Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Agenda
Women, income and poverty: Gendered access to resources in PostApartheid South Africa
To cite this Article Posel, Dorrit and Rogan, Michael(2009) 'Women, income and poverty: Gendered access to resources in
Downloaded By: [University of Cape Town Libraries] At: 07:32 6 June 2011
abstract
__
___
_- -
__
---
- __ -
Far-reaching changes in the post-apartheid period in South Africa are likely to have affected gendered access to resources In
thisArt,c/e. we use nationally representative household survey data to examine whether trends in the extent of income poverty
over a recent ten-year period have been gendered We find that females are more likely than males to live in poor households
Poverty rates have fallen from 1997 to 2006. and particularly following the expansion of the social grant system However, the
decline in poverty rates has been larger among males than among females Higher levels of unemployment and lower earnings
among women, as well as changes in household structure, help explain why the gender gap in poverty rates has widened
over the period We find also that femaleheaded households are far more vulnerable to income poverty than maleheaded
households and further, that the extent of poverty has fallen by more among households headed by men However, we show
that there are significant differences in poverty risks not only among femaleheaded households, but also among maleheaded
households, depending on the employment status of household members
keywords
~
Introduction
In this Article, we investigate whether trends
in the extent of income poverty in South Africa
over the past decade have been gendered. The
post-apartheid period has been characterised by
complex changes in all sectors of society and
many of these changes are likely to have affected
gendered access to resources. On one hand,
the past decade has seen employment growth
for women (Casale and Posel, 2002; Casale and
Women, income and poverty: Gendered access to resources in Post-Apartheid South Africa
25
Downloaded By: [University of Cape Town Libraries] At: 07:32 6 June 2011
26
AGENDA 81 2009
Downloaded By: [University of Cape Town Libraries] At: 07:32 6 June 2011
9)
c)
Women, income and poverty: Gendered access to resources in Post-Apartheid South Africa
27
Q,
.
I
,111)
Downloaded By: [University of Cape Town Libraries] At: 07:32 6 June 2011
2007).
The increased coverage of these grants is
reflected in the proportion of households receiving
social grantsupport.Inthe 1997October Household
Survey (OHS), approximately one quarter of all
households reported receiving at least one social
grant. In the 2006 General Household Survey
(GHS). this had risen to more than two fifths of
households.
If households had relied only on income from
employment, then poverty rates over the period
would have been far higher, and the fall in the
poverty rates from 1997 to 2006 would have
been considerably smaller. Figure 1 shows that
in 1997,65.39/0of individuals lived in households
where average earnings were insufficient to lift
household members above the poverty line. By
2006,this had fallen, but only by one percentage
point to 64.3%. Including social grant income into
a measure of total income, however, significantly
lowers poverty rates and results in a decline in the
extent of poverty over the 2000s.
1-
2004
2006
57.1
61.3
Female
61.8
65.8
58.4
64.7
52.3
59.6
Africans
Male
67.3
70 1
67.6
606
Female
72.6
75.7
74.7
69.0
Source: Own calculations from the 1997 and 7999 OHSs and the
2004 and 2 w 6 GHSs
- 1
Source: Own calculations from the 7997 and 7999 OHSs and the
2004 and 2006 GHSs
28
AGENDA 81 2009
Downloaded By: [University of Cape Town Libraries] At: 07:32 6 June 2011
1997
1999
2004
2006
2,251
2,398
2.222
2.405
3,279
4.173
3,071
3.187
0.69
0.57
0.72
0.75
1,066
825
921
821
1,649
1,475
1.580
1,343
0.65
0.56
0.58
0.61
Source Own wlculatrons from the 1997 and 1999 OHSs and the 2004 and 2006 GHSs
Women, income and poverty Gendered access to resources in Post-Apartheid South Africa
29
3,
c)
(P
1997
1999
2M4
2006
YO men
unemployed
29.9
32 4
35.7
31 9
YO women
unemployed
45.8
47.3
50.9
49.5
Source. Own calculations from the 7997and 1999 OHSs and rhe
Downloaded By: [University of Cape Town Libraries] At: 07:32 6 June 2011
- 2006
1997
1999
2001
Mo6
No employed members
37.9
35.3
37.3
37.2
18.8
22.5
23.2
22.3
22.9
20.5
20.1
20.7
20.4
21.7
19.4
19.8
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
No employed members
33.4
31.6
33.9
32.5
12.5
14.1
14.4
13.4
31.7
31.5
31.9
33.7
22.4
22.8
19.8
20.4
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
-P
Source: Own calculations from the 1997 and 1999 OHSs and the 2004 and 2006 GHSs
30
AGENDA81 2009
Downloaded By: [University of Cape Town Libraries] At: 07:32 6 June 2011
1"
10 - '
1997
1999
2064
2006
2004
2006
1997
1999
Maleheaded
5 981 957
6 647 800
7 664 456
8 073 892
Female-headed
3 244 538
3 735 295
4520349
4858648
35.9
37.1
37.5
Percentage female-headed
(Iwn calculetions from the
35.2
1 B 7 and 1999 OH& and the 2004 and 2006 GHSs
1997
1999
2004
2006
All households5
48.6
50.9
48.2
43.6
Maleheaded
38.8
41.7
37.2
32.5
Femaleheaded
66.7
67.2
66.9
62.0
Sotme Own wlculations from the 1997 and 1999 OHSs and the 2004 and 2006 GHSs
Women, income and poverty: Gendered access to resources in Post-Apartheid South Africa
31
Q,
I
*e
Downloaded By: [University of Cape Town Libraries] At: 07:32 6 June 2011
(0
1 etllployed
More than 1
No employed
household member hous&old manber employed howhold
member
32
AGENDA 81 2009
Downloaded By: [University of Cape Town Libraries] At: 07:32 6 June 2011
Concluding comments
The money-metric poverty analysis presented in
this paper has demonstrated that females in South
Africa are more at risk of poverty than males.
Furthermore, although poverty rates have fallen for
both females and males over the ten-year period
from 1997 to 2006, the decline in the extent of
income poverty has been greater for males. While
a larger proportion of women have received social
grant support over the period, the small size of
the grants, the increasing gender gap in median
wages, relatively lower access to employment
for women, and a growing reliance on women's
income has meant that poverty rates have fallen
more slowly among females than among males.
Consequently, gender differences in poverty rates
have widened over the period.
To explore these gender differences in poverty
further, we compared the level of poverty in
female- and male-headed households. Although
there is considerable variation among these
household types, households headed by women
are far more likely to be poor than households
headed by men. This is because these households
are more reliant on income received by women.
Furthermore, over the period, poverty rates have
fallen by .less among female-headed households
than among maleheaded households.
Income poverty therefore remains a gendered
phenomenon in post-apartheidSouth Africa. Females
and those residing in femaleheaded households
have seen their contribution to overall income poverty
increase over the period. While income poverty
is only one measure of well-being, the findings
presented in this Article highlight the implications of
persistent gender inequality in the labour market and
a growing reliance on women's earnings.
Footnotes
1. The first nationally representative household survey in
South Africa was conducted in 1993 by the South African
References
Bentley K (2004) 'Women's human rights and the feminisation
of poverty in South Africa', in Review of African Political
Economy, 31,100:247-261.
Bhorat H & Kanbur R (2005) 'Poverty and w e i h i n g in postapartheid South Africa: An overview of data, outcomes
and policy', DPRU Working Paper OV101. Cape Town,
Development Policy Research Unit, University of Cape Town.
Bhorat H & van der Westhuizen C (2008)'Economic growth,
poverty and inequality in South Africa: The first decade
of democracy', Development Policy Research Unit
Conference 2008 - The Regulatory Environment and its
Impact on the Nature and Level of Economic Growth and
Development in South Africa, Gauteng.
Buvinic M & Gupta GR (1997)'Femaleheaded households
and female-maintained families: Are they worth targetting
to reduce poverty in developing countries?' in Economic
Development and Cultural Change, 45,2: 254280.
Casale D (20041 'What has the feminisation of the labour
force 'bought' women in South Africa? Trends in labour
force participation, employment and earnings, 19952001'.
DPRU Working Paper Series- No. 04/84,Development
Policy Research Unit- University of Cape Town.
Casale D & Pose1 D (2002)'The continued feminisation of the
labour force in South Africa: An analysis of recent data
and trends', in The South African Journal of Economics,
70, 1 : 156-184.
33
9)
z5
*I .
c)
(D
Downloaded By: [University of Cape Town Libraries] At: 07:32 6 June 2011
34
AGENDA 81 2009