Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Manual Therapy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/math
Original article
a r t i c l e i n f o
a b s t r a c t
Article history:
Received 16 November 2009
Received in revised form
16 June 2010
Accepted 21 June 2010
Extensive computer use amongst ofce workers has lead to an increase in work-related neck pain.
Aberrant activity within the three portions of the trapezius muscle and associated changes in scapular
posture have been identied as potential contributing factors. This study compared the activity (surface
electromyography) of the three portions of the trapezius in healthy controls (n 20) to a neck pain group
with poor scapular posture (n 18) during the performance of a functional typing task. A scapular
postural correction strategy was used to correct scapular orientation in the neck pain group and electromyographic recordings were repeated. During the typing task, the neck pain group generated greater
activity in the middle trapezius (MT) (p 0.02) and less activity in the lower trapezius (LT) (p 0.03)
than the control group. Following correction of the scapula, activity recorded by the neck pain group was
similar to the control group for the middle and lower portions (p 0.09; p 0.91). These ndings
indicate that a scapular postural correction exercise may be effective in altering the distribution of
activity in the trapezius to better reect that displayed by healthy individuals.
2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords:
Postural correction
Trapezius muscle
Neck pain
1. Introduction
Complaints of work-related neck pain are becoming increasingly
prevalent, especially amongst intensive computer users (Cook et al.,
2000; Korhonen et al., 2003; Silanpaa et al., 2003; Cagnie et al.,
2007). A recent study conducted by Cagnie et al. (2007) found
that over a twelve-month period, 45.5% of 512 ofce workers
reported neck pain. Studies investigating neck pain associated with
static sitting postures have identied altered posture and muscle
recruitment patterns in the cervicobrachial region as potential
contributing factors (Nederhand et al., 2000; Falla et al., 2004;
Szeto et al., 2005).
Individuals with neck pain may display altered postural
behaviours when performing prolonged sitting tasks, such as
during computer use. Szeto et al. (2002) found that ofce workers
with neck pain tended to drift in and out of scapular protraction
more than asymptomatic ofce workers. These changes were
associated with altered behaviour in the upper trapezius (UT)
muscle and were linked to the severity of neck pain experienced.
That is, those with higher levels of discomfort displayed a more
aberrant pattern of trapezius muscle behaviour compared to those
with mild/no symptoms (Szeto et al., 2005). These ndings are
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: sallywegner@hotmail.com (S. Wegner).
1356-689X/$ e see front matter 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.math.2010.06.006
563
2. Methods
Surface electromyography (EMG) was used to obtain myoelectric signals from the three portions of the trapezius muscle. Pairs of
electrodes were placed unilaterally at the mid-position between
the C6 spinous process and the lateral acromion, on the anterior
border of the muscle bulk, for the UT muscle (Mercer, 2002).
Electrodes for the middle portion of the trapezius (MT) were placed
adjacent to the spinous process of T2. For the LT, electrodes were
positioned along the line between T5 and the acromion (Johnson
and Pandyan, 2005). The electrodes used were 10 mm adhesive
Ag/AgCl (Myotronics-Noromed, Inc.) surface electrodes (MT and LT)
and 20 mm surface electrodes (Myotronics-Noromed, Inc.) (UT). A
centre-to-centre inter-electrode distance of 20 mm was employed.
The reference electrode was placed over the upper thoracic spine.
Prior to attachment of the electrodes, the participants skin was
prepared by cleaning the area with an abrasive gel and alcohol
(Hermens et al., 2000). The area was shaved if necessary. A 6channel EMG was used (NeuroLog, Digitimer Ltd., England). EMG
signals were amplied (gain, 1000), passed through a 10e500 Hz
band-width lter and sampled at 1000 Hz. Data were sampled with
Spike software (Cambridge Electronics Design, UK) and converted
into a format suitable for signal processing with Matlab 7 software
(The Math Works, Inc).
2.1. Participants
Thirty-eight volunteers participated in the study including 20
pain free controls and 18 individuals with neck pain. Participants
included both males and females in an age range of 18e48 years
and were recruited from the university and general community.
Sample size was based on our previous study utilizing similar data
collection methodology and patient populations to identify differences in trapezius muscle activity between control and neck pain
populations (alpha 0.05, power 0.92) (Johnston et al., 2008b).
Participants were included into the control group if they were
asymptomatic and were without a history of neck pain or neck
trauma. The control participants were also required to display
good scapular posture and control to allow comparison with the
neck pain group who were selected on the basis of an aberrant
scapular posture. It was hypothesised that controls who displayed
good posture would ultimately display ideal trapezius muscle
behaviour. Good scapular posture was dened as the mid-position
between all available ranges of scapular motion e upward/downward rotation, medial/lateral rotation, anterior/posterior tipping
and protraction/retraction (Ludewig et al., 2009; Mottram et al.,
2009). This was assessed by the primary investigator who visually analysed the position of the acromion in the sagittal plane both
at rest and during upper limb active movement. The side that most
accurately displayed scapular mid-position was chosen as the test
side.
Participants were included into the neck pain group if they
scored 15% or greater on the Neck Disability Index (NDI) e
a minimal score to reect the presence of at least a mild neck pain
disorder (Vernon, 2008), had a history of neck pain of greater than
three months duration over a 12-month period and demonstrated
poor scapular posture on the symptomatic side of their neck in
a relaxed standing posture. The resting position was visually
assessed by the primary investigator with a poor posture being
considered a deviation from the mid-position between all available
ranges of scapular motion e upward/downward rotation, medial/
lateral rotation, anterior/posterior tipping and protraction/retraction. Poor scapular posture was included as a criterion to ensure
that there was clinical justication to perform a scapula correction
strategy in the second part of the study. If both sides displayed poor
scapular posture, the most symptomatic side was chosen as the test
side. Participants were excluded if they had a history of neck
surgery; chronic neck pain resulting from a traumatic incident (for
example: motor vehicle crash); a medical diagnosis of bromyalgia,
cervical radiculopathy, carpal tunnel syndrome, systemic illness or
a connective tissue disorder, any neurological signs or shoulder
pathology.
Written informed consent was obtained from all participants.
The Institutional Medical Research Ethics Committee granted
ethical approval for this study.
2.2. Baseline measures
The participants with neck pain completed theNDI (Vernon and
Mior, 1991) and completed a visual analogue scale (VAS) for pain.
2.3. Electromyography
2.4. Procedure
Participants sat in a comfortable position at a standard ofce
workstation in an adjustable chair without arm supports. They
were instructed to make individual changes for their comfort
(McLean, 2005). Resting EMG was recorded for 10 s prior to
commencement of the task with the participant sitting in a relaxed
position with their hands resting on the keyboard. They were then
asked to type continuously at their normal pace for 5 min. A copytyping program, Bruces Typing Tutor was used to display the text.
Errors could be corrected using the backspace key.
The participants with neck pain undertook the second stage of
the study. These participants were instructed in a postural correction exercise. The primary investigator taught the participant to
assume a neutral lumbar spine and to correct the scapular position
using the necessary cues to position the scapula on the chest wall in
the mid-position between all directions of scapular motion specic
for that participant. This involved various instructions as pertinent
to the scapular orientation of the individual subject e for example
for downwardly rotated scapula instructions included gently lift
Table 1
Descriptive statistics for the neck pain and control groups.
Neck pain (n 18) [mean (S.D)] Control (n 20) [mean (S.D)]
Age (years)
Gender Male
Female
BMI (kg/m2)
NDI (0e100)
VAS (0e10) on
testing day
Duration of
neck pain
(yrs)
27.2 (6.9)
7
11
22.4 (3.7)
20.2 (5.5)
2.0 (2.0)
24.8 (6.6)
7
14
23.3 (2.4)
e
e
5.5 (4.8)
564
Table 2
RMS EMG activity of the three portions of the trapezius muscle in the neck pain and
control groups during the resting condition.
Muscle
(1sRMS [V])
Control group
(mean [S.D.])
F-statistic
UT
MT
LT
1.49 [0.28]
1.18 [0.46]
1.26 [0.35]
1.47 [0.25]
1.30 [0.38]
1.22 [0.33]
UT e upper trapezius.
MT e middle trapezius.
LT e lower trapezius.
Table 3
Mean EMG activity recorded from the control and neck pain groups during typing
condition 1 (TT 1) with natural scapular posture.
Muscle
TT 1: control group TT 1: neck pain group F-statistic
(1sRMS [V]) (mean [S.D.])
(mean [S.D.])
UT
MT
LT
1.78 [0.28]
1.47 [0.10]
1.57 [0.13]
UT e upper trapezius.
MT e middle trapezius.
LT e lower trapezius.
a
p < 0.05.
1.74 [0.17]
1.59 [0.20]
1.45 [0.19]
TT 1:
(mean [S.D.])
TT 2:
(mean [S.D.])
t-Test
UT
MT
LT
1.74 [0.17]
1.59 [0.20]
1.45 [0.19]
1.71 [0.09]
1.53 [0.12]
1.56 [0.24]
UT e upper trapezius.
MT e middle trapezius.
LT e lower trapezius.
a
p < 0.05.
activity in MT was higher and the LT was less in the neck pain group
compared to the control group. There was a trend towards lesser
activity in the UT in the neck pain group but activity was not
signicantly different to that recorded from the control group.
Previous studies have shown that individuals with neck pain
display altered trapezius activation patterns. Most have examined
the activity of the UT during typing or other similar upper limb
tasks. Results are mixed with both lesser (Falla et al., 2004) and
greater activity (Szeto et al., 2005; Johnston et al., 2008a, b) in the
UT being recorded in neck pain subjects compared to pain free
individuals. That is, the presence of pain can be associated with
either an inhibitory (Falla et al., 2007) or facilitory effect (Szeto
et al., 2005) on trapezius activation patterns. The average pain
(VAS) of subjects in the current study on the day of testing was
2.0 2.0 cm on a 10 cm scale, but pain during the typing task was
not monitored. Thus we are unable to determine if there was any
association between changes in pain and changes in the UT muscle
behaviour during the typing task in this study.
The relationship between the three portions of trapezius during
a functional activity has not been widely investigated. In one study,
Falla et al. (2007) produced experimental pain with hypertonic
saline injections into the upper portion of trapezius and found that
activity during a shoulder exion task was re-distributed across the
trapezius. In response to pain, activity reduced in the UT compared
to the pain free control condition which the authors considered was
in line with a pain adaptation model. Activity increased in the LT but
remained unchanged in the MT, which was reasoned to be a reorganisation of trapezius muscle activation to allow the subject to
complete the task. This present study also found differences in
muscle activity within the trapezius in the mechanical neck pain
group relative to the pain free control group. During the typing task,
our ndings were that the neck pain group had greater activity in
the MT and lesser activity in the LT relative to the control group.
Methodological differences between this present study and that of
Falla et al. (2007) may explain the discrepancies in the ndings. Falla
et al. used an experimental pain paradigm and recorded trapezius
muscle activity during a shoulder exion task in comparison to the
typing task used in this study. The different upper limb tasks would
impart different forces and excursions of motion to the shoulder
Table 5
A comparison of EMG activity in the three portions of trapezius between control
participants in TT 1 and the neck pain group during typing condition 2 (TT2) with
scapular correction.
Muscle
TT 1: control group TT 2: neck pain group F-statistic
(1sRMS [V]) (mean [S.D.])
(mean [S.D.])
UT
MT
LT
1.78 [0.28]
1.47 [0.10]
1.57 [0.13]
UT e upper trapezius.
MT e middle trapezius.
LT e lower trapezius.
1.71 [0.09]
1.53 [0.12]
1.56 [0.24]
565
566
Marras WS, Davis KG. A non-MVC EMG normalization technique for the trunk
musculature: part 1 method development. Journal of Electromyography and
Kinesiology 2001;11:1e9.
McClure PW, Michener LA, Sennett BJ, Karduna AR. Direct 3-dimensional
measurement of scapular kinematics during dynamic movements in vivo.
Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery 2001;10:269e77.
McLean L. The effect of postural correction on muscle activation amplitude recorded
from the cervicobrachial region. Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology
2005;15:527e35.
Mercer SR. Surface electrode placement and upper trapezius. Advances in Physiotherapy 2002;4:50e3.
Mottram S, Woledge RC, Morrissey D. Motion analysis study of a scapular orientation exercise and subjects ability to learn the exercise. Manual Therapy
2009;14:13e8.
Nederhand MJ, IJzerman MJ, Hermens HJ, Baten CTM, Zilvold G. Cervical muscle
dysfunction in the chronic whiplash associated disorder grade II (WAD II). Spine
2000;25:1938e43.
Silanpaa J, Huikko S, Nyberg M, Kivi P, Laippala P, Uitti J. Effect of work with visual
display units on musculo-skeletal disorders in the ofce environment. Occupational Medicine 2003;53:443e51.
Szeto GPY, Straker LM, OSullivan PB. A comparison of symptomatic and asymptomatic ofce workers performing monotonous keyboard work-1: neck and
shoulder muscle recruitment patterns. Manual Therapy 2005;10:270e80.
Szeto GPY, Straker L, Raine S. A eld comparison of neck and shoulder postures in
symptomatic and asymptomatic ofce workers. Applied Ergonomics 2002;33:
75e84.
Thorn S, Sogaard K, Kallenberg LAC, Sandsjo L, Sjogaard G, Hermens HJ, et al.
Trapezius muscle rest time during standardized computer work e a comparison
of female users with and without self-reported neck/shoulder complaints.
Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology 2007;17:420e7.
van Dien JH, Cholewicki J, Radebold A. Trunk muscle recruitment patterns in
patients with low back pain enhance the stability of the lumbar spine. Spine
2003;28:834e41.
Vernon H, Mior S. The neck disability index: a study of reliability and validity.
Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 1991;14:409e15.
Vernon H. The neck disability index: state-of-the-art, 1991e2008. Journal of
Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 2008;31:491e502.