Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 7

Functional therapy for

children with cerebral


palsy: an ecological
approach
Lena Ekstrm Ahl* MSc PT PCS, Child and Youth
Habilitation, Uppsala;
Eva Johansson PhD PT, Mlardalen University, Vsters;
Tina Granat PhD, Clinical Psychologist, Child and Youth
Habilitation, Uppsala;
Eva Brogren Carlberg PhD PT PCS, The Research Unit,
Handicap and Habilitation, Stockholm, Sweden.
*Correspondence to first author at Child and Youth
Habilitation, Box 260 74, S-750 26 Uppsala, Sweden.
E-mail: lena.ekstrom.ahl@lul.se

The aim of this pilot study was to evaluate functional training


for children with cerebral palsy (CP). The outcomes
examined were goal-achievement, gross motor function,
performance of everyday activities, caregiver assistance,
parents perception of family-centredness, and preschool
assistants feeling of competence in the care of the children.
The outcome measures used were goal attainment scaling,
Gross Motor Function Measure, Pediatric Evaluation of
Disability Inventory (functional skills and caregiver
assistance scales), Measure of Processes of Care, and a
questionnaire. The intervention was carried out in the context
of daily life settings, i.e. in an ecological framework. Fourteen
children (three females, 11 males; age range 1y 6mo to 6y)
with diplegia and tetraplegia, classified at Gross Motor
Function Classification System levels IIV, participated in the
five-month intervention. Frequency of training towards a
specific goal varied between twice a day and 23 times a day,
depending on the type of goal. Seventy-seven per cent of goals
were fully attained. Gross motor function and performance of
daily activities, including social function, improved significantly.
A decrease in caregiver assistance was noted in relation to the
childrens mobility. Parents perception of family-centredness
improved in all domains. Furthermore, the childrens preschool
assistants felt more competent in their care of the children.

An ecological approach, where the aim is to promote better


functioning in the context of daily life settings, can serve as an
effective framework for physical therapy (Ketelaar et al. 2001).
This approach encompasses two aspects of childrens development in relation to the environment: development in the
sociocultural context (Bronfenbrenner 1986) and development through the childrens perceptual-motor exploration of
their surroundings (Gibson and Pick 2003). Physical therapy
in this context emphasizes the interaction between the individual, the task, and the environment as a basis for the child to
learn; children actively seek effective solutions to problems
that arise in situations they desire to master (Gentile 1998,
Lesensky and Kaplan 2000). The approach is called functional
as primarily functional skills (e.g. dressing and climbing stairs),
are practised to achieve functional goals. Furthermore, this
approach offers a good basis for individualized planning,
stressing the importance of developing skills that are meaningful for the children and their parents (Law et al. 1998,
Rosenbaum et al. 1998, Bower et al. 2001). Defining specific
goals can enhance motivation and, possibly, the childs capacity to learn (King et al. 1999). In this context the child can
become an active problem solver instead of a passive recipient
of treatment. To provide frequent opportunities for training,
the participation of parents and caregivers is very important.
They provide possibilities to practise activities towards predefined goals, in many situations and on many occasions,
throughout the day.
Recently, Jansen and coworkers (2003) presented an excellent review of the literature on parental participation in physical therapy for children with physical disabilities. They pointed
out that parents who participate in physical therapy are likely
to develop a more realistic view of their childs potential in
terms of daily functioning. The authors suggest that this could
increase parents confidence in their own competence and
reduce parental stress. Jansen et al. call for studies in which the
effect of therapy on both parents and children is evaluated in
order to shed light on the complex interactions that bring
about a childs development. They considered the Measure of
Processes of Care (MPOC; King et al.1995) to be a good evaluative tool for parental participation.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of training in
daily life settings for preschool children with cerebral palsy
(CP) with respect to (1) goal attainment, (2) gross motor function, (3) performance of daily activities, and (4) amount of caregiver assistance required. Furthermore, this study examined
whether the parents and assistants perceptions of family-centredness and competence in the care and training of their child
was affected by the intervention procedure.
Method
PARTICIPANTS

Fourteen children (three females, 11 males; age range 1y


6mo to 6y) with CP without severe learning disability*, living
in Uppsala, Sweden, were invited to take part in the study
(n=16); all participants completed the evaluations. Children
had spastic diplegia or tetraplegia and their functional performance was classified between levels IIV of the Gross
Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS; Palisano et
al. 1997). The children were divided into two groups to facilitate training and teaching (Table I). There was no control
*US usage: mental retardation.

Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology 2005, 47: 613619 613

group due to a lack of children who were matched for severity


of disability, age, and sex. The ethics committee of the Faculty
of Medicine at Uppsala University approved the study. Parents
gave their informed consent. Those in charge of the childrens
preschools were informed about the content of the intervention and agreed to participate.
OUTCOME MEASURES

Considerable attention was given to identifying and evaluating individual goals for each child. Goals were set in close collaboration with the parents, the child (as much as possible),
the childs preschool assistant, and staff from the habilitation
team (i.e. physical therapist, special needs teacher). Seven
specific and measurable goals were set for each child. Goal
attainment was graded as complete (100%), partial (50%), or
no improvement (<50%). An example of a set goal might be
for the child to get up from a prone position to a sitting position. Goal attainment would be graded as partial, for example,
if the children rolled over on their side, placed weight on the
elbow, and was able to stretch the arm to sit up, but was
unable to sit up completely.
Change in gross motor function was assessed using the
Gross Motor Function Measure (GMFM-66; Russell et al. 2002).
Achievement in daily life activities of self-care, mobility, and
social function was monitored with the Pediatric Evaluation
of Disability Inventory (PEDI; Haley et al. 1992) using a Swedish
version of the functional skills and caregiver assistance scales
(Nordmark et al. 1999).
Parents and preschool assistants perception of services was
evaluated with a self-administrated questionnaire: the MPOC
(Swedish version, Bjerre et al. 1997). The MPOC was supplemented with four questions to cover areas of interest not covered by it (see Appendix I). To appraise the frequency of
training, diaries were written at home and at preschool for one
week during the 1st, 3rd, and 5th months of the intervention
(Fig. 1).
Three physical therapists, sometimes together with a special
needs teacher, performed all the assessments. They followed
the same children throughout the study. They also participated

in the training of the children. All physical therapists had extensive (1225y) rehabilitation experience and were familiar with
using the various assessments.
INTERVENTION

The intervention period started with a structured four-day livein course for the participating families and the preschool assistants, together with staff from a habilitation team. Intervention
took place at a foundation in the countryside owned by the
association of parents of children with CP. Staff included a medical doctor, physiotherapist, special needs teacher, psychologist, and a social worker. The course was theoretical and
practical. To understand and participate in the training, knowledge about the aetiology of CP and the consequences for
overall development, normal and abnormal motor development, motor learning, psychological aspects, and motivation
were considered essential. During the four days the children
started their training. This began the process of practical guidance for parents and preschool assistants.
During the following 5 months, goal-directed functional
therapy was mainly carried out in the childs normal settings at
home and at preschool. Throughout the intervention period,
continuous discussions were held with, and advice and support given to trainers during regular home and preschool visits. All children met once a week for three hours to attend
training at the local habilitation-centre, together with parents
and/or preschool assistants. Group sessions also focused on
guiding parents and preschool assistants in goal-directed
training with the opportunity to discuss and practice the techniques. Special attention was paid to making children active
participants in this process. Apart from individually tailored
guidance, in group sessions children could meet peers, play,
and have fun. After 5 months, group training was reduced to
one meeting per month; only occasional guidance was given
to parents and assistants.
Child F, a female of 5 years of age (GMFCS level III), will
serve as an example of the individually tailored intervention.
One of the seven goals that the parents, preschool assistant,
and this participant considered important was to be able to

Table I: Children included in study (n=14)


Participant

A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N

Age at start
of study (y:m)

Diagnosis

GMFCS

Other impairments

Group

2:6
2:11
4:0
4:1
4:2
4:2
4:9
5:4
6:0
1:6
1:9
3:4
3:0
2:8

SpDi
SpDi
SpDi
SpDi
SpDi
SpDi
SpTet
SpDi
SpDi
SpDi
SpDi
SpTet
SpDi
SpDi

III
III
III
III
IV
III
V
IV
II
III
III
V
III
IV

No speech
No speech
No speech, visual

No speech
No speech
Visual, epilepsy
No speech

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
2
2

GMFCS, Gross Motor Function Classification System (Palisano et al. 1997). SpDi, spastic diplegia; SpTet, spastic
tetraplegia. Children were assigned to training group 1 or 2 for didactic reasons.

614

Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology 2005, 47: 613619

stand up from the toilet and walk to the bathroom sink. The
activity was analyzed with the physiotherapist and found to
contain several sub-skills that the participant needed to learn,
i.e. stand up, step down a stair, move one hand during the
stepping-down transfer, walk sideways, and turn when reaching the sink. The bathroom floor, which was often slippery,
added to the difficulties. Training was given in the goal-activity
and its sub-skills several times each day, at home and at
preschool. Sub-skills could be practised during other activities, i.e. climbing down stairs and pavements, moving along
holding on to furniture when playing with friends, and standing up from a chair.
Participants were encouraged to perform the different activities in a variety of ways; activities were discussed and suitable
solutions were tried out. The physiotherapists discussion with
helpers (i.e. parents and caregivers) focused on how much
assistance the participant needed to succeed while still doing
as much as possible independently. Another important aspect
of the consultations was to support the helpers ability to do
task-analyses, i.e. what parts does a task consist of, what are the
difficulties for this particular child, how can the situation be
used for training, and how can the motivation of the child be
encouraged? For child F, the main problem was muscular
weakness which contributed to her difficulties in standing up
and walking down stairs. Therefore, focus was on strengthening as an integrated part of the activities. Stronger leg-muscles
would allow her to perform the task with less assistance.

I). To test associations between age and gross motor change,


Spearmans rank correlation (rs) was used. Significance was set
at p<0.01.
Results
FREQUENCY ACCORDING TO THE DIARY

The training diary reflected the true intensity of the training.


Frequency of training varied considerably. Variation was related
to type of goal and how frequently the task occurred in daily
life. For example, a goal to maintain range of motion in the
hamstrings was trained twice a day, whereas a goal aimed at
standing up from a chair could result in over twenty practice
occasions.
GOAL ATTAINMENT

Ninety-eight goals were set for all 14 participants (Fig. 2). Three
goals were related to body function, i.e. increasing range of
motion. One goal was related to participation and aimed at
promoting the childs ability to play with peers. The remaining 94 goals were related to activities, e.g. being able to walk
from the toilet to the sink or rise from the floor into a walker.
Goals relating to eating and dressing were also common, e.g.
taking off a sweater, cutting soft food.
After three months of training, 46 out of 98 goals were fulfilled completely and 25 were partially completed. After five
months, 76 goals were fulfilled completely and 19 were partially completed (Fig. 2). At eight months follow-up goal attainment was sustained.

DATA ANALYSIS

As no significant difference was found between the two training


groups in any of the measured aspects, data were pooled.
Because the data were not normally distributed, the non-parametric Wilcoxons matched pair test was used to evaluate
changes in PEDI and GMFM-66 scores. Furthermore, Friedmans analysis of variance by ranks was used for multiple comparisons with the GMFM-66. To calculate differences in the
MPOC scores, parametric statistics (t-test) were applied according to recommendations in the manual, as data were not
skewed (King et al. 1995). The same procedures were used for
non-skewed data from the additional questionnaire (Appendix

GMFM

GMFM scores did not change significantly during the baseline period. Two children, however, had an unstable baseline. One child exhibited a change of 1, and the other, the
youngest child in the group, a change of 2.42 between the
first and the second assessment. However, the amount of
change displayed during baseline measures was not significantly related to age (rs=0.49). An obvious change in gross
motor function took place over the 5-month training period
(Friedman p<0.001, median change score 3.13, range
1.476.79; Fig. 3). The improvement was most pronounced

Gross Motor Function Measure-66 assessments

Baseline
I

Baseline
II

1mo

Training
diary

PEDI
MPOC
Additional questionnaire

2mo

3mo

4mo

Training
diary
Goal attainment

5mo

PostPostintervention intervention
I
III

Postintervention
III

Training
diary
PEDI
MPOC
Additional questionnaire
Goal attainment

Goal
attainment

Figure 1: Timing of assessments before, during, and after intervention. Each interval indicates one month. Arrows indicate
timing. Gross Motor Function Measure-66 assessments (Russell et al. 2002) were made by three physical therapists (PTs)
following same child through indicated time-period. Pediatric Evaluation of Disability Inventory (PEDI; Haley et al. 1992)
assessments were made by same three PTs and a special needs teacher. Goal assessment was made by parents in
collaboration with PTs and a special needs teacher; MPOC, Measure of Processes of Care (King et al. 1995).

Functional Therapy in Children with Cerebral Palsy Lena Ekstrm Ahl et al. 615

PEDI

According to the parents, the children significantly improved


self-care performance (median 44 vs 49.2, p<0.001), mobility
(median 41.3 vs 43.8, p<0.01), and social function (median
53.4 vs 56, p<0.01) after the intervention period (Fig. 4).
Variation between children on the mobility domain was considerable (see Fig 4). The amount of assistance from caregivers
in daily life activities changed significantly only on the mobility
domain (p<0.001; Fig. 5).
MPOC

Mothers and fathers in nine families, and preschool assistants


in two families, completed the MPOC questionnaire. In four
families only the mother of the child returned a filled-in questionnaire: in three of these the childs assistant also answered
the questions. For one child only, the assistant replied.
Parents perceptions of services received from the habilitation
team during the intervention period significantly improved in
all domains after the training period (t-test p<0.001) although
variability was large, especially before the intervention (Fig. 6).
Mothers and fathers exhibited significantly different opinions before and after the intervention in the domains of
enabling and partnership: (t-test p<0.01; pre: mother 4.7 [SD
1.8], father 5.1 [SD 1.4]; post: mother 6 [SD 1.2], father 6.5 [SD
1]); and coordinated and comprehensive care (pre: mother 4.5
[SD 1.9], father 5 [SD 1.7] post: mother 6.2 [SD 1.2], father, 6.6
[SD 0.9]). Mothers indicated a lower level of satisfaction with
the intervention than fathers. In the domain of respectful and
supportive care the fathers rated a higher grade of satisfaction with the services after the intervention than the mothers
(t-test p<0.01; father 6.9 [SD 0.4], mother 6.4 [SD 1]).
Six preschool assistants partially filled in the questionnaire.
In the two domains, enabling and partnership and coordinated
and comprehensive care, their ratings were higher after the
intervention (t-test p<0.01).

QUESTIONNAIRE

The supplementary questionnaire was completed to a larger


extent than the MPOC, by mothers (n=11), fathers (n=9),
and assistants (n=10). Preintervention, fathers had the lowest
score relating to all four questions. After the intervention the
scores indicated a significant change in the knowledge they
had acquired (questions 1, 2, 3) and how clear the goals were
(p<0.001). Mothers also expressed that they had an enhanced
knowledge in response to all four questions. Preschool assistants initially graded the last three questions higher than the
parents; no significant change caused by the intervention was
found. However, assistants felt they had acquired more knowledge on training the child during the intervention period
(p<0.01).
Discussion
Functional, goal-directed therapy carried out in daily life settings
of 14 children with CP influenced their gross motor capacity
and their performance in self-care, mobility, and social function
over a five-month training period. The goals set were reached
in 77% of cases. Parents expressed a more positive perception
of service delivery after the training period than before. Also, the
childrens preschool assistants showed that they had acquired
more knowledge on how to train and motivate the child.
A fundamental aspect of cooperation between families and
others actively involved in daily care of children with CP is the
formulation of specific goals for treatment (Bower et al. 2001,
Ketelaar 2001). Goals can be viewed as being the cement that
can assist in avoiding fragmentation of services. By making
individual goals clear, everyone involved with the children
can understand them and can unite and work together with
the children to achieve them. Goals that are understandable,

60
55
50
GMFM-66 score

during the first two months of the intervention (Wilcoxon


p<0.01). Between the following assessments a steady upward
trend was found, but the change did not reach significance (p
values ranging from 0.020.05). Between the last three assessments performed post-intervention, no significant change was
seen, indicating that functions gained through training were
sustained. The amount of change in gross motor function was
not related to age at onset of the intervention (rs=0.17).

45
40
35
Participants

30

Intervention
20
BL
BL I
II
1m
o
2m
o
3m
o
4m
o
5m
o
Po
st
Po I
st
Po II
st
III

Assessment times
(mo)

25
8
5
3

Assessments
0

20

40

60

80

98

Number of goals

Figure 2: Goal attainment. Black bar, seven goals set for each
child (n=98). Striped bars, goals fully achieved at 3, 5, and 8
months follow-up. White bars, goals partially achieved.
616

A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N

Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology 2005, 47: 613619

Figure 3: Change in (Gross Motor Function Manual66


(GMFM-66) scores; Russell et al. 2002). Different traces
indicate change in GMFM-66 score (y-axis) in individual
children over 10 assessments (x-axis). GMFM-66 consists of 66
items grouped into five dimensions. Items form a hierarchical
structure with interval scaling, ranging from 0 (low motor
ability) to 100 (high motor ability). BL, Baseline; Post, post
intervention.

attainable, and time-limited give the child an opportunity for


active problem solving: a fundamental aspect of motor learning. The formulation of goals also provides a basis for individualized measures of outcome (King et al. 1999).
In this study the children had fully obtained 77% and partially obtained 19% of the goals at the end of the training period.
This level of goal fulfilment was maintained at follow-up.
Results support the idea that skills used every day persist even if
they are not explicitly trained (Bower and McLellan 1992). In
future studies goal-setting could be further improved by using
goal-attainment scaling with five levels (2 to +2), making it
possible to follow the childrens development towards a goal
(King et al. 1999).
Frequency of training is important for motor progress (Taub
et al. 1999). However, it is uncertain how often children should
practise a function in order to learn it. This seems to be dependent on many factors including the severity of the disability, the
task to be learned, the environment in which the function is to
be practised, the learning capacity of the child, and the method
used (Valvano and Newell 1998, Bower et al. 2001, Trahan and
Malouin 2002, Shumway-Cook et al. 2003). In this study, frequency was measured using training diaries, a method not
tested for reliability. However, the diaries were filled in conscientiously showing that all goal activities received training for at
least five days each week, which indicated that frequency might
play a role in the success of the intervention. However, variation in frequency was related to type of goal and how often the
task occurred in daily life. Therefore, it was not feasible in this
pilot study to relate the frequency to goal attainment.
Childrens gross motor function improved significantly
during the five months of intervention: the rate of improvement was most pronounced during the first two months.
This indicates that although the training was predominantly
specific, it had general effects. It was queried whether some of
the improvement could be due to natural development: a
stable baseline before and after the intervention is one indication of improvement being training-related.
Five gross motor curves corresponding to the five GMFCS
levels have been developed to give an approximate idea about

75

b
80

Caregiver assistance

65

Functional scales

gross motor prognosis in children with CP (Rosenbaum et al.


2002). So far, there is no statistical approach for comparing
the incline of individual children during development to the
incline of the five curves. Visual judgement of the current
results suggested that, considering the age of the children
and the severity of the disability, the incline in 13 of the 14
children was steeper then expected. This corroborates the
assumption that gross motor progress was accelerated due
to the intervention.
The PEDI served two purposes. Apart from being an outcome measure it also formed a basis for discussing appropriate
goals for therapy. The items in the three domains of the PEDI
are aligned along an interval scale, providing an indication of the
childs performance along a continuum from easy to difficult.
The scale can assist in providing ideas about the childs next
developmental step in daily activities, and can indicate what
might be possible in the future. Functional goal-directed therapy provides significant progress in the domains of self-care and
mobility (Ketelaar 2001). The childrens considerable progress
in social function was somewhat more surprising, as this has not
been shown previously. Many factors in the training approach
might have contributed to this development. Possibly, the opportunity to meet regularly peers in group activities was one factor
promoting social development. The goal-directed training
was also very communicative and dealt with problem solving,
causing the child to be active and expressive with regards to
feelings, solutions, and preferences.
In the mobility domain of the PEDI, the amount of caregiver assistance was significantly reduced, indicating that the
children could exercise their newly achieved skills independently. However, the level of caregiver assistance did not correspond to the childrens progress in self-care and social
function. This might relate to the children performing the
tasks slowly due to a lack of automatization, making it difficult
to withdraw support. It also takes time to change behaviour.
Most theories on child development propose that the environment is important for progress and, therefore, the role of
parents is imperative (Bronfenbrenner 1986). The focus of
the current study was on the special role of parents of children

55
45
35
25
15
5

a
60

40

20

Self-care

Mobility

Self-care

Social function

Figure 4: Change in Pediatric Evaluation of Disability


Inventory (PEDI; Haley et al. 1992) functional skill scores
(n=14). Boxplots represent 25th, 50th, and 75th centile.
Whiskers represent minimum and maximum values. White
boxplots indicate assessments before intervention and
black boxplots assessments after intervention. ap<0.001,
bp<0.01 (Wilcoxon). PEDI evaluates through a structured
interview if a child is able or unable to perform 197 skills
(score 1 or 0) in everyday life situations.

Mobility

Social function

Figure 5: Change in Pediatric Evaluation of Disability


Inventory (Haley et al. 1992) caregiver assistance (n=14).
Boxplots represent 25th, 50th, and 75th centile. Whiskers
represent minimum and maximum values. White boxplots
indicate assessments before intervention and black boxplots
assessments after intervention. ap<0.001 (Wilcoxon).
Caregiver assistance is evaluated in 20 different activity areas
using a 6-point scale. A score of 5 indicates independence and
a score of 0 complete dependence on assistance.

Functional Therapy in Children with Cerebral Palsy Lena Ekstrm Ahl et al. 617

Measure of Processes of Care scores

with disabilities, and supporting them in that role. Particular


attention was given to knowledge transfer between parents
and professionals, but other forms of parental support appear
to be important (Solomon et al. 2001). Results from the MPOC
indicate that there was a substantial change in the parents
experiences of caregiving. Considering that the MPOC is a
questionnaire and, therefore, subjective in nature, it is not
surprising that parents who have actively chosen to participate
and have dedicated much time to work together with their children and professionals, express positive feeling towards their
experiences. Previous studies have demonstrated that MPOC is
sensitive to parents perceptions of various types of rehabilitation efforts (King et al. 1997).
Mothers and fathers expressed different views on how
they perceived services, a finding in agreement with that of a
previous study (King et al. 1996). However, the sample in our
study was small and no general conclusion could be drawn.
Determining such perceived differences for future studies could
add valuable information to improve family-centred services,
also taking into account cultural differences.
An area calling for further exploration is the role of preschool assistants. Positive reactions to the approach expressed by the preschool assistants during the intervention
were not reflected to the same extent in the MPOC and the
questionnaire. Assistants were given continuous consultation
and supervision throughout the intervention. The primary
aim of supervision was to enable assistants to handle the child
and to enhance the childs participation at preschool. Thus,
their role in this approach should be considered very important. A meticulous look at the specific role of preschool assistants could form the basis for a more valid way of evaluating
their contribution.

7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0

EP

PGI

PSI

CCC

RSC

Figure 6: Change in Measure of Processes of Care (MPOC;


Swedish version: Bjerre et al. 1997) scores (n=22). Group
means and standard deviations pre- (white horizontal
line) and post- (black horizontal line) intervention. EP,
enabling and partnership; PGI, providing general
information; PSI, providing specific information about
child; CCC, coordinated and comprehensive care; RSC,
respectful and supportive care; significance for all
measures: p<0.001 (t-test). MPOC measures through 56
questions in a self-administrated questionnaire, covering
five domains above, how parents perceive that services
from habilitation-team meet their needs. Parents grade
their statements on a 7-point scale ranging from to a great
extent (7) to never (1).

618

Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology 2005, 47: 613619

Assessing parentalprofessional interactions and the


effect of parental participation in training programmes on
parental well-being will be of importance in future studies to
elucidate the complex interactions between different facets
of an ecological framework.
Conclusion
Children with CP benefited from a functional goal-directed
training approach in their development of gross motor function and everyday activities. The ecological intervention approach was also positively perceived by the parents. The study
adds to the growing knowledge that the efficacy of treatment
lies within the childs day-to-day environment.
DOI: 10.1017/S0012162205001210
Accepted for publication 15th September 2004.
Acknowledgements
We sincerely thank the children, their parents and assistants, and
our colleagues for making this study possible.
References
Bjerre I, Larsson M, Franzon AM, Nilsson M, Strmberg GB, Westblom
L. (1997) Hur fungerar habiliteringsprocessen fr frldrar till barn
med funktionshinder? [How does the habilitation process work for
parents of children with disabilities?] Mnniska-hinder-livsvillkor.
Rapport 39. Psykiatri och habilitering. rebro lns landsting.
Bower E, McLellan D. (1992) Effect of increased exposure to
physiotherapy on skill acquisition of children with cerebral palsy.
Dev Med Child Neurol 34: 2539.
Bower E, Michell D, Burnett M, Campbell M, McLellan D. (2001)
Randomized controlled trial of physiotherapy in 56 children with
cerebral palsy followed for 18 months. Dev Med Child Neurol
43: 415.
Bronfenbrenner U. (1986) The Ecology of Human Development.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Gentile AM. (1998) Implicit and explicit processes during
acquisition of functional skills. Scan J Occup Ther 5: 716.
Gibson J, Pick A. (2003) An Ecological Approach To Perceptual
Learning And Development. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Haley S, Coster W, Ludlow L, Haltiwanger J, Andrellos P. (1992)
Pediatric Evaluation of Disability Inventory (PEDI).
Development, Standardization and Administration: Manual.
Boston MA: Boston University.
Jansen L, Ketelaar M, Vermeer A. (2003) Parental experience and
participation in physical therapy for children with physical
disabilities. Dev Med Child Neurol 45: 5869.
Ketelaar M, Vermeer A, Hart H, van Petegem-van Beek E, Helders
PJM. (2001) Effects of a functional therapy program on motor
abilities of children with cerebral palsy. Phys Ther 81: 15351545.
King G, McDougall J, Palisano R, Gritzan J, Tucker M. (1999) Goal
attainment scaling: its use in evaluating pediatric therapy
programs. Phys Occup Ther Ped 19: 3152.
King G, Rosenbaum P, King S. (1997) Evaluating family-centred
service using a measure of parents perception. Child Care
Health Dev 23: 4762.
King G, King S, Rosenbaum P. (1996) How mothers and fathers view
professionals caregiving for children with disabilities. Dev Med
Child Neurol 38: 397407.
King S, Rosenbaum P, King G. (1995) The Measure Of Processes Of
Care MPOC. A Means to Assess Family-centred Behaviours of
Health Care Providers. NCRU. McMaster University, Canada.
Law M, Darrah J, Pollock N, King G, Rosenbaum P, Russell D,
Palisano R, Harris S, Armstrong R, Watt J. (1998) Family-centred
functional therapy for children with cerebral palsy: an emerging
practice model. Phys Occup Ther Pediatr 18: 83102.
Lesensky S, Kaplan L. (2000) Motor learning putting theory into
practice. OT Practice 25: 1316.
Nordmark E, Orban K, Hgglund G, Jarnlo G-B. (1999) The American
Paediatric Evaluation of Disability Inventory (PEDI). Applicability
of PEDI in Sweden for children aged 2.06.9 years. Scand J Rehab
Med 31: 95100.

Palisano R, Rosenbaum P, Walter S, Russell D, Wood E, Galuppi B.


(1997) Development and reliability of a system to classify gross
motor function in children with cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child
Neurol 39: 214223.
Rosenbaum P, Walter S, Hana S, Palisano R, Russell D, Raina P, Barlett D,
Galupi B. (2002) Prognosis for gross motor function in cerebral
palsy. Creation of motor development curves. JAMA 288: 13571363.
Rosenbaum P, King S, Law M, King G, Evans J. (1998) Family-centred
service: a conceptual framework and research review. Phys Occup
Ther Ped 18: 120.
Russell DJ, Rosenbaum PL, Avery LM, Lane M. (2002) Gross Motor
Function Measure (GMFM-66 and GMFM-88) Users Manual.
London: Mac Keith Press.
Shumway-Cook A, Hutchinson S, Kartin D, Price R, Wollacoott M.
(2003) Effect of balance training on recovery of stability in
children with cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol 45: 591602.
Solomon M, Pistrang N, Barker C. (2001) The benefits of mutual
support groups for parents of children with disabilities. Am J
Community Psychol 29: 113132.
Taub E, Uswatte G, Pidikiti R. (1999) Constraint-induced movement
therapy: a new family of techniques with broad application to
physical rehabilitation a clinical review. J Rehabil Res Dev
36: 237251.

Book Review
The Brains Sense of Movement
By Alain Berthoz
Cambridge, USA: Harvard University Press, 2000
pp 352, 16.95, US$24.95
ISBN 0 674 00980 0 (Paperback)
When I began my doctoral studies in sensorimotor control,
I was intrigued by seemingly unexplainable phenomena
associated with both perceptual illusions and altered perceptual experiences following unique brain lesions. How
could vibrations applied to biceps while the fingertip is on
the nose lead to the perception that the nose is growing
(Pinocchio illusion)? How could two objects of identical
weight but different size be perceived to have different
weights (sizeweight illusion)? How could patients with
parietal area lesions not recognize one half of their body or
visual field (unilateral neglect)? What underlies amputees
perception that their amputated limb still exists or hurts
(phantom limbs)? To me, answers to these questions
appeared to be the key to understanding sensorimotor
interactions in the brain. In The Brains Sense of Movement
(translated from French) the author, Alain Berthoz, uses
these or similar examples of perceptual disconnects as a
guide to describing the relationship between perception
and action. As stated by the author, the book is a reflection
on how the brain works proactively, with perception being
much more than an interpretation of sensory messages.
Perception is proposed to be inseparable from action, and it
is suggested that perceptual illusions are solutions to problems of sen-sory conflict or ambiguity.
What is truly unique is that the book frequently highlights these perceptual disconnects as well as practical
examples and exercises that show how we control movements, such as gaze control, posture and limb movement,

Trahan J, Malouin F.(2002) Intermittent intensive physiotherapy in


children with cerebral palsy: a pilot study. Dev Med Child Neurol
44: 233239.
Valvano J, Newell K. (1998) Practice of a precision isometric
grip-force task by children with spastic cerebral palsy. Dev Med
Child Neurol 40: 464473.

Appendix I: Measure of Processes of Care: additional questions


1. Do you have adequate knowledge to train your child?
2. Can you apply the training recommendations in daily life
settings?
3. Have you received satisfactory information on how to motivate
your child?
4. Have the goals been clear-cut enough for everybody involved to
work towards the same goals?

space orientation, and gait, to guide the reader to an understanding of sensorimotor control. Furthermore, it often
draws upon philosophy and presents historical perspectives on the interaction between perception and action.
The book is nicely divided into 14 important chapters
with sexy subheadings, such as The Art of Breaking and
What If Newton Had Wanted to Catch the Apple, that cover
many bases of perception and action, from control of balance, limb movement, and visual gaze. The central tenant is
that the brain uses sensory information proactively. The
brain is, above all, a biological machine for moving quickly
with anticipation. Berthoz, a highly regarded neurophysiologist, boldly asserts that the brain uses configurations of
receptors to work out a perception and action. As the
author acknowledges, science moves quickly. But despite
having been published almost five years ago, the work was
ahead of its time and this has been reinforced by subsequent
experimental work. However, one exception is the authors
rejection of the term internal representation. While he correctly asserts that it is too easy to hide our ignorance behind
such a generic term, considerable evidence for representations of manipulated objects and their use in proactive control has been published since this book was published.
However, as the author embraces the term internal model,
I suspect the objection largely involves the terms overuse
and that, therefore, Berthozs concern merely involves
syntax.
Overall, The Brains Sense of Movement is a detailed and
refreshing review of sensorimotor control. The book is
filled with wonderful examples which make the presentation of material practical, fascinating, and a delight to read.
The relation of basic material to interesting clinical pathologies makes it all the more interesting to clinicians. This book
contains information that should inspire research in clinical
motor control for decades to come.
DOI: 10.1017/S0012162205001283

Andrew M Gordon

Functional Therapy in Children with Cerebral Palsy Lena Ekstrm Ahl et al. 619

Вам также может понравиться