Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
V 36 ' NO 3
M A Y ; JUN 14
Clinical Article
Posterior Preveneered Stainless Steel Crowns: Clinical Performance after Three Years
Anne C. O'Connell, BA, BDentSc, MS' Evelina Kratunova, BDentSc, MFD(RCSI), DChDent, FFD^ Rona Leith, BA, BDentSc, MFD(RCSI), DChDent^
Abstract: Purpose: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical performance of posterior preveneered stainless steel crowns after three years.
Methods: NuSmile crowns and Kinder Krowns were randomly allocated on paired molars using a split-mouth design. Variables such as fracture, wear,
gingival heaith, and esthetics were recorded. (P<.05). Results: Statistical analysis was compieted on 34 paired crowns in M children. After three years, 53
percent of crowns were fracture free compared to 81 percent at one year. There was minimai esthetic impact for most fractures due to the location
of the veneer fracture, but five crowns had extensive fracture. No difference was reported in the clinical performance between the two crown types.
Fracture was more likely to occur where the adjacent tooth was missing. Parents reported a satisfaction rating of 83 out of 10. Conclusions: Clinical
performance of both crown types was similar and successful for three years. Facing fracture occurred in 47 percent of crowns but had minimal
impact on the esthetic value or parental satisfaction in the majority of cases. These crowns offer an esthetic alternative to the traditional stainless
steel crown, but parents should be alerted to the possibility of veneer ioss over time.
Revision Aprii 7, 2013
KEYWORDS: DENTAL ESTHETICS, POSTERIOR CROWN, PRIMARY DENTITION, LONGEVITY, PREVENEERED STAINLESS STEEL CROWNS
Methods
Two types of commercially available VSSCs were used in a
'Dr. O'Connell is an associate professor and consultant. Pdiatrie Der.tistry: ^Dr. Kratunova is a clinical instructor. Pdiatrie Dentistry: and 'Dr. Leith is a lecturer. Pdiatrie
Dentistry, all in the Division of Publie and Child Dental Health. Dublin Dental University Hospital. Trinity College. Dublin, Ireland.
Correspond with Dr. O'Connellat anne.oconnell@dental.tcd.ie
254
Original Sample
64 crowns 8nd 20 participants
Excluded Sample
6 crowns and 2 participants
Exfoliated/extracted teeth/lost
pairing/ Participant did not return
20 crowns and 6 participants
PEDIATRIC DENTISTRY
previously described (Table 1).' Loss or fracture of the composite facing was measured separately for the buccal and
occlusal surfaces and recorded as intact, less than or greater
than 50 pereent loss, or eomplete loss of eomposite veneer
(Table 1). Wear was not seored in a site when the eomposite
veneet had fraetured. Intraexaminer and interexaminer reliability were analyzed using Cohens kappa test.
Statistieal analysis was eompleted using SPSS 20 statistieal
software (SPSS Ine, Armonk, N.Y., USA). Cross-tabulation
analysis of the elinieal data was performed on multiple variables.'" MeNemar's test for paired data and Fisher's exaet test
V 36
NO 3
M A Y ! JUN
Results
Twenty participants were recruited in the initial study, and 54
VSSCs (27 pairs) were placed (Figure 1). One patient was lost
to follow up, but several patients had exfoliated one or two
of the crowns (five tooth pairs and two single teeth) by the
three-year review. One crown was extracted as a precaution
following a medical diagnosis. Although all tteated ehildren
were periodieally examined, only intaet pairs of erowns were
ineluded in statistieal analysis. After 36 months, the remaining
34 VSSCs (17 pairs) in 14 participants were statistically compared to the same crowns at 12 months. Five female patients
had 14 crowns, and nine males had 20 erowns, with a mean
age of 5.4 years old at the time of the crown placement
(range=two to nine years old). All examiners were trained and
calibrated on two separate occasions, and kappa scores for each
variable ranged between 0.8 and 1, indieating almost perfeet
agreement.'"
Eight VSSCs were placed on primary second molars and
26 VSSCs were placed on primary first molars. Three patients
had four VSSCs for evaluation at 36 months, but the majority of participants (79 percent) had just one pair of VSSCs. Almost all crowns had a film of plaque at the gingival margin,
and only approximately three percent were plaque free at three
years. Hiere was no statistically significant difference in plaque
retention (P<.50) or gingival health {P=.7l) between the two
commercially available VSSCs after 36 months.^'* There was
no significant deterioration in gingival health measured via
Figure 3. (a) A smooth outline shows occlusal wear on the cusp tip of the
primary maxillary left fitst molat NuSmile crown compared to the sharp
edges showing an occlusal fracture on the palatal margin of the ptimaty
maxiilary right Kinder Krowns. (b) Irregular loss of veneer on tbe ptimary
mandibular first motat NuSmile ctowns (tight) and Kinder Krowns (left).
255
PEDIATRIC DENTISTRY
V 36 ' NO 3
MAY I JUN 14
256
PEDIATRIC DENTISTRY
Year 2 (%)
Facing wear
15
15
19
24
23
39
42
Year 3 (%)
V 36 ' NO 3
MAY ( )UN
257
PEDIATRIC DENTISTRY
V 36 / NO 3
MAY I JUN 14
3.
4.
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
Conclusions
Based on this study's results, the following conclusions can be
made:
1. The clinical performance of posterior NuSmile crowns
and Kinder Krowns was comparable; both provided
successful full coverage restoration for a minimum of
three years.
2. Stainless steel crowns (SSCs) preveneered with composite
resin provided an esthetic alternative to traditional
SSCs, but parents must be advised that facing fracture
occurs over time in 47 percent of crowns.
258
Very few of the fractured crowns had an esthetic impact, according to parents.
Fracture was more likely if the adjacent tooth was
absent.
15.
16.
17.
18.
Copyright of Pediatric Dentistry is the property of American Society of Dentistry for Children
and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without
the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or
email articles for individual use.