Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Park,
Soon-Ok
Choi,
Hee-Jung
Taegu,
Lee,
Republic
&&ground/Purpose:
The authors
evaluated
prospectively
the utility
of ultrasonography,
Tc-99m-DISIDA
hepatobiliary
scintigraphy,
and liver needle
biopsy
in differentiating
biliary
atresia
(BA) from
intrahepatic
cholestasis
in 73 consecutive
infants
who had cholestasis.
Methods:
Sixty
three
ultrasonographic
examinations
of 61
infants
with 7.0-MHz
transducer
were carried
out, focusing
on
the fibrous
tissue
at the porta
hepatis.
The authors
defined
the triangular
cord (TC) as visualization
of a triangular
or
tubular
shaped
echogenic
density
just cranial
to the portal
vein bifurcation
on a transverse
or longitudinal
scan.
Results:
Although
17 of 20 ultrasonographic
examinations
from
infants
who had BA denoted
TC, 43 ultrasonographic
examinations
from infants
with either neonatal
hepatitis
(NH)
or other
causes
of cholestasis
denoted
no TC, showing
a
diagnostic
accuracy
of 95% with 85% sensitivity
and 100%
specificity.
Investigation
with Tc-99m-DISIDA
hepatobiliary
scintigraphy
showed
that 24 of 25 infants
who had BA had no
gut excretion,
and 16 of 46 infants
who had either NH or other
causes
of cholestasis
had gut excretion,
showing
a diagnostic
accuracy
of 56% with
96% sensitivity
and 35% specificity.
Therefore,
gut excretion
of tracer
excluded
BA, but no gut
excretion
of tracer
needed
further
investigations
as liver
needle
biopsy.
Forty-four
liver
needle
biopsies
were
carried
out in 19
infants
who had BA and 24 infants
who had either NH or other
of Pediatric
Surgery,
%I 32, No 11 (Novem
her),
1997: pp 1555-1559
Sang-Pyo
Kim,
Seok-Kil
Zeon,
and
Sang-Lak
Lee
of Korea
causes
of cholestasis.
Although
18 of 20 biopsy
findings
in
infants
who had BA were correctly
interpreted
as having
BA,
23 of 24 biopsy
results
in infants
who had either NH or other
causes
of cholestasis
were
correctly
diagnosed,
showing
a
diagnostic
accuracy
of 93% with 90% sensitivity
and 96%
specificity.
Conclusions:
Since the introduction
of ultrasonographic
TC
sign in the diagnosis
of BA by our institution,
we have found
that it seemed
to be a simple,
time-saving,
highly
reliable,
and non-invasive
tool in the diagnosis
of BA from
other
causes
of cholestasis.
The authors
propose
a new diagnostic
strategy
in the evaluation
of infantile
cholestasis
with emphasis on ultrasonographic
TC sign as first priority
of investigations.
When
the TC is visualized,
prompt
exploratory
laparotomy
is mandatory
without
further
investigations.
When
the TC is not visualized,
hepatobiliary
scintigraphy
is the next
step. Excretion
of tracer
into the small bowel
actually
rules
out BA. Liver needle
biopsy
is reserved
only for the infants
with no excretion
of tracer. The authors
believe
that a correct
decision
regarding
the need for surgery
can be made
in
almost
all cases with infantile
cholestasis
by this multidisciplinary
approach.
J Pediatr Surg 32:1555-7559.
Copyright
o 1997 by W.B. Saunders
Company.
INDEX WORDS:
Biliary
nography,
hepatobiliary
atresia,
infantile
scintigraphy,
cholestasis,
liver
needle
ultrasobiopsy.
The aim of this study is to reassess the relative accuracy and the role of ultrasonography (US), hepatobiliary
scintigraphy (HS), and liver needle biopsy (NBx) with
particular emphasis on ultrasonographic TC in differentiating BA from other causes of intrahepatic cholestasis
1556
PARK ET AL
AND
METHODS
Seventy-three
consecutive
infants who were suspected of having BA,
neonatal hepatitis (NH), or other causes of cholestatic
jaundice
were
evaluated prospectively,
using US, HS, or NBx during the period from
March 1992 to October 1996 at the Departments
of Pediatric Surgery,
Radiology,
Pathology,
Nuclear
Medicine,
and Pediatrics,
Keimyung
University
Dongsan Medical Center. Choledochal
cyst was excluded in
this study. The patients undergoing
study ranged in age from 12 to 120
days. The infants presented with conjugated
hyperbilirubinemia
(direct
bilirubin, 2 mg% or more) or clay-colored
stool. The averages of total
and direct serum bilirubin
level were 10.9 mg/dL and 6.3 mg/dL,
respectively.
US examinations
were carried out by one of the authors (HJL),
focusing on the fibrous tissue at the porta hepatis. We defined the TC
sign as visualization
of a triangular or tubular shaped echogenic density
just cranial to the portal vein bifurcation
on a transverse or longitudinal
scan (Fig 1). ACUSON
XP-10 ultrasound
equipment
(Acuson, Mountain View, CA) with a 7.0-MHz
transducer
was used in the majority
of
the infants. As described in our previous reports,11.12 the presence of TC
was interpreted
as having BA, and absence of TC was interpreted
as
having NH or other causes of cholestasis.
During the US studies, we
also measured the size and shape of the gallbladder,
its contractility
after feeding, and the dilatation
of the intra- and extrahepatic
biliary
duct. To evaluate the presence of the gallbladder. the infant fasted for at
least 4 hours.
Tc-99m-DISIDA
hepatobiliary
scintigraphy
(HS) was performed
after a 3- to 5-day course of phenobarbital
pretreatment
(5 mg/kg/d).
ULTRASONOGRAPHIC
TRIANGULAR
CORD
IN BA
Table 2. Diagnostic
Accuracy
of Tc-99m-DISIDA
Hepatobiliary
Scintigraphy
improvement,
(2) hepatocellular
degeneration
without portal change in
liver biopsy specimen or evidence of clinical improvement
of 3 months
or more follow-up,
and (3) patent extrahepatic
bile ducts noted via
cholangiography.
The 73 infants turned out to be composed
of 25 cases
with BA, 42 cases with NH, 5 cases with total parenteral
nutrition
(TPN)-associated
cholestasis,
and one case with Alagille syndrome.
Seventy-one infants underwent Tc-99m-DISIDA hepatobiliary scintigraphy. Twenty-four of 25 infants who had
BA had no gut excretion, and 16 of 46 infants who had
either NH or other causes of cholestasis had gut excretion, denoting a diagnostic accuracy of 56% with 96%
sensitivity and 35% specificity (Table 2). The mean direct
bilirubin concentration of the infants with intrahepatic
cholestasis was 5.4 mg/dL for those without gut excretion
of tracer and 4.3 mg/dL for those with gut excretion,
respectively.
Pecutaneous Liver Needle Biopsy
Forty-three infants underwent 44 needle biopsies. The
majority of the infants (42 of 43 infants) showed no
excretion of tracer in 24 hours on Tc-99m-DISIDA
NOTE.
Sensitivity,
1. Accuracy
of Diagnosis
of Biliary
Atresia
Biliary
atresia
Neonatal
NOTE.
(n = 20)
hepatitis
Sensitivity,
and other
(n = 43)
85%; specificity,
Accuracy
of Percutaneous
TC
Negative
17
0
3
43
100%; accuracy,
95%.
Liver
Interpretation
of US
TC
Positive
56%
DISCUSSION
by Ultrasonography
lnterm3tation
16
35%; accuracy,
Table 3. Diagnostic
Table
30
96%; specificity,
Scan
Neonatal
Hepatitis/Other
24
(n = 46)
Ultrasonography
by Hepatobiliary
Biiiary
Atresia
RESULTS
Tc-99mDISIDA
Interpretation
Biliary
Atresia
Sensitivity,
Needle
of Needle Biopsy
Neonatal
Hepatitis/Other
18
1
90%; specificity,
96%; accuracy,
Biopsy
23
93%.
PARK ET AL
diagnostic accuracy of these tests, none has been constantly reliable. Therefore, a multidisciplinary approach
to the evaluation of infantile cholestasis is required.
Ultrasonography is a simple and noninvasive procedure that has been used in all cases with infantile
cholestasis as a first step in the work-up of these patients.
An abdominal US is useful in the detection of a choledochal cyst, but it is not so helpful in differentiating BA
from NH or other causes of intrahepatic cholestasis. Most
investigators have focused on the shape or change in size
of the gallbladder.4-*0 Nonvisualization of the normal
gallbladder was thought to suggest BA,4-10 but this may
occur in association with both BA and severe intrahepatic
cholestasis.4,xFurthermore, several investigators have
documented BA cases with a normal gallbladder as seen
in three of 25 infants who had BA in our study. Although
the gallbladder is usually small or nonvisible in BA, a
normal gallbladder does not exclude the diagnosis of BA.
Conversely, nonvisualization of the gallbladder does not
exclude the diagnosis of NH or other intrahepatic cholestatic disorders.
Green and Carroll6 and Ikeda et al have suggested that
BA can be excluded when the change in the gallbladder
size is observed after feeding on serial US examinations.
Although in infants who have BA, the gallbladder is
usually small and difficult to identify, it is not surprising
to demonstrate the contractility of the gallbladder after
feeding, because a patent bile duct from the gallbladder to
the duodenum can be seen in 19% to 22% of cases.2,3,5
Three of 25 BA infants demonstrated contractility of the
gallbladder after feeding in this study. We believe that
ultrasonographic evaluation of the gallbladder shape,
size, and contractility is not such a reliable test for the
differentiation of BA from intrahepatic cholestasis.
With the development of high-resolution gray-scale
recording and real-time imaging technique with 7.0 MHz
or 10 MHz transducer, we recently reported the sonographic feature of a fibrous cone at the porta hepatis as a
triangular-shaped or tubular-shaped echogenic density
just cranial to the portal vein bifurcation on transverse or
longitudinal scan. 11-12The echogenic density was confirmed to represent the fibrous remnant in the porta
hepatis of BA cases at surgery. We named this echogenic
density the triangular cord (TC). Although we are still in
a learning period, the TC appears to be a very specific
ultrasonographic finding representing the fibrous cone in
BA cases, showing overall diagnostic accuracy of 95%
with 85% sensitivity and 100% specificity on the basis of
our study. A very experienced and enthusiastic radiologist
is indispensible for precise interpretation of the TC.
In light of our experience, there can be pitfalls with this
proposal. False-negative TC may occur in some BA
infants because of the patterns of unusual hepatic radicles
such as hypoplastic, aplastic, or fibrous hepatic ducts,3
and in the early stage of some BA cases. The fibrotic
ULTRASONOGRAPHIC
TRIANGULAR
CORD
1559
IN BA
Tc-99m-DISIDA hepatobiliary scintigraphy. Our diagnostic accuracy rate of 93% is similar to those of previous
reports.17J1.Z3Although NBx is considered to be a very
valuable test with a diagnostic accuracy of over 93%,17.1.23
NBx biopsy is invasive and can be misleading in certain
cases.17,21,22.24,25
If it is performed before 4 to 8 weeks of
age in infants who have BA, it may not show the
characteristic ductal proliferation or portal fibrosis24.25
necessitating a second biopsy as demonstrated in our two
false-negative cases. False-positive results can occur in
some cholestatic liver diseases such as bile plug syndrome, alpha-1-antitrypsin deficiency, and some neonatal
hepatitis.i7-*I We also experienced one false-positive case
of TPN-associated cholestasis that showed mild ductal
proliferation (3 to 4 ducts per one portal area). In these
cases, we have to evaluate infants who have cholestatic
jaundice in the context of clinical and laboratory data.
Since the introduction of the TC sign on US in the
diagnosis of BA by our institution, we found that it
seemed to be a simple, time saving, highly reliable, and
noninvasive tool in the diagnosis of BA from other causes
of cholestasis. The authors would like to propose a new
diagnostic strategy in the evaluation of infantile cholestasis. When the TC is visualized on US, prompt exploratory
laparotomy is mandatory without further investigations.
BILIARY ATRESIA
VS INTRAHEPATIC
CHOLESTASIS
1
Ultrasonography
Triangular A cord (+)
I
surgery
-k&i,,
cord (-)
I
Tc-99m-DISIDA
Excretion
into intestine
1
Conservative
\
into intestine
1
Liver Needle Biopsy
Rx
Neonatal
Rx)
H-----l\
hepatitis
Inconclusive
1
Optional
Biliary atresia
I
surgery
Fig 2. Algorithm
for workup
of infantile
cholestasis.
*Optional:
Minilaparotomy
or laparoscopy
is advised in older infants (more than
8 weeks)
but repeat ultrasonography,
liver biopsy, or hepatobiliary
scan are mandatory
in 2 weeks in younger
infants (less than 8 weeks).
REFERENCES
1, Kasai M, Kimura S. Asakura Y, et al: Surgical treatment of biliary
atresia. J Pediatr Surg 3:665-675,
1968
2. Karrer FM: Lilly JR. Stewart BA; et al: Biliary atresia registry,
1976 to 1989. J Pediatr Surg 25:1076-1081,
1990
3. Ohi R, Ibrahim M: Biliary atresia. Sem Pediatr Surg 1:115-124,
1995
4. Abramson
SJ, Treves S, Teele RL: The infant with possible biliary
atresia: Evaluation
by ultrasound
and nuclear medicine. Pediatr Radio1
12:1-5, 1982
5. Brun F, Gauthier
F, Doucher
D, et al: Ultrasound
findings in
biliary atresia in children. Ann Radio1 28:259-263,
198.5
6. Green D, Carroll BA: Ultrasonography
in the jaundiced infant: A
new approach. J Ultrasound
Med 5:323-329,
1986
7. Ikeda S, Sera Y, Akagi M: Serial ultrasonic
examination
to
differentiate
biliary atresia from neonatal hepatitis-special
reference to
change in size of the gallbladder.
Eur J Pediatr 148:396-400,
1989
8. Altman RP, Abramson
S: Potential errors in the diagnosis
and
surgical management
of neonatal jaundice. J Pediatr Surg 20:529-534,
1985
9. Kirks DR. Coleman RE, Filston HC, et al: An imaging approach to
persistent neonatal jaundice. Am J Roentgen01 142:461-465,
1984
10. Weinberger
E, Blumhagen
JD, Ode11 JM: Gall bladder contraction in biliary atresia. Am J Roentgen01 149:401-402.
1987
11. Choi SO, Park WH; Lee HJ. et al: Triangular
cord:
A
sonographic
finding applicable
in the diagnosis
of biliary atresia. J
Pediatr Surg 3 1:363-366,
1996
12. Choi SO, Park WH, Lee HJ: Ultrasonographic
Triangular
cord: The most definite finding for noninvasive
diagnosis of extrahepatic biliary atresia. Eur J Pediatr Surg [in press)
13. Balistreri WF: Neonatal cholestasis.
J Pediatr 106: 17 1-l 84, 1985
14. Majd M, Reba RC, Altman RP: Diagnostic
accuracy of hepatobiliary scintigraphy
with Tc-99m-PIPIDA
questioned.
Pediatrics
68:606607, 1981