Available online at www.sciencedirect.

com

Waste Management 28 (2008) 12461253

www.elsevier.com/locate/wasman

Changes in soil chemical and microbiological properties during

4 years of application of various organic residues
M. Odlare
b

a,*

, M. Pell b, K. Svensson

a
Department of Public Technology, Malardalen University, Box 883, SE-721 23 Vasteras, Sweden
Department of Microbiology, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Box 7025, SE-750 07 Uppsala, Sweden

Accepted 19 June 2007

Available online 13 August 2007

Abstract
A 4-year eld trial was established in eastern Sweden to evaluate the eects of organic waste on soil chemical and microbiological variables. A simple crop rotation with barley and oats was treated with either compost from household waste, biogas residue from household
waste, anaerobically treated sewage sludge, pig manure, cow manure or mineral fertilizer. All fertilizers were amended in rates corresponding
to 100 kg N ha1 year1. The eects of the dierent types of organic waste were evaluated by subjecting soil samples, taken each autumn 4
weeks after harvest, to an extensive set of soil chemical (pH, Org-C, Tot-N, Tot-P, Tot-S, P-AL, P-Olsen, K-AL, and some metals) and
microbiological (B-resp, SIR, lSIR active and dormant microorganisms, PDA, lPDA, PAO, Alk-P and N-min) analyses. Results show that
compost increased pH, and that compost as well as sewage sludge increased plant available phosphorus; however, the chemical analysis
showed few clear trends over the 4 years and few clear relations to plant yield or soil quality. Biogas residues increased substrate induced
respiration (SIR) and, compared to the untreated control amendment of biogas residues as well as compost, led to a higher proportion
of active microorganisms. In addition, biogas residues increased potential ammonia oxidation rate (PAO), nitrogen mineralization capacity
(N-min) as well as the specic growth rate constant of denitriers (lPDA). Despite rather large concentrations of heavy metals in some of the
waste products, no negative eects could be seen on either chemical or microbiological soil properties. Changes in soil microbial properties
appeared to occur more rapidly than most chemical properties. This suggests that soil microbial processes can function as more sensitive
indicators of short-term changes in soil properties due to amendment of organic wastes.
2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction
Organic waste can be a valuable and inexpensive soil
conditioner and source of plant nutrients, and positive
eects of organic waste on soil have been reported in several studies. For example, organic waste application can
increase soil nitrogen and phosphorous contents (Jakobsen, 1995), improve soil structure and water holding capacity (Joshua et al., 1998), increase microbial biomass
(Leifeld et al., 2002; Jedidi et al., 2004), reduce the need
for chemical weed control (Pinamonti, 1998) and suppress
plant diseases (Hoitink and Boehm, 1999).

Corresponding author. Tel.: +46 21 101611; fax: +46 21 101370.

E-mail address: monica.odlare@mdh.se (M. Odlare).

0956-053X/$ - see front matter 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.wasman.2007.06.005

Compost from organic waste is frequently mixed with

urban garden waste in order to improve its structure and
to increase the C:N ratio. Due to anthropogenic activities,
such as leaded fuel in the past, park and garden waste often
contain heavy metals. Sewage sludge is known to sometimes contain heavy metals and the question of whether
agricultural soils should be amended with sewage sludge
or not has been debated since the late 1960s. Biogas can
be produced from a wide variety of organic wastes, which
may result in both dierent and variable qualities of the
resulting residue. Anaerobic digestate from source separated household waste may contain several types of organic
contaminants (Nilsson et al., 2000). Hence, there is an
urgent need for long-term eld experiments to evaluate
the eects of repeated amendment of organic waste on soil
properties.

M. Odlare et al. / Waste Management 28 (2008) 12461253

Soil quality is a complex characteristic determined by

physical, chemical and biological components of the soil.
Doran and Parkin (1994) dene soil quality as the capacity of a soil to sustain biological productivity, maintain
environmental quality, and promote plant and animal
health. Changes in the soil microbial community may
occur more rapidly than changes in other soil characteristics and therefore, soil microbial processes are thought to
be sensitive indicators of changes in soil quality (Kennedy
and Papendick, 1995). In a well-designed eld experiment,
the accumulated eect of organic waste on soil quality can
be monitored and evaluated during a long period under
realistic conditions.
The objective of this study was to evaluate the eects of
application of organic waste on soil chemical and microbiological properties in an agricultural soil. A 4-year eld
experiment was conducted to compare the eects of compost from municipal household waste, biogas residues
and anaerobically treated sewage sludge with the traditional fertilizers cow manure, liquid pig manure and mineral fertilizer (NPS). Soil samples were collected each
year and the changes in dierent chemical and microbiological soil properties were monitored in order to evaluate
the eect on soil quality. Another objective was to compare
the sensitivity of soil chemical and microbiological parameters to function as indicators of soil quality in terms of
reecting changes in soil properties.
2. Materials and methods
2.1. Site characteristics and experimental design
The eld experiment was established in autumn 1998 at
a site located in central Sweden (5937 0 N, 1633 0 E). The
soil had not been fertilized with farmyard manure since
1975, and in some 20 years before the start of the experiment the eld had been cropped mainly with cereals, oil
seed rape and legumes. Soil management was conventional
with annual plowing. The soil contained 3749% clay, 36
44% silt and 1420% sand, and was classied as a Eutric
Cambisol (FAO, 1998). The experiment was set up in a
random block design with four replications and a plot size
of 90 m2. The crop rotation in the experiment comprised
oats (Avena sativa cv. Freja) and spring barley (Hordeum
vulgare cv. Baronessa). The site for the eld experiment
was selected using a specic selection technique where near
infrared reection (NIR) spectroscopy is combined with
principal component analysis (Odlare et al., 2005). The
NIR strategy made it possible to nd the area within the
eld that had the smallest spatial variation of soil
properties.
2.2. The fertilizers
All organic and inorganic fertilizers were applied at a
rate corresponding to 100 kg N ha1 year1. The compost
(C) and the liquid biogas residues (BR) were applied at

1247

two rates: C100 and C50, and BR100 and BR50, respectively. In C100 and BR100, all N originated from the
organic waste, whereas in C50 and BR50 half of the N
was supplied as mineral N. Anaerobically treated sewage
sludge (SS), pig manure (PM) and cow manure (CM) were
all complemented with 50 kg mineral N ha1 year1. Other
plots had solely mineral fertilizer (NPS) applied at
100 kg N ha1 year1. The reason for using NPS instead
of NPK, was that the soil in the eld experiment is rich
in potassium but poor in sulphur. In addition, there is a
general trend towards lower atmospheric sulphur deposition, which leads to a need for complementary sulphur fertilization. The nitrogen in the mineral fertilizer was 50% in
the NH4 form and 50% in the NO3 form. Unfertilized plots
were used as control. The treatments are summarized in
Table 1, and the actual applied yearly amounts of dry matter and various plant nutrients are given in Table 2. In
order to be able to apply the results to real agricultural systems, the dierent types of manure were applied according
to general farming practice in Sweden. Therefore, compost,
sewage sludge and cow manure were spread a few days
before ploughing in late autumn. Biogas residues and pig
manure were spread on the seedlings immediately before
stem elongation. Mineral fertilizers were applied in spring
at sowing. Compost, sludge, cow manure and mineral fertilizer were applied by hand from a bucket as evenly as possible. Biogas residue and pig manure were spread by hand
with a watering can.
The compost was produced at the municipal composting
plant at Vasteras, close to the study site. Source separated
household waste (70%) was mixed with chopped park and
garden litter (30%) before composting. The biogas residue
was obtained from a biogas plant in Stockholm where
source-separated household waste is co-digested with food
residues from restaurants and kitchens. The sewage sludge
was taken from the municipal wastewater treatment plant
in the city of Vasteras. The plant treats sewage from
118,000 p.e. yielding 12,000 tonnes dewatered (25% d.m.)
sludge per year. Inuent raw wastewater is pre-precipitated
with iron sulphate, biologically treated by an activated
sludge process with pre-denitrication supported with glycol as external carbon and energy source. Excess sludge is
anaerobically digested to reduce its volume, make the
product hygienic and produce biogas. The pig and cow
manure was collected from local farmers.

2.3. Soil sampling

Soil samples were collected separately in each plot prior
to the experiment and then every year in autumn 4 weeks
after harvest. Each experimental plot was sampled about
25 times from the topsoil at a 020 cm depth with soil corers (diameter 2225 mm) to obtain 4 kg of moist soil per
plot. The soil samples were put in polythene bags and
transported to the laboratory the same day where
they were stored at +2 C. In order to be manageable,

1248

M. Odlare et al. / Waste Management 28 (2008) 12461253

Table 1
The dierent treatments used in the ORC eld experiment
Treatment

Residue/fertilizer

N in organic
fertilizer
(kg ha1 year1)

Applied N in mineral
fertilizer (kg ha1 year1)

Time for applicationa

C100
C50
BR100
BR50
SS
PM
CM
NPS
Control

Compost
Compost + mineral N
Biogas residues
Biogas residues + mineral N
Sewage sludge + mineral N
Pig manure + mineral N
Cow manure + mineral N
NPS
No fertilizer

100
50
100
50
50
50
50
0
0

0
50
0
50
50
50
50
100
0

6 November to 3 December
6 November to 3 December
16 June to 29 June
16 June to 29 June
6 November to 3 December
16 June to 29 June
6 November to 3 December
25 April to 20 May

All treatments correspond to a total of 100 kg N ha1 year1.

a
The time for application diered between the 4 years. These dates represent the earliest and the latest date.

the samples were dried slowly at +2 C to a dry matter content of 83%. For biological analyses each sample was sieved
(5 mm), thoroughly mixed and portioned in polythene bags
for the dierent analyses. The samples were stored at
20 C and all analyses were performed within 13 months
of the sampling date (Stenberg et al., 1998). All biological
tests were run in triplicate. For ammonium and nitrate
analyses, the samples were frozen moist at arrival to the
laboratory whereas for the remaining chemical analyses,
the samples were dried (35 C) and sieved (2 mm).
2.4. Chemical and physical analyses
Total soil carbon (Tot-C), nitrogen (Tot-N) and sulphur
(Tot-S) were determined after combustion at 1250 C with
a carbon, nitrogen and sulphur analyzer (CNS-2000,
LECO Equipment Corp., St. Joseph, MI, USA). Tot-C
was corrected for carbonate to give organic C (Org-C).
Mineral N (NH4-N and NO3-N) was analyzed with dialysis
on an AutoAnalyzer TRAACS 800 (Kontram, Stockholm,
Sweden). NH4-N was analyzed according to the method
ST9002-NH4D and NO3-N according to the method
ST9002-NO3D. Organic N was measured by the Kjeldahl
method (Bremner and Mulvaney, 1982). Available P
(P-AL) and K (K-AL) were extracted with the ammonium
lactate method (AL) and analyzed as described by Egner
et al. (1960). Available P (P-Ols) was also analyzed according to the method described by Olsen et al. (1954). Total
cation-exchange capacity (CEC) and total exchangeable
base cations (TEB) were determined according to Nommik
(1974). The pH was determined in 0.01 M CaCl2 with the
vol/vol ratio 1:2 (pHCaCl2). Total sulphur (Tot-S) and the
metals Cu, Zn, Cd, Ni, Pb and Cr were analyzed by ICPAES (Perkin-Elmer ICP Optima 3000) according to SS
02 83 11 (SIS, 1997). The particle size distribution was
determined according to Jung (1987).
2.5. Microbiological analysis
Microbial biomass measured as substrate induced respiration (SIR), specic growth rate (lSIR) and the basal

respiration (B-resp), were determined in 25 g soil adjusted

to 50% of the water holding capacity and incubated at
20C. CO2 evolution was determined hourly with a respirometer (Respicond III, Nordgren Innovations AB, Umea,
Sweden). The CO2 was determined from conductivity
changes measured during accumulation in a 250 mM
KOH solution (Nordgren, 1992). B-resp was calculated
as the average respiration rate measured for incubation
times between 200 and 240 h. SIR measurement was then
initiated by mixing a substrate consisting of 75 mg glucose,
2.5 mg (NH4)2SO4-N, 0.5 mg KH2PO4-P and 1000 mg of
powdered talcum into each soil sample. Empty vessels were
used as control. The respiration data were tted by nonlinear regression to an exponential growth equation as
described by Stenstrom et al. (2001):
dp=dt relt K

where dp/dt is the rate of CO2 formation, r is the initial respiration rate of growing microorganisms, l is the specic
growth rate, and t is the time after addition of the SIR substrate. Hence, relt is the CO2 production rate of exponentially growing microorganisms and K is the production
rate of non-growing microorganisms. The SIR rate is dened as the sum of r and K, i.e., the total respiration rate
obtained instantaneously on the addition of the SIR substrate. Thus, by use of the equation, the SIR response after
addition of glucose can be divided into the initial respiration rate of growing (active) and non-growing (dormant)
microorganisms. Altogether, the method yields a quantitative estimation of the active and dormant microorganisms,
as well as the parameters SIR and lSIR.
The potential ammonia oxidation rate (PAO) in 25 g of
soil was assayed as accumulated nitrite according to the
short-incubation chlorate-inhibition technique described
by Belser and Mays (1980) and modied by Torstensson
(1993); ISO 15685 (2004). The rate of NO
2 formation
was determined by linear regression.
The potential denitrication activity (PDA) was assayed
in 25 g of soil according to the modied short incubation
C2H2-inhibition method described by Pell et al. (1996).
The assay substrate contained 2 mM glucose and 2 mM
KNO3. During the assay, seven gas samples were

M. Odlare et al. / Waste Management 28 (2008) 12461253

1249

Table 2
Application rates of dry matter, total carbon, plant nutrients and heavy metals in the eld experiment
kg ha1 year1

C50

C100

BR50

BR100

SS

PM

CM

NPS

Dry matter
Tot-C
Org-N
NH4-N
NO3-N
Supplemental mineral N
P-Olsen
P-AL
K-AL
Tot-P
Tot-S
Cua
Zna
Cda
Nia
Pba
Cra

2520
565
47
0
3
50
0.5
5.9
20
11
6.7
170
520
1
22
58
40

5040
1130
94
0
6
0
0.9
11.8
39
22
13.4
340
1030
2.1
44
120
81

287
103
20
30
0
50
2.1
2.3
21
3.5
2.2
17
57
0.1
3
3
7

575
207
39
61
0
0
4.3
4.7
42
6.9
4.3
35
110
0.2
6
5
13

1335
324
42
8
0
50
0.4
6
1
37
12
433
620
0.9
15
21
18

559
203
14
36
0
50
12
13
34
22
8
140
631
0.3
4
1
17

2252
743
43
7
0
50
5
11
68
17
10
76
415
0.4
7
4
6

366
0
0
50
50
100
14.8
15.4
0.8
20
13.7
1
9
0.04
3
0.2
12

Total carbon (Tot-C), organic nitrogen (Org-N), ammonium (NH4-N) and nitrate (NO3-N), available P (P-Olsen), available P (P-AL), available K
(K-AL), total P (Tot-P), total S (Tot-S). The values represent mean values for 4 years (n = 4). For treatment abbreviations, see Table 1.
a
Expressed as g ha1 year1.

withdrawn from the headspace and analyzed for N2O on a

gas chromatograph provided with an electron capture
detector. The rate of N2O formation increased with time
and the data were tted to a product formation equation
that takes exponential growth into consideration (Stenstrom et al., 1991). Two parameters, the initial product formation rate (PDA) and the specic growth rate (lPDA),
were derived by non-linear regression.
Alkaline phosphatase activity (Alk-P) was assayed
according to the p-nitrophenol (PNP) method (Sjoqvist,
1993). Prior to the analysis, the soils were preincubated
for 4 weeks at 15 C and 50% WHC. After this incubation
period, 2 g of soil was mixed in a ask with 2 ml of water,
8 ml 0.1 M TRIS (pH 9.0) and a substrate of 2 ml 0.115 M
PNP-P. The rate of product formation was determined as
the dierence in concentration of PNP between the start
and end of a 2-h incubation period.
The nitrogen mineralization capacity (N-min) was measured with the anaerobic incubation method described by
Waring and Bremner (1964) and modied by Stenberg
et al. (1998). A slurry with 10 g of soil was anaerobically
incubated for 10 days at 37 C before extraction and anal
ysis of NH
4 . The rate of NH4 formation was determined
as the dierence in product between the start and end of
a 10-day incubation period.
2.6. Data treatment
Descriptive statistics are presented as maximum, minimum, mean, median and coecient of variance (CV). Signicant eects between the dierent treatments were
evaluated by one-way ANOVA followed by Tukeys
HSD multiple comparison test. Statistical interactions

between treatment and year were evaluated using a general

linear model. All statistical tests were performed by
the computer software package SPSS 11.5.1, SPSS Inc.,
Chicago, IL, USA.

3. Results
3.1. Organic fertilizers
Selected characteristics of the fertilizers used in this
study are presented in Table 2. More than half of the nitrogen content of the biogas residue occurred as ammonium,
whereas only small amounts of mineral nitrogen, mainly
nitrate, were found in compost. In sewage sludge, pig manure and cow manure, the mineral nitrogen was present as
ammonium. Biogas residues contained small amounts of
both total phosphorous (Tot-P) and plant available phosphorous (P-AL), whereas sewage sludge was high in TotP but low in P-AL. High concentrations of plant available
potassium (K-AL) were found in all organic fertilizers
except sewage sludge. The compost contained large concentrations of all heavy metals analyzed, especially Zn
and Pb. Sewage sludge contained large amounts of Cu.
Plots amended with compost as the sole fertilizer exceeded
the Swedish Environmental Protection Agencys threshold
values for all heavy metals, whereas plots amended with
sewage sludge exceeded the threshold value for Cu. Since
the application rate was based on nitrogen supply, the
dry matter applied in the compost-amended plots was
nearly nine times higher than the biogas residue-amended
plots and twice as high as the sewage sludge-amended
plots.

1250

M. Odlare et al. / Waste Management 28 (2008) 12461253

3.2. Statistics
The soil nutrient, metal and microbial properties prior
to the start of the experiment are shown in Table 3. The
values represent mean values for the entire experiment
area, i.e., mean values of all plots (n = 36). The CV-values
indicate only a small spatial variation at the site, and hence
treatment-eects should not be obscured by intrinsic
variation.
Analyses with ANOVA showed no signicant dierences between the years and no interactions between treatment and year. Also, there was no signicant dierence
between years 1 and 4. Therefore, the accumulated eects
(Table 4) are presented as mean values for all 4 years
(n = 16). This has the advantage that eects of extreme
meteorological conditions during specic years are
avoided. Data interpretation was supported by Tukey
HSD (p = 0.10). A relatively high probability value was
chosen because a eld experiment always involves a high
risk of environmental disturbances where rainfall, drought,
temperature, etc. may obscure treatment eects. Therefore,
in order to be able to more accurately detect changes due to
the dierent treatments, the signicance level was set to
p = 0.10.
3.3. The crop
Crop yields and grain quality in the ORC-experiment
are discussed in detail in Svensson et al. (2004). Crop yield
data is summarized in Table 4.
3.4. Soil chemical properties
The results of all chemical analyses are presented in
Table 4. Signicant dierences between the treatments
could only be detected for three of the soil chemical analyses made. C100 and PM resulted in a small, though significant, increase in pH by approximately 0.2 units compared
to NPS and the untreated control. C100 and SS increased
the level of P-AL in the soil by about 20% compared to
BR50, NPS and the control treatment. Although not significant, a trend of increasing P-AL concentrations was
observed in C50 and BR100. K-AL was about 9% larger
in plots applied with C50, C100, PM, CM and BR100 compared to the NPS and untreated control.
3.5. Soil microbiological properties
The results of all microbiological analyses are presented
in Table 4. None of the fertilizers had any clear eects on
B-resp, but BR50 and BR100 increased substrate-induced
respiration (SIR) by about 11% compared to the untreated
control. Generally, the SIR response consisted of a biomass
with about 90% dormant and 10% active organisms. Compared with the untreated control, the proportion of active
biomass was about 25% higher in C50, BR50, PM and
NPS, but was only slightly larger in C100 and SS. The dor-

mant microbial biomass was signicantly larger in BR100

than NPS and the untreated control. None of the fertilizers
had any signicant eect on the potential denitrication
rate (PDA). However, the specic growth rate constant
lPDA was about 19% larger in BR100 compared to
NPS. The potential nitrication rate (PAO) showed a similar pattern as lPDA, being approximately 19% higher in
B100 than in NPS. CM and BR100 increased nitrogen mineralization (N-min) compared to NPS and the untreated
plot by about 20%.
4. Discussion
4.1. Soil chemical properties
Of all of the chemical soil properties analyzed, only
three of them showed signicant dierences between the
treatments: pH, K-AL and P-AL.
Compost increased the pH in the soil, which could probably be explained by the production of ammonia formed
as the organically bound nitrogen is mineralized and then
transformed into ammonia in the aerated soil. Similar
results have been reported by Jakobsen (2005) and Lee
et al. (2004). The increased pH in the plots fertilized with
pig manure can be explained by the relatively high concentrations of ammonium nitrogen in this fertilizer.
Plant available phosphorous (P-AL) increased in the
plots amended with compost and sewage sludge. Both these
fertilizers were rich in phosphorous but poor in nitrogen,
and since the application rate was based on nitrogen content, the amount of phosphorous in the soil is likely to
increase.
The same reasoning applies for plant available potassium (K-AL). Application of fertilizers rich in potassium
(compost, biogas residues, pig manure and cow manure)
increased the content in the soil.
4.2. Soil microbiological properties
The majority of the microbial populations in the soil are
heterotrophs and therefore dependent on the availability of
organic carbon and energy, such as sugar and starch.
Hence, amending the soil with organic carbon should
support a larger biomass and thereby aect respiration
parameters. SIR responded well to the application of biogas residues, which was expected, because it is likely to contain a higher amount of easy-degradable carbon than, for
example, compost. Degradation of organic material is less
eective in the anaerobic biogas process and proceeds for a
shorter period of time than aerobic degradation through
composting. In addition, the ammonium content in biogas
residue could have contributed to the increased plant
growth with higher yields (Svensson et al., 2004), which
in turn would supply more carbon to the soil through litter
and root exudates.
The proportion of active microorganisms in the soil was
generally small, only about 10%. This is in agreement with

M. Odlare et al. / Waste Management 28 (2008) 12461253

1251

Table 3
Descriptive statistics (maximum, minimum, mean, median and CV) for various soil properties for the experimental site prior to the experiment (n = 36)
Parameter

Range

Mean

Median

CV

Minimum

Maximum

Chemical analysis
pH
Org-C (%)
Tot-C (%)
Tot-N (%)
Tot-P (g kg1 dw)
Tot-S (g kg1 dw)
P-AL (mg 100 g1 dw)
P-Olsen (mg 100 g1 dw)
K-AL (mg 100 g1 dw)
TEB (mekv 100 g1)
CEC (mekv 100 g1)
Cu (mg kg1 dw)
Zn (mg kg1 dw)
Cd (mg kg1 dw)
Ni (mg kg1 dw)
Pb (mg kg1 dw)
Cr (mg kg1 dw)

5.4
1.2
1.2
0.1
0.6
0.2
3.4
1.7
16.5
10.0
15.8
22.1
81.6
0.2
20.0
19.1
34.2

5.7
1.6
1.6
0.2
0.7
0.2
5.4
2.9
21.0
12.6
20.2
31.3
98.4
0.3
28.5
23.3
42.2

5.6
1.3
1.3
0.1
0.7
0.2
4.6
2.2
18.5
11.2
17.1
25.7
90.3
0.3
24.0
20.4
37.2

5.6
1.3
1.3
0.1
0.7
0.2
4.8
2.2
18.5
11.2
16.8
26.0
91.6
0.3
23.8
20.4
36.6

1.4
6.3
6.1
6.3
6.3
4.3
13.0
10.6
6.1
6.0
5.3
9.5
5.9
6.0
11.2
3.9
51.2

Soil analysis (% of mineral fraction)

>0.002 mm
0.020.002 mm
0.060.02 mm
0.20.06 mm

37.0
24.0
11.0
13.0

49.0
29.0
18.0
19.0

42.1
26.5
14.6
15.5

41.5
27.0
15.0
15.0

7.4
4.9
12.9
10.6

Microbial analysis
B-resp (lg CO2-C g1 dw h1)
SIR (lg CO2-C g1 dw h1)
lSIR (min1)
PDA (ng N2O-N g1 dw min1)
lPDA (min1)
PAO (ng NO2-N g1 dw min1)
Alk-P (lmol PNP g1 dw h1)
1
N-min (lgNH
dw 10 d1)
4 -N g

1.2
11.4
0.12
7.1
0.002
1.6
1.1
19.1

0.7
15.4
0.16
11.5
0.005
3.9
1.8
24.0

0.9
13.4
0.15
9.1
0.004
2.9
1.5
24.4

0.9
13.5
0.15
8.9
0.004
2.8
1.5
21.2

12.9
6.4
11.6
18.2
17.2
9.3
7.2

Total carbon (Tot-C), total N (Tot-N), total exchangeable base cations (TEB), cation exchange capacity (CEC), basal respiration (B-resp), substrateinduced respiration (SIR), growth rate constant (lSIR), potential denitrication activity (PDA), growth rate constant (lPDA), potential ammonia
oxidation (PAO), alkaline phosphatase activity (Alk-P), N-mineralization capacity (N-min). For additional abbreviations, see Table 2.
dw, dry weight.

the 510% active organisms as reported by Stenstrom et al.

(2001) for soils with no recent addition of organic substrate. Moreover, Stenstrom et al. (2001) observed that
up to 100% of the microbial biomass can be active in soils
with high substrate availability, followed by periods of several weeks of back transition into a dormant state when
substrate ceased. One reason for the low proportion of
active organisms found in our eld experiment most likely
was that the soil sampling took place 4 weeks after harvest,
a stage where most easy available carbon remaining after
harvest had been consumed. The largest proportion of
active microorganisms was found in BR50 and NPS, which
were also the treatments that gave the largest crop yields.
The results suggest that proportion of active microorganisms can be an indicator of the amount of easy degradable
carbon in the soil. It should also be noted that when longterm changes in soil quality is to be assessed, sampling
should preferably be performed at occasions when the soil
microorganisms and plant roots are not in an active grow-

ing state. Our strategy is to collect samples 1 month after

harvest seemed to meet such a criterion.
Denitriers are heterotrophs and although PDA showed
no signicant treatment eects, the enzymes reected in
growth, lPDA, increased as a result of application of biogas residues. The bacteria involved in denitrication usually respond quickly to the presence of easy degradable
carbon (deCantanzaro and Beuchamp, 1985). Although
denitriers are facultative anaerobes respiring both under
aerobic and anaerobic conditions using carbon as an
energy source, they grow faster in the presence of oxygen.
Intense aerobic respiration will successively lower the partial pressure of oxygen thus stimulating anaerobic denitrication activity. Hence, sources of readily degradable
carbon are important for denitrifying bacteria and their
activities. Altogether, the carbon-dependent microbial
parameters SIR, dormant and active microorganisms and
lPDA seem to be ecient indicators of available carbon
in the soil.

1252

M. Odlare et al. / Waste Management 28 (2008) 12461253

Table 4
Soil chemical and microbiological characteristics and crop yield after fertilizer amendment
C50
pH
Org-C (%)
Tot-N (%)
Tot-P (g kg1 dw)
Tot-S (g kg1 dw)
P-AL (mg 100 g1 dw)
P-Olsen (mg 100 g1 dw)
K-AL (mg 100 g1 dw)
Cu (mg kg1 dw)
Zn (mg kg1 dw)
Cd (mg kg1 dw)
Cr (mg kg1 dw)
Ni (mg kg1 dw)
Pb (mg kg1 dw)
B-resp (lg CO2-C g1 dw h1)
SIR (lg CO2-C g1 dw h1)
lSIR (min1)
Non-growers (lg CO2-C g1 dw h1)
Growers (lg CO2-C g1 dw h1)
PDA (ng N2O-N g1 dw min1)
lPDA (min1)
PAO (ng NO2-N g1 dw min1)
Alk-P (lmol PNP g1 dw h1)
1
N-min (lg NH
dw 10 d1)
4 -N g
1
1
Yield (kg ha year )

5.7
1.3
0.13
0.74
0.20
4.5
2.1
19.8b
29.0
101.1
0.26
37.8
23.1
20.5
0.23
3.4
0.16
2.9
0.45bc
9.9
0.25
4.2
1.6
18.9
2532.5bc

BR50
5.7
1.3
0.1
0.7
0.2
4.0a
2.0
19.3
28.2
98.2
0.3
36.5
22.6
20.2
0.2
3.5b
0.2
3.0
0.5c
9.3
0.3
4.1
1.6
18.6
2666.7bc

SS
5.7
1.3
0.1
0.8
0.2
4.8bc
2.2
19.5
28.5
99.2
0.3
37.6
23.4
20.3
0.2
3.4
0.2
3.0
0.4
9.6
0.3
4.0
1.6
19.0
2699.4bc

PM

CM
bc

5.7
1.3
0.1
0.7
0.2
4.4ab
2.1
19.8b
28.6
99.4
0.3
37.2
23.1
20.3
0.2
3.4
0.2
3.0
0.5bc
9.8
0.3
4.1
1.6
18.7
2704.7bc

5.7
1.3
0.1
0.7
0.2
4.5
2.1
20.6b
28.6
98.8
0.3
36.7
23.0
20.4
0.2
3.4
0.2
3.0
0.4
8.7
0.3
3.9
1.5
20.5c
2597.0bc

NPS

C100
a

5.6
1.3
0.1
0.7
0.2
4.0a
2.0
18.4a
26.4
93.4
0.2
35.2
20.8
19.8
0.2
3.2
0.2
2.8a
0.5bc
9.0
0.2a
3.6a
1.5
18.2ab
2798.9c

5.7
1.3
0.1
0.8
0.2
5.0c
2.2
20.3b
28.1
97.9
0.3
36.5
22.5
19.7
0.2
3.3
0.2
3.0
0.3ab
9.5
0.3
4.3
1.6
19.1
1946.8ab

BR100

Control

5.7
1.3
0.1
0.8
0.2
4.4
2.1
20.1b
29.2
101.3
0.3
37.7
23.6
21.0
0.2
3.6b
0.2
3.2b
0.4
9.2
0.3b
4.4b
1.7
19.3bc
2272.5

5.6ab
1.2
0.1
0.7
0.2
4.0a
2.0
18.4a
26.6
93.8
0.2
35.8
21.5
19.7
0.2
3.1a
0.2
2.8a
0.3a
8.7
0.2
4.0
1.5
17.2a
1593.4a

Means calculated as mean values over 4 years (n = 16). For abbreviations, see Tables 13. Statistically signicant dierences (Tukey p = 0.10) are indicated
by dierent letters.

Nitrogen mineralization was increased in BR100 and

cow manure treatments. These results are in agreement
with Tiwari et al. (2000) who found that application of biogas slurry resulted in a proliferation of the microbial
population and increased nitrogen mineralization.
Together with soil respiration, potentially mineralizable
N is the most commonly suggested biological soil indicator
for assessing soil quality (Wienhold et al., 2004). The reason for its usefulness is two-fold: (1) it may serve as a general probe of the soil ecosystem status since most
microorganisms have at least some capacity to mineralize
N, and (2) it gives an estimate of the N deliverability to
the plants. The observed increase in nitrogen mineralization
indicates that biogas residues are benecial to soil quality.
In contrast to organic-carbon-dependent respiration and
denitrication, autotrophic nitrication bacteria, also
being lithotrophic, are more dependent on pH and ammonia availability since they use ammonia as their source of
energy. The nitrication process is vulnerable and is performed only by highly specialized organisms (Johansson
et al., 1999), whose activity is enhanced by ammonia. It
was therefore expected that the ammonium-rich biogas residue should increase PAO, compared to the nitrate-rich
NPS. The data indicated such an increase in PAO, but
the dierence was not statistically signicant.
4.3. Indicators of soil quality
Many of the existing methods used to evaluate treatment eects on soil quality focus mostly on soil chemical

properties that change slowly with time, such as C, N

and P content, which limits their usefulness for detecting
short-term changes in soil quality. Measurements of the
status and activity of specic microbial communities contributing to soil processes have the potential to provide
rapid and sensitive means of characterizing soil quality.
In this experiment the simple crop rotation and the homogenous experimental site chosen for the study made it possible to detect early responses of soil microorganisms to the
dierences in composition of the organic wastes. Microbial
biomass (Doran and Parkin, 1994) and enzyme activity
(Badiane et al., 2001) have been proposed to indicate soil
quality. In this experiment the increase in microbial biomass measured as SIR and the increase in several enzyme
activities suggests that the microorganisms responded relatively fast to the content of ammonium and easy degradable carbon.

5. Conclusions
Although the experimental period included 4 years of
nitrogen and organic matter supply of very dierent qualities, surprisingly few signicant dierences in chemical and
microbiological properties could be observed. The most
prominent eect was that biogas residues increased the
substrate induced respiration, the proportion of active
microorganism, and the nitrogen mineralization, as well
as potential ammonia oxidation. In all, studying microbial
parameters seems to be a better choice than chemical

M. Odlare et al. / Waste Management 28 (2008) 12461253

parameters when short-term eects of organic wastes are to

be evaluated.
In addition, the results can help to assess the relative
benets of the various organic residues tested. No negative
eects on the soil microbial properties studied could be
observed by any of the applied organic wastes products
and they all seemed to be equally good or better as fertilizers as compared to cow manure, pig slurry and NPS. Biogas residue contained larger concentrations of mineral
nitrogen and easy degradable carbon, and was therefore
more ecient than the other organic wastes in terms of
supplying plant-available nitrogen and promoting the soil
biological activity. Sewage sludge supplied the soil with
potassium and phosphorous, but the mineral nitrogen content did not match that found in the biogas residue. Compost contained low concentrations of mineral nitrogen and
the microbial mineralization rate seemed to be too slow to
meet the nitrogen requirements of agricultural plants.
References
Badiane, N.N.Y., Chotte, J.L., Pate, E., Masse, D., Rouland, C., 2001.
Use of soil enzyme activities to monitor soil quality in natural and
improved fallows in semi-arid tropical regions. Applied Soil Ecology
18, 229238.
Belser, L.W., Mays, E.L., 1980. Specic inhibition of nitrate oxidation by
chlorate and its use in assessing nitrication in soils and sediments.
Applied and Environonmental Microbiology 39, 505510.
Bremner, J.M., Mulvaney, C.S., 1982. Nitrogentotal. In: Page, A.L.,
Miller, R.H., Keeny, R.D. (Eds.), Methods of Soil Analysis. American
Society of Agronomy, Soil Science Society of America, Madison, WI,
pp. 595624.
deCantanzaro, J.B., Beuchamp, E.G., 1985. The eect of some substrates
on denitrication rates and carbon utilization in soil. Biology and
Fertility of Soils 1, 183187.
Doran, J.W., Parkin, T.P., 1994. Dening and assessing soil quality. In:
Doran, J.W., Coleman, D.C., Bezdicek, D.F., Stewart, B.A. (Eds.),
Dening soil quality for a sustainable environment. American Society
of Agronomy Special Publication, Madison, WI, pp. 321.
Egner, H., Riehm, H. and Domingo, W.R., 1960. Untersuchungen uber
die chemische Bodenanalyse als Grundlage fur die Beurteilung des
Nahrstozustandes der Boden. Chemische Extractionsmethoden zur
Phosphorund Kaliumbestimmung. Annal. d. Landw. Hochschule
Schwedens 26, 119215.
FAO, 1998. Soil map of the world, Revised legend. World Soil Resources
Report 60. FAO, Rome.
Hoitink, H.A.J., Boehm, M.J., 1999. Biocontrol within the context of soil
microbial communities: a substrate-dependent phenomenon. Annual
Review of Phytopathology 37, 427446.
ISO 15685, 2004. Soil quality Determination of potential nitrication
Rapid test by ammonium oxidation. International Organization for
Standardization, Geneva.
Jakobsen, S.T., 1995. Aerobic decomposition of organic wastes 2. Value of
compost as fertilizer. Resources, Conservation and Recycling 13, 57
71.
Jedidi, N., Hassen, A., van Cleemput, O., MHiri, A., 2004. Microbial
biomass in a soil amended with dierent types of organic wastes. Waste
Management and Research 22 (2), 9399.
Johansson, M., Stenberg, B., Torstensson, L., 1999. Microbiological and
chemical changes in two arable soils after long-term sludge amendments. Biology and Fertility of Soils 30, 160167.
Joshua, W.D., Michalk, D.L., Curtis, I.H., Salt, M., Osborne, G.J., 1998.
The potential for contamination of soil and surface waters from

1253

sewage sludge (biosolids) in a sheep grazing study, Australia.

Geoderma 84, 135156.
Jung, G., 1987. Mekanisk analys beskrivning av en rationell metod for
jordartsbestamning. (Mechanical analysis a description of a rational
method for determination of soil type). Report 87:2. The section for
hydro technique, Department of Soil Science, The Swedish University
for Agricultural Sciences.
Kennedy, A.C., Papendick, R.I., 1995. Microbial characteristics of soil
quality. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 50, 243248.
Lee, J.-J., Park, R.-D., Kim, Y.-W., Shim, J.-H., Chae, D.-H., Rim, Y.-S.,
Sohn, B.-K., Kim, T.-H., Kim, K.-Y., 2004. Eect of food waste
compost on microbial population, soil enzyme activity and lettuce
growth. Bioresource Technology 93, 2128.
Leifeld, J., Siebert, S., Kogel-Knabner, I., 2002. Biological activity and
organic matter mineralization of soils amended with biowaste
composts. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Soil Science 165, 151159.
Nilsson, M.-L., Kylin, H., Sundin, H., 2000. Major extractable organic
compounds in the biologically degradable fraction of fresh, composted
and anaerobically digested household waste. Acta Acriculurae Scandinavica Section BSoil and Plant Science 50, 5765.
Nordgren, A., 1992. A method for determining microbial available N and
P in an organic soil. Biology and Fertility of Soils 13, 1951999.
Nommik, H., 1974. Ammonium cloride-imidazole extraction procedure
for determining titratable acidity, exchangeable base cations, and
cation exchange capacity in soils. Soil Science 118, 254262.
Odlare, M., Svensson, K., Pell, M., 2005. Near infrared reectance
spectroscopy for assessment of spatial soil variation in an agricultural
eld. Geoderma 126, 193202.
Olsen, S.R., Cole, C.V., Watanabe, F.S. and Dean, C.A., 1954. Estimation
of available phosphorus in soils by extraction with sodium bicarbonate. U.S. Dep. Agric. Cir. No. 939.
Pell, M., Stenberg, B., Stenstrom, J., Torstensson, L., 1996. Potential
denitrication activity assay in soilwith or without chloramphenicol?
Soil Biology and Biochemistry 28, 393398.
Pinamonti, F., 1998. Compost mulch eects on soil fertility, nutritional
status and performance of grapevine. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 51, 148239.
SIS, 1997. Soil Analyses Determination of Trace Elements in Soil
Extraction with Nitric Acids. SS 02 83 11Swedish Institute for
Standards (SIS).
Sjoqvist, T., 1993. A method to test phosphatase activity in soil, In:
Torstensson (Ed.), Soil Biological Variables in Environmental Hazard
Assessment. Swedish EPA Report No. 4262.
Stenberg, B., Johansson, M., Pell, M., Sjodahl-Svensson, K., Stenstrom,
J., Torstensson, L., 1998. Microbial biomass and activities as aected
by frozen and cold storage. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 30, 393
402.
Stenstrom, J., Hansen, A., Svensson, B., 1991. Kinetics of microbial
growth associated product formation. Swedish Journal of Agricultural
Research 21, 5562.
Stenstrom, J., Svensson, K., Johansson, M., 2001. Reverible transition
between active and dormant microbial states in soil. FEMS Microbiology Ecology 36, 93104.
Svensson, K., Odlare, M., Pell, M., 2004. The fertilizing eect of compost
and biogas residues from source separated household waste. Journal of
Agricultural Science 142 (4), 461467.
Tiwari, V.N., Tiwari, K.N., Upadhyay, R.M., 2000. Eect of crop residues
and biogas slurry incorporation in wheat on yield and soil fertility.
Journal of Indian Society of Soil Science 48, 515520.
Torstensson, L., 1993. Soil Biological Variables in Environmental Hazard
AssessmentGuidelines. Swedish EPA Report, No. 4262.
Waring, S.A., Bremner, J.M., 1964. Ammonium production in soil under
waterlogged conditions as an index of nitrogen availability. Nature
201, 952.
Wienhold, B.J., Andrews, S.S., Karlen, D.L., 2004. Soil quality: a review
of the science and experiences in the USA. Environmental Geochemistry and Health 26, 8995.