Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
SYMBOLISM IN EXHIBITIONAL
ARCHITECTURE
Philosophy of Space
Lebanon -Tripoli
2015-2016
Committee Members:
Dr. Nahed Ghazal
Dr. Samir Tawil
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Although only few names are included in the first pages of this
thesis, a great many people have contributed to its production. I owe
my gratitude to all the people who were involved in this work and
who supported me throughout my research. I am indebted to the
counsel, guidance and support of the committee members Dr. Nahed
Ghazal and Dr. Samir Tawil. Their contribution to the development
of this paper was crucial and valuable.
METHODOLOGY
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION...1
CHAPTER 1: UNDERSTANDING THE SYMBOLISM IN
ARCHITECTURE
1.1 Definition of Symbolism and its Purpose ..5
1.2 Distinction between Symbolism and Representation.10
1.3 The Beginning of Symbolism in Architecture - Between Scientific
Knowledge and Religion:
1.3.1 Newgrange Mound Case..12
1.3.2 The Pyramids Complex in Giza Case.15
1.3.3 Deduction ..18
1.4 Appearance of Symbolism in Secular Architecture.19
1.5 The Languages of Symbolism:
1.5.1 Material...22
1.5.2 Form ...23
1.5.3 Light....23
2.3
CONCLUSION.....84
APPENDIX ...87
REFERENCES ...94
INTRODUCTION
Since the very beginning, human beings have used symbols and
different representational drawings to depict information and label the
elements of their inhabited environment. Behind these images, which took
numerous shapes and forms, usually stood a solid and well defined
conceptual idea. The German philosopher Ernst Cassierer comprehensively
classified the human being as a symbolic animal who needs to provide
meaning to whatever given to it1. According to his philosophy, meaning
was very essential to the human mind and its presence was a fundamental
requirement of humanity. The idea that the mind perceives in a symbolic
way may imply that everything produced by it similarly contains
significance. This concept might seem legit and appealing if one takes a look
at the products of the humans artistic expression: almost every work of art
is clearly embedded with some kind of symbolism.
Cassierer, 1953
Page | 1
of the theme. This is the exact reason why I chose to undertake a research
concerning symbolism in architecture in the first place, but the research does
not stop here.
It seems to be clear and vivid that some architectural spaces are simply
filled with meaningfulness. This can be noticed mostly in religious buildings
from different eras. Egyptian temples, Byzantine churches, Islamic mosques
and other sacred structures are generally embedded with symbolism on
various scales and levels. Yet, after a closer look, similar elements of hidden
concepts and ideas could be found behind some secular ancient monuments
and numerous contemporary buildings, especially museums. The physical
structure of the exhibit spaces often implements the atmosphere of the theme
that the exhibited collection encircles. The use of architectural symbolism
behind such spaces becomes very vivid and undeniable. Although the
encrypted ideas could differ, the rich and conceptually saturated quality of
architecture may be observed in numerous modern exhibitional spaces
around the world.
Page | 3
Chapter 1:
UNDERSTANDING THE SYMBOLISM IN
ARCHITECTURE
Page | 4
Chapter 1
Page | 6
Based on this idea of experience, the scope of our search may now be
narrowed. Focusing on the concept of symbolism as an experience, one might
reach a conclusion that the Theory of Symbolism of the German
Philosopher Ernst Cassierer (1874-1945) best describes the concept of
symbolism in arts (including architecture).
Page | 7
but as to general structure and form3. Translating this philosophy unto the
realm of architecture, this means that the symbolism in the architectural
space is a global concept that is implemented in all elements of space and
forms one unified meaningful idea that each individual may experience
through his senses.
3
4
Page | 8
5
6
Cassierer 1953, 51
Cassierer 1953, 46,61,65,78
Page | 9
Page | 10
belongs to both space and time and it must assert itself in the temporal8.
This means that the meaning behind the symbolism might change with
time, depending on the perception of the current viewer and his
background, giving the architectural symbolism a fourth dimension.
Representations on the other hand disallow any new meanings from being
implemented. The perceptional experience is a unique phenomenon where
cannot be just one representation.
8
9
Cassierer, 1953, 31
Since the Neolithic period
Page | 11
Two interesting questions arise here: What is the nature of the hidden
information behind these structures? And how is it related to the primary
function of these ancient monuments? In order to answer these questions,
the cases of the Newgrange mound and the Pyramids Complex in Giza will
be studied as the most suitable examples.
1.3.1.
Page | 12
The mound was found to be aligned to the position of the rising sun at
the winter solstice, the shortest day of the year13. The long passage at the
Newgrange admitted a narrow beam of light illuminating the central
chamber at midwinter revealing the carvings inside including the triple
spiral14 of the inside wall. The sunlight enters the passage through a specially
dedicated opening (roofbox) directly above the main entrance and is able to
reach the floor. Professor M. J. O. Kelly was the first modern person to
observe this event on 21 December 196715. The illumination lasts for around
11
Different theories exist. Only the most important ones will be stated in this section.
OKelly, Michael J.,1982,122
13
Between December 21 and December 22, depending on the location and year.
14
The meaning behind this Pre-Celtic symbol was not yet certainly identified. One possible interpretation is the
union between a male and a female that gives an offspring, thus symbolizing fertility.
15
Bru na Boinne (Newgrange, Knowth and Dowth). Retrieved on 16 November 2015 from
(http://www.meath.ie/Tourism/Heritage/Newgrange)
12
Page | 13
prevents us from doubting the idea that the builders intended this
Astrological feature. Conceptually, the idea of this alignment was thus
integrated as a basis into the design of the mound.
Planet Quest: The History of Astronomy Newgrange. Retrieved on 16 November 2015 from
(http://www.planetquest.org/learn/newgrange.html)
17
Brennan M, 1994. The Stones of Time: Calendars, Sundials and Stone Chambers of Ancient Ireland. Vermont.
Page | 14
megalithic sites in the region, he formed many supporting ideas for his
theory, but his explanation was not widely acclaimed. Nevertheless, his
effort was helpful in proving the Astronomical meaning behind the structure
despite the speculation around the function of Newgrange (whether it was
purely astrological, burial and religious or a combination between them).
1.3.2.
starting
with
the
Cheops
Pyramid
(Constructed
18
The approximation is based on marks in an interior chamber naming the work gang and a reference to the fourth
dynasty Egyptian Pharaoh Khufu.
Page | 15
respectively. The Great Pyramid, being Khufus tomb, is the oldest of the
Seven Wonders of the Ancient World and the only one of them to survive
and stand till our days. Many mysteries surrounding the Giza ensemble have
not been solved yet, nevertheless many facts regarding the symbolism
behind its architecture are already proven. Religious meaning is thought to
be encrypted in the pyramidal form that symbolizes the sun beams on which
the pharaohs were believed to be transported to the god Ra19. The scientific
symbolism, on the other hand, is even more certain. The mathematical and
Astrological significance encrypted in these ancient structures was revealed
by the researchers after a detailed study of the Positioning of the Pyramids
and their geometry.
19
Page | 16
and afterlife Osiris. As an extension to this idea, the Great Sphynx was
thought to be associated with the constellation of Leo, which explains its lion
body. This hypothesis was not accepted by the mainstream Egyptology and
got criticized by several scientists mainly due to the inaccuracy of
correlations. On the other hand, the symbolism encoded in the Great
Pyramid of Giza is scientifically proven and much more vivid.
study, the sides of the square base are closely aligned to the four cardinal
compass points based on true north. In addition to that, the ratio of the
perimeter to the height of the pyramid equals to 2 with an accuracy of better
than 0.05%. Finally, out of all the number systems and numerical
relationships that could have been used, the Egyptians selected the Golden
ratio and its square root in the geometry of the structure. Having a base of
230.4 meters and an estimated original height of 146.5 meters, the height to
base ratio becomes 0.636, which is equal to the Golden Number Phi with
Page | 17
1.3.3.
Deduction:
After analyzing the two given cases, we may now answer the questions
stated above concerning the nature of the symbolism and its purpose in these
ancient structures. There is enough data to let us determine the type of the
information embedded in the design of some pre-historic structures: Along
with religious meaning, it includes elements of mathematics, geometry and
astrology. Similar symbolism might be noticed in other structures of the time
around the world including many temples in Egypt for example. We may
thus note that scientific knowledge was encrypted behind many
architectural spaces of the ancient world since pre-history.
Meisner G, 2012. Phi. Pi and the Great Pyramid of Egypt at Giza, (Published on August 18,2012)
22
Petrie, 1940, 30
Page | 18
23
The Ancient Egyptian Book of Nut contains astronomical texts that links this knowledge to religion.
Calter P. Polygons, Tilings and Sacred Geometry. Retrieved on 21 November 2015 from
https://www.dartmouth.edu/~matc/math5.geometry/unit5/unit5.html)
24
Page | 19
25
Page | 20
26
28
The Colosseum Through Times: Functions and Symbols. (Published on May 13, 2009). Retrieved on 21 November
2015 from http://itopiarometheeternalcity.blogspot.com/2009/05/colosseum-through-times-functions-and.html)
Page | 21
1.5.1.
Material:
One of the most important mediums through which hidden meaning
may be translated is the material of the structure. This technique was widely
used by the ancient Egyptians. The solid stones were used to symbolize the
strength and eternity, which lead to using them in all important structures
including temples and pyramids. The mud and clay, on the other hand, were
used civil structures. In addition to the strength of the material, its surface
may play an important role. Sharp or bumpy surfaces symbolize
29
The philosophy behind the materials and forms was discussed by Richard Weston in his book: Materials, Form
and Architecture
Page | 22
Form:
Geometrical form of the structure is the best platform for
1.5.3.
Light:
Another very important medium of communication through which
hidden information may be translated is light. The contrast between the light
and the dark spaces, the casting of shadows and their movement across the
interior surfaces are all able to translate specific ideas and concepts. The
30
Page | 23
Newgrange case is a good example on the use of this medium. Despite the
fact that at first light and luminosity were only useful in religious and
astrological symbolism, in our days it may be manipulated to create specific
experience and atmosphere in the structure according to the intended ideas.
Page | 24
Overview
Page | 25
Chapter 2:
SYMBOLISM IN CONTEMPORARY EXHIBITIONAL
ARCHITECTURE
Page | 26
Chapter 2
Page | 27
33
Dernie D, 2006
Page | 28
2.2
Nevertheless its origins may be dated back to the classical period of the
ancient Greeks34. A brief look at the contemporary museology and the
planning of museums shows that currently new trends are being integrated
into the field. These ideas push us to ask ourselves the following questions:
How did Museums start and what are their origins? What is a
contemporary museum and what are the motives and desired goals behind
it?
34
Page | 29
35
Llddell H.G, Scott R. A Greek-English Lexicon. Retrieved on 30 November 2015 from (http://www.perseus.tufts.edu)
Virtual Museums might be separate digital elements that function on their own, or might be complementary
items that enhance the experience of the physical museum.
37
Alexander E, Alexander M, 2008
36
Page | 30
Page | 31
38
Page | 32
specialists
and
initiators
of
diffusion
of
knowledge39.
Museums not only collect and store items and artifacts, but also work on
educating the visitors, thus creating an educational goal of many museums.
This idea was adopted in 1970s by the Canada Science and Technology
Museum that favored education over preservation of their objects. In
addition to that, many museums of natural history in the late 19th century
concentrated on researches related to the items that are being exhibited.
Many large museums, until our days, are still considered to be respected
research centers. Hence, we can conclude, that museums might serve
preservation, educational and research purposes.
39
Page | 33
Dana, 1917, 25
Dana, 1917, 32
Page | 34
Page | 35
Curtis L. Carter claims: Some would say that museums have become
the contemporary equivalent of cathedrals and civic architecture of the
past44. This argument might seem true to some degree, putting in mind the
importance of contemporary exhibitional spaces and their functional
purpose. In his publication, Symbol and Function in Contemporary Architecture
for Museums, he studies the relation between the functionality and the
symbolism in such spaces. The emphasis was made on the idea of equal
44
Carter C, 2010
Page | 36
importance of the two aspects symbolism of the form should not be made
at the expense of functions of the building. According to this concept, a
museum should not turn into a massive structure that is unable to perform
its primary task The meaning and significance should be implemented
without disturbing the functional program.
Page | 37
Overview
To clarify the main ideas stated previously, the next chapter will
analyze study cases of Museums that are implemented with symbolism in
their design.
Page | 38
Chapter 3:
CASE STUDIES
Page | 39
Chapter 3
CASE STUDIES
3.1
extension
of
the
Berlin
45
Additional data, photos and architectural drawings may be found in the annex
Page | 40
Berlin during and after the Second World War and to the tragedies of the
Holocaust46.
The
form
was
positioning of the windows and openings (in the shape of narrow slits that
remind us of deep scars) on the plane zinc coated faade follow the same
well-defined matrix48. The use of Zinc alloys as the main material in the
exterior has its own symbolism: This material has a long tradition in Berlins
history and architecture. The untreated zinc and titanium panels, as intended
by design, will oxidize over time and change color due to the environmental
factors48.
46
The Holocaust was a genocide during the Second World War in which almost 6 million Jews were killed by Adolf
Hitlers Nazi regime.
47
Kroll A. AD Classics: Jewish Museum, Berlin / Daniel Libeskind. Retrieved on 5 December 2015 from
(http://www.archdaily.com/91273/ad-classics-jewish-museum-berlin-daniel-libeskind)
48
The Libeskid Building. Retrieved on 5 December 2015 from (http://www.jmberlin.de/main/EN/04-About-TheMuseum/01-Architecture/01-libeskind-Building.php?exp=,1,#h5-1)
Page | 41
Significance
and
meaning
are
great void one of the six hollow spaces in the structure. The void, which is
not really a museum space49, represents the central structural element with
bare concrete walls. All voids are not heated or air-conditioned and are
largely without artificial light, with only small upper openings for
daylighting. As Libeskind explains, the Museum's Voids refer to "that which
can never be exhibited when it comes to Jewish Berlin history: Humanity reduced to
ashes."49
At the end of the staircase, the people reach a path system made up of
three axes resembling three realities in the history of German Jews. The first
Axis of Continuity connects the old building with the main staircase and
represents the continuation of the Jews history in Berlin. The main staircase
49
Page | 42
is a prolongation of the corridor and leads to the third floor of the exhibitional
space straight from the underground in the same narrow path. The oblique
and numerous structural columns seem to be holding the passage open with
a great effort. This symbolizes the difficulty of reaching the bright light after
the deep terror.
that
leads
goes
while
uneven
the
and
floor
is
ascends
gradually. Behind the heavy door lies the green exterior space with 49
concrete pillars standing on a square grid plan (7 by 7)50. Inside 48 of these
pillars lies Berlins soil while one of them contains soil from Jerusalem51. The
whole space is on a 12 degree gradient which works on disorienting visitors
and destabilizing them resembling the lack of orientation of those escaping
Germany. Russian willow oaks on top of the piles were used to symbolize
hope. The garden is still dug into the ground and the space is surrounded by
50
51
The square shape and the number 7 both carry religious symbolism for the Jewish people.
Riding A, 1998
Page | 43
strong concrete walls, so the visitor has no other choice but to return back to
the main axis. This element symbolizes the idea that the escape into free air
is an illusion and exile is also a form of imprisonment.
At the end we may note that after the construction was completed in
1999, the museum was open to visitors unofficially with no exhibitions inside
of the main halls. There was still nothing to display at the moment, yet
350,000 visitors came to witness the museum space52. Many people claimed
that they came for the architecture itself and liked the space the way it is,
without display items.
52
Page | 44
3.2
for
the
du
53
Simsons M, 1993
Page | 45
entrance pyramid
same rules55. The historical reference to the Egyptian pyramids is very vivid
here, putting in mind the function of the museum that exhibits different
items relating to many ancient civilizations. It appears to be a starting point
of the journey into time. On the other hand, speaking about the form, I.M.
Pei stated: Formally, it is the most compatible with the architecture of the
Louvre..., it is also one of the most structurally stable of forms, which assures
its transparency, as it is constructed of glass and steel, it signifies a break with
the architectural traditions of the past. It is a work of our time.
Despite the fact that the architect officially doesnt mention any
intended symbolism in the structure, clear resemblance to the Great Pyramid
54
Souza E. Ad Classics: Le Grande Louvre /I.M. Pei. Retrieved on 7 December 2015 from
(http://www.archdaily.com/88705/ad-classics-le-grande-louvre-i-m-pei)
55
Blankenbehler B, 2015.
Page | 46
and Golden Mean can be observed according to the data above. Moreover,
this is not the only theory regarding the significance in Peis project. Relying
on the architects sketches and personal research, Benjamin Blankenbehler
has posted an article suggesting the presence of additional symbolism in the
main design55.
Additional data, photos and explanatory diagrams included in the article, may be found in the appendix
Page | 47
their funeral upright pyramids near the river Nile. The male was related to
death while the female counterpart was resembling life, which explains the
vegetation in the inversed pyramid. The interior space also supports this
gender concept where two staircases exist, the spiral stairs (resembling
female) and the straight one (pointing to the male essence).
The contrast between the female and male is thus proceeded by the
idea of life and death. The above-ground and underground manifestations
develop this concept even further, where the water fountains of the entrance
pyramid reflect the blue sky and the pyramid itself on the surface suggesting
an inverse relationship. This forces the visitors to investigate and examine
natures opposites. The perfect proportions, perfect shapes and natural
opposite relationships make the audience visiting the Louvre museum
experience the natural law. The summation of all this significance brings us
to the essential cosmological and natural concept relating to the world we
live in. Blankenbehler has noted additional theories relating to this natural
symbolism57, but the examples and explanations stated above are the most
vivid.
57
Blankenbehler noted additional theories regarding the astrological and historical symbolism of the complex,
relating the axis of the summer solstice, Keplers Zodiac and the historical axis of Paris to the position of the
pyramids on the plan. Further information may be found in the appendix.
Page | 48
3.3
with
tribal
themes,
the
but also to capture that rare ray of light indispensable to make it vibrate and
awaken its spirituality. In a place inhabited by symbols of forests and rivers,
by obsessions of death and oblivion, it is an asylum for censored and cast off
works from Australia and the Americas. It is a loaded place haunted with
dialogues between the ancestral spirits of men, who, in discovering their
human condition, invented gods and beliefs. It is a place that is unique and
strange, poetic and unsettling.59
58
Quai Branley Museum France on Jean Nouvels Official Website. Retrieved on 9 December 2015 from
(http://www.jeannouvel.com/en/desktop/home/#/en/desktop/projet/paris-france-quai-branly-museum1)
59
Musee Du Quai Branley official website. Retrieved on 9 December 2015 from
(http://www.quaibranly.fr/en/public-areas/an-architecture-for-a-dream/)
Page | 49
of
forest.
While
approaching the building and seeing its features that appear gradually
behind the green bushes and trees, people start to feel like explorers that are
craving for a new discovery. Being suspended on columns, which are
blended into surroundings, the structure seems to be elevated over the
ground reminding the audience of tree houses and vernacular architecture.
The multicolored boxes in the main elevation resemble suspended huts from
different cultures, thus forming a feeling that the building is similar to a
shelter in the middle of the woods60.
60
Quai Branley Museum France on Jean Nouvels Official Website. Retrieved on 9 December 2015 from
(http://www.jeannouvel.com/en/desktop/home/#/en/desktop/projet/paris-france-quai-branly-museum1)
61
Additional photos and architectural drawings may be found in the appendix.
Page | 50
curvilinear free-form ramp that leads from the ground level to the main
upper floor. It represents the beginning of the journey and the travel of
explorers between four different continents. The ramp is divided into three
phases by different curvatures, each consecutively symbolizing transition,
transformation and overture62. A moving stream of words and signs
from different cultures, a digital artistic installation called "The River"63,
flows down the winding ramp leading from the entrance of the museum to
the main galleries. The way in which these signs move is designed to
captivate the visitor, who is encouraged to imagine relationships between
the symbols, to bring them together, interpret and dream about them. The
installation is accompanied with various sound effects according to the
phases that visitors have to pass through. Following the ramp, people have
to pass through a black tunnel, symbolizing transition into another world64.
At the end of this tunnel, visitors reach the equidistant center of the
exhibition, which provokes the feeling of being in the center of the world.
This element also emphasizes on the idea of cultural diversity and equality
that the museum is trying to propagate. The haunting atmosphere,
developed in the interior of the primary exhibit hall, refers to the tribal
concepts and their religious beliefs regarding death and oblivion. Statues,
Symbols, Totems and other items present in the collection are accompanied
by a dark mood with few light sources which enhances the experience of the
62
Launay, 2007, 56
Musee Du Quai Branley official website. Retrieved on 9 December 2015 from
(http://www.quaibranly.fr/en/public-areas/an-architecture-for-a-dream/)
64
Launay, 2007, 55
63
Page | 51
65
Page | 52
The
idea
of
dematerialization66
was
of
the
exhibitional
had to somehow vanish and disappear before the sacred objects so that the
visitors could enter into communion with them. This was a challenge to the
current western creative expressions. All mechanical and technical items,
structural elements, false ceilings, parapets and emergency staircases had to
be hidden from the view of the audience. The visual intervention thus had to
be minimal: The collection had to speak for itself and be experienced, and all
means had to be used in order to amplify this experience.
At the end, we can note that the best expression that is able to interpret
the design of this museum space is: An Architecture for a dream. The
whole architectural composition, including the exterior landscape, works on
forming a very intense experience a dream-like journey into cultural
66
Quai Branley Museum France on Jean Nouvels Official Website. Retrieved on 9 December 2015 from
(http://www.jeannouvel.com/en/desktop/home/#/en/desktop/projet/paris-france-quai-branly-museum1)
Page | 53
diversity. Every element of this rich and carefully designed space pushes the
visitors towards discovery while moving the focal point from the
architecture to the exhibited collections.
Page | 54
Overview
In the third chapter, which includes three study cases, we were able to
note the use of symbolism in contemporary museum spaces as a tool for
enhancing experience. In the Berlin Holocaust museum, where the emphasis
was made on architecture itself, one might observe clear structural
significance of the building that becomes the center of the exhibit and the
main theme. The entrance pyramidal complex of the Louvre museum, on the
other hand, embodies symbolism that is hard to decrypt and grasp for the
general public. Being deeply hidden behind the forms, shapes and
landscape, the cosmological and universal meaning in this complex have the
function of provoking curiosity in the minds of the visitors. Finally, the case
of the Quai Branly Museum is a great example on an exhibitional space
where architectural symbolism works as a supportive mechanism and an
extension for the exhibited collection. In this museum, the significance and
philosophy behind the structure of the building are catalysts of the
mysterious and dreamy atmosphere that the artifacts emit. The analysis of
study cases provided us with a sufficient background regarding the different
methods of embedding symbolism in the architecture of contemporary
museums and the purposes behind it. After collecting all the data from
previous chapters and analyzing it, we may now draw a conclusion and
propose the architectural project emerging out of the main theme.
Page | 55
Chapter 4:
INTENDED PROJECT HISTORY OF NATURAL
SCIENCES MUSEUM
Page | 56
Chapter 4
In this section of the report, the intended project and its main idea will
be discussed. The proposed function and goal of the architectural project are
derived directly from theme of Symbolism in Exhibitional Space.
4.1
4.2
i) Chamber of Astronomy
ii) Chamber of Theoretical Physics and Mechanics
iii) Labyrinth of doubts
Age of Might and Power (19th and 20th Century) Zone 700 m2
- Buffer Zone
- Hall of Nikola Tesla
i) Teslas Room
ii) Field of Electro-Magnetism
iii) Chamber of Communication
- Hall of Albert Einstein
i) Einsteins Room
ii) Field of Relativity
iii) Chamber of Energy
- Hall of Atomic Energy
- Bunker of Instability
Ticketing Office 50 m2
Large Auditorium 500 m2
Educational Block 700 m2
- 5 Small classes for Lectures
- Conference Room
- Bookshop
Cafeteria 400 m2
Gift shop 250 m2
Roof Restaurant 500 m2
Exterior Extension Spaces 1000 m2
Storage and Technical Spaces of the Site 400 m2
Total = 9250 m2
4.3
Page | 62
resides on three lots: 575, 579, 534 and 535 which are only partially taken. The
total area of the taken land is equal to 20089 m2.
SWOT Analysis:
Strengths: The sites ease of accessibility and location near the capitol
are a major positive point. Moreover, the site has unconstrained view
Page | 64
above
the
highway
which
noise
and
sound
pollution.
Opportunities:
topography
and
The
sites
variable
appealing spaces. The unobstructed views may add value to the overall
design. The site is eligible for holding a monumental landmark
building such as a contemporary museum.
Threats: The site is subjected to wind currents and thus the project has
to take that into consideration. Moreover, the presence of the nearby
historical monuments should be noted. The project should not interfere
with the existing heritage.
Page | 65
Overview
In the fourth chapter, we have described the project that is intended to
be designed, proposed a preliminary program of spaces (that most probably
will be altered in the final design phase) and chose the site for the building.
At first glance, it might seem that the choice of site is somehow arbitrary and
that it is not completely compatible with the given theme of the project. The
real reason for choosing this site in particular will be discussed in the
conception phase of the following chapter.
The final outcome of this thesis report The Final Project will be
presented in the final fifth chapter.
Page | 66
Chapter 5:
CONCEPTION AND FINAL PROJECT
Page | 67
Chapter 5
The main conception of the project is based on the nearby heritage site - The
memorial rock reliefs that were erected in different ages. As the historical site
Page | 68
Page | 69
It is a known fact that square and rectangular shapes were used to symbolize
knowledge since ancient times. As a guideline for the interior space, a glass
prism is installed above a point of singularity which symbolizes the source
of all sciences - Reasoning and logic. The shape is derived from a square
plane and a single point in three dimensional space, which together form a
prism of Propagating Enlightment. The enlightment traverses different
stages of scientific evolution through the voids carved in each floor.
Following this guideline, the Truth Seekers will pass through every age
and roam through the historical timeline discovering all the main concepts
and ideas. Let the Journey begin!
Page | 70
Page | 71
Page | 72
Page | 73
Page | 74
Page | 75
Page | 76
Page | 77
Page | 78
Page | 79
Page | 80
Figure 42 3D Section of The Main Exhibitional Mass with The Visitors Circuit Directions
Page | 81
Figure 43 Sections
Page | 82
Page | 83
CONCLUSION
Throughout the research above, we were able to tackle all the main
ideas and arguments that were related to the chosen theme. The questions
that were previously stated at the beginning have all found their appropriate
answers. Ultimately, on the other hand, this does not mean that the answers
that emerged out of this research are the only ones valid. As it was noted
before, the path undertaken in studying this topic will always be subjective
to some degree. There is no one certain and widely accepted definition for
symbolism in architecture. Similarly, a single defined method for embedding
hidden meaning behind architectural spaces does not exist. Even the
impressions and interpretations of this symbolism are subjective and only
unique to the perception of the observer. Meaningful significance of physical
spaces, and exhibitional spaces in particular, has no certain beginning and
no unified end-result. All this pushes us to state and accept that there might
be other paths that could have been taken, just as there might be other valid
and clear answers to our questions. The aim in such situation was to stay
objective as much as possible and to responsibly search for definitions,
explanations and supportive examples. Being carefully chosen, the
undertaken path was traced as a continuous thread through the three main
chapters.
Page | 84
At the end of the research we may note that this study is not a complete
and omnipotent manifesto that totally describes the topic, but it is a solid and
logically structured contribution to the vast ocean of concepts surrounding
architectural symbolism. Similarly, the designed experiential museum and
its subjective translation of the scientific timeline and its concepts, is not the
Page | 85
only true and perfect solution for the given thematic background. The quest
for greater understanding doesnt end here it is ongoing and seems to be
fueling researchers in pursuit with uplifting curiosity
Page | 86
Appendix 1
Jewish Holocaust Museum in Berlin
Figure 48 One of the Voids of the Museum with an artistic installation (Source:
flyingoranges.com)
Page | 87
Page | 88
Page | 89
Appendix 2
Louvres Entrance Pyramid Complex
Figure 54 Blankenbehler's theory regarding the alignment of the complex with the historical axis of Paris
and the axis of summer solstice (Source: architecturerevived.blogspot.com)
Page | 90
Figure 57 Blankenbehler's theory relating the landscape plan of the main pyramid to the Kepler's Zodiac, thus noting astrological
symbolism (Source: architecturerevived.blogspot.com)
Figure 56 Blankenbehler's theory relating the planning of the pyramidal complex with accordance to the Kepler's Eye (Source:
architecturerevived.blogspot.com)
Page | 91
Appendix 3
Musee du Quai Branley
Page | 92
Page | 93
REFERENCES
Books:
- Alexander E, Alexander M, 2008. Museums in Motion: An Introduction
to the History and Function of Museums. Lanham.
- Brennan M, 1994. The Stones of Time: Calendars, Sundials and Stone
Chambers of Ancient Ireland. Vermont.
- Cassierer E, 1953. The Philosophy of Symbolic forms (Volume 1). New
Haven.
- Dana J.C, 1917. The New Museum. New Yorkshire.
- Dernie D, 2006. Exhibition Design. New York.
- Eisenman P, 1998. The End of the Classical: The End of the Beginning,
the End of the End in Architecture Theory Since 1968. Cambridge.
- Flinder Petrie W.M, 1883. The Pyramids and Temples of Gizeh. London.
- Flinder Petrie W.M, 1940. Wisdom of the Egyptians. London.
- Grin J, Gorin S, Fleming N, 2001. The Archaeology Coursebook: An
Introduction to Study Skills, Topics and Methods. London.
- Moffet, M. Fazio, M. and Wodehouse, L. 2003. A World History of
Architecture. London.
- OKelly, Michael J, 1982. Newgrange: Archaeology, Arts and Legend.
London.
- Tschumi B, 1998. The Architectural Paradox in Architecture Theory Since
1968. Cambridge.
Page | 94
Articles:
- Blankenbehler B, 2015. Symbolic Meaning of the Louvre, Paris France.
(Published on August 23, 2015)
- Carter C, 2010. Symbol and Function in Contemporary Architecture for
Museums. (National Technical University of Athens)
- Findeln P, 1989. The Museum: Its Classical Etymology and Renaissance
Genealogy. (University of California, Berkley)
- Launay S, 2007. Le muse du Quai Branly, construction et reprsentation
des identits par la mdiation musale. (Mmoire de fin dtudes,
Universit Lumire Lyon 2.) Retrieved on 11 December 2015
- Meisner G, 2012. Phi. Pi and the Great Pyramid of Egypt at Giza,
(Published on August 18,2012)
- Riding A, 1998. Now Practicing What He Preaches; Jewish Museum in
Berlin Is a Noted Architect's First Building. (The New York Times, 17
March 1998)
- Sear F.B, John R, 2010. Triumphal Arch. (Oxford Art Online, July 30,
2010)
- Simsons M, 1993. 5 Pieces of Europe's Past Return to Life: France; A vast
new exhibition space as the Louvre renovates. (The New York Times, 28
March 1993)
Page | 95
Websites:
- A Perfectly Normal Museum. Retrieved on 5 December 2015 from
(http://www.jmberlin.de/main/EN/04-About-The-Museum/01Architecture/00-architecture.php)
- Bru na Boinne (Newgrange, Knowth and Dowth). Retrieved on 16
November 2015 from
(http://www.meath.ie/Tourism/Heritage/Newgrange)
- Building The Coloseum. Retrieved on 21 November 2015 from
(http://www.tribunesandtriumphs.org/colosseum/building-thecolosseum.htm)
- Calter P. Polygons, Tilings and Sacred Geometry. Retrieved on 21
November 2015 from
(https://www.dartmouth.edu/~matc/math5.geometry/unit5/unit5.htm
l)
- Griffith
Observatory.
Retrieved
on
December
2015
FROM
(http://griffithobservatory.org/)
- Kroll A. AD Classics: Jewish Museum, Berlin / Daniel Libeskind. Retrieved
on 5 December 2015 from (http://www.archdaily.com/91273/adclassics-jewish-museum-berlin-daniel-libeskind)
- La exposicin ms vista en Espaa el ao pasado fue la de Yoko Ono en el
Guggengheim.
Retrieved
on
December
2015
from
Page | 96
(http://www.elcorreo.com/bizkaia/culturas/201501/02/guggenheimsupero-millon-visitantes-20150102132645.html)
- Llddell H.G, Scott R. A Greek-English Lexicon. Retrieved on 30
November 2015 from (http://www.perseus.tufts.edu)
- Musee Du Quai Branley official website. Retrieved on 9 December 2015
from (http://www.quaibranly.fr/en/public-areas/an-architecture-for-adream/)
- National Constitution Center of Philadelphia. Retrieved on 7 December
2015 from (http://constitutioncenter.org/)
- Planet Quest: The History of Astronomy Newgrange. Retrieved on 16
November 2015 from
(http://www.planetquest.org/learn/newgrange.html)
- Quai Branley Museum France on Jean Nouvels Official Website.
Retrieved
on
December
2015
from
(http://www.jeannouvel.com/en/desktop/home/#/en/desktop/projet/p
aris-france-quai-branly-museum1)Wikipedia:
Retrieved
on
21
Sacred
November
Architecture.
2015
from
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sacred_architecture)
- Smithson J. Smithsonian Institution. Retrieved on 30 November 2015
from (https://www.si.edu/giving/giv_james_smithson.html)
- Souza E. Ad Classics: Le Grande Louvre /I.M. Pei. Retrieved on 7
December 2015 from (http://www.archdaily.com/88705/ad-classics-legrande-louvre-i-m-pei)
Page | 97
Page | 98