Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 40

,

,
, 2016

,
CASE ( )
:
, ,
, ,
- CASE .
.

This publication has been produced with the assistance of the European Union. The contents
of this publication are the sole responsibility of the author and can in no way be taken
to reflect the views of the European Union.

C
1. , ........... 5
2. ..................................... 12
3. .......................... 24
4. ,
:
, .................................... 29
5. : SWOT ...................................................... 34


,
, , ,
. ,
, .
. , , -.
, ,
,
.
, : ) ; )
; )
.
SWOT .

1.


,

1.1.


,

,
.
c ,



. 1990-
,
,
:
,


( 1). 2015
40,1% . ,

25
, 1990 .

. 1.
1, % , 19902015
60

40
30

10

2014

2012

2010

2008

2006

2004

2002

2000

1998

1996

1994

1992

1990

50

20



, ..
,
,
, - .

1
, ,
, ,


44,6% 36,7%
1990 25,9% 17,9% , , 2015 .

90- , ,
2009 ,
.

: ,

2.
2, % , 19932015
120%
100%
80%
60%
40%

20%

2015

2013

2011

2009

2007

2005

2003

2001

1999

1997

1993

1995

00%

: ,

. 3.
, %
, 20012014
8

5
4
3
2
1

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

,

. -,
, .
1991

( 2).
,
80%,
2000- .
,
2004 ,
65% , , - 2000 3. 1999

,
.

.
2014
(3,8%

3
6,7% 2006
10,5% 2014 (http://www.belstat.gov.by/ofitsialnayastatistika/makroekonomika-i-okruzhayushchaya-sreda/
natsionalnye-scheta/godovye-dannye_11/struktura-valovogovnutrennego-produkta-po-vidam-ekonomicheskoi-deyatelnosti/)

6,8% 20114 .),


(2,3%) (0,4%) (. 3).
,
,

( 22% 2011 14,6% 2014 )
(11,1%
2011 ) (3,1% 2014
).4.

: ,

. 4.
,
% , 20012014
0,25

0,2



, . ,

0,15
0,1
0,05

2014

2012

2010

2008

2006

2004

2002

2000

4
-,

2011-2014 .

: , :
(http://belstat.gov.by/)
http://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/).
(http://www.statistica.md/index.php?l=ru)

1. ,

Belarus

Ukraine

Moldova

2005

2014

2005

2014

2005

2014

, %

3.8

3.3

2.3

0.4

0.4

, %

14.6

12

11.1

2.8

3.1

,
%

19.0

14.6

12.3

8.6

2.2

1.9

,
%

29.2

25

21.8

17.4

10.5

7.1

, %

11.3

7.6

6.4

6.3

1.9

8.4

,
%

25.7

6.9

19.6

,
%

11.2

8.3

10.5

5.6

14.4

: , 2015.

2. V4

Czech Republic

Hungary

Poland

Slovakia

2005

2013

2005

2013

2005

2013

2005

2013


, %

32.3

41.0

36.5

37.9

14.6

30.1

45.2


, %

8.0

9.8

7.7

8.5

3.5

5.1

6.5


, % o

28.5

35.1

34.8

38.5

16.0

19.6

28.6

,
%

27.9

32.1

29.6

34.3

19.4

17.8

23.9

29.3

,
%

51.2

55.0

62.0

53.0

39.6

38.4

44.9

57.9


,


.

, , , ,

,
.

2
V4,
: i)
,
; ii)

, ; iii) V4

( ).

, , ,
,

(V4: , ,
). V4
90- 2000- 5.


,
. ,
:

( 5).

31% 2005 24,2%
2014 . 24,2%
2014.

5 . Naurodski, S. (editor), Benc, V., Lacny, V., Lafiuk, I., Valetka,


U. (2016). Machine Industry Report: Comparative Analysis of
Machine Building Industry in Belarus, Moldova, and Ukraine.
Hungarian Academy of Sciences / Central European University

:


(http://belstat.gov.by/)

. 5.
, 2005 2014, %
100
90

19,8

24,2

31,0

24,2

80
70

60
50
40
30

49,3

20

51,5

10

0
2005

2014

:


(http://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/)

. 6.
, 2001 2014, %
100
90
80

26,3

46,7

70

60

26,2

50

20, 4

40
30
20

47,5

10

32,9

0
2001

2014

2000-

, ,

. ,
, 2000-
: )

,
; )

,
.
6
7 -
.


. ,
,


8.
2000-

6
60% 2.
2009 3. 2011 (. Akulich.U., Naurodski,S., Valetka.U. (2015).
Labour and Capital Market in Belarus: equal status for long-run
growth. CASE Belarus Policy Papers, February 2015 (:
http://case-belarus.eu/ wp-content/uploads/2015/04/FINAL-BelarusCapital-and-LM_2015. pdf )
7 , 2011-2012
$600 .

,

(. http://www.belta.by/economics/view/
sberbank-rf-lgotno-prokreditoval-postavki-belorusskoj-tehniki-vrossiju-na-summu-svyshe-600-mln.-97375-2012)
8 InvestUkraine, Deloitte (2012). Machine building industry/
Industry overview (: http://ccipu.org/ua/industry_analy-
sis/machine_building/ )

.
,


.
, ,
,
( 6).
2001 2008
,

2009
,


.
,
,

,
2001 2014 .

,
,
9,


. ,
,

10.
1990-
,
,
( 7).
70% 40%
, ,



30% .

:

(http://www.statistica.md/index.php?l=ru)

. 7.
, 1996 2012,%
100
90

15,4

80

8,8
6,6

70

60

30

27,0

30,9

50
40

1,9

69,1
40,3

20
10
0
1996

2012

9 . Naurodski et al., 2016


10 2

10

1.2.
: ,
,
,
, ,

, 8.


(V4 ,
, ).
V4



.

() V4

,
.



. ,
,
.. ; ;
( ,
);

; ,
,
,
12.

11 Naurodski et al. (2016)

12 Naurodski et al. (2016)


11. , , ,
, .
,

,

,
,

.

. 8.

I. :


II. :


III. :

-

11

2.

2.1. :

:
/ >
> >
BYR >
, ,
,
, , ,
, . 1990

34,2%

, 1995
23,3%. , : )

; )
-
; )

12

,

90- .

2000- ,
( , , ISO 9001
2000- ),
( ,
) .
,

2014 2005 ;

1,6 .

15-20% - ,
.
.

-

,
, ,

,
25 . :
()
.


,
,
, , ,

.
3 .

2015 85%,

16%.
,
,
5 ,
6 ,

158 98 .
, , ,
,
.

(. 3).

: () ,

3. , 2011 2015

2011

2015

2011

2015

2011

2015

962

1122

1031

1084

115

139

, %

81.8

83.5

90.4

89.9

52.5

64.0

, %

13.2

24.8

23.8

26.7

1.6

5.8

149

110

70

54

551

336

, %

12.2

-7.6

11.5

3.5

21.5

-5.1

7.9

6.7

3.5

3.6

4.5

3.0

13.5

13.4

6.7

6.3

6.0

5.1

12.2

13.9

4.9

5.6

11.5

4.9

,
%

, %

, %

13

:
,

. 9.
, 20112014
2,5

.
4,7% 2014 15,2%
2015 .
13 2011-2014
(. 9)
.

2
1,5
1
0,5
0
2011

2012

2013

2014




(.10). 2014



16,5%
15,4% 2015 .
2015
9,9%,
. , 20112013

13,6%.

: ,

. 10.
, % 2010, 20112015
60
40
20
0
-20
-40

14

.
. , (+/-

,

.
4 15 .
: 1998 86,4% , ,
, 76,4% . 2013
90,6%,

3 .. (73,4%). 1998

13 ,
(% ) 1%
(% ).
R = MVA / MI, MVA
(% ), MI
(% )

(77,2%
). , 2013
: 27,5%.
,

( 32,8% 1998
21,3% 2013 ).
(61,2%
62,8%),
8 ..
(43,9% 51,9%) 1998 .
Moodys, ,

, : ,

. ( 5) ,

,
, , .
.

, ,

.

,
.
,

,

.
2015 ,
.




.
(),



.

.


( 11).

15

: (http://comtrade.un.org/)

4. ,
, 1998 and 2013
(HS Code)

1998

2013

+ +

76.4

86.4

100

43.9

61.2

100

32.8

77.2

100

73.4

90.6

100

51.9

62.8

100

21.3

27.5

100

: Moodys (http://moodys.com/)

5.

()


(2013), %


(2013), %

(2013)
, %

25.2

23.5

1.2

0.6

10.6

8.4

0.3

1.9

24.5

7.9

0.5

16.0

10%
510%
, 5%

:
(http://belstat.gov.by/)

. 11.

, 2013, %
100
80

2,5
0,4

1,6
1,6

24,4

25,8

0,1
3,1
11,4

60
40

72,3

71,0

85,4

20
0

16

2.2. :

: ,
(
-
) >
>
>
> (
) >


,
, ,
( , )14. , ,
,
.
,

-

. 70%,

15.

16.
14 InvestUkraine, Deloitte (2012).
15
16
(:
http://www.rbc.ua/rus/news/premer-rf-schitaet-diskrimi- natsionnoydlya-ukrainy-sistemu-15122014081500)

, 70% 90%


.

,
17. 2014 ,
20%,
( ,
) 60%.

,

,
- ( 12).

,
,
, ,

( 13).
, ,
,
.
, , .
17 Saha D., Guicci R., Naumenko D., Kovalchuk A. (2014), Ukrainian
machine building: strategic options and short term measures
in view of trade disruptions with Russia / D. Saha, R. Guicci,
D. Naumenko, A. Kovalchuk. German Advisory Group Institute
for Economic Research and Policy Consulting. 19 p.

17

:

(http://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/)

.12. ,
20102013, %
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
2010

2011

2012

2013


,

,


:

(http://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/)

.13.
, , 2013, %


100

9,4
12,4

80

12,4

6,3

61 9
78,2

14,9

21,2

32,1

20,0

18,9

60
40

53,0

44,0
4,40

59,3

51,6
31,8

79,29

68,7

20
0

2,9

17,99

,
,

7% , .

5,5
.

,
( ,
, ;
, ,
).

- ,


.
,

( , ,
),
. , ,
,
14%

18. ,
2,8% 2009 2,2%
2014 ( 14).

1.
2. ,

3. ,
4.
5.
6.
7.

,


,
18 Kirchner.R., Kravchuk.V., Ries.J. (2015) Foreign Direct
Investments in Ukraine: Past, Present, and Future. German
Advisory Group and Institute for Economic Research and Policy
Consulting Policy Paper Series. PP/02/2015. Berlin/Kyiv, June 2015

18

:
(http://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/

.14.
( ) ,
, 20092014,%
0,35

0,3

0,25
0,2

0,15
0,1

0,05
2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

: ,

.15.

, 20012014
1,8
1,6
1,4
1,2
1


.
, 19, ,
- / ,

20. ,

21,



. , ,
,
, , ,

,

.
22
( 15) ,
2001 ,
.
,
, , -

,

.
,
2,7 ,
.
19 ., , ., .
:
- .
-, 10, 2013, .187-193

0,8
0,6

20 InvestUkraine, Deloitte (2012).


21 . http://carnegie.ru/commentary/
experts/?fa=1057

0,4
0,2

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

22 , ,
(
) 1%
(
). R = MVA / MI, MVA
(% ), MI
(% )

19

.
, , ,
, , ,
. - ,
. , 62% . - 94% , , ,
1% 5% 23.
,

. ,

1,1% 201224 .
,
, , , .
, :
. , , .

.

23 InvestUkraine, Deloitte (2012).


24 Saha D., Guicci R., Naumenko D., Kovalchuk A. (2014), Ukrainian machine building: strategic options and short term measures in view
of trade disruptions with Russia / D. Saha, R. Guicci, D. Naumenko, A. Kovalchuk. German Advisory Group Institute for Economic
Research and Policy Consulting. 19 .

20

2.3.:

: > (
) > 2 25, >
>
> ,

.
,


,

25 2- ,

( ),
1- , ,
,

. 16.
, , 20052014
1,6

1,4

1,2

1
0,8
0,6

.
26 , 2005 2014 (.16).

,

.
2001 ,
, 2000- 27.

, ,
,
2000-
. 2004 , ,

() 2005
,
. ,
,


(DCFTA), 2014 ,
2- 3- 28.
,
, -

0,4
0,2

26
(% )
(% ).

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

27 . 4
28 Introduction to the Automotive Sector, Republic of Moldova/
Invest in Moldova

21

, ,
.
2010
,
,
.
, 29

.
()
, .
, , ,

, , .

2006, 2007 2010 .
.
,
,
.
, 53,1 . USD
2006 315,9 . USD 2012.
, ,
,


30. ,
29
30 ?
/ MoldovaWeek (: http://www.moldova.org/pretenzii-rossii-kmoldavii-okazalis-obosnovannimi-moldaviya-za-nedelyu-3996-rus/ ).

22


2014. ,


. ()

.

. 2013

200 . USD, 7000
31. 2010 ,
. ,

, .
,
1990-

.
: 1990-
2000-,
, 2003 . 2008
(63%)32.
2009 ,
2011 (74%).
20082009 ,
,
, 31 :
? 93, 2014 (: http://www.
businessclass.md// Svobodnie_ekonomicheskie_zoni_/ )
32

.
2001 .
,
,

.
. ,
, , .


,
33.
. 1998 ,

(77,2%
). 2013

27,5%.
: 21,3%

2013 (
32,8% 1998 ).
,

.
,
34. ,
,

. 200 .
USD35. ,
33 Kolesnikova I. WTO Accession and Economic Development:
Experience of Newly Acceded Countries and Implications for
Belarus, 2013 (accessed at http://www.case-research.eu/
sites/default/files/WTO%20Accession%20and%20Economic%20
Development%20Experience%20of%20Newly%20Acceded%20
Countries%20and%20Implications%20for%20Belarus_1.pdf )
34 ?
/ MoldovaWeek (: http://www.moldova.org/pretenzii-rossii-kmoldavii-okazalis-obosnovannimi-moldaviya-za-nedelyu-3996-rus/ ).
35 POZI IA INVESTI IONAL INTERNA IONAL A REPUBLICII
MOLDOVA LA 30.06.2015. National Bank of Moldova (:
http://www.bnm.org/files/attachments/na_pii_0.pdf )


11,2%, , 52,1%36.



-.
, ,
, .
35%


,
40% 15%
37.
, ,

2001
.
,
,
,

,

.
,

. , ,

,

.

36
37 -
(: (http://tiraspol.ru/en/news/vitseprezident-tpp-pmr- yuriy-ganin-i-posol-velikobritanii-v-rm-fil-batsonobsudili-problemyi- vneshney-torgovli/ )

23

3.








, , .
,



.

.
, ,
.
, .


,
,
.
, ,
, ,
, , -

24

,
38. ,
,

, ,
,
,
.


, ,
. : ) -
; )
;
)
; )
, .

38 . Baldersheim, et al. (1996)

: , .

6. ,
, ,

V4:

9,5 . (2009)

45.5 . (2014)

3,6 . (2012)

10.4 .(2011)

I : 1 +
6
II : 128 -
(118 + 10
)
III : 1191 -

(1167
+ 10

+ 14 )

I : 2
+ 1 .. 1+
24
II : 668 -
(490 + 178
)
III : 11520
-
(10279 + 783

+
458
)

I : 2 +
1 ATU
II : 32



III : 896 -

I : 1 +
13 -

II: 6253 -

< 1000

< 500

< 1000

<500

, % ,
(2012), :

0.2

1.7

0.85

1.6


, %

0.1

0.8

0.35

0.4

0.1

0.9

0.5

1.2


, %
3

1.4

0.7

0.7

2.5

0.18

0.09


, .

41,7

52.7

75

1 2014 , ,
, , .
2 , , ,
.
3

25

, -
,
.
, -

39.
6, ,
, - ,
-
.

2013 - () .


40. ,

15,7% 1346 116341.

, 201442
2015-2016 .
, 100 (
490 ) 39 .
.
,

, 87268-.
40 168
12.04.2013
25%.

26


1500 ( 11,5 ).
2016 ,
,

43.
, ,
, 1998-1999
, 2001-2003
, ,

. ,
2012-2013

,
.
, , ,
.

,
, ,
,
. ,

,
.
2014 2015
,
44.

41 2009
,
2016, : www.
belstat.gov.by

43 ,
16 2016
1,7 (. http://decentralization.gov.ua/
news/item/id/3458)

42
, 1
2014 , 333.

44 . Martinez-Vazquez, J., 2013. Tax Assignments at the Regional


and Local Levels, in E. Ahmad and G. Brosio (eds.) Handbook on
Fiscal Decentralization. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, U.K.

, ,
,

( ). 2015
(
).
(
, 6),
(

) (
).


). ()



.

( ).

,

( ) .

(
).



,
,
.



.
,

,

45.


. Eckard,
Martinez-Vasquez,

.

, ,
(,
)
46. 6 ,
()
,
.

,
, ,
,


,

( , 45 ,
, .
18% (.
Eckard, Martinez-Vasquez, Tmofeev, 2014. Efficiency cost of fiscal
equalization: the case of Belarus. ICPP Working Paper 14-01).

46 , 2014. 87268-MD

27

47.



.
2013
.
,
,
- ( ),
,
48.



.
,
.

.

,
( ) ,
.
,
.
, ,
1990-

.
47 , 2013.
.
48 , 2014. 87268-MD.

28

49 ,

( )
.




.
, 50,
,
51. ,
1991 V4

500 .

,
. ,

.
,

.

49 1995 , 2000,
2006, 2009
50 , 1053
,
2500
51 , () 2014
13 . ,
(
) 200 ..

4.


,

: -
,

,

,

. ,

1991 ,
, ,
,
. 52 ( )

(. 17),

.


, . ,
,
52 1 4,
1
-
4 +
(. ebrd.com)

.
,
, ,

1,7 2,2
.



.
,

: ( ), ,
(. 7).
,
,
, . 2,

29

. 17. ,

04

05
04

03

03

02

02
01

01

00

2013

2011

2009

2007

2005

2003

2001

1999

1997

1995

1993

1991

1989

2013

2011

2009

2007

2005

2003

2001

1999

1997

1995

1993

1991

1989

00

05





04
03
02
01

2013

2011

2009

2007

2005

2003

2001

1999

1997

1995

1993

1991

1989

00



.
, ,

,
.


. , -

30


, ,
.
,
-, ,
(. 2).

, ,

,
.
V4 ,
, , 53.
,

V4, : i) ; ii) ; iii)
. ,
V4 ,
54. ,
,
, , ,
( , ,
), (,
),

.

,
,
(
, , ).

V4

,
, ,
.
,
V4 , ,
,
53 . Naurodski et al. (2016)
54 . http://www.ebrd.com/what-we-do/economic-researchand-data/data/forecasts-macro-data-transition-indicators.html,
26 , 2016

, ,

. -, (

, )
.



,
. -,

, ,
,
, , .
,

(,
) (,

)
V4,
.


,
1991 ,

,

.
-

31

, , ,
.
2010 114,6 (23,8%)

; 54,3 (19,2%) ;
1,3 (15,1%) .
,

(. 1).
, ,
,

. ,
,

:
)

,

;
) ,
, .



.
,

. ,


.
V4 , ,

32

(. 2).

,
.


() ,
.
158
166
,

. ,

,
,
, ,
. ,


, ,
,
, ,
.. ,
-
55.
-
,
55 ., , Starcher, G. Socially responsible enterprise
restructuring. Joint working paper of the ILO and the EBBF.
Geneva: ILO, 1999; or Serving Workers in Transition: A guide to
Peer Support. Human Resources Development Institute, 1995;
Socially Sensitive Enterprise Restructuring in Asia: Country
Context and Examples / ed. by N. Rogovsky and R.S. Schuler.
Tokyo: Asian Productivity Organization, 2007.

- .

. -
, ,
,
,
56.
,
, - ,
.

.
-
, .

,

30 ,
, . 57, ,

56 ,

. . (2013)
57 . :
(
1989 240 ,
205 41 );
(
415 . 1989 216 2005);
, 3,7
. 1989 1993 , , ,
300 1990
98 2005

,
.

,
,
, .
,
(), . ,
.
,
:
, ,
;
;
; ; ;
; ; ; ; .

-

. 2,
,
,

, , , .
,


, ,
.


,
.

33

5.

:
SWOT

SWOT
, , . SWOT
,
,
, ,
.
(SO, ST, WO, WT), . ( SO)
( WT).

34

8. (SWOT):

(S)

(W)



()



1. SO
(
)
a)

b)


,

.


.

3. WO
(
)
a)

b)



,
,
.


.


(
)

-






(
)





2. ST
(
)
a)

b)

,
.

. , ,
.

4. WT
( )
a)

( )
b)




.
,

,
, , ,

.

(T)

(O)

35

,
(SO ) . , ,
.
,
. , , WO WT .
- .
.
, , .
, , ,
.

36

9. (SWOT):

(S)

(W)



( , ,
)




,




DCFTA




1. SO
(
)
a)

b)

SO ,



.

.
, SO


.

3. WO
( )
a)


b)

WO.
,

. , ( )

. ,



greenfield brownfield .

( )

-

(

)


2. ST
( )
a)


b)





,
.
.

4. WT
( )
a)


b)

WT
,
.


, , .

(T)

(O)

37

, , , ,
WO WT.
,
. greenfield brownfield
,
58. .
,
.

58 , 83 Doing Business 2016 r ,


44 , 52 . (GCR) 2015-2016
, 79 , 84 . GCR,
CASE Belarus , 55 61 2012-2014 (. http://
case-belarus.eu/index.php/2015/08/gci_belarus/ )

38

10. (SWOT):

(S)





DCFTA




1. SO
( )
a)

b)



.


.

3. WO
( )
a)

b)
greenfield
,
,
, WO.

,
.

.
greenfield
, ,

.



( ,
)

2. ST
( )
a)

, .
.

,
,

.
b)


, (,
,
, (, ..) ).

,
,
.

4. WT
( )
a)
b) .
, ,

,
.


.
, .

(O)

(T)

(W)

, V4 . ,
. , ,
. , ,
, , , .

39

Оценить