Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
| The Diplomat
3/1/16, 11:06 AM
Dinnerware Replacements
Find Your Patterns and Details
on Free Shipping Here
Chinese Capillary
Democracy: Can Western
Democracies Learn From
China?
Why the Chinese government is by and
for the people.
By Patrik K. Meyer
March 01, 2016
Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons/Dong Fang
Page 1 of 3
Chinese Capillary Democracy: Can Western Democracies Learn From China? | The Diplomat
3/1/16, 11:06 AM
in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised by them directly
or indirectly through a system of representation usually involving periodically held
free elections.
Using this definition of democracy, let us check if Chinas political system is a democracy or not.
The first indication that it is indeed a democracy is that the Chinese peoples interests are the
foundation on which the Chinese government is built. These foundations are made up of two
grassroots organizations where information is exchanged between the people and the
government: the local Communist Party of China (CPC) branch and village/community
committees, with the first playing the leading role and the latter carrying out the actual work.
While the CPC members are appointed, the village/community committees members are
regularly elected by holding free direct elections.
Furthermore, representatives at the township level of the peoples congress are also elected by
direct voting and are responsible for gathering relevant information about the needs and
expectations of the people and sending it all the way to the National Peoples Congress. In
addition, more than three million grassroots organizations and millions of representatives from
hundreds of thousands of villages, towns, and cities keep the central government constantly and
directly connected with its people. Hence, thanks to the elections of grassroots-level officials and
the vast network of CPC and government cadres, it can be argued that the government is fully
informed about most Chinese peoples grievances and expectations. This structure allows
information to flow from the most remote village to the highest levels of the government, and it is
why this work labels the Chinese political system as a capillary democracy.
While being fully informed is a necessary condition for a government to fulfill the expectations
and needs of its people, it is not sufficient. To be a government for the people, it also needs to
have the capacity to make relevant decisions and be accountable to its people, thereby
guaranteeing that it will pursue their interests. The decision-making capacity of the Chinese
government is ensured by the fact that most officials are professionals who have a long-term
commitment to their work in the government. This combined with mainly performance-based
promotions results in a leadership made up of committed, experienced, and skilled individuals
that are capable of confronting the complex challenges posed by running a country. (It took over
40 years of excellent public service for Xi Jinping to reach Chinas presidency.)
Then, it is necessary to show that the CPC, the de facto sole power in China, is a legitimate and
accountable authority. Two concepts can be considered most relevant when it comes to how
authority is gained and lost in China: status and recognition.
The concept of status is hierarchical and fluid, in the sense that the status of an institution
within the authority structure can change based on its performance. Hence, the CPC has to
perform if it wants to preserve its status as the leader. As for recognition, it is also important
because the status or rank of an institution has to be supported by public acknowledgement that
it deserves that rank. The two concepts on which the authority stands are fluid and need to be
http://thediplomat.com/2016/03/chinese-capillary-democracy-can-western-democracies-learn-from-china/?allpages=yes&print=yes
Page 2 of 3
Chinese Capillary Democracy: Can Western Democracies Learn From China? | The Diplomat
3/1/16, 11:06 AM
http://thediplomat.com/2016/03/chinese-capillary-democracy-can-western-democracies-learn-from-china/?allpages=yes&print=yes
Page 3 of 3