Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
D I V YA DVA I T A D R U S H T I
September 2016
One should never stop showing devotion towards Vishnu and others
in the hierarchy according to their gradation. Further, one should
gradually show more and more devotion towards them
A person slipping and falling from a height or struggling to come out of a
flooded river, needs to catch hold of a branch of a tamarind tree and not that
of a drumstick tree. Similarly Jivas struggling in the flood of samsaara and
aiming to get out of it need to catch hold of the strong Vedas (and its doctrines). Fools choose philosophies that appear easier to follow, just like the
drumstick tree which is more approachable than the strong tamarind tree
Vadiraja Tirtha
Q & AJIIJNYASA
FORUM
3,
7
NECESSITY
WHO IS GANESHA
RAMAYANA UNFOLDED 6
WHY DID RAMA LEAVE
SITA
Volume 1, Issue 2
VISHNU IS NOT A
SECTARIAN DEITY OF A
Vishnu's Supremacy
OF THE COSMOS
Vishnu is not a sectarian deity of a few people known as Vaishnavas. When we speak
of Vishnu, we are speaking of the Supreme
being who is the cause of all causes, the only
independent entity, the embodiment of infinite virtues, the One who doesn't have the
slightest trace of flaw, that Supreme principle which pervades every atom of the cosmos, the Supreme ruler of the world, the One
whom everyone calls by different names and
worships in different ways, the indwelling
ruler of all creatures.
The one whom Sri Shankaracharya identifies as the 'Saguna Brahman' and the One who is given the status of the Supreme
Brahman, the God paramount by Sri Ramanujacharya and Sri Madhwacharya. This and the succeeding article explain in
brief the reason why Vishnu occupies such Supreme position in most of the Indian philosophies. However the reasons given
in this particular article are very simple and straight in nature, so that the readers are comfortable.
1) Among the trinity of Gods, both Brahma and Shiva are popularly depicted as in deep meditation, while Vishnu in His
moola roopa is depicted as comfortably resting on Shesha. This is obvious as Vishnu doesn't have a superior on whom He is
to meditate!!
2)The river Ganga which emerges from the feet of Vishnu, is devotedly placed on his head by Shiva, while Brahma collects
it in his 'kamandal'. We do this when we wash a Swamiji's feet as he is superior to us. Now apply the same reasoning here
and decide who is the Supreme!
3)Make a list of popular Vishnu devotees like Dhruva, Prahlada, Ambarisha etc. and then list out devotees of other gods,
like Ravana, Jarasandha, Banasura etc. Compare the two cases, remember the ends they met and this can bring us to the
conclusion that Vishnu is the Supreme.
4)The 'Brahman' of the Upanishads is called so because of His all-pervasion in space, time and attributes(bruhatva). Veda
Vyasa on the other hand attributes such all-pervasion to Vishnu by stating "bruhatvAt vishnuruchyatE". The word Vishnu
also means the same as Brahman because its root word "vishlr" indicates pervasion('vishlr vyAptow').
5)Another popular term denoting the Supreme God in the Upanishads is 'Atman' who is none other than Vishnu. This is
made clear in the Bhagavata where it is said that the three sons of Atri-Anasuya i.e. Datta, Durvasa and Soma manifested
from Atma, Isha and Brahma ("dattam durvAsasam sOmam AtmEsha brahma sambhavAhA") . Here, Shiva is called by his
popular name 'Isha' and so is 'Brahma'. Vishnu is addressed as Atma which indicates the epithet is very popular for Him in
the scriptures.
6)When all those crores of gods together were not even able to shake the Mandara parvata to the slightest during Samudra mathana, Vishnu single handedly plucked the mountain, placed it on Garuda, brought it to the ocean and helped the
gods churn the ocean.
7)When Lakshmi manifested from the ocean as a result of Samudra mathana, she saw flaws in all gods and divinities present there and chose Vishnu as her husband as He doesn't have any flaws and was the only one there who was so selfsufficient that He never was in need of even Lakshmi while all others out there, both gods and demons yearned for Lakshmi
in different ways. This is recorded in the Bhagavata.
8)We know very well, how the pantheon of gods headed by Brahma and Shiva, rushes to Vishnu when there is any threat
to the world from an evil force.
Page 2
9)The Ramayana and the Mahabharata which are the most widely accepted epics, have Vishnu
(Rama and Krishna) as their central theme. The Mahabharata is called "Narayana katha" in the
Mahabharata itself and also by the famous Kannada poet, Kumara Vyasa in his 'Karnata bharata katha manjari'. The Manu smriti also explains the meaning of the word Narayana in the
very beginning, proving He is the primary goal of everything described in it.
10) The births of Brahma and Shiva are very popular in the scriptures. Brahma is said to have
born in the lotus from the navel of Vishnu, while Shiva was born from Brahma's anger as described in the Bhagavata. Vishnu is not described as being born from someone in our scriptures.
11) As recorded in the Bhagavata, when there is a specific inquiry as to who is the Supreme
among the trinity to whom all the sacrificial oblations are to be offered, Bhrigu rishi visits all the
three and gives his verdict that Vishnu is the Supreme among Brahma-Vishnu-Maheshwara.
12) The usage "Harih OM" which is an indispensable part of all Dharmik acts and also an equivalent of 'Hello' in Sanskrit, after all equates Hari(Vishnu) with "OMkaara" and thus brings out the
fact that "OM" is the most comprehensive name of Vishnu, which describes His infinite attributes.
OF GODS, BOTH
BRAHMA AND SHIVA
ARE POPULARLY
DEPICTED AS IN DEEP
MEDITATION, WHILE
VISHNU IN HIS
MOOLA ROOPA IS
DEPICTED AS
COMFORTABLY
RESTING ON SHESHA.
THIS IS OBVIOUS AS
VISHNU DOESN'T
HAVE A SUPERIOR ON
WHOM HE IS TO
MEDITATE!!
Clarifications:Vishnu in His various incarnations might have worshipped Shiva and others. But such acts done by "avataras" like Rama and
Krishna is to
i)Guide people on earth to do so when particular circumstances arrive, for example Krishna pretended to worship Shiva to get
a son, to show the world that those who wish for a son should worship Shiva. After all the very purpose of God coming down
in the form of a human is to teach humans.
ii) To mislead undeserving asuras, so that they start believing Krishna, Rama etc. aren't the Supreme.
iii) Especially when it comes to Rama-Krishna worshipping Shiva, it is clearly mentioned in the Puranas that Shiva had a boon
from Vishnu that the latter would worship Shiva in His incarnations.
These are a very few logical observations to kindle the fire of conviction in "Hari sarvottamatva". Readers are to openmindedly go through this and seek more justifications for themselves. The article which succeeds this now, complements whatever is mentioned here and also is a step ahead of this one, in driving home the required point.
Gururaj Bhandarkar, author of the above article, is an engineering student at Maharaja Institute of Technology, Mysore. He is
from Mysore. He is very knowledgeable about Madhva philosophy. He wrote his first book on Madhva philosophy while in
10th standard and when most of his friends were into games.
We get questions all the time. And we knock many doors to find answers. While some are
knocking many doors because the right answers don't appeal to them and want anukula shaastra, others are honestly looking for right answers.
We think only the latter category deserve answers. Right answers are based on the solid foundation of philosophy.
WHY DO WE DO THE
RITUAL OF
SHRAADDHA FOR OUR
ELDERS? DO OUR
FOREFATHERS COME
TO PARTAKE FOOD
ON THAT DAY? WHAT
HAPPENS TO THE SOUL
AFTER IT DEPARTS
FROM THE BODY?
As said in Bhagavadgeeta and explained by Srimadacharya, Pranadeva carries the soul on His left shoulder and God
on His right shoulder and flies out. The soul, who is thus carried has his sukshma deha, the subtle body made up of the
pancabhutas and his karma.
Once the parent soul leaves the body we have to look after him as we did when he/she was alive. This involves certain
regular kriya karmas throughout our life. Immediately after death, the body, a sadhana deha, has to be given utmost
respect and with certain rituals it has to be given to the fire as an ahuti (sacrifice). The agni here is kravyAda and the
indweller Narayana. The whole life is led through the body as an oblation, different kinds of yajnas finally becomes an
ahuti to God. But the soul has been deprived of a body through which he can do his duties in the afterworld. Immediately
after death the jiva is endowed with aativaahika sharira and rushes to the town of Yama in 24 to 48 hours and returns
back. Now the son has to make an effort to give a body to the departed soul, quench the hunger and thirst and provide
vastra. All this is done for the first ten days through giving anna pindas. The sukshma bhaaga (subtle part) of the anna
and tila goes up to make all the parts of the body slowly from head to toe in first ten days. On the tenth day, the jiva is
given over to Rudra for further travel. This procedure done on the tenth day is called dharma vedika where a larger size
dashama dina panda is kept in a vedika drawn along with some others for other gods Yama and Rudra.
From this day to the first year shraddha the jeeva will be travelling to Yama loka. The path traversed is graphically described in Garuda puraana by Vishnu. There are sixteen major milestones or stops on this way. The shodasha shraadhas
16 shraadhas done in the first year are for this soul at each of the stop. Currently these 16 shraddhas are done on 11th
day and again on the first year shraaddha . Various daanas are given to help him on the way and also for his journey in
the afterworld. We will see the details about these in a separate article.
Now, on tenth day, the soul has acquired a body, the size of which is said to be one hasta. This is about one and half
feet. The rough length is from our elbow to the top of our closed fist. With this body, which is sukshma bhoga deha, he
travels and reaches Yamaloka in a years time. Meanwhile there is one more important ritual which must be done. This is
called sapindeekarana. The soul has to discard its pretatva and become a pitra. This is done on the twelfth day. The departed soul has to be merged with the line of our forefathers. So a bigger elliptical pinda along with grandfather, great
grandfather and great-great-grandfather is prepared and worshipped. The fathers pinda is cut into three by a darbhagold-thread and each of the three parts joined and mixed with the earlier three.
Page 4
Volume 1, Issue 2
Once this is done the father loses the preta deha and henceforth is called pitra. The
great-great-grandfather is supposed to go ahead in his journey and is not worshipped
anymore. On thirteenth day or later a preetishraadha is done for him in some paramparas. On first year when the shraadha is done and the soul has reached Yamaloka he
discards the hasta-long shareera and acquires praadesha maatra shareera. This is
about 6 inches long and with this sukshma shareera he travels to his goal according to
his karma.
FOREFATHERS?
DO THEY COME
DOWN TO US
ON SHRADDHA
DAY?
IMPORTANT?
For us one day is of twenty four hours. For pitrus the bright half of the month-shukla pasha- is day and dark half-krishna
paksha- is night. In this day we have to do one shraadha. But it is no more in vogue. But at least we should not miss the
yearly shraadha. This brings on the displeasure of the pitru devatas mentioned above and finally displeasure of Lord
which affects us and our childrens well-being.
Also the Krishna paksha of bhadrapada is reserved by God for pitrus. It is said in puranas that Yamaloka is empty in
these fifteen days as Yamadeva sends the jivas to bhuloka so that they can get the oblations and be satisfied with
shraadha offered to them in the mahalaya. They wait till Deepavali amavasya and if not given pinda they curse and
return. So it is also necessary to do shraadha in Mahalaya , at least on the tithi on which they departed .
Would the pitru come to the home of the son to receive the food offered? This is a question asked often. The answer is
yes, they do come. It is said that Yama sends them for a day for the shraadha. What if they are reborn elsewhere? As
there is proof that the pitrus do come for shraaddha Lord may send an amsha which is possible with His inscrutable power. When Sriramachandra was doing shraadha for Dasharatha, Seetaadevi suddenly went away. When asked for reason she said she saw her father-in-law Dasharatha there and it is not fit to be present in presence of father-in-law. There
is another incidence of Shantanus hand coming out of earth to get the pinda being offered by Bhishma, but instead of
giving it in his fathers hand suddenly appearing, Bhishma keeps the pinda on the darbhas as mandated by shaastra. So
there need not be any doubt. Pitrus do come and it is the infinite kindness of Lord which makes it possible.
The three duties mandated by shaastra which is an express order of Lord Vishnu for the sons toward father are 1) look
after them when they are alive 2) do all aparakarmas and yearly shraadhaas and 3) once in a lifetime give pinda on
vishnupada in Gayaa.
May shraadhaadhipati Sri Gayaa Gadaadhara bless us all by motivating to keep doing these three duties.
Who is Ganesha?
Ganesha is the deity controlling aaakasha (aakasha abhimani). He
falls in the 18th kaksha (18th in the line of hierarchy starting from
Lord Vishnu Himself at number 1). He is to be worshipped as the remover of obstacles. Ganapati removes the vignas caused by reasons
below 18th kakshe. He is also to be worshipped as subservient to Lord
Vishnu and not as equal to Him or superior to Him.
Raktaambaro Raktatanuh Raktamaalyaanulepanah
lambodaro Gajamukhah Paashadantaakushaabhaye
Bibhraddhyeyo Vighnaharah kamadastvarayaa hyayam//
Page 5
Volume 1, Issue 2
Ramayana unfoldedWhy did Rama leave Sita?
FIRE-GOD, DECLARED
THAT SITA WAS FREE
FROM SINS, SO ALSO
VAYU; SO DID
PROCLAIM THE TWO
SUN AND MOON
BEFORE THE GODS
SITA FREE FROM SINS
BEFORE ALL THE
RISHIS.
..AND MY INNER
CONSCIENCE BEARS
TESTIMONY TO HER
PURITY AND NOBILITY.
Through these series of articles, we will try to unfold some of the common misunderstandings
people have regarding our scriptures, our God. We will start with Lord Rama and the common questions that haunt people who hear the stories from Ramayana. We know that Rama
is termed as the ideal King, ideal husband, ideal son, ideal brother etc. He is termed as the
role model! But was Rama an ideal husband? Let us analyze this part.
Is Rama an ideal husband?
Did Rama not do an injustice to Sita by letting Her go and leave Her in a forest, just because He had heard about Her chastity from a washer-man? How can Rama be an ideal
husband when He leaves His pregnant wife and that too in a deserted forest?
This question keeps lingering in the mind of people. Let us refer to Valmiki Ramayana, instead of listening to all tom-dick-harry, about certifying Rama.
Firstly, it is not just a word of one fisherman/washer-man, but people of Ayodhya were
talking ill about Sita across the town. People were also talking about the wife-indulgence of
Rama.
.
.
.
.. at the crossroads, in the markets, on the streets, in the forests and in the groves
..What must be the pleasure in his heart born out of conjugation with Sita? Why does not
Rama censure her, who formerly had been forcibly carried away by Ravana, placing her in
his lap ..Such conduct of our wives shall have to be suffered by us also, since whatever
a king does, the subjects follow
..the citizens of all the towns and the countryside pass remarks in so many ways
Lord Rama uses multiple resources to confirm the same.
Thus, it was not some fisherman said something, the whole of Ayodhya and other towns
and villages, were speaking ill of Sita!
Secondly, Rama never doubted Sita. Rama always knew that Sita was pure. See what
Secondly, Rama never doubted Sita. Rama always knew that Sita was pure. See what Valmiki says:
.
.
.
... .
..Fire-god, declared that Sita was free from sins, so also Vayu; so did proclaim the two sun and moon before the gods Sita
free from sins before all the Rishis.
..and my inner conscience bears testimony to her purity and nobility
Thus, in spite of the whole country doubting Sita, Lord Rama had no iota of doubt about Sitas chastity. We can also see Rama
in distress after having left Sita.
Thirdly, Sita too wished to visit penance-groves. The husband Rama, asks His pregnant wife Sita about her desire and Sita
wishes to live in the forest eating fruits and roots, much like how they lived for 14 years.
.
.
.
... - .
Rama, upon knowing about Sitas pregnancy, being immeasurably happy, asks Sita which desire of yours should be fulfilled.
Vaidehi replied I wish to visit the holy penance-groves and to stay at the feet of sages., living on the banks of Ganga and
living only on fruits and roots. This is my greatest wish that I should stay even for one night in the penance-grove of those who
live only on fruits and roots. Be it so, said Rama, rest assured you will undoubtedly go tomorrow.
Page 6
Thus, it was Sitas wish too to visit hermitages on the banks of Ganga, which
Rama should have fulfilled. Fourthly, Rama and Sita lived together for 10,000
years after they returned from Lanka!
It is incorrect to say Rama asked Sita to go to forest immediately after they returned from Lanka; they actually lived the life
of King and Queen ruling this earth for 10,00 years. We all know that there was Rama rajya during this period. Citizens
used to live the life of how they would live during Krita/Satya yuga.
This incident of the people of Ayodhya talking ill about Sita happens after these 10,000 years have passed. So much for
public memory!
Now, let us look at what Rama could have done, as a King, as a husband.
Option (a) Ignore the citizens voice and continue to live with Sita
Option (b) Let go off the throne of Ayodhya (Resign from His post of being a King), but continue to be with Sita
Option (c) Prove Sitas purity
Option (a) would mean that Sitas blemish would remain, and Ramas would not be an ideal King anymore, as He did not listen to citizens voice.
Option (b) Ramas fame of ideal King would remain, but Sitas blemish would continue. People would say Rama can give off
His throne, but doesnt want to give away His impure wife! What a wife-indulgence!
Thus, (c) is the best option for Rama. Let go off Sita, listening to citizens voice and continue to carry the ideal King fame; then,
let Sitas purity be proved through a third-person whom the people listen. Valmiki was regarded as a great sage, and when
Lava-Kusha started singing Valmikis Ramayana throughout Ayodhya, the people realize their folly and cry for Sita.
The blemish on Sita, is thus removed.
Rama has no doubt about Sita being pure, but as an ideal King, has to listen to the people; it is Sitas wish too that She stays
in hermitages. Rama ensures all these are taken care of
There is more to this based on Madhvacharyas MBTN, but let us pick it up in another issue. Remember always that Lord Rama
is guna-paripoorna (full of auspicious attributes) and dosha-doora (defectless). Next time, someone talks about Ramas defects, you know what to say!
Have more questions about Ramayana, or about Ramas actions? Write to us gsbmadhva@gmail.com
Lord is there in
each and every thing living and non living.
anurenu truNa kaaShTa
Without Lord, nothing ever
exists!
He HAS to be present in us
to read this, to type on your
computer/phone, to understand, and to even ignore this. At
NO point, does Lord go away from this world.
http://www.facebook.com/groups/gsbmadhva/
PREETOSTU KRISHNA PRABHUH
Write to us, if you know the answers. Correct answers will be provided in the next issue