Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
BLACKNWHITETHOUGHTSBLOG
SALAZAR VS J.Y BROTHERS (G.R. NO. 171998 OCTOBER 20, 2010)
Salazar vs J.Y Brothers Marketing Corporation
G.R. No. 171998 October 20, 2010
And, under Article 1231 of the Civil Code, obligations are extinguished:
xxxx
(6) By novation.
There are only two ways which indicate the presence of novation and
thereby produce the effect of extinguishing an obligation by another
which substitutes the same. First, novation must be explicitly stated
and declared in unequivocal terms as novation is never presumed.
Secondly, the old and the new obligations must be incompatible on
every point.1avvphi1 The test of incompatibility is whether or not the
two obligations can stand together, each one having its independent
existence. If they cannot, they are incompatible and the latter
obligation novates the first. In the instant case, there was no express
agreement that BA Finance's acceptance of the SBTC check will
discharge Nyco from liability. Neither is there incompatibility because
both checks were given precisely to terminate a single obligation
arising from Nyco's sale of credit to BA Finance. As novation speaks of
two distinct obligations, such is inapplicable to this case.16
Petitioner also contends that the acceptance of the Solid Bank check, a
non-negotiable check being a crossed check, which replaced the
dishonored Prudential Bank check, a negotiable check, is a new
obligation in lieu of the old obligation arising from the issuance of the
Prudential Bank check, since there was an essential change in the
circumstance of each check.
Considering that when the Solid Bank check, which replaced the
Prudential Bank check, was presented for payment, the same was
again dishonored; thus, the obligation which was secured by the
Prudential Bank check was not extinguished and the Prudential Bank
check was not discharged. Thus, we found no reversible error
committed by the CA in holding petitioner liable as an accommodation
indorser for the payment of the dishonored Prudential Bank check.