2012

ICTSD

:


: ,

40

 2012
l ICTSD
:


: ,

40

ii
. , . - :

(ICTSD)
International Environment House 2
7 Chemin de Balexert, 1219 Geneva, Switzerland
Tel: +41 22 917 8492
E-mail: ictsd@ictsd.org
:
:
:

Fax: +41 22 917 8093

Internet: www.ictsd.org
- (Ricardo Melndez-Ortiz)
(Christophe Bellmann)
(Jonathan Hepburn),
(Ammad Bahalim),
(Tyler Blake)

ICTSD
. ICTSD ,
(DFID),
(SIDA),
(DGIS),
, (Danida),
(AusAID), (IADB)
ICTSD
Matthews) (Eugenia Serova).
ICTSD
agriculture
ICTSD .
: ,
(2012)

?
IC
, www.ictsd.org.
ICTSD, 2012 .
.
Creative Commons Attribution-oncommercial-o-Derivative
Works3.0. - http:
creativecommons.org licenses bincund 3.0 Creative Commons,
171 Second Street, Suite 300, San Francisco, California, 9410, USA.
, ,
ICTSD .
ISS 1817 3X

iii
ICTSD

iv
vi
viii

ix
1
1.

1.2

2008-2010 .

1.1

1.3

2008-2010
12
2.


1

3.

4.
2.1

2.2




,

i:
,

ii:

2010 .
iii:

1
22
3
41
44
4
47
2

4

iv
. , . - :


. 1
()
. 2.

2000-2009 .
. 3.

200-2
. 4.

2008-2010 . (. )
. .

. .
2008-2010 . (. )
. 7.
2008-2010 . (. )
. 8.

20082010 . (
. 9.

2008-2010 . (. )

. 10.

. 11.

200- 2010 . (. )
. 12.

, 200-2010 . ()
. 13.
200-2010 .
. 14.
200-2010 . (. )
. 1.
20072010 .
. 1.
,

. 17.

2010 (. )
. 18.

, 2010 . (. )
. 19.

. 20.

, (. )
. 21.

,
2010 . ()

 ICTSD

.
.
.
.
.
.

22.
23.
24.
2.
2.
27

(
2000, 200, 2009 2010 . (. )
2008-2010 . (. )
2000, 200, 2009 2010 . (. )
2000-2009 . (. )

2000, 200, 2009 2010 . (. )

. 28.
(. )
. 29.
. 30.
. 31.
. 32.
. 33.
v

2000, 200, 2009 2

2000, 200, 2009 2010 . (. )
2000, 200, 2009 2010 . (. )
2000, 200, 2009 2010 . (. )
(. )
2000, 200, 2009 2010 (. )

vi
. , . - :


. 1

. 2
() ,
2008-2011 .
. 3
2008-2009 .
. 4
( )
. 
, 200-2008 . (.
)
. 

: ()
. 7

,
()
. 8
()

. 9

2010 . (. )
. 1.1

2000-2009 .
. 1.2

2008-2010 .
. 1.3

 2008-2010 .
. 1.4

2008-2010 . (. )
. 1.
200-2009 .
. 1.
200-2010 . (. )
. 1.7
2007 2008 2009 2010 . (. )
. 1.8
,
()
. 1.9

, ()
. 2.1

2010 .
. 2.2

2010 .
. 3.1

. 3.2
()
. 3.3

 ICTSD

. 3.4
()
. 3.

. 3.
()
. 3.7

. 3.8
()
. 3.9

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
vii

3.10
3.11
3.12
3.13
3.14
3.1
3.1
3.17
3.18
3.19
3.20
3.21
3.22

()
()
()
()
()
()
()

viii
. , . - :

MEX
- -
SPS-
TR

 ICTSD

8- 2011 .

. ,
2012 .,
.
1993 .,

, .

, , , .
,
,
.
, , . .

,
.
,
. . ,
. ,
, ,
,
-
. , ,
: -, ,

. ,
, , -
.
, ,

,
.
, ,
,
- -. ,
,
- , ,
.

,
, ,
.
.
ix

x
. , . - :

:
,
,

, .
,
. ,
.
Ricardo Melndez-Ortiz
Chief Executive, ICTSD

 ICTSD

1999 .,
1999-2010 . 2,4  .
8,4 . 2008-2010 .

.
.,
, 2008-2012 . 200-2009
. ,
, .

,

, - .

, .
,
.

.
.
, ,
, -.
10 
2008-2010 ., 90 .

()
.

. .
,

1

2
. , . - :

.
, . 2010 .
.
.
,
.
,
.
.
,
. 2010 .
39 
,
, , , , , , , .

. 2010 .
, .

. . 2010 .

, , .

. ,
,
.
.
.
- .
, , .
.
90 , 80 .

 ICTSD

,
, , .
, ,
,
.
.


.
, 7 
, (0 

, , .
-.

.
(,
), .
,
.
, ,
. ,
( 10 1 ) .
( )

. ,

.
( )
,
,
. 3

4
. , . - :

,
.

.
,
,

 ICTSD

1.

1.1.


1999 .,
.
1999 2010 .,
,4 .
1998 18,7 .
.
1999-2010
2,4  .

2010 .
. 2010 .

11,3 , , -

23,8 .
. 1. ()

.
1999 .

,

( )

( )

(
)
.


. , . - :

2000- .
(. . 2).

,
2008-2012 .

. 1). 2009 .
3,7 ,
2009 . 2,2 .
. 1.

200
2007
2008
2009
(. USD)
990.0
1299.7
19.8
1234.2
(.
USD)
1700.0
227.7
288.3
2182.2
- (. USD)
33.7
43.

7.0
4.8
- (. USD)

3.

82.4
108.2
88.0
3.4
3.4
3.4
3.7
- (. USD)
21.9
2.8
34.7
27.7
- (. USD)
72.9
98.2
123.2
103.7
,
, , 
2.2
2.1
2.1
2.2

(. USD)

7.8
7.
99.2
79.4

, 

3.4
3.3
3.4
3.


, , 
,

,
(. . 2 . 1.1 1).



2000-2003 .
2002007 .,


.

.
,

.

 ICTSD

,


(
, )
,
.

.

.
,
,

,
, .

.
. .
. 2.
2000-2009 .

, (. . )
, (. . )
,
, 
:

.3 ,
. 200 . (,7  )
(11,1  ).
(
) 

, 2 .
,
, .

8
. , . - :

.

.
(, )
0  .

.

,
,
,
,
. ,
.
. 3.
200-2009 . (. )
10000
9000
. .
8000
381
7000
2970

000
000
3077
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
340
3217
2339
223
2008
2009
2327
134

10
789
4
90
90
200
200

1087
2007

, 200-2009 .
,
,

, .

, 2008 .
.
:
,
,
, ,

9
ICTSD

,
,

.
1.2
20082010 .

2008-2010
. 8,4 . (.
. 1.2 1).
(47,1 ).
, , , , ,
( 0  ),

( 0 ), ( 2 ).


4,7 , 7,

.
1,4 
, 14,2 .
. 4  . 1.2 1). 0 

2009-2010 .,

2008 .,
108,2 . .
. 4. 
2008-2010 . (. )
20000
. .
18000
1000
14000
12000
10000
8000
000
4000
2000
0

2008
2009


2010

2008-2010

10
. , . - :

. .
2008-2010 . ()
20
18
1
14
12

10
8

4
2
0

2008
2009

2010

2008-2010

.
13, . .

2010 . ,
2010 . , 1,7  32 .
2010 ., 2 
2,  113 ( 400
).
.

.


4,1  (3, . ) 20082010 .
- .

, .
,
.
9,1 
(7,9 . ),
7,  (, . ),
7,2  (,2 . ).

200
. 2010 . .

20082010 (.
1). 27,9  2010 . 2008
. .

 ICTSD

. . 2008-2010 . (. )
120000
.
100000
80000
0000
40000
20000
0

2008
2009

2010
:
. 7. 2008-2010 . (. )
3000
30000
.
2000
20000
1000
10000
000
0

2008

2009

2010
:

11

12
. , . - :

1.3. 2008-2010


1,4 1).
,
.
(. . 8, 9
10). 7,1 . 2008-2010 .
33 

. 8. ()
20082010 (.)
70000
0000
.

0000
40000
30000
20000
10000
0

2008
2009
2010

2008-2010

(19 ).
3 . . ,
23, . , ,
. ,
4,1, 3,1 2,8
. .

(29,3 ).
7,4 . .
, .

21, . , 1, .
.

. 2,7 , 2,9 ,

19,4 . .
.

13
ICTSD

. 9. ()
20082010 (.)
2008-2010 .. ( USD)
0000

0000
.
40000
30000
20000
10000
0

14
. , . - :

. 10. ()
2008-2010 .
100
90
80
70

0
 0
40
30
20
10
0

,
- .

, ,
, , -

.
(
)
.

.

 ICTSD

2.

2.1.

2.1.1.


.
, ,
,

.
2008-2010 .,

. 2  ,

200-2007 .
. 11.
, 200- 2010 . (. )
40
30
. .
20
10
0
200
200
2007
2008
2009
2010
-10
-20
-30



:

200 . 2010
., . 2008 .
27, 
. 2010 .
18,8 . 2010 .



. 2010 .


2008 .,
2,2 . .

1,.
1

1
. , . - :

. 12.
, 200-2010 . ()
3
30
2
20
1


10

0
-
200
200
2007
2008
2009
2010
-10
-1
-20
:

2008-2010 . .

10 ,
90 .
,

2008 .
12,  2008 ., 17, 
2009 . 1,  2010 .

. ,

, (.
. 13 . 1. 1).

.

.

17
ICTSD

.
. 13. 200-2010 .
12000
70
10000

0
0
8000
40
000


30
4000
20
2000
10
0
0
200
200

2007
2008

2009

, 
, 
2010
:


( ) 2008 . ,4 . , 19,2
 .

2009 . 14,3 
( , .
), 2010 . 20,  ( 4,4
. ). (. . 14
. 1. 1).
. 14. 200-2010 . (. ))
1800
100
1400
.
1200
1000
800
00
400
200
0
200
2007
2008
( )
2009
2010

:
(TR), ,
.
TR , -

. ,
2009-2011 .,

18
. , . - :

. 2. () ,
2008-2011 .
.
.
2008
2009
2010
2011
28.9
29.
30
30
,

.


1, 0.2 .


4,
0,
..
40,
0,3

0,
1
.
0,
1

,

.

44
40

30
30


1, 0,1

1,
0,2

1,
0,2


0,
0,

0,
1

0,
1

40,
0,4
.
, ,

.

493.

31.9

472.1


1, 0.2 .


0,
1,0

7,
1,
.
7,
1,
.
472.1
7,
1,
.
, ,

.

1211.
92
780


2, 0,2 .


0,
0,48
.

9,
0,8

80,
0,7
.
30
80,
0,7
.
:

2008-2011 .

-

2008 .

0,22
0,3 2009 .,

1 . 1 20  .
.

 ICTSD

2010 .
,
2 
, :
0,3 0,4 (
) 0, 0,
. ,
,
2010 .
2009 .
.

,
, 0 10 

(. . 1
. 1.7 1). ,

,
, .
2009 .

 .
(
110 . . 70 . .),
( 110 . .
132 . .).
. 1.
0
8000
7000

0
000
40
.

000
30 
4000
3000
20
2000
10
1000
0
0

2007 2008
2008 2009
2009 2010





, 
, 
:
19

20
. , . - :

-.
.
.
- 1,8  2009 .
-. ,
-
,8 . -
2010 .
2009 . 1,7 (208,3 . .
123,3 . .). 2010 .
2009 .
. 3. 2008-2009 .

2008

2009
2008
2009

.
.
.
,
.
USD
.
.
USD
.
,
.
USD
.
,

.
USD
.

.
USD
.
,
.
USD

2419.9
944.2
123.3

07.3
3.
2.3
133.7

.7

1.1
87.4
28.9
147.3
:
2010 .
- - -
- (MEX) 28,0 39,83 .
-
39,83 ,
140
.
.
270
. ,
- 28,0 .
-
1 31 .
0 ,
- 48,02

 , 20 ,

, 2010 . - MEX
.
,

.

- . -

. -
100 000 .
2008 .
10 000 .
2009 2010 .
2011 . 200 000 .
, ,
2008-2010 .
()

 ICTSD

,
, . ,
,
-.
2008 . , 2007 .,

(30 , 70 )
(10 , 22
) ,
.
2.1.2.

.
2008 .
, ( )
,
()
2008 2009 . .

30 2009 .
2009 .
31 2010 .

.

(. . 11).
2002 . .
,
.

9,3 . 2009 .

2,3  2008-2009 .

.
( )

.
(40 , 10
)
1 30

,
,
, ,
1 2010 . 31 2010 .
2010 .
, , 30 2011 .

.
.
, (
).

21

22
. , . - :

2.2.

2.2.1.


: ,
.

( ,

, , ,
, ).
. 1,
20 
.
1 .
.

. 2000 .
13,1 , 2010 . 31,4 .
, ,
34,3  2000 . 13,8  2010 .

. 1. ,

100
90
80
70
0
 0
40
30
20
10
0
2000
200
2009
2010
2000
200

2009

2010

:

(. . 1.8 1).

,

(. . 17 . 1.9 1).
2010 .
39 
.
31 .

 ICTSD

. .
. 17.
, 2010 (. )
2000
20000
1000
10000
000
0

:

3  .
20 
(7,2 )
(12 ).

17 
. (7,4 ).
.
,
2010 .

(204,8 .
), (2228,2 . ),
(117,3 . ),
(903,2 . ), (,
. ),
(4,4 . ) (. . 18
. 2.1 2).
(. . 19).
, 70 
,
  47 
. , ,
.

23

24
. , . - :

. .
. 18.
, 2010 . (. )

,
,

,
,
,

:

, (2,3 
182,3 .
).
.

,
(84,3 . ),
(719, . ),
, (49,9 .
). ,

.

. 19.
, 2010 . ()

,
,


:

,
,
,

 ICTSD

,
(4,1 )
(40, ).
.
,


. ,

,

,
.
, ,
, (.
. 20-21 . 2.2 2).
(77,2 ), (0,7 )
.

(42,9 )
.
. 20.
, (. )

2

2
. , . - :

. 21.
, 2010 . ()

2.2.2. -

,
, , , , , ,
.

2000 .
.


,

2000 .

 . ,

.
, .

200 .
,
,
,
,
.

 ICTSD

. 22.
(. )
000
400
4000
300
3000
200
2000
100
1000
00
0
1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 199 199 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 200
200 2007 2008 2009 2010
Bovi ne a nimals
Swi nes
Sheep a nd goats
Poul try
:

(. . 23). 2010 .
4,4

2000 ., 3,2 .

200 .

2009, 2010 2011 . -

(. . 2)

7.
, ,
.

(, )
2010 .
00 . .
27

28
. , . - :

. 23. 2000, 200, 2009 2010 . (. )
1400
1200
.
1000
800
00
400
200
0

2000

200
2009
2010


,
.

. 2010 .
, 7 , 3,3
 23,2  ,
1,8 , 8,  2,4  2000 . (. 3, . 3.1-3.).


. 2010 .
,
0,9 , 99,3  94,  .
,
.

(. . 24), ,
, . 2008 . ,
,  (
34,  ).

( 2009 .

1 )

.

29
ICTSD

.
. 24. 2008-2010 . (. )
30000
70
2000

0
0
20000
40
1000


30
10000
20

000
10
0
0
2008
2009
2010

,
,
, , , 
:

(.
. 2).
2009 .
, , 2 . .
. 2. 2000, 200, 2009 2010 . (. )

000
000

.
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
2000
200

2009
2010

:

30
. , . - :

-

(. 3, . 3.7-3.8).
.
2010 . 8,8 .
,

.


. 2010 . ( 400 . .)
11 , 2000 .

(. 3,
.3.9-3.10). 2000 .
10 .

, ,
.
. 2. 2000-2009 . (. )
900
800
.
700
00
00
400
300
200
100
0
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
200
200
2007
: .
2008

2009

 ICTSD

. 27. 2000, 200, 2009 2012 (. )
00
40
.
400
30
300
20
200
10
100
0
0
2000
200
2009
2010


:

(. .28).
2010 .
0 , 2000 .
2009
. 28. 2000, 200, 2009
2010 . (. )
1200
1000
.

800
00
400
200
0
2000
200
2009
2010

:

31

32
. , . - :


(. 3,
. 3.11-3.12).
, ,
. ,
,

2000-2010 .
(. . 29). 2010 .
100 . .,

2000 .


(. 3,
3.13-3.14).
2010 . .

2000 .
. 29. 2000, 200, 2009 2010 . (. )
120
100
.
80

0
40
20
0
2000
200
2009
2010


:

24,7
. . (1,1 ) 2010 . 2000 .
(. . 30 . 3.1-3.1
3).

 - . 2000
2010 . -
18,8  32,4 ,
7,  11,7 .
, , .

33
ICTSD

. 30. 2000, 200, 2009 2010 . (. )
200
180
10
.
140
120
100
80
0
40
20
0
2000
200
2009
2010


:



2000-2010 . (. . 31).
2010 . 2,1
2000 .,
3,4 ,
8,2 .

(. 3, . 3.17-3.22).


100 ,
90 ,
80 .
. 31. 2000, 200, 2009 2010 . (. )
100
1400
1200
.
1000
2000
800

200
00
2009
2010
400
200
0

34
. , . - :

. 90

.
(30, 
(14,2 ) (11,7 ).
(9  2
(10,2 ).
2.2.3.
,
1998 .
. 2000 .
. 2008 .

1991 . (. . 32).
.
. 32. (. )
:

,


2009 .,
21,8 . .
,
.
2008 2010
,

8.

(47,1
2010 .) (14,1).

(38,2), (1,) (,4).

2010 . (1 . . 9,1 ).


,
.

 ICTSD

. 33. 2000, 200, 2009 2010 (. )
18000
1000
14000
.
12000
10000
2000
8000
200

000
2009
4000
2010
2000
0

3

3
. , . - :

3.



, , : ,

.
,
2020 . ( ).
(
)
2012 2013 .,

, ,

(. . 4).
. 4. ( )

. USD
2012
2013
2014
201
201
2017
2018 and beyond
9.0
9.0
8.1
7.2

.3
.4
4.4

: ( I
)

9 .


2012 2013 . . ,
()
4,4 . 2018 . , ,
200-2008
. (. . ). ,
,
,
2010 2011 .

,
-
-

. , , 31 2017 .,
- 30 
.


- -
.
. . , 200-2008 . (.
)
200
2007
2008
200-2008
.
2

( )
1.8
2.0
2.4
2.1

3.8
3.9

.7
4.4
: JOB ACC 

 ICTSD

, 10,8
. 20  ,
13,  2010 . (. . ).
. .
: ()

2000
2007
2008
2009
2010

9.9
14.
14.2
13.2
13.
10.8

23.0
13.0
9.7
9.8
11.0

1.0
10.2

10.3
10.3
10.3
32.4

1.
10.3
10.2
10.2
13.7
3.4

1.9
1.8
1.
1.
1.
1.7

47.4
34.4
32.2
31.8
31.8
113.1

.8
9.2
9.3

8.9
9.0
39.

: WTO Tariff Profiles.

: ,
, , , ,
.
2001., 2000

,
.

(113,1 ),
(39, ),
(3,4 ) (32,4 ).

(1,7 ),
2010 . (1, )

(31,8 ).
, (9 ) (10,3 )
.

,

.

,
( 30, ),
( 28, ).

(3.3 ).
( 10,2 ),
,
( 10, ).

.

. ,
-
- ,
-
270 20
. 37

38
. , . - :




(140 ).

, - -
. 7.
,
()
2001
200
2010


14.9
1.2
1.
14.9
10.2
13.1
9.1
30.

9.7
13.1
14.2
10.
2.1

7.2
9.4
8.
7.
10.

11.1
11.
9.2
8.9
3.3

.0
21.9
1.
11.8
28.

: ,
( I-A)


-,

. (28,0 - 39,83
, 1 30
1 31 ),
(28,0 - 48,82
, 1 31
) 100 - 198,4
.

,
- .
,


,

.
,
2012
. .

(-10 ) ,

2013-201 .
(
),

. ,
, .
, ,
.
.

 ICTSD

,

.
. ,
, , 8000
,
,
- ( I-A ).

, 0  .
,
, 1
2020 . ,
40  .
,
: 27, 
, 2  37, 
.
. 8. ()

()
()
(0201)
1


40000
(0202)
1


30000
( 0203 29 0 2,0203 29 900 2)
0



400000
(0203 29 0 2,0203 29
900 2)
0


30000
(0207 14 200,0207 00)
2
80
20000
(0207 14 100)
2
80
100000
(0207 27)
2
80
14000
(0404 10 120,0404 10 10)
10
1
1000
()
: ( I-A)

.
(
), ( , , -
),
( ).
, - ,
.

. ,

20  12,  4 .


1   .
,
, ,
.
() (),
,
. ,
, ,
, 7 
,
. , 39

40
. , . - :

, 0 .
(103 ) (49 ),

,
(. 1 17 ).
,
,
(.
18 ).

0.

. ,
20  0 


20  , 

, 10 0 ,
,  0  .

(),
,
,
.
,
, ,
.

,
,
,

,
:
, ,
,
,


, , ,
,
, .

,
,
,
-
.
,

,
, ,
9.

.

 ICTSD

4.
,



, ,
,

,
,
. ,
, :







.
,


.
, ,

.
.


(. . ).
. , ,
.
,
(. . 9): , , , ,
. ,

,
,
.




,










. ,
,
,
2  , , , .

-
.
,

.

, ,
.

 ,

.
, ,

.
.
41

42
. , . - :

. 9.
2010 . (. )

, , ,
11.4

714.

28.3
(003)
,
102.
(0801,0802)
, , , ,
, -,
92.9
(080)
, , , , ,

430.
,
(0808)
, , ,
230.4
(0901)

, , , , ,

134.
(0902)
-, , , , ,

17.2
(100)
, , ,
100.2
- (1701)
, , , ,
1132.0
:
,
.

.

,
, ,
,
.
,
( 10   )
.
,


.

.

(, -

, , ,
, , ) ,
.

, ,


. ,
,

,

 . ,

 ICTSD

. ,
, , , , , ,
, , ,
, , -, ,
, ,
, ,
.
, ( , )

,
.
( )
.
, ,





. , ,
,


.
30 
.

,


, . ,
,

.
,

.



. ,
,



.


XI 1994 12 .
,

.
.
.
,
.
, ,

 ,
.
43

44
. , . - :

, 2008-2012 .
,
, ,
, .
3

31,3 . ., 2003 30,8 . ., 2004 28,81 . ., 200 28,28 .
., 200 27,19 . ., 2007 2,8 . ., 2008 24,81 . ., 2009
31,8 . ., 2010 30,3 . . .
4

: , ,
, ,
,
,

, .

, .
7
1 2010 .
), .
2010 .

,
,
2011 .

 ICTSD

,
, .
8
. ., (2009) :
,
, 2009.
9
Sharma, R. (2011) Food Export Restrictions: Review of the 2007-2010 Experience
and Considerations for Disciplining Restrictive Measures. FAO Commodity and Trade
PolicyResearch Working Paper o. 32. May 2011. http: ictsd.org downloads 2011 0

sharmaexport-restrictions.pdf
4

4
. , . - :


, 2000.
. , 2001.
, 200.
. , 200.
, 2009.
. , 2010.
, 2010.
. , 2011.
(FAS),
. FAS Production, Supply and Distribution Online. Available online: http: www.fas.
usda.gov psdonline.
,
. , 200.
200.

,
. , 2009.
2008.

,
. , 2011.
2010.

.WT ACC RUS 70, WT MI(11) 2. , 17

, 2011 .

.. . , .
. ., . . (2002)
. . .Matthews, A. Russian WTO accession by end year? Available at:
http: capreform.eu russian-wto-accession-by-end-year .
. ., (2009) :
,
, 2009.Sharma, R.

(2011) Food Export Restrictions: Review of the 2007-2010 Experience and Considera
tions
for Disciplining Restrictive Measures. FAO Commodity and Trade Policy Research Wo
rking
Paper o. 32. May 2011. Available at: http: ictsd.org downloads 2011 0 sharmaexportrestrictions.pdf
Tarr, D. (2008) Russian WTO Accession: Achievements, Impacts, Challenges. Publishe
d by the
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. Available at: http: www.
oecd.
org dataoecd 28 4 40747249.pdf
United States Trade Representative (2011), US Export Opportunities from Russias Me
mbership in
the WTO. Available at: http://www.ustr.gov/countries-regions/europe-middle-east/r
ussiaand-eurasia/russia-0.
., . .
.Choices Magazine (2009). http: www.choicesmagazine.
org magazine article.php?article
78.

47
ICTSD

1.
,

. 1.1.
2000-2009 .
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 200 200 2007 2008 2009
,

(. USD)
1.2
2.1
2.
3.0
4.0

.0
8.2
13.2
1.1
10.0

,


(. USD)
1.
1.7
2.1
2.7
3.2
4.0
4.7

.
7.8

.0


,


, 
3.0
4.0
4.
4.1
4.1
3.9
4.8

.0
4.
4.0

,


3.8
3.4
3.8
3.8
3.3
3.1
2.7
2.
2.2
2.0
:
. 1.2.
2008-2010 .
, .
USD

, 
2008
2009
2010
20082010
avg
2008
2009
2010
20082010
avg
(
)
19700
1304
9788
14177
19.9
1.4
12.2
1.4

3201
2443
3138
2927
3.2
3.1
3.9
3.4


14
110
11
1411
1.
1.
2.0
1.

37
88
10
18
.
7.4
7.
7.2

7274
778
8497
782
7.3
9.8
10.
9.1

07
327

71

17
.1
8.0
8.9
7.

14818
1141 14093
13484
14.9
14.
17.
1.

32
3420
37
3.7
4.3
4.
4.1
34

48
. , . - :

. 1.2.
, .
USD

, 
2008
2009
2010
20082010
avg
2008
2009
2010
20082010
avg

303
27838 2423
302
3.8
3.1
32.8
3.0

99208
79417 8027

8384
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0

:
. 1.3. 2008-2010 .
, .


, 
2008
2009
2010
20082010 avg
2009
2010
2010 to
2008

(
)
108179.0
97111.0

088.3
8872.1
89.8

2.7
.3

8791.7
8000.
7140.9

7977.8
91.0
89.3
81.2

2899.3
24892.0
22238.0
237.1
8.8
89.3
7.7

178.7
1740.
1721.
1743.
98.4
98.9
97.3

2042.1
219.
2321.4
2177.7
10.2
107.0
113.7

221.7

2.1
283.2
23.0
11.3
111.0
127.9

3232.
3270.0
32000.0
32310.9
100.
98.2
98.9

2114.3
2190.
221.1
2114.3
103.
103.2
10.9
:

49
ICTSD

. 1.4.
2008-2010 . (. )


2008
2009
2010
2008-2010

2008
2009
2010
1393.9 27778. 1389.
20082010

43097. 30. 311.

(
.)
3803.2

2428.4 20903.8 19089.3

2140.

1904. 19144.1 19094.9

19097.8
49.0

1.4
28.8

43.1

818.8
4889.1
4728.0

14.3
3.8
133.7
2.
71.4

2.7
18.
80.4
7.2
14.8
334.
180.1
220.

284.9
312.8
329.
3113.7
2.8


18.
9.1

229.7

2331.3
2281.
2303.2
0.1
0.3
0.1
0.2

192.07 247.03 22.97
2384.0

32.
724.3
417.

8.1

1823.9
207.2
2304.9
208.0
0.1
0.2
0.2
0.2

11.8
102.
19.
111.3

(
.)

99.0
431.3
443.7
18410.7

11.3

70.4 370.3 49814.9 707.2

2428.4 20903.8 19089.3 2140.

238.9
22.4
42.
30.9
19342. 19447.9 190.2 1944.8

28.0
112.2
2374.3
217.2
847.

3.0
7128.9
7373.8

92.9
1071.
1212.9
992.4

10.4

774.
723.4

978.1

1224
98.9

88.1
9.0
3911.7
4118.7
423.2
4088.8

872
71
72
79.0
318.8
3092.
3033.
3098.3
111.9
43.4
114.7
90.0
29.
3314.7
318.2
3032.1
822

7
81
723.3
24.0
2742.4
298.1
2791.
11.8
102.
19.
111.3

0
. , . - :

. 1.. 200-2009 .
200
200
2007
2008
2009
2010

92
0
7
733
744
804
(
)
4 972

 29
 790
 28
 720
7 17

3 094
3 17
3 177
3 248
2 919
2 8

8 8
9 084
9 43
10 249
10 383
10 82

4
2

4
41
37

1
13
1
17
18
19

7
7

90


97
7 871
8 287
8 774

9 33
9 4
9 871

0
7
733
744
804
802
, 
3,7
3,0
32,9
31,7
28,1
2,4
, 

7,4
7,9
0,0
1,2
4,7
,2
:
. 1.. 200-2010 . (. )
200

2007
2008
2009
2010

(
)
1411.4
1489.
1710.9
1437.8
1441.

1282.
1294.9
1224.0
98.9

88.0
:
. 1.7. 2007 2008 2009 2010 .
(. )

2007 2008
2008 2009
2009 2010

440

0
481

3200
3481

3313
-
2800
180
2100

300
300
280

740
181
174

200
200
100

990
00
94

0
481
380

740
181
174

1
ICTSD

. 1.8. ,
()

2000
200
2009
2010
2000
200
2009
2010
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0

8.0
.4
2.
3.
2.
.9
8.7
4.8

18.
19.
22.0
21.
13.1
23.
28.3
31.4

13.4
14.1
1.
1.0
34.3
20.
13.0
13.8

.4
4.4

.
4.
11.0

.2
4.0
4.3

2.2
2.8

3.0
2.7

.
3.
2.2
2.0

:
. 1.9.
, ()
. USD

93.7
3482.
100.0
100.0

2327.2
1894.4
24.9

1.9

37.1
1132.7

39.0
31.1

3381.4

184.
3.1
17.0

78.0
288.4
7.2
7.4

1124.3
12.7
12.0
0.3

2
. , . - :

2.

2010 .
. 2.1.
2010 .

-

. USD

01

333.3
0.4
18.
13.
0.2
02

12.1
2228.2

719.

3.7
0.1
03
,


2039.9
37.9
31.
12.9
12.1
04







,


3493.0

4.
182.3
1417.9
2.1
0

,


13.

8.0
3.1
1.8
0.0
0



,

79.0
287.9
4.
1.1
0.1
07

2331.
903.2
480.0

.9
42.1
08

04.2
204.8
84.3
11.0
11.2
09
, , ,
,

99.8
48.2

14.4
0.3
0.2
10

248.2
7.4
38.3
0.7
30.

3
ICTSD

2.1

-

. s

01

100
0.1

 .
4.1
0.1
02

100
34.2
11.0
10.2
0.0
03
,

100
18.4
1.
0.
0.
04







,


100
1.

2.3
40.
0.1
0

,


100
42.4
2.2
1.3
0.0
0


,

100

37.9
0.
0.1
0.0
07

100
38.7
20.
2.4
1.8
08




100
47.3
1.7
0.2
0.2
09
, , ,
,

100
47.7
1.
0.0
0.0
10

100
30.8
1.4
0.3
12.3

4
. , . - :

2.1

-

. USD

11

-







14.

.4
9.4
31.

.7
12



,

100.
3.

.
1.
1.1
13


,

13.4
40.1
0.7
0.3
0.0
14





,


2.8
1.2
0.2
0.0
0.0
1

139.2

4.4
290.
10.3
0.0
1

,
,

23.
104.3
23.9
203.1
0.0
17


18.7
117.3
2.3
12.8
10.1
18

1304.
137.0
38.9
20.
3.2


ICTSD

2.1

-

. USD

11

-







100
4.4
40.
21.
3.9
12



,





100
3.3

 .
0.2

0.1
13


,

100
29.7
0.
0.2
0.0
14





,


100
41.0
7.3
0.1
0.0
1

100
47.8
21.2
0.8

0.0
1

,
,

100
19.9
4.1
38.8
0.0
17


100
70.
1.9
9.2
0.
18

100
10.
29.7
1.
0.2


. , . - :

2.1

-

. USD

19

, ,

82.3
44.2
11.3
28.9
4.8
20

, ,

1401.0

43.3
204.3
19.1
0.
21

1493.9
320.9
41.0
13.
0.1
22



224.2
87.1
49.9
24.2
0.8
23




97.
18.0
7.
3.3
0.7
24


1209.1

.
43.3
0.1
1.2

7
ICTSD

2.1

-

. USD

19

, ,

100

.
1.9
4.2
0.7
20

, ,

100
38.8
14.
1.4
0.0

21

100
21.
2.7
0.9
0.0
22



100
3.8
21.9
1.1
0.0
23




100
1.
0.8
0.3
0.1
24


100

.1
3.
0.0

0.1
:

8
. , . - :

. 2.2.
2010 .

-

. USD

01

11.1
2.3
7.9
2.
3.7
02

3.2

.1
9.
0.
8.7
03
,


2209.4
170.

4.3
37.7
14.
04







,


271.2
7.
22.1
30.2
134.1
0

,


23.2
10.1
1.
1.3
0.0
0


,

1.8

0.4
1.0
0.0
0.
07

77.
13.3
2.1
4.1
10.3
08




37.0

.1
17.3
0.
14.7
09
, , ,
,

137.7
1.2
127.7
4.1
17.1
10

2419.
147.
132.9
9.4
14.2
11

-







119.7
1.8

7.2
24.3
10.9

9
ICTSD

2.2

-

01

100.0
20.9
71.3
23.7
33.3
02

100.0
14.1
2.
1.7
23.9
03

 ,


100.0
77.2
2.9
1.7
0.7
04







,


100.0
2.8
93.0
11.1
49.
0

,


100.0
43.7

.8
.
0.2
0


,

100.0
24.3

.7
0.4
32.0
07

100.0
17.2
33.7

.3
13.2
08





100.0
13.8
4.8
1.
39.7
09
, , ,
,

100.0
0.8
92.7
33.
12.4

10

100.0

0.7
.
0.4
0.
11

-







100.0
13.2

.1
20.3
9.1

0
. , . - :

2.2

-

. USD

12



,





99.3
11.
18.
10.

.9
13


,

4.7
0.4
4.0
2.3

1.4
14





,

.3
0.
0.1
0.1
0.0
1

83.2
14.8
39.0

1.7
104.4
1

,
,

209.3
3.9
187.2
22.4

108.7
17


14.7
1.
111.4
11.3
37.8
18

390.
19.0
319.1
44.2
89.7
19

, ,

414.1
12.
32.4
92.0
134.
20

, ,

10.
3.2

127.8
48.0

.8

1
ICTSD

2.2

-

. USD

12



,





100.0
11.
18.
10.

.0
13


,

100.0
8.9

8.1
48.8
30.7
14





,


100.0
7.2
1.1
1.1
0.1
1

100.0
18.
42.9

.2
12.
1

,
,

100.0
1.9
89.4

10.7

1.9
17


100.0
10.
7.9
7.7
2.8
18

100.0
4.9
81.7
11.3
23.0
19

, ,

100.0
3.0
87.
22.2
32.
20

, ,

100.0

2.1
84.9
31.9
37.7

2
. , . - :

2.2

-

. USD

21

478.
19.
391.0
90.3
148.0
22

40.1
20.7
289.0
78.2
94.
23


31.
14.7
91.7
23.7
29.2
24


43.3

.8
412.2
4.7
84.4

3
ICTSD

2.2

-

. USD

21

100.0
4.1
81.7
18.9
30.9
22



100.0
4.

2.8
17.0
20.
23





100.0
42.8
2.4

.
8.1
24


100.0
1.
89.0
10.1
18.2
:

140011


1024.7
1977.1
134.7

37.8
234
1801
3908
4897
:
22149
1322

 9

922
3383
124
190849

470.
,

299930
498
,

. USD
2000

. 3.1.
81133.

8734.
2918.8

24.1
4898.8
3728.
2374.2
,
. USD
200

32230
97
824
47732

83
331247
140174
,

224989
210722.8
17387.8
1418.7
234217.8
120742.

48448
,
. USD
2009

1230
4374
47
2888
394
2

418
77247
28323
33792
,

2124909.
180117.1
14.4
1094.4
7913.8
8.2
21239.4
27298.1
9780.8
11499
,
. USD
2010

4
. , . - :

 3.

1.8


:
100.0

12.0
100.0
8.8
100.0
84.7
100.0
0.4
94.2
100.0
1.4
93.4
100.0
0.8
7.8
0.8
0.0
13.9
1.

0.9
7.3

7.0
100.0
0.0
0.
8.0
11.1

7.2
23.0
c.
0.

9.0
9.
11.

.
23.

9.2

2.7
9.4
0.7

4.8
34.4
c.
2009

2.7

4.7
0.

 .
34.8

23.
c.
200

4.7
22.

2000

. 3.2. ()
74.4
100.0
0.0
0.7
0.
0.0
13.4
1.3

1.8
7.3
c.
2010
ICTSD



198714.0


197933.4
14944.9
:
17124.0

1482.0

42.0
408090.0

04.0
170.0
113.0
100.0

134.4
48.0

13.9
828.0
39782.0

129.
80908.1

01370.
804.0
2424.1

187.8
40.0
1081.1

893.
,
. USD

4949.0
2001.0
2098.0
2.0
420.0
2707.0
,

19118.
81018.0

089.9
9.8
1493.
80241.8
,
. USD
,

4184.0
22778.0
124.0
2214.0
143.0
,

2009

,
. USD
200
23,0
,

2000

. 3.3.
1922882.7
71903.3
492.
714470.8
100,
,
. USD
2010


. , . - :

8.
100.0
8.7

7.
100.0
73.3
100.0
1.
0.4
0.3

.9

4.1
0.1

10.9
0.2
97.

8.0
74.3
100.0
1.4
0.4
0.3

0.1
0.2
97.
40.0
100.0
0.8
0.0
0.2
99.0
42.3
100.0
0.8
0.0
0.2
99.1
3.3
100.0
0.7
37.4
100.0
0.
99.4
0.0
c.
2010

99.3
8.
c.
2009


c.
200

0.0
c.
2000

. 3.4. ()
ICTSD

7

77288.0

704.
32340.2
10131.8

2.4
100.0

.3
2.8
100.0
7.0
19.2
100.0
0.2
9.4
93.0
c.
24.7
100.0

0.2
9.0
3.7
7.8
100.0
0.
0.3
92.9

.4

13.4
100.0
0.4
0.1
94.8
4.7
23.2
100.0
0.
0.2
94.
4.7
31.3
100.0
0.3
0.1
9.8
3.8
c.
2010

82794.2
2998.1

2.7
939.3
23.4
28330.4
10130.3
,
. USD
2010

49812.0
10830.0
41.0
781.0
241.0
142742.0
702.0
,

c.
2009
1089271.9
14327.3

38.8
209.
138.9

923.1
,
. USD
2009
c.

200
9071.0

93.7
84773.
790.0
3.0
192.0
70201.0
4841.0
,

3.

44.3
20973.0
2000
131849.0
2328.0
448.0
201373.2
784.
,
. USD
200

. 3.. ()
:
1030.0
1223.0

9427.3
244282.0
1193.0

8798.0
,
. USD
2000

. 3..

8
. , . - :

481.7
:
74.3
298.1
2724.9
77.2
701.
1312.4
1188.3
10.7

39.
47.9
7.2
21.2
2089.8
10.7
70.2
17.9


72.9
14.2
0.1
4734.0

7.8
0.1
I

44.0
3.
12.2
20.3

14.2
4.0

0.7
44.0
2.0
20.9
80.9
20.3
30.0

3.2
1793.2

12.1
142.8
37.

1.1
,

-
4.9
47.
1004.8

. USD
30.4
42.
18.2

09.
,

279.3

302.
23.8
2.

. USD
2009

2042.9

279.8
10.0
,

200
2.
1828.2

13.1

. USD
2000

1.0
,

. 3.7.
1209.8
117.

.9
32.1
7.

19.3
11.0
41.8
99.7
42.0

. USD
2010
ICTSD

9

98.3


:
100.0

9.1
100.0

.1
91.8
100.0
2.1
91.4
100.0
2.0
0.
90.
100.0
0.9
84.9
100.0
1.
97.0
100.0
0.
3.4
0.9

.
0.
1.7

0.1

1.7
0.0
3.9

.1
4.
11.
8.8

.
2.
12.0
82.2
-
1.7

.8
84.
2.9
9.7
100.0
0.
2.8
0.7
1.7
1.0
3.
8.1
3.
c.
2010

1.

1.7

.8
8.9
c.
1.2
.8
41.
8.8
0.4

.9
43.2

38.
0.4
c.
2009

38.

1.8

200

1.3
c.
2000

. 3.8. ()
70

. , . - :

30130
3720400
30871820

1088.7
241.8
1123.
743.3
12.1


:
100.0

4.7
100.0
14.2
100.0
3.2
82.0

4.
21.4
7.8

30.8
0.1
74.8

0.
22.7
c.
12.
100.0
7.
43.
0.2
0.3
48.
22.8
100.0
7.1
19.4
1.0
30.8
41.

1.
100.0
9.0
40.
0.8
1.0
33.
23.
9.4
100.0
21.4
37.3

9.9
100.0
1.

9.
1.2
7.4
1.2
c.
2010
1.
2.4

9473.7
1132.2
700819.8

432419737
409097
8720782
41389.4
838.8

141.1
1072.2
,
. USD
2010
11103
9331
93170

2871
,

c.

2009

33407.8
83430.8
7497.
33899.
707.
1333.9
27972.2
,
. USD
2009
c.
200
380378
8143872

800017
177337
842037
211912
339019
,

10.2

37
271.1
1020
29298.
2000
23223940

3023480
118240
7703800

1
113.3
17819.
,
. USD
200

. 3.10. ()
:
28870

20330
29310
,

49.0
,
. USD
17700
380010
,

2000

. 3.9.
ICTSD

71

218227

347

8488,9
119,8
:
33103

3330
324397
872,
811,7
279,9

3,7
 9
1798
4249
92418
73779
,

24942
20804
420
9338
87
22214

47,2

29171,4
17038,
19093
,
. USD
1374
83,2
1480,2
24137
128237
8287

84
,

200

3130

143
18,
3031,

08,9
2917,4
,
. USD
2000

497
47228

103
,

. 3.11.
139811,2
133381,3
34,2

927,
8492,8

44
9829,8
177,
4228,4
47847
,
. USD
2009
214484
199299
112

0
832

00
108
4838
1921
7442

0902
,

1214,7
107401
793,
374,2

33,7
473,3
10,7
2993,1
7223,9
34194,3
32824,3
,
. USD
2010
72
. , . - :

.9
0.2
1.

9.2


:
100.0

89.3
100.0
9.4
100.0
94.9
100.0
0.2
0.0
7.2
17.0
3.8
29.4
98.4
100.0
0.2
3.7
3.4
8.2
8.0

3.9
21.0
23.

2.7

.8
7.4
39.
2.
18.0
9.4
100.0
0.3
4.4

.4
0.4
0.0
7.4
13.3
32.0
3.9
c.
2009

.
1.4
23.8
0.3

8.9
10.8

4.8
c.
200

0.9
14.3

3.2
c.
2000

. 3.12. ()
92.9
100.0
0.8
0.3
4.2
0.3
0.1
23.
8.0
37.4
2.
88.4
100.0
0.7
0.3

.0

0.4
0.1
24.2

.7
31.8
30.
c.
2010

ICTSD

73

40.3
30874.8
118992.8
17.
434.2
:
20274

13193
114

38
270

103.8
392
20892
120
1308
494
99
772
70077.8
2241
231.8
1477.
3081.1

213.4
133.3
88808

439
1884
279
247
1111
708
98
712

432.
188
287
448
1907
122
2099
,

47
9.
218
90
122.9
348.4
100.1
3337.2
3127.

933.1

,
. USD
200

13
44
291
381
372
,

91
32.9
78
2733.
113940.1
1038.8
,
. USD
2000

232

1803

4
9177

132
,

. 3.13.
2448.1
12439.

17.4
20.9
2.8
4378.7
223
302.
1884.2
73.9
924.8
137.4
3142.3
3007

2749.
,
. USD
2009
101784

1008
291
2894
18
10

4
9
171
327

1194
829
948
1738
2294
,

33078.7
18083
870.
700

222.7
712.
2721.
398.1
44.8
1334.2

8.4
3070.2
19307.3
447.4
884.1
,
. USD
2010
74
. , . - :

7.9
0.2

.1


:
100.0

0.9

38.4
100.0
0.1
3.2
100.0

.0
.3
23.8
2.0

0.4
0.3

0.0
0.
3.7

0.1
37.4
100.0
9.

 .

11.7
0.8

.1
1.2
100.0
3.

.1
4.7
2.0
1.3
0.7

1.3
0.3
4.9
0.8
3.1
2.3
38.
0.1
1.
0.
13.
0.4
12.7
11.9
2.4

0.8
100.0
4.2

4.2

.3
3.
1.8
0.2
1.
0.
7.4
1.1
2.3
2.4
42.4
c.
2009

0.1
0.3
0.1
14.0
1.0
1.8

0.7
0.3

2.3
18.3

13.7

9.8
18.0
0.4

9.

0.9
c.
200

10.1
c.
2000

. 3.14. ()

0.1
100.0

.1
.7
3.1
3.2
1.3
0.1
3.4
0.
2.3
1.
18.
3.4

1.

47.8
100.0

.
4.
3.3
4.
1.7
0.3
2.8
0.8
3.
1.9
12.2
2.8

.1
c.
2010

ICTSD

7

13088


22019.7
20099
0.1
0.3

9.9


:
100.0

9.
100.0
0.2
0.1
18.7
93.9
100.0

.2
8.1
42.7
12.3
88.8
100.0
3.4
8.9

4.
9.1

18.1
11.7
8.7
31.
10.7
2.
10.8
9.8
100.0
0.0
18.
-
2.0
21.8

.0

2.

77.
9.0

0.0
7.

1.
c.
94.
100.0
0.0
0.0

.9
8.
4.8
7.7
24.1
7.8
94.3
100.0
0.1
11.
8.8
32.4
8.0
27.4
11.7
93.3
100.0
0.0

.8
8.7
4.3

.8
24.1
9.3
c.
2010

477.8
17479.9
20.9
29804.4

44871.4
239.3
30141.
12424
48132.4
,
. USD
2010

177773
177
11
19218
147

4404
1344
4011
194
,

c.
2009
491.4
497.1
10.7
142.8
2719.8
409
2110.9
324.
11329.9

34.
,
. USD
2009

2.0
c.
200
179948
172419

309404.8
27487.4
2000

17492
13

. 3.1. ()
:
148384

2120.
921.
1033

427
1842
4788
1809
,

8
10193
24398.2
149978.1
2494.7
49719.3
14.
,
. USD
8
44.2
13337
708
2031
317
14938
,

200

44

12.7
3977.3
4321
1477.4
3087.9
,
. USD
2000

9
274
-

3824
11348

289
,

. 3.1.
7
. , . - :

1738
491781
0292

82934
8487
17040.7
3948
21190
1707.

474.3
114.4
:
2921

79107
4104.
40012.7
2092.
11102.9
412088.8
8221.8
3217

212
98089
980809
384
241
29
14321.7

148
1477.8
402
911208
442890
14.9
2800
1380.7

4200
-
701.9
2284

22771

37.
22

30447.3
3037.3
378.3
1119

84342.9
1720.9
21443.2
3441.2
24.4
347.4
,

10871
10838
29831
970
1140
48212
900
27
74
38.1
,
. USD

982
,

384
400.9
,
. USD
207
,

2009

,
. USD
200
1
,

2000

. 3.17.

704129.2
70388
194.9

42092
738.3
32907.9

329.1
1719.

33.2
110,1
,
. USD
2010
ICTSD

77

97.8


:
100.0

97.
100.0
3.2
99.8
100.0
0.
99.8
100.0
0.
2.
100.0
100.0
0.0
2.
3.2
2.

0.7
0.

91.
0.3
91.7
92.9
90.4
3.3
90.1

1.8

1.8
0.

0.9
3.3
100.0
100.0
0.1
2.
92.7
0.3
3.4
0.
0.4
100.0
100.0
2.8
91.4
0.1
4.
0.9
0.2
0.9
3.2
0.4
-
4.4
0.3

4.
0.3
0.1

0.2
0.0
0.2
0.1

0.1
0.0
0.2
100.0
100.0
2.8
91.2
0.1
4.7
0.9
0.2
0.1
0.0
c.
2010

0.
c.
2009

c.

200

0.0
c.
2000

. 3.18 ()
78
. , . - :

27130
3832
439373

124894
10094.8
784.3
429.8
2498.4
12.2
403.3

920.
124
1073.7
11219.
,
. USD
2000
:
1883

1841

39
19991

83381
4


3900

42011

. 3.19.
902407
838723

849
209
2782
1401
1988
49219
9020
1433
1293
,

471.
43177.8
3800.9
10840.
12220.1
8228.
11081
2904.9
4212.7

747.2

811.9
,
. USD
200
127217
11208
13321
8982
3170
43477
2190
1112
1308
4133
108187
,

101177
902879.
109387.2
782.9
2039.8
39721.7
191082.7
8911.8
11040.2
33.2
8899
,
. USD
2009

14809
1311114
1808
14194
40021
82944
23317
118812
1274
2297
120132
,

127410.4
1128122.4
112.3
1214
34130.
7480
209781.
980.8
131008.9
2049.1
10180.2
,
. USD
2010
ICTSD

79

4.2
0.0
23.2
4.4
7.

:
81.

 .

0.1

100.0
1.1

11.7
80.8
100.0
7.
4.3
24.
0.0
4.

.9
0.1
1.1

11.1
c.
2000

. 3.20. ()
92.9
100.0
8.2
2.
31.9
1.8
23.3

.9
10.8
0.2
1.

92.
100.0
8.3
2.
29.0
1.9
2.7

.7
9.8
0.2
1.9
c.

200
88.9
100.0
11.9
0.8
32.4
3.9
19.3
10.2
11.
0.4
9.

89.2
100.0
12.1
0.9
29.
4.4
21.2
9.9
12.2
0.4
9.
c.
2009
88.
100.0
14.2
1.1

30.

.3
17.8
9.1
11.7
0.2
9.2

88.
100.0
13.8
1.1
30.3

.
18.
8.7
11.
0.2
9.0
c.
2010
80
. , . - :

1229.9
12091.9
803.8

94.8
213.
2789.

32.7
37.
,
. USD
2000
3.
4.8

:
90.1
1.4

34.3

100.0
40.7

0.2
79.4
100.0

.
4.9

20.8
23.1
44.3
0.3
c.
2000
79.4
100.0
4.9
17.
44.1
22.3

.1
.1
77.1
100.0

.3
20.3
48.0
1.7
3.4
7.3
78.9
100.0

.1
17.9

8.1
9.9
4.
4.3


78.4
100.0

.2
17.8

7.
10.8
4.4
4.2
79.
100.0
4.
17.1

9.0
10.2
4.9
4.1
77.8
100.0
4.7
1.7

9.
10.7
4.3
3.9
c.
2010

3199.2
43014
2037.1

71904.2
297.
489.8
1871.4
17004
,
. USD
2010

37934
2928
1338

0028
1724
29941
1442
12142
,

c.
2009
4020.9
31780.
1424.

34.8
18311.
34299.3
1392.
13414.7
,
. USD

2009
c.
200
28724
2271
114
409
131773
2239
1033
9793
,

1414.4
112242.2

907.7
22830.2

388.9
17.9
3827
812.
,
. USD
200

21470
17009
8342
29980
7249

3797
827
1043
,

. 3.22. ()
:
4487


1412

1944

30

4042
13881

148

100

. 3.21.
ICTSD

81

SELECTED ICTSD ISSUE PAPERS

Agriculture Trade and Sustainable Development
The Impact of US Biofuel Policies on Agricultural Price Levels and olatility. B
y Bruce Babcock. Issue Paper o. 3, 2011.
Risk Management in Agriculture and the Future of the EUs Common Agricultural Poli
cy. By Stefan Tangermann. Issue Paper No. 34, 2011.
Policy Solutions To Agricultural Market Volatility: A Synthesis. By Stefan Tange
rmann. Issue Paper No. 33, 2011.
Composite Index of Market Access for the Export of Rice from the United States.
By Eric Wailes. Issue Paper No. 32, 2011.
Composite Index of Market Access for the Export of Rice from Thailand. By T. Dec
hachete. Issue Paper No. 31, 2011.
Composite Index of Market Access for the Export of Poultry from Brazil. By H. L.
Burnquist, C. C. da Costa, M. J. P. de Souza, L. M. Fassarella. Issue
Paper No. 30, 2011.
How Might the EUs Common Agricultural Policy Affect Trade and Development After 2
013? By A. Matthews. Issue Paper No. 29, 2010.
Food Security, Price Volatility and Trade: Some Reflections for Developing Count
ries. By Eugenio Daz-Bonilla and Juan Francisco Ron. Issue Paper No.
28, 2010.
Composite Index of Market Access for the Export of Rice from Uruguay. By Carlos
Perez Del Castillo and Daniela Alfaro. Issue Paper No. 27, 2010.
How Would A Trade Deal On Cotton Affect Exporting And Importing Countries? By Ma
rio Jales. Issue Paper No. 26, 2010.
Simulations on the Special Safeguard Mechanism: A Look at the December Draft Agr
iculture Modalities. By Raul Montemayor. Issue Paper No. 25, 2010.
Competitiveness and Sustainable Development
The Role of International Trade, Technology and Structural Change in Shifting La
bour Demands in South Africa. By H. Bhorat, C. van der Westhuizen
and S.Goga. Issue Paper No. 17, 2010.
Trade Integration and Labour Market Trends in India: an Unresolved Unemployment
Problem. By C.P. Chandrasekhar. Issue Paper No. 16, 2010.
The Impact of Trade Liberalization and the Global Economic Crisis on the Product
ive Sectors, Employment and Incomes in Mexico. By A. Puyana. Issue
Paper No. 15, 2010.
Globalization in Chile: A Positive Sum of Winners and Losers. By V. E. Tokman. I
ssue Paper No. 14, 2010.
Practical Aspects of Border Carbon Adjustment Measures Using a Trade Facilitatio
n Perspective to Assess Trade Costs. By Sofia Persson. Issue Paper
No.13, 2010.
Trade, Economic Vulnerability, Resilience and the Implications of Climate Change
in Small Island and Littoral Developing Economies. By Robert Read.
Issue Paper No.12, 2010.
The Potential Role of Non Traditional Donors Aid in Africa. By Peter Kragelund. I
ssue Paper No.11, 2010.
Aid for Trade and Climate Change Financing Mechanisms: Best Practices and Lesson
s Learned for LDCs and SVEs in Africa. By Vinaye Dey Ancharaz.
Issue Paper No.10, 2010.
Resilience Amidst Rising Tides: An Issue Paper on Trade, Climate Change and Comp
etitiveness in the Tourism Sector in the Caribbean. By Keron Niles.
Issue Paper No. 9, 2010.
Dispute Settlement and Legal Aspects of International Trade
Conflicting Rules and Clashing Courts. The Case of Multilateral Environmental Ag
reements, Free Trade Agreements and the WTO. By Pieter Jan Kuijper. Issue
Paper No.10, 2010.
Burden of Proof in WTO Dispute Settlement: Contemplating Preponderance of the Ev
idence. By James Headen Pfitzer and Sheila Sabune. Issue Paper No. 9, 2009.
Suspension of Concessions in the Services Sector: Legal, Technical and Economic
Problems. By Arthur E. Appleton. Issue Paper No. 7, 2009.

Trading Profiles and Developing Country Participation in the WTO Dispute Settlem
ent System. By Henrik Horn, Joseph Francois and Niklas Kaunitz. Issue Paper
No. 6, 2009.
Fisheries, International Trade and Sustainable Development
The Importance of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures to Fisheries Negotiations
in Economic Partnership Agreements. By Martin Doherty. Issue Paper
No. 7, 2008.
Fisheries, Aspects of ACP-EU Interim Economic Partnership Agreements: Trade and
Sustainable Development Implications. By Liam Campling. Issue
Paper No. 6, 2008.
Fisheries, International Trade and Sustainable Development. By ICTSD. Policy Dis
cussion Paper, 2006.
Innovation, Technology and Intellectual Property
The Influence of Preferential Trade Agreements on the Implementation of Intellec
tual Property Rights in Developing Countries. By Ermias Tekeste
Biadgleng and Jean-Christophe Maur. Issue Paper No. 33, 2011.
Intellectual Property Rights and International Technology Transfer to Address Cl
imate Change: Risks, Opportunities and Policy Options. By K. E.
Maskus and R. L. Okediji. Issue Paper No. 32, 2010
Intellectual Property Training and Education: A Development Perspective. By Jere
my de Beer and Chidi Oguamanam. Issue Paper No. 31, 2010.
An International Legal Framework for the Sharing of Pathogens: Issues and Challe
nges. By Frederick M. Abbott. Issue Paper No. 30, 2010.
Sustainable Development In International Intellectual Property Law New Approache
s From EU Economic Partnership Agreements? By Henning Grosse
Ruse Khan. Issue Paper No. 29, 2010.
Trade in Services and Sustainable Development
Facilitating Temporary Labour Mobility in African Least-Developed Countries: Add
ressing Mode 4 Supply-Side Constraints. By Sabrina Varma. Issue
Paper No.10, 2009.
Advancing Services Export Interests of Least-Developed Countries: Towards GATS C
ommitments on the Temporary Movement of natural Persons for
the Supply of Low-Skilled and Semi-Skilled Services. By Daniel Crosby, Issue Pap
er No. 9, 2009.
Maritime Transport and Related Logistics Services in Egypt. By Ahmed F. Ghoneim,
and Omneia A. Helmy. Issue Paper No. 8, 2007.
Environmental Goods and Services Programme
Harmonising Energy Efficiency Requirements Building Foundations for Co-operative
Action. By Rod Janssen. Issue Paper No. 14, 2010
Climate-related single-use environmental goods. By Rene Vossenaar. Issue Paper N
o.13, 2010.
Technology Mapping of the Renewable Energy, Buildings, and transport Sectors: Po
licy Drivers and International Trade Aspects: An ICTSD Synthesis
Paper. By Renee Vossenaar and Veena Jha. Issue Paper No.12, 2010.
Trade and Sustainable Energy
International Transport, Climate Change and Trade: What are the Options for Regu
lating Emissions from Aviation and Shipping and what will be their
Impact on Trade? By Joachim Monkelbaan. Background Paper, 2010.
Climate Change and Trade on the Road to Copenhagen. Policy Discussion Paper, 200
9.
Trade, Climate Change and Global Competitiveness: Opportunities and Challenge fo
r Sustainable Development in China and Beyond. By ICTSD.
Selected Issue Briefs No. 3, 2008.
Intellectual Property and Access to Clean Energy Technologies in Developing Coun
tries: An Analysis of Solar Photovoltaic, Biofuel and Wind
Technologies. By John H. Barton. Issue Paper No. 2, 2007.
Regionalism and EPAs
Questions Juridiques et Systmiques Dans les Accords de Partenariat conomique : Que
lle Voie Suivre Prsent ? By Cosmas Milton Obote Ochieng.

Issue Paper No. 8, 2010.

Rules of Origin in EU-ACP Economic Partnership Agreements. By Eckart Naumann. Is
sue Paper No. 7, 2010
SPS and TBT in the EPAs between the EU and the ACP Countries. By Denise Prvost. I
ssue Paper No. 6, 2010.
Los acuerdos comerciales y su relacin con las normas laborales: Estado actual del
arte. By Pablo Lazo Grandi. Issue Paper No. 5, 2010.
Revisiting Regional Trade Agreements and their Impact on Services and Trade. By
Mario Marconini. Issue Paper No. 4, 2010.
Trade Agreements and their Relation to Labour Standards: The Current Situation.
By Pablo Lazo Grandi. Issue Paper No. 3, 2009.
Global Economic Policy and Institutions
The Microcosm of Climate Change Negotiations: What Can the World Learn from the
European Union? By Hkan Nordstrm, Issue Paper No. 1, 2009.
These and other ICTSD resources are available at http://www.ictsd.org

www.ictsd.org
ICTSDs Programme on Agricultural Trade and Sustainable Development aims to promot
e food security, equity and environmental sustainability in agricultural trade.
Publications include:

Post-2013 EU Common Agricultural Policy, Trade and Development: A Review of

egislative
Proposals. By Alan Matthews. Issue paper No. 39, 2011.

Improving the International Governance of Food Security and Trade. By Manzoor Ah

mad. Issue
Paper No. 38, 2011.

Food Reserves in Developing Countries: Trade Policy Options for Improved Food Se
curity. By
C. L. Gilbert, Issue Paper No. 37, 2011.

Global Food Stamps: An Idea Worth Considering? By Tim Josling, Issue Paper No. 3
6, 2011.

Risk Management in Agriculture and the Future of the EUs Common Agricultural Poli
cy. By
Stefan Tangermann, Issue Paper No. 34, 2011.

Policy Solutions To Agricultural Market Volatility: A Synthesis. By Stefan Tange

rmann, Issue
Paper No. 33, 2011.

Composite Index of Market Access for the Export of Rice from the United States.
By Eric
Wailes. Issue Paper No. 32, 2011.

Composite Index of Market Access for the Export of Rice from Thailand. By T. Dec
hachete.
Issue Paper No. 31, 2011.

Composite Index of Market Access for the Export of Poultry from Brazil. By H. L.
Burnquist, C.
C. da Costa, M. J. P. de Souza, L. M. Fassarella. Issue Paper No. 30, 2011.

How Might the EUs Common Agricultural Policy Affect Trade and Development After 2

013? An
Analysis of the European Commissions November 2010 Communication. By Alan Matthew
s.
Issue Paper No. 29, 2010.

Food Security, Price Volatility and Trade: Some Reflections for Developing Count
ries. By
Eugenio Daz-Bonilla and Juan Francisco Ron. Issue Paper No. 28, 2010.

Composite Index of Market Access for the Export of Rice from Uruguay. By Carlos
Perez Del
Castillo and Daniela Alfaro. Issue Paper No. 27, 2010.

How Would A Trade Deal On Cotton Affect Exporting And Importing Countries? By Ma
rio Jales.
Issue Paper No. 26, 2010.

Simulations on the Special Safeguard Mechanism: A Look at the December 2008 Draf
t
Agriculture Modalities. By Raul Montemayor. Issue Paper No. 25, 2010.

How Would a Trade Deal on Sugar Affect Exporting and Importing Countries? By Ama
ni Elobeid.
Issue Paper No. 24, 2009.

Constructing a Composite Index of Market Acess. By Tim Josling. Issue Paper No.
23, 2009.

Comparing safeguard measures in regional and bilateral agreements. By Paul Kruge

r, Willemien
Denner and JB Cronje. Issue Paper No. 22, 2009.

How would a WTO agreement on bananas affect exporting and importing countries? B
y
Giovanni Anania. Issue Paper No. 21, 2009.

Biofuels Subsidies and the Law of the World Trade Organisation. By Toni Harmer.
Issue Paper
No. 20, 2009.

Biofuels Certification and the Law of the World Trade Organisation. By Marsha A.
Echols. Issue
Paper No. 19, 2009.

, www.ictsd.org.
(ICTSD), 199 .,
- , ,
, , , ,
, , ,
, ICTSD
,
. ICTSD
, , ,
.