Case 6:10-cv-00417-RWS Document 1071 Filed 11/22/16 Page 1 of 4 PagelD #: 42180 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION Judge Robert W, Schroeder III VIRNETX INC., et al v. CIVIL NO. 6:10¢v417 APPLE INC. MINUTES FOR POST-TRIAL MOTIONS HEARING HELD BEFORE JUDGE ROBERT W. SCHROEDER III NOVEMBER 22, 2016 OPEN: 9:00 am, ADJOURN: ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFFS: _ See Attorney Sign-In Sheet ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANTS: See Attorney Sign-In Sheet LAW CLERK: Jenna Rea Deneault COURTROOM DEPUTY: Betty Schroeder COURT REPORTER: ‘Amanda Leigh 9:00am Case called, parties announced ready, Court welcomes parties 9:03 am Mr. John Summers argues VimetX’s Request for a Finding of Willfulness (dkt. #1047) 9:21am Court questions Mr. Summers; Mr. Summers responds 9:24am Court questions Mr. Summers; Mr. Summers responds 9:34am Court questions Mr. Summers; Mr. Summers responds 9:37am Court questions Mr. Summers; Mr. Summers responds 9:38 am Mr. John Desmarais respondsCase 6:10-cv-00417-RWS Document 1071 Filed 11/22/16 Page 2 of 4 PagelD #: 42181 9:43 am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds 9:51 am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds 9:59 am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds 10:12am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds 10:18am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds 10:24am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr, Desmarais responds 10:29am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds 10:36am Break 10:46am Mr. Summers replies 11:02am Mr, Desmarais responds 11:06am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds 11:09am Mr. Summers replies 11:14am Mr. Chris Stewart argues VimetX’s Motion for Entry of Judgment and Equitable and Statutory Relief (dkt. #1063) (Enhanced Damages) 11:25am Court questions Mr. Stewart; Mr. Stewart responds 11:29am Courtroom sealed 11:29am Court questions Mr. Stewart; Mr. Stewart responds 11:36am Courtroom unsealed 11:38am Mr. Greg Arovas responds 11:46am Court questions Mr. Arovas; Mr. Arovas responds 11:54am Mr, Stewart requests the courtroom to be sealed; Mr. Arovas responds; Court, responds 12:13 pm Mr. Stewart replies 12:22 pm Mr, Arovas respondsCase 6:10-cv-00417-RWS Document 1071 Filed 11/22/16 Page 3 of 4 PagelD #: 42182 12:28 pm 12:29 pm 1:33 pm 1:51 pm 1:55 pm 2:03 pm 2:14 pm 2:20 pm 2:42 pm 3:01 pm 3:05 pm 3:15 pm 3:17 pm 3:22 pm 3:23 pm 3:24 pm 3:35 pm 3:38 pm 3:58 pm 4:16 pm 4:19 pm 4:21 pm Mr. Stewart replies Break Ms. Jeannie Heffernan argues Apple’s Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law (dkt. #1062) (damages) Ms. Heffernan argues Apple’s Motion for New Trial (damages) Court questions Ms. Hefffeman; Ms. Heffernan responds Court questions Ms. Heffernan; Ms. Heffernan responds Mr. Jason Cassady responds to the Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law Court questions Mr. Cassady; Mr. Cassady responds Mr. Daniel Pearson responds to the Motion for New Trial Mr. Brad Caldwell responds Ms. Heffernan replies ‘Mr. Pearson responds Mr. Cassady responds ‘Ms, Heffernan replies Mr. Cassady responds Break ‘Mr, Robert Appleby argues Apple’s Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law and New Trial (non-infringement) Court questions Mr. Appleby: Mr. Appleby responds ‘Mr. Austin Curry responds Mr. Appleby replies Mr. Curry responds ‘Mr. Appleby repliesCase 6:10-cv-00417-RWS Document 1071 Filed 11/22/16 Page 4 of 4 PagelD #: 42183 Mr. Curry responds Mr. Joseph Loy argues Apple's Motion for New Trial Regarding Prejudicial FaceTime Relay Redesign Mr, Caldwell responds Mr. Loy replies Mr, Caldwell responds Mr. Akshay Doaras argues Apple’s Motion for New Trial - Liability Jury Instructions Court questions Mr. Doaras; Mr. Doaras responds Mr. Caldwell responds Mr. Appleby replies Mr. Caldwell responds Mr. Appleby replies Mr. Caldwell responds Mr. Stewart argues VimnetX’s Motion for Attorney's Fees Mr. Arovas responds Mr. Stewart replies Mr. Caldwell replies Mr. Arovas responds Mr, Caldwell replies Court asks for page and line regarding the Van Pelt issue Mr. Pearson argues VirnetX’s Motion for Pre/Post Judgment Interest; will submit the Motion for Costs on paper Court asks the parties to file their slides; Re