Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Clinical Neurophysiology
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/clinph
a r t i c l e i n f o h i g h l i g h t s
Article history:
Ipsilateral MTL neurons show an increased degree of burstiness during interictal recordings.
Accepted 15 August 2016
This effect is found only for putative principal cells, not for interneurons.
Available online 20 August 2016
Burstiness may serve as a protective factor and its absence may in turn facilitate seizure emergence.
Keywords:
Burstiness
Interictal a b s t r a c t
Pre-ictal
Interneurons
Objective: To better understand the mechanisms that lead to the sudden and unexpected occurrence of
Principal cells seizures, with the neuronal correlate being abnormally synchronous discharges that disrupt neuronal
function.
Methods: To address this problem, we recorded single neuron activity in epilepsy patients during the
transition to seizures to uncover specific changes of neuronal firing patterns. We focused particularly
on neurons repeatedly firing discrete groups of high-frequency action potentials (so called bursters) that
have been associated with ictogenesis. We analyzed a total of 459 single neurons and used the mean
autocorrelation time as a quantitative measure of burstiness. To unravel the intricate roles of excitation
and inhibition, we also examined differential contributions from putative principal cells and interneu-
rons.
Results: During interictal recordings, burstiness was significantly higher in the seizure onset hemisphere,
an effect found only for principal cells, but not for interneurons, and which disappeared before seizures.
Conclusion: These findings deviate from conventional views of ictogenesis that propose slowly-increasing
aggregates of bursting neurons which give rise to seizures once they reach a critical mass.
Significance: Instead our results are in line with recent hypotheses that bursting may represent a protec-
tive mechanism by preventing direct transmission of postsynaptic high-frequency oscillations.
2016 International Federation of Clinical Neurophysiology. Published by Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights
reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.clinph.2016.08.010
1388-2457/ 2016 International Federation of Clinical Neurophysiology. Published by Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
3330 H. Gast et al. / Clinical Neurophysiology 127 (2016) 33293334
high-frequency action potentials, has been associated with chronic peak-amplitude-to-noise level, the inter-spike interval (ISI)
epilepsy both in experimental models of epilepsy and in humans distribution of each cluster, and presence of a refractory period.
(Wyler and Ward, 1986; Sanabria et al., 2001; Schindler et al., Multi-units and artifacts were excluded from further analysis. A
2006). To date only a few in vivo studies in humans have investi- total of 249 SU were recorded interictally and 210 pre-ictally
gated bursting and its relevance to the pathophysiology of epi- (mean number per patient 23 interictally and 30 pre-ictally).
lepsy. These few studies have yielded conflicting results. Earlier Fig. 1 shows an example of an intracranial LFP recorded with a
studies compared seizure onset zones to contralateral brain microwire capturing two different SU.
regions during seizure-free (interictal) periods and reported burst Electrode locations were determined by clinical criteria and ver-
discharges to be less frequent ipsilaterally (Colder et al., 1996). In ified by MRI and CT. All patients had bilaterally implanted depth
contrast, other studies found higher burst rates in seizure onset electrodes, each equipped with 8 cylindrical contacts, in multiple
zones in MTL epilepsy (MTLE) (Staba et al., 2002). Single cells sites of the MTL, including hippocampus, amygdala, entorhinal cor-
recorded in close proximity to the seizure onset zone tended to tex and parahippocampal cortex. Total recording time analyzed
have higher bursting rates if they showed pre-ictal and ictal from these patient (interictal and pre-ictal) was 300 min (see
changes in spiking rates (Keller et al., 2010). Finally, burst inter- Table 1).
spike interval ratios have been used to predict seizure onset zones Recordings were performed continuously for the entire dura-
from interictal recordings (Valdez et al., 2013). tion of the epilepsy monitoring (typically 714 days). Eleven inter-
The relation between interictal epileptiform EEG activity and ictal sessions were recorded one or two days after electrode
neuronal bursting has also been investigated. Neurons whose firing implantation. In 8 of the 11 patients, a total of 21 seizures were
rates were modulated by interictal discharges had a significantly recorded and analyzed. All seizures occurred at least one day after
higher bursting rate than neurons not showing this modulation the interictal recordings. Pre-ictal recordings covered the period of
(Keller et al., 2010). Alarcn and colleagues reported an increased 10 min before seizure onset as determined from the intracranial
occurrence of burst firing during spontaneous interictal epilepti- macro electrode recordings via joint visual inspection by two
form discharges and after single pulse electrical stimulation board-certified electroencephalographers (H.G. and F.M.). Electro-
(Alarcn et al., 2012). clinical evaluation of interictal and ictal recordings confirmed that
The analysis methods employed by these studies, particularly seizures typically started near the most medial contacts of the clin-
the definition of bursting, varied considerably, and most were car- ical depth electrodes (Supplementary Table S1).
ried out on limited data sets. This might explain why no consistent Based on electrographical seizure onset, or postoperative sei-
relationship between burst firing and localization of the seizure zure control in those cases where no seizure could be recorded,
onset zone has been demonstrated to date. electrodes were labeled ipsilateral or contralateral, depending on
We here examined the role of bursting neurons in the emer- their location with respect to the seizure onset and/or resection
gence of clinical seizures. We analyzed simultaneous recordings zone. Note that not all of the 11 patients included in this study
from the MTLs ipsi- and contralateral to the seizure onset zone went on to have surgery, and of those who did, not all became
in patients with MTLE both during the seizure-free interval and seizure-free (Table 1). Nevertheless, at the time of electro-clinical
immediately before seizures. To unravel the intricate and poten- evaluation all 11 patients were diagnosed as unilateral MTLE, and
tially counterintuitive roles of excitation and inhibition, we also therefore included in this study.
studied the differential contributions of putative principal cells
and interneurons.
2.3. Analysis of electrophysiological data
Table 1
Summary of clinical data. H.S.: hippocampal sclerosis; SAH: selective amygdalo-hippocampectomy. Seizure outcome according to Engel classification.
Pat. No. Gender Age MRI Resection Histo-pathological Seizure Number Total pre-ictal Number of Seizure
(years) findings findings outcome of time micro- onset
seizures analyzed wires hemisphere
(min) in MTL
1 m 37 Normal Left SAH Left H.S. 1A 3 30 64 Left
2 f 26 Normal No surgery n/a n/a 1 10 80 Left
3 f 56 Left H.S. No surgery n/a n/a 0 0 64 Left
4 f 43 Normal Left SAH Focal loss of neurons 3 4 30 80 Left
5 f 48 Normal Right SAH Focal loss of neurons 1B 0 0 80 Right
6 f 29 Normal No surgery n/a n/a 5 50 88 Right
7 f 38 Right H.S. Right SAH Right H.S. 1A 0 0 64 Right
8 m 33 Normal No surgery n/a n/a 2 20 80 Left
9 m 44 Normal Left SAH + Cell loss, gliosis, heterotopia. 1A 2 20 72 Left
lesionectomy
10 m 54 Right H.S. Right SAH Right H.S. 3 1 10 64 Right
11 f 42 Normal Right SAH Gliosis 1A 3 20 64 Right
4. Discussion
dynamic features might change just before a seizure, we restricted
this analysis to interictally recorded neurons (Supplementary A fundamental question in epileptology is what mechanisms
Fig. S2A). Interneurons showed higher firing activity than principal are responsible for changing the state of the epileptic brain from
cells (p = 0.012, Wilcoxon ranksum test, Supplementary Fig. S2B) interictal to ictal. We here investigated this question at the cellular
while principal cells exhibited a stronger tendency for burstiness level by assessing the role of burst firing by single neurons. We
(p < 10 4, Supplementary Fig. S2C). analyzed interictal and pre-ictal recordings from regions ipsi-
As a first exploratory analysis, we applied a two-way ANOVA and contralateral to the seizure onset zone in the MTLs of 11
with factors time (interictal vs. pre-ictal) and location (ipsi- vs. patients. To investigate the roles of excitation and inhibition, we
contralateral) to all 459 recorded neurons. Results yielded a signif- examined the differential contributions of putative principal cells
icant main effect of location on burstiness (F1455 = 12.0; and interneurons. We found that burst firing was higher in the ipsi-
p = 0.0006). Neither a significant main effect of time (F1455 = 0.09; lateral MTL during interictal recordings. Interestingly, the signifi-
p = 0.77) nor a significant interaction between time and location cant difference in burst firing between the ipsi- and contralateral
(F1455 = 1.72; p = 0.19) were observed. Post hoc Wilcoxon ranksum MTL was found exclusively in principal cells, not in interneurons,
tests with Bonferroni correction confirmed higher burstiness in and disappeared in pre-ictal recordings.
3332 H. Gast et al. / Clinical Neurophysiology 127 (2016) 33293334
Fig. 2. Burstiness of different cell types as quantified by the mean autocorrelation time (MAT). (A) MAT histograms of all recorded cells for the conditions interictal/ipsilateral
(top left, red), interictal/contralateral (bottom left, green), pre-ictal/ipsilateral (top right, black), and pre-ictal/contralateral (bottom right, blue), flanked by results of posthoc
Wilcoxon ranksum tests after Bonferroni correction. (B) Same as (A), but for putative principal cells only. (C) Same as (A), but for putative interneurons only. N, number of
neurons; int-ict, interictal; pre-ict, pre-ictal; n.s., not significant; p < 0.05; p < 0.01; p < 0.001. (For interpretation of the references to color in this figure legend, the reader
is referred to the web version of this article.)
H. Gast et al. / Clinical Neurophysiology 127 (2016) 33293334 3333
Increased burst firing in the ipsilateral MTL during interictal The fact that we found interictal burst firing to be significantly
recordings agrees with previous observations (Staba et al., 2002). more pronounced in the focal MTL may bear clinical relevance
These findings deviate from an older study in which authors since it could provide diagnostically important information even
describe a weakly significant overall reduction in interictal burst before an actual seizure has occurred. Gaining all clinically relevant
discharges in ipsilateral MTL structures (Colder et al., 1996). This information from interictal recordings has been a long-standing
study, however, used the area under the first significant peak in goal in presurgical evaluation because this could potentially reduce
the autocorrelogram within the first 150 ms as a measure of bursti- the number of seizures to be recorded. A smaller number of sei-
ness. This measure is strongly biased by the average firing rate and zures reduces the duration of intracranial monitoring and thus
will pick up any cell with preferred ISIs up to 150 ms, many of decreases the risk of complications such as infections.
which would not be considered bursty in a stricter sense. Thus, In conclusion, our study demonstrates that seizures in MTLE are
the reported difference may merely be an artifact of firing rate, preceded by altered burstiness of principal cells with respect to
which was indeed reported to be higher in the contralateral MTL interictal baseline recordings in the ipsilateral MTL. Rather than
(Colder et al., 1996). supporting conventional views of ictogenesis that propose
How can a pre-ictal reduction of bursting be interpreted in slowly-increasing aggregates of bursting neurons, our findings
terms of a transition from the interictal to an ictal brain state? are in line with recent hypotheses that bursting may represent a
The fact that interictal burst firing was significantly more pro- protective mechanism by preventing direct transmission of postsy-
nounced ipsilaterally but then decreased and was no longer differ- naptic high-frequency oscillations. Future studies investigating the
ent from the contralateral hemisphere in the minutes before interplay between interneurons and principal cells as well as the
seizure onset contradicts traditional views of ictogenesis. Accord- correlation of neuronal activity with LFP events such as epileptic
ing to these views, excitation, e.g. in the form of bursting principal spikes and HFOs might offer possibilities to entertain alternative,
cells, should steadily build up until a critical mass is reached, non-canonical mechanistic models for seizure initiation in human
which then leads to uncontrolled activity in the form of a seizure epilepsy.
that dissipates and resets the accumulated excitation (Lennox,
1941). Instead, our study demonstrates that the excess burstiness
Acknowledgements
in the ipsilateral MTL is significantly reduced during the transition
to seizure. Could differences in pre-ictal synaptic input dynamics
We thank Christopher John for help with the clinical data. This
lead to reduced bursting? A characterization of input patterns that
research was supported by grants from the Volkswagen
lead to synaptically driven bursting has shown that fast oscillations
Foundation (Lichtenberg Program), the German Research Council
of input currents >100 Hz are most likely to generate bursting
(SFB 1089 and MO 930/4-1), and the European Commission (FP7
(Schindler et al., 2006). Thus, any change in spectral patterns of
602102 EPITARGET).
input that transitions out of this range might cause reduced burst-
Conflict of interest: None.
ing. This does not preclude that inputs may become more syn-
chronous in the pre-ictal period, giving rise to highly structured,
regular firing as a precursor to seizures. Appendix A. Supplementary data
Bursting could thus help to dissipate fast oscillations by pre-
venting their direct transmission and thereby reflect a seizure- Supplementary data associated with this article can be found, in
protective mechanism. Increased interictal occurrence of high- the online version, at http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.clinph.2016.08.
frequency oscillations (HFOs) has been shown to be highly specific 010.
for the seizure onset zone in patients with MTLE (Haegelen et al.,
2013). However, their occurrence rate does not change systemati-
References
cally before seizures (Jacobs et al., 2009), and recent evidence sug-
gests that underlying mechanisms of interictal HFOs differ from Alarcn G, Martinez J, Kerai SV, Lacruz ME, Quiroga RQ, Selway RP, et al. In vivo
those of high-frequency activity during seizure onset (de Curtis neuronal firing patterns during human epileptiform discharges replicated by
and Avoli, 2016). One may therefore speculate that the pre-ictal electrical stimulation. Clin Neurophysiol 2012;123:173644.
Bower MR, Stead M, Meyer FB, Marsh WR, Worrell GA. Spatiotemporal neuronal
decrease in bursting in the ipsilateral MTL may play a causal role correlates of seizure generation in focal epilepsy. Epilepsia 2012;53:80716.
in the generation of seizures. Chen S, Su H, Yue C, Remy S, Royeck M, Sochivko D, et al. An increase in persistent
Note that for most patients, anti-epileptic drugs (AEDs) were sodium current contributes to intrinsic neuronal bursting after status
epilepticus. J Neurophysiol 2011;105:11729.
gradually tapered off in order to increase the likelihood of seizure Colder BW, Frysinger RC, Wilson CL, Harper RM, Engel J. Decreased neuronal burst
occurrence a procedure that is standard practice for epilepsy discharge near site of seizure onset in epileptic human temporal lobes. Epilepsia
monitoring. AED blood levels were therefore in general lower dur- 1996;37:11321.
Csicsvari J, Hirase H, Czurko A, Buzski G. Reliability and state dependence of
ing pre-ictal recordings than during interictal recordings. Reduced pyramidal cell-interneuron synapses in the hippocampus: an ensemble
AED levels, however, would be expected to result in an increased approach in the behaving rat. Neuron 1998;21:17989.
rather than a decreased burstiness as observed in our study de Curtis M, Avoli M. GABAergic networks jump-start focal seizures. Epilepsia
2016;57:67987.
(Chen et al., 2011; Uebachs et al., 2012). It therefore appears unli-
Haegelen C, Perucca P, Chtillon C-E, Andrade-Valena L, Zelmann R, Jacobs J, et al.
kely that the changes in neuronal dynamics found in this study are High-frequency oscillations, extent of surgical resection, and surgical outcome
merely attributable to AED blood levels per se, but instead are more in drug-resistant focal epilepsy. Epilepsia 2013;54:84857.
Ison MJ, Mormann F, Cerf M, Koch C, Fried I, Quiroga RQ. Selectivity of pyramidal
likely to reflect general mechanisms of ictogenesis.
cells and interneurons in the human medial temporal lobe. J Neurophysiol
As our recordings continue, we will be able to collect a succes- 2011;106:171321.
sively larger number of pairs of interneurons/principal cells Jacobs J, Zelmann R, Jirsch J, Chander R, Dubeau C-ECF, Gotman J. High frequency
recorded from the same microwire bundle. This will allow us to oscillations (80500 Hz) in the preictal period in patients with focal seizures.
Epilepsia 2009;50:178092.
scrutinize their interaction and shed light on the intricate interplay Keller CJ, Truccolo W, Gale JT, Eskandar E, Thesen T, Carlson C, et al. Heterogeneous
between these inhibitory and excitatory groups of neurons before neuronal firing patterns during interictal epileptiform discharges in the human
seizures. It will furthermore provide us with the necessary statisti- cortex. Brain 2010;133:166881.
Lennox WG. The causes of seizures. Science and seizures. New York: Harper; 1941.
cal power to individually assess the contributions of different MTL Mormann F, Jefferys JGR. Neuronal firing in human epileptic cortex: the ins and outs
subregions to the changes described in this study. of synchrony during seizures. Epilepsy Curr 2013;13:1002.
3334 H. Gast et al. / Clinical Neurophysiology 127 (2016) 33293334
Quiroga RQ, Nadasdy Z, Ben-Shaul Y. Unsupervised spike detection and sorting with Szabo GG, Schneider CJ, Soltesz I. Resolution revolution: epilepsy dynamics at the
wavelets and superparamagnetic clustering. Neural Comput 2004;16:166187. microscale. Curr Opin Neurobiol 2015;31:23943.
Rosenow F, Lders H. Presurgical evaluation of epilepsy. Brain 2001;124:1683700. Uebachs M, Albus C, Opitz T, Isom L, Niespodziany I, Wolff C, et al. Loss of b1
Sanabria ER, Su H, Yaari Y. Initiation of network bursts by Ca2+-dependent intrinsic accessory Na+ channel subunits causes failure of carbamazepine, but not of
bursting in the rat pilocarpine model of temporal lobe epilepsy. J Physiol (Lond) lacosamide, in blocking high-frequency firing via differential effects on
2001;532:20516. persistent Na+ currents. Epilepsia 2012;53:195967.
Schindler KA, Goodman PH, Wieser HG, Douglas RJ. Fast oscillations trigger bursts of Valdez AB, Hickman EN, Treiman DM, Smith KA, Steinmetz PN. A statistical method
action potentials in neocortical neurons in vitro: a quasi-white-noise analysis for predicting seizure onset zones from human single-neuron recordings. J
study. Brain Res 2006;1110:20110. Neural Eng 2013;10:16001.
Staba RJ, Wilson CL, Bragin A, Fried I, Engel J. Sleep states differentiate single neuron Wyler AR, Ward AA. Neuronal firing patterns from epileptogenic foci of monkey and
activity recorded from human epileptic hippocampus, entorhinal cortex, and human. Adv Neurol 1986;44:96789.
subiculum. J Neurosci 2002;22:5694704.