Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Powder Technology
j o u r n a l h o m e p a g e : w w w.e l s e v i e r.c o m / l o c a t e / p o w t e c
Pengaruh komposisi gas dan suhu pada karakteristik fluidisasi bijih besi dilapisi
karbon
Chao Lei a,b, Shengyi He
a
b
a,b
State Key Laboratory of Multiphase Complex Systems, Institute of Process Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China
University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 28 February 2016
Received in revised form 21 June
2016
Accepted 30 June 2016
Available online 2 July 2016
Keywords:
Direct reduction
Deuidization
Carbon deposition
Process
optimization
a b s t r a c t
Untuk mengurangi kadar karbon dalam besi reduksi langsung (DRI) yang
diperoleh melalui dua langkah fl uidized proses reduksi tidur, kami
menyelidiki fl uidization / de fl uidization perilaku bijih besi dilapisi
karbon di bawah komposisi gas yang berbeda dan suhu. Ditemukan bahwa
penting nilai kandungan karbon (Ccritical) diperlukan untuk mencegah agar
de fl uidization meningkat jelas dengan meningkatnya fl suhu uidization,
tetapi sedikit dipengaruhi oleh komposisi gas, sedangkan stabilitas karbon
diendapkan sangat tergantung pada komposisi gas, yaitu ketika fraksi H2 mol
lebih besar dari nilai kritis tertentu, karbon diendapkan tidak stabil dan
akan terus dikonsumsi selama reduksi, yang mengarah ke de fl uidization.
Melalui optimalisasi proses, kandungan karbon di DRI menurun ke b 5 wt.%,
Yang juga jauh lebih rendah dari nilai-nilai dilaporkan 16,5-22,3 berat.%
Dalam literatur.
2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Fluidized beds are ideal reactors for non-blast furnace ironmaking
due to their excellent heat and mass transfer efciency, coke-free
ironmaking and direct use of ne iron ore potential [1,2]. However,
the serious deuidization problem during the reduction of ne iron
ore, caused by the sticking of newly-formed metallic iron at elevated
temperatures, always induces abrupt shut down of the equipment
and hinders the stability of continuous operation in industry [35].
Among various deuidization prevention measures, carbon-coating is
simple, effective, economical and draws more and more attention
from recent researchers [610].
Generally for this method, a two-step reduction process is
adopted,
where pre-reduction process is conducted at relatively low temperatures for coating enough carbon on the surface of ne iron ore
particles, to prevent the deuidization during the subsequent high
temperature reduction process. One of the main problems lies in the
fact that the di- rect reduction iron (DRI) obtained by such process
contains a high car- bon content (16.522.3 wt.%) as reported by
previous studies [9,10], which is obviously too high to be used as the
feedstock of following elec- tric furnace steelmaking process. This can
be attributed to two reasons: (1) the critical carbon content value
(Ccritical) needed to prevent the high temperature deuidization is too
high, e.g., after pre-reduction process, the carbon content of a prereduced iron ore needs to exceed 13
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: 491961198@qq.com (C. Lei), heshengyi@gmail.com (S.
He), duyinyi2008823@126.com (Z. Du), Fpan@ipe.ac.cn (F. Pan),
qszhu@home.ipe.ac.cn (Q. Zhu), hzli@home.ipe.ac.cn (H. Li).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.powtec.2016.06.048
C. Lei
C. Lei
et al.
et /al.
Powder
/ Powder
Technology
Technology
301301
(2016)
(2016)
608
608
614614
60
60
Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of the uidized bed apparatus (1-Gas Cylinder; 2-Shutoff Valve; 3-Mass Flow Controller; 4-Fluidized Bed Reactor; 5-Differential Pressure Sensor; 6Thermocouple; 7-Display Instrument; 8-Data Acquisition System; 9-Electric Resistance Furnace).
Chemical composition of the Brazil iron ore.
A Brazil iron ore with the particle diameter of 106150 m was
used as the raw material in the present study. Its true density and
Composition
TFe
Fe2O3
FeO
SiO2
CaO
MgO
Al2O3
bulk den- sity are about 4939 kg/m3 and 2209 kg/m3 respectively,
Weight (wt.%)
68.94
96.80
0.72
1.98
0.10
0.10
while its mini- mum uidization gas velocity (umf) in N2 at 0.30
room
temperature is about
3.2 cm/s. Table 1 shows its chemical composition. N2, H2 and CO of
99.99% purity were used and supplied by Beijing Huayuan Gas
Chemical Industry Co. Ltd., Beijing, China. All the carbon-coated iron
ore samples were prepared by reducing the iron ore under the same
pre-reduction condition, i.e., 1.5 L/min CO-H2 mixture gas with H2
mole fraction of
0.733 at 650 C. Fig. 2 shows the corresponding pre-reduction rate
and
carbon deposition rate. And the umf of such carbon-coated iron ore is
in the range of 3.03.8 cm/s, depending on its composition.
2.2.
procedure
Experimental
The high temperature reduction process was conducted under atmospheric pressure. The uidized bed reactor was pre-heated to 800
C under N2 atmosphere (1.0 L/min, about 29.6 cm/s), then 6.00 g
car- bon-coated iron ore were fed into the reactor (about 1.3 cm
initial bed height) and N2 was immediately altered to the desired
reducing gas (1.5 L/min, about 44.4 cm/s). The used reducing gas was
CO-H2 mixture gas with a xed CO/H2 ratio, which was controlled by
digital mass ow controllers. After the desired time or deuidization,
the reducing gas was switched back to N2 atmosphere (1.0 L/min,
about 29.6 cm/s), and the reactor was removed from furnace and
quenched directly by spraying water on its outer surface to the
ambient temperature under N2 atmosphere. Then the samples were
transferred into zipper seal sample bag full of N2 gas to prevent
oxidation.
The carbon content of samples was measured by a carbon-sulfur
analyzer (LECO CS-344, USA). The reduction degree of samples was
mea- sured by the titrimetric method according the national
standard method of China
(GB 223.7-2002). The off-gas
composition was
Table 1
C. Lei
C. Lei
et al.
et /al.
Powder
/ Powder
Technology
Technology
301301
(2016)
(2016)
608
608
614614
61
61
and
initial
carbon
Fig. 2. Rates of reduction and carbon deposition during the pre-reduction process.
Fig. 3. Fluidization pressure drop of carbon-coated iron ore with different initial
carbon content at 800 C in CO (a-0.75 wt.%; b-1.91 wt.%; c-4.55 wt.%).
of
the
gas
Fig. 5. Fluidization behavior of the carbon-coated iron ore with different initial carbon
content in CO-H2 mixture gas at 800 C (-deuidization; -unstable uidization; stable uidization).
61
C. Lei
C. Lei
et al.
et /al.
Powder
/ Powder
Technology
Technology
301301
(2016)
(2016)
608
608
614614
61
Fig. 7. Deuidization time and carbon content after deuidization (Cdef) during
reduction of the carbon-coated iron ore with different initial carbon content at 800 C
in H2.
Fig. 6. Carbon contents of the carbon-coated iron ore after 30 min uidization in the
gas mixture with different CO/H2 ratios at 800 C.
much smaller than the Ccritical value (4.55 wt.%). From the above two
ex- periments, it can be concluded that deuidization under the gas
mixture with the xH2 N 0.9 is mainly caused by the consumption of the
deposited carbon during the reduction process.
Previous study indicated that during the reduction of carboncoated iron ore, the deposited carbon could be consumed by its
reduction reac- tion with FeO [11]. To check this, we investigated the
composition var- iation of pre-reduced iron ore with the Cinitial of
14.7 wt.% after heating in N2 at 800 C for 30 min. Results showed
that reduction reaction be- tween deposition carbon and FeO indeed
happened, which leaded to the decrease of carbon content to about
12.6 wt.%. However, results in Fig. 7 showed that its carbon content
after deuidization was only
2.2 wt.% after reduction in H2 at 800 C for 27.5 min, much smaller
than the value of 12.6 wt.%. This meant that reduction with FeO was
not the main consumption way of the deposited carbon, and there
must exist other reasons leading to the fast carbon consumption
during the reduction in H2.
Cypres et al. [12] once reported that deposited carbon generated
by
the low temperature decomposition of CO had high chemical
reaction activity, which could be gasied by H2 (C + 2H2 =
2CH4). Thus, off- gas composition during the carbon-coated iron
ore reduction at 800 C in H2 was measured, where about 1.652.48%
CH4 was detected depen- dent on the reduction time. This meant
carbon methanation with H2 in- deed happened and could be
considered as the main reason of the fast carbon consumption during
reduction in H2.
C. Lei
C. Lei
et al.
et /al.
Powder
/ Powder
Technology
Technology
301301
(2016)
(2016)
608
608
614614
61
of
the
uidization
61
Fig. 8. Molar mass of carbon after the CO-H2-C closed system reaching the equilibrium
at
800 C.
smaller than that at 800 C, e.g., the carbon content increases 12.75
wt.% after reduction at 800 C in CO-H2 mixture gas with the xH2 =
0.4 for 30 min, while the increment is only 6.95 wt.% at 900 C; (2) the
xcritical value at 900 C is 0.85, a little lower than that at 800 C (0.9).
To understand these effects, Fig. 12 shows the equilibrium state at
different temperatures for the closed
system with the initial
composi- tion of 1 mol solid carbon and 1 mol mixture gas with
different CO/H2 ratios. Results indicated that the theoretical xcritical
value decreases with increasing temperature, e.g., the xcritical value
at 900 C is 0.05 smaller than that at 800 C, which is in good
agreement with those of experimental results. Moreover, combining
the experimental results and the theoretical results, the relationship
between the xcritical and the temperature in this study can be
expressed by the tting equation: xcritical = 0.0007 T + 1.265
(800 C b T b 900 C). Besides, when the xH2 is smaller than the
xcritical, the equilibrium solid carbon decreases with increasing the
temperature under the same gas composition, due
61
C. Lei
C. Lei
et al.
et /al.
Powder
/ Powder
Technology
Technology
301301
(2016)
(2016)
608
608
614614
61
Fig. 10. Fluidization behavior of the carbon-coated iron ore with different initial
carbon content in CO-H2 mixture gas at 900 C (-deuidization; -unstable
uidization; - stable uidization).
to the fact that both the CO decomposition reaction and the carbon
methanation reaction are exothermic reaction, and the equilibria
shift towards the reverse direction with increasing the temperature.
Our previous study [11] indicated that the reduction rate at 800
C was quite fast, thus further increase of the temperature to 900
C would not show obvious enhancement of the reduction rate, but
lead to a remarkable increase of the Ccritical value. So from the respects
of pro- cess optimization, 800 C is more suitable in the present
study.
The above experiments investigated the effects of gas composition
and temperature on the uidization characteristics from the respect
of the particle cohesive force. It should be noted that particle
reduction or change of experiment conditions will also inuence the
gas and par- ticle physical properties, such as gas viscosity, particle
diameter, particle density, and further affects the uidization
characteristics.
Generally, such effects of gas and particle physical properties on
par- ticle uidization characteristics are evaluated by the minimum
uidiza- tion velocity (umf). For example, in this study, the umf in N2
at room temperature is about 3.2 cm/s and the operating gas velocity
during re- duction is 44.4 cm/s at 800 C, about 1314 times of the
umf. During the reduction process, increase of the temperature (800
C 900 C) or de- crease of the H2 mole fraction (1 0) will induce
the increase of gas viscosity, further leading to the variation of umf in the range of 1.32.9
cm/
s. Besides, increase of carbon content and reduction of iron ore will
61
C. Lei
C. Lei
et al.
et /al.
Powder
/ Powder
Technology
Technology
301301
(2016)
(2016)
608
608
614614
Fig. 11. Variation of carbon content after 30 min uidization in CO-H2 mixture gas at
800 C and 900 C.
61
Fig. 12. Molar mass of solid carbon after the CO-H2-C closed system reaching the
equilibrium state under different temperatures.
increase the particle diameter and decrease the particle density. Base
on the experimental results, such variations of particle properties will
lead to the variation of umf in the range of 3.03.8 cm/s.
From the above calculation, variations of gas and particle physical
properties show relatively small effects on the umf, and will not
induce deuidization under such
high operating gas velocity.
However, under the same reduction condition (800 C, CO-H2 gas
mixture, 44.4 cm/s), deuidization will occur once the metallization
ratio of iron ore (with- out carbon deposition) increases to about
25% [6]. It can be concluded that compared with the particle cohesive
force, the effects of gas and particle physical properties on the
uidization/deuidization character- istics are much smaller in this
study, so their further effects on the Ccritical and xcritical are ignored
in this paper.
3.4. Optimization of the two-step direct reduction
process
The nal optimization aim is to raise the efciency of
deuidization prevention by carbon and reduce the nal carbon
content in DRI on the premise of stable uidization. From the
systematic investigations in the present study and our previous study
[11], we propose two key optimi- zation principles as:
(1) reducing the Ccritical value, which can be achieved through increasing the reduction rate and reducing the carbon
deposition rate during the pre-reduction process, such as by
increasing the temperature or the xH2 in the CO-H2 mixture
gas [11] and through decreasing the reduction temperature;
(2) Balancing the carbon deposition and consumption rates during
the high temperature reduction process. Preferably, the carbon
content of iron ore should be kept constant or increase in quite
slow rate in practice through controlling the reducing gas
com- position, which can be achieved through regulating the
xH2 in CO-H2 mixture gas equal to or a little smaller than the
corre- sponding xcritical value under certain xed temperature.
Fig. 13. Variations of metallization ratio and carbon content for the iron ore during the
reduction under the optimized operation conditions.
above optimized operation conditions. Results showed that after prere- duction for 16 min, the metallization ratio and carbon content of
iron ore reached 69.5% and 3.86 wt.%, respectively. Then, after the
subse- quent high temperature reduction for 14 min, its metallization
ratio fur- ther increased to 91%, while its carbon content only
showed a small increase to 4.83
wt.%. More
importantly,
deuidization was not ob- served during the whole process.
The above results indicated that through reasonable process
optimi- zation, DRI production with the metallization ratio N 90% can
be pre- pared within 30 min, and its nial carbon content was b 5 wt.
%, much lower than the reported value in literature (16.522.3 wt.%).
4. Conclusion
Fluidization/deuidization characteristics of the carbon-coated
iron ore were investigated in CO-H2 mixture gas at 800-900 C, for
the pur- pose of process optimization. The main conclusions can be
stated as follows:
1) The Ccritical value increases with increasing the uidization
tempera- ture, but is little affected by the change of the gas
composition. The Ccritical value at 900 C is almost three times of
that at 800 C.
2) For the reduction in CO-H2 mixture gas, gas composition shows
obvious effects on the stability of deposited carbon, and further
affects the particle uidization/deuidization behavior. When the
xH2 is greater than a certain critical value (xcritical), deposited
carbon is un- stable and will be constantly consumed during
reduction, leading to the deuidization. Moreover, both the
experimental and calculated results show that such xcritical value
decreases with increasing the temperature.
3) Principles for reducing the DRI carbon content were proposed
through two corresponding processes as reducing the Ccritical
value and balancing the carbon deposition and consumption rates
during the high temperature reduction process. Consequently,
the two- step direct reduction process was optimized, and the
nal carbon content in DRI obtained was decreased to b 5 wt.% in
the present study, much smaller than those reported values of
16.522.3 wt.% in literature.
Notation
Ccritical
critical carbon content for deuidization
prevention.
Cinitial
initial carbon content of the carbon-coated iron
ore.
umf
xH2
xcritical
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to gratefully acknowledge the nancial supports
from National Outstanding Youth Science Fund Project under Grant
No. (21325628).
[6]
[7]
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11]
References
[1] H.Z. Li, M. Kwauk, Review and prospect of uidization science and technology,
CIESC J. 64 (2013) 5261.
[2] J.L. Scheck, Recent status of uidized bed technologies for producing iron input
ma- terials for steelmaking, Particuology 9 (2011) 1423.
[3] Q. Zhu, R. Wu, H. Li, Direct reduction of hematite powders in a uidized bed
reactor, Particuology 11 (2013) 294300.
[4] M. Komatina, H.W. Gudenau, The sticking problem during direct reduction of
ne iron ore in the uidized bed, J. Metall. 10 (2004) 309328.
[5] J.F. Gransden, J.S. Sheasby, The sticking of iron ore during reduction by hydrogen in
a
uidized bed, Can. Metall. Q. 13 (1974) 649657.
[12]
[13]
[14]
T. Zhang, C. Lei, Q.S. Zhu, Reduction of ne iron ore via a two-step uidized bed
di- rect reduction process, Powder Technol. 254 (2014) 111.
C. Lei, T. Zhang, J.B. Zhang, C.L. Fan, Q.S. Zhu, H.Z. Li, Inuence of content and
micro- structure of deposited carbon on uidization behavior of iron powder at
eleva ted temperatures, ISIJ Int. 54 (2014) 589595.
K.S. Zhu, J.H. Huang, W.G. Li, Prevention of particle coherence by carbon-black
adhe- sion during uidizing pre-reduction in smelting reduction, J. Anhui Univ.
Technol. (Nat. Sci.) 6 (1989) 97102.
B. Zhang, Z. Wang, X. Gong, Z. Guo, Characterization of precipitated carbon by
XPS and its prevention mechanism of sticking during reduction of Fe2O3
particles in the uidized bed, ISIJ Int. 53 (2013) 411418.
D. Neusc htz, Sticking preventi on during ne-ore me talliza ti on in two-stage
smelting-reduction processes, Steel Res. 62 (1991) 333337.
C. Lei, G.Y. Zhang, Q.S. Zhu, Z.H. Xie, Optimization of carbon deposition process
dur- ing the pre-reduction of ne iron ore in a uidized bed, Powder Technol. 296
(2016)
7986.
R. Cypres, M. Ghodsi, J.P. Lempereur, Direct hydrogenation of carbons by
isothermal microthermogravimetry at atmospheric pressure, Fuel
Process.
Technol. 3 (1979)
171178.
C. Lei, T. Zhang, Q.S. Zhu, H.Z. Li, Experimental and theoretical study on the
uidiza- tion behavior s of iron powder at high temperature, Chem. Eng. Sci. 118
(2014)
5059.
Y.W. Zhong, Z. Wang, Z. Guo, Q. Tang, Prediction of deuidization behavior of iron
powder in a uidized bed at elevated temperatures: theoretical model and
experi- mental verication, Powder Technol. 249 (2013) 175180.