Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Content:
Week 1: Service Marketing I
Week 2: Service Marketing II
Week 3: Financial Services Marketing
Week 4: Marketing Strategy in the Financial Sector
Week 5: Service Quality Management and Models
Week 6: Service Quality Management and Models II
Week 7: Consumer Behaviour I
Week 8: Consumer Behaviour II
Week 9: Customer: Managing Relationships and Building Loyalty
Week 10: Customer: Managing Relationships and Building Loyalty II
Week 11: Processes, People and Physical Evidence: moments of truth
Week 12: Financial and services marketing key concepts on
distribution
Week 13: Key topics on communication
Week 14:
Goods
Technology
Fx costs
Rate
Storable
Yes
Reduce cost and price
7. New products
8. Differentiation
9. Competitive
advantages
10. Flexibility
11. Suppliers and Clients
implication
12. Quality measures
13. Human factor
Service
People
Fx of quality perception
Quality
Inestable demand
No
Increase quality
perception and price
Cheap but more risk
Difficult
More difficult
Ok in short term
Higher
Objective
Important
Subjective
Decisive
Models
Molecular model (Shostack): Every product has both tangible and intangible
elements. This model is used as a management tool. You have a basic service
(transport), which can be extended with an advanced service (seats, space
comfort) you offer to your customers. And you can also offer a potential service
(menu, drinks) which is not directly related to the basic service.
Customer-driven model:
Intangibility
Services
Intangible
Subjective
Ask others opinions
Experience
Intangibility goes together with: not storable, no patent, difficult pricing and
difficult communication. Because of this it is really hard to differentiate your
service. A strategy is to provide tangible evidence to your customers, have a
strong corporate image, reinforce staff professionalism and try to cross sell
Inseparability:
Production: customer participation and customer interaction (critical incidents).
Customer participation can be critical for example emergencies. Customer
interaction can be negative (family with loud children while a couple is having a
romantic dinner in the same restaurant) or positive (other people in cinema
reinforce laughs).
Other characteristics that belong to inseparability are service delivery and
uniformity.
Inseparability goes together with: customers involvement in production, other
clients interaction, simultaneously production and delivery, difficult massive
production and difficult delivery. Because of this it is really hard to differentiate
your service. A strategy is: Personnel selection and training, customers
management (= f.e. smokers and non-smokers area), increase the personnel,
technology to mass production and many locations.
Heterogeneity:
Quality is important. If there is something wrong with a product you can control
quality before the client arrives, check and fix mistakes and customer mood
doesnt affect. With a service however there is no second change, every
employee can behave different on different days.
Heterogeneity goes together with: Customer involvement in production, random
factors have effects on quality, real service differs from planning service and
higher risk on consumer perception. Because of this it is really difficult to control
quality standards. A strategy is: Customization (it will impact on speed delivery
and prices, you may have a higher margin), standardization (= low prices) and
technology.
Perishability:
Perishability goes together with: No storage, no inventory, difficult quality control,
difficult synchronice S/D, D>S (dissatisfied customers, there is scarcity or
exclusivity), S>D (excess of resources). This leads to problems with
supply/demand balance.
Strategies of demand are: Creative prices, booking services(less waiting time, let
you know the D in advance and you can fix the S to the D but there is a problem
is customer books but does not arrive), additional services(f.e. bar in a
restaurant), demand development(manage the dips and picks, more D in low
activity hours, employees working in different positions, preparing tangibles
before consume), new services, new targets.
Strategies of supply are: Part-time employees (costs reduce and flexibility but low
compromise and low skills), capacity share, prepare for medium-long term
growth, increase distribution through agreements, increase customer
participation (increase customization and price but you can lose control and have
a negative impact on corporate image and customer sensity).
Servuction
The systematic and coherent organization of all the physical and human
elements of the interface client/enterprise necessary to the realization of a
provision of services whose commercial characteristics and the levels of quality
were given.
Invisible component: consists of invisible organizations and systems. It refers to
the rules regulations and processes upon which the organization is based.
Although they are invisible to the customers, they have a very profound effect on
the consumers service experience.
Visible part consists of 3 parts: Serviscape (inanimate environment), contact
personnel/service providers, and other customers.
1993
2000
Regulation
Restrictive
Open with
entry barriers
Open and
international
Margin
High
Lower
Low
Volumes
Competitors
Low
Few
High
Medium-high
High
MKT investment
Low
Huge
High&selective
Differentiation
Coverage and
Brand
Very limited
Coverage and
Price
Important &
separate
Price and
Service
Important &
integrated
MKT Role
After the
crisis
Recapitalizati
on and
provisionin
g
Fees
increase
Concentrati
on, Saving
banks
High &
selective
Price wars
Important
&
Integrated
(jobless&payment)/technological gifts
Prices Increase in margins (risk)/Increase of all fees
Communication Both global corporate image & selective/international
(Sant/BBVA)
Special features of financial institutions
Dual relationship (=buyer-seller relationship) ; High regulation ; Stable
relationship with customer ; High risk ; No industrial property.
Financial services as products:
Separability the production of many financial products can be separated from
their consumption, you dont need to be physically in your bank to use your
checking account.
Lack of perishability you can use whenever you want, easier to manage supply
and demand.
Mass production While many financial services are individualized such as
financial advice, other can be mass-produced and mass-marketed, like insurance
policies, college saving accounts or data analysis systems. Mass distribution and
cost saving.
Financial services as services:
Low cost of entry There is no such cost to manufacture, inventory or distribute
a financial product. Few barriers to creating or copying. Also there are no
warehousing or physical distribution costs.
Speed to the market You dont need prototypes, models.. the idea is the
product.
Lack of exclusivity it cannot be patented.
Financial mkt-mix strategies
Before planning commercial activity the following should be clear: Corporate
culture, market positioning, entity goals and competitors positioning.
Key elements of commercial strategy:
Strategic Plan (long term) ; Goals and results ; Market share ; Business goals
(=lead to) Marketing plan (annual) ; Business objectives ; Product
objectives ; Segment
objectives ; Geographical area objectives ; Profitability
objectives
(= lead to) Product ; Price ; Distribution ; Communication
(=both ways) Resources; Budget
You go from market segmentation to services positioning to the marketing mix (4
or 7 Ps). This marketing mix leads eventually to the product, price, distribution
and communication.
Marketing Department Organization
Centralized organization:
* End users select provider based on other matters like convenience (word-ofmouth referral).
* Cost doesnt matter, most people make no cost comparison and sometimes
they just focus on return and ignore costs.
* Stickiness of money decisions means that once a purchase has been made, the
buyer tends to stay with the product even when the reason for the initial decision
is no longer valid, more time to amortize the cost of new customer but do not
take loyalty for granted.
Elements from transactions to relations
Traditional marketing = Focused on sale: Be known, preferred and bought
Interactive marketing = Focused on satisfying: Moments of truth
Associative Marketing = Focused on success: Added value
Relationship Marketing
Scope Relationship marketing is the point where quality, customers service
and marketing come together, so all 3 should be present.
Quality From production faced to customer faced Important: pay attention
to perceived quality.
Marketing strategy exists out of: Customer; Compromise; Confidence;
Friendship and Loyalty.
Transaction
Focus on isolated sales
Oriented to product features
Short-term vision
Low service customer attention
Low customer compromise
Limited customers contact
Relationship
Focus on customers retention
Oriented to product benefits
Long-term vision
High service customer attention
Frequent customers contact
Quality as main worry for everyone
Relations Marketing
Customer retention
Product benefits
Long term
High customer service
High customer compromise
High customer contract
Quality is everyones worry
Marketing 1-to-1
Customer share
Customer differentiation
Customer management
Customers as colleagues
Find products for customers
Servqual conclusions
Quality benefits are: loyalty customers; recurring businesses and lower churn rate
Name
Individualized
Quantities
Database and CRM
Specialist
Special relationship
Service
Relationship banking:
No name
Mass market
Statistics
Product information
Any employee
Not a loyal customer
price
Money transfer Transferring funds (cheque book, debit and credit card).
Deferred payment Delay payments (credit card, personal loan, mortgage).
Financial advice Not only a solution but also instrumental to finding one.
Cogniti
ve
Growth
=
=
=
Extern
al
Passive
Emotional responses
Rational responses
Maintenance of
equilibrium
Driven by need for
internal change
Self-initiated
Self-development
Driven by
environmental change
Reactive
Motive bundling: One product attends to a number of needs at the same time.
Credit card, is not only buy now and pay later, it also attends need for safety (less
cash handling), belongingness (club membership), esteem (prestige) or power.
Fear appeal: Needs drive motivated behaviour in a specific direction, and
negative goals involve avoidance objects. Avoidance objects are the raison dtre
of most financial services (theft, ill-health, an impoverished old age,
unemployment)
Conflicting motivations and goal polarity: Either attracting or repealing forces,
results in three types of goal conflicts. They are described in the drawing below:
Segmentation
We need to look at data/characteristics that are measurable, accessible and
substantial.
Single variable 1: Sex woman less active role in familiar financial matters,
divorce, less pressure to admit lack of knowledge.
Single variable 2: Social class Conceptually complicated (private banking),
divorce, some blue collar workers earn, best informed usually have the most to
invest.
Single variable 3: Income Income, disposable/discretionary income, does not
reflect needs, niches as singles and gays.
Hybrid 1: Family life-cycle Single bachelor, newly-wed, family growth, family
reduction etc.
Hybrid 2: Geodemographics Niches as singles and gays ; GDP per square
meter ; unemployment by regions
Financial services segmentation:
* Objective methods: demographic, geopgraphic, life-cycle, product.
* Psychographic clusters Benefits-based segmentation or lifestyle
segmentation
* Customer value segmentation
If you combine customer value segmentation with the following questions you get
a clear view what type of customers you want, how you can find them and how
you can serve them best.
Cognitive map
The learning process: Behavioural Conditioning. think about the dog, food and
the bell.
Theories and Instrumental conditioning: Cognition- mental processes of knowing,
perceiving and judging which enables individuals to interpret the world around
them. Both learning and perception are central to the production of the
individuals world view or cognitive map. BCT-automatic response to
stimulus/instrumental conditioning-learning is trial-error basis, the individual will
seek positive reinforcement and will avoid negative ones.
The learning process: Cognitive learning
Cognitivists reject that all behaviour is learn through stimulus-response and
reinforcement, as it ignores the powerful influence of observation and conscious
problem solving. Learning is the result of mental activity which restructures the
cognitive map. So it introduces cognition as an intervening organizing force
between the stimulus and the response. Continuous reinforcement will imply a
decreasing of cognitive or mental activity required for a decision, leading to habit
or loyalty.
The learning process: Memory
Cognitive learning requires memory both short and long term. Motives are
important determinants of what a selectively stored, as it is widely believed that
consumers retrieve product benefits or shortcomings rather than attributes. Each
person will remember the same product in a different way depending on his own
judgment, interpretation and perception.
Perception:
The cognitive map is partial personal construction in which certain objects are
perceived in an individual manner.
Perception is the process by which an individual selects, organizes, and interprets
stimuli into a meaningful and coherent picture of the world. Perception is
selective; there is selective attention and selective exposure. Perceptual
defense: Selection distortion and selective blocking. And eventually there is also
selective retention.
Perceived risk:
Dimensions: Uncertainty about the outcome/Seriousness of consequences. There
are 4 types of risk:
Physical risk; Psychological risk; Financial risk and Time risk.
COMPREHENSIVE MODEL:
This model provides a framework for analyzing all the factors known to influence
consumer behaviour, unlike the limited models such as the response hierarchies
which simply looks at attitudes.
problem recognition search alternative evaluation purchase decision
purchase behaviour
Decision rules in alternative evaluation:
* Compensatory decision rules assign weights to reflect the perceived
importance of each relevant attribute. The service with the highest sum total will
be preferred. Low rating on one dimension can be compensated with high score
on another, very expensive financial adviser may be chosen for experience and
trustworthiness.
*Non-compensatory decision rules
- Conjuctive rule the consumer sets minimum acceptable standards for
each attribute and any falling below this level are rejected. The consumer
achieves smaller choice set, but he
needs further decision rule.
- Lexicographic choice strategy the consumer first ranks the attributes
according to their relative importance. The alternative scoring mostly highly on
the most important criterion
will be selected, but in the event of no clear
winner, the process is repeated using the second most important attribute.
ALTERNATIVE MODEL:
Need of a model which incorporates:
* The role of consumers play in the Servuction
Questions to answer:
1. Useful market segmentation
2. Needs
3. Best fit of each of these markets in our operations capabilities
4. Advantages and disadvantages for each segment
5. Target?
6. How to differentiate from our competitors
7. Long term value
8. Long term loyalty strategies
You should do a cost revenue analysis but dont forget to take risk into account.
Selecting the appropriate customer portfolio:
1. Creating a portfolio of market segments
2. Segmentation strategies for effective capacity utilization
3. Customers as part of the service experience
Unattractive customers
Targeting the right customers Is the customer always right?
There are two parts of this questions, is the customer indeed always right or is
the marketplace as positively overpopulated with nasty people?
There are 5 types of jay customers:
1. The thief
2. The rule breaker
3. The belligerent (=strijdlustig/oorlogvoerend)
4. The vandal
5. The deadbeat
Be restrictive to the target customer. You do want to do a life insurance of a
business man but not of a bungee jumper because you have much more risk with
him.
Value of loyal customer
There are big differences in the relationships of customers with the company. The
nature of service delivery can be a membership relationship or no formal
relationship. Furthermore both categories can have continuous delivery of service
or discrete transaction.
Relationship vs transactions:
1. Information
2. Computerized analysis
3. Direct mail
4. Telephone selling
5. Personal sales calls
Valued relationships: A long relationship results in higher profits. Every year a
customer stays a customer the profit rises. So it is important to make your
customers loyal to you.
Full profit potential of a customer:
1. Profit derived from increased purchases
2. Profit from reduced operating costs
CRM
Support:
- Management support
- Support functions
- technological/knowledge support
Unrelated functions
Designing the process: Blueprinting Services
Blueprinting = Flowcharting
The process: (1) Sequential flow of the service in both visible and support
services ; (2) Deliver consistent quality.
The mean: (1) Resources used to accomplish each of the tasks in the process ;
(2) Physical asset pr people
The evidence: (1) Set of clues customers use to assess the quality of a firm ; (2)
i.e. Appearance, professionalism and demeanor of front line personnel.
Developing a blueprint:
Group 3-8 participants Specific instance of a service Select the beginning
point Departments and persons involved Map the steps in sequence
Notation in a blueprint is not standard you can use the following:
Dialogue points Require carefully prepared scripts to interact with the
customer.
Problem points Require problem solving, diagnosis, judgment and choice on
part of service employees.
Fail points Should be easy to locate and study the diagram for possible
improvements
People
Managing people using internal marketing:
Internal marketing exists out of: Training ; Continuous interaction with
management ; Internal mass communication ; Marketing research ; other HR
activities.
Physical evidence
For example bankbooks, plastic cards and wallets.
Managing the physical evidence: servicescape
The environment in which the service is assembled an in which the seller and
customer interact, combined with tangible commodities that facilitate
performance or communication of the service.
Points of sales:
NFC ; Contactless ; mobile (this is new banking)
Shared with others, limited services
Remote distribution channels
Remote distribution channels:
Home banking Services: information and operations (transfers, payments,
investment funds subscription). Advantage: low cost, no timetables and
disadvantage: need computer/coldness
Telephone banking
a)Complementary and branches support
b) Different channel with specific products
c) Separate form branches, own channel (First Direct, UK)
Mobile phone where is the closest bank I can find
Internet banking
Indirect distribution channels
Europe: 26% mortgages, 27% consume loans, 54% investment funds
Bestinvert
Financial agents:
Strengths: no fixed cost/prescription/high motivation of FA
Weaknesses: complex product difficul to undertand by FA/no high revenues for
FA/ FA develops the relationship with customer
Insurance distribution
In-store (f.e. ATM in supermarket) / large commercial surfaces distribution
Corners/stands
El corte ingls, agreement with 20 financial institutions
A Spanish example is BanCorreos Deutsche bank approached Correos to open
a bank inside of their buildings. The services are provided by Deutsche bank but
the people have more trust and it is more convenient because it is part of
Correos.
Objectives
Communication in society
There is too much information in the society.
Last 30 years more information has been generated than in the previous 5.000
years.
Every day more than 4,000 books are published.
A 18 years old man in UK has been exposed to 140,000 adds
Communication mix
Communication exists out of sales promotion ; public relations ; personal selling ;
direct marketing and advertising.
Below the line, not general but to specific targets: direct marketing, promotional
marketing, public relations, sponsorship, merchandising, telephone marketing,
communication in sales-point.
Efficiency-cost
Prescriber = people who can influence other to buy my product, for example,
bank director for an insurance
Communication: Personal sale
Only 20-25% of time in financial branches is devoted to sales.
Main changes:
Communication: Advertising
Advertising is any paid form of non-personal presentation and promotion of
ideas, goods and services through mass media such as newspapers, magazines,
television or radio by an identified sponsor (Kotler)
Communication Charged Impersonal Sponsor advertiser Persuade
Advertising goal: AIDA = awareness, interest, action, desire.
Financial advertising goals: Corporate image, added value and reliability, specific
target
The functions of advertising:
Brand building most financial advertising are bought irregularly so reinforce
corporate image
Familiarity gives potential buyers the comfort that they are making the right
decision, support salespeople
Customer retention reinforce satisfaction among those who already bought
your product
Reaching 3-party influencers aimed at senior management, financial advisors
will be more willing to refer business to companies well known
Maintain market share defensive advertising
Improving employee moral can have a positive effect on staff motivation and
make recruitment easier
Communication: advertising channels
Papers: diary, local /national press, general magazines, specialized magazines,
professional magazines
TV: sponsorship, inside a tv serie or direct sale (never in Spain)
Radio: cheap and immediately
Mailing: you can choose your target
Outside publicity: poster, neon sign, transports. Cheap and great impact and
geographical flexibility.
New: social nets, guest blogging
The newspaper is less expensive to create and place. Furthermore the complexity
of financial products lends itself to be printed. And print media offer the ability to
target more precisely, for example in the financial part of a paper.
While tv is good to communicate emotions, print is better able to communicate
facts and figures. You will have to decide also the size and placement (back
cover, inside front cover, full page, inside back cover, inside spread, vertical 2/3
page, horizontal page, vertical 1/3 page)
Platforms of social media:
Twitter allows companies to promote products on an individual level (followers).
Facebook more detailed profiles than Twitter (videos, testimonials)
Blogs allow a product/company to provide longer descriptions of products or
services.
Communication: Sponsorship
Sponsorship can be defined as the provision of resources (e.g., money, people,
equipment) by an organization directly to an event or activity in exchange for a
direct association to the event or activity (Sandler and Shani, 1989). It is about
media coverage.
Revenue, cost reductions, equivalent value (pre-event publicity or direct
marketing and event-based promotion)
Communication
During leisure
time
Common content
in media
Awareness
High impact on
target
Awareness in
other groups
Increase your
Image
Built positive
corporate image
Associate
corporate image
with the event
Appreciation for
Economic
Tax deductions
brand-appearance
Balance with
competitors
advertising
the event
Differentiate your
corporate image
from competitors
Benefits:
Built brand awareness by associating a companys product with an event
Shorten the sales cycle, helps purchasers relate the products to a cause or event
that the customers also support
Maintain and strengthen existing relationships
Demonstrate to attends a companys expertise through seminars and exhibit
Improve employee morale