officer/

report

Officer presenting

Station House Officer

Senior Inspector K.K. Khanvilkar

P.I. Kiran Rane

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL, PAREL, MUMBAI.

REPORT OF POST-MORTEM EXAMINATION.
A.

POST MORTEM FINDINGS FOR CASE NO: 252/2016

POST-MORTEM NO: 222/2016

BODY IDENTIFIED BY: HC-23420 Dadar Police Station
DATE AND HOUR OF RECIEPT OF REQUISITION: 04:30 hours, 21/07/2016
DATE AND HOUR OF STARTING AUTOPSY: 07:00 hours, 21/07/2016
DATE AND HOUR OF CONCLUDING AUTOPSY: 11:00 hours. 21/07/2016

1.

NAME OF DECEASED PERSONS:

a) Mr. Raju Sharma (Male)

b) Smt. Manju Sharma (Female)
c) Mr. Ram Sharma (Male)
d) Smt. Sita Sharma (Female)

DECEASED NO. 1 : Mr. Raju Sharma (S/o Ram Sharma), AGE : 45 years, SEX: Male.
HEIGHT: 4.6 ft

WEIGHT: 71 kgs

PHYSIQUE: Normal.

SPECIAL IDENTIFICATION FEATURES: Mole on right shoulder blade

POST-MORTEM CHANGES PRESENT: Rigor mortis seen on entire body. Post
mortem lividity seen on back of trunk.
EXTERNAL APPEARANCE: Body dressed in white kurta-pajama, Throat was slit
INJURIES: Following ante-mortem injuries are noted:
Multiple two stab wound 6x5 cm x trachea cut x front of neck.
Stomach contained about 350 ml food content. There was gas in small intestine
and large intestine. The cause of death was shock and haemorrhage due to ante
mortem injuries and the viscera was preserved. Rigor mortis had passed from the
ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

neck and it was present on the upper and lower parts of the body.

DESEASED NO. 2 : Smt. Manju Sharma (W/o Mr. Raju Sharma), SEX : Female, AGE:
40 years
HEIGHT: 4 ft

WEIGHT: 65 kgs

PHYSIQUE: Normal.

SPECIAL IDENTIFICATION FEATURES: Mole on right arm.

POST-MORTEM CHANGES PRESENT: Rigor mortis seen on entire body. Post
mortem lividity observed.
EXTERNAL APPEARANCE: Body dressed in a black Punjabi dress, Throat was slit,
and loss of blood through the slit, upper part of the body wet with red coloured
blood.
INJURIES : Following ante-mortem injuries were noted:
Rigor mortis was present on both upper and lower limbs. Clotted blood was
present. Decomposition had not started. Ante-mortem injuries were as under:
1. An oblique incised wound of size 4 cm x 2 cm x trachea deep on the front of
right side neck. Clotted blood present and its direction from above downwards.
2. Stab wound 2.5 cm x 2 cm x bone deep on right side chest from upper part 4 cm
above right tip of shoulder tapering from medial to lateral. Clotted blood present.
3. Transverse incised wound 7 cm x 5 cm x trachea cut just above right side
manubrialsterni. Clotted blood present. Viscera was preserved.

DECEASED NO. 3: Mr. Ram Sharma (S/o Dashrath Sharma), SEX : Male, AGE : 70
years ,

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

HEIGHT: 4.9 ft

WEIGHT: 79 kgs

PHYSIQUE: Normal.

SPECIAL IDENTIFICATION FEATURES: Mole on right thigh.

POST-MORTEM CHANGES PRESENT: Rigor mortis seen on entire body. Post
mortem lividity observed.
EXTERNAL APPEARANCE: Body dressed in white kurta-pajama, Throat was slit, and
loss of blood through the slit, upper part of the body wet with red coloured blood.
INJURIES : Following ante-mortem injuries were noted:
Rigor mortis was present in upper and lower limbs. Decomposition was not
present. Blood from both nostrils coming out. Following ante-mortem injuries were
found:
1. An oblique incised wound 1 cm x .5 cm x muscle deep on the right side face just
outside the right eye. Clotted blood present. Wound's direction from above
downward.
2. An oblique incised wound 3 cm x 0.8 cm cartilages cut on upper part of right ear
pinna. Clotted blood present. Wound is directing from outer to inwards.
3. Transverse incised wound 8 cm x 5 cm trachea cut in front of lower part neck 3
cm above Manubrium sterniesophagus, blood vessels and nerves are cut. Clotted
blood present. Larynx was congested. On internal examination, membranes of
brain, both lungs, spleen and both kidneys were congested. C 6 vertebra was cut.
Death was due to Asphyxia as a result of shock and haemorrhage as a result of
ante-mortem injuries. The viscera was preserved.

DECEASED NO. 4 : Smt. Sita Sharma (W/o Mr. Ram Sharma), SEX : Female, AGE : 63
years .
HEIGHT: 4 ft

WEIGHT: 60 kgs

PHYSIQUE: Normal.
ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

SPECIAL IDENTIFICATION FEATURES: Mole on left cheek

POST-MORTEM CHANGES PRESENT: Rigor mortis seen on entire body. Post
mortem lividity observed.
EXTERNAL APPEARANCE: Body dressed in yellow coloured sari, Throat was slit, and
loss of blood through the slit, upper part of the body wet with red coloured blood.
INJURIES: Following ante-mortem injuries were noted:
Time of death was about half a day old and rigor mortis was present. No
decomposition was present. The following anti-mortem injuries were found:
1. An oblique incised wound 3 x 2 cm trachea cut on the front of neck, lower part
on the right side. Clotted blood present. Wound is directing from medial to lateral.
2. An oblique transverse incised wound 4.5 x 2 cm x trachea cut on front of neck
lower part 2 cm behind injury no. 1. Wound is directing from medial to laterally.
Clotted blood present.
On external examination, both lungs were congested. Both chambers of hearts
were empty. Lever and kidneys were congested. The viscera were preserved. The
cause of death was due to Asphyxia due to shock and haemorrhage due to antemortem injury.

2. INTERNAL EXAMINATION: on dissection of the chest and abdomen of all four

deceased persons, it was observed that, all organs are pale. Brain shows excessive
internal haemorrhage
TIME OF DEATH: The timing of death of all the four deceased persons is approximately
9 hours ago.

A.SPECIMEN COLLECTED FOR TOXICOLOGICAL ANALYSIS Viscera of all the four

deceased persons sent to the Department of Forensic Science, Government Hospital,
Mumbai.
ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

B. ITEMS HANDED OVER TO POLICEPost Mortem Report, Inquest papers, Dead bodies of all four deceased persons, Clothes
of all the deceased persons.
OPINION: The cause of death as due to Asphyxia due to shock and haemorrhage due to
ante-mortem injury
On 21/07/2016 at 11:30 am.
Sd/Dr. A.B. Barve
Medical Officer
Government Medical Hospital.

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

FORENSIC REPORT
No. P. (T) /564 of 2016
M.L. Case No. MP..
DEPARTMENT OF FORENSIC SCIENCE,
GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL, PAREL, MUMBAI.
Date : 27/07/2016
To,
P.I. Kiran Rane,
Dadar Police Station,
Dadar, Mumbai.

Your letter No. 23 dated 22/07/2016 regarding Five parcels in connection with
C.R. No. 252 of 2016 under I.P.C Section 302 stated by you to have been dispatched on
22/07/2016 per P.C. No. 2193 was duly received in this Department on 22/07/2016
Description of parcel/s
One blood stained axe (murder weapon), Two separate blood soaked mattresses,
four separate blood stained bed sheets, four separate blood soaked pillows, a partially
blood stained white coloured Punjabi dress, a knife, blood samples of four different
persons.
All the above materials were separately sealed in their respective plastic packets. Four
blood samples were with preservatives and duly sealed.

Description of articles contained in parcel/s

Exh.

1) Blood stained axe, sealed in plastic labelled A

2) Two separate blood soaked mattresses, sealed in plastic and labelled

B1 and B2 respectively.
3) Four separate blood soaked pillows sealed in plastic and labelled C1,

C2, C3 and C4 respectively.

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

4) Four separate blood stained bed sheets, plastic sealed and labelled D

1, D 2, D 3 and D 4
5) Partly blood stained white coloured Punjabi dress Exhibit H
6) An empty packet of Rameleon rozerem tablets Exhibit R
7) Viscera of four deceased persons.
8) Four different preserved blood samples (BS) of four persons in four different
respective bottles, labelled with their respective names Raju Sharma (BS 1),
Manju Sharma (BS 2), Ram Sharma (BS 3), Sita Sharma (BS 4).

RESULTS OF ANALYSIS
Blood samples- BS 1- A (rh positive)
BS 2- O (rh positive)
BS 3- O (rh positive)
BS 4- A (rh positive)
1) Blood on Exhibit C1, D1 matched with Exhibit (BS 1).
2) Blood on Exhibit C3, D 3 matched with Exhibit (BS 3).
3) Blood on Exhibit C2, D 2 and F matched with Exhibit (BS 2).
4) Blood on Exhibit C4, D 4 matched with Exhibit (BS 4).
5) Blood on Exhibit B1 matched with Exhibit (BS 1) and Exhibit (BS 2)
6) Blood on Exhibit B2 matched with Exhibit (BS 3) and Exhibit (BS 4)
7) Blood stains on Exhibit (H) matched with Exhibit (BS1).
8) Exhibit (R) had no presence of any poisonous substance on it.
9) Blood stains on Exhibit (A) could not be identified.
10) Presence of toxic substance in similar amounts in Viscera of all four persons.

No. P(T)/15066/12
Date 27/07/2016

Sd/-

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)

Attested photo copy issued to the

PI
Dadar Police Station.

B.S. Kotnis
Assistant Chemical Analyser
Department of Forensic Science
.

ADV. B.P.APTE MEMORIAL MOCK TRIAL, MOOT COURT AND JUDGEMENT WRITING
COMPETITION (FOURTH EDITION)