Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://about.jstor.org/terms
Oxford University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The
English Historical Review
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
THE ENGLISH
HISTORICAL REVI EW
NO. LXIV.-OCTOBER I9OI
what point discussion has so far brought us, what the questions alre
which call for more light, and what appear to me to be some
determining facts.
The first question about this deification of the ruling man is how
it arose. We know that the Romans borrowed it from the Greek
Vita X Orat. 7, 22, 842 D (2, 1026, 42 Didot); Deinarch. in Demosth. 1, 94; Hypereides (Blass), p. 14.
VOL.
XVI.-NO.
LX..
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
6 Dittenberger, ed. i. no. 370 (ed. ii. no. 600, 1. 110) a Michel, no. 839, 1. 60.
' Strabo, xiv. 1, 31, p. 644; Bull. d,e Corr. Hell. ix. (1885), p. 387 = Michel,
no. 486.
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
of a tribe.23 The cult of the first Seleukos, during his life, at Ilion
included an altar, inscribed as that of king Seleukos, the naming of
a month after him, and the institution of games (7v[unKcd Ka'a
t7WT7rtLK9 5ry'w) similar to those held in honour of Apollo.24 Games
16 Dittenberger, ed. i. no. 138 (ed. ii. no. 190) Michel, no. 350.
" Diod. xx. 100, 3 f.; Paus. i. 8, 6.
'25 Dittenberger, ed. i. no. 190 (ed. ii. no. 250) Michel, nos. 50, 507,
?6 C. I. G. 3595 -Dittenberger, ed. i. no. 156= Michel, no. 525.
28 Dittenberger, ed. i. no. 165 (ed. ii. no. 216) =Michel, no. 457.
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
cult her husband, curiously enough, does not appear; her son,
Antiochos Theos, is associated with her. It is expressly mentioned
that the cult of these two was maintained not only by the city but
by individuals privately. The surname lTeos, not hitherto borne,
so far as we know, by a living man, not afterwards borne, as a rule,
in Asia Minor by living men, was started in the case of Antiochos II,
Appian says 34 by the Milesians. This naturally implies the institution of a special cult in that city. In the second century B.C. the
princes of the Pergamene house take the place of the Seleukids as
objects of worship for the Greeks of Asia Minor. Cults of them are
about the altar, sing a sacred ode (7rapa,O,ttos); and the train of
39 Dittenberger, ed. i. no. 246 = Michel, no. 327. 40 Polyb. xvii. 16.
41 Ibid. xvi. 25, 9; Paus. i. 5, 5.
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
king was the son of Ra, the ' good god,' served, like other celestials,
with temples and altars and sacrifice.45 Egypt was but a small part
of Alexander's empire; the Egyptians were one of a number of
Euplhrates and Tigris thani from the valley of the Nile. If it was
the object of Alexander to conform to the style of his predecessors,
43 The surname Soter given to Ptolemy I by the Rhodians (Paus. i. 8, 6).
The surname Euergetes given to Ptolemy III by the Egyptians (' gens Aegyptiorum')
The surname Philometor given to Ptolemy VIII (Soter II) X7lXXevaqT, i.e. by
The surname Nikator given to Seleukos I. The phrase in App. Syr. 57 implies a
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
find later oriental kings, Arsacids and Sassanians, taking the title
of Ea6s9 upon their coins. But in doing so it was they who
followed the Greek example. So far from its being the case that
the Greek kings borrowed their apotheosis from the East, the
exact reverse is the truth. The Athenians, the representatives
par excellence of pure Hellenism, led the way; the East followed
suit.5'
iv. 51 f.)
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
still alive. That was a slight bar. The step to the worship of the
living was easy. It had even been made on occasion before the
time of Alexander, as in the well-known instance of Lysander.
I do not know whether any one has yet suggested that some
light may be thrown upon this matter by the practice, which was
not strange to the ancient states, of conferring in some cases the
outward insignia and honours of an office upon those who did not,
or did not yet, actually hold it. We have, for instance, in
Ptolemaic Egypt besides an order of veyeyevsts a class of persons
58 Plut. Lys. 18. 59 Strack, in Rhein. Muts. N.F. lv. (1900), p. 171.
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
which doth hedge a king, not extinct with ourselves, and but
lately so strong that beliefs like that in the king's touch could
6" For the case of the Attalids see Frankel, Inschr. von Pergarnon, nos. 43-45,
commentary. And the same distinction seems to have been observed in the case of
(C. I. G. 3137): 8a 'rob rby 7ra7-Epa az'rroi Oeobz 'AvTtoXov xal 'rhJ /AL-TEpa Thv roO 7raTpos
E 'a v :rparoYhcKJv KTA, 1. 10; 6 OE e s xal awr-p 'AVT!oXoS (i.e. Antiochos I), 1. 101.
Antiochos IV Epiphanes is, I believe, the first Greek king who puts ,66s upon his
coins. Thenceforth it became common for the title to appear.
65 Suet. Vesp. 23.
66 Tcv aaesAf'CVv EIs DEo 'V S / TAET a aTaVTZ V. Dittenberger (ed. i.), no. 246=Michel,
no. 327, 1. 16. Cf. Friinkel, Inschr. von Pergarmon, 240, 4; Rohde, Psyche (ed. i.),
p. 664, note. The most delightful expression is that of Memnon, 4, ? 5 (P. H. G. iii.
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
from Pergamos, inscribed BAXIAEA ['A-r-raXov] EEON IQ[rTpa Kcal] TON BQMO[v o 8itva].7' The troops stationed in the
Ombite nome erect an altar to the reigning Ptolemy and Cleopatra,
as o-v.uvao& with Aro6ris-Apollo.72 We even find special associations
for the worship of the sovereign, calling themselves after him in
the same way in which other religious associations for the worship
of a particular deity form their names from the name of their
the court and who have a special temple, 'Ar'rXaXtov, for their
rites ; 76 in Delos (?) the Evzraroptcrat, whose god is Mithridates
Eupator.77 Sometimes an association brackets the king, or the
king and queen, with its particular deity. So we have in Ptolemais
ol -rExVb-at 0t 7pt ToV AtOvvoov Kca't Eso?V 'A8,e?0oVos (Ptolemy II
and Arsinoe78), in Paphos o0 7Ep.' TOV AtO6VVoOV Kalt Oso?V EVzpy7&as(
TSXVZ'Tat/9 in Teos a KOtVO)V r0'v Tspl T7OV AtOVVOoV TEXVtT0V Tl V E7(
70 Frankel, Inschr. vom Pergamou, no. 43. 7' Ibid. no. 59.
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
that the court should establish a cult of this sort under its own
direction. In the case of the Ptolemies a state cult of the first
Ptolemy, as Soter, can be traced back to the early years of his son's
reign, and becomes apparently, after the death of Berenike, a cult
of Alexander and the eEsol @YrpaY. Another state cult, of Alexander
so C. I. G. 3068 =Michel, no. 1016.
" 'EDraipeas pu 7oreoZ-oe ,77&6 aVidaous &IEv 72S1 f?#s 7y7/77s. at -yap ToavWra
aT-vc-rdcELs f'v /.LV Tras AXaLS roXLTetaLs mkXOpeICTOOUTiZ E'J O& Tats yovapxiais icLJaVVE5OvUStP
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
S5 Bull. de Corr. Hell. xxi. (1897), p. 184 f. 6 App. Syr. 63; cf. C.I.G. 4458.
11 Beurlier, p. 79.
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Did these iEp'a include the shrines erected by cities and individuals,
or were there a separate set of i,epta maintained by the central
government? Documents which relate to a public cult of the
Pergamene dynasts in their capital have not, as yet at any rate,
come to light, except one which belongs to quite the early days of
the dynasty, the time of Eumenes I, before the rulers of Pergamos
had begun to call themselves kings.91 Eumeneia are already at that
time celebrated, and the sacrifice of a sheep offered to the prince.95
It would be especially difficult to say in the case of Pergamos
whether a cult of this sort were civic or of court institution.
Perhaps such an ambiguity lies in the nature of the case, for the
Pergamene dynasts seem to have beeii especially careful to veil
their despotism under the forms of a free state.96
But to say that the first evidence of a practice occurs at a
certain date is not equivalent to saying that the practice itself
begins at that date.97 In the case of Seleukos and his line, where
we have nlot even anything to take the place of papyri, and inscriptiolns have not yet been found in sufficient numbers to do more
than light up at casual points the darkness of the period between
the battle of Ipsos and Antiochos III, the argument from silence is
more than usually inapplicable. It must remain to a great degree
problematical what the attitude of the first Seleukos and the first
Antiochos was to the worship offered themr. I have argued elsewhere 98 that there is some ground for conjecturing that the
identification of Seleukos with Zeus which we find after his death
was countenanced, already during his lifetime, at court. However
that may be, the coins of these two kings seem to prove that the
claim to deity was officially advanced. The portrayal of the king's
96 Ibid. commentary.
97 See the remarks of Strack, fRheie. Mts. lv. (1900), p. 164, note.
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
itself why they did so. They were, many of them, practical
statesmen, perfectly aware, we must suppose, both of their own
plain human nature and of the formal and unreal character of all
tincture of faith did after all enter into them. The king may have
considered the strange propensity of the human mind to be
influenced by imagination, where belief falls short; he may have
felt that the repeated ceremonial insensibly raised his prestige,
especially with the common people; yes, even he himself, though
a practical man, may have found his weaker part illogically
gratified.
But we may perhaps divine more solid reasons as well for the
importance attached to these cults. In the first place, even if the
cult was a barren formality as a religiots act, it might be pregnant
as a declaration of political loyalty. It might have the same significance as in our days the flying of a cloth of certain colours upon
a pole does under some circumstances assume. And this is the
light in which the inscriptions of Asia Minor seem to represent it.
It is the time when the Greek world is being made the battleground of rival Macedonian princes. A city which, through
violence and seduction, has adhered to one of the kings, can
proudly declare in the day of his victory how always through
the dark days sacrifice had gone up to him and his priest invoked
his name. Had the temper of the Greeks in the fourth century
been other than it was, other forms might have been found for
There was, perhaps, another reason why the kings found their
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
how far a similar policy was possible in the very differently constituted Greek world. The Egyptian example, however, may suggest
to us that in some way or to some extent the kings found themselves put by their deification among the Greeks in a stronger position for dealing with the religious funds of the Greek cities. The
odd story of Antiochos IV Epiphanes and the goddess of Hierapolis seems to illustrate this. He pretended, we are told, to marry
her, celebrated a formal wedding, and, while the wine of the
wedding feast was flowing, caused all the temple treasures, with
one exception, to be carried off under the title of a dowry.101 The
story becomes clearer when we remember that Antiochos IV
identified himself in all probability with Zeus. This would explaini
his demand. For not only was the goddess of Hierapolis very
generally identified with Hera, but Lucian expressly states that
in the holy place, beside her image, was the image of a male deity,
who was unquestionably Zeus.'02 WVhether the similar story in
2 Maccabees about Antiochos and the goddess Nanaea in Persial03 is
a reflexion of the same event, or whether Antiochos used the same
device more than once, we do not know. At any rate we can see
how useful to a man like Antiochos, who suffered from the combination of magnificent projects with a meagre purse, his godhead might
promise to be. If, however, he hoped it would cover the spoliation
of temples, he must have been disappointed; for he was driven with
loss from the temple of Anaitis in Persia.'04 His violence done to the
temple at Jerusalem caused the Maccabean revolt. The Asiatics
could not all be treated as the Ptolemies treated the peasants of the
Nile.10;5
p. 119.
"n3 ' For Antiochus, as though he would marry her, came into the place, and his
friends that were with him, to receive money in name of a dowry ' (2 Macc. i. 14).
I04 Polyb. xxxi. 11; cf. 2 Macc. i. 13 f.
'?S An important article on the subject of the worship of kings has recently appeared, by E. Kornemann (Beitrdge zur alten Geschichte, vol. i. Leipzig, 1901), which
I had not the advantage of consulting at the time my own article was composed. It
may be remarked that I have approached the question from a somewhat different point
of view, and have come, in certain respects, to different conclusions.
This content downloaded from 196.204.161.200 on Thu, 10 Nov 2016 11:42:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms