Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
yields Equation 10 [5,609 bytes], the results of which are always less than
1.0.
This means that the zero hoop stress always occur when the external
pressure is less than the internal pressure. This is logical if we consider the
respective areas contacted by the internal pressure and external pressure.
Figure 4 [24,355 bytes] represents Equation 10 in graphical form. At D/t =
20, zero hoop stress occurs when the external pressure is 90.5% of the
internal pressure. For example, if the internal pressure is 2,500 psi, zero hoop
stress will occur at 2,500 times 0.905, or 2,263 psi external pressure. Above
the 2,263 psi external pressure, holding the internal pressure constant, the
pipe will experience a compressive hoop stress. The hoop and radial
compressive stresses will be 2,500 psi at Pi = Po = 2,500 psi (Figure 3).
The magnitude of the hoop stress is always maximum at the inner wall
surface (Figures 2 and 3). Since the pipe is to be designed for the maximum
stress across the wall, the thick wall pipe formula with r = a (Equation 3), is
used to determine the pipe wall thickness. This equation gives exact
maximum hoop stress for any pipe wall thickness and it is called the "thick
wall pipe formula".
Equation 11 [7,701 bytes] is applicable for pipes in the elastic region, which
is acceptable since the plastic deformation due to internal pressure is
normally not allowed in the pipe wall thickness determination. However, the
pipe wall thickness determined by Equation 11 must be checked for
excessive external buckling collapse pressure. The pipe collapse calculation
methods are presented in many industry codes and are not described in this
paper.
For a known pipe wall thickness, the hoop stress can be calculated by using
Equation 11. However, with an unknown pipe wall thickness, and a known
maximum allowable hoop stress (normal practice), the equation requires
several iterations to solve for the pipe wall thickness. Therefore, a simpler
formula was introduced and is widely used in the pressure vessel industries.
The formula is derived for a thin walled pipe, and is thus called the "thin wall
pipe formula".
the hoop stress will be uniform across the wall thickness, since the
summation of the hoop stress and radial stress must be constant.
Figure 6 also indicates that the use of the thin wall pipe formula for a thick
wall pipe, for example - D/t ratios less than 20, gives inaccurate results
because the radial stress is not negligible in this region. As the external
pressure increases, the tensile hoop stress decreases. The radial stress at the
inner wall surface is equal to the internal pressure (it is not affected by the
external pressure), so the ratio of the radial stress to the hoop stress
increases as the external pressure increases.
Figure 6 shows that the radial stress to hoop stress ratio becomes 19% at D/t
ratio = 20, when Po/Pi = 0.4. Moreover, at Pi = Po, the radial stress is equal
to the hoop stress, which means the ratio reaches 100%. As Po/Pi ratios
increase, the radial stress contributions to the hoop stress increase
exponentially. This shows that the thin wall pipe formula cannot be used for
external pressure situations where the radial stress cannot be neglected.
The thin wall pipe formula yields a uniform hoop stress across the wall
thickness while the thick wall formula gives a variable hoop stress with a
maximum at the inner wall surface. The thin wall pipe formula will give a
maximum hoop stress when the pipe outside diameter is used. Figure 7
represents the hoop stress estimated by the thin wall pipe formula using the
pipe outside diameter, mean diameter, and inside diameter.
Using the outside diameter gives about 5% over-prediction of the exact
solution at 20 D/t ratio. If a mean diameter is used, the thin wall pipe formula
slightly under-predicts the exact solution by 0.3-0.1% at D/t ratios of from 20
to 40. The mean diameter may be used if 0.3% or less under-prediction, at
D/t ratios greater than 20, is acceptable. However, API and ASME codes use
the outside diameter, which is conservative.
Equation 13 [4,867 bytes] provides reasonable results for D/t ratios greater
than 20 with no external pressure. To account for the external pressure, most
of industry codes such as API 1111 and ASME B31.8 subtract the external
pressure from the internal pressure term in Equation 13 (Shown in Equation
14 [4,620 bytes]).
This equation is not correct, as the original equation (Equation 13) is derived
from the no external pressure and negligible radial stress assumptions.
Therefore, Equation 13 cannot be modified to account for the external
pressure effect. This can be proved by inserting Pi = Po in Equation 14. When
Pi = Po, Equation 14 shows zero hoop stress, which is contradictory to the
thick wall pipe formula. When Pi = Po, the hoop stress must be negative (-)
Po, from the thick wall pipe formula (Equation 11).
For this reason, Equation 14 over-predicts the hoop stress at high external
pressures. Figure 8 shows how much Equation 14, which is called "original
thin wall pipe formula," over-estimates the hoop stress, compared to the
thick wall pipe formula. If no external pressure exists, when Po = 0, and for
D/t ratios greater than 20, the original thin wall pipe formula over-estimates
the hoop stress a maximum of 5%, compared to the thick wall pipe formula.
Modified formula
To find a more realistic formula to account for the external pressure, we need
to go back to the thick wall pipe formula (Equation 11), which provides an
exact solution. In Equation 11, assuming a very thin thickness (as t
approaches zero), we have Equation 15 [5,765 bytes].
Substituting Equation 15 into Equation 11 produces Equation 16 [6,147
bytes].
The left hand side of the Equation 15 is always smaller than D, thus Equation
16 always yields higher wall thickness requirements than the thick wall pipe
formula. Note that Equation 16 has an additional minus (-) Po term compared
to the original thin wall pipe formula (Equation 13). Equation 16 is called the
"modified thin wall pipe formula."
When the external pressure is equal to the internal pressure, Equation 16
gives compressive stresses equivalent to the external pressure, which agrees
with the thick wall pipe theory. The modified thin wall pipe formula predicts
the hoop stress more accurately than the original thin wall pipe formula as
presented in Figure 9.
For D/t ratios greater than 20 at Po/Pi =0.4, the original thin wall pipe
formula over-estimates by 13% or less (Figure 8), while the modified thin wall
pipe formula over predicts the hoop stress by 6% (Figure 8), both are
compared to the thick wall pipe formula. As the pipe wall thickness and the
external pressure increase, the difference in error between the original and
the modified thin wall formulas becomes more significant.
Recommendation
As the external pressure increases, for example as the water depth increases
for a marine pipeline, the thin wall formula predicts a higher hoop stress than
the exact value. This is caused by using the thin wall pipe theory replacing
the Pi term with (Pi - Po) to account for the external pressure effect. This is
not correct as the original thin wall pipe equation is derived from the "no
external pressure" and "negligible radial stress" assumptions.
Based on the "exact" thick wall pipe theory, the original thin wall pipe
formula should have an additional minus external pressure term as shown in
Equation 16, to more accurately account for the external pressure effect.
The proposed modified thin wall pipe formula (Equation 16) will provide
reasonably accurate estimates, less than 10% over the exact values, for D/t
ratios greater than 20. For D/t ratios less than 20, using the thick wall pipe
formula is recommended.
Several industry codes do not account for the external pressure effect, these
should be modified for deep water application by accounting for the external
pressure, either using the modified thin wall pipe formula or the thick wall
pipe formula.
References
http://www.offshore-mag.com/learning-center/subsea/subsea-productionsystems/jumper-installation.html