Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Post-Crisis Rebuilding
Xin Hua
Syracuse University
Introduction
Crisis situations for an organization consist of different forms, but one thing for sure is
that: No corporations have the immune system to the crisis (Saffitz, 2010, p. 6). Post-crisis
is a term used to describe the stage that takes place after a crisis. In the past decade, the whole
POST-CRISIS REBUILDING 2
world has experienced a period of persistent enterprise crisis, including product defects and
tensions, and mortgage fraud (Reed, 2014; Saffitz, 2010). This literature review focuses on
One corporations corporate social responsibility (CSR) contains its social, ethical and
environmental obligations to its supporters and the society (Saffitz, 2010). CSR activities are
a good way to help organizations build positive reputations (Coombs & Holladay, 2015).
More and more organizations use CSR as a marketing tool, which takes the responsibility
Corporate image is defined as the way that the organization wants the public to think
about it, while reputation is what the public actually thinks about it (Grebe, 2012). The brand
value and reputation in company decreases dramatically after a crisis (Falkheimer & Heide,
Being able to communicate accurately with its stakeholders is a critical ability to the
uncertainty variables between the organization and stakeholders, which in turn leads to a high
demand for more information (McDonald & Crawford, 2012). Therefore, rebuilding
confidence for stakeholders should be included (Taneja, Pryor, Sewell, & Recuero, 2014).
Applied Theories
To analyze the complex post-crisis rebuilding issue, researchers use a broad range of
Both qualitative and quantitative methods were applied to enhance the validity of the
research findings. Researchers conducted case study, experiment and survey as three basic
primary methods to do the analysis. This research is a single case study focusing on
Purpose
The purpose of this study is to review the recent researches on post-crisis rebuilding to
determine its implications for public relations and post-crisis management today; apply the
findings to the case study about background checks on Disney employees scandal in 2014;
Main Ideas
In many researches and theories, crisis is often taken as a whole to do the analysis.
However, post-crisis stage is lacking of research and theory that dedicated to the study of the
topic. The crisis is an unpredictable event that can have substantial long-term effects on a
particular organization if the situation is not dealt with effectively and efficiently (Taneja,
In order to get a better understanding of post-crisis, the research concluded three trends
relationship rebuilding. This review can draw upon the existing literature about post-crisis
Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) efforts can alleviate long-term brand image
damage and rebuild its reputation and relationships among consumers to a cooperation
without prior CSR history, which can benefit both society and business (Saffitz, 2010). For
organizations, crisis brings threat to the stability of the organizations, its image, legitimacy
and ultimately survival (Saffitz, 2010). Regardless of the nature of the crisis, corporate may
suffer a serious defeat the loss of trust. Therefore, it is crucial to do the research on post-
crisis CSR strategy and what outcome the strategy may bring to the post-crisis rebuilding for
One interesting case study is the Dove Campaign for Real Beauty. The first ten years of
the Dove Campaign for Real Beauty in the United States to determine its impact on public
relations industry and current corporate social responsibility (CSR) and emphasizing the
between CSR and caused marketing or traditional marketing campaigns that CSR expands the
corporate expertise and culture to social demands and interests (Goins, 2016). CSR serve a
role that help to protect a company during a crisis, at the same time, CSR also been seen as an
opportunity to rebuild its image and renew its reputation after crisis.
Moreover, CSR initiatives have the potential ability to build stronger relationships
between companies and stakeholders. CSR as a means of creating stakeholder value, which
maintained a consistent perspective with Barnett (2007) who argued that CSR consists of
specific firm investments. According to the study done by Peloza & Shang (2011), there are
The role of corporate social responsibility (CSR) as a crisis risk rather than an asset in a
irresponsible. CSR efforts can be seen as asset and cushion the corporation from harm as well
as rebuild the reputation in actual crisis cases. But the buffering value of CSR was negative
POST-CRISIS REBUILDING 5
when a crisis violated CSR prospects. CSR and crises have a much more complicated
relationship than current research. At the same time, CSR itself can be a potential threat for
cooperation rather than an asset used to protect a reputation during or after a crisis.
We are experiencing an ages of crisis in the past decade, even the general public can
notice that that there have been continually corporate crises: product defects and recalls,
insider trading, corporate malfeasance, mortgage fraud, and other wrong-doing that has led to
global financial crises (Reed, 2014). Because of the crisis, it requests crisis managers to have
a set of communication strategies to communicate with both internal and external audiences,
such as employees, stakeholders and consumers. Traditionally, the print, radio, and television
media outlets are the most primary methods for PR professionals to communicate with its
audiences, however, corporate communications strategies have included the online social
media platform such as Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn. In other word, the way that the
consume news and information have been shaped by social media in recent years (Reed,
2014). Therefore, the image and reputation restoration not only related to how an
organization responds to the crisis, also what media outlets they use.
The AWB case serve as a negative example, which failed to demonstrate an initial crisis
response that would meet the requirements of the society and their key stakeholders. In the
case of AWB, the company avoided taking responsibility and their insincerely apology only
showed that they were trying to defend themselves. The AWB failed to comfort the key
stakeholders and community, which made the company hard to achieve forgiveness and
rebuild their reputation. When corporations dont admit their mistakes cant achieve real
reforms to solve the problems, then it will harm its reputation and image after crisis.
On the other hand, the relationship between post-crisis media communication channel
POST-CRISIS REBUILDING 6
and consumer behavior that showed brand trust levels. There is no doubt that the product
crises have the negative influence on brand trust. According to study done by Reed (2014),
there are three main corporate crisis response strategies: (a) accommodative, (b) defensive (c)
full apology, mortification or compensation. Its a behavior of admitting mistakes and asking
for forgiveness, may including some compensation. At the same time, the organization takes
full responsibility for the crisis. This strategy can help organization repair its image.
Defensive strategy refers to minimizing the perceived damage associated with the crisis
(Reed, 2014, p9). The organization may state that no serious damages or the victims
deserved what they received (Reed, 2014, p9). This strategy may include the statement of
denying any intention to injury, which will minimize the organizations responsibility for the
crisis. Therefore, accommodative and blended crisis response strategies have the positive
impact on recovering damaged brand trust at post-crisis stage. Trust played a critical role in
rebuilding corporate reputation/image and concluded the most efficient way to recover brand
trust is to use three crisis strategies through two media channels (traditional online or online
By reviewing the Findus Nordic and the Horsemeat Scandal, it shows that the important
role of a trust recovery campaign in post-crisis. A trust recovery campaign can help accelerate
the image retrieval whether it was involved with ordinary visitors or not. Also a trust
recovery campaign should be set up and launched as soon as possible after a crisis. Moreover,
parallel with external trust building campaigns, an organization should also intend to recover
The reputation restoration after crisis also can apply to how nations (U.S.), which was
accused of triggering the financial crisis, has affected the global economy and repaired its
image. The study used rhetorical analysis of speeches and news reports from September 8,
POST-CRISIS REBUILDING 7
2008 (start of the U.S. financial crisis) to November, 2009 (culmination). Three out of 12
articles were found to be relevant in image repair studies, including news reports such as the
New York Times, USA Today and The Wall Street Journal. The researchers utilized image
repair theory to analyze the strategies that were used by the U.S. government to recover its
image during the 2008 financial crisis. Hiebert (2005) argued that success in diplomacy
occurs when communication is credible and when words match action (p. 320). The
consistency of speech and action will establish credibility, which can help repair U.S.
governments image after the crisis. Also the use of clarity, dialogue and ease tensions
contents via new media platform can complement the lack of mainstream media.
Winning the trust from stakeholders is the essential step after crisis. Stakeholders may
upset when a crisis happens because they believe the organization has violated their
expectations, and the crisis may would affect the perception by stakeholders toward the
organization.
reviewing a case study called the Helicopter Task Group (HTG), instead of following the
focused on promoting the dialogue between public, stakeholders and leaders, to create a
consensus to rebuild the corporate. The case study shows us the post-crisis strategy should go
beyond the crisis and apply efficient crisis communication with the wider community.
Moreover, generating safety culture and building stakeholder relationships is important for an
On the other hand, it is necessary to have crisis management and a corporate leader to
communicate with stakeholders. Because a successful crisis management has to deal with a
POST-CRISIS REBUILDING 8
lot of urgent issues and their stakeholders (Taneja, Pryor, Sewell, & Recuero, 2014). Also the
first person, who reacts to the crisis, takes an essential role. Because the first phase of crisis
management and the first actions you take always turn out to be a critical phase. Every crisis
needs a proper communicational way to reach those key individuals in the organization,
which can resolve the crisis efficiently and effectively. At the same time, the corporate should
have a balance between the corporate and its stakeholders to guarantee a higher degree of
participation in between. According to the study done by Taneja, Pryor, Sewell, & Recuero
(2014) that rebuilding the confidence for employees and stakeholders in the post-crisis stage
structuration, which conducted a communicative impact on the micro level, the meso level,
and the macro level. The key of securing a long-term organizational reputation is to have a
Ingenhoff, 2011), because a good reputation among stakeholders can secure a faster image
the four crisis causes on stakeholders responses, are also very important. Base on Weiners
Attribution Theory (WAT) and Situational Crisis Communication Theory (SCCT), confession
can increase stakeholders sympathy, loyalty, and attitude. Although confession means the
organization takes the crisis responsibility, denial will trigger strong negative stakeholder
reactions. Furthermore, media usually is the sender of all the crisis causes to the stakeholders,
and then the media relations strategy should focus on mitigating adverse reactions.
Summary
From the literature review of CSR initiatives, reputation restoration, and stakeholder
The conjunction of all three trends is a more efficient way to deal with post-crisis
CSR initiatives are a good way to help organizations build positive reputations, which may
help rebuild its trust and reputation during crisis. Second, prioritizing stakeholders correctly
is the key to good crisis management. Sometime the crisis management teams can get too
focused on the crisis itself and forget to effectively communicate with their stakeholders.
opportunity, and the realization of that opportunity needs employees support the crisis
management of the company facing clients, institutions, the media and society as a whole.
The critical stakeholder reactions may get involved with their emotional reaction
(Falkheimer & Heide, 2015). There are three emotions that tend to dominate crises: anger,
stakeholders are sympathy for the crisis and the organization, the stakeholders may support
the organization and try to help in some way during the crisis. Anxiety is the most common
emotion in product harm or other crises that directly threaten stakeholders safety or interests.
Therefore, the crisis manager should establish corrective actions to prevent another crisis
important during a crisis. Because employees are the credible source of information about an
organization. Any of their friends or family members may have the possibility to get
information from them. If the employees are unaware of the current situation of the crisis,
then it may bring a negative perception of the organization. Therefore, the crisis manager
POST-CRISIS REBUILDING 10
should treat employees as an asset that should be informed rather than ignored during a crisis.
Although the implement of CSR, stakeholder relationships and image restoration are all
important elements to post-crisis rebuilding, there are very few research integrate these three
aspects together. The implement of CSR address those CSR initiatives can bring good
reputation to an organization and can accelerate the reputation repairing speech during crisis.
Because a crisis causes incalculable uncertainty variables between the organization and
stakeholders, which in turn leads to a high demand for more information. Except for
emphasizing on external stakeholder relationship rebuilding, but also take the internal
communication into consideration. The main difficulty is defining the best way of post-crisis
rebuilding, because there are many variables are included in this certain situation.
As with most communication theories, most of the literature reviewed here is qualitative
in nature. There three major drawbacks of qualitative research methodology. First, the
issue. Since all interpretations and finding are limited, there may exist personal and
knowledge influence on the observations and results. Considered the nature of qualitative
research methodology that is generally open-ended, the qualitative inquiry may need more
data to be collected. Last, the data that been collected is not objectively confirmable.
However, because qualitative method is open-ended, which allow participants to raise the
However, there may still need more research to be done in the future, to do the research
in post-crisis rebuilding in depth. The strength of the integration research upon three trends is
Analysis
The following case study focus on the post-crisis management effort of the major
multinational mass media and entertainment conglomerate The Walt Disney Company in
response to the background checks on Disney employees scandal in 2014. Ever since
Disney creation in 1955, Disneyland, as a global well-known brand, has been known as "the
happiest place on earth." When people mention the word Disney, you will have a fantasy
image in your mind. Maybe you will bring the Small World, Mickey Mouth or Winne-
the-Pooh to mind.
While Disney owns its strong brand reputation, they have been attempting to restore their
image and rebuild their reputation after crisis as well. This case study will explore the 2014
Background Checks on Disney Employees Scandal, and how the established three trends
On July, 2014, CNN reports that at least 35 Disney employees in and around Florida
have been arrested and accused of sex crimes involving children since 2006, as part of a six-
month investigation. Disney, known as the perfect family-friendly travel destiny, however, a
report on the CNN news reveals that 35 Disney employees with felonious records who
should not be eligible for employment, and Disney Theme Park employees caught in sex
stings, child porn arrests. Obviously, parents are scared by those creepers are still at the
working spot in Disney Theme Park, and start online protest to require Disney address the
issue. In addition to the online activism, lots of news outlets have also pitched on it with the
The arrested Disney employees, who ranged from maintenance workers to tour guides to
security guards, were charged including possession of child pornography and trying to meet a
POST-CRISIS REBUILDING 12
After CNNs report, The numbers reported by CNN represent one one-hundredth of one
percent of the 300,000 people we have employed during this time period, Disney said in a
statement. We continue to work closely with law enforcement and organizations like the
National Center for Missing and Exploited Children as we constantly strengthen our efforts.
Disney also addresses that it has extensive measures in place to block child predators
before theyre employed, including background checks and computer monitoring. According
environment. We will acknowledge the concern recently raised by the public that
background checks have not been performed for all employees and we will express how
we have the same concern that has been brought to light. We do believe our parks and
cruises ships are safe environments for all ages with no reports of child-predator crimes,
but we actively are working to improve this perception and to assure our guests that they
After Disney this press release, Disney also post a video version of their press release
and article version as well on their official website. They also post the link of the press
release on all of their social media platforms. Moreover, Disney started running background
checks on all current employees immediately, but appropriate manner right after crisis.
Connections and Gaps between the Literature Review and Case Study
The Disney case study contains all of the major trends emphasized in this literature
review. Disney has been practicing CSR on childhood obesity, healthy nutrition, the
environment, community, labor standards and volunteerism issues for a long time; they have
informed their stakeholders on both social media and press release; they rebuilt their trust and
While this case study fits very well to the post-crisis rebuilding strategies established
here, there are still several limitations. First, because of the current nature of crisis, this study
does not have any quantitative measures to verify the impact of any Disney CSR activities on
post-crisis rebuilding. Secondly, it is difficult to measure the damage of crisis that bring to
In overview, Disney has well-handled the crisis by utilizing three trends, instead of pre-
crisis CSR, it is lacking of post-crisis CSR activities, and therefore, still suffers from
significant image rebuilding problems. Disney has noticed the importance of CSR initiatives
for long-term to build a strong brand loyalty and company reputation, also well-
As the largest media and entertainment conglomerate in the world, Disney has the
responsibility to give back to the community who have helped it become the empire today.
CSR efforts can be seen as asset and cushion the corporation from harm as well as rebuild the
reputation in actual crisis cases. Disneys long-term pre-CSR initiatives help it build a strong
brand loyalty and an indestructible brand image. Although those CSR activities cannot
change the reality that Disney did hired some employees with felonious records, but the CSR
activities can alleviate the negative influences and use CSR as a marketing tool, which takes
The Situational Crisis Communication Theory (SCCT) has been perfectly applied to this
case study. Due to the negligence of background investigation before recruiting, Disney has
hired employees with felonious records who should not be eligible for employment, which
may put their stakeholders at risk situation and reduce its credibility of the brand. According
to the SCCT, organizational guilt belongs to the preventable cluster, which Disney knowingly
placed people at risk, took inappropriate actions hiring ineligible employees. The company
POST-CRISIS REBUILDING 14
chooses rebuild crisis response strategies, which including compensation and apology. Base
social/environmental groups, media and competitors. Within the literature review, with the
emergency of social media platform, the image and reputation restoration not only related to
how an organization responds to the crisis, also what media outlets they use. Therefore, to
have a better communication with their stakeholders, Disney actively post updates of the
crisis and inform all stakeholders, also respond to comments and questions via different
media outlets.
For this case, Disney has reached their stakeholders in several different ways. The press
release has two versions, both video and article version, which have post on website and
connect the link to each social media platforms as well. For stockholders/investors,
consumers and competitors, Disney use press release that been posted on the website and
other social media platforms to reach out them. But for other stakeholders such as partners,
government organizations should generate other communication methods to reach out them,
for instance, e-mail, phone, in person, face-to-face will be the best way. And for the media,
Disney should have a press conference to address this issue to all media outlets.
compared to pre-crisis avoidance, post-crisis rebuilding has more specific rules to follow.
Even though crisis management are a frequently cited necessity in public relation field, there
are only few studies to guide crisis mangers or public relations practitioners. Below is a list of
POST-CRISIS REBUILDING 15
1. Establish CSR initiatives before a crisis happens or after crisis also helps.
Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) efforts can alleviate long-term brand image
cooperation without prior CSR history, which can benefit both society and business
(Saffitz, 2010). According to a study done by Goins (2016), CSR initiatives are able
mouth. Disney company put effort in the environment, community, and labor
give back to their communities doing volunteer job by offering free tickets in
exchange for a day of volunteer service. The company established The Disney
organization to protect wild animals and ecological system, and have a positive
impact on society. The long-term CSR strategies helps Disney build a strong brand
loyalty and positive reputation, which can help repair its image during post-crisis
stage.
Stakeholders may upset and lose their trust when a crisis happens because they
believe the organization has violated their expectations, and the crisis may would
practitioners should inform stakeholders and timely update what is the company
doing to deal with the crisis situation. Disney did really great job by communicating
with its stakeholders, especially consumers. While for The Walt Disney Company,
References
Campbell, A. (n.d.). 35 Disney employees arrested on child sex charges in less than 10 years.
charges_n_5587395.htm
Chua, A. A., & Pang, A. (2012). US government efforts to repair its image after the 2008
doi:10.1016/j.pubrev.2011.11.003
Coombs, T., & Holladay, S. (2015). CSR as crisis risk: Expanding how we conceptualize the
doi:10.1108/ccij-10-2013-0078
Falkheimer, J., & Heide, M. (2015). Trust and brand recovery campaigns in crisis: Findus
9(2), 134-147.
doi:10.1080/1553118x.2015.1008636
Goins, K. E. (2016). Dove campaign for real beauty (Order No. 10127929). Available from
http://search.proquest.com/docview/1798843744?accountid=14214
Grebe, S. (2012). Getting it right from the start: How the initial crisis response by scandalized
doi:10.1108/13563281211220300
POST-CRISIS REBUILDING 17
Mcdonald, L. M., Sparks, B., & Glendon, A. I. (2010). Stakeholder reactions to company
doi:10.1016/j.pubrev.2010.04.004
Peloza, J., & Shang, J. (2010). How can corporate social responsibility activities create value
39(1), 117-135.
doi:10.1007/s11747-010-0213-6
Phillips, K., & Zamost, S. (n.d.). Theme park employees caught in sex stings, child porn
sex-stings/index.html
strategies and repairing damaged trust (Order No. 3637483). Available from ProQuest
http://search.proquest.com.libezproxy2.syr.edu/docview/1617525706?accountid=14214
Report: 35 Disney World employees arrested for sex abuse crimes since 2006. (n.d.).
arrested-for-sex-abuse-crimes-since-2006/
strategy for post-crisis rebuilding and renewal (Order No. 1476187). Available from
from http://search.proquest.com.libezproxy2.syr.edu/docview/366305822?
accountid=14214
Taneja, S., Pryor, M. G., Sewell, S., & Recuero, A. M. (2014). Strategic crisis management: A
basis for renewal and crisis prevention. Journal of Management Policy and Practice,
15(1), 78-85.
POST-CRISIS REBUILDING 18
The Walt Disney Company - A leader in corporate social responsibility. (2013). Retrieved
from http://www.businessreviewusa.com/leadership/3827/The-Walt-Disney-Company-A-
Leader-In-Corporate-Social-Responsibility
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Walt_Disney_Company
Thiessen, A., & Ingenhoff, D. (2011). Safeguarding reputation through strategic, integrated
doi:10.1108/13563281111100944