E in A

MMC CORPORATION BERHAD GAMUDA BERHAD JOINT VENTURE
Revision 01
PROJEK MASS RAPID TRANSIT LALUAN 2 SUNGAI BULOH SERDANG PUTRAJAYA (SSP)
D E S I G N / DOCUMENT R E V I E W REQUEST (DRR) S H E E T

R
To
Bombardier Global Rail Consortium
Date Reviewed
14 December 2016
Submittal Ref.
NOISE VIBRATION COMPLIANCE MANAGEMENT PLAN
Submittal Type
PLAN
Submittal Stage
Concept/Prelim/ Detailed/ Tender/ Construction/

As-built/Others
(Doc.No: SSP-BTGR-SS01-SYSW-PLN-00029-00)
Date of Dwg/ Doc Received
29th November 2016
Your Ref. : SSP-BTGR-TRANSMIT-000139

(WF-011980)
Our Ref.
SSP-PDP2-SS01-SYSW-DRR-00045 (Rev 00)
(* Please circle relevant item)
Revision 01

R
Reviewer
Systems
Approver
Name & Initial
Item
1.
Design/Document / Drawings No.
1.2 Scope
AMK
Final Approver
Name & Initial
Name & Initial
PDPs Comment
WPC does not need to repeat statement
on track work construction/ installation
does not form part of the work package in
this section. Please omit.
PAR
Reviewers
Name
CH2M
Status
Comment
Code
WPCs / Consultants Response
Omitted
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
PDPs Comment
2.
2.1 Abbreviations
WPC to clarify whether abbreviation for

PSD and APD are used for discussion in
this plan? If not, please remove from the
abbreviation section.
3.
3 REFERENCES
WPC to include The Planning Guidelines

for Vibration Limits and Control in the
Environment published by DOE.
Reviewers
Name
Status
Comment
Code
CH2M
CH2M
Included PSD/APG in discussion
Included The Planning Guidelines for Vibration

Limits and Control in the Environment
published by DOE
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
PDPs Comment
Reviewers
Name
Status
Comment
Code
4.
Table 3: List of References ~ Standards
WPC to remove Ministry of Housing and

Local Government Malaysia from the list.
CH2M
Removed Ministry of Housing and Local

Government Malaysia
5.
5.3 Environmental Roles and

Responsibilities
Content in this section looks identical to

EMP without considerable discussion on
noise and vibration management.
CH2M
Rewritten the section
WPC to rewrite this section and elaborate

specific roles and responsibility in regards
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
PDPs Comment
Reviewers
Name
Status
Comment
Code
to noise and vibration management for PD,

Site Manager, EM and EO.
6.
6 CONSTRUCTION NOISE AND

VIBRATION MONITORING
All subsections under section 6 are poorly

structured/ arranged and confuse to the
reviewer. WPC to rearrange and rewrite
the subsection with consideration on:
What are the source of noise or
CH2M
Rewritten and restructured Section 6
Please refer to Section 6
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
PDPs Comment
Reviewers
Name
Status
Comment
Code
vibration expected from WPCs activities?

What are the proposed operation
control by WPC on these sources to
reduce impact to sensitive receptor?
Please refer to Section 1.2 on last paragraph

and Section 6
What are the proposed arrangement of

Baseline monitoring by WPC?
No monitoring will be done as the noise and

vibration generated from BT-GR Consortium not
that of concern level due to the nature of job
What are the propose arrangement on
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
Reviewers
Name
PDPs Comment
Status
Comment
Code
environment monitoring by WPC?
7.
6.1 Methodology
WPC to clarify methodology in this

subsection is refering to methodology to
control
the
noise/
vibration
or
methodology to monitor / measurement?
WPC to rewrite and elaborate
subsection with better clarity.
this
CH2M
Methodology to control the noise/vibration
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
8.
6.2 Baseline Monitoring
PDPs Comment
Reviewers
Name
WPC
shall
elaborate
proposed
arrangement to fulfil the requirement under
GS 8.12 instead of copy and paste the
content.
CH2M
WPC to rewrite this subsection to propose

arrangement of baseline monitoring prior
start of site activities.
Status
Comment
Code
Rewritten the Section
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
9.
6.2 Baseline Monitoring 2)
10.
6.2 Baseline Monitoring - list of tools and

equipment that generate noise
PDPs Comment
In-situ instrument such as pH Meter,
Dissolved Oxygen Meter, Total Suspended
Solid, Turbidity has no relevancy to
NVCMP. Please remove these items from
the discussion.
WPC to list down the tools and equipment
used for baseline monitoring instead of the
grinder, low level noise generator set and
Reviewers
Name
Status
Comment
Code
CH2M
Removed
CH2M

(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
PDPs Comment
Reviewers
Name
Status
Comment
Code

drill. Please correct it.

11.
6.2 Baseline Monitoring final paragraph
Statement by WPC on BT- GR

Consortium will not do the monitoring by
appointing consultant and others is not
compliance to GS 8.12 (2) and 8.25 (1).
CH2M

(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
12.
6.3.1 2) Sensitive Receptor.
PDPs Comment
WPC shall re-write this sentence to
elaborate arrangement for engaging
accredited laboratory to carry out
monitoring on noise and vibration stated in
the DEIA and associated approval
conditions.
Noise exposure to construction workers is
occupational health hazard and not
Reviewers
Name
CH2M
Status
Comment
Code
Removed
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
13.
14.
PDPs Comment
6.3.1 4) Impacts to the Environment: first

bullet point
categorised under sensitive receptor in

environmental impact. Please remove this.
Disturbances and annoyance to workers is
not impact to environment. Please remove
this.
Possibility of hearing loss or impairment
particularly for workers who are exposed
6.3.1 4) Impacts to the Environment:

second bullet point
Reviewers
Name
Status
Comment
Code
CH2M
Removed
CH2M
Removed
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
PDPs Comment
Reviewers
Name
Status
Comment
Code
to high noise level over an extended

period is occupational health hazard and
not impact to environment. Please remove
this.
15.
6.3.2 1) Applicable Environmental

Regulations, Guidelines and DOE
Approval Conditions first bullet point
Do not understand this sentence. WPC to

rewrite with better clarity.
CH2M
Rewritten
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
16.
6.3.2 final paragraph
17.
7 OTHERS
PDPs Comment
This paragraph should read as vibration
related mitigation and noise. Please
amend sentence accordingly.
The elaboration of this paragraph is not
acceptable. WPC is not an authority to
establish guideline.
This NVCMP should read as working
document prepared by WPC to explain
Reviewers
Name
Status
Comment
Code
CH2M
Amended
CH2M
Omitted and included in Section 1.1
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
PDPs Comment
18.
General
how to control and manage the noise and

vibration requirement required under GS
and legislation.
WPC to omit this section and include it
under section 1.1 purpose.
Comply to the guideline and format given.
19.
References
Item no.7 Local Authority Provisions. Detail
Reviewers
Name
PDP HSE
PDP HSE
Status
Comment
Code
Rewritten
Detailed out and included The Planning
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
5.2 Environmental Organization Chart

20.
21.
5.3 Roles and Responsibilities
PDPs Comment
out and include The Planning Guidelines
for Environmental Vibration Limits and
Control (2007).
The name in the org chart for EM is his full
time handling EM?
The roles and responsibilities listed for all
Reviewers
Name
Status
Comment
Code
Guidelines for Environmental Vibration Limits

and Control (2007).
PDP HSE
3
PDP HSE
For this while, the EM appointed is Mr. B.

Nagavinotha. He is also a Safety & Health
Manager
Rewritten
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
22.
23.
Section 6.2 Baseline Monitoring
Section 6.3.1 (4) Potential Impacts to the
PDPs Comment
does not link anything on this plan. It
should be how they are involved in
managing the noise and vibration control.
This section should not be copy paste from
GS. WPC to elaborate on the monitoring
locations if monitoring shall be carried out.
That line is not referring to the impact to
Reviewers
Name
Status
Comment
Code
PDP HSE
PDP HSE
Monitoring shall not be carried out
Removed
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item

Environment
24.
Section 6.3.2 Proposed Vibration

Mitigation Measures Program
25.
General
PDPs Comment
environment but human which is more of a
safety
The para according to GS 8.25 (10) .
And last para contradicts. Rewrite the
statement.
to include the noise and vibration control
mitigation measure operation hour from
Reviewers
Name
Status
Comment
Code
PDP HSE
PDP
Rewritten the section
Included in Section 1.2 and Section 6
(Open/
Closed)
Revision 01

R
Item
PDPs Comment
8am to 7pm and no work for sunday and
public holiday
Note: Comment Code 1 Approved

Comment Code 2 Approved with Comment
Comment Code 3 Rejected
Reviewers
Name
Comment
Code
Status
(Open/
Closed)

E in A

Загружено:

Сведения о документе

Оригинальное название

Авторское право

Доступные форматы

Поделиться этим документом

Поделиться или встроить документ

Параметры публикации

Этот документ был вам полезен?

Это неприемлемый материал?

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

E in A

Загружено:

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

MMC CORPORATION BERHAD GAMUDA BERHAD JOINT VENTURE

D E S I G N / DOCUMENT R E V I E W REQUEST (DRR) S H E E T

Bombardier Global Rail Consortium

NOISE VIBRATION COMPLIANCE MANAGEMENT PLAN

Concept/Prelim/ Detailed/ Tender/ Construction/

29th November 2016

Your Ref. : SSP-BTGR-TRANSMIT-000139

SSP-PDP2-SS01-SYSW-DRR-00045 (Rev 00)

(* Please circle relevant item)

MMC CORPORATION BERHAD GAMUDA BERHAD JOINT VENTURE

D E S I G N / DOCUMENT R E V I E W REQUEST (DRR) S H E E T

Name & Initial

Design/Document / Drawings No.

Name & Initial

Name & Initial

WPCs / Consultants Response

MMC CORPORATION BERHAD GAMUDA BERHAD JOINT VENTURE

D E S I G N / DOCUMENT R E V I E W REQUEST (DRR) S H E E T

Design/Document / Drawings No.

WPC to clarify whether abbreviation for

WPC to include The Planning Guidelines

WPCs / Consultants Response

Included PSD/APG in discussion

Included The Planning Guidelines for Vibration

MMC CORPORATION BERHAD GAMUDA BERHAD JOINT VENTURE

D E S I G N / DOCUMENT R E V I E W REQUEST (DRR) S H E E T

Design/Document / Drawings No.

WPCs / Consultants Response

Table 3: List of References ~ Standards

WPC to remove Ministry of Housing and

Removed Ministry of Housing and Local

5.3 Environmental Roles and

Content in this section looks identical to

Rewritten the section

WPC to rewrite this section and elaborate

MMC CORPORATION BERHAD GAMUDA BERHAD JOINT VENTURE

D E S I G N / DOCUMENT R E V I E W REQUEST (DRR) S H E E T

Design/Document / Drawings No.

WPCs / Consultants Response

to noise and vibration management for PD,

6 CONSTRUCTION NOISE AND

All subsections under section 6 are poorly

What are the source of noise or

Rewritten and restructured Section 6

Please refer to Section 6

MMC CORPORATION BERHAD GAMUDA BERHAD JOINT VENTURE

D E S I G N / DOCUMENT R E V I E W REQUEST (DRR) S H E E T

Design/Document / Drawings No.

WPCs / Consultants Response

vibration expected from WPCs activities?

Please refer to Section 1.2 on last paragraph

What are the proposed arrangement of

No monitoring will be done as the noise and

What are the propose arrangement on

MMC CORPORATION BERHAD GAMUDA BERHAD JOINT VENTURE

D E S I G N / DOCUMENT R E V I E W REQUEST (DRR) S H E E T

Design/Document / Drawings No.

WPCs / Consultants Response

environment monitoring by WPC?

WPC to clarify methodology in this

Methodology to control the noise/vibration

MMC CORPORATION BERHAD GAMUDA BERHAD JOINT VENTURE

D E S I G N / DOCUMENT R E V I E W REQUEST (DRR) S H E E T