173 views

Uploaded by Yahyah Nahaboo

hhioi

- Mar Operations
- Energy Balance on Distillation Column
- Student Sup
- Lab Report Distillation
- Design and Simulation of a Reactive Distillation Process to Produce High-purity Ethyl Acetate
- Synthesis of Pentaerythritol Diphosphonate Dichloride (SPDPC)
- 44 Rosendo Maria Jose Vargas Valle Translated
- Integration of Nonlinear Crude Distillation Unit Models in Refinery
- RMP Lecture Notes
- acetone-b
- EV_Plantas Automatizadas-Manuales.pdf
- Distillation Column Specifications
- CA 26528538
- Synthesis of Methylamine - OrgSyn
- GROUP 5 PROCESS EQUIPMENT DESIGN II.docx
- articulo destilación
- 10_32_exam1
- 68186_Lecture 11-A
- DISTILASI
- Column revamps - From inside to outside (CE).pdf

You are on page 1of 17

Ethanol Distillation

Analysis

Yixi Chen, Laura Hart, Jeniece Macedonio, Vinay Pai

11/9/2012

To:

N.A. Deskins, VP Process Development

From: Yixi Chen

Laura Hart

Jeniece Macedonio

Vinay Pai

Subject: Zamboni Chemicals Renewable Energy Project

Introduction

Zamboni Chemical, unfortunately, is suffering from the economic recession that has taken place

in their company. Because of this, they are debating whether they should continue to move

forward and build another fuel ethanol plant or focus on their financial complications. However,

they have decided to continue with the creation of the plant that will be located in Pisco, Peru. It

will be fed agricultural waste and go through fermentation, separating ethanol and water. This

plant will, luckily, aid the community that surrounds it by helping them recover from a past

earthquake. The Vice President of Process Development, N.A. Deskins, has assigned us the task

to design the distillate column that will be operating in this new fuel ethanol plant. In the creation

of this column, we examined another distillation column to compare diameters and stage

numbers in order to prove that our distillation column design is plausible.

Methodology

Part A.

Data was collected from the Goddard Hall laboratory to aid us in our calculations. Samples from

both the bottoms and distillate were taken from the distillation column. This was necessary to

determine compositions of the ethanol-water mixture at the top and bottom. Because the column

is in total reflux, meaning no streams in or out of it, small samples had to be manually removed

and measured. The samples were cooled to 20 degrees Celsius and density was measured by a

density meter. Using charts in the lab the density could be converted to composition in weight

percent, which was then converted to mole percent. Using an X-Y vapor liquid equilibrium

diagram, we were able to determine the theoretical number of stages via the McCabe-Thiele

method which is needed to calculate efficiency of the column. Efficiency is calculated by:

To find the efficiency using temperature, both the T-x-y graph and the enthalpy-composition

diagrams are used (Wankat, 19-20). To find the composition of the bottoms, the temperature of

the reboiler should be located on the T-x-y diagram, and the composition is read off of the xaxis. The same is done to find the composition of the distillate, but instead using the temperature

of the vapor. These compositions are then plotted on the vapor liquid equilibrium curve for

ethanol-water. The number of stages can then be determined from the distillate and bottoms

compositions by using the x=y line as the operating lines since the system is in total reflux,

(L/V)min = 1. The number of stages determined by the McCabe-Thiele diagram is the theoretical

value used in the equation for efficiency:

To calculate heat leaving the condenser, we took some measurements of the cooling water. Flow

rate and entering and exiting temperatures of the water were measured. Specific heat of the water

was found in (Smith, Van Ness, Abbot).

Similarly for the heat entering the reboiler, temperature, pressure, and flow rate were measured

for the steam. Enthalpy of condensation was found in (Smith, van ness, Abbot.)

As the column in the lab is in total reflux, the equation for the energy balance is reduced to just

heat in and out of the system. After calculating heat of the condenser and reboiler, heat loss can

be found using the following equation.

+

The molar vapor rate is found using the total energy balance around the condenser.

Since QC is already calculated, the enthalpies for the vapor and liquid stream need to be obtained

from the enthalpy-composition diagram (Wankat, 17). Since the system is in total reflux, this

means that the ratio L/V is equal to 1. Therefore, L=V and the energy balance can be rewritten

as:

Solving for V will give a mass vapor flow rate because the enthalpy-composition diagram uses

weight compositions on the x-axis. Therefore, V will have to be converted using the molar mass

of ethanol in order to give the molar vapor rate.

The molar vapor rate is found using the total energy balance around the condenser.

Since QR is already calculated, the enthalpies for the vapor and liquid stream need to be obtained

from the enthalpy-composition diagram (Wankat, 17). Since the system is in total reflux, and

there is no feed, both the ratio L/V and are equal to 1. Therefore, and the energy

balance can be rewritten as:

Solving for will give a mass vapor flow rate because the enthalpy-composition diagram uses

weight compositions on the x-axis. Therefore, V will have to be converted using the molar mass

of ethanol in order to give the molar vapor rate.

Part B

Part B requested a design of a column with a feed of 100,000 and a composition of 20-35 wt.

% ethanol. The bottom product is to be 1.0 wt. % ethanol and the distillate product is to be 85

wt% ethanol. The wt%s were all converted to mol % for use with the X-Y vapor liquid

equilibrium diagram. The feed composition of 15 mol % (31 wt%) With compositions known,

flow rates of the distillate and bottoms can be found.

Using the X-Y plot, the pinch point was determined using the intersection of the feed line and the

enriching operating line on the equilibrium curve. The feed is assumed to be saturated liquid and

the slope is a vertical line. The point is used to find the slope of the operating line. The operating

line slope determines . The pinch point indicates the minimal . The minimum can be found.

The optimal

(

Using the McCabe-Thiele method, the number of stages required can be determined as well as

the efficiency of the column. Because the feed line and both enriching and stripping operating

lines must intersect, the stripping section operating line slope can be found.

(

The slope gives us

Using the overall energy balance, QC and QR can be found. The energy balance around the

condenser is needed as well. The enthalpy values were researched. (Wankat 18)

To find the diameter of the column, the Souders-Brown equation must be used. To use the

equation, vapor density must be found.

Gasohol

The number of drivers who benefit is calculated by the equation:

Part A.

Condenser water flow

4 grams/second

Condenser water inlet temperature

C

Condenser water outlet temperature

C

Steam pressure

129.6 kPa

Condensate flow

0.5 gal/min

Top stage vapor temperature

. C

Reboiler temperature

. C

% ethanol in bottoms samples

5.5%

% ethanol in distillate samples

94.4%

Temperature of distillate sample

. C

Above is the information that was taken from the distillation column in the Goddard Hall

Laboratory. This information was essential to the remainder of the project calculations.

The efficiency was 0.8 (1). This may be, however, inaccurate because the composition of the

ethanol leaving the distillate was extremely close to the azeotrope, the number of theoretical

stages may be been miscalculated when looking at the vapor liquid equilibrium. The theoretical

stages can be seen below. There are a total of 8 theoretical stages and 10 actual stages in the

laboratory.

Using the temperature 92.9 degrees Celsius for the reboiler (seen in the T-x-y graph below),

following the isotherm resulted in a composition of 0.03 for the bottoms. For the condenser,

there was no isotherm to follow for the 76.9 degrees Celsius temperature of the vapor, because it

fell underneath the azeotrope. Therefore, the azeotrope composition was used for the

composition of the distillate, which is 0.9. After plotting 0.03 and 0.9 on the McCabe-Thiele

diagram, and stepping off stages, the result was 9 stages, including the reboiler. Therefore, the

theoretical number of stages is 8, and the efficiency can be calculated using the actual number of

stages counted in the lab, which was 10 stages, plus the reboiler. The efficiency with respect to

temperature is 0.8 which is same efficiency obtained from the actual sample data (2).

Since the system is in total reflux, there is no distillate D included in the material or energy

balance for the condenser. Using the energy balance and the total reflux ratio L/V = 1, we can

simplify the equation to solve for V (3).

The enthalpies for the vapor and liquid can be obtained from the enthalpy-composition diagram

(Wankat, 20). The enthalpy of the vapor is found by finding the weight fraction of ethanol on the

x-axis, which is in this case 0.994. Then, moving up to the saturated vapor curve, the enthalpy

can be read off of the y-axis. For the enthalpy of the liquid (sub-cooled), 0.994 was used again

for the weight fraction, and read at the vapor temperature. This was found to be 76.9 degrees

Celsius.

Plugging these enthalpies into the equation for V gives a V of 0.01013 kg/s (4). Ethanol has a

molar mass of 0.046kg/mol which helps to convert the mass vapor rate into molar vapor rate.

The molar vapor rate was found to be 792.8 mol/h (5).

Since the system is in total reflux, there is no bottoms B included in the material or energy

balance for the reboiler. Since the system is in total reflux, and there is no feed, L = and V = .

Therefore, =1. Using the energy balance and the ratio = 1, we can simplify the

equation to solve for (6).

The enthalpies for the vapor and liquid can be obtained from the enthalpy-composition diagram

(Wankat, 17). The enthalpy of the liquid is found by finding the weight fraction of ethanol on the

x-axis, which is in this case 0.055. Then, moving up to the saturated liquid curve, the enthalpy

can be read off of the y-axis. For the enthalpy of the vapor, 0.055 was used again, and read at the

saturated vapor line.

Plugging these enthalpies into the equation for gives the value of 0.01676 kg/s (7). Ethanol has

a molar mass of 46g/mol. This value helps to convert the mass vapor rate into molar vapor rate

which was 1311 mol/h (8). The table below summarizes the needed results.

Determining Molar Vapor Rates

(Wankat 18). The thermal condition of the reflux was found to be at a sub-cooled liquid. In order

to assume Constant Molal Overflow (CMO), there are many requirements that must take place.

The column must be adiabatic, meaning no heat flow, to assume CMO (Wankat 106). CMO

cannot be assumed because heat loss takes place in this distillation column due to poor

insulation.

Like any experiments, errors are inevitable. Errors that might have occurred while collecting data

had to do with certain measurements. While taking the measurements of density the sample had

to be at a temperature of 20 degrees Celsius. When the sample was removed from the ice bath,

the temperature of the sample quickly increased and as a result gave error to the density

calculated. Another error that might have occurred was misreading the flow rate in the meter and

temperatures. Incorrect information would affect the calculations in this project.

Part B

The design specifications that were provided asked for a column of feed of 20-35 wt. % ethanol.

Our products were to be a 1.0 wt. % ethanol product and 85 wt. % ethanol product. 0.31 wt. %

was chosen for our feed for its ease when converting to mol % for use with the McCabe Thiele

method. It becomes 15 mol % when converted. Using the McCabe-Thiele method on the X-Y

VLE diagram, the minimum external reflux ratio was found. The relation of 1.1 <

< 1.25

gives us the optimal . The value of 1.25 was chosen because it offers us the minimal number of

stages for the column while at the same time keeping costs reasonable. According to Table 7.3,

1.25 gives us the fewest number of stages while keeping low cost per year. (Smith, Van Ness,

Abbot 384) From the diagram, the number of stages would be 7 (seen in the VLE graph below).

We feel that this is reasonable height and cost to run a column. Then QC and QR were calculated

to be -17449 kW and 19009 kW respectively. Finally the diameter of the distillation column was

calculated by Souders-Brown Equation to be 2.15 meters.

It is estimated that the distillation column runs for 5000 hours a year. It is also estimated that

average MPG of a car is 22 miles/gallon and each car drives an average of 15,000 miles per year.

Then the dimensional analysis is conducted and the number of drivers who benefit is 87464.

Feed

Distillate

Bottoms

Flow Rate (kg/h)

100,000

35,714

64,286

Composition (mol %)

0.15

.689

.0039

Composition ( wt%)

0.31

0.85

0.01

To find minimum , refer to the X-Y vapor liquid equilibrium graph attached. It is found by

finding the pinch point, which is the point where the enriching operating line and the feed line

intersect at the equilibrium curve. The feed line is a vertical line because the feed is a saturated

liquid. The slope of the operating line gives us

the optimal .

0.420 is the slope of the optimal enriching section operating line. Using the intersection of the

operating line and the feed line, the stripping section operating line can be found, as all 3 must

intersect at the same point. With the McCabe Thiele method, the number of stages can be

calculated. 7 stages and a reboiler were counted. To calculate actual number of stages, efficiency

from the part a calculations was used.

Appendix

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

(7)

(8)

Overall system

To convert from wt. % to mol %:

Feed

Bottoms

Distillate

Flow Rates

System of condenser

Flow Rates

Using the graph,

Energy

Overall

All the enthalpy values can be researched. (Wankat 18)

Condenser

Diameter

To find diameter, the Souders-Brown equation is used. The liquid density is found by using a

water density calculator for 77.9 degrees Celsius.

Gasohol

N.A. Deskins, the Vice President of Process Development, designated our group to design a

distillation column that will produce ethanol. Once we designed the column we analyzed how

efficient the 85% ethanol would be with real world applications. It was found that using this

ethanol would be more sustainable and safer than gasoline. This was more beneficial to farmers

economically. Ethanol can be produced in the United States as opposed to importing it from

other countries and as a result would save a lot of money. However, the cost to produce this

ethanol is extremely expensive. Another problem that rises from this is the need for a specific car

would be inconvenient and expensive for the consumer. A recommendation for Zamboni

Chemical Company is to move forward with the production of ethanol. The advantages outweigh

the disadvantages. This ethanol would help the environment. Because a specific car needs to be

created for ethanol, more jobs would be available and as a result would help the economy.

References

"Ethanol." Fuel Economy. N.p., n.d. Web. 09 Nov. 2012.

<http://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/ethanol.shtml>.

"Gallons of Ethano"" The Energy Advocate Index. N.p., n.d. Web. 09 Nov. 2012.

<http://www.energyadvocate.com/fw3.htm>.

Oho, Shuzo. "Vapor-Liquid Equilibria Calculation Program." Ethanol-Water VLE Calculation.

N.p., n.d. Web. 09 Nov. 2012.

<http://www2g.biglobe.ne.jp/~infosci/Ethanol_Water_cal.html>.

Seader, J. D., and Ernest J. Henley. Separation Process Principles. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley, 2006.

Print.

Smith, Van Ness, and Abbott. Introduction to Chemical Engineering Thermodynamics. 7th ed.

N.p.: McGraw Hill, 2005. Print.

Wankat, P.C., Separation Process Engineering, 2nd edition, Prentice Hall, 2007. Print.

"Water Density Calculator." Water Density Calculator. N.p., n.d. Web. 09 Nov. 2012.

<http://www.csgnetwork.com/h2odenscalc.html>.

""Gallons of Ethanol"" The Energy Advocate Index. N.p., n.d. Web. 09 Nov. 2012.

<http://www.energyadvocate.com/fw3.htm>.

- Mar OperationsUploaded byJoshua Johnson
- Energy Balance on Distillation ColumnUploaded byCecilia Tan
- Student SupUploaded byBhanupriya Vaishnaw
- Lab Report DistillationUploaded byTimothy Brown
- Design and Simulation of a Reactive Distillation Process to Produce High-purity Ethyl AcetateUploaded byAjib Sari Putra
- Synthesis of Pentaerythritol Diphosphonate Dichloride (SPDPC)Uploaded byG. Chandra Sekhar Reddy
- 44 Rosendo Maria Jose Vargas Valle TranslatedUploaded byأصلان أصلان
- Integration of Nonlinear Crude Distillation Unit Models in RefineryUploaded byNông Dân
- RMP Lecture NotesUploaded byGiuseppe Attuario
- acetone-bUploaded byBruna Carla Slusars
- EV_Plantas Automatizadas-Manuales.pdfUploaded byCesar Gutierrez
- Distillation Column SpecificationsUploaded byPeter John Rpanut
- CA 26528538Uploaded byAnonymous 7VPPkWS8O
- Synthesis of Methylamine - OrgSynUploaded byzodd01
- GROUP 5 PROCESS EQUIPMENT DESIGN II.docxUploaded byNanda Dwi Anggraeni
- articulo destilaciónUploaded byMarbel Vld
- 10_32_exam1Uploaded byrajany93
- 68186_Lecture 11-AUploaded byChirag Garg
- DISTILASIUploaded byArluky Novandy
- Column revamps - From inside to outside (CE).pdfUploaded byjdgh1986
- 11555_2Uploaded byTarun Bhatia
- 22 - Staged DistillationUploaded byRebwar Nori Jan
- CBE582_2Uploaded bysimple_uu
- Binous - 06Uploaded byOsas Jessica Uwoghiren
- Flow SheetingUploaded byFalom Bander
- 62241.pdfUploaded bySiddhant Batham
- Ponchon Savarit vs Mc Cabe ThieleUploaded byAlicia Avila
- 63e7fe6e4c45ed6bc6bccc69d8277567.pdfUploaded byHicham Fouraiji
- 00006387Uploaded byanacruz84
- Data and InterpretationUploaded bymichsantos

- sivarajingam.pdfUploaded byanil4u29
- Week 3 notesUploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- Autocad2d TutorialUploaded bysplaw9484
- 2.2._hydroUploaded byMeron Moges
- saponifikasiUploaded byMirza Auliya
- Use of Carbon DioxideUploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- Qualitative StudyUploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- BEng (Hons) ChemEngg (Minor_Env) -Level 4Uploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- The UoM Guide to the Harvard System of ReferencingUploaded byevilchatteryan
- 3. CO2 Transport Overview - S. Santos IEAGHGUploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- MSS SWMUploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- Hazards Associated With CCS 1Uploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- Assessment of CCS Sweden.pdfUploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- Timetable for Academic Year 2017Uploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- Industrial flow meter.pdfUploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- AnswerUploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- Pm ManualUploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- pmmanual.pdfUploaded byJuan Jose Vaquera Vargas
- Alternative to Practicals0002Uploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- Pid Diagram 2Uploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- MSS Chemical Process Safety 2013-2014Uploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- Milk Powder Production in New ZealandUploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- Milk PowerUploaded bySUTHAN
- probeml 11 4 3Uploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- problem 11 4 5Uploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- Introduction Cooling TowerUploaded byYahyah Nahaboo
- BEng (Hons) Chemical Engineering (Minor-Environemental-Energy) - Level 3Uploaded byYahyah Nahaboo

- Special Task-Plant Layout-Final ReportUploaded byMuktar Bashir
- nptel reboilerUploaded byGurubasavaraju T M
- P&ID NotesUploaded bynokaraju
- appmanUploaded byeldiosthorve
- Introduction to Vessels and Vessel OrientationUploaded bySanjay Patel
- ReboilerUploaded byKim Lloyd A. Barrientos
- SAES-A-020Uploaded byM Siddique
- hysys example 4Uploaded byjenny2409
- Energy Conservation in Distillation ColumnUploaded bykalyan555
- SAEP-1664Uploaded bytimam
- 206182526 Distillation Column DesignUploaded byMayssam Dalhoumi
- Healt Hazard Identification_FinalUploaded bywisnuakbar16
- nirma.pritesh.docxUploaded byNavjyot Singh
- Aspen HYSYS simulation and control of distillation columns.pdfUploaded byResmi Suresh
- AK B + PUploaded byANDRÉS FELIPE SERRANO BARRIOS
- THE NORM PUploaded byDhanny Miharja
- Heat Exchanger Design- ProcessUploaded byalokbdas
- BSGT_AminePlantOperationManualUploaded byAdeel Jamil
- Refrigeration for NGL RecoveryUploaded byOgenioja
- Delayed Coker Unit PinchUploaded byPavel Marcinkovic
- 04815Uploaded byBoulos Nassar
- Flare SystemUploaded byvikkoo7
- Lab Report FinalUploaded byidyllic20
- Types of Column and Internal PartsUploaded byRey
- Crude Tower Simulation ( HYSYS V8.6 )Uploaded byFrank Quijada
- HeatFlux Limits in ReboilersUploaded byNoolOotsil
- 05 FS GDUUploaded byAnonymous O0lyGOShYG
- Pid NotesUploaded byNguyen Thien Tung
- Final_Report TEG.pdfUploaded byKev Lhuillier
- 2nd Assignment - Furnace(1)Uploaded byJosiph Bukair