Republic of the Philippines )

CITY OF MANILA
) ss.

Reply-Affidavit
I, JAYZEE DEL ROSARIO, 14 years old, after having been duly sworn
to in accordance with law, now depose and state that:
1. That I have already executed a Complaint-Affidavit for
FRUSTRATED MURDER in relation to R.A. 7610 against
respondents TYRONE ISIP, KEVIN VILLADAREZ, MARK
ANTHONY NEVADO, JOEZEN PRESBITERO and JEFEL REYES;
2. That I have read the Joint Counter-Affidavit of all the
respondents and now submit this present Reply to rebut their
allegations.
3. That on May 10, 2014, at about 1:30 A.M. respondents
committed the above crime of FRUSTRATED MURDER in
relation to R.A. 7610 against me as I have narrated in my
original Complaint-Affidavit as well as my Supplemental
Affidavit. As expected, apart from the bare and
unsubstantiated allegation of me being drunk at that time,
the Joint Counter-Affidavit of all respondents offers
nothing but plain and ugly denial. Denial, like alibi, is

inherently a weak defense and cannot prevail over the

positive and credible testimony of the prosecution
witness that the accused committed the crime. (People
of the Philippines vs.Edwin Belibet, Manny Banoy
and Ronnie Rosero G.R. No. 91260, July 25, 1991) At
the outset, suffice it to say that respondents convenient
defense of denial is a matter best threshed out in a full blown
trial.
4. That the records and the evidence I submitted positively
proves the following facts: TYRONE DELOS REYES ISIP
suddenly strangled me and punched me repeatedly on the
face on the date and time of incident; the rest of the group
which include KEVIN VILLADAREZ, MARK ANTHONY NEVADO,
JOEZEN PRESBITERO and JEFEL REYES, held me down
completely that I was not even able to struggle; that was
when TYRONE stabbed me at my back and elbow using what I
later learned was a piece of broken glass bottle; and the
attack was so vicious, unexpected and swift that I had
no means nor opportunity to put up any defense;
5. That respondent TYRONE and JEFEL submitted as an
afterthought medical certificates which would purportedly
prove that they also sustained injuries allegedly caused by
me. However, the said medical certificates would show that
respondent TYRONE sought medical attention for
alleged injuries hours after the incident (5/10/14 4:00
P.M. in TYRONEs case) while it is unsure from JEFERS
medical certificates when he was actually treated

(Medico-Legal Slip says 5/9/14 while another is dated 10 May

2014). Additionally, all of the injuries that would appear
TYRONE and JEFER sustained were merely superficial
(on the knee in TYRONEs case and a mere contusion on
JEFERs). These are all in stark contrast to the evidence I
submittedI was mauled and stabbed, with fistic blows that
hit me in the head, knocking me unconscious, and a volley of
kicks hitting me all over; I was practically left for dead;
6. That if indeed respondent TYRONE and JEFEL were the real
victims of the incident they should have had sustained more
substantial injuries than me; and yet they have not. I, on the
other hand, have been mauled and stabbed in such a sudden
manner that I was left with no chance at all to defend myself;
I was left for dead and would have probably died had I not
been brought and treated in the hospital. If indeed they were
the ones actually injured they should have swiftly complained
against me; and yet they did not. I, on the other hand, by the
filing of the present case against the respondents, have
quickly asserted my right to lodge a criminal complaint, a
clear badge of one whose right has surely been violated;
7. That again the evident intention of respondents based on
their concerted actions is to put an end to my life. Their
vicious attack on my person almost killed me if not for the
prompt medical attention given to me. I am lucky to have
survived that terrible mauling and stabbing incident, but I am
every day traumatized and frightened because of it;
8. That is why I have caused the filing of the above charge
against the respondents TYRONE ISIP, KEVIN VILLADAREZ,
MARK ANTHONY NEVADO, JOEZEN PRESBITERO and JEFEL
REYES based on the above evidence and narration;
9. That I am executing this Reply-Affidavit to attest to the
truthfulness and veracity of the foregoing contents and for
the purpose of lodging a criminal case of FRUSTRATED
MURDER in relation to R.A. 7610 against TYRONE ISIP, KEVIN
VILLADAREZ, MARK ANTHONY NEVADO, JOEZEN PRESBITERO
and JEFEL REYES.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand this 8 th day of
August 2014 in the City of Manila, Philippines.

JAYZEE DEL ROSARIO

Complainant

SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me this 8th day of August 2014

in the City of Manila, Philippines.
ADMINISTERING OFFICER