SAR Peer Review and Feedback Checklist

SAR Elements

Yes

No

Student Feedback or
Suggestion

1. Answers the
question
2. Embeds the
prompt (The first
sentence is not
just a
restatement of
the prompt)
3. Identifies one
idea that answers
the question
4. Provides two (2)
pieces of text
evidence
5. Provides text
evidence that
accurately
supports the idea
Bonus: Makes the
connection between
the answer and the
text evidence

SAR Peer Review and Feedback Checklist

SAR Elements
1. Answers the
question
2. Embeds the
prompt (The first
sentence is not
just a restatement
of the prompt)
3. Identifies one idea
that answers the
question

Yes

No

Student Feedback or
Suggestion

4. Provides two (2)

pieces of text
evidence
5. Provides text
evidence that
accurately
supports the idea
Bonus: Makes the
connection between the
answer and the text
evidence