Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Sarbacker, Stuart Ray, Samadhi: The Numinous and Cessative in IndoTibetan Yoga (Albany: State University of New York Press, ), xi +
pp., ., ISBN .
This book is an expanded and revised version of the authors doctoral
dissertation completed at the University of Michigan in . It includes,
as chapters three and five, two reworked articles previously published in
academic journals.
As clearly defined by Sarbacker, the books goal is to develop a new
methodological approach to the study of yoga and meditation in the context of Hinduism and Buddhism, i.e. one that tries to balance both psychological and sociological standpoints in the study of religion. This approach
as one may expect given the title of the bookis developed through
the paradigm of the numinous and cessative dimensions of yoga, which
roughly corresponds to the ecstasis vs. enstasis dichotomy coined by Mircea
Eliade. According to the authors own words (p. ), the numinous represents the manner in which a practitioner of yoga embodies the worldsurmounting power of divinity, while the cessative dimension emphasizes
the attainment of freedom through separation from phenomenal existence.
The author finds this methodological orientation to be the key to a significantly more sophisticated understanding of the relationship of Classical
Yoga and Buddhism (p. ). An attempt is made to link the tensionand
not real oppositionexisting between the qualities of numinous and cessative to that existing between the categories of samapatti and nirodha in
the context of Classical Yoga, and of samatha and vipasyana in the Buddhist
Mahayana context. A fundamental point in Sarbackers analysis is the idea
that samadhi is composed by both numinous and cessative aspects, against
previous characterizations, such as that by Eliade, stressing the enstatic
element only.
Sarbacker devotes a large part of the introductionwhich I found engaging and thought-provokingto contextualize the object of his research,
i.e. meditation, taking into account the theoretical issues that have been
object of debate in the field of Religious Studies since the pioneering work
of Eliade. Starting from the characterization of contemporary attitudes
towards meditation, the author declares his intention to overcome the
polarization between empathetic and critical approaches to the study of
religion through the development of an integrative and interdisciplinary
approach, which would eventually make that discipline act as a medium
for social and cultural renewal (p. ). He then declares his study to be
Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden,
DOI: 10.1163/001972409X12645171002054
Buddhist
sources such as the Abhidharma.
The above themes are tackled in the usual way implemented through the
book, i.e. by synthesizing the theories of previous scholars one after another.
In this respect, the author has been successful in surveying in a clear and
informative way the academic dialectic from the early th century up to
nowadays. The long citations of the theories developed by previous scholars
that characterize so many pages of Sarbackers book are no doubt useful, but
not always well balanced with the exposition of the authors own views. I
found this defect to be particularly evident in chapter three Yoga, Shamanism, and Buddhism, in which the juxtaposition of the theories of Eliade,
Lewis and the ones by the author is often confusing. On the other hand, in
such (few) cases where Sarbacker appears to draw his own conclusions, he
often does so by way of approval or criticism toward previous works of other
scholars, keeping the citation of original sources to a minimum. As a student of Sanskrit texts, I found this aspect to be the most serious flaw of the
book. I believe, in fact, that the authors claims to a revolution in the current interpretation of Hindu and Buddhist yoga through the numinouscessative paradigm are often not suciently backed up with evidence gathered from textual sources, which are in any case essentially limited to the
seminal Yogasutra of Patajali and the Bhavanakrama of Kamalasla. Given
the general scope of the book and wide-ranging analysis attempted by the
author, this limitation is hardly acceptable. Even those two sources could
have been put to a better use, for example by actually quoting passages
enlightening the non-specialist reader about technicalities of yoga that are
referred to at every corner but not suciently explained or contextualized,
or by reading problematic passages of the Yogasutra in the light of the most
significant commentaries besides the Yogasutrabhasya.
Another fundamental handicap is the authors choice to not take into
account in his studynot even in an endnoteimportant systems of
yoga, such as the yoga of six ancillaries (sadangayoga)as opposed to
atajala yoga)widespread
the yoga of eight ancillaries (astan gayoga, i.e. P
texts. The authors failure to mention the
in Saiva
and Buddhist (Tantric)
existence of sadangayogaon which a significant amount of literature has
Zigmund-Cerbu ; Pensa ; Grnbold ;
been written (see
Sferra )is hardly justifiable, especially when he tries to limit his
scope and define which yoga he is referring to in his work, contrasting
it to Upanisadic yoga and hathayoga only (p. ). This is especially true
in view of the programmatic statements made by the author to revisit
Tantric sadhana on the basis of the numinous-cessative paradigm that is
applied to Classical and Buddhist Yoga, without taking into account the
fact that the overwhelming majority of Tantric sources of both aliations
only knew about sadangayoga (on the other hand, it is not clear what is
: Saivite
thinkers saw dhyana as a method to reach the absolute, which
Sanderson, Alexis, . History through Textual Criticism in the Study of Saivism, the Pacaratra and the Buddhist Yogintantras, in Grimal, F. (ed.), Les
sources et le temps. A colloquium. Pondicherry, January . Pondicherry: Institut Franais de Pondichry-Ecole Franaise dExtrme Orient.
Seyfort Ruegg, David, . A note on the Relationship between Buddhist and
Hindu Divinities in Buddhist Literature and Iconology: the laukika/lokottara
Contrast and the Notion of an Indian Religious Substratum , in Le parole e i
marmi. Studi in onore di Raniero Gnoli nel suo compleanno, pp. .
Serie Orientale Roma XCII. Roma: ISIAO.
Sferra, Francesco, . The Sadangayoga by Anupamaraksita. With Ravisrjanas
tippan. Serie Orientale Roma LXXXV. Roma:
gunabharannama-sadangayoga
ISIAO.
Zigmund-Cerbu, A., . The Sadan gayoga, History of Religions , pp. .
A A
Leiden University