Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 8

January 2010 Vol. 16 No.

1
From the publishers of
The New England Journal of Medicine

CA RDI OLOGY
ARBITER 6-HALTS: ezetimibe group and by 10 mg/dL in the important outcomes
A Surprise Knockout niacin group. The mean HDL level de- of large trials of ezetimibe will not be
Niacin’s clear win over ezetimibe as an creased by 3 mg/dL in the ezetimibe group available for many years. In the meantime,
adjunct to statin therapy challenges and increased by 8 mg/dL in the niacin ezetimibe should be a drug of last resort,
assumptions about lipid management. group. if it is used at all.
To compare the effects of niacin versus Niacin, but not ezetimibe, was associ- — Harlan M. Krumholz, MD, SM
ezetimibe when added to statin treatment, ated with a significant reduction in CIMT. Taylor AJ et al. Extended-release niacin or ezetimibe
investigators conducted a randomized, In the ezetimibe group, paradoxically, and carotid intima–media thickness. N Engl J Med
open-label trial with blinded adjudication of greater decreases in LDL levels were asso- 2009 Nov 26; 361:2113.
endpoints. All patients were already taking ciated with greater increases in CIMT.
a statin and had LDL levels <100 mg/dL, The rate of major cardiovascular events ARBs in Heart Failure: What
HDL levels <55 mg/dL, and coronary heart was higher in the ezetimibe group than Difference Does a Dose Make?
disease or a risk equivalent (e.g., diabetes or in the niacin group (5% vs. 1%; P=0.04).
High-dose losartan yielded small but signifi-
a 10-year Framingham risk score of ≥20%). cant improvements in clinical outcomes,
COMMENT
The primary endpoint was change in carotid compared with a lower dose.
In this small trial, niacin was superior to
intima–media thickness (CIMT) after 14
ezetimibe in high-risk patients on statin A growing body of data suggests that
months. The industry-funded, investigator-
monotherapy. These findings do not deliver angiotensin-receptor blocker doses higher
initiated trial was terminated early on the
a final verdict on ezetimibe. (Nor do they than those currently given could achieve
basis of results of prespecified interim
prove that the niacin-statin combination clinical benefits in patients with heart fail-
analysis.
confers clinical benefit beyond statin ure. In the international, double-blind,
A total of 208 participants (mean age, monotherapy in this patient population.) manufacturer-sponsored and manufac-
65; 80% men) had 14-month endpoint However, they add to concerns about a turer-administered HEAAL study, 3846
data. At baseline, mean levels of LDL and medication that continues to be quite patients with NYHA class II–IV heart
HDL were 82 mg/dL and 42 mg/dL, re- popular, despite a lack of evidence that its failure symptoms, LV ejection fractions
spectively. At 14 months, the mean LDL ability to reduce LDL levels translates into ≤40%, and intolerance to ACE inhibitors
level had decreased by 18 mg/dL in the patient benefits. Unfortunately, patient- were randomly assigned to receive either
150 mg or 50 mg of losartan daily. Most
patients were taking standard therapies
CONTENTS for heart failure at enrollment, including
diuretics (76%), beta-blockers (72%),
SUMMARY & COMMENT In-Hospital Mortality After MI: and aldosterone blockers (38%).
ARBITER 6-HALTS: Vive la Différence? ..................................................... 4
A Surprise Knockout ...................................... 1 Self-Management for Hypertension ......................... 5
During a median follow-up of
ARBs in Heart Failure: Lipids, Apolipoproteins, and Vascular Disease:
4.7 years, high-dose losartan significantly
What Difference Does a Dose Make? .................... 1 What to Measure? ..................................................... 5 reduced the rate of the primary composite
Should Patients with Heart Failure Folic Acid and Cancer................................................... 6 outcome of death or hospital admission
“Pump” Iron?............................................................... 2
Revascularization Is Ineffective for heart failure, compared with low-dose
LV Assistance for End-Stage Heart Failure: for Atherosclerotic Renal Artery Stenosis ............ 6
Have We Reached Our Destination? ...................... 2 losartan (43% vs. 46%; P=0.027); both
Two Clopidogrel Loading Doses Compared components of the composite endpoint
Again I Say, Again: Avoid Pacing the in Patients with STEMI .............................................. 6
Right Ventricle! ........................................................... 3 contributed to the overall result. The
Cangrelor Is Not the New Champion......................... 7
Primary PCI for STEMI: How Important composite outcome of death or cardiovas-
Are Hospitals’ Procedure Volumes?....................... 3 CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE WATCH
USPSTF Doesn’t Recommend Using cular admission occurred in 54% of pa-
Reducing Door-to-ECG Time Without
Nontraditional Risk Factors for CHD Risk .............. 7 tients in the high-dose group and in 57%
Increasing ED Staffing............................................... 4
Investigation of Incidental Findings
in the low-dose group. The rate of study-
on Cardiac CT .............................................................. 4 drug discontinuation during follow-up

JOURNAL WATCH (AND ITS DESIGN) IS A REGISTERED TRADEMARK OF THE MASSACHUSETTS MEDICAL SOCIETY.
AN EDITORIALLY INDEPENDENT LITERATURE-SURVEILLANCE NEWSLETTER SUMMARIZING ARTICLES FROM MAJOR MEDICAL JOURNALS. ©2010 MASSACHUSETTS MEDICAL SOCIETY.
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. DISCLOSURE INFORMATION ABOUT OUR AUTHORS CAN BE FOUND AT http://cardiology.jwatch.org/misc/board_disclosures.dtl
2 CARDIOLOGY Vol. 16 No. 1

was substantial (28% and 27% in the Iron recipients were significantly
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Harlan M. Krumholz, MD, SM, Harold H. Hines, Jr.,
high- and low-dose groups, respectively). more likely than placebo recipients to im-
Professor of Medicine, Section of Cardiovascular Adverse events, including hyperkalemia, prove clinically, as measured by the pri-
Medicine, Yale University School of Medicine, hypotension, and renal impairment, mary endpoints — Patient Global Assess-
New Haven
were significantly more common in the ment (odds ratio, 2.51) and NHYA
EXECUTIVE EDITOR
high-dose group than in the low-dose classification (OR, 2.40) — as well as by
Kristin L. Odmark
Massachusetts Medical Society group. health-related quality of life and 6-minute
DEPUTY EDITOR
walk distance. The benefits were apparent
COMMENT
Howard C. Herrmann, MD, Professor of Medicine, by 4 weeks and were similar in patients
Director, Interventional Cardiology and Cardiac
These findings suggest a favorable effect
with and without anemia. Aside from a
Catheterization Laboratories, University of of 150 mg of losartan, compared with
higher rate of injection-site discomfort or
Pennsylvania Medical Center, Philadelphia 50 mg, in patients with systolic heart fail-
discoloration (6 iron recipients vs. zero
ASSOCIATE EDITORS ure, although the benefit came at a cost
JoAnne M. Foody, MD, Director, Cardiovascular
placebo recipients), adverse events did not
of adverse events. As an editorialist points
Wellness Center, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, differ significantly between the two
Boston out, we cannot assume similar results in
groups.
Joel M. Gore, MD, Edward Budnitz Professor patients who can tolerate ACE inhibitors,
of Cardiovascular Medicine, University of and this trial does not compare a high- COMMENT
Massachusetts, Worcester
dose ARB with a high-dose ACE inhibi- In this trial, intravenous ferric carboxy-
Mark S. Link, MD, Associate Professor of Medicine,
New England Medical Center and Tufts University tor. We are well reminded, however, to maltose significantly improved symptoms
School of Medicine, Boston uptitrate all medications to the highest and sense of well-being in patients with
Frederick A. Masoudi, MD, MSPH, Division of efficacious dose (according to the best systolic heart failure, suggesting that iron
Cardiology, Denver Health Medical Center and
Associate Professor of Medicine, University of
available trial evidence), as tolerated by has benefits beyond anemia treatment per
Colorado at Denver the patient. — Joel M. Gore, MD se (e.g., improved muscle energetics). We
Beat J. Meyer, MD, Associate Professor of don’t know if (1) oral iron — considerably
Cardiology, University of Bern; Chief, Division of
Konstam MA et al. Effects of high-dose versus
low-dose losartan on clinical outcomes in patients less expensive and more convenient than
Cardiology, Lindenhofspital, Bern, Switzerland
with heart failure (HEAAL study): A randomised, intravenous iron — confers the same ben-
CONTRIBUTING EDITORS
double-blind trial. Lancet 2009 Nov 28; 374:1840. efits, (2) all intravenous iron preparations
William T. Abraham, MD, Professor of Medicine,
Chief, Division of Cardiovascular Medicine, Krum H. Optimising management of chronic heart are equivalent in this context (ferric car-
The Ohio State University Heart Center, Columbus failure. Lancet 2009 Nov 28; 374:1808. boxymaltose is currently unavailable in
Hugh Calkins, MD, Professor of Medicine and the U.S.), or (3) this therapy benefits pa-
Director of Electrophysiology, The Johns Hopkins
Hospital, Baltimore Should Patients with Heart tients with clinically important renal dys-
FOUNDING EDITOR Failure “Pump” Iron? function, which also commonly causes
Kim A. Eagle, MD, Albion Walter Hewlett Professor anemia. Nonetheless, these provocative
In a randomized trial, intravenous iron
of Internal Medicine and Chief of Clinical findings suggest possible benefits of
Cardiology, Division of Cardiology, University of improved symptoms, even in patients
Michigan Medical Center, Ann Arbor without anemia. screening for and treating iron deficiency
in patients with heart failure — even those
MASSACHUSETTS MEDICAL SOCIETY Anemia is common and associated with
Christopher R. Lynch, Vice President for
without anemia.
adverse outcomes in patients with heart
Publishing; Alberta L. Fitzpatrick, Publisher — Frederick A. Masoudi, MD, MSPH
failure. Iron deficiency is also common in
Betty Barrer, Christine Sadlowski, Sharon S.
Salinger, Staff Editors; Kara O’Halloran, Copy heart failure, sometimes in the absence of Anker SD et al. Ferric carboxymaltose in patients
Editor; Misty Horten, Layout; Matthew O’Rourke, frank anemia. Although results of small with heart failure and iron deficiency. N Engl J
Director, Editorial Operations and Development; Med 2009 Nov 17; [e-pub ahead of print].
trials suggest benefits of iron supplemen- (http://dx.doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa0908355)
Art Wilschek, Christine Miller, Lew Wetzel,
Advertising Sales; William Paige, Publishing tation for iron deficiency in heart failure
Dec GW. Anemia and iron deficiency — New thera-
Services; Bette Clancy, Customer Service patients, definitive evidence has been peutic targets in heart failure? N Engl J Med 2009
Published 12 times a year. Subscription rates per lacking. Nov 17; [e-pub ahead of print]. (http://dx.doi
year: $119 (U.S.), C$166.67 (Canada), US$165 (Intl); .org/10.1056/NEJMe0910313)
Residents/Students/Nurses/PAs: $69 (U.S.), C$96.19 In the manufacturer-sponsored
(Canada), US$80 (Intl); Institutions: $219 (U.S.), FAIR-HF trial, 459 patients with systolic
C$256.19 (Canada), US$230 (Intl); individual print heart failure, iron deficiency, and NYHA LV Assistance for End-Stage
only: $89 (U.S.). Prices do not include GST, HST,
or VAT. In Canada remit to: Massachusetts Medical class II–III symptoms were randomized in Heart Failure: Have We Reached
Society C/O #B9162, P.O. Box 9100, Postal Station F, a 2:1 ratio to receive intravenous ferric car- Our Destination?
Toronto, Ontario, M4Y 3A5. All others remit to:
boxymaltose or placebo. Notably, half of A continuous-flow device achieves impressive
Journal Watch Cardiology, P.O. Box 9085, Waltham,
MA 02454-9085 or call 1-800-843-6356. E-mail the patients had normal baseline hemoglo- results in a randomized trial.
inquiries or comments via the Contact Us page at bin levels, and patients with clinically sig-
JWatch.org. Information on our conflict-of-interest LV assistance has been proposed as per-
policy can be found at JWatch.org/misc/conflict.dtl
nificant renal dysfunction were excluded.
manent, or destination, therapy for pa-
Participants were treated for 24 weeks:
tients with advanced heart failure who are
weekly until estimated iron repletion was
not candidates for cardiac transplantation.
achieved and monthly thereafter.
Findings from the REMATCH trial
January 2010 JWatch.org 3

(JW Cardiol Feb 2002, p. 20, and N Engl Again I Say, Again: Yu C-M et al. Biventricular pacing in patients with
bradycardia and normal ejection fraction. N Engl J
J Med 2001; 345:1435) provided proof of Avoid Pacing the Right Ventricle!
Med 2009 Nov 26; 361:2123.
concept for this approach, demonstrating Findings from yet another study show the
improved survival in end-stage heart detriment of RV pacing.
failure patients randomized to receive a
Biventricular pacing, or cardiac resynchro- Primary PCI for STEMI:
pulsatile-flow LV assist device (LVAD) How Important Are Hospitals’
nization therapy (CRT), has been shown to
versus ongoing medical treatment. However, Procedure Volumes?
benefit patients with reduced LV ejection
survival in the LVAD group was limited Lower-than-recommended procedure
fractions and NYHA class III heart failure
by device complications, including stroke, volume was common but not associated
symptoms and, more recently, those with
infection, and the need for reoperation. In with elevated mortality.
NYHA class I or II symptoms (JW Cardiol
a manufacturer-sponsored, randomized
Oct 2009, p. 77, and N Engl J Med 2009; Guidelines recommend that at hospitals
controlled trial, investigators compared
361:1329). By contrast, although RV-only offering primary percutaneous coronary
an FDA-approved pulsatile-flow LVAD
pacing has long been suspected of causing intervention for patients with ST-segment-
with a second-generation, investigational
LV dysfunction and is thought to have re- elevation MI, at least 36 such procedures
continuous-flow LVAD.
sulted in worsened heart failure in the — and at least 200 angioplasties — should
Two hundred patients with advanced DAVID trial (JW Cardiol Apr 2003, p. 31, be performed per year. To assess the asso-
heart failure who were not considered and JAMA 2002; 288:3115), evidence of its ciation between volume of primary PCI
candidates for cardiac transplantation detrimental effects is relatively scarce. and patient outcomes, investigators identi-
were randomized in a 2:1 ratio to receive fied 29,513 patients hospitalized for STEMI
In a multicenter, manufacturer-
the continuous-flow or the pulsatile-flow who underwent primary PCI at 166 hospi-
sponsored trial of RV pacing versus CRT
LVAD. The primary composite endpoint tals participating in the American Heart
in patients with preserved LV function,
was survival free from disabling stroke and Association’s Get With The Guidelines
177 patients received a CRT device and
device repair or replacement at 2 years. quality-improvement registry from 2001
were randomized to programmed RV-only
Secondary endpoints included survival, through 2007.
or biventricular pacing. The indication for
frequency of adverse events, quality-of-life
pacing was advanced atrioventricular block The participating hospitals’ annual
changes, and functional capacity. Sixty-
in 104 participants (59%) and sinus node primary PCI volumes ranged from 9 to
two patients (46%) in the continuous-flow
dysfunction in 73 (41%). The study proto- 224 and were characterized as high (>70),
group achieved the primary endpoint
col called for obligatory RV pacing in all medium (36–70), or low (<36). Sixty-five
compared with 7 patients (11%) in the
patients assigned to it, even those with percent of hospitals met the guideline rec-
pulsatile-flow group (hazard ratio, 0.38;
intact AV conduction systems. ommendation of 36 procedures per year.
95% confidence interval, 0.27–0.54;
At 12 months of follow-up, the aver- High-volume hospitals had shorter door-
P<0.001). Continuous-flow device recipi-
age percentage of patients with ventricular to-balloon times than medium- or low-
ents had a better actuarial survival rate at
pacing was 98% in the CRT group and volume hospitals (median times, 88, 90,
2 years than pulsatile-flow device recipients
97% in the RV-pacing group (P=0.95). and 98 minutes, respectively). Patients at
(58% vs. 24%; P=0.008), as well as fewer
Mean LVEF was significantly lower in the low-volume hospitals were less likely than
adverse events and device replacements.
RV-pacing group than in the CRT group those at high-volume hospitals to receive
COMMENT (54.8% vs. 62.2%), although no between- smoking-cessation counseling or prescrip-
A new, continuous-flow LVAD is superior group differences were seen in 6-minute tions for aspirin, beta-blockers, and ACE
to the currently available pulsatile-flow de- walk distance, hospitalization for heart inhibitors or angiotensin-receptor blockers
vice at improving morbidity and mortality failure, or quality-of-life measures. at discharge.
in end-stage heart failure patients who are
not candidates for cardiac transplantation. COMMENT JOURNAL WATCH ONLINE
Good candidates for such destination thera- These results add to those of a series of
py are patients with very low LV ejection studies demonstrating the potential detri- • Ring in the new year with our
fractions, advanced heart failure symptoms, ment of RV pacing. However, this study’s exclusive in-depth analysis
and recurrent hospitalization or inotropic findings are weakened by the protocol- of the most important topics
support. — William T. Abraham, MD mandated RV pacing, which is not the in General Medicine in 2009.
standard of care for patients with intact Available January 1.
Slaughter MS et al. for the HeartMate II Investigators.
AV conduction systems, and by the lack of • Coming January 5, only at
Advanced heart failure treated with continuous-flow
left ventricular assist device. N Engl J Med 2009 between-group differences in clinical out- JWatch.org: Year in Review
Dec 3; 361:2241. comes. These results should not change discussions of the most
Fang JC. Rise of the machines — Left ventricular current recommendations, in which pacing important developments in
assist devices as permanent therapy for advanced the right ventricle is avoided if possible, but Psychiatry and in HIV/AIDS
heart failure. N Engl J Med 2009 Dec 3; 361:2282. CRT is not indicated in patients with pre- Clinical Care.
served LV function. — Mark S. Link, MD
JWatch.org/online
4 CARDIOLOGY Vol. 16 No. 1

In-hospital mortality was 3.2% overall, increased significantly from 16% before the ules/cysts). After a mean 18-month
with the lowest rate at the high-volume intervention to 64% after. Median time to follow-up, no indeterminate finding be-
hospitals (3.0%, vs. 3.2% and 3.9% in ECG decreased from 16 to 9 minutes. An came clinically significant, although three
medium- and low-volume hospitals, re- ECG was obtained within 10 minutes in malignancies were diagnosed after sub-
spectively). In an adjusted analysis, mor- none of four patients with ST-segment- sequent diagnostic tests. Noncardiac and
tality did not differ significantly among elevation myocardial infarction before cancer death rates were not significantly
the three groups. Duration of stay was also the intervention and in all seven patients different between patients with and with-
similar in all groups. with STEMI after the intervention. (Two out incidental findings. In all, 164 addi-
STEMI patients before the intervention tional diagnostic tests and procedures
COMMENT
had dehydration or shortness of breath as were performed in the 80 patients with in-
These findings indicate that many hospi-
the chief complaint, whereas all seven determinate or clinically significant inci-
tals do not meet the guideline recommen-
STEMI patients after the intervention had dental findings, including 1 patient who
dations for primary PCI volume. However,
chest pain as the chief complaint.) suffered empyema and abdominal ab-
the researchers failed to detect an associa-
scesses as a complication of transthoracic
tion between volume and patient outcomes COMMENT
biopsy.
in this sample of hospitals, which partici- As ED volume increases, adhering to the
pate in a national quality-improvement 10-minute presentation-to-ECG guideline COMMENT
initiative and comprise about 10% of U.S. for patients with chest pain becomes more This study highlights the dilemma posed
hospitals that offer PCI. We do not know challenging. This simple intervention of- by incidental findings that are a common
whether these results can be generalized to fers a starting point, but the goal must be byproduct of cardiac CT. These findings
other hospitals. ECGs within the 10-minute window for are clinically relevant in only a few cases
— Harlan M. Krumholz, MD, SM 100% of patients. Meeting that goal re- but are associated with real risks and costs
quires constant measurement and adjust- as well as benefits. Editorialists suggest
Kumbhani DJ et al. for the Get With the Guidelines
Steering Committee and Investigators. Association of ment, willingness to deploy or dedicate one way of dealing with the issue: Ask
hospital primary angioplasty volume in ST-segment additional staff, and detailed review of patients about their concerns and prefer-
elevation myocardial infarction with quality and every significant failure. ences and then reconstruct images of and
outcomes. JAMA 2009 Nov 25; 302:2207.
— Diane M. Birnbaumer, MD, FACEP, evaluate noncardiac structures only if
Journal Watch Emergency Medicine patients provide informed consent. In
Reducing Door-to-ECG Time the meantime, as CCT becomes more
Takakuwa KM et al. A method for improving arrival-
Without Increasing ED Staffing to-electrocardiogram time in emergency department widespread, individual clinicians will
chest pain patients and the effect on door-to-balloon continue to struggle with the best way
Training registration clerks to page dedicated
time for ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction. to address “incidentalomas.”
ECG technicians when patients present with
Acad Emerg Med 2009 Oct; 16:921.
chest pain significantly reduced time to ECG. — Kirsten E. Fleischmann, MD, MPH,
Journal Watch General Medicine
Guidelines from the American College of
Cardiology and the American Heart Asso- Investigation of Incidental MacHaalany J et al. Potential clinical and economic
ciation state that an electrocardiogram Findings on Cardiac CT consequences of noncardiac incidental findings on
cardiac computed tomography. J Am Coll Cardiol
should be obtained within 10 minutes after These findings are clinically relevant in only
2009 Oct 13; 54:1533.
patients present with chest pain. These au- a minority of cases and are associated with
risks and costs. Hlatky MA and Iribarren C. The dilemma of inci-
thors evaluated the effect on time to ECG dental findings on cardiac computed tomography.
of an intervention that involved training Cardiac computed tomography (CCT), J Am Coll Cardiol 2009 Oct 13; 54:1542.
registration clerks to page dedicated emer- which is increasingly popular for evaluat-
gency department ECG technicians when ing patients with coronary calcification
patients present with chest pain or other and arterial disease, often produces non- In-Hospital Mortality After MI:
complaints associated with acute coronary cardiac incidental findings. To evaluate Vive la Différence?
syndromes. The technician immediately de- the incidence, clinical importance, and Sex differences in survival to discharge are
livered the ECG to an emergency physician costs of these incidental findings, re- getting smaller.
for interpretation. Before the intervention, searchers studied 966 consecutive patients Previous prospective, observational data
patients were registered by clerks and tri- who underwent CCT during 12 months at from the National Registry of Myocardial
aged by nurses before an ECG was ordered. a single Canadian institution. Infarction (NRMI) have shown that the risk
The authors compared data for 313 Incidental findings were noted in 401 for death after MI is higher in women than
consecutive adult patients who presented patients (41.5%); of these, 12 were deemed in men, particularly in younger patients
with chest pain during the month before to be clinically significant (e.g., 5 thrombi, (N Engl J Med 1999; 341:217). In a new
the intervention and 405 such patients who 1 aortic dissection that was not clinically NRMI study, researchers examined whether
presented during the month after at a single suspected, 1 ruptured breast implant), that sex difference persists.
urban academic emergency department and 68 were deemed to be indeterminate The analysis included 916,380 patients
(ED). The proportion of patients for whom (e.g., 34 noncalcified pulmonary nodules hospitalized with confirmed acute coro-
an ECG was obtained within 10 minutes <1 cm, 11 larger lung nodules, 9 liver nod- nary ischemia from 1994 through 2006.
January 2010 JWatch.org 5

During this period, the prevalence of many telephone calls, with tailored behavioral and North America, with a total popula-
coexisting conditions increased across age counseling focused on medication adher- tion of 300,000 patients and mean follow-
and sex subgroups, and the proportion of ence; thrice-weekly home blood pressure up of about 6 years. Risk for coronary dis-
patients with ST-segment-elevation MI measurement, with values recorded in ease, adjusted for several demographic and
decreased. Diabetes, heart failure, and logs (logs were mailed to primary care clinical risk factors, was associated with
stroke were more prevalent among younger providers every 2 months); both interven- higher values of non-HDL and LDL, higher
women than among younger men. tions; or usual care. Blood pressure con- ratios of non-HDL/HDL and apo B/A1,
Over time, in-hospital mortality rates trol was defined as systolic blood pressure and lower values of HDL. Risks for coro-
declined across the age spectrum, generally (SBP) <140 mm Hg and diastolic blood nary disease and ischemic stroke were not
more in women than in men. The decline in pressure (DBP) <90 mm Hg for patients associated with triglyceride levels, and risk
mortality was most pronounced in women without diabetes, and SBP <130 mm Hg and for ischemic stroke was only weakly associ-
younger than 55 (from 5.1% in 1994–1995 DBP <80 mm Hg for patients with diabetes. ated with HDL or non-HDL levels. No dif-
to 2.4% in 2004–2006). Within the <55 age At 24 months, blood pressure control ference in risk prediction was observed be-
group, the unadjusted female-to-male odds was achieved by 11% more patients in the tween fasting and nonfasting measurements.
ratio for death declined from 1.93 in 1994– combined-intervention group than in the COMMENT
1995 to 1.34 in 2004–2006, although it re- usual-care group. The drop in SBP from Because many physicians have relatively
mained statistically significant. Notably, baseline was also significant only for the easier access to standard cholesterol pro-
multivariable analyses showed that the nar- combined-intervention group (3.9 mm Hg files than to apolipoprotein measurements,
rowing of the risk between young women lower than usual care alone). because patients appreciate the convenience
and young men resulted from changes in of nonfasting tests, and because risk was
COMMENT
coexisting illnesses and clinical features at similar for all lipid parameters including
To achieve better outcomes for patients
admission rather than in processes of care. non-HDL or directly measured LDL, one
with chronic conditions, we need to go be-
COMMENT yond what we can do in the confines of of- efficient approach supported by this study
Sex differences in in-hospital mortality after fice visits. Implementation of these two is to use nonfasting cholesterol profiles
MI have narrowed over time, particularly strategies for management of hypertension (without triglyceride or LDL levels) for
among younger people. However, the analy- seems feasible, as long as resources are assessing risk for vascular disease. Although
sis suggests that this temporal trend stems available. Similar strategies likely would some clinicians already use this approach,
from concomitant changes in clinical pro- work for other chronic conditions. considerable effort will be required to
files rather than from improvements in care. — Richard Saitz, MD, MPH, FACP, FASAM, change the current culture of lipid manage-
Furthermore, changes in practice patterns Journal Watch General Medicine ment, with its heavy emphasis on LDL.
(e.g., shorter hospital stays and more fre- — Thomas L. Schwenk, MD,
Bosworth HB et al. Two self-management interven- Journal Watch General Medicine
quent use of skilled nursing facilities) might tions to improve hypertension control: A random-
result in lower in-hospital mortality rates ized trial. Ann Intern Med 2009 Nov 17; 151:687. Di Angelantonio E et al. for the Emerging Risk
that do not reflect improved longer-term Factors Collaboration. Major lipids, apolipoproteins,
outcomes. Gratifying as these data are, there and risk of vascular disease. JAMA 2009 Nov 11;
Lipids, Apolipoproteins, 302:1993.
is still ample room for the medical commu-
nity to do better.
and Vascular Disease:
— Frederick A. Masoudi, MD, MSPH What to Measure?
Total and HDL cholesterol and apolipopro-
Vaccarino V et al. Sex differences in mortality after teins, fasting or not, are equally accurate.
acute myocardial infarction: Changes from 1994 to
2006. Arch Intern Med 2009 Oct 26; 169:1767. To assess vascular disease risk conferred by
serum lipids, we typically measure fasting
levels of total cholesterol, HDL, and triglyc- Save time and stay informed
Self-Management erides, and the laboratory calculates LDL with a FREE daily e-mail alert.
for Hypertension from the other results. However, an alter- • Relevant information and practical
Two interventions helped patients reach native is to measure only total cholesterol intelligence you can use
blood pressure goals. and HDL (neither measurement requires • Brief reviews of the medical news
Because many hypertensive patients do fasting); subtracting HDL from total cho- that affects your practice
not achieve good control of blood pres- lesterol yields the so-called non-HDL • Gleaned from government
sure, strategies are needed beyond physi- cholesterol, which roughly parallels LDL. agencies, journals, and other
cian adjustment of medication based on Less commonly measured predictors are key sources
office-visit blood pressure measurements. apolipoproteins (apo) A1 and B. • Delivered to your e-mail box each
In a study of two self-management strat- weekday by 7:30 a.m. ET
To investigate the capacity of these
egies, North Carolina investigators ran-
markers to predict vascular risk, researchers Visit JWatch.org
domized 636 patients with hypertension
collapsed 68 long-term studies of lipids to sign up FREE
to receive bimonthly nurse-delivered
and vascular disease, mostly from Europe
6 CARDIOLOGY Vol. 16 No. 1

Folic Acid and Cancer Ebbing M et al. Cancer incidence and mortality people who required revascularization,
after treatment with folic acid and vitamin B12. in their doctors’ opinions: Examples are
Cancer incidence and mortality rose with JAMA 2009 Nov 18; 302:2119.
vitamin use. patients with flash pulmonary edema or
Drake BF and Colditz GA. Assessing cancer preven-
Since 1998, when the U.S. mandated folic acute renal injury (or rapidly progressing
tion studies — A matter of time. JAMA 2009 Nov
acid (FA) fortification of flour and other 18; 302:2152. disease) that was thought to be caused by
grain foods to lower risk for neural tube renal artery stenosis. Whether such pa-
defects, FA intake has risen dramatically. tients benefit from revascularization is
Revascularization Is Ineffective unknown. But, for most people, revascu-
Supplementation with FA and other B vita-
for Atherosclerotic Renal Artery larization for renal artery stenosis does
mins also has been proposed to prevent
Stenosis not appear to be associated with clinical
cardiovascular disease (by lowering homo-
cysteine levels), although no studies yet This procedure conferred substantial risk benefit.
without clinical benefit. — Richard Saitz, MD, MPH, FACP, FASAM,
have shown such benefit. To examine a
Revascularization for atherosclerotic renal Journal Watch General Medicine
possible association between FA treatment
and cancer risk, researchers combined the artery stenosis can improve artery patency, The ASTRAL Investigators. Revascularization
results of two Norwegian trials of vitamin but is it associated with clinical benefit? In versus medical therapy for renal-artery stenosis.
a 5-year U.K. study, investigators random- N Engl J Med 2009 Nov 12; 361:1953.
B supplementation in nearly 7000 patients
with ischemic heart disease. More than ized 806 patients with renal artery stenosis
70% of patients were current or former and related clinical findings (such as Two Clopidogrel Loading
smokers. Norway does not mandate FA difficult-to-control hypertension or un-
Doses Compared in Patients
fortification of foods. explained renal dysfunction) to medical
with STEMI
management alone or to medical manage-
Patients were randomized to one of four STEMI patients who underwent primary
ment plus angioplasty (with stenting at the
daily regimens: FA (0.8 mg) plus vitamin PCI had better clinical outcomes with a
discretion of treating physicians). In all
B12 (0.4 mg) plus vitamin B6 (40 mg); FA 600-mg loading dose than with 300 mg.
cases, treating physicians were uncertain
plus vitamin B12; vitamin B6 alone; or pla- Given that platelet inhibition during per-
whether revascularization would confer
cebo. After a median of 78 months of treat- cutaneous coronary intervention is more
benefit. Median follow-up was 34 months.
ment and follow-up, risk for developing rapid and complete when a 600-mg load-
cancer in groups that were taking FA com- Among participants who were assigned ing dose of clopidogrel is used, it is often
pared with those that were not taking FA to revascularization, 17% did not undergo preferred over a 300-mg dose, both for
was 21% higher (number needed to harm the procedure, mainly because angiogra- PCI with stenting and in acute coronary
[NNH], about 63). Risk for dying from can- phy revealed that their stenoses were less syndrome patients who undergo PCI.
cer was 38% higher in the FA groups (NNH, severe than expected. Compared with Now, using data from the HORIZONS-
91), and, for all-cause mortality, risk was medical management–only patients, AMI trial (JW Cardiol Aug 2008, p. 67,
18% higher (NNH, 43). Lung cancer inci- those assigned to revascularization had a and N Engl J Med 2008; 358:2218), investi-
dence accounted for much of the risk for borderline significant mean lower rate of gators have compared outcomes in pa-
developing or dying from cancer. disease progression (as measured by the tients with ST-segment-elevation MI who
reciprocal of the mean serum creatinine received a 300-mg (1153 patients) or a
COMMENT level; P=0.06). However, no significant 600-mg (2158 patients) loading dose
Because folic acid impairs immune surveil- differences were noted between groups in of clopidogrel before being randomized
lance of cancer cells and might stimulate the serum creatinine level, systolic blood pres- either to bivalirudin alone or to unfrac-
growth of established cancers, these find- sure, adverse renal events, adverse cardio- tionated heparin plus a glycoprotein (GP)
ings have a biological basis; indeed, in an- vascular events, or death. Mean diastolic IIb/IIIa inhibitor.
other 2009 trial, folic acid supplementation blood pressure was significantly lower in
was associated with excess risk for prostate the medical management–only group. For each of the 30-day endpoints —
cancer (J Natl Cancer Inst 2009; 101:432). Researchers found no effects of revascu- death, reinfarction, major adverse cardio-
Differences in baseline FA intake and smok- larization in subgroups as defined by vascular events, and major bleeding un-
ing history might account for the results of stenosis or renal dysfunction severity. related to bypass surgery — recipients of
earlier studies that did not show elevated Twenty-three patients suffered serious the 600-mg clopidogrel loading dose fared
risk for cancer. In any case, these results complications related to revascularization. significantly better than recipients of the
provide further reason not to recommend 300-mg dose, without any greater risk for
FA supplements for most middle-aged or COMMENT stroke or thrombocytopenia and regard-
older adults. The issue of what to do about A small recently published study sug- less of antithrombotic-therapy assign-
FA fortification of foods is much more com- gested that revascularization produced no ment. Among stent recipients, the inci-
plicated, but editorialists believe that U.S. benefit (Ann Intern Med 2009; 150:840); dence of definite or probable stent
fortification places the population well with- now, a much larger study yielded similar thrombosis was significantly lower with
in safe limits. findings. The authors note that the main 600-mg than with 300-mg of clopidogrel
— Thomas L. Schwenk, MD, limitation of their study is that they excluded (1.7% vs. 2.8%).
Journal Watch General Medicine
January 2010 JWatch.org 7

COMMENT
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE WATCH
STEMI patients who underwent PCI had
significantly better ischemic outcomes with
USPSTF Doesn’t Recommend Using
a 600-mg loading dose of clopidogrel com-
Nontraditional Risk Factors for CHD Risk
pared with 300 mg without any greater risk
for bleeding, regardless of which anti- The task force finds the evidence to be insufficient to make a recommendation.
thrombotic therapy was used and whether The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force overestimating CHD risk, expense of
a GP IIb/IIIa inhibitor was included. The (USPSTF) has issued a new guideline testing, and side effects of any preventive
findings are consistent with data from the about the use of nontraditional markers interventions (such as statins) that gener-
TRITON-TIMI 38 trial, in which prasugrel for coronary heart disease risk to screen ally are safe but have known side effects
(which achieves greater platelet inhibition patients, particularly those at intermedi- that would be acceptable only if the inter-
than clopidogrel) outperformed clopid- ate risk according to traditional risk ventions provide benefits.
ogrel in terms of patient outcomes (J Am factors (Framingham score). The task
Coll Cardiol 2009; 54:678). Based in part on COMMENT
force evaluated nine nontraditional
these results, the newly revised American The temptation exists to collect as much
markers: high-sensitivity C-reactive
College of Cardiology/American Heart information as possible to prevent a
protein (hs-CRP), ankle-brachial index
Association STEMI guidelines support the common cause of death. However, based
(ABI), leukocyte count, fasting blood
use of 300–600 mg of clopidogrel before on current data, the best outcome of
glucose level, periodontal disease, carotid
primary PCI. screening with nontraditional risk fac-
intima–media thickness, coronary artery
— Howard C. Herrmann, MD tors would be to reclassify a small pro-
calcification score as determined by
portion of patients; such screening
Dangas G et al. for the HORIZONS-AMI Trial electron-beam computed tomography,
would not necessarily be associated with
Investigators. Role of clopidogrel loading dose in homocysteine level, and lipoprotein(a)
patients with ST-segment elevation myocardial preventing CHD. Some experts still
level.
infarction undergoing primary angioplasty: Results might advocate testing because they
from the HORIZONS-AMI (Harmonizing Out- The USPSTF concluded that evi- hope that the evidence will catch up to
comes With Revascularization and Stents in Acute dence is insufficient to assess the balance clinical practice. Although this ap-
Myocardial Infarction) Trial. J Am Coll Cardiol of benefits and harms of using nontradi-
2009 Oct 6; 54:1438. proach perhaps is not entirely unreason-
tional risk factors to screen asymptomatic able, it is problematic, because it could
Simon DI and Parikh SA. Hunting for the “sweet
men and women with no histories of distract us from focusing on preventive
spot” in P2Y12 receptor blockade. J Am Coll
Cardiol 2009 Oct 6; 54:1447. CHD to prevent subsequent CHD events. health interventions of proven benefit.
I statement (insufficient evidence; the — Richard Saitz, MD, MPH, FACP,
grading system can be accessed on the FASAM, Journal Watch General
Cangrelor Is Not the USPSTF website.) Medicine
New Champion
In the evidence review, researchers U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. Using non-
Unexpected setbacks for a promising new
found that 11% of men with intermediate traditional risk factors in coronary heart disease
antiplatelet agent illustrate the gap between
CHD risk would be reclassified as having risk assessment: U.S. Preventive Services Task
laboratory results and clinical efficacy. Force recommendation statement. Ann Intern
high risk and 12% would have low risk by
Cangrelor, an investigational intravenous Med 2009 Oct 6; 151:474.
hs-CRP; 10% of women would be reclas-
agent that reversibly inhibits the platelet sified as having high risk by ABI. Data Buckley DI et al. C-reactive protein as a risk
P2Y12 adenosine diphosphate receptor, has factor for coronary heart disease: A systematic
are insufficient for all other tests. The review and meta-analyses for the U.S. Preventive
two potential advantages over clopidogrel: evidence is also insufficient to determine Services Task Force. Ann Intern Med 2009 Oct
a rapid onset of action and a short half-life whether CHD events (and deaths) would 6; 151:483.
that allows normalization of platelet func- be lessened following nontraditional risk Helfand M et al. Emerging risk factors for coro-
tion within 60 minutes of discontinuation. factor screening. The USPSTF also cites nary heart disease: A summary of systematic
In two manufacturer-sponsored studies, possible harms of screening, such as ad-
reviews conducted for the U.S. Preventive Services
investigators assessed cangrelor’s efficacy Task Force. Ann Intern Med 2009 Oct 6;
verse psychological consequences of 151:496.
in patients undergoing percutaneous coro-
nary intervention. Both trials were termi-
nated early based on findings from interim
analyses. inhibitors were used in 9.2% of patients. bosis rate (0.2%, vs. 0.6% with placebo)
In the CHAMPION PLATFORM The primary composite endpoint of death, and mortality (0.2% vs. 0.7%). Major and
trial, 5301 patients undergoing PCI for MI, or ischemia-driven revascularization minor bleeding rates were similar in the
acute coronary syndromes were random- within 48 hours occurred in 7% of can- two groups, although groin hematomas
ized to receive cangrelor or placebo for grelor recipients and in 8% of placebo occurred more frequently in cangrelor
2 to 4 hours during the procedure and recipients, a nonsignificant difference. recipients. Dyspnea was more common in
clopidogrel (600 mg) at the end of the However, cangrelor was associated with cangrelor recipients (1.4%) than in placebo
procedure. Glycoprotein (GP) IIb/IIIa significant reductions in the stent throm- recipients (0.5%).
No part of this newsletter may be reproduced or otherwise incorporated into any information retrieval system without the written
JW ONLINE CME permission of the Massachusetts Medical Society. Printed in the USA. ISSN 1521-5822.

JOURNAL WATCH SUBSCRIBERS


HAVE 10 FREE CREDITS!
Massachusetts Medical Society
This is one of four questions in a recent Journal
860 Winter Street
Watch Online CME exam.
Waltham, MA 02451-1413
from “ARBITER 6-HALTS: A Surprise
Knockout” (p. 1)
JWatch.org
Which of the following statements
describes a finding from a randomized
trial of statin therapy plus ezetimibe or
extended-release niacin in patients at
high risk for cardiovascular events?
A. The mean low-density lipoprotein (LDL)
level increased significantly in the
ezetimibe group.
B. The mean high-density lipoprotein
(HDL) level decreased significantly in
the niacin group.
C. Carotid intima–media thickness de-
creased significantly in the niacin group.
D. The major cardiovascular event rate was
significantly lower in the ezetimibe
group than in the niacin group.
Category: Cardiovascular Diseases
Exam Title: HDL Cholesterol
Posted Date: Dec 15 2009
View this exam and others at http://cme.jwatch.org
User name and password are required.
CME FACULTY
Kelly Anne Spratt, DO, FACC, Section Editor, Cardiology

8 CARDIOLOGY Vol. 16 No. 1

In the CHAMPION PCI trial, 8877 greater platelet inhibition than clopidogrel
patients undergoing PCI were randomized alone — is surprising. Study design issues, The Journal Watch Series
to receive either 600 mg of clopidogrel including the definition of periprocedural Journal Watch AIDS Clinical Care
or cangrelor at the beginning of the pro- MI and the abrupt transition to an oral Journal Watch Cardiology
cedure. GPIIb/IIIa inhibitors were used antiplatelet after cangrelor infusion, could Journal Watch Dermatology
in 26.5% of patients. Cangrelor recipients have contributed to these negative results. Journal Watch Emergency Medicine
received clopidogrel at the end of the infu- However, newer oral agents with a faster Journal Watch Gastroenterology
sion. The rate of the composite endpoint onset of action and more-consistent plate-
Journal Watch General Medicine
of death, MI, or ischemia-driven revascu- let inhibition than clopidogrel are now
Journal Watch Hospital Medicine
larization did not differ significantly be- available and will pose a further challenge
Journal Watch Infectious Diseases
tween the two groups at either 48 hours to cangrelor’s development.
Journal Watch Neurology
or 30 days or among subgroups with — Howard C. Herrmann, MD
Journal Watch Oncology
stable angina, unstable angina, and ST- Dr. Herrmann was a site investigator for the CHAMPION
and Hematology
segment-elevation MI. Bleeding rates PCI study but was not involved in data analysis or manu-
script preparation. Journal Watch Pediatrics and
were similar in the two treatment groups, Adolescent Medicine
Bhatt DL et al for the CHAMPION PLATFORM
but dyspnea occurred in slightly more
Investigators. Intravenous platelet blockade with Journal Watch Psychiatry
cangrelor recipients (1.0%) than clopid- cangrelor during PCI. N Engl J Med 2009 Dec 10; Journal Watch Women’s Health
ogrel recipients (0.4%). 361:2330.
FOR MORE INFORMATION
Harrington RA et al. Platelet inhibition with cangre-
COMMENT From the United States and Canada: call (800) 843-
lor in patients undergoing PCI. N Engl J Med 2009
Given the importance of platelet inhibition Dec 10; 361:2318. 6356, fax (781) 893-0413, or see JWatch.org
in ACS treatment and PCI, the fact that From all other locations: call (49) 30 312 3883,
Kastrati A and Ndrepepa G. Cangrelor — A cham-
fax (49) 30 313 2032 (Germany) call +1 781 893 3800
cangrelor did not improve outcomes — pion lost in translation? N Engl J Med 2009 Dec 10;
x5515, fax +1 781 893 0413 (U.S.)
despite presumably achieving earlier and 361:2382.

Вам также может понравиться